Russian films are no joke! Intense! I saw the 1975 French film which was also good. The Germans were just as bad in that one. I do love Russian films. They go deep. Come And See is another one worth watching! Russian Ark , The Cranes Are Flying , Ballad of a Soldier.
БАЛЛАДА О СОЛДАТЕ, ЛЕТЯТ ЖУРАВЛИ - это настоящие, достойные похвалы фильмы, а тот, что сейчас показали - фигня! Плохо поставлен, автор совершенно не знает КАК жили в нашей стране до войны. Вы, иностранцы, думаете, что накануне войны 1941года учитель сидел и ждал придут ли дети в школу? Смешно. Деревни наши думаете были вот такие, как в этом дурацком фильме? Нет, возле каждого дома росли деревья, за домами были сады,на дорогах хоть и не было асфальта, но была колея поросшая травой. И вообще, я смотрела этот фильм с полным равнодушием, как глупый комикс👎 P. S. И ещë: огнедышащее оружие у немцев появилось в самом конце войны, и оно называлось фауст-патрон, а в этом фильме события происходят в начале войны. Авторы совершенно не знают историю.
So sad...the cruelty. I know it's fiction...but...based on truth from so many untold stories. It's also sad that Russia has done the same in the past. The military should fight the military, not civilians.
russians and germans were both worth each other in their cruelty. They may have been some humane ones but what is 1 against a hundred or more of torturers r@pists pedos and not only. It's a little bit funny for me that in russian movies they are shown in the good light and germans get all the hate. Also russians didn't have so good in their own country. If they would want to go home, return from battlefield or were caught by the enemy snd survived, thy were ordered tobe killed by the russian government.
I agree. Not entirely sure that we need two reminders of the wife's horrific death at the beginning of episode 3. We all got it first time round. Unhealthy and borderline voyeuristic.
russians and germans were both worth each other in their cruelty. They may have been some humane ones but what is 1 against a hundred or more of torturers r@pists pedos and not only. It's a little bit funny for me that in russian movies they are shown in the good light and germans get all the hate. Also russians didn't have so good in their own country. If they would want to go home, return from battlefield or were caught by the enemy snd survived, thy were ordered tobe killed by the russian government.
When a film like this is too slow, the emotions depicted are drawn out and become unbearable cliches, like the Germans always laughing like brainless morons; the hate in the eyes of Petya, the stupid dog hanging around (hmmm, let's see what happens to it). War films are not philosophical essays on evil. If you want to produce a philosophical essay on evil, write it down, don't make a film. Sure, you can talk about evil in a war film, but then you have to use a different language, the language of war films. To each its own.
Russian films are no joke! Intense! I saw the 1975 French film which was also good. The Germans were just as bad in that one. I do love Russian films. They go deep. Come And See is another one worth watching! Russian Ark , The Cranes Are Flying , Ballad of a Soldier.
БАЛЛАДА О СОЛДАТЕ, ЛЕТЯТ ЖУРАВЛИ - это настоящие, достойные похвалы фильмы, а тот, что сейчас показали - фигня!
Плохо поставлен, автор совершенно не знает КАК жили в нашей стране до войны. Вы, иностранцы, думаете, что накануне войны 1941года учитель сидел и ждал придут ли дети в школу? Смешно.
Деревни наши думаете были вот такие, как в этом дурацком фильме? Нет, возле каждого дома росли деревья, за домами были сады,на дорогах хоть и не было асфальта, но была колея поросшая травой.
И вообще, я смотрела этот фильм с полным равнодушием, как глупый комикс👎
P. S. И ещë: огнедышащее оружие у немцев появилось в самом конце войны, и оно называлось фауст-патрон, а в этом фильме события происходят в начале войны. Авторы совершенно не знают историю.
So sad...the cruelty. I know it's fiction...but...based on truth from so many untold stories. It's also sad that Russia has done the same in the past. The military should fight the military, not civilians.
"based on truth from so many UNTOLD stories"?
russians and germans were both worth each other in their cruelty. They may have been some humane ones but what is 1 against a hundred or more of torturers r@pists pedos and not only. It's a little bit funny for me that in russian movies they are shown in the good light and germans get all the hate. Also russians didn't have so good in their own country. If they would want to go home, return from battlefield or were caught by the enemy snd survived, thy were ordered tobe killed by the russian government.
Damn that dude don’t know how to cover this mouth, so he doesn’t give them away?
Also keep some salt with him all the time?
Фильм недостоверный. Сразу видно , что иностранцы снимали.
Phim bạo lực quá.
I agree. Not entirely sure that we need two reminders of the wife's horrific death at the beginning of episode 3. We all got it first time round. Unhealthy and borderline voyeuristic.
А что у него за болезнь у Пети?
Probably asthma
russians and germans were both worth each other in their cruelty. They may have been some humane ones but what is 1 against a hundred or more of torturers r@pists pedos and not only. It's a little bit funny for me that in russian movies they are shown in the good light and germans get all the hate. Also russians didn't have so good in their own country. If they would want to go home, return from battlefield or were caught by the enemy snd survived, thy were ordered tobe killed by the russian government.
CCCP ❤❤❤❤❤
Hogy a fene egye meg a nemeteket.
Ýõũ want you
When a film like this is too slow, the emotions depicted are drawn out and become unbearable cliches, like the Germans always laughing like brainless morons; the hate in the eyes of Petya, the stupid dog hanging around (hmmm, let's see what happens to it). War films are not philosophical essays on evil. If you want to produce a philosophical essay on evil, write it down, don't make a film. Sure, you can talk about evil in a war film, but then you have to use a different language, the language of war films. To each its own.
U filthy nazi.
С приходом к власти чекиста путина кино стало советское. А этого говна я в ссср насмотрелся. Голимая пропаганда а не правда о войне.
Если ты про фильм то ты даун