An IMPORTANT update on emergency medical treatment! I've had a few people point out the "No Surprises Act" which was passed this year: www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/no-surprises-understand-your-rights-against-surprise-medical-bills Now, if you have health insurance, this act will "Ban surprise bills for most emergency services, even if you get them out-of-network and without approval beforehand (prior authorization)." This is super good news, and it means that you shouldn't be afraid of calling 911 in a medical emergency-you'll still have to pay for it (like an in-network procedure), but it won't be completely out of pocket if you go to an out-of-network hospital. The act will also "Require that health care providers and facilities give you an easy-to-understand notice explaining the applicable billing protections..." and though I'm less convinced about the "easy-to-understand" aspect, at the very least it means you SHOULD be notified about this when you receive the bill!
NSA was great, but also worth a shout out to the Transparency in Coverage regulation. Idealistically will also mean that you should be able to get an (at least approximate) rate from your health insurance provider for a given service.
Also REMEMBER EVERYONE: *If you have a procedure done that you are told is going to be covered and then when you get there to pay, they have an OUT-Of-NETWORK company give you Anesthesia but they never told you they weren't in-network & make you pay $2,380 for it, MAKE A COMPLAINT/APPEAL for it because not telling your patients about an additional out-of-network cost that's also being done is ILLEGAL.* Because this is against the law, your insurance company will APPROVE your Appeal and the doctor's office who you paid will have to PAY YOU BACK THAT MONEY. Get your money back!!! Don't overpay or let doctors get away with ILLEGAL shit like this!! I just had it happen to me TWICE so they're having to pay ME back over $3,000.
Yo, my current job is in a department that *enforces* the rules of the No Surprises Act! 😁 This "no-choice" loophole was a thorn in my side for *years* because it was "technically" legal. Now I get to call bullsh*t on their billing practices with the federal government to back me up, and save regular people from getting billed for things completely out of their control.
To elaborate, the "easy-to-understand" requirement includes - most importantly - a price estimate of the cost of the services you will be receiving voluntarily by providers who are out of your insurance network. You must be given this paperwork at least 72 hours before the expected procedure - if you weren't given the papers, then it's on them to explain why, not you. It also protects you from hospitals contracting out their labs/radiology/anesthesia to third party companies that stay out of network because they know people have no choice. (There's one company in particular that provided *neonatal care* that stayed out of network to take advantage of this loophole. That's right, *preying on families with newborns.* I'm SO glad they're finally facing consequences.)
Unrelated, but if there's a bounty for if you turn in a guy who did something really cool to the police, don't fall for it because they will screw you over and not pay it out.
@@vulpinemachine Tell me about it. I'm going to a 200k dollar uni (my dumbass thought it was 50k because they never said that amount was per year on their website and I trusted them on that figure, stupid me) and while the president is getting a key to the city and spending 22 million on a football stadium, the music building literally has fucking asbestos in the noise cancelling panels on the walls and one of the dorm halls has a mold problem, the asbestos being a completely open secret and the mold issue being an open fact. The goal was never to make your life better. It's to give you the illusion that your life is better or will be better down the line
Re-sharing this again. Folks in the UK asking questions after a certain incident. Extreme health care reform advocacy is shining a light on this cursed hellscape
Seeing this as an American in my early 20s is like walking down a long, dark, narrow corridor and seeing a text prompt telling me to hold Shift to sprint.
I don't usually leave comments like this, but this is genuinely one of the funniest and most encompassing descriptions I've ever heard for being an early 20-something. Thanks for the laugh and existential dread lol.
I mean they wrote the code for their maximum gain. The question is why we allowed them to. Seems like a functioning democracy should have stopped such a disgusting predatory system. Yet support for public healthcare in the US is only around 50%.
@@chazdomingo475 Wanna know another funny little trick Politicians don't want you to know? Being a politician with money causes your vote to all of a sudden carry a lot more weight than if you were broke.
One of my core memories is my mom being locked in the office on the phone like a full time job for several days because our insurance got bought out and they stopped covering ALL of my sister’s medical costs. Eye exams, tests, PCP appointments, EVERYTHING. After a LITERAL WEEK of being transferred , gathering documents, getting corporate phone numbers, she finally found out why: my sister was receiving health insurance from her two full time jobs which excluded her from the family plan. MY SISTER WAS 8. The best part is you have to confirm the patients name and DOB to access any information. They eventually got slammed with a fee (that was definitely way less than they made from charging people who didn’t have the knowledge or time to fight this battle) in a lawsuit. Turns out in the data transfer they purposely lost or altered data to shit like “grade schooler has 2 full time jobs” to siphon money out of people in the confusion and then use the confusion and unnavigability of a new system as a smoke screen. I love it here.
Btw if you know you are being charged unfairly DO NOT PAY. You should have a grace period to pay so that gives you time to fight back. Otherwise they’ll go “oh yeah there was a mistake but it looks like the bills already settled so that’s great!” And now you’re out $15000 and filing for bankruptcy. :/
@@Lorraine202I just learned this. My insurance company has been increasing the amount listed as what I owe for months even though the actual HCP’s costs were settled. Double check before paying anything to these vultures.
@@orppranator5230It depends, but that's the government's problem to deal with then. You still only pay a maximum of $35 per consultation or medically necessary procedure/medication, and your involvement in it ends there.
@@orppranator5230 A public system could be designed to be non-profit. If the government sets up a system where it's a CRIME to charge people then Any Charge At All will be su autosuspect that only the particularly uneducated would even try.
As someone that's worked in health insurance for 6+ years, I can confirm that *all* of this is correct, and it's exactly as baffling, opaque, and unfair as it sounds. Well done on creating something that gave me flashbacks to the innocent days when I was being onboarded into this nightmare of a system, but had to learn all this through "fun" modules.
@@bunshine Oh, I intend to!! That's part of the reason I've stayed in this industry. I want to work my way up to a point where I can help in the dismantling of the whole thing, with the infrastructure scrapped for parts and used to manage a single-payer system. I've worked in Medicaid AND private plans, I *KNOW* it can be done.
surely you must also know that the lobbying is also used on lowering costs via workplace safety? I get its bad, but from the outside looking in- isnt that largely just the sales dept's and healthcare provider's fault?
I got charged for watching this video by my health insuarance. Apparently, Brian is an out-of-network consultant and I didnt get him approved beforehand as a specialist by my PCP. Now I'm broke! Thanks Insurance!
Too funny!! Doing research on all of this and it seems the affordable health care act and the government and IRS and people running it..have been banking. They have been receiving $6400 a month or more .. definetly $300 a week for EVERYONE with a social security number! And GOD knows how long this has been going on for..and to just think only a handful of people have actually "applied" to recieve there entitled benefits. Seems super shady and a way to line the government's pockets. Investigation is continuing and hopefully EVERYONE will be informed of the TRUTH very soon.
Or the classic "it's either this or increased taxes! Do you really want more taxes?" as if the increased taxes will somehow be more expensive for the individual than the thousands of dollars people are forced to spend on healthcare.
@@creeperhunterD [2 buttons meme:] [option 1: pay like 1% higher taxes and live worry-free] [option 2: pay a completely unpredictable amount for health care and have to navigate medical bureaucracy every time you have an unexpected medical situation] It's just so hard to choose!
torries complaining about having to wait months to see a specialist while i, an american, couldn't even get a referral for my obvious chronic illness until after i developed permanent damage to my spine...and then i STILL have to wait half a year for my initial appointment with a specialist! (not saying the british healthcare system doesn't need improving, but privatizing the industry is a massive step in the wrong direction. fight for your public healthcare tooth and nail.)
I have been diabetic for 30 years (since I was a kid) and let me tell you.. navigating the nightmare that is the American Healthcare system for my entire life has been soul crushing. It's worse than the fucking disease.
I will never forget hearing my 20 year old brother sobbing on the phone trying to get his diabetic supplies shipped to him after days of calling and hours on hold and after nearly a month of having no method of testing his glucose levels. To this day it makes my blood boil.
Not trying to be funny but I have a question, why not just leave America? For real, it's a shit hole, have you considered moving to a place with free healthcare?
It's honestly crazy how Brian comes up with these weird existential nightmare scenarios... Like could you imagine if that's how health insurance really worked? That would be terrifying!
Ha ha! Even just thinking about the existential crisis I would have over this totally nonexistent system is killing me! And I wouldn't be able to afford the medicine that would save me! 😂
Soooooo damn glad I'm German right now. You go to whichever doctor you like, let them do whatever they want, and never even see the bill for the treatment.
Also REMEMBER EVERYONE: *If you have a procedure done that you are told is going to be covered and then when you get there to pay, they have an OUT-Of-NETWORK company give you Anesthesia but they never told you they weren't in-network & make you pay $2,380 for it, MAKE A COMPLAINT/APPEAL for it because not telling your patients about an additional out-of-network cost that's also being done is ILLEGAL.* Because this is against the law, your insurance company will APPROVE your Appeal and the doctor's office who you paid will have to PAY YOU BACK THAT MONEY. Get your money back!!! Don't overpay or let doctors get away with ILLEGAL shit like this!! I just had it happen to me TWICE so they're having to pay ME back over $3,000.
Ah yes. How reasonable to expect a person with a concussion or with terrible wounds to stop their ambulance, doctor, and specialist before treatment and say, "Now, wait just a minute. Are you in my network? If not, would you kindly let my chances of living dwindle and get one who is? Thank you."
Actually this happened to my family. My sister had an injury and we called an ambulance just to waive their help and drive her ourselves to the hospital. We were still billed an insane amount, but it was better than the $2000 for the ride
I have yet to meet an insurance where an ambulance is covered. I have decided they are fancy scams on wheels and unless I hit gold or am literally dying I won’t/ can’t use one without going into debilitating debt lmao
@@musemccormack5436 the most depressing part about that is im canadian and when i was young i just went to an adult hospital and they let me take an ambulance for fun, and last year i had an ambulance called for me bc i had a panic attack at the dentist, so i know from being in one they are incredibly *incredibly* useful when in need of one, god americs makes me sad
As a Canadian that moved to the US for work, it was maddening trying to understand why people don't riot because of this. There is literally a whole private insurance industry and departments in hospitals dedicated to just dealing with billing. It wastes so much money.
I always thought it was hilarious that conservatives try to claim private healthcare is cheaper and more efficient. I'm no fan of wading through the swamp of government bureaucracy, but I'd take it any day over corporate bureaucracy that charges me a cover fee just to get into the bog.
'cause it's just normal for them, a lot of people think without it healthcare is worse in other countries, when it really really isn't, or that it has insane waiting times, when it doesn't, (and that one's always been insane 'cause their waiting times... Aren't good?) it's hard to see a different world without ever experiencing it. Especially with all the money that goes into preserving the fuckitude that the system is. It makes me so glad to be British. 'Cause we do know what it's like, and there would absolutely be riots across the country if our system became like theirs.
And it's larger than the department dedicated to just dealing with patients. Inside of a hospital, you ONLY see the tip of the iceberg, but every level between insurance and providers have to fund their own department dedicated to fighting the other parties on coverage and billing decisions. At a hospital, your doctor is conscripted into this effort with excessive charting requirements and justification checks and outside reviews that may cost them more time than actual patient care.
Can I just say 1) this feels like a real return to form for fans of Unraveled 2) this really demonstrates that some creators are such that their audience will listen to them talk about literally ANYTHING and trust it to be entertaining
@@cygnahoshiko4629 Yeah, I'm going to grad school next year and I'm chronically ill too so I also really needed to know it. New insurance + new place + being independent to deal with my own insurance stuff. I just realized how complicated this is all going to be next year while I was watching the video.
@@chaosandbunnies8291 Imagine people not reporting it for spam. ..or worse, imagine a couple hundred people reporting it and TH-cam not doing anything about it for months.
I think BDG may have found his true calling: making adulting PSAs. I can't even imagine how helpful this would have been if my high school had shown me this video 15 years ago. Please make this a series.
Adulting step one: if you say adulting you are neurodivergent and your needs are fundamentally different from every other person the system is created to accommodate and you never will be accommodated by said system. you must find solice and support within compasionate friends because you never will find solice or support through any system where money changes hands. The best you will ever do is learn to scrape by to be able to find more moments where you can be with people you trust.
>blue cross blue shield mentioned Oh yeah I remember those guys hitting the news recently. They wanted to implement policy changes to limit the amount of anesthesia administered per surgery based on arbitrary "guidelines" defined by insurance company executives who saw some data but never spent a second in an ER. A decision which got rolled back the instant the CEO for UMC hit concrete.
@@Jehty_ the short answer is no every insurance is supposed to cover it. In practice many insurers have major caveats in their coverage regarding mental health fueled by the intrinsically subjective nature of such reports. For example I can take your blood pressure and objectively report to insurance that it's too high so you need corrective meds. But if you have depression there's no lab test, I am fully reliant on your reported symptoms to make a diagnosis and prescribe treatment. And if BDGs video was any indication it gets even more complicated when you start talking covered meds or therapy.
@@ohnoagremlin And are then surprised by the disproportionately large amount of mental health issues in our nation. Yup, the system's clearly working as intended, folks!
But then how will the government invest millions of dollar into the problem, steal most of the money, spend some money on something real to show as progress and get nothing done so they can justify another investiment to do it again?
The craziest part is actually that they categorically won't show you this in school because US curriculum don't include a single piece of information about a system that is going to dictate, more than anything else in your entire life, your health and your financial status until the day you die (possibly as a direct result of this very system). Fun! Is it not? How our educational institutions do nothing to educate us about the most consequential and universal realities of our upcoming adulthoods! Great all around.
So, I have a friend with a chronic disease that was working in the States for a couple of months, and when he needed prescription drugs, he found it more convenient to fly back to Europe, go to the doctor, get the drugs and return. Not just in terms of money, because it was also cheaper to do so, but that way he didn't have to wrestle between several companies so he could get his damn drugs.
Literally what I do too, and I've lived in the US for four years now and have insurance. Even though I don't have my German insurance anymore and have to pay out of pocket, it's much cheaper to fly home and go see my old providers there every year or two. Especially women's health services in the US are sub-par compared to the rest of the world (it's basically just a manual exam and pap-smear in the US, where in other countries they're also checking everything via ultrasound, which makes much more sense). It's ridiculous.
It can be cheaper to fly to Mexico, have a vacation, get dental surgery, then go back by the time you can even get scheduled for one in the US Even with dental insurance
@@genderender Yeah but in the US it's done by doctors with dental tools, pretty sure in Mexico it's done by mechanics with auto tools who have some free time
Yo, same. I learned the hard way that even if you have a life change that qualities you to get health insurance at a different time, you still might not be able to get it. In Massachusetts if you don’t have health insurance for three months, you get dinged on your taxes and I ALMOST hit that, luckily my employer helped me out and I got my plan sooner than later. I fucking hate this system.
Well... It is working. You just have to redefine "whom" it's working for. And that's definitely not anyone who is sick. Rich people get sick, they either are so rich they don't care or they blow through a ton of cash because they have sooooo much money that it really doesn't matter. If you don't believe me, google Sumner Redstone's net worth in 2014 and his net worth in 2020.
I still can't wrap my head around the fact that a health insurance can just say: "No we won't pay for THIS doctor. Yes, we agree that you broke your leg and needed a cast and pain medication, but it was done by the wrong guy. If Peter had done it we would pay, but we won't pay for Mark!"
As a recent US immigrant, After getting health insurance that my job pays for, I decided to have my issues looked up. I started with tinnitus which was keeping me up at night. I made sure to go to a clinic that was "in-network". They tested my hearing and there were no issues and I didn't have to pay for any of it. So far so good. But then they suggested that the issue might be brain related and could be serious. So they directed me to another clinic in the same building to get a brain scan where I got scheduled. Little did I realize that the second clinic wasn't in network, so imagine my shock when I received a 1,500$ bill on my way out. Good news is, they didn't find anything wrong with my brain... This experience destroyed my willingness to get my issues checked out and my trust in the medical industry in general. Although I have many concerning issues with my body, I'd much rather take the risk of death than ruining my family's financial stability. And I have a sneaking suspicion that this is exactly what this system is engineered to do.
Of course it is on purpose, they make seeking help so troublesome so people do it as little as possible so they can get that premium every month without offering a service.
I find it more mind-blowing that people, like yourself, prefer the chance of death over an insane hospital bill....I had friends just let me lay on their floor after a seizure during a hangout night (had too much beer as a diabetic) only because they thought my health insurance wouldn't cover the ER room. But they were sure to say how scared they were for my life....If I'm dead, I will have no bills anyway. JESUS CHRIST THIS COUNTRY IS INSANE!
@AssBlasster that's the thing, they fucking don't. That's not what OP is saying, that's not what people in the US are saying. Most people want single payer. But the health industry lobbyists don't.
US Medicare is awful. Medicaid is usually all free, but usually medicare patients are disabled and/or retired and they often need it more; *Medicare usually only covers around 80% of medical expenses. Which can be a ton if you have to see any sort of specialist regularly - (pain specialist, immunology doc, etc) And unfortunately Obamacare made it worse for a while with misleading promises, along with private insurances getting butthurt, and raising premiums and making it harder to reach a deductable(?) with medications (part D). Benefits I take for granted as a medicaid patient (free doctors visits/no copays/access to more resources like bus passes, free counseling, etc) cost too much for my permanently disabled mom to really do. She’s 60. Im 23 and chronically ill/can’t work right now. Im sad I can’t pay for her to be seen.
tip from a health insurance agent who hates his job: if your drug list includes tier 3 and up drugs, you can submit a tier reduction request. basically, if your doctor says you can't take the generic/plan-preferred drug a lot of the time the plan has to "price match" your tier 3 drug to a lower tier. it's not always a guarantee but we have a pretty good success rate with getting these requests approved. most people aren't aware that this is a possibility but it could save you a bit of money. also this video is amazing and made me cackle 😂
It's awfully convenient how health care doesn't cover psychological damage given that the structure of this system causes me the most psychological anguish
I love how TH-camrs in our generation will just organically, randomly, make the critical educational content we need the most effective or memorable way possible.
@@toulouse1 I assume it counts enough, I watch some tiktok comps about stuff like leftism and disability info and stuff like that, mainly the ones by “a dude” (that’s their actual channel name /gen) which have some pretty good info in a pretty digestible format!
Oh sure I'll think about the others I've seen sometime. Just remember watching channels I'd know for one thing and then something would come up in their life and they'd make a video to help anyone else (like their subscribers for one) with that potential life scenario. But yeah someone should make a playlist out of them, since they're more watchable and thus easy-to-remember than more bland how-tos.
@@toulouse1 not quite 'critical', but "history of the entire world, i guess" by bill wurtz is a good example of spontaneous really helpful educational videos from someone who normally doesn't make them.
Don't let them take it away from you, you can't understand how bad it is until you've lived through it, you can't let it happen, any politician even flirting with expanding private healthcare to the detriment of public healthcare should be understood for what they are, a life ending human-sized parasite determined to suck the blood out of you and every one of your loved ones until they're nothing more than dust. You are privileged if they are crushed under heel like such voracious parasites should be, however, barring that, do your damndest to keep them away from any kind of civil service. They will destroy anything good.
They have tried to several times, and they tried to do the same with tertiary education. Very scary times. So glad we still have higher taxes and better benefits 👍
I cant believe that Brian just tricked me, a 21 year old who is nervously gripping onto their parents health insurance, into learning about how to navigate getting my own healthcare. You’re doing to lords work Brian.
I am being sincere here when I say this: Start leaning now. Seriously. This shit is intentionally overly complicated, and it changes a little in ways that are hard for us plebs to understand year after year. New laws are coming out all the time that allow insurance companies to get away with literal murder. Fun fact, did you know that failure to provide aid as a professional in the event of an emergency is actually classified as a form of murder through negligence in some states? Well, insurance companies sure do, so they made damn sure those laws have loop holes in them that excuse them from ever having to pay for potentially life saving procedures that hospitals will refuse to even attempt unless you can guarantee payment in advance! YAY!
As a French person, I...I have no words for this- Our healthcare is already pretty battered, it lacks funding, and there aren't enough doctors in any field anywhere, especially in the countryside, as well as specialists dying out- But this ? This makes our country look like heaven. What the hell ?!
@@DavideMenezes42 I'm literally in shock rn, i could never imagine that something like going to a doctor could be so complicated in the US. VIVA O SUS PORRA!
First of all, Americans who understand healthcare do indeed look at the French system and think yours is pretty great. As to how we got here, it’s a historical accident. During World War II, wage controls were put in place to prevent the US economy from spinning out of control. Businesses were not allowed to increase salary by too much. But if a business can’t raise wages, how can they attract workers? Well, they can offer something else besides money as payment. So they started offering health insurance. And then a little while later, the government started giving tax breaks to companies that offer health insurance. So now the system is entrenched. Every time someone tries to reform it, businesses rebel. Also, the health insurance companies are not set up to provide good care. They are set up to make money. A lot of the reforms of Obamacare were regulations on premiums, coinsurance, copays, out of pocket maximums, and a bunch of other things. It still wasn’t a fundamental change to the system, but it did make a difference in a lot of places.
I'm french and the video was so funny it made me forget this was actually a real thing and not some strange dystopian fiction. Then I read the comments and now I'm tearing up in a bus. This is awful, I sincerely hope this whole system gets burned to the ground and no one ever has to go through that again. How is access to healthcare not a human right??
Basically, it’s an accident of history. During the Second World War, the US froze prices and wages to prevent inflation, but companies still needed incentives to lure workers during an extreme wartime labor shortage. So they started offering health insurance in lieu of higher pay, and since the US wasn’t bombed to shit during the war and exited into an economic boom, it remained in place. Nobody likes it, but most people are afraid that a total overhaul will mess up the service they’ve already worked so hard to set up for themselves. Even many labor unions are skeptical of nationalized healthcare because they fear not being able to negotiate with employers for their own insurance will deprive them of leverage.
@@noalequinoa I would add two things to Sam's explanation: First, our health insurance premiums come with the benefit of lower taxes, meaning that the money we spend on our healthcare system is, at least in theory, "extra" money that we have because our taxes are lower than yours. There's quite a bit of truth to this; in France, the average person pays 27.8% income tax, if I understand the results of my Google search correctly, along with a 20% VAT, meaning you pay an average combined tax rate of 47.8%, while--depending on your state--in my home state of Oregon, you'd probably be paying more like 20% _combined_ state and federal taxes. On the other hand, our marginal tax rates aren't that much lower than some countries that have national healthcare systems, since we also spend more money per person on our military and defense industry. (Some have even complained that foreign countries e.g. in Europe are being freed up to spend more of their taxes on social programs such as healthcare *because* the USA spends so much on defense.) Second, our private system comes with quite a bit more decision-making power for people who are looking for care (maybe not emergency care, but most healthcare). We have a lot of latitude to seek second opinions, perhaps look for a doctor with a similar healthcare philosophy to our own (e.g. on the cost-benefit analysis of ordering tests or prescribing medications). We have a lot more latitude to decide whether spending that extra $10,000 to potentially save our life is worth it, whereas a country with government healthcare will make that "worth-it decision" for you.
@@philipmcniel4908 VAT stands for Value Added Tax, and it has nothing to do with income. It is just a tax added to goods and services that the end-consumer has to pay for (included in the listed price of an iPhone, which is partly why iPhones are more expensive in Europe, for example). So the average person pays 27.8% income tax (according to your research) plus some other collective deductions like health insurance and unemployment insurance (less than 10%). I've lived in both Finland and the U.S for my whole life in and out, and the system is 100% more favorable in Finland for the middle class and the poor. If you're making $100k and more, which is of course more likely in the U.S, only then the lower taxes favor you. Also, you can get private insurance in Europe as well that gives you that decision-making power for far cheaper premiums. Anyway, it's true that the U.S is as individualistic as it gets and a land full of opportunities, so with smart work and some luck you might just be able to get the best of both worlds.
What kills me (literally) is when the insurance companies refused coverage for anything they could label a "pre-existing condition". An infamous case was a young rape victim being denied coverage for her treatment, because she had been raped a few years previously so her being a rape victim was a pre-existing condition.
You would not believe the private and public armies that will be dispatched if they come under any serious pressure from the proletariat. A civil war would be hideous, unfortunately we have to use the government. Luckily we can still vote- for now.
The guillotine really isn't the best revolutionary symbol given its bedbugs used more as a tool for colonial violence than it's been used as against kings and the bourgeois.
Working in healthcare, I'd like to add: Insurance companies will do everything they can to NOT pay a claim. They don't make money at the rates they do without denying claims at every chance they can.
Very much true. My partner has quite a few health issues and whenever her doctor recommends a new medicine, she has to go through a negotiation process of her insurance saying well we don't think you need THAT medicine, how about THIS medicine tho? After that medicine fails to work and the doctor reports that to the insurance, they MIGHT agree to cover the recommended medication. I say might because many times they have you go through several different options first, despite the doctor believing their recommendation is best. My daughter has chronic migraines and her specialist recommended Botox treatments in parts of her head and neck, which have pretty good success rates and next to no side effects compared to migraine meds which leave her super tired and dizzy and nauseous. Insurance made her go through a month of 3 different medicines before they finally agreed to cover the Botox, which has helped her greatly. It's an extremely frustrating, wasteful system. Perhaps it's because we use government insurance and not private so we generally don't have copays, thank god, but this system just doesn't work well for seemingly anyone. Sorry for the wall of text, I kinda just poured my frustrated brain out here because it's a constant source of stress living with 2 chronically unwell people that I know deserve better
Had a similar situation in my family. Doctor prescribed a certain medication, but insurance was only willing to pay some tiny percentage of the cost, but would cover 100% of the cost of some other medication that sort of is supposed to do some of the same things, but not exactly. So, had to take the worse medication for a period to prove that it wouldn't work completely before they would cover the prescribed medication.
@@iamjustkiwi That our healthcare system allows (and incentivizes) your treatment to be determined by insurance companies against the doctor's actual suggestions is one of the clearest examples of how fucking broken this shit is.
Exactly why I'm leaving this buzzsaw of an industry. It does nothing but create pressure at all levels, personally and professionally, internally and externally.
And when you call the customer service line to check if something is covered, they rattle off a line about “nothing I say is a guarantee of coverage.” I asked a rep once how I could get a definite Yes or No before scheduling an appt and risk owing 100% of the bill. They said, “you can’t.”
I had the same issue with the dentist. I would call the receptionist and ask "Is X covered?" You couldn't get a straight answer from her! She would give you a bunch of mumbo jumbo! Something about how you have to book an appointment first and be seen by the dentist first. I told her "Ma'am, this is a yes-or-no question." She got SOOOO angry and frustrated with me! She exploded at me!
My favorite part about the deep dives on American healthcare is seeing the horrified reactions of people who aren't from the United States. This is an in depth beginners crash course on health insurance. None of the information presented here is satire, right down to the plans that are referred to as "Part A," "Part B," etc. It's exhausting.
I live in a third world country and I get literally EVERYTHING for free. "Oh but queue's must be super long!" I go see a doctor same day if I need to, and I if I have to I can get a doctor home visit (also free).
@@ThoughtsOnThoughts thank you, I swear I have people in my family who are obvious victims of the predatory privatized healthcare and they still go “well at least I only have to wait 3-6 months to even a year to see a doctor instead of however long the queues must be over in places with privatized healthcare!”
@@ThoughtsOnThoughts free? nothing is free my friend. Somebody always has to pay, people have to make the medications, work the hospitals, track the records, etc... payment comes through money or time. The real reason American health insurance is so bad, *aside from the shoddy bureaucracy* is because there is *basically* no upper limit to what the government will pay for different things. So in practice big pharma and hospitals can cooperate to charge exorbitant rates to insured people. Really, Americas insurance problem is deeply rooted in a very large number of other issues, like government money laundering and insider trading, gross government inefficient/malicious spending, outdated laws and systems... When people say they want insurance in the private sector, they don't normally mean completely independent from law, they just want it in businesses with a monetary incentive to do things right, and a minimal degree of government intervention necessary only for keeping the companies from cooperating to jack prices up and to keep insurance payments at a low price for consumers that is affordable but still profitable. Another reason people want private insurance is so that people that have enough money to not need insurance do not have to pay for other peoples insurance, either through taxes or payments. Long story short, governments don't normally have their peoples best interests in mind.*yes I am aware that businesses don't either, but they at least have an incentive existing in the bottom line they must meet*
You know you're chronically ill when the first five seconds of this video make complete sense to you, both in what the acronyms mean and in why BDG chose them.
Haha, yup! The only reason I wasn't immediately screwed by the system when my illness showed up is because I had my mom who also dealt with chronic illness as a guide.
As an American college student, this video is genuinely very helpful. They never teach you any of this stuff but it can be life ruining if you don't know about it.
Its by design. Creating an unnecessarily complicated system then justifies the existence of "experts" (Tax Experts, Insurance Experts, Ect) who can then make money off of people usually not having the time to learn these complicated systems. Its also why none of these systems are ever taught, and if anything is done to try and simplify it, lobbyist groups who represent those "experts" step in to keep the money making scheme going.
@@ThatOneREDScout Information asymmetry is one of the most common ways to capture profits. OP, the main thing you need to understand is that you live in a society that is trying to trick and trap you at every step. Never trust anyone.
About two thirds of the way in I felt a panic attack brewing because I was getting scared that I wasn't understanding this enough so I had to start repeating "I'm not American, I'm not American" to calm down. Not sure if that speaks more to how terrifying this system is or to how good you are at immersing me into a topic
Hahahaah well at least you dont actually live in this nightmare. I only have a year left being under my parents and im scared 😢 make sure this doesnt happen where you live!
@@princessalia6 Oh I've been trying. I live in Alberta, Canada and our last Premier (Basically a Governer, he was American too) tried his damnedest to privitize healthcare, and sadly enough a lot of people were on his side, but he never really got anywhere with it and ultimately if he did I wouldn't have been surprised if the Federal Govt stepped in and said "No", but for a hot minute I was pretty terrified
@@princessalia6 Not a thing apperently. I'm planning on moving at some point to Ontario or maybe Nova Scotia. The more time goes on the more Alberta is turning into a Little US inside of Canadian borders at best, or a fascist splinter state at worst and I don't wanna be here when the axe comes down either way
I can't speak to not living in this nightmare, but I can say that having lived in it all my life and now currently being unable to fix significant and life-altering problems with my teeth for several years to the point where I haven't been able to chew food and I don't know that fixing my teeth will even fix the problem now because I have no idea if I'll be able to chew like normal or if my jaw has atrophied...it's not great.
As a french fellow, I first laugh. Then I remember my government craves to privatize our health system and the video became suddenly a LOT LESS funnier.
its because your goverment is paying billonaires out of the ass for products, it just appears free to you. trust me corporations are still raping the supposed "free" healthcare countries. your healthcare is owned by american and foreign corporations through your govermemt
I once watched EMTs debate which hospital they should take a patient to because they couldn’t remember which hospital was in what network, while the man held his own head wound closed. That’s when I realized I might want to leave the country… …and then I did. Never have to deal with this crap in Canada 🇨🇦
As someone who took an EMT course in America and is training to be an EMT; when I asked one of my instructors about why certain things were they way they were, the instructor literally told me: "Oh because of the power of Insurance companies, they set that up." Like, what the fuck?! How can someone who has not one minute of medical training possibly be determining what is covered or what a "pre-existing condition" is??? This whole system is a fucking farce. We need Universal Healthcare in the USA
@@robert-rv8lo The differences between late stage capitalism and fascism get so blurry that sometimes it is hard to tell when your democracy did die or if it even existed in the first place.
Check if your state provides subsidized insurance for people with disabilities. That information should be available on your state's department of health/public health website. I ended up paying like $60 a month for Medicare cause I'm constantly dying.
My sympathies. Also worth checking, if you’re still living with your family and are likely to for the foreseeable future, if you might be able to stay on theirs as a disabled dependent. (Which has its obvious downsides, but as someone who’s remained on parental health insurance after 26 because I can’t really work, I bring it up.)
As an ER doctor, that's true, we're often private contractors. Which also means I don't get health insurance through work. Which blows and also screws patients over because the middleman who staffs the ED is often out of network. Oh, and did you know that insurance companies can completely change what drugs are covered by their formulary anytime of the year? and that doesn't count as a qualifying life event? Wait is our medical system... Irretrievably... Broken?
Wtf doctors dont get health insurance....what a weird concept. it should be universal healthcare for doctors/nurses/other medical profs doing the work for our health care system!
@@Superboologan1 I'd assume that doctors have a good enough salary to be able to afford private healthcare and costs of out-of-network care, but at worst, the same thing that everyone else does when they don't have medical help. They die.
the american health care system was made to make money and not spend it.., thats what america is about.. making money as much as possible and making sure to not lose any... at any cost..
1:40 yes, they wanted to privatize health care here in Brazil. We have free and private healthcare available but they wanted to privatize all of it. We didn't let them do that.
Play this _in_ the insurance offices when you want to make a claim. Remember that scene in The Incredibles when Bob tells a client how to get her claim approved? That should be mandatory. People deserve to know how to benefit from their insurance.
Thanks for the helpful guide! I've decided that the best course of action is to remain in a sterilized room wrapped in twenty layers of bubble wrap for the rest of my days.
You know, in my experience, it is even WORSE than this. Especially if you live in a black or Hispanic or Asian neighborhood. I lived near a physical therapy clinic. The therapist there would ruin it for you, even if you had insurance. He would fuck it up for you by failing to ask the insurance company for permission to treat his patients. Which meant no visits for them. He would also touch their breasts while they were on the table and sexually harass them. Which meant you didn't even WANT a visit with him anyway! Ironically. For some reason, when I reported him to the insurance company for both transgressions, they took his side.
@@jakobvanklinken Yeah ... no. Sure we have copays but don't pretend like we get insane pricings and holes in our coverage like in the US. Sure if you go to a specialist which isn't in basic insurance such as physical therapy you'll have to pay it yourself. But that's only if you don't have a certain chronic issue which requires you to go. And if you are in an emergency situation 'network' doesn't mean anything. And if it is 'out of network' you usually only pay about 10-30% of the full price. In a country as small as the Netherlands and like I said earlier ignoring emergency situations which don't apply there is basically no reason to go out of network in the Netherlands. Where American companies have those systems in place mostly for monetary gain, Dutch insurance companies have it in place to stop people from hopping from doctor to doctor, clogging up systems with inefficiency. The Netherlands has far from a perfect system. But it's harmful to the existing system and the people fighting for universal healthcare to state that the system in place in the Netherlands is anywhere near the system of the US.
Pro tip: if you have to take a super expensive medication that has a high copay, the drug manufacturer will often have a program to cover the copay for you. This is because they'd rather eat the copay amount if it means they can still bill your insurance for the rest.
THIS. My specialty medication would have bankrupted me years ago if my doctor hadn't offhandedly mentioned that the manufacturer had a reimbursement system. It's saved me probably over $100K in the past decade.
@@nemo-zl1vm as someone who is not american and does not take medication it baffles me to think that a life-saving medicine could even cost 10k a year. is it subsidised at all?
@@acookie7548 This particular medication gets billed at $40K per dose, and I get 8 doses per year, but my max out of pocket for health insurance is about $7K. With the reimbursement program, I "only" end of paying a thousand or so a year for it. Sometimes my insurance likes to deny my claim for bullshit reasons, so I get to spend a few months thinking I'm suddenly $40K in debt while I beg them to change their mind. Whatever country you live in, vote like hell to prevent them from privatising health costs - it really is hard to exaggerate how hellish it can be. As for subsidies, there's lots of "it depends" that can take age or poverty status into account. You can theoretically deduct health costs from your taxes, but it's limited and it's difficult to qualify for it.
I hate that some dude on the internet was able to go over all this in 30 minutes (and the sad part is, that it's trending) whereas the person in HR couldn't even bother to tell me what all of this meant when I first started working. Thank you for this, Brian. Not all heroes wear capes. Congratulations on making it onto the trending page too!
I'm so glad my mom worked in health insurance and could explain everything to me when it was time for me to choose my plan. It's such a scam that there's so many extra little costs, and that some plans don't even cover you fully once you hit your deductible!! I'm enrolled in a German university now, and it was SO weird to not have to wade through different copay levels, deductibles, etc... the public options that I looked at all were the same price and covered the same things. Though I do have to choose doctors who accept public insurance.
To be fair, I'd bet that 90% of HR personnel don't understand Health Insurance themselves, so it's easier to just kind of hand wave it. They should do better, but they likely don't do better for themselves either.
@@LeafMaltieze In a lot of corporations the plans or even providers are changes every 2-3 years. Literally no one can keep up with it. All the training comes directly from the provider. Guess how helpful it is.
My wife has a blood condition that 4 people in the US have. It’s SUPER cheap to treat, but bc it’s rare, we’ve had to fight for 9 months to get care. Thank you for this cathartic, and hilarious, recap of our year.
Same thing happened to my family, insurance wouldn't accept the first Dr.s letter so had to literally beg the chief of medicine of a children's hospital in person so my family wouldn't be financially crippled for life... and we're the ones who are lucky
whoaa how do you even get a diagnosis for something that rare? because most doctors will have never even heard of it, and even for relatively common chronic illnesses like POTS it's ridiculously difficult to get a diagnosis or any type of referral for further testing
@@notebeans3134 She's now what you call a "case study." Lol. The diagnosis was by accident and by the American Red Cross. They noticed something was up with her blood and appropriately took action. God bless them.
My dad had a minor stroke earlier this year and he got a type of health insurance that was for covering cancer and stroke treatments and he was supposed to receive 3,000 dollars for it but apparently the type of stroke he had wasn't part of the list of things covered despite it literally being a stroke and he was rightfully angry and planned on just canceling the whole thing, he eventually received the money anyway because I guess after checking they discovered it was indeed a stroke what he had, it was crazy
The worst part is that most insurance companies don’t even play by their own convoluted rules and frequently deny coverage that they are contractually obligated to provide. They will make every excuse imaginable to withhold money from you and make zero effort to maintain a positive business relationship with you, their cash cow. The one constant I have seen over the 10 years of having private health insurance with various providers is that you have to fight like hell, for an exorbitant amount of time, to get what you need without bleeding money, as well.
And they're rude too, you call them and put up with their convoluted bullshit for an hour or more and the person on the other end almost always is an asshole, refusing to actually help you or explain things, their job is to suck you dry, not help you, you're just disagreeable food
reminds me of the time i had a procedure that was covered fail, and bcbs tried to charge me almost $300 for that failed procedure. EVEN THO if it had gone right, it wouldve cost me almost nothing at that point bc my family had already met our deductible!!!!!!!!!!
Why on earth would they play by their own rules? If a provider defrauds, say, 1.3 million people a year, how many of those people will realize they've been robbed? How many of the people who realized will be in a position to do something about it? How many of _those_ people will actually manage to get it done? Stealing money from your cash cows is, it turns out, _incredibly profitable and very low-risk._
Legal fees are just another calculated risk, and they are experts at calculating risk. They'll break their contract exactly as much as they calculate they can. The profits they save by denying you coverage are used to pay for the very lawyers that fight against you, the mathematicians that find optimal pathways to screw you, and the politicians that write laws in their favor. Ultimately you are the one funding their efforts against you. You never had a chance. You don't have teams of mathematicians helping you calculate your risk. You don't have teams of lawyers to make sure your contract is upheld, in which you didn't contribute any of the fine print, let alone half the contract. You don't have politicians in your pocket writing laws for you. You don't have economists keeping an eye on the markets for you. There is an extreme inequality of every economically important resource, both physical and conceptual, including time, attention, money, law, information, negotiating ability, and even general decision making skills such as game theory. The insurance company counted their win against you as predicted future profits before you were born.
And if I can point out, they may deny coverage for life-threatening conditions that your well-respected oncologist has ordered. You are so right about having to fight hard. Do it early - your private health insurance will likely explain that they are not obligated to provide you any answer sooner than 10 to 14 days; that's a problem when your platelets are low and dropping by 6k a day, but hey, if you bleed out because you bite your tongue, that solves their problem of expensive medical procedures....
I'm in my late twenties, I have a college degree, I teach high school history, and my father once worked in insurance, and this is still the first time I've understood anything about health insurance.
as a disabled person who has to brawl with healthcare services on a weekly basis in AUSTRALIA i can boldly and assuredly say you are braver than any us marine
as a disabled person, this system did overwhelm me to the extent i stopped seeking care for a long time and it cost me in ways i won’t recover from. it is so validating for someone to articulate the complexities of the healthcare system that abled bodied individuals struggle with too. education is our greatest tool in humanity. to anyone reading this- NEVER give up advocating for your health and needs. you are worthy and deserving of getting help.
As a 29 year old. Learning this all when I left my parents was literally a nightmare. I asked about high deductible vs premiums with my dad. And he just said. Well you gotta decide. Neat.
I just had an AUS friend send this to me to ask if this was supposed to be satire or if this was fact. I studied medical billing and coding for a year in the US and live in the US with chronic illnesses. This is not satire. This is accurate. This is how the US system works.
In Aus we have Medicare which means most general consults are government subsidied and you have the option to buy private insurance for certain stuff if you need it. Correct me if I'm wrong though
My favorite part of insurance is that, for a service that's suppose to be there when something bad happens, you end up getting punished when something bad happens and have to end up paying more because you're now a "risk" in the eyes of the company, who will continue raising the price every time you end up needing the service. Boy oh boy do I like getting scammed!
This. Both my brother and my mother have had to go into preventable surgery that made it so they had exponentially worse short and long term health repercussions (with my mom's being life threatening emergency surgery) and too many a times have I turned to Google because it doesn't make sense to pay for a doctor's visit just for them to say 'your blood and pee is healthy go drink water or something'
And gets much worse the more of a minority you are. Trying to get chronic pain that I believe is MS, but my last doctor blamed it entirely on my trans HRT despite it starting to progress before starting that She did the same thing with my chronic migraines I finally needed meds for that I had been fighting for 10-15 years. And of course US healthcare is so underfunded that it takes months to get a new doctor
My sister had a similar problem, except she got coverage that didn't cover pre-existing conditions in the meantime, which meant she was paying premiums for useless insurance.
I would totally watch a series called "Adulting" by BDG that dives in or gives an overview of all the bs the world doesn't teach you enough about until it's too late.
I desperately need info on taxes. Like, every year, I spend months trying to figure this shit out and I have no idea. There's no help for people with learning disabilities like me, and I can't afford a tax service again this year, so I'm already shitting myself.
You pick a plan in November, and hope your health situation doesn't change during the upcoming year, because you don't get to pick again until next November. Good luck!!
I feel like its really an indictment of the system that 1. A somewhat basic explanation takes 30 minutes 2. You really do need to understand all of it to navigate getting insurance or healthcare
He just scratched the surface. All the those times where he says your plan/employer/situation may differ? Yeah, that's all real and there are a thousand exceptions to every item he covered. All of them mean you will end up paying through the nose for healthcare.
Haha 30 minutes? He didn't even explain enough to get started with finding health insurance that's worth your money. All he explained are absolute basics.
Meh, my process for picking health insurance was basically finding the lowest combined annual premium+out of pocket maximum. I understand the rest but ultimately didn't need it.
As someone who is almost off their parents insurance and is looking to go into an industry that usually doesn’t have benefits, this is immensely helpful and terrifying
@@swesleyc7 Ah yes I also chose to be born and make the world a shitty place where people will look down on one another and decide "hmm yes that person deserves the almost inevitable fate of suffering and death that is being denied healthcare, because they don't have a job I deem worthy". Absolutely a choice we, the young, made. Yes indeedy.
Brian David Gilbert is the best TH-camr because you never know if he's going to write a song about Roasted Garlic Summer Sausage or make a half-hour essay about the intricacies of American health insurance.
I'm French, and I already knew that our healthcare system is precious considering your situation, but MY GOD I didn't know this was so bad for you... Universal healthcare is really important. Dear Americans, fight to get it.
Unfortunately, 40% of us have been convinced that the government helping people IN ANY WAY WHATSOEVER is morally wrong and "against the will of God". Public Roads? Communism. Universal Healthcare? Communism. Firefighters? Communism. Giant Military Industrial Complex? That's for Jesus 😊
@@Grintock *Laughs in the stupidity of the Electoral College* Sir I assure you a lot of us don't consider it freedom and are attempting to get better but there's some barriers in our way.
I'm Canadian and the idiotic premier of my province wants to privatize our healthcare. Maybe this video can help explain some things to his followers, but I doubt it.
An IMPORTANT update on emergency medical treatment! I've had a few people point out the "No Surprises Act" which was passed this year: www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/no-surprises-understand-your-rights-against-surprise-medical-bills
Now, if you have health insurance, this act will "Ban surprise bills for most emergency services, even if you get them out-of-network and without approval beforehand (prior authorization)." This is super good news, and it means that you shouldn't be afraid of calling 911 in a medical emergency-you'll still have to pay for it (like an in-network procedure), but it won't be completely out of pocket if you go to an out-of-network hospital. The act will also "Require that health care providers and facilities give you an easy-to-understand notice explaining the applicable billing protections..." and though I'm less convinced about the "easy-to-understand" aspect, at the very least it means you SHOULD be notified about this when you receive the bill!
radiohead
NSA was great, but also worth a shout out to the Transparency in Coverage regulation. Idealistically will also mean that you should be able to get an (at least approximate) rate from your health insurance provider for a given service.
Also REMEMBER EVERYONE:
*If you have a procedure done that you are told is going to be covered and then when you get there to pay, they have an OUT-Of-NETWORK company give you Anesthesia but they never told you they weren't in-network & make you pay $2,380 for it, MAKE A COMPLAINT/APPEAL for it because not telling your patients about an additional out-of-network cost that's also being done is ILLEGAL.*
Because this is against the law, your insurance company will APPROVE your Appeal and the doctor's office who you paid will have to PAY YOU BACK THAT MONEY.
Get your money back!!! Don't overpay or let doctors get away with ILLEGAL shit like this!!
I just had it happen to me TWICE so they're having to pay ME back over $3,000.
Yo, my current job is in a department that *enforces* the rules of the No Surprises Act! 😁 This "no-choice" loophole was a thorn in my side for *years* because it was "technically" legal. Now I get to call bullsh*t on their billing practices with the federal government to back me up, and save regular people from getting billed for things completely out of their control.
To elaborate, the "easy-to-understand" requirement includes - most importantly - a price estimate of the cost of the services you will be receiving voluntarily by providers who are out of your insurance network. You must be given this paperwork at least 72 hours before the expected procedure - if you weren't given the papers, then it's on them to explain why, not you. It also protects you from hospitals contracting out their labs/radiology/anesthesia to third party companies that stay out of network because they know people have no choice. (There's one company in particular that provided *neonatal care* that stayed out of network to take advantage of this loophole. That's right, *preying on families with newborns.* I'm SO glad they're finally facing consequences.)
rewatching this today for ... reasons
Indeed
Hi, my poor, lost, and exhausted, friend. We are brothers now.
Same.
Reasons
Delay, deny, defend
Remember to keep the receipts for the pistol and silencer you bought. They could be deductible.
Unrelated, but if there's a bounty for if you turn in a guy who did something really cool to the police, don't fall for it because they will screw you over and not pay it out.
@@U.Inferno FBI takin' a page out the Big Insurance playbook
You were so right. @@U.Inferno
As an outsider, this feels like the worlds greatest legal scam.
It is.
It is. The health care industry in America is a scam on top of a scam on top of a scam.
It's the SECOND greatest legal scam. The number one spot goes to student loans. But they often work in tandem to destroy people's lives (like mine).
Yes💀
@@vulpinemachine Tell me about it. I'm going to a 200k dollar uni (my dumbass thought it was 50k because they never said that amount was per year on their website and I trusted them on that figure, stupid me) and while the president is getting a key to the city and spending 22 million on a football stadium, the music building literally has fucking asbestos in the noise cancelling panels on the walls and one of the dorm halls has a mold problem, the asbestos being a completely open secret and the mold issue being an open fact.
The goal was never to make your life better. It's to give you the illusion that your life is better or will be better down the line
Re-sharing this again. Folks in the UK asking questions after a certain incident.
Extreme health care reform advocacy is shining a light on this cursed hellscape
Seeing this as an American in my early 20s is like walking down a long, dark, narrow corridor and seeing a text prompt telling me to hold Shift to sprint.
I don't usually leave comments like this, but this is genuinely one of the funniest and most encompassing descriptions I've ever heard for being an early 20-something. Thanks for the laugh and existential dread lol.
LMFAOOO
Is this a Sister Location reference? 💀
@@vitorpinho3290 idk i havent played it lol
@@vitorpinho3290 no but sister location is one of the many games that does this
The developers really dedicated a lot of time into the worldbuilding of this dystopia. I'm beyond impressed.
I mean they wrote the code for their maximum gain. The question is why we allowed them to. Seems like a functioning democracy should have stopped such a disgusting predatory system. Yet support for public healthcare in the US is only around 50%.
I know and the game is so emersive! Hey, by the way, do you have any tips of turning it off?
A great amount of drugs and a gun gets you a secret ending tbh
Alternatively, being reckless or unlucky also nets you another secret ending as well.
@@chazdomingo475 Wanna know another funny little trick Politicians don't want you to know? Being a politician with money causes your vote to all of a sudden carry a lot more weight than if you were broke.
Can't wait for this to be the unironic insurance guide that everyone grows up with
Hey nice name
lord knows public schools aren't stepping up
This is better than my works training
@@Weckacore no u.
No jokes, it took me 2 of the past 3 years working in specialty pharmacy to get all this.
One of my core memories is my mom being locked in the office on the phone like a full time job for several days because our insurance got bought out and they stopped covering ALL of my sister’s medical costs. Eye exams, tests, PCP appointments, EVERYTHING. After a LITERAL WEEK of being transferred , gathering documents, getting corporate phone numbers, she finally found out why: my sister was receiving health insurance from her two full time jobs which excluded her from the family plan. MY SISTER WAS 8. The best part is you have to confirm the patients name and DOB to access any information.
They eventually got slammed with a fee (that was definitely way less than they made from charging people who didn’t have the knowledge or time to fight this battle) in a lawsuit. Turns out in the data transfer they purposely lost or altered data to shit like “grade schooler has 2 full time jobs” to siphon money out of people in the confusion and then use the confusion and unnavigability of a new system as a smoke screen.
I love it here.
Btw if you know you are being charged unfairly DO NOT PAY. You should have a grace period to pay so that gives you time to fight back. Otherwise they’ll go “oh yeah there was a mistake but it looks like the bills already settled so that’s great!” And now you’re out $15000 and filing for bankruptcy. :/
@@Lorraine202I just learned this. My insurance company has been increasing the amount listed as what I owe for months even though the actual HCP’s costs were settled. Double check before paying anything to these vultures.
To be fair, that’s just blatant corruption and that would occur in a public healthcare system as well.
@@orppranator5230It depends, but that's the government's problem to deal with then. You still only pay a maximum of $35 per consultation or medically necessary procedure/medication, and your involvement in it ends there.
@@orppranator5230 A public system could be designed to be non-profit.
If the government sets up a system where it's a CRIME to charge people then Any Charge At All will be su autosuspect that only the particularly uneducated would even try.
As someone that's worked in health insurance for 6+ years, I can confirm that *all* of this is correct, and it's exactly as baffling, opaque, and unfair as it sounds. Well done on creating something that gave me flashbacks to the innocent days when I was being onboarded into this nightmare of a system, but had to learn all this through "fun" modules.
you've worked in health insurance????? burn it down from the inside for me, please
@@bunshine Oh, I intend to!! That's part of the reason I've stayed in this industry. I want to work my way up to a point where I can help in the dismantling of the whole thing, with the infrastructure scrapped for parts and used to manage a single-payer system. I've worked in Medicaid AND private plans, I *KNOW* it can be done.
surely you must also know that the lobbying is also used on lowering costs via workplace safety? I get its bad, but from the outside looking in- isnt that largely just the sales dept's and healthcare provider's fault?
I made (nay, mass produced) corporate health benefits explainer videos/modules. I am sorry if you were forced to watch any of them.
@@Gliccit Nope, it's the system that incentivices behavior like that, it's made with the purpose to make the most money, not to help the most people.
Now that Brian David Gilbert makes explainers, I think we can retire now? -John
I was gonna say, I think this is just Crash Course now?
john green in my bdg video?
Happy Pizzamas everybody ❤
Update: We can't retire we need health insurance. -John
Can you pay your health care providers in pizzamas merch?
I got charged for watching this video by my health insuarance. Apparently, Brian is an out-of-network consultant and I didnt get him approved beforehand as a specialist by my PCP. Now I'm broke! Thanks Insurance!
Things have gotten to a point where this could be true
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Too funny!! Doing research on all of this and it seems the affordable health care act and the government and IRS and people running it..have been banking. They have been receiving $6400 a month or more .. definetly $300 a week for EVERYONE with a social security number! And GOD knows how long this has been going on for..and to just think only a handful of people have actually "applied" to recieve there entitled benefits. Seems super shady and a way to line the government's pockets. Investigation is continuing and hopefully EVERYONE will be informed of the TRUTH very soon.
mood
Ahhhh omg that's funny but not funny people go through that same situation every damn day because of stupid insurance rules
27:04 One New Yorker on the morning of December 4th, 2024: "I understand it now."
I love the argument of "Well it's either this or you wait for hours in the ER" when we literally all have to wait for hours in the ER
Or the classic "it's either this or increased taxes! Do you really want more taxes?" as if the increased taxes will somehow be more expensive for the individual than the thousands of dollars people are forced to spend on healthcare.
@@creeperhunterD [2 buttons meme:] [option 1: pay like 1% higher taxes and live worry-free] [option 2: pay a completely unpredictable amount for health care and have to navigate medical bureaucracy every time you have an unexpected medical situation]
It's just so hard to choose!
I had a recent hospital stay where I literally waited for 9 hours in the ER, and I have good health insurance.
And don't get me started on the "it's the cost of the best healthcare in the world" bullshit.
torries complaining about having to wait months to see a specialist while i, an american, couldn't even get a referral for my obvious chronic illness until after i developed permanent damage to my spine...and then i STILL have to wait half a year for my initial appointment with a specialist!
(not saying the british healthcare system doesn't need improving, but privatizing the industry is a massive step in the wrong direction. fight for your public healthcare tooth and nail.)
I have been diabetic for 30 years (since I was a kid) and let me tell you.. navigating the nightmare that is the American Healthcare system for my entire life has been soul crushing. It's worse than the fucking disease.
TRUE
Same my guy. It suuuucccckkkkkssss
I will never forget hearing my 20 year old brother sobbing on the phone trying to get his diabetic supplies shipped to him after days of calling and hours on hold and after nearly a month of having no method of testing his glucose levels. To this day it makes my blood boil.
Not trying to be funny but I have a question, why not just leave America? For real, it's a shit hole, have you considered moving to a place with free healthcare?
its weird to see that, im in a 3° world country and diabetic supplies are free here, i mean, the right of life dont apply to this situation?
It's honestly crazy how Brian comes up with these weird existential nightmare scenarios... Like could you imagine if that's how health insurance really worked? That would be terrifying!
🤣🤣🤣
Ha ha! Even just thinking about the existential crisis I would have over this totally nonexistent system is killing me! And I wouldn't be able to afford the medicine that would save me! 😂
Soooooo damn glad I'm German right now.
You go to whichever doctor you like, let them do whatever they want, and never even see the bill for the treatment.
Also REMEMBER EVERYONE:
*If you have a procedure done that you are told is going to be covered and then when you get there to pay, they have an OUT-Of-NETWORK company give you Anesthesia but they never told you they weren't in-network & make you pay $2,380 for it, MAKE A COMPLAINT/APPEAL for it because not telling your patients about an additional out-of-network cost that's also being done is ILLEGAL.*
Because this is against the law, your insurance company will APPROVE your Appeal and the doctor's office who you paid will have to PAY YOU BACK THAT MONEY.
Get your money back!!! Don't overpay or let doctors get away with ILLEGAL shit like this!!
I just had it happen to me TWICE so they're having to pay ME back over $3,000.
@@emilytada455 Same in Canada! And I’m thankful for it.
This video helped me land a job interview for a healthcare company CEO, thank you!
My condolences
Ah yes. How reasonable to expect a person with a concussion or with terrible wounds to stop their ambulance, doctor, and specialist before treatment and say, "Now, wait just a minute. Are you in my network? If not, would you kindly let my chances of living dwindle and get one who is? Thank you."
Actually this happened to my family. My sister had an injury and we called an ambulance just to waive their help and drive her ourselves to the hospital. We were still billed an insane amount, but it was better than the $2000 for the ride
This is America 🇺🇸
ok
I have yet to meet an insurance where an ambulance is covered. I have decided they are fancy scams on wheels and unless I hit gold or am literally dying I won’t/ can’t use one without going into debilitating debt lmao
@@musemccormack5436 the most depressing part about that is im canadian and when i was young i just went to an adult hospital and they let me take an ambulance for fun, and last year i had an ambulance called for me bc i had a panic attack at the dentist, so i know from being in one they are incredibly *incredibly* useful when in need of one, god americs makes me sad
As a Canadian that moved to the US for work, it was maddening trying to understand why people don't riot because of this. There is literally a whole private insurance industry and departments in hospitals dedicated to just dealing with billing. It wastes so much money.
That's the point. It wastes your money, but someone is getting rich off it.
I always thought it was hilarious that conservatives try to claim private healthcare is cheaper and more efficient. I'm no fan of wading through the swamp of government bureaucracy, but I'd take it any day over corporate bureaucracy that charges me a cover fee just to get into the bog.
'cause it's just normal for them, a lot of people think without it healthcare is worse in other countries, when it really really isn't, or that it has insane waiting times, when it doesn't, (and that one's always been insane 'cause their waiting times... Aren't good?) it's hard to see a different world without ever experiencing it.
Especially with all the money that goes into preserving the fuckitude that the system is.
It makes me so glad to be British. 'Cause we do know what it's like, and there would absolutely be riots across the country if our system became like theirs.
And it's larger than the department dedicated to just dealing with patients. Inside of a hospital, you ONLY see the tip of the iceberg, but every level between insurance and providers have to fund their own department dedicated to fighting the other parties on coverage and billing decisions. At a hospital, your doctor is conscripted into this effort with excessive charting requirements and justification checks and outside reviews that may cost them more time than actual patient care.
@@MagicCardboardBox our system absolutely will become like theirs within the next decade, so I hope you’re ready to crack some skulls when it does
I'm so upset this came out AFTER I had to learn all this myself LMAO
just come to canada bro
YOOOOO ITS CIRCLE
I’m one of the first ppl to respond to this
Same lol
Don’t worry, all the rules will change the moment any of us actually understand them. Isn’t this the best system ever?
Who's here after the United Health Care CEO was un-CEOed?
Can I just say
1) this feels like a real return to form for fans of Unraveled
2) this really demonstrates that some creators are such that their audience will listen to them talk about literally ANYTHING and trust it to be entertaining
I feel like I somewhat agree with number one
As for number two Brian could read the dictionary and make it interesting
I almost didn't watch it because based on the title I thought it would be boring, but I decided to trust BDG.
honestly as an european in a non english speaking country this is absolutely useless... but bdg makes it entertaining
I'm a chronically ill American, so this is really just as relevant to my interests as Unraveled, unfortunately.
@@cygnahoshiko4629 Yeah, I'm going to grad school next year and I'm chronically ill too so I also really needed to know it. New insurance + new place + being independent to deal with my own insurance stuff. I just realized how complicated this is all going to be next year while I was watching the video.
Funnily enough, this is the most horrific video BDG has ever made.
One of those reasons that keep me faaar away from the USA. I don't even have to deal with this and it still stresses me the hell out
Yeah. It's crazy to think that people have actually died because of this
So rich people can make more money. Real people are actually dead
@i better call stop spamming
@@danielblank9917 bro it's a bot
@@chaosandbunnies8291 Imagine people not reporting it for spam.
..or worse, imagine a couple hundred people reporting it and TH-cam not doing anything about it for months.
I think BDG may have found his true calling: making adulting PSAs. I can't even imagine how helpful this would have been if my high school had shown me this video 15 years ago. Please make this a series.
I'd love to see him collab with Hank and John Green (vlogbrothers duo) to remake their How To Adult series
@@purplegill10 YEAHHHHHHHHHHH
get that complexly funding bdg!!!!!!!!!!!!
Honestly I would really like more videos of him explaining stuff like this
Like maybe he could help explain taxes next, that'd be really nice
Adulting step one: if you say adulting you are neurodivergent and your needs are fundamentally different from every other person the system is created to accommodate and you never will be accommodated by said system. you must find solice and support within compasionate friends because you never will find solice or support through any system where money changes hands. The best you will ever do is learn to scrape by to be able to find more moments where you can be with people you trust.
>blue cross blue shield mentioned
Oh yeah I remember those guys hitting the news recently. They wanted to implement policy changes to limit the amount of anesthesia administered per surgery based on arbitrary "guidelines" defined by insurance company executives who saw some data but never spent a second in an ER.
A decision which got rolled back the instant the CEO for UMC hit concrete.
I mean list is pretty long I think you guys need to sit down and talk about this with your guns.
As a psychiatrist the part when you removed "Mental" from the definition made me laugh while crying tears of rage on the inside
APAB
So who pays for mental healthcare?
Do you have to get special insurance?
@@Jehty_ the short answer is no every insurance is supposed to cover it. In practice many insurers have major caveats in their coverage regarding mental health fueled by the intrinsically subjective nature of such reports. For example I can take your blood pressure and objectively report to insurance that it's too high so you need corrective meds. But if you have depression there's no lab test, I am fully reliant on your reported symptoms to make a diagnosis and prescribe treatment. And if BDGs video was any indication it gets even more complicated when you start talking covered meds or therapy.
@@Jehty_ in most cases folks just don't seek it.
@@ohnoagremlin And are then surprised by the disproportionately large amount of mental health issues in our nation. Yup, the system's clearly working as intended, folks!
A clear memory of mine: Watching my dad argue with the insurance company on the phone, from his hospital bed, battling with cancer
Jesús Christ how do you Americans put up with that, I'm so sorry
@@Capitanosimp2174 Because Conservative chumps say, "Socialism bad".
@@Capitanosimp2174 some of us don't! we go bankrupt or die!!!
Genuinely heartbreaking, I would be so enraged I could be on that phone for 2 days
@@Capitanosimp2174 i want to agree but that Jesús might indicate a French keyboard and I can’t risk it
The craziest part of the US Healthcare is that this video is actually good enough to be shown in school...
But then how will the government invest millions of dollar into the problem, steal most of the money, spend some money on something real to show as progress and get nothing done so they can justify another investiment to do it again?
Beautiful
it would be great to see this in school
I wish I had seen it in school. Twice.
The craziest part is actually that they categorically won't show you this in school because US curriculum don't include a single piece of information about a system that is going to dictate, more than anything else in your entire life, your health and your financial status until the day you die (possibly as a direct result of this very system). Fun! Is it not? How our educational institutions do nothing to educate us about the most consequential and universal realities of our upcoming adulthoods! Great all around.
Me: *Sorts by new.*
LMAO same
YT algorithm has been serving me multiple health insurance-related videos lately. I’ve enjoyed hitting “Sort by new” on all of them.
So, I have a friend with a chronic disease that was working in the States for a couple of months, and when he needed prescription drugs, he found it more convenient to fly back to Europe, go to the doctor, get the drugs and return. Not just in terms of money, because it was also cheaper to do so, but that way he didn't have to wrestle between several companies so he could get his damn drugs.
Literally what I do too, and I've lived in the US for four years now and have insurance. Even though I don't have my German insurance anymore and have to pay out of pocket, it's much cheaper to fly home and go see my old providers there every year or two. Especially women's health services in the US are sub-par compared to the rest of the world (it's basically just a manual exam and pap-smear in the US, where in other countries they're also checking everything via ultrasound, which makes much more sense). It's ridiculous.
It can be cheaper to fly to Mexico, have a vacation, get dental surgery, then go back by the time you can even get scheduled for one in the US
Even with dental insurance
@@genderender Yeah but in the US it's done by doctors with dental tools, pretty sure in Mexico it's done by mechanics with auto tools who have some free time
Wow, Europe sounds like a wonderful place with free and fast drugs, how can I join in? 😃
@@testname4464 doesn’t seem like a racist statement at all
This is genuinely the most terrifying thing Brian has ever posted, nothing is scarier than the American healthcare system.
Send help
Except, quite possibly, the American Tax System, which is just as confusing, and carries criminal charges if you don't do it correctly
'The IRS' has entered the chat
North American gun laws and gun culture are also quite scary.
At least they can't calculate your HP yet
I'm a 32 year old professional and this is the most time anyone has ever dedicated to explaining health insurance to me.
Yo, same. I learned the hard way that even if you have a life change that qualities you to get health insurance at a different time, you still might not be able to get it. In Massachusetts if you don’t have health insurance for three months, you get dinged on your taxes and I ALMOST hit that, luckily my employer helped me out and I got my plan sooner than later. I fucking hate this system.
@here is the full clip stop spamming
Are you professional at beign 32 😂?
@clairedark I was so good at it they promoted me to 33. :p
@@PROTAsoloproject 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
The idea that some people look at this and think “the system is working” makes me question their grip on reality.
Well... It is working. You just have to redefine "whom" it's working for. And that's definitely not anyone who is sick. Rich people get sick, they either are so rich they don't care or they blow through a ton of cash because they have sooooo much money that it really doesn't matter. If you don't believe me, google Sumner Redstone's net worth in 2014 and his net worth in 2020.
They don't care because they have the money to cover medical bills or they have someone else do this stuff for them. My uncle is one of those people.
Propaganda is an extremely powerful force
Actually, the system IS working
We need to destroy it
Well when you see things like Canada’s MAID system…
I still can't wrap my head around the fact that a health insurance can just say: "No we won't pay for THIS doctor. Yes, we agree that you broke your leg and needed a cast and pain medication, but it was done by the wrong guy. If Peter had done it we would pay, but we won't pay for Mark!"
Don't forget how the broken leg could be a cosmetic issue and therefore not covered
@@MintyMoron64 No no, This broken leg is a pre-existing condition
if you didn't want to have to pay for your broken leg you should have thought about that before you decided to have legs
@@danhonks6264 but make sure mark doesn't amputate them we won't pay for that
@@MintyMoron64 you bruised your knee badly once before, so a harmed leg is a pre-existing condition
Me: I don't understand
America: That's the point, silly! Sign here.
honestly, BDG pivoting into edutainment was not something I expected, but I'm all for it.
I dunno it definitely has an “unraveled” vibe which I have sorely missed, I just wish the topic wasn’t so rl horrifying.
@@MrPiptron *laughs in Britishness*.
did you forget the second part of the complete pokerap? for shame
@@MrPiptron Unravel is definitely edutainment.
Pivoting? Unraveled was very edutainment
What a time to be recommended this again
As a recent US immigrant, After getting health insurance that my job pays for, I decided to have my issues looked up. I started with tinnitus which was keeping me up at night. I made sure to go to a clinic that was "in-network". They tested my hearing and there were no issues and I didn't have to pay for any of it. So far so good. But then they suggested that the issue might be brain related and could be serious. So they directed me to another clinic in the same building to get a brain scan where I got scheduled. Little did I realize that the second clinic wasn't in network, so imagine my shock when I received a 1,500$ bill on my way out. Good news is, they didn't find anything wrong with my brain...
This experience destroyed my willingness to get my issues checked out and my trust in the medical industry in general. Although I have many concerning issues with my body, I'd much rather take the risk of death than ruining my family's financial stability. And I have a sneaking suspicion that this is exactly what this system is engineered to do.
Lying until proven sickly
Yep.
If I were to say what I think should happen to the CEO's of the health insurance industry, I would be physiclly removed from this website.
Of course it is on purpose, they make seeking help so troublesome so people do it as little as possible so they can get that premium every month without offering a service.
I find it more mind-blowing that people, like yourself, prefer the chance of death over an insane hospital bill....I had friends just let me lay on their floor after a seizure during a hangout night (had too much beer as a diabetic) only because they thought my health insurance wouldn't cover the ER room. But they were sure to say how scared they were for my life....If I'm dead, I will have no bills anyway. JESUS CHRIST THIS COUNTRY IS INSANE!
@AssBlasster that's the thing, they fucking don't.
That's not what OP is saying, that's not what people in the US are saying. Most people want single payer. But the health industry lobbyists don't.
Me, an Australian: "Oh Medicare I know that one!"
Me, an Australian, post-Medicare summary: "Nevermind I have no idea what that is"
My reaction also.
Maybe its different? Idk, all I know is that I have one
Had this same reaction but I'm American
As an American, most Americans have no idea how any of this works.
US Medicare is awful.
Medicaid is usually all free, but usually medicare patients are disabled and/or retired and they often need it more;
*Medicare usually only covers around 80% of medical expenses. Which can be a ton if you have to see any sort of specialist regularly - (pain specialist, immunology doc, etc)
And unfortunately Obamacare made it worse for a while with misleading promises, along with private insurances getting butthurt, and raising premiums and making it harder to reach a deductable(?) with medications (part D).
Benefits I take for granted as a medicaid patient (free doctors visits/no copays/access to more resources like bus passes, free counseling, etc) cost too much for my permanently disabled mom to really do. She’s 60. Im 23 and chronically ill/can’t work right now. Im sad I can’t pay for her to be seen.
tip from a health insurance agent who hates his job: if your drug list includes tier 3 and up drugs, you can submit a tier reduction request. basically, if your doctor says you can't take the generic/plan-preferred drug a lot of the time the plan has to "price match" your tier 3 drug to a lower tier. it's not always a guarantee but we have a pretty good success rate with getting these requests approved. most people aren't aware that this is a possibility but it could save you a bit of money.
also this video is amazing and made me cackle 😂
+++
Hero
@@sabinajoh In all fairness, in an ideal world, their job wouldn't exist.
thank you friend, i hope you can help as many ppl as possible
I understood nothing of this.
Once again the TH-cam algorithm never fails to be the height of comedy due to recent event
It's awfully convenient how health care doesn't cover psychological damage given that the structure of this system causes me the most psychological anguish
Insurance also fairly regularly reaches the top of the most depressing jobs in the US
I love how TH-camrs in our generation will just organically, randomly, make the critical educational content we need the most effective or memorable way possible.
could you link/name some? this is the only example I've seen of what you're describing
@@toulouse1 I assume it counts enough, I watch some tiktok comps about stuff like leftism and disability info and stuff like that, mainly the ones by “a dude” (that’s their actual channel name /gen) which have some pretty good info in a pretty digestible format!
Oh sure I'll think about the others I've seen sometime. Just remember watching channels I'd know for one thing and then something would come up in their life and they'd make a video to help anyone else (like their subscribers for one) with that potential life scenario. But yeah someone should make a playlist out of them, since they're more watchable and thus easy-to-remember than more bland how-tos.
well exactly. They're filling a vital niche that no one else is. Anyway, Brian's cool.
@@toulouse1 not quite 'critical', but "history of the entire world, i guess" by bill wurtz is a good example of spontaneous really helpful educational videos from someone who normally doesn't make them.
As an Australian, this comes off as a psychological horror video.
Please don't take my Medicare away from me.
you CANT let them take it away
Yoink 🏥
Don't let them take it away from you, you can't understand how bad it is until you've lived through it, you can't let it happen, any politician even flirting with expanding private healthcare to the detriment of public healthcare should be understood for what they are, a life ending human-sized parasite determined to suck the blood out of you and every one of your loved ones until they're nothing more than dust. You are privileged if they are crushed under heel like such voracious parasites should be, however, barring that, do your damndest to keep them away from any kind of civil service. They will destroy anything good.
They have tried to several times, and they tried to do the same with tertiary education. Very scary times. So glad we still have higher taxes and better benefits 👍
@@The_Cyber_System ill bet 10-1 odds your "higher taxes" are less than what most Americans pay for private insurance.
Thats crazy, they should do something about that.
Nah, that'd never happen
I'm so glad Brian is still doing psychological horror content, this is great.
Is it just me, or are his horror videos getting more realistic?
all his horror videos before were pretty scary but this takes the cake
666 likes, oddly fitting
Edit: nevermind I guess they stopped doing that.
Unironically this is his scariest video
This video is excellent socialist propoganda
i’m on the edge of my seat for this video to devolve into horror
the true horror is the system itself
@@briandavidgilbert As well as the fact that there are people who think this is a good thing
@@samlevy9897 YES
HH : healthcare horror
@@briandavidgilbert the real horror was the friends we made along the way
I cant believe that Brian just tricked me, a 21 year old who is nervously gripping onto their parents health insurance, into learning about how to navigate getting my own healthcare. You’re doing to lords work Brian.
I love your picture
I am being sincere here when I say this: Start leaning now. Seriously. This shit is intentionally overly complicated, and it changes a little in ways that are hard for us plebs to understand year after year. New laws are coming out all the time that allow insurance companies to get away with literal murder. Fun fact, did you know that failure to provide aid as a professional in the event of an emergency is actually classified as a form of murder through negligence in some states? Well, insurance companies sure do, so they made damn sure those laws have loop holes in them that excuse them from ever having to pay for potentially life saving procedures that hospitals will refuse to even attempt unless you can guarantee payment in advance! YAY!
Well….can’t you have it for 6 more years?
@just i c e stop spamming
@@EricLS 3 to 4, depending on when her birthday is. It drops when you turn 25.
Oh my god, im so glad youtube has a sense of humor
30 minutes of Brian explaining manmade capitalistic horrors beyond our comprehension
ok
The one time "beyond our comprehension" is not a meme. Jesus fucking christ
@@duongchuc1834 👀 ok
Surprisingly informative
So what you're saying is Unraveled is back?
As a French person, I...I have no words for this-
Our healthcare is already pretty battered, it lacks funding, and there aren't enough doctors in any field anywhere, especially in the countryside, as well as specialists dying out-
But this ? This makes our country look like heaven. What the hell ?!
Its funny that there are americans that defend this terrible system. Literally every other country is better in this.
I can say the same. And I live in Brazil. That's how absurd the healthcare in the US is. VIVA O SUS, CARALHO.
Is it bc you guys didn't finish the job and left Monaco standing after the Revolution?
@@DavideMenezes42 I'm literally in shock rn, i could never imagine that something like going to a doctor could be so complicated in the US. VIVA O SUS PORRA!
First of all, Americans who understand healthcare do indeed look at the French system and think yours is pretty great.
As to how we got here, it’s a historical accident. During World War II, wage controls were put in place to prevent the US economy from spinning out of control. Businesses were not allowed to increase salary by too much.
But if a business can’t raise wages, how can they attract workers? Well, they can offer something else besides money as payment. So they started offering health insurance. And then a little while later, the government started giving tax breaks to companies that offer health insurance.
So now the system is entrenched. Every time someone tries to reform it, businesses rebel. Also, the health insurance companies are not set up to provide good care. They are set up to make money. A lot of the reforms of Obamacare were regulations on premiums, coinsurance, copays, out of pocket maximums, and a bunch of other things. It still wasn’t a fundamental change to the system, but it did make a difference in a lot of places.
I'm french and the video was so funny it made me forget this was actually a real thing and not some strange dystopian fiction. Then I read the comments and now I'm tearing up in a bus. This is awful, I sincerely hope this whole system gets burned to the ground and no one ever has to go through that again.
How is access to healthcare not a human right??
Basically, it’s an accident of history. During the Second World War, the US froze prices and wages to prevent inflation, but companies still needed incentives to lure workers during an extreme wartime labor shortage. So they started offering health insurance in lieu of higher pay, and since the US wasn’t bombed to shit during the war and exited into an economic boom, it remained in place. Nobody likes it, but most people are afraid that a total overhaul will mess up the service they’ve already worked so hard to set up for themselves. Even many labor unions are skeptical of nationalized healthcare because they fear not being able to negotiate with employers for their own insurance will deprive them of leverage.
@@SamAronow thank you for the lesson in US history, it's really interesting and I had never heard of this before
@@noalequinoa I would add two things to Sam's explanation:
First, our health insurance premiums come with the benefit of lower taxes, meaning that the money we spend on our healthcare system is, at least in theory, "extra" money that we have because our taxes are lower than yours. There's quite a bit of truth to this; in France, the average person pays 27.8% income tax, if I understand the results of my Google search correctly, along with a 20% VAT, meaning you pay an average combined tax rate of 47.8%, while--depending on your state--in my home state of Oregon, you'd probably be paying more like 20% _combined_ state and federal taxes. On the other hand, our marginal tax rates aren't that much lower than some countries that have national healthcare systems, since we also spend more money per person on our military and defense industry. (Some have even complained that foreign countries e.g. in Europe are being freed up to spend more of their taxes on social programs such as healthcare *because* the USA spends so much on defense.)
Second, our private system comes with quite a bit more decision-making power for people who are looking for care (maybe not emergency care, but most healthcare). We have a lot of latitude to seek second opinions, perhaps look for a doctor with a similar healthcare philosophy to our own (e.g. on the cost-benefit analysis of ordering tests or prescribing medications). We have a lot more latitude to decide whether spending that extra $10,000 to potentially save our life is worth it, whereas a country with government healthcare will make that "worth-it decision" for you.
*British
@@philipmcniel4908 VAT stands for Value Added Tax, and it has nothing to do with income. It is just a tax added to goods and services that the end-consumer has to pay for (included in the listed price of an iPhone, which is partly why iPhones are more expensive in Europe, for example). So the average person pays 27.8% income tax (according to your research) plus some other collective deductions like health insurance and unemployment insurance (less than 10%). I've lived in both Finland and the U.S for my whole life in and out, and the system is 100% more favorable in Finland for the middle class and the poor. If you're making $100k and more, which is of course more likely in the U.S, only then the lower taxes favor you. Also, you can get private insurance in Europe as well that gives you that decision-making power for far cheaper premiums. Anyway, it's true that the U.S is as individualistic as it gets and a land full of opportunities, so with smart work and some luck you might just be able to get the best of both worlds.
oh look, this is suddenly getting recommended to me in December 2024. wonder why?
🫸 open enrollment
👉 open season
What kills me (literally) is when the insurance companies refused coverage for anything they could label a "pre-existing condition". An infamous case was a young rape victim being denied coverage for her treatment, because she had been raped a few years previously so her being a rape victim was a pre-existing condition.
You what now?
I swear, the U.S. healthcare system should be investigated by the U.N. or something for crimes against humanity.
@@qzamboni unfortunately that will never happen because the US is one of the primary financial backers of the UN
Obamacare got rid of pre-existing condition restrictions.
I...
How in the fuck? Do rape survivors not deal with enough shit already!? Thats baffling, like inexplicably absurd
As a French person, i started mechanically sharpening my guillotine while watching this
ship them over please
You would not believe the private and public armies that will be dispatched if they come under any serious pressure from the proletariat. A civil war would be hideous, unfortunately we have to use the government. Luckily we can still vote- for now.
@@jjoohhhnn people have the power. but you're right, it will get messy, it always does and somehow it seems worse nowadays.
The guillotine really isn't the best revolutionary symbol given its bedbugs used more as a tool for colonial violence than it's been used as against kings and the bourgeois.
Maybe instead, ship over tips on how to make better barricades, you have a proud history of making those in the face of state violence.
Working in healthcare, I'd like to add:
Insurance companies will do everything they can to NOT pay a claim. They don't make money at the rates they do without denying claims at every chance they can.
Very much true. My partner has quite a few health issues and whenever her doctor recommends a new medicine, she has to go through a negotiation process of her insurance saying well we don't think you need THAT medicine, how about THIS medicine tho? After that medicine fails to work and the doctor reports that to the insurance, they MIGHT agree to cover the recommended medication. I say might because many times they have you go through several different options first, despite the doctor believing their recommendation is best.
My daughter has chronic migraines and her specialist recommended Botox treatments in parts of her head and neck, which have pretty good success rates and next to no side effects compared to migraine meds which leave her super tired and dizzy and nauseous. Insurance made her go through a month of 3 different medicines before they finally agreed to cover the Botox, which has helped her greatly. It's an extremely frustrating, wasteful system. Perhaps it's because we use government insurance and not private so we generally don't have copays, thank god, but this system just doesn't work well for seemingly anyone.
Sorry for the wall of text, I kinda just poured my frustrated brain out here because it's a constant source of stress living with 2 chronically unwell people that I know deserve better
Had a similar situation in my family. Doctor prescribed a certain medication, but insurance was only willing to pay some tiny percentage of the cost, but would cover 100% of the cost of some other medication that sort of is supposed to do some of the same things, but not exactly. So, had to take the worse medication for a period to prove that it wouldn't work completely before they would cover the prescribed medication.
@@iamjustkiwi That our healthcare system allows (and incentivizes) your treatment to be determined by insurance companies against the doctor's actual suggestions is one of the clearest examples of how fucking broken this shit is.
Exactly why I'm leaving this buzzsaw of an industry. It does nothing but create pressure at all levels, personally and professionally, internally and externally.
@@nikolicious589 good for you, we all deserve better and it can't feel good being a part of this system.
And when you call the customer service line to check if something is covered, they rattle off a line about “nothing I say is a guarantee of coverage.” I asked a rep once how I could get a definite Yes or No before scheduling an appt and risk owing 100% of the bill. They said, “you can’t.”
I had the same issue with the dentist. I would call the receptionist and ask "Is X covered?"
You couldn't get a straight answer from her! She would give you a bunch of mumbo jumbo! Something about how you have to book an appointment first and be seen by the dentist first.
I told her "Ma'am, this is a yes-or-no question."
She got SOOOO angry and frustrated with me! She exploded at me!
My favorite part about the deep dives on American healthcare is seeing the horrified reactions of people who aren't from the United States. This is an in depth beginners crash course on health insurance. None of the information presented here is satire, right down to the plans that are referred to as "Part A," "Part B," etc. It's exhausting.
Yeah I'm not from the US and I have to say that this is fucking terrifying
I could never move to there for this reason
I live in a third world country and I get literally EVERYTHING for free. "Oh but queue's must be super long!" I go see a doctor same day if I need to, and I if I have to I can get a doctor home visit (also free).
@@ThoughtsOnThoughts thank you, I swear I have people in my family who are obvious victims of the predatory privatized healthcare and they still go “well at least I only have to wait 3-6 months to even a year to see a doctor instead of however long the queues must be over in places with privatized healthcare!”
Yeah I just show up to the hospital and say "treat me" Done. U wait a little while and u pay nothing or a symbolic value like 5€
@@ThoughtsOnThoughts free? nothing is free my friend. Somebody always has to pay, people have to make the medications, work the hospitals, track the records, etc... payment comes through money or time. The real reason American health insurance is so bad, *aside from the shoddy bureaucracy* is because there is *basically* no upper limit to what the government will pay for different things. So in practice big pharma and hospitals can cooperate to charge exorbitant rates to insured people. Really, Americas insurance problem is deeply rooted in a very large number of other issues, like government money laundering and insider trading, gross government inefficient/malicious spending, outdated laws and systems... When people say they want insurance in the private sector, they don't normally mean completely independent from law, they just want it in businesses with a monetary incentive to do things right, and a minimal degree of government intervention necessary only for keeping the companies from cooperating to jack prices up and to keep insurance payments at a low price for consumers that is affordable but still profitable. Another reason people want private insurance is so that people that have enough money to not need insurance do not have to pay for other peoples insurance, either through taxes or payments. Long story short, governments don't normally have their peoples best interests in mind.*yes I am aware that businesses don't either, but they at least have an incentive existing in the bottom line they must meet*
You know you're chronically ill when the first five seconds of this video make complete sense to you, both in what the acronyms mean and in why BDG chose them.
Damn some people really are born gamers. Gesundheit
the struggle is real 👨🦽
chronic illness was a very cruel teacher in that I knew everything in this video and mode
yup
Haha, yup! The only reason I wasn't immediately screwed by the system when my illness showed up is because I had my mom who also dealt with chronic illness as a guide.
For all those wondering if this is actually a 30 minute video on heath insurance or if it devolves into horror, just know: this video made me cry
So it’s a 30 minute video on health insurance. Thanks for sharing
o-oh...
So it sticks with talking about health insurance the whole time - good to know!
Its a 30 minute video on health insurance which means its necessarily also about horror
Why can't it be both?
Someone should really come up with a simple solution for this!
As an American college student, this video is genuinely very helpful. They never teach you any of this stuff but it can be life ruining if you don't know about it.
Its by design. Creating an unnecessarily complicated system then justifies the existence of "experts" (Tax Experts, Insurance Experts, Ect) who can then make money off of people usually not having the time to learn these complicated systems. Its also why none of these systems are ever taught, and if anything is done to try and simplify it, lobbyist groups who represent those "experts" step in to keep the money making scheme going.
@@ThatOneREDScout Information asymmetry is one of the most common ways to capture profits.
OP, the main thing you need to understand is that you live in a society that is trying to trick and trap you at every step. Never trust anyone.
@@chazdomingo475 capitalism moment
@@Artameful sadly. Business moment for sure but especially a capitalism moment
oh don't worry, it's life ruining even if you do know about it.
About two thirds of the way in I felt a panic attack brewing because I was getting scared that I wasn't understanding this enough so I had to start repeating "I'm not American, I'm not American" to calm down. Not sure if that speaks more to how terrifying this system is or to how good you are at immersing me into a topic
Hahahaah well at least you dont actually live in this nightmare. I only have a year left being under my parents and im scared 😢 make sure this doesnt happen where you live!
@@princessalia6 Oh I've been trying. I live in Alberta, Canada and our last Premier (Basically a Governer, he was American too) tried his damnedest to privitize healthcare, and sadly enough a lot of people were on his side, but he never really got anywhere with it and ultimately if he did I wouldn't have been surprised if the Federal Govt stepped in and said "No", but for a hot minute I was pretty terrified
@@PerishingPurplePulsar Holy sheit that was way too close! Have they not learned anything from us!?
@@princessalia6 Not a thing apperently. I'm planning on moving at some point to Ontario or maybe Nova Scotia. The more time goes on the more Alberta is turning into a Little US inside of Canadian borders at best, or a fascist splinter state at worst and I don't wanna be here when the axe comes down either way
I can't speak to not living in this nightmare, but I can say that having lived in it all my life and now currently being unable to fix significant and life-altering problems with my teeth for several years to the point where I haven't been able to chew food and I don't know that fixing my teeth will even fix the problem now because I have no idea if I'll be able to chew like normal or if my jaw has atrophied...it's not great.
As a french fellow, I first laugh. Then I remember my government craves to privatize our health system and the video became suddenly a LOT LESS funnier.
Do not let them do that, I pray to you use your natural inborn abilities as a Frenchman to riot and strike to prevent that.
if they do, prepare the guilotines
its because your goverment is paying billonaires out of the ass for products, it just appears free to you. trust me corporations are still raping the supposed "free" healthcare countries. your healthcare is owned by american and foreign corporations through your govermemt
Yes, guilotines, bro.
@@ChipCheerioOh yeah, you frenchies are my heroes for that.
I once watched EMTs debate which hospital they should take a patient to because they couldn’t remember which hospital was in what network, while the man held his own head wound closed. That’s when I realized I might want to leave the country…
…and then I did. Never have to deal with this crap in Canada 🇨🇦
Canada will try to push this system on its own citizens eventually... capitalism always leads to late stage capitalism
As someone who took an EMT course in America and is training to be an EMT; when I asked one of my instructors about why certain things were they way they were, the instructor literally told me: "Oh because of the power of Insurance companies, they set that up."
Like, what the fuck?! How can someone who has not one minute of medical training possibly be determining what is covered or what a "pre-existing condition" is???
This whole system is a fucking farce. We need Universal Healthcare in the USA
@@robert-rv8loInteresting that you and OP didn’t/won’t move to a commie country
@@robert-rv8lo The differences between late stage capitalism and fascism get so blurry that sometimes it is hard to tell when your democracy did die or if it even existed in the first place.
This is fantastic. It's entertaining, informative, and calls out the bullshit. If I could make everyone in this country watch this, I would
M&JTV has good taste
you said it, mikey. i for one am going to toss this link around like it’s on fire.
Hail yeah!
The comment crossover I never expected but I am glad is here
I'd totally watch if you made a video about health insurance or administration with Mirror B's theme in the background the whole time
As someone recently diagnosed with a chronic illness and about to no longer be covered by my parents' insurance, this is perfect timing
Check if your state provides subsidized insurance for people with disabilities. That information should be available on your state's department of health/public health website. I ended up paying like $60 a month for Medicare cause I'm constantly dying.
@@0000-r2b definitely will, thanks so much
My sympathies. Also worth checking, if you’re still living with your family and are likely to for the foreseeable future, if you might be able to stay on theirs as a disabled dependent. (Which has its obvious downsides, but as someone who’s remained on parental health insurance after 26 because I can’t really work, I bring it up.)
As an ER doctor, that's true, we're often private contractors. Which also means I don't get health insurance through work. Which blows and also screws patients over because the middleman who staffs the ED is often out of network. Oh, and did you know that insurance companies can completely change what drugs are covered by their formulary anytime of the year? and that doesn't count as a qualifying life event? Wait is our medical system... Irretrievably... Broken?
Wtf doctors dont get health insurance....what a weird concept. it should be universal healthcare for doctors/nurses/other medical profs doing the work for our health care system!
Bruh wtf do the doctors do when they don't have insurance?
@@Superboologan1 I'd assume that doctors have a good enough salary to be able to afford private healthcare and costs of out-of-network care, but at worst, the same thing that everyone else does when they don't have medical help. They die.
> is a doctor
> can't get health insurance from job
> doctor can't afford to go to the doctor
Conclusion: We are living in hell
the american health care system was made to make money and not spend it.., thats what america is about.. making money as much as possible and making sure to not lose any... at any cost..
1:40 yes, they wanted to privatize health care here in Brazil. We have free and private healthcare available but they wanted to privatize all of it. We didn't let them do that.
Glad to see BDG is sticking to his roots and still making horror videos
This is even scarier cus everyone in the US has to deal with this.
the worst kind of horror is the things that CAN hurt you
This should play on repeat in every waiting room in every doctors office that accepts insurance.
Play this _in_ the insurance offices when you want to make a claim. Remember that scene in The Incredibles when Bob tells a client how to get her claim approved? That should be mandatory. People deserve to know how to benefit from their insurance.
AGREED!! ***ESPECIALLY*** before and during open enrollment.
Thanks for the helpful guide! I've decided that the best course of action is to remain in a sterilized room wrapped in twenty layers of bubble wrap for the rest of my days.
Yep, better to not take any risks and stay inside our rented 10m² apartment that we can barely afford because real estate is also complete bullshit
You know, in my experience, it is even WORSE than this. Especially if you live in a black or Hispanic or Asian neighborhood.
I lived near a physical therapy clinic. The therapist there would ruin it for you, even if you had insurance.
He would fuck it up for you by failing to ask the insurance company for permission to treat his patients. Which meant no visits for them.
He would also touch their breasts while they were on the table and sexually harass them. Which meant you didn't even WANT a visit with him anyway! Ironically.
For some reason, when I reported him to the insurance company for both transgressions, they took his side.
Someone should really do something about this
Reminder, people of Europe. THIS is what “privatized healthcare” means.
We have this in the Netherlands too, so europe, sadly, knows
@@jakobvanklinken Yeah ... no. Sure we have copays but don't pretend like we get insane pricings and holes in our coverage like in the US. Sure if you go to a specialist which isn't in basic insurance such as physical therapy you'll have to pay it yourself. But that's only if you don't have a certain chronic issue which requires you to go. And if you are in an emergency situation 'network' doesn't mean anything. And if it is 'out of network' you usually only pay about 10-30% of the full price.
In a country as small as the Netherlands and like I said earlier ignoring emergency situations which don't apply there is basically no reason to go out of network in the Netherlands. Where American companies have those systems in place mostly for monetary gain, Dutch insurance companies have it in place to stop people from hopping from doctor to doctor, clogging up systems with inefficiency.
The Netherlands has far from a perfect system. But it's harmful to the existing system and the people fighting for universal healthcare to state that the system in place in the Netherlands is anywhere near the system of the US.
And South America
Ok
If by private you mean heavily regulated at state and federal levels
Pro tip: if you have to take a super expensive medication that has a high copay, the drug manufacturer will often have a program to cover the copay for you. This is because they'd rather eat the copay amount if it means they can still bill your insurance for the rest.
THIS. My specialty medication would have bankrupted me years ago if my doctor hadn't offhandedly mentioned that the manufacturer had a reimbursement system. It's saved me probably over $100K in the past decade.
You guys have to worry about this!?😭
Damn, I didn't know US Americans were struggling _this_ hard...
@@nemo-zl1vm as someone who is not american and does not take medication it baffles me to think that a life-saving medicine could even cost 10k a year. is it subsidised at all?
@@acookie7548 I don't think you understood. That IS the subsidized price.
@@acookie7548 This particular medication gets billed at $40K per dose, and I get 8 doses per year, but my max out of pocket for health insurance is about $7K. With the reimbursement program, I "only" end of paying a thousand or so a year for it. Sometimes my insurance likes to deny my claim for bullshit reasons, so I get to spend a few months thinking I'm suddenly $40K in debt while I beg them to change their mind. Whatever country you live in, vote like hell to prevent them from privatising health costs - it really is hard to exaggerate how hellish it can be.
As for subsidies, there's lots of "it depends" that can take age or poverty status into account. You can theoretically deduct health costs from your taxes, but it's limited and it's difficult to qualify for it.
As someone with a JOB in insurance, I want nothing more than to burn this whole industry down.
Same. I love helping people find plans that fit their needs but hate the fact that I have to. If I had a vote to get rid of private insurance I would.
Meh they’re probably covered for that
it is your moral duty to do so in whatever way you can.
@@Owl325 oh geez I never thought of it that way. I guess you’re right 🙄
We still hate you.
I just thought you should know that.
I love that this has popped up in my feed again considering recent events.
I hate that some dude on the internet was able to go over all this in 30 minutes (and the sad part is, that it's trending) whereas the person in HR couldn't even bother to tell me what all of this meant when I first started working.
Thank you for this, Brian. Not all heroes wear capes.
Congratulations on making it onto the trending page too!
It's not that they didn't bother, they don't want you to understand any of this, that's why it's so convoluted in the first place.
I'm so glad my mom worked in health insurance and could explain everything to me when it was time for me to choose my plan. It's such a scam that there's so many extra little costs, and that some plans don't even cover you fully once you hit your deductible!! I'm enrolled in a German university now, and it was SO weird to not have to wade through different copay levels, deductibles, etc... the public options that I looked at all were the same price and covered the same things. Though I do have to choose doctors who accept public insurance.
To be fair, I'd bet that 90% of HR personnel don't understand Health Insurance themselves, so it's easier to just kind of hand wave it. They should do better, but they likely don't do better for themselves either.
@@LeafMaltieze In a lot of corporations the plans or even providers are changes every 2-3 years. Literally no one can keep up with it. All the training comes directly from the provider. Guess how helpful it is.
My wife has a blood condition that 4 people in the US have. It’s SUPER cheap to treat, but bc it’s rare, we’ve had to fight for 9 months to get care. Thank you for this cathartic, and hilarious, recap of our year.
Same thing happened to my family, insurance wouldn't accept the first Dr.s letter so had to literally beg the chief of medicine of a children's hospital in person so my family wouldn't be financially crippled for life... and we're the ones who are lucky
whoaa how do you even get a diagnosis for something that rare? because most doctors will have never even heard of it, and even for relatively common chronic illnesses like POTS it's ridiculously difficult to get a diagnosis or any type of referral for further testing
what disease is this??
@@notebeans3134 She's now what you call a "case study."
Lol. The diagnosis was by accident and by the American Red Cross. They noticed something was up with her blood and appropriately took action. God bless them.
@@girlrottingpro I need to know too 0.o
This truly proves that BDG can talk about literally anything, not just video games, for 30 minutes and i would enjoy it
I'm from canada and I watched the whole thing unable to look away, panic laughing.
@@Mugulord Same :')
You just made me realize this video is 30 minutes long like how?
My dad had a minor stroke earlier this year and he got a type of health insurance that was for covering cancer and stroke treatments and he was supposed to receive 3,000 dollars for it but apparently the type of stroke he had wasn't part of the list of things covered despite it literally being a stroke and he was rightfully angry and planned on just canceling the whole thing, he eventually received the money anyway because I guess after checking they discovered it was indeed a stroke what he had, it was crazy
The worst part is that most insurance companies don’t even play by their own convoluted rules and frequently deny coverage that they are contractually obligated to provide. They will make every excuse imaginable to withhold money from you and make zero effort to maintain a positive business relationship with you, their cash cow. The one constant I have seen over the 10 years of having private health insurance with various providers is that you have to fight like hell, for an exorbitant amount of time, to get what you need without bleeding money, as well.
And they're rude too, you call them and put up with their convoluted bullshit for an hour or more and the person on the other end almost always is an asshole, refusing to actually help you or explain things, their job is to suck you dry, not help you, you're just disagreeable food
reminds me of the time i had a procedure that was covered fail, and bcbs tried to charge me almost $300 for that failed procedure. EVEN THO if it had gone right, it wouldve cost me almost nothing at that point bc my family had already met our deductible!!!!!!!!!!
Why on earth would they play by their own rules? If a provider defrauds, say, 1.3 million people a year, how many of those people will realize they've been robbed? How many of the people who realized will be in a position to do something about it? How many of _those_ people will actually manage to get it done? Stealing money from your cash cows is, it turns out, _incredibly profitable and very low-risk._
Legal fees are just another calculated risk, and they are experts at calculating risk. They'll break their contract exactly as much as they calculate they can. The profits they save by denying you coverage are used to pay for the very lawyers that fight against you, the mathematicians that find optimal pathways to screw you, and the politicians that write laws in their favor. Ultimately you are the one funding their efforts against you.
You never had a chance. You don't have teams of mathematicians helping you calculate your risk. You don't have teams of lawyers to make sure your contract is upheld, in which you didn't contribute any of the fine print, let alone half the contract. You don't have politicians in your pocket writing laws for you. You don't have economists keeping an eye on the markets for you.
There is an extreme inequality of every economically important resource, both physical and conceptual, including time, attention, money, law, information, negotiating ability, and even general decision making skills such as game theory. The insurance company counted their win against you as predicted future profits before you were born.
And if I can point out, they may deny coverage for life-threatening conditions that your well-respected oncologist has ordered. You are so right about having to fight hard. Do it early - your private health insurance will likely explain that they are not obligated to provide you any answer sooner than 10 to 14 days; that's a problem when your platelets are low and dropping by 6k a day, but hey, if you bleed out because you bite your tongue, that solves their problem of expensive medical procedures....
I'm in my late twenties, I have a college degree, I teach high school history, and my father once worked in insurance, and this is still the first time I've understood anything about health insurance.
As a disabled person who has had to literally fight the american healthcare system, this video was so cathartic. I feel heard. Thank you so much.
More 'Why Healthcare sucks': Some More News, Second Thought, Professor Dave.
as a disabled person who has to brawl with healthcare services on a weekly basis in AUSTRALIA i can boldly and assuredly say you are braver than any us marine
as a disabled person, this system did overwhelm me to the extent i stopped seeking care for a long time and it cost me in ways i won’t recover from. it is so validating for someone to articulate the complexities of the healthcare system that abled bodied individuals struggle with too.
education is our greatest tool in humanity.
to anyone reading this- NEVER give up advocating for your health and needs. you are worthy and deserving of getting help.
Samezies.
Same, Chronic pain sufferers are completely taken advantage of by the system that claims to help them
Oh, I remember this video! I wonder why it's being recommended to me again? Hmm... a mystery.
As a 29 year old. Learning this all when I left my parents was literally a nightmare. I asked about high deductible vs premiums with my dad. And he just said. Well you gotta decide. Neat.
@im sacred Fr??????????????
I just had an AUS friend send this to me to ask if this was supposed to be satire or if this was fact. I studied medical billing and coding for a year in the US and live in the US with chronic illnesses. This is not satire. This is accurate. This is how the US system works.
Nice try, I know this is a joke because it does not, in fact, work
@@crunglemcbungley I haven’t laughed this hard since I finished this video.
Oh my gosh. How do you guys survive
In Aus we have Medicare which means most general consults are government subsidied and you have the option to buy private insurance for certain stuff if you need it. Correct me if I'm wrong though
@@thefabulouskitten7204 we don't
My favorite part of insurance is that, for a service that's suppose to be there when something bad happens, you end up getting punished when something bad happens and have to end up paying more because you're now a "risk" in the eyes of the company, who will continue raising the price every time you end up needing the service. Boy oh boy do I like getting scammed!
I watched this two years ago and remember feeling confused, angry and frustrated.
So i get exactly why its on the top of my fyp today.
And what sucks is when you DO go to the hospital and pay all that money you often don’t get taken serious and end up going home with a misdiagnosis
This. Both my brother and my mother have had to go into preventable surgery that made it so they had exponentially worse short and long term health repercussions (with my mom's being life threatening emergency surgery) and too many a times have I turned to Google because it doesn't make sense to pay for a doctor's visit just for them to say 'your blood and pee is healthy go drink water or something'
And gets much worse the more of a minority you are. Trying to get chronic pain that I believe is MS, but my last doctor blamed it entirely on my trans HRT despite it starting to progress before starting that
She did the same thing with my chronic migraines I finally needed meds for that I had been fighting for 10-15 years. And of course US healthcare is so underfunded that it takes months to get a new doctor
yep took my doctors over 6 months to figure out I didn't have post nasal drip, but a brain tumor (I'm ok now, they cut that shit out 4 years ago)
My sister had a similar problem, except she got coverage that didn't cover pre-existing conditions in the meantime, which meant she was paying premiums for useless insurance.
@@scharlesworth93 I was told my sui-level headaches are “TMJ” and I’m legitimately terrified that it’s a fucking tumor that no one will go looking for
I would totally watch a series called "Adulting" by BDG that dives in or gives an overview of all the bs the world doesn't teach you enough about until it's too late.
I desperately need info on taxes. Like, every year, I spend months trying to figure this shit out and I have no idea. There's no help for people with learning disabilities like me, and I can't afford a tax service again this year, so I'm already shitting myself.
I couldn't get through it without encouraging fight club
This would be incredible. I definitely trust him to learn the things I'm to dumb to figure out and teach them to me via entertaining videos
taxes would be very good
I mean this is a specifically US problem, same goes for taxes
i actually need BDG to explain every adult concept to me in this exact manner.
Huh, mysteriously this popped up again on my recommendations
Also, when Brian says “pay very little” for catastrophic health insurance, these numbers can be upwards of $250 per month 🤗
BRUH
WHAT THE FUCK IS THE US
My "non-catastrophic" health insurance is $650/month and covers both me and my spouse... x_x
@@capajensen5689 Jesus fuck that’s literally more than my rent
and "high premium, low deductible" is usually 4 digits a month, especially if you a spouse and kids.
“Gamble on your health” is the perfect way to explain Health insurance costs in America
You pick a plan in November, and hope your health situation doesn't change during the upcoming year, because you don't get to pick again until next November. Good luck!!
Damn, American lootboxes are hardcore
I feel like its really an indictment of the system that
1. A somewhat basic explanation takes 30 minutes
2. You really do need to understand all of it to navigate getting insurance or healthcare
He just scratched the surface. All the those times where he says your plan/employer/situation may differ? Yeah, that's all real and there are a thousand exceptions to every item he covered. All of them mean you will end up paying through the nose for healthcare.
Haha 30 minutes? He didn't even explain enough to get started with finding health insurance that's worth your money.
All he explained are absolute basics.
Meh, my process for picking health insurance was basically finding the lowest combined annual premium+out of pocket maximum. I understand the rest but ultimately didn't need it.
@@ghosthunter0950 That's... literally what OP said
glad this is making the rounds again
As someone who is almost off their parents insurance and is looking to go into an industry that usually doesn’t have benefits, this is immensely helpful and terrifying
Sounds like that's a choice you made...
literally same here. and ^ dude the point is healthcare should be available for everyone
for your own sake, please reconsider
ok
@@swesleyc7
Ah yes I also chose to be born and make the world a shitty place where people will look down on one another and decide "hmm yes that person deserves the almost inevitable fate of suffering and death that is being denied healthcare, because they don't have a job I deem worthy". Absolutely a choice we, the young, made. Yes indeedy.
Brian David Gilbert is the best TH-camr because you never know if he's going to write a song about Roasted Garlic Summer Sausage or make a half-hour essay about the intricacies of American health insurance.
And everyone is going to watch it either way
I literally started watching it and 5 mins in I was like wait hold on this is a lot longer than I thought and I got up to make a cup of tea first
I'm French, and I already knew that our healthcare system is precious considering your situation, but MY GOD I didn't know this was so bad for you... Universal healthcare is really important. Dear Americans, fight to get it.
Unfortunately, 40% of us have been convinced that the government helping people IN ANY WAY WHATSOEVER is morally wrong and "against the will of God". Public Roads? Communism. Universal Healthcare? Communism. Firefighters? Communism. Giant Military Industrial Complex? That's for Jesus 😊
They voted for this. This is what Americans consider freedom.
@@Grintock *Laughs in the stupidity of the Electoral College*
Sir I assure you a lot of us don't consider it freedom and are attempting to get better but there's some barriers in our way.
I'm Canadian and the idiotic premier of my province wants to privatize our healthcare. Maybe this video can help explain some things to his followers, but I doubt it.
we have been for so long 😭