Simply magical music making. There is no question that Kleiber hangs on for dear life at the end of the Brahms. He is so exhausted physically that the orchestra helps him get over the finish line by sheer will. You will not hear more otherworldly interpreting than this. If you are sensitive enough to feel it, you are the lucky ones. People said Furtwängler was touched by God. But Carlos had his telephone number!
Absolutely. He is the conductor's conductor. The detail and drive. Everything is to the limits. His Brahms with VPO is fantastic. This is so good! And yes they go with him to the end.
This Coriolan ....... oh my God , oh my God .... this is so incredibly beautiful ..... this immediate violence , broken energy and sudden anger , hoffnungslose Rufe ............................. tragedy at every millisecond ..... Beethoven , Kleiber , and us , on the Titanic .......
Kleiber is the greatest conductor to walk the planet. He had access to Flow, Depth, Nuance, Musical Sentences, Deep Architecture, "the Codes".........................the Bliss of it ALL, the Radical Void of Life.......................the Fullness, the Presence. ......Consciousness. Not just mind, emotion, body........The Beauty, The Aesthetic Itself anchored in Consciousness...................transtemporal/transspatial. End of story.
Nein, liebe target 9972, es ist nicht das Alter, es ist einfach Carlos Kleiber und die wundervolle Musik. Wir sind glueckliche Menschen mit Traenen in den Augen, stimmt??
It is absolutely criminal to have all these adverts throughout this wonderful concert. Shame on you TH-cam - what an insult to the composers, the conductor, the orchestra and to us, the audience.
I agree with you 100%. The robot that runs YT "hears" a moment of silence, and thinks the "program" is over. How anyone imagines such a stupid entity will take over mankind is beyond me. But about the ads: they're easy to avoid. The last time I checked, YT offered a payment plan to avoid ads. I don't know how much, because I don't use it. Instead, I use a server called Firefox. They offer a variety of "extensions," one of which tells the YT bot that the program hasn't stopped yet. As a result, I haven't seen an ad that interrupts a program in years, only ones that YT puts in its own little box or that YTubers provide in their presentation. There was no ad in this entire concert, for example. (Maybe this is the AI we have to fear?)
54-18 I heard this piece as a very young man at the Salzburg festival and this passage made me feel as if I was floating out of my seat. I never thought to have that experience again, but I just did. (50years later)!
@@katrinat.3032 It is an astonishing rendition but, in my opinion, not as great as the Karajan Salzburg 1983 (??) cycle. Kleiber rehearsed to the absolute maximum, which meant he would often stop conducting and leave the orchestra to do it, whereas HvK often left things to chance in the performance. This is where the 'new' generation of conductors took over. Furtwangler (who, in my opinion, was a GOOD conductor but nothing special in the slightest), along with Erich Kleiber and many others, were totally eclipsed by C Kleiber, Karajan, Solti etc (I put the 'etc' there so people don't say 'but what about him and her and him!!!'
Such a joy and privilege to watch this maestro of maestros conduct with such joy and elegance, often minimal, producing such glorious playing of such glorious music. May he rest in peace.
I vividly remember this programme played in Ravenna, since M. Solti was unable to go there with the LSO. We bought tickets just before the concert and it was incredible, probably the best concert of my life. I till can see CK conducting Mozart only with his left hand, amazing...
1:04:32 to the end , ach Mensch , ist das grossartig und hoffnungslos .... Kleiber no more "conducting" this Brahms Symphony , but explaining us his own desperation and anguish , which is , of course , our personnal destiny too ......
Stunning. I've never heard Beethoven's Coriolan or Brahms 4 performed with such intensity. Such great music making in the Hercules Hall in Munich. (I once conducted there...... unimaginable to think I even stood on the same stage as the genius that was Kleiber.)
There's not many conductor's that come close to Kleiber with Coriolan. Pure electrically charged performance that Beethoven would of been proud of. Bravo!
A wonderful performance by the great Carlos Kleiber conducting Beethoven's Coriolan Overture, Mozart's Symphony No.33 and Brahms magnificent Symphony No. 4.
I sincerely hope that the final sounds that I hear as I leave this planet will be my children promising not to fight over the will...and Carlos Kleiber conducting anything Beethoven. For a musician, observing Kleiber convey his thoughts through his baton and body language, provides all the necessary musical cues and nuance...that you feel Beethoven himself was up on the podium. Thank-you TH-cam.
One way for your children not to fight over your will is to appoint a corporate trustee over them as the executor. For example, a family accountant or estate lawyer would suffice with a notarized document appointing them that amends your current will. That way, your intended going away listening to Maestro Kleiber conduct Beethoven might be undisturbed, God willing.
Long after McCartney, Dylan, Jagger - let alone Bacharach, Webber, Taylor Swift, et al - are forgotten - Beethoven, Mozart conducted by the likes of Carlos Kleiber will still be played, their stars rising ever higher
43:15 .... every single moment here of the conducting of Carlos is a treasury , but here ...; could you ever dream of something better than this utterly and extreme beauty ?
true! but there’s another moment of extreme beauty, where Carlos is barely doing anything: the flute solo ensuing from 1:07:41 - what immense beauty of tone throughout the full range, what depth and passion, what phrasing! better than in the recording with the VPO… I’m lucky to live in munich: although I sadly didn’t witness Kleiber anymore, I get to hear this wonderful flute player from time to time in concert (he’s with the BRSO today)!
Yes, you are quite right. But Kleiber no more conducting the flute solo, but participating in it ..... and indicating to the young flutist : my friend, this is even more dramatic and more hopeless as you think, and as you're playing it ..... an incredible moment.@@durmiend0 Greetings from Strassburg, a small stupid village compared to Munich the Great, leave well !
Claudio Abbado called Kleiber "one of the greatest if not the greatest conductor of the 20th century" ("Carlos è stato uno dei più grandi, se non il più grande direttore del Novecento.")
These are the interpretations of a true genius! I particularly like the moment in Coriolan at 7:08 when he gives the cue to the French horns with a Heavy Metal sign in his left hand. I don't know whether he does this intuitively, or perhaps was a real Heavy Metal fan, but in any case, this place is so Heavy Metal-esque that leaves no doubt how it should be shown by a conductor...
Kleiber is terribly nervous; you can see his hands shaking quite often and here especially at 56'30" and the end of the movement. Such an insecure titan and I miss him just every day of the week!! Dear Carlos, thank you for the music!!
Carlos Kleiber grandissimo bravissimo geniale direttore maestro: lui nella classifica dei migliori maestri direttori insieme Herbert Von Karajan, Leonard Bernstein , direttore Maestro italiano Riccardo Muti ancora presente attività in vita esercizio presente.
Yo tuve la gran oportunidad de verle dirigir Beethoven, Brahms y Mozart y este talentudo-director, no ha tenido parangón, técnicamente perfecto conocedor de las obras que dirigía, en cambio en los ensayos, era casi la guerra. Que pena que artistas de tanta clase, se hayan ido para para siempre, aunque quedaron sus clases magistrales, recogidas en videos como estos, que siempre disfrutaremos. R.I.P.
Havia outros maestros extraordinários, mas Carlos Kleiber era o maior entre todos. Ele tinha uma compreensão/identificação com as obras que interpretava que o diferenciava dos outros grandes músicos. Abbado, Furtwangler, Talich, Bernstein, Gardiner. É pena que tenha gravado, relativamente, tão pouco. Talvez não nos quisesse presentear. Não nos achasse merecedores. Tinha razão...
There will never be another Kleiber, with a few exceptions to a few schools in the world that produce amazing conductors like Rice University. He's the supreme best, right up there with, well, no one else. He's in his own company.
Браво, МАЭСТРО! Браво, ОРКЕСТР! "Кориолан". Эту увертюру я дирижировал в Москве в 2002 году. Вчечатляюще!!! ❤ С оркестром штаба Московского военного округа.
It may be a tired Kleiber past his peak, but even in this video, his interpretation and baton technique still exceeds the vast majority of conductors at their prime. One of the greatest conductors who ever lived even in advanced age.
MariaCaIIas Very well noted. How can a conductor be past his peak ? An athlete, yes. An accountant, a writer even, yes. But it swarms in the music-history of conducters active till high age. Nowadays: Haitink and, even older, Blomstedt. Past their peak ? They have never been better than they are now; overripe, yes, but 'tasting sweeter and with an even nicer aftertaste' than before. One gets sick of all those morons listening with their eyes instead of with their ears. Beethoven could even hear withour ears, so why you, not deaf I hope, can not, having ears to listen with !! You could at least give it a try.
But listen to the orchestral playing. It's nowhere close to as well phrased and balanced as recordings in his youth. There are plenty of conductors who got better with age, but this recording is not an example of it.
Stephen Chun He'd obviously have more time to perfect things in a recording studio. You can see by his expression at certain parts that the orchestra isn't giving him exactly what his inner ear wants of them. His earlier recording of Brahms' 4th will always be beyond reach. Plus don't forget he was teamed up with the vienna phil for that.
I always became entranced by Ludwigs "5th" first movement and I my favorite piece regardless of it's infamous mainstream nature, yet I find OP. 62 slowingly overtaking it as my favorite piece all time, yet it seems Coriolan overture Op 62, the 5th first movement, and even Egmonts overture share very similar DNA, maybe that's why I keep going back to them more anything else.
don't know why, the first half of Brahms Symphonie No.4 - 4th movement, always reminds me of a scene in ''L'Assommoir''. It's about a dying little girl, lying on the bed, telling her alcoholic dad, who abused her day after day, ''now it's time to say goodbye'', serenely... as the wind of death filling up the room. Holy but profane, untrammeled but also suffocating.
Ich gehöre sicherlich zu den größten Kleiber - Fans. "Onkel" Carlos ging im Hause meiner Eltern ein und aus - seine Stuttgarter Elektra war für mich eine gigantische Erfahrung, die mich zum bedingungslosen Anhänger werden ließ - nicht zuletzt auch wegen der äußersten Akribie, mit der er und mein Vater Notenmaterial einrichtete. Von dieser Aufnahme bin ich allerdings enttäuscht: Er "macht" traumhafte Musik - zeigt alles, was er hören möchte und doch: Die Intonation zwischen Blech, Holz und Streichern ist teilweise dürftig - es "klappert" an vielen Stellen hörbar und sogar optisch (Bratschen/Celli) - eigentlich völlig untypisch für das von mir ebenfalls sehr verehrte Bayerische Staatsorchester... Pauke und Streicher im Coriolan... Temposchwankungen im Brahms (gewollt oder versehentlich ?) werden im Orchester unterschiedlich umgesetzt. Diese höre ich auf seiner phantastischen Einspielung mit den Wiener Philharmonikern nicht. Schade - und das im Herkulessaal, wo sich die Instrumentalisten eigentlich sehr gut untereinander hören.
カルロスクライバーらしい、重厚で情感溢れる演奏！
One of THE greatest conductors ever.
take the ONE OF out and it is correct
@@tommeggle9966согласен с ВАМИ
Simply magical music making. There is no question that Kleiber hangs on for dear life at the end of the Brahms. He is so exhausted physically that the orchestra helps him get over the finish line by sheer will. You will not hear more otherworldly interpreting than this.
If you are sensitive enough to feel it, you are the lucky ones. People said Furtwängler was touched by God. But Carlos had his telephone number!
❤
Absolutely. He is the conductor's conductor. The detail and drive. Everything is to the limits. His Brahms with VPO is fantastic. This is so good! And yes they go with him to the end.
Perfect from the first to the last Note
This Coriolan ....... oh my God , oh my God .... this is so incredibly beautiful ..... this immediate violence , broken energy and sudden anger , hoffnungslose Rufe ............................. tragedy at every millisecond ..... Beethoven , Kleiber , and us , on the Titanic .......
Klemperer also has one of the best Coriolan Overtures I've heard.
Dopo averlo visto dirigere, ora capite perchè Carlos Kleiber è il NUMERO UNO DEI DIRETTORI D'ORCHESTRA DI MUSICA CLASSICA al mondo ???????
0:44 Coriolan Overture
9:56 Mozart Symphony nr. 33
32:46 Brahms Symphony nr. 4
The silence at the end of "Coriolan" says it all
Kleiber is the greatest conductor to walk the planet. He had access to Flow, Depth, Nuance, Musical Sentences, Deep Architecture, "the Codes".........................the Bliss of it ALL, the Radical Void of Life.......................the Fullness, the Presence. ......Consciousness. Not just mind, emotion, body........The Beauty, The Aesthetic Itself anchored in Consciousness...................transtemporal/transspatial. End of story.
the greatest and the most handsome conductor.............
@@joannaklee7230 indeed
Thank you, Maestro Carlos Kleiber, you may no longer be with us but you still embellish our lives exquisitely.
very nicely put. thank you. How strange that so many great artists who come into this world are only given a comparatively short stay, alas.
i guess I am quite off topic but does anybody know of a good website to stream new series online ?
@Uriel Jeffrey Lately I have been using Flixzone. Just search on google for it :)
@Carson Alijah Yup, have been using FlixZone for since april myself =)
@Carson Alijah thanks, I went there and it seems like a nice service :) I really appreciate it!
Carlos Kleiber war nicht von dieser Welt ….
Er war ein Engel.
u 're right
Das ist so!
@@MrTwcdaveот мира сего был и доказал то, что хотел. БРАВО!
Was ist bloß los: Jedesmal habe ich bei Carlos Kleiber nach ein paar Momenten Tränen in den Augen. Und ich bin 73 - na ja, vielleicht deshalb ...
Nein, liebe target 9972, es ist nicht das Alter, es ist einfach Carlos Kleiber und die wundervolle Musik. Wir sind glueckliche Menschen mit Traenen in den Augen, stimmt??
It is absolutely criminal to have all these adverts throughout this wonderful concert. Shame on you TH-cam - what an insult to the composers, the conductor, the orchestra and to us, the audience.
so true!
Pay premium abo …. No advert , ni commercial
@@Zaiko4 How much is that costing you?
I agree with you 100%. The robot that runs YT "hears" a moment of silence, and thinks the "program" is over. How anyone imagines such a stupid entity will take over mankind is beyond me.
But about the ads: they're easy to avoid. The last time I checked, YT offered a payment plan to avoid ads. I don't know how much, because I don't use it.
Instead, I use a server called Firefox. They offer a variety of "extensions," one of which tells the YT bot that the program hasn't stopped yet. As a result, I haven't seen an ad that interrupts a program in years, only ones that YT puts in its own little box or that YTubers provide in their presentation. There was no ad in this entire concert, for example. (Maybe this is the AI we have to fear?)
I never heard that ending before WOW for Cariolan
54-18 I heard this piece as a very young man at the Salzburg festival and this passage made me feel as if I was floating out of my seat. I never thought to have that experience again, but I just did. (50years later)!
🎉🎉ᆢㅡ 1:07:13 1:07:13
Kleiber. Every single piece he touched - Out of the ball park.
Ian24s
Exactly so.
Assolutamente uno dei più grandi direttori d'orchestra!
Самый великий дирижер 20 века, а не один из....
Great. The Best.
Every time I listen to the 4th movement of Brahms the 4th,
I think it's the highest moment of human grief!!
Yesssssssssssss, you have understood it all.
It’s agony and my father’s fav
Kleiber and Brahms 4th symphony is still the best version ever.
I prefer Jansons's. More sentimental
I agree with Rmir2 Kleiber and the brahms4th will stop you dead in your tracks because it’s so beautiful
@@katrinat.3032 It is an astonishing rendition but, in my opinion, not as great as the Karajan Salzburg 1983 (??) cycle. Kleiber rehearsed to the absolute maximum, which meant he would often stop conducting and leave the orchestra to do it, whereas HvK often left things to chance in the performance. This is where the 'new' generation of conductors took over. Furtwangler (who, in my opinion, was a GOOD conductor but nothing special in the slightest), along with Erich Kleiber and many others, were totally eclipsed by C Kleiber, Karajan, Solti etc (I put the 'etc' there so people don't say 'but what about him and her and him!!!'
It took me 54 years to know how to be in awe, his ways are enchanting! Thank God my soul findeth Kleiber
56:17 Kleiber entering a forbidden world . Perfection .
Such a joy and privilege to watch this maestro of maestros conduct with such joy and elegance, often minimal, producing such glorious playing of such glorious music. May he rest in peace.
1
Nur ein großer Liebender vermochte so den Taktstock zu führen wie Carlos Kleiber es getan hat..
I vividly remember this programme played in Ravenna, since M. Solti was unable to go there with the LSO. We bought tickets just before the concert and it was incredible, probably the best concert of my life. I till can see CK conducting Mozart only with his left hand, amazing...
Dear Samuel, you are a gentleman and a scholar for posting this video of the maestro in all his glory with his favorite orchestra at hand! thank you!
Coriolan Overture: 0:44
Mozart Symphony No. 33
1. Allegro Assai: 9:57
2. Andante moderato: 17:19
3. Menuetto: 22:58
4. Finale: Allegro assai: 25:52
Brahms Symphony No. 4
1. Allegro non troppo: 32:46
2. Andante moderato: 46:24
3. Allegro giocoso: 58:05
4. Allegro energico e passionato: 1:04:33
Merci 🤤🤤🤤
Thanks I love when people do the time stamps
Thanks
1:04:32 to the end , ach Mensch , ist das grossartig und hoffnungslos .... Kleiber no more "conducting" this Brahms Symphony , but explaining us his own desperation and anguish , which is , of course , our personnal destiny too ......
Stunning. I've never heard Beethoven's Coriolan or Brahms 4 performed with such intensity. Such great music making in the Hercules Hall in Munich. (I once conducted there...... unimaginable to think I even stood on the same stage as the genius that was Kleiber.)
What orchestra and program did you conduct?
GREAT HORNS SECTION !!!
FANTASTIC
As another has commented -"thank you for the music Kleiber" Sadly missed RIP.
6:53 The end of the Coriolan ........ impossible to clap after this . The Munich audience paralysed ....
No, è perchè sono ignoranti, si aspettavano il finale in fortissimo, sono solo ignoranti.........
@@renato45222
In Munich, the audience ignoring the end of the Coriolan, really ?
I would say - very well behaved
Good behaviour ? What has good behaviour to do with this ?@@brucekuehn4031
Passion, mastery, genius.
Just love the moments from 1:04:45 - 1:05:02. I come here everyday to see this part.
same here
you mean how he is getting the timpani in line? masterful
welch eine wunderbare grosse Musik und Dirigent ! ;-)
Besten Dank, Samuel.
There's not many conductor's that come close to Kleiber with Coriolan. Pure electrically charged performance that Beethoven would of been proud of. Bravo!
Paul Klecki
A wonderful performance by the great Carlos Kleiber conducting Beethoven's Coriolan Overture, Mozart's Symphony No.33 and Brahms magnificent Symphony No. 4.
Beautiful and powerful
Beethoven purely
Hello Ahang.
Grandissimi geniali compositore, orchestra preparata professionale professionisti grandissimo bravissimo geniale direttore esecutore direttore
the best conductor, for me
the best conductor of all
@Luigi Raimondo Pomo Abbado is also fantastic
@Luigi Raimondo Pomo and dont forget about his beautiful Mahler adaptations
Greeting!
@Luigi Raimondo Pomo from transylvania
0:43 Beginning/Exposition
1:00 m.15
1:35 B
1:54 2nd theme
2:41 C
3:19 D
3:31 Development
4:18 Recapitulation (E)
4:52 F (2nd Theme)
5:46 G
6:25 H (Coda)
7:17 I
7:37 Disintegration of the theme
I sincerely hope that the final sounds that I hear as I leave this planet will be my children promising not to fight over the will...and Carlos Kleiber conducting anything Beethoven. For a musician, observing Kleiber convey his thoughts through his baton and body language, provides all the necessary musical cues and nuance...that you feel Beethoven himself was up on the podium. Thank-you TH-cam.
One way for your children not to fight over your will is to appoint a corporate trustee over them as the executor. For example, a family accountant or estate lawyer would suffice with a notarized document appointing them that amends your current will. That way, your intended going away listening to Maestro Kleiber conduct Beethoven might be undisturbed, God willing.
My thanks to all for this beautiful performance.
Fantastic
Thank you for this upload... At last, I understood this overture!
1:11:33 - 1:11:57 are some of the most exquisite seconds of all Kleiber's work...
1:13:30 when I reading your comment , the music suddenly become quiet. So I raise my eyes and aware his body language. He is the sculptor of music.
Lo que disfruta este director se le refleja en la cara y en la dulzura de sus manos es un gozón de la música y es un comunicador de poesía
Long after McCartney, Dylan, Jagger - let alone Bacharach, Webber, Taylor Swift, et al - are forgotten - Beethoven, Mozart conducted by the likes of Carlos Kleiber will still be played, their stars rising ever higher
09:27 Mozart Symphonie n.33 B-dur KV 319
32:00 Brahms Symphonie n.4 op. 98
Danke!
Thank you for your kindness.
These masterpiece and performances are beyond description , and full of overwhelming admiration and deep emotion
43:15 .... every single moment here of the conducting of Carlos is a treasury , but here ...; could you ever dream of something better than this utterly and extreme beauty ?
no.I fell in love with him.after he died, mind.
true! but there’s another moment of extreme beauty, where Carlos is barely doing anything: the flute solo ensuing from 1:07:41 - what immense beauty of tone throughout the full range, what depth and passion, what phrasing! better than in the recording with the VPO… I’m lucky to live in munich: although I sadly didn’t witness Kleiber anymore, I get to hear this wonderful flute player from time to time in concert (he’s with the BRSO today)!
Yes, you are quite right. But Kleiber no more conducting the flute solo, but participating in it ..... and indicating to the young flutist : my friend, this is even more dramatic and more hopeless as you think, and as you're playing it ..... an incredible moment.@@durmiend0
Greetings from Strassburg, a small stupid village compared to Munich the Great, leave well !
Великий дирижёр.
КАРЛОСА КЛАЙБЕРА МОГУ СЛУШАТЬ, КОГДА ВИЖУ, ЧТОБЫ ВИДЕТЬ ВЗМАХ ПАЛОЧКОЙ И ДВИЖЕНИЮ РУК.🌹🌹🌹
Claudio Abbado called Kleiber "one of the greatest if not the greatest conductor of the 20th century" ("Carlos è stato uno dei più grandi, se non il più grande direttore del Novecento.")
And Kleiber said that about Karajan.
@@alejandrobeltranena8409
No. This is wrong.
@@alejandrobeltranena8409дал Караяну аванс😂. Караяну до него расти и расти
Lorin Maazel….
And from 56:50 to the end of the movement , the incredible perfect landing of the huge brahmsian airplane by Kleiber Airways .... ....
These are the interpretations of a true genius! I particularly like the moment in Coriolan at 7:08 when he gives the cue to the French horns with a Heavy Metal sign in his left hand. I don't know whether he does this intuitively, or perhaps was a real Heavy Metal fan, but in any case, this place is so Heavy Metal-esque that leaves no doubt how it should be shown by a conductor...
❤❤
Priceless
Concerto magnifico: complimenti per la pubblicità : fornisce un bel contributo ala comprensione delle opere .Bravissimi!
Una meraviglia, da ascoltare e pure da vedere!! Mitico Carlos!!!
Kleiber made it look so easy.....it wasnt ....but he convinced me it was.
Heavenly Beethoven marvelous
Great and memorable performence.
Kleiber is terribly nervous; you can see his hands shaking quite often and here especially at 56'30" and the end of the movement. Such an insecure titan and I miss him just every day of the week!! Dear Carlos, thank you for the music!!
i would say thats mainly because of age and exhaustment of that performance
He hardly ever felt good enough.
His health was failing, but he went forward in spite of it.
Esto es dibujar la música con las manos. Pedazo de Arte Kleiber.
Wonderful Carlos Kleiber
KLEIBERRR!!! BRAAAVOOO!!!
Carlos Kleiber grandissimo bravissimo geniale direttore maestro: lui nella classifica dei migliori maestri direttori insieme Herbert Von Karajan, Leonard Bernstein , direttore Maestro italiano Riccardo Muti ancora presente attività in vita esercizio presente.
Klassik Kleiber Koriolan, KOLOSSAL!
Yo tuve la gran oportunidad de verle dirigir Beethoven, Brahms y Mozart y este talentudo-director, no ha tenido parangón, técnicamente perfecto conocedor de las obras que dirigía, en cambio en los ensayos, era casi la guerra. Que pena que artistas de tanta clase, se hayan ido para para siempre, aunque quedaron sus clases magistrales, recogidas en videos como estos, que siempre disfrutaremos. R.I.P.
Brahms symphony 4
32:34~ 1st movement
46:15~ 2nd movement
58:00~ 3rd movement
1:04:26~ 4th movement
For humanity sake, somebody have to reincarnate Carlos Kleiber !
Let it will be himself
Carlos Kleiber, Genio de la dirección orquestal. Gracias MAESTRO!!!
Als eingeweihte Seele in die Mysterien des Dirigierens bleibt uns Carlos Kleiber ewig gegenwärtig...
Such elegance.
Odlicna glazba, ki jo sedaj lahko poslusam na TH-cam nekaj kilometrov stran od Konjscice, v poklon mojstru.
Of course Kleiber goes further than Furtwängler . This tremendous beauty . And not only emotion .
'Tristan' defeated him though. A problem Furt. never had.
Havia outros maestros extraordinários, mas Carlos Kleiber era o maior entre todos. Ele tinha uma compreensão/identificação com as obras que interpretava que o diferenciava dos outros grandes músicos. Abbado, Furtwangler, Talich, Bernstein, Gardiner. É pena que tenha gravado, relativamente, tão pouco. Talvez não nos quisesse presentear. Não nos achasse merecedores. Tinha razão...
❤
6 months prior to this, I witnessed the first concert in Ingolstadt - nuff said.
well, say it.
Danke für dieses außergewöhnliches Konzert.
Boy, that little correction at 56:24 is a zinger. Anybody think this guy isn't listening with every fiber doesn't know what conductors do.
la overtura corian del gran compositor beethoven, es única en su género y encarna un romanticismo heroico, sencillamente genial.
There will never be another Kleiber, with a few exceptions to a few schools in the world that produce amazing conductors like Rice University. He's the supreme best, right up there with, well, no one else. He's in his own company.
I agree he is the supreme best! But where is Rice University?
Houston, TX
That qualification (Rice University) is absolutely hilarious!
greatest conductor
Браво, МАЭСТРО! Браво, ОРКЕСТР! "Кориолан". Эту увертюру я дирижировал в Москве в 2002 году. Вчечатляюще!!! ❤ С оркестром штаба Московского военного округа.
No se puede ser más elegante, tener mejor técnica y tanto sentimiento. Inigualable!!!
It may be a tired Kleiber past his peak, but even in this video, his interpretation and baton technique still exceeds the vast majority of conductors at their prime. One of the greatest conductors who ever lived even in advanced age.
How can a conductor be past his peak!?
I know it when I hear it.
MariaCaIIas Very well noted. How can a conductor be past his peak ? An athlete, yes. An accountant, a writer even, yes. But it swarms in the music-history of conducters active till high age. Nowadays: Haitink and, even older, Blomstedt. Past their peak ? They have never been better than they are now; overripe, yes, but 'tasting sweeter and with an even nicer aftertaste' than before. One gets sick of all those morons listening with their eyes instead of with their ears. Beethoven could even hear withour ears, so why you, not deaf I hope, can not, having ears to listen with !! You could at least give it a try.
But listen to the orchestral playing. It's nowhere close to as well phrased and balanced as recordings in his youth. There are plenty of conductors who got better with age, but this recording is not an example of it.
Stephen Chun
He'd obviously have more time to perfect things in a recording studio. You can see by his expression at certain parts that the orchestra isn't giving him exactly what his inner ear wants of them. His earlier recording of Brahms' 4th will always be beyond reach. Plus don't forget he was teamed up with the vienna phil for that.
Only Kleiber can conduct with a hand in the pocket: ohne sorgen.
Absolutne nedostizny VYKON - orchestra a DIRIGENTA - GENIA
Великолепно! Прекрасное исполнение!
increible..
I always became entranced by Ludwigs "5th" first movement and I my favorite piece regardless of it's infamous mainstream nature, yet I find OP. 62 slowingly overtaking it as my favorite piece all time, yet it seems Coriolan overture Op 62, the 5th first movement, and even Egmonts overture share very similar DNA, maybe that's why I keep going back to them more anything else.
Un enorme director. Gracias por su genial aporte !!!
Any praise may fall short of the art of Maestro Kleiber. Thank you for this video!
don't know why, the first half of Brahms Symphonie No.4 - 4th movement, always reminds me of a scene in ''L'Assommoir''. It's about a dying little girl, lying on the bed, telling her alcoholic dad, who abused her day after day, ''now it's time to say goodbye'', serenely... as the wind of death filling up the room. Holy but profane, untrammeled but also suffocating.
Maravilloso !!!
やほりこのスピード感とメリハリが唯一無二。
Fantastic. Great rendition, great conductor. Second only to Karajan in my book. I wish he had recorded more!
Kleiber, Furtwangler, Bohm, Karajan... What else?
Ich gehöre sicherlich zu den größten Kleiber - Fans. "Onkel" Carlos ging im Hause meiner Eltern ein und aus - seine Stuttgarter Elektra war für mich eine gigantische Erfahrung, die mich zum bedingungslosen Anhänger werden ließ - nicht zuletzt auch wegen der äußersten Akribie, mit der er und mein Vater Notenmaterial einrichtete.
Von dieser Aufnahme bin ich allerdings enttäuscht: Er "macht" traumhafte Musik - zeigt alles, was er hören möchte und doch: Die Intonation zwischen Blech, Holz und Streichern ist teilweise dürftig - es "klappert" an vielen Stellen hörbar und sogar optisch (Bratschen/Celli) - eigentlich völlig untypisch für das von mir ebenfalls sehr verehrte Bayerische Staatsorchester... Pauke und Streicher im Coriolan... Temposchwankungen im Brahms (gewollt oder versehentlich ?) werden im Orchester unterschiedlich umgesetzt. Diese höre ich auf seiner phantastischen Einspielung mit den Wiener Philharmonikern nicht.
Schade - und das im Herkulessaal, wo sich die Instrumentalisten eigentlich sehr gut untereinander hören.
GRANDISSIMO
위대한 지휘자이며 위대한 예술가인 당신을 영원히 기억할것입니다!!
Ich werde dich für immer in Erinnerung behalten, großer Dirigent und großer Künstler!
우주 최고의 연주입니다. 너무나 감사드립니다! ^:^
素晴らしい！
winning music