How Trip Tucker SURVIVED in Enterprise - Star Trek Explained!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 พ.ย. 2024
- The tragic death of Commander Trip Tucker was one of Star Trek: Enterprise's saddest moments, but did he actually really die in the much-discussed series finale? Trek Central's Ensign Adam is back to talk all about the characters supposed death, and his secret involvement with Section 31!
⭐ Support our channel!
www.youtube.co...
Commander Charles Tucker III, known affectionately as "Trip" Tucker, was a 22nd century Human male Starfleet officer. He served for ten years as the chief engineer and Second officer of Earth's first warp 5-capable starship, Enterprise NX-01, under the command of his best friend, Captain Jonathan Archer.
Fan of Star Trek and like our content? Subscribe and follow us!
▶ Website -
trekcentral.net
▶ Facebook -
/ trekcentral
▶ Twitter -
/ thetrekcentral
▶ Discord - / discord
___________________________________________
Sources:
MemoryAlpha
MemoryBeta
ViacomCBS
MGM (Stargate)
Video Credits:
Written by Craig Turner
Presented by Adam Watson
Edited by Comfi_Monkii
___________________________________________
All STAR TREK® footage and its various marks are trademarks of CBS Studios Inc. 2019 © CBS Studios Inc./Paramount Pictures Corp.
Title: How Trip Tucker SURVIVED in Enterprise - Star Trek Explained!
#StarTrek #Enterprise #TrekCentral
dominic keating michael kenmore stargate atlantis connor trinneer
![เจ็บที่ยังฮัก - ม่อน วรวิทย์ [ Official Mv ] จอนนี่มิวสิค](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KALIGSRSjFs/mqdefault.jpg)
Still a massive mistake that they canceled the show when it was getting to be really good
Especially when the Ratings were high.
It was touted as the Number 1 Rated Show on TV.
Then *boom* 3 weeks later it was being canceled.
I never understood that.
🤷♂️🤷♂️
Les Moonves was never a fan of star trek.
They problem was it was on UPN, in my area we didn’t have a station to watch it on. So we were stuck buying the series on dvd when they came out if we wanted to watch it.
@@mikewd1983 and therein lied the problem.
Agreed, I was hoping for at least 7 seasons, dealing with the Romulan war and more about the beginning of the federation. Season 5-6 Romulan war, season 7 jumping ahead to early days of the UFP. I thought it was really good from day one. The first two season pure early Starfleet exploratory episodes, loved it! Season the Xindi arc and all the goodies in season 4. I remember hearing of the cancellation when it was on air, I was furious.
I still maintain that what we saw was a dramatisation of the NX-01's last mission, and inaccuracies often creep into dramatisations. One such inaccuracy was, for whatever reason, Tripp's death.
When the official report says you're dead but you're saving the galaxy...
Yes! It was a twenty-third century holodeck scenario based upon the "official" record. I get a real kick out of watching T'Pol fidget & swing while standing still near the end - exactly like a video game character!
Riker intentionally programmed it that way because he was testing various "what if...?" scenarios.
That's also the reason why the last ep is an holodeck replay. It's the... official... version.
even if taking what we saw as canon with teh holo program . the fact is Phlox never called it . Trip was put in a chamber as a last resort . if trip was dead the crew would not be as they where as Archer was about to give teh SPEECH . they would have been beyond devastated . I keep think Trip and T Pol did get together and had kids . maybe they found a planet and lived there as it was still a controversy to have interspecies mating even in spocks time
I saw trip alive and well in 2019 at the convention in Las Vegas. Cheers :)
Fans would’ve put up with the silly theme song for 3-4 years more. Thank you for this. You made my day.
Ya know teh funny thing is its the only song that actually has lyrics that really have meaning
@@yukinagato6761 I liked the photos and videos of our space history best for the intro. Just the theme music would've been enough (though I liked the song). Tunes with words are best saved for comedies ("All in the Family") and dramas ("Touched By An Angel") in my opinion.
@@virginiaconnor8350 I liked how they used photos of our technological history starting from ground to outer space. I mean it's pretty much telling how the NX-01 Enterprise came to be.
"I swear I can still hear the theme song" 😂😂😂 yeah me too buddy 😂
😂🤣😂🤣
Loved Enterprise, hated the theme song!
The song wasn't that bad
And almost see Yeager and Shepherd (spelling?).
@@dave4114 It's absolutely awful. And it's not even for Enterprise. Diane Warren pulled it out of her closet when Rick Berman decided he hated that "wherever you will go" song (and I don't blame him, it was even worse) and called her on the phone for her input.
I'm so mad this didn't get a full 7 season run. I know this show is looked down upon quite a bit in the trek community, but the show itself was good. And the intro in this video about the song made me realize why people didn't want to watch it. It was the song... It was the damn song... And then they added a little more drum and bass to improve it, but really just made it worse. It's sad because this show really is the last of the Rick Berman, Brannan Braga and Michael Piller days.
I Do Agree They Should Have He Come Back!! I've Read Some Of The Books!! I Don't Think They Should Have Killed Trip Off, Even Though It Was The Last Episode!! I'm Upset That They Only Got 4 Seasons, And I Think That Should Have At Least Made A Movie!! That Way They Could Explain Everything!! I'll Just Have To Get The Books!!
That wink and slight smirk he gives Archer before going in the medical scanner, that felt WAY more coherent than how Trip was behaving seconds before.
Was surprised to hear 20 years. Geez it feels 10. Loved the show. And Trip did not die...f them.
I think Tucker went to the Pegasus galaxy and turned into a Wraith, then human, wraith, human, then back wraith again. And changed his name to Michael 😜😜
I was very much trying to figure out how the Enterprise got to the Pegasus galaxy... those are clearly Wraith he's fighting.
Nice.
@@Belboz99 , same actor but 2 diffent tv show ,,
@@Belboz99 well, he aged considerably, but after traveling back in time in season 3, his captors cloned him, and the clone acquainted himself with the US military, and eventually fathered Kathrine Langford and discovered the stargate… traveling through it to abidos he was captured by the goald Jaffa and rescued by the Asgard and ended up in the Pegasus galaxy… where he was conditioned into being a wraith, then back to human, then back to wraith, then back to human, then back to wraith yet again…
Yep that's exactly what happened.
Trip's death in Enterprise always appeared dodgy to me. They got everyone else right in the holodeck, but Trip wasn't. This includes his personality and actions, as if the history had been doctored.
lol Trip would never eat an unpeeled carrot!!! 😂😂😂
I think it would be amazing if Trip came back in Strange New Worlds as a former Section 31 agent...or reactivated even. Its possible because many trek characters have appeared living over 100 years old. Maybe he could use the Michael Kenmore alias and put some revealing references for the uninitiated. It would just be amazing and a tribute to a rudely abrupt ending to Enterprise at its stellar 4th season.
Trip did not die. All the episodes we watched 1st hand. But, the episode that Trip's die we watch a historical reenactment. So we all know that the historical reenactment is not what actually happened.
Keep your shirt on, Lieutenant. Your equipment will be here in the morning
I'm so glad someone finally put this out! I've been reading the novels and have known this for a while now. The way they continued it in the books as Nog coming to Jake was great.
same here. i read that one months ago. kind of did the books backwars.....romulan war, then K. Maru....then this one
Trip did survive in the books, genius!
@@dave4114 it does depend on if you consider books/other media cannon. for example according to star trek online worf resigned from star fleet to join the klingons in the war against the federation.(star trek picard tells a different story as it may be that worf is captain of the enterprise now)
In one of those books it ends with a look at their future and we learn that T'Pol has two children, presumably with Tripp. I think one of those children should be introduced as a character on Strange New Worlds, maybe as a former teacher of Spock's whose mother was T'Pol, who would be well known, but whose father was a mystery.
I'd rather the Ferengis stay out of the stories (as the other "ST" stories) and let "Enterprise" stand alone w/o their "help". Riker and Troi interfered with the real story and we didn't get to see the end with T'Pol meeting Trip under the steps. I had to read the books, but enjoyed them. Maybe, if we can't get a continued series or movies, I guess we fans will have to read more books like we did at the end of "TOS" til we got "TAS" and "ST:TMP".
I'm glad they did the last episode the way they did. That left it open for ways to reveal that Trip didn't die. Like the novels that say his death was faked, and he became an agent, going undercover. Or just that the writer of that holo program decided it needed a death.
It was a hologram so maybe Riker programmed his "death" because he wanted to see how the early Starfleet crews dealt with the loss of a close crewmate. It could've easily have been Captain Archer. Real Tripp is alive and well
I like it!
Great!!! What a good option... I like it... I hate the final episode...Enterprise was a great serie... it deserve more seasons
Riker and Troi talk about his death outside of the program. It's pretty clear they believe it be an accurate portrayal of the key events.
I think Archer does “buy the farm” at one point and Pike becomes the “lead man” for Starfleet.
I dunno, in the Kelvin timeline Archer is still around, only he's an admiral. It's a throwaway line from scotty. Something about trying the transwarp beaming on admiral archers prized beagle. Which is why he was stranded where he was.
Finally! This episode was for me. Thanks
🖖❤️
You definitely gave me things to think about Trip. I had no idea but very interesting information
Indeed, Trip did *not* die, but it had nothing to do with Section 31; Rather, it was Riker's holodeck program that misled us. Riker actually programmed a change in the historical playback in order to find out how Archer would have reacted to Tucker's death. Unfortunately, this wasn't made clear in the episode. The best way to deal with this oversight would be either to simply edit the scenes relating to Tucker's death out, or to forget this episode ever happened, and never watch it again. (Sorry, but Trip could never pass as a Romulan. Not with *that* accent!)
Trip isn’t exactly the most subtle of people, which doesn’t make him a very good spy against the Romulans, along with that Southern accent.
An interesting idea but a much simpler solution is the final episode was a fabrication and nothing in it actually happened.
There is no theory, mate, there are some Section 31 books, set during a certain DS9 Episode, narrated by Bashir, that confirm that Tucker was recruited by them, faking his own death to do that, worked for them for some time, shortly after, Archer and T'Pol found out he was alive albeit with another name. Tucker and T'Pol rekindled their relation, keepng it a secret, and after he completed his mission and after some preassure from Archer, S-31 released and alowed him, with his new name, to go live with T'Pol, in Vulcan!!!!!
Actually a simple fix to that episode would be to add a 5 second clip of Reg Barkley asking Riker if he liked his simulation.
well deanna did say she had a meeting with him . reg was a so unused char . I really would have loved to see a series with him as teh headliner . him commanding a ship a NX styled one with Voyager elements
Also idk about anyone else, but I think it'd be great if T'Pol made a cameo in a future Star Trek show. Given that the Kelvin timeline films take place shortly to a century after Enterprise(as an example), T'Pol would still be alive by then. She'd be elderly sure, but she'd still be around. So something could be worked out.
That was a good story and now that damn song is stuck in my head..
They could actually tackle this in Strange New?Worlds if they wanted. I'm betting on T'Pol or Phlox showing up without a doubt.
One can only hope!!
Oh I really hope so, I loved them in Enterprise.
@@mary-kittybonkers2374 Absolutely!!!! Me, too!!!
or Shran! There have been clues but never a definitive on screen telling of how long Andorians live so Shran could also still be alive!
That would be amazing!
Has become my favorite star trek show
It was mine, until Trip "died" and thus the show abruptly ended. That wasnt nice at all.
I hope he’s not. That was so stupid and dumb to kill him off the show. Thank you for the video.
Such a dumb move. Spock back, Voyager ending Chakotay back, seven back, Picard back. You can still have tragedy and all the emotions for the audience but also “miracles” and bring them back. And It’s not like Connor wanted to leave the show or something. Jadzia sucked as well but we know of the issue behind cameras. They probably did kill the character but new shows can rewrite what happened to him based on these theories.
Geez, my mate Malcolm Reed can’t catch a break. First he has a horrendous childhood where he is led to believe he is a failure by his father (and mother?) because he is afraid of water and chooses to join Starfleet instead of following the rest of the Reeds into the Royal Navy… Then he’s constantly ignored by the overly friendly Captain Archer when it comes to security concerns… Then he’s forced to continue working with Section 31 against his captain and ship… And now he apparently had his chance of any future heirs ruined by a bloody transporter?? It’s bad enough that Enterprise seemingly forgot about Malcolm, Hoshi, and Travis lol
Hoshi had some good times in season 4 but Travis needed expanding. The guy in the pilot chair of a starship just seems to have the least to do when it comes to character development. I mean Hoshi suddenly became a black belt in one universe and empress of the mirror universe in the other.
I now no one will like me but Enterprise is my favorit star trek show
I prefer your postscript to the entire series. Thanks for sharing. I LOL'd at all the Sanders things.
Question: How Trip Tucker SURVIVED in Enterprise
Answer:because he is really a Wraith from the Pegasus Galaxy😜
👀👀👀
He’s not someone I’d want to run into under any circumstances….
He would be functionally immortal as a Wraith... Stargate happened in the Star Trek timeline confirmed?
The section 31 show should be The Romulan War starring Connor Trinneer. It could have some encounters with Bakula and the rest of the OG cast. I'd kill to have that happen. Basically the other Enterprise seasons we never got.
This sounds more like fan fiction than canon even on B level. Good Job Ensign Adam!
honestly some of the books and other media in general sound like fan fiction.
Man, everybody getting their mileage out of that remastered DS9 footage.
The long explanation is appreciated but not necessary . The episode " These Are The Voyages " never occurred as far as I`m concerned. An Earth / Romulan War mini-series with this cast is needed.
I think that (STAR TREK: ENTERPRISE) show series deserves to get rebooted.
I envision an alternate version, of the character (Charles Tucker 3rd.) aka TRIP, would not die in the reboot version, but instead I imagine that he survives in a battle against an enemy, and I imagine at some point into the storyline, of the series he marries (T’Pol) the female Vulcan.
Correction... "he marries (T’Pol) the female Vulcan" should be he married the half Romulan-Vulcan female T'Pol!
Ya. I agree. Thats a good way for Trip and Tpol to go. They bonded. They should have a family to raise on Vulcan.
The so-call “death” of Tucker is just a sloppy last minute contrived writing from our creative Talented Brannon Braga. He was Alex Kurtzman before Alex Kurtzman.
Though heroic, Trip’s death almost made no sense as it was just a stupid sacrifice!!!
The writers of the Enterprise Novel had to give the exit a better resolution.
And yea. Either don;t kill your heros. Kill them GoT Style "out of no where' or let them go out as EPIC heroes. THE WORST is when they die doing things that incomparison to past risk seem basically MUNDANE. It's like.....how many times did he almost die from MUCH MUCH more likely situations and he couldn't find a better way out this way out of THIS ONE. I think he was just suicidal, frankly!
I like the idea of Trip in Strange New Worlds.
That would be AWESOME!
❤❤❤❤❤❤
he would be over 100 years old by that point
@@thewewguy8t88 so the life expectancy in trek is regularly north of 100...look at McCoy and even Montgomery Scott...and others. So its theoretically possible for a former section 31 older Trip Tucker to appear in Strange New Worlds...
@@thewewguy8t88In star trek 2009, its known that Archer lived long enough to at least meet scotty. Scotty sorta killed his dog using a transporter though.
I know its the kelvin timeline, but Enterprise happens before the timeline was split.
@@deadturret4049 he also met his dog apparently lol
@@thewewguy8t88 I mean, it probably wasn't porthos but whatever
The holoprogram Riker used have been based on the "official " version of his death. That would be a good way to explain him being alive and Enterprise ending still canon by him faking his death.
Not to be biased at all, but absolutely love your presentation of this, Adam! Sorry, Jack... don't fire me 😁
The ensign should be promoted.
@@LangeloScuro from your mouth to the captains ears 🤣
I would love to see it back on the screen.
I liked that Enterprise is the only ST series with an actual opening song(that wasn't only an instrumental)
Ensign Adam tell CPT Jack to promote you. IMO, you did a better job than he normally does and found you more entertaining.
Good review of the Memory Beta canon. Hope that some of the paperback books eventually make it into official lore one day. They were a fun read.
Reason was for finalie. It was ment to be 2 EPs but as ppl know if a series goes to 100 EPs it can be brought out and redone by a syndacate so they rewritten the last 2 to do a TNG ep of that being shown on the holodeck to make it 99 EPs
Excellent idea! Lets bring any of the cast back to guest star on Strange New Worlds: Archer or T-pol and of course Trip to explain his death was just a coverup so he could turn into a Romulan spy. Brilliant! (Because: Killing off a major beloved character at series end was hard to watch!)
Now I want a Colonel Sanders Star Trek series.
😂 Omg ! How have I never heard this guy before?! 😃. This was brilliant! TYVM 🙏🏼👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🖖🏼
They should have released a TV pilot.
“Tucker 3 - Secret Agent Man.
He died to save his friend. He’ll die again to save the president!”
Coming to screens near you. You paid for the whole seat but you’ll only need the edge of it!
I started watching Trek during the pandemic, and Enterprise was my first Trek series. I kinda liked the vibe of the song. It gave me a feeling of hope for the future, which I and the world needed badly at that time. Maybe it's just that it found me at the right time, but I absolutely did not hate it.
Ensign Adam sounds like Gul Survives. Miss those uploads.
*JUST NOW* I got why his nickname was Trip. He was the 3rd ... TRIPLE .... TRIP ....
Anyone else used to watch SyFy Wire? I keep expect Ensign Adam to shout out "Crusher Watch!" just like SyFy Wire's host...
I always hated that Trip died. I felt it was pointless. 😕
"Revisionist history is such a comfort." The Doctor, Living Witness ;)
Very interesting scenario. Keep up the good work
I never thought of this until now. I mean Trip was approached more than once by Section 31 during the show if I remember correctly. And Trip was always positive when his life was hanging by a thread in the series finale, even if it looked like there was no hope he would survive.
I wouldn't have watched the entire series had I known Trip would die like that. 1001 plans they can all come up on the fly to thwart the bad guys, but this time, this one time alone he decides to blow himself up? And how did the sensors not detect the enemy vessel that day? or where they boarded? So many bizarre circumstances that the writers don't really account for. At least if they make a movie, they can come up with something like this video.
I would like to see Tpol come to Trips rescue, and save his life further strenghtening their bond and driving them to having a family together.
So sad enterprise didn't make it to a 5th season unfortunately time has passed them by as much of a fan of enterprise lam still today approximately 20 years since enterprise ended l hardly see the series being revised so so sad l truly miss the series and do watch the reruns
Still never want to use a teleporter...
Ditto. I’ll never forget years ago I had a dream where I was transported, it was wild, my brain trying it’s best to imagine the sensations what I would see. I woke up and I could still feel the sensation, crazy. But I would be like McCoy and take a shuttle. I love the transporter, probably my fav trek tech…but…it’s a kill box. I’d like to believe the essence is transported but I’m not convinced it’s not a copy.
Teleportation affects my WHAT!!!???
No thanks- I'll take a ship, or walk through space if I have to.
(Why can't the effect on the privates be uhh...positive!!!)
TRIPP WAS MY PERSONAL FAVORITE MEMBER I WONDER WHY.
Daniels intervened and pulled him to the future , probably 2399 or farther
Love your commentary. Very funny and entertaining
Hey! I'm just happy he survived! He was my favorite character! As well as any person who loves a good pan fried catfish is good 👍
The old "Reichenbach Falls" trick!
Perceptive observation Sherlock!!!
@@jamesfan3010 Elementary! A. Conan Doyle wanted to end Sherlock by killing him off with Moriarty at the Reichenbach falls but popular opinion made him bring Holmes back. The technique is often used by other writers.
Trip Tucker sprinkles 🤣🤣🤣 nice Lower Decks reference 👏🏻
Section 31 has been played as the get out of jail free retcon of Star Trek.
I kind of wish there wasn’t a Section 31 first introduced in DS9.
It’s gott out of hand to the point Federation are becoming the Romulans
"it's still the wrong song, for anything Star Trek. I've got faith, I will gag. It's a rock ballad. ,.....faith, I will gag, faith of the gag"
I'm sorry I just can't see Trip joining Section 31 at all. His personality doesn't fit.
Yeah, catchy song.
But, I much prefer the Lower Decks' explaination for ALL 'return from death' in Star Trek. 😃😄
My brother was a Chef and avid Star Trek fan. Would have loved creating culinary delights for crews aboard NX starship❤😊
You can tell trip didnt die because the crew acted like nothing happened after it. 😅😅 its clearly a rewrite of history from the holodeck by Riker
That would be a good story. Another one I want to see in Picard is at some point Picard is horribly wounded on a remote planet. He is taken to a nearby settlement to be patched up by Doctor Simon Tarses (not a real doctor but the best the people in this remote area have).
Please let this be true in some fashion. Keep Trip Tucker alive in either Section 31 or SNW, PLEASE!!!
I can see a team up of Trip and Gergeiou for the Section 31 series.
@@driftbandit4740 Me too!
so the theory that Archer can be the unknown time silhouette can be wrong if it is Trip who helped Sillick in the temporal war because he may have access to early time communication from the secret section 31
I’ve had to watch this twice and I’m still fuddled…got the Col. Sanders joke second time round though😊. Did you mention the ‘Harkonnens’ as well as ‘Michael the Wraith’?
Yep
while watching this video I saw an ad for Star Trek discovery and I noticed that the guy who played Baal in Stargate SG one was in it. This makes me even more curious.
As for the thing with the transporters can't explains why old doc McCoy didn't like them...
It's a good feeling that Mr. Trip isn't dead.
Trip didn't need to "survive." Riker's holoprogram was malfunctioning on the Enterprise D. That was a common occurrence on his Enterprise and O'Brien even jokes about the holodeck "gone wrong" with Worf on DS9. So Trip never was harmed in reality in the first place!
Trip was the wholesome every man and while I can see him sacrificing for Star Fleet it would indeed affect him deeply.
Fans have ULTIMATE say on canon. If WE say these are the voyages never happened it DIDN'T happen!
Archer would know, because he went into the future
"it's been a long road"
Apparently, S31 chose the most Human of Humans to ever have humaned for their Romulan infiltration.
As someone with minimal tactical experience, he seems to have been picked for his engineering/warp 5 background and extreme patriotism brought on by the Xindi incident.
It's nice to envision a future for Tripp & T'Pol beyond Riker's icky fan fiction, but this truly seems like an unnecessarily long road. My headcanon is that Tripp was recruited and did one mission for S31 and then he returned to his normal life very much like Bahir would do years later.
commander trip doesn't have to come back from dead tpol clearly states that it had been more the 6yrs since their sexual relationship had ended since we don't know how long their relationship lasted it could easily start here for the reboot, your take is cool to
I would really like to see Trip and Tpol end up together. The show was driving the viewers toward that general conclusion, but instead we got a huge mess with Trips "death" and a sudden end to the show. Total blue balls.
He "survived" because he was never dead in the first place.
Well it was a holodeck simulation
@@mammutMK2 Exactly.
Ok guys
I’m a newb
I started chronological order
Trip was my favorite character
I Just finished the show today….
What in the actual F-k happened?? lol I’m devastated by how bad the last episode was and felt so outta theme with whole show then look what they did to my boy?? I refuse to believe that’s how trip went out.
I’m like literally shaking so pissed , this is brand new information for some people ! So wrong 😑
Trip's death in Enterprise always thought was a big mistake and so was the cancellation of show. and finale episode was stupid too.
I think this theory goes down hill when one realizes that Romulans don't have southern accents
I have a simple explanation as to why he died... someone simply screwed up when they set up the holodeck program (Probably Reg)
Riker messed up the simulation by interacting with the other characters and the holodeck was trying to adapt to the small changes he created
I think you have a GREAT Cardassian voice! And thanks for refreshing my memory on the ENT relaunch novels; I read all of them and enjoyed them. But I gotta say, the whole premise for Trip established in "The Good that Men Do" and carried forward was so convoluted and unnecessary, it never made any sense. In other words, okay, canonically Trip was "killed" in that equally incoherent finale episode "These Are The Voyages," set YEARS after "Terra Prime" and the rest of the series. And the premise for these novels is going to be that, in the future, old men Jake and Nog uncover a conspiracy proving that, no, Trip's death was staged. Okay, fine, so far I'm with you. But then, Jake and Nog, tell us that, oh no, Trip didn't actually "die" in 2161 as history has been propagandized. Those events actually took place years prior, some time shortly after "Terra Prime" so that average folks in the far future (who probably never heard of him anyway--seriously, he was the ship's mechanic) will be led to believe that Trip Tucker was actually STILL ALIVE!!! when he was...actually still alive. Wait. What??
Okay, hold on, let me try this conspiracy again: History was rewritten to so that average folks in the future are taught that Trip was actually still alive when he was actually still alive and that he "died" years later to...cover up his undercover activities leading up to and during the Romulan War...which happened years BEFORE his supposed death...so that the world believes that he died years AFTER he was supposedly still alive when he was...still alive. Meanwhile, fellow crewmembers in his own time (those who were not in on it), were led to believe that Trip was dead, contemporary news and media reported that he was "dead," the whole world was lead to believe that he was dead--and nobody from that time raised any question or objection when the history books began to shift those events around and claim that he was actually still alive when he supposed to be dead and, instead, "died" later. None of that makes any sense--and it was completely unnecessary.
The authors didn't need to twist themselves into a pretzel to reveal to the reader that Trip Tucker was actually still alive, set during a period we already knew that he was still alive. They could have written years worth of adventures for Trip (even clandestine adventures, Starfleet officers do it all the time) and then addressed his "death" when the timeline came to it. Is Strange New Worlds going to go out of its way to show us that Pike is still uninjured during a period that he is still uninjured?
Don’t forget that STK also has several alternative timelines because of various “time altering anomalies” so it really depends on which timeline you are following.
@@christianfreedom-seeker934 - STK?
I would have killed for a season or 2 of terra prime where they ended up there fighting their othere selves . i do have to wonder if the Philip Georgio was a product of Hoshi
@@yukinagato6761 - The writer of of the Discovery episode which introduced her with that long list of titles included a Japanese title which was supposed to be a reference to Hoshi. Not necessarily a direct relative (the actress and the character are both Malaysian) but the title was supposed to be a nod to Hoshi. I’ve never been a big Mirror Universe fan, but “Enterprise” did the best ever Mirror episodes. I actually did want to see it continued.
@@MoonjumperReviews I think so as well . they learned from teh mistakes of TOS and DS9
That blue skin was one of my favorite characters.
Sir you are utterly priceless !!😀👌👍👍👍
Ensign Adam deserves a promotion! Or, we riot!! Lol
That was a complete and utter useless death. Series finale, never to return, yet creating an arc that would never be used or followed.
Just maybe thinking Dr Flox kept the other Charles Tucker Frozen in Stacy's and somehow he broke out and remembering not liking the Cindy decided to take matters into his own hands knowing he wasn't going to live long anyway.....
That's my thoughts on it....
I don't think Trip is dead at all. I consider that episode a huge error on the part of the Enterprise D's Holo deck history archives. It is simple as that. That last episode on Enterprise was hugely disrespectful towards the Enterprise series. I think everyone would rather just forget about it. In my mind there were many many more adventures for the entire crew of the Enterprise NX01, Trip simply never died in that manner nor in that time period. I am sure Trip had a lot to do with the second hull and large deflector they are destined to add to their ship. There are many more adventures to be had.
No no that's not how Tucker survived. Because of the debt he owed Archer for restoring the future timeline Daniels the time traveler from the future removed Tucker from the ship just before the plasma conduit exploded. He was sent to the future so the timeline would not be contaminated. This is consistent with the time Capt Braxton recruited Seven of Nine and Janeway to save Voyager from being destroyed.
The return of Tripp is an idea for a storyline for Strange New Worlds that should be submitted.