When Mia Shem cried in her mother's arms, I bawled my eyes out. Her cry said it all. No words were needed. Praying for all of the hostages and the ones still there, and their families 🙏God bless this doctor and all treating the hostages/patients 💖
Exactly 💯. It was so heartbreaking 💔 seeing her cry in her Mother's arms. It was very obvious that she had been starved and abused. She is just a shadow of her former self. The HAMMAS MONSTERS tortured her.
And why did she even ask this Israeli doctor about Gazans? It’s as if some reporters think these people went in there and asked for this. I would lose my mind if people were asking me well what about them? What about them? He can’t do anything anyway. They would not want a Jewish doctor to help if he was the last man on earth.
@@Ms7of8 You clearly don't understand the context of their "support" for Hamas. And that you would call doctors who are risking their lives to save lives complicit in atrocities simply shows how twisted or ignorant you are about the conflict.
I know some employees from the Red Cross in France and in other countries. They mistreat their employees and they always hated Israel and Jewish. Previously, for the 6 days war and the Yom Kippur war, the Red Cross refused to give medical help to the Israeli soldiers while they are supposed to be neutral.
It's what many of us suspected. I think many of the hostages that have shared their stories so far probably deny having been raped because that degree of trauma and violation is so personal and hard to talk about in comparison to not having enough to eat and being watched like a hawk. And considering that it didn't happen that long ago, I'm not expecting complete transparency in these interviews. If anything, people often downplay trauma in the beginning because it's how they cope.
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas. Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.
Can this doctor explain to us the best way for Palestinian doctors to amputate the limbs of injured children without anesthesia so that they do not feel pain and the doctors do not have to hear their screams?? What hypocrites you are
Palestinian Arabs do not feel 'the same.' They were not hostages. They were not raped or burned alive. Instead, they were celebrating October 7 on the streets. There is hours of footage showing them beating hostages or dead bodies when they arrived in the Gaza Strip.
Probably bc that is done to them day in and day out in the West bank and through previous bombing campaigns of Gaza. Idk but if you were always the victim and all of a sudden this is done to your Oppressor I'm sure you would be thinking finally a taste of your own medicine!
You act like Israelis are angels. That is an article one moth before October 7th. RAMALLAH, 18 Sept 2023 - At least 38 Palestinian children have been killed by Israeli forces in the occupied West Bank so far in 2023, making it the deadliest year since records began, said Save the Children.
There was no evidence of hostages or anyone being burnt alive or beheaded babies-this was all fabricated by the idf and their officials.The White House admitted the next day that Biden had not seen photos of beheaded children or burnt bodies.The reporter who wrote that they had seen burnt bodies and photos of beheaded victims retracted their story saying they had also fabricated it as well!!!Get your facts right before you talk BS!!!
"Constant bombardment of Gaza" ? Can you mention that Hamas has not stopped and said it will not stop attacking Israel?!? It seems that the interviewer has no tact in how she's addressing these questions.
Israel bombing Gaza puts the hostages in mortal peril too. Have you thought of that? That is a major concern too. And the women and children of Gaza that are dying. Or is your mind too tiny to accept two truths at once and your heart too mean to only feel sympathy for one side?
Its apalling yet the UN refuse to admit what hamas did . Now they have turned off the comments section because they know that the world is disgusted with them. Thank yoh doctor for helping those tormented people I pray that God gives you strength and the right words for your people
Israel has refused to let the UN conduct an independent investigation. Israel has provided no forensic evidence and has no first-hand testimony from a rape victim.
Leslie Stahl appears sympathetic. She is definitely one of my least favorite and one of my least trustworthy journalists but, at least she displays some sympathy.
No it doesn't. She's referring to the civilians, the children etc of Gaza who are swept into this war, which is •really• only between Hamas and Israel. The Palestinians are victims of Hamas too and live in fear of them. Thousands of Palestinians have been tortured and killed by Hamas. And it's Hamas who stokes the fires of hatred in their hearts against Israelis. It is accurate to say that there is tremendous suffering on both sides. Bibi says that Palestinians are suffering because of their leaders. Yes, Israel has suffered much because of this attack! It's heartbreaking!
Exactly. This "both sides" stance is morally perverse. Especially when doing a show on the suffering of hostages. It's a slap in the face to trot out this "both sides" posture, as if the hostages somehow deserved what they got. Or as if the Gazans were just innocently living their lives and this just "happened" to them. 'What? Look how bad they are. Why are they doing this to us now? All we did was ... '
@@charwest9449 we know for certain that 12,000 children in Gaza killed are innocent, the 25,000 who gave lost 1or both parents and 22-27,000 injured children. Although there are some beliefs, including military analysts that declare "there are no innocent people in Gaza, even the babies are not innocent". Anything that happens to innocent people is horrible, just like the stories of survivors of hostage taking. Either we logically apply this belief, don't apply if at all, or, divulge our racist beliefs by only applying the label to one people worthy as worthy of suffering.
@@Bagelsmoker1945 You guys set one criteria for Palestinian Resistance and different for IDF You are calling Palestinian Resistance Terrorism But when IDF puts innocent people in prison and treat them less than humans that's self defence and not terrorism.
She is the worst. If she had heard about the medication given to the hostages, then why would she ask a horrible question about not looking like some of the hostages where harmed? She is truly at the bottom of the barrel when it comes to reporting 😡
This is beyond sad and scary. We can’t begin to comprehend it. Actually just looked up this video because I had a very vivid dream that I somehow wound up in that country and I was one of the hostages. I thought I was gonna die so many times and I just remember talking to God so many times. It was a dream, but surrounded by men with guns. I never felt so terrified. I can only imagine how they feel.
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas. Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas. Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative...
It’s more unbelievable that 30,000 Palestinians have been murdered, with over 10,000 of those being children. 25,000 children are orphaned. 1000 children are now amputees, many had their limbs removed without anesthesia. 350,000 homes destroyed and all institutions wiped out. A complete erasure of their culture
This comment is for all the supporters on both sides. Just remember that all the killing of innocent civilians and children could be stopped right now if Hamas would just surrender. These terrorists know they can’t win and if they truly cared about the Palestinians, they would stop fighting a no win situation and stop all this senseless killing on both sides.
IDF is committing genocide but u are so blind due to your hatred of Islam. Palestine will win eventually. Because God doesn't give victory to oppressors
Because she is a raging liberal and wants to portray Israel as the bad guys. She tried her best buy i imagine shell use portions of this in her agenda.
@@christerry1773 do you have a point? How does what other news outlets do support your sarcastic comment that" they did not ask the questions that you wanted?" Troll
This extremely biased interviewer couldn’t wait to bring up the Palestinian’s dilemma. Took her mere seconds. She has to be one of the worst “journalists” on the planet! Inserting her woke views into the doctor describing those poor children he treated. Retire already please. Not sure why I listened to her that long!
Does hamas wanted a peaceful and prosperous life for their palestinian/gazan people? I think not. They are overshadowed by their hate and envy. Life alone is hard enough and hamas make it more harder for gazan people by putting their land at war.
Always have been. They line their pockets with the billions in aid intended for the people of Gaza, instead blaming Israel for all of their woes. Wake up.
Are you trying to say being held hostage wasn’t so bad? Even if they treated them like welcomed guest, they were still kidnapped and that alone is evil.
It is important to recognize the attacks by Hamas did not happen in a vacuum People who are subjected to oppression and almost apartheid ways, will always have the "will" to Fight. #FreePalestine
@@polpol1005 not always but can be. It’s a choice that we ask need to make. Either you stand for peace and care for others or you don’t. There is no way to do both. The only thing Palestine needs to be free from is Hamas and all those who think like Hamas
@@jackack1429 guess what, on October 7th there were hundreds of Palestinian hostages in Israeli prison undergoing severe tortures. That was the whole point of kidnapping Israeli hostages...to exchange them. Try to keep up.
Praying 🙏 for the release of all the remaining hostages that they be released immediately and be able to return home safely to their loved ones In Jesus name Amen
Is this gonna be like the testimony of the dude from Nova festival who said he SAW 29 of his friends killed - and it turns out he was a complete fraud who wasn’t even there???!! Ffs 🤦♀️ I
he not only got an interview, he got a place to stay, therapy sessions, food. until they realized nobody knew him and he wasnt even there.. the people from Nova are one big community that meet each other in such events every now and then. every one of them that has survived, had lost dozens of friends there. most of them are getting therapy in groups together because of that. they are not strangers. many of them were under the effects of drugs, and that makes the emotional trauma even more complexed. the fact that there was a sick dude lying, does not nullify the trauma of the 3000 people that were there.
what about them? if you are a relative of one of them, you can get information of where they are, what they eat, their condition, their release date, they have medical care and you can even talk to them. thats because they are PRISONERS, not hostages. the israeli hostages in gaza, we dont even know if they are alive and the red cross is not allowed to visit them or give them their medications.
They brought it on themselves. Israel had nothing to do with it maybe they should have been using all that money to build up their communities instead of using it for tunnels. It's all on them
This reporter is too smart to then state "some of them don't look abused 🙄😵💫is that deceptive?"😡👎 🤬You cannot sleep well at night after asking that question!
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas. Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative...
Sexual abuse is a very vague word. Yes it has a meaning which is bad but it is manifested in different ways. The doctor could not confirm there was rape or any other form. So far al the videos of hostages interviewed titled -sexual abuse - have them saying they feared being abused but not actually being abused. Everything is not clear and the media isn't doing their work
The IDF dictates what goes out of the hostages mouth, especially after the first few released hostages spoke freely, in uncensored fashion sighting no harm was inflicted on them by their captives. The Israeli propanganda is looking for victory somewhere through unfounded sympathy.
NO MATTER WHAT, you ALWAYS try to make it about Hamas and the Gazans, Gazans who voted for Hamas to rule them, Gazans who beat the hostages coming in and going out and spat on them, Gazans who beat dead bodies paraded around as trophies by Hamas, and who celebrated the horrible massacres, some even entering to loot the attacked areas. Gazans are suffering, yes, but that is the fault of Hamas and consequences of their own actions. Some have begun to speak out against Hamas, but overwhelmingly, the majority still supports them. Most of them are NOT "victims." Even their doctors helped turn hospitals and baby incubators into terror bases and weapon stashes. If you're going to tell it, tell it ALL.
“Anyone who wants to prevent the establishment of a Palestinian state needs to support strengthening H@m@s.” - Netanyahu, 2019 at a Likud party conference "‘Buying Quiet’: Inside the Israeli Plan That Propped Up Hàmás Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gambled that a strong H@m@s (but not too strong) would keep the peace and reduce pressure for a Palestinian state." - NYT
I d f has done much worse things just in last two Months (we are not gonna even go into years before last attack) maybe they should be reporting on that too.
LOL If in WW2 the Germans shot men surrendering with a white flag they would have been called monsters, evil murderers. It is disappointing how the media in the USA always works to dehumanizes one group
I don’t like her tone . It was like interrogating trying to prove the Israelis are lying. I’m glad she got the truth on camera from a credible witness. She acted surprised each time he said yes I saw that
So were just gonna forget that israel has 10 times more hostages that are in much worse conditions. Oh and dont forget the lady who came out and said that they were treated very nicely with food and medications and it wasnt just one but multiple people came out and said this.
That "Department of Peace" is irrelevant against people like Hamas.... It exists several "Peace Institutions" around the world and they haven't avoid any wars...
Stop with your disproportional argument. I’m so glad you weren’t around during the Vietnam war. Plus during the Afghan war and the internet putting the hanging of sadamn Hussein so we could all see it. As a journalist you should remain neutral In private it’s fine but not on the air
Talk about the Palestinians people held as hostages in Israeli prisons men women and children who are suffering abuse from the Israeli prisons guards and what about the 20000 and counting dead Palestinians??? And let the hostages speak for themselves not word by mouth by other people the US media is one sided and the world is watching trauma on both sides of the innocent people
would you talk on TV for the whole world to see if you went through this massacre? so that people from all over the world would laugh at you and call you a liar and ask for proof?
Pretty sure if I was a hostage and told I was being released.... But we have your husband/friend/child/neighbor etc who will pay if you break silence *aka we will find you and all you love* I'd stay quiet too in hope of no retribution for them. There could b many reasons for choosing silence. Yet not all of them are. The stories are pouring in.
Why has hardly anyone seen this video after a ' full month ' . The world doesn't care about the hostages......because the world went into shock on October the 7th.....then they went into mental denial of the horror . They want a rational explanation for irrational acts. They will never get it.
@@proronen yes they did. One of the ladies said she thought they would abuse her bit they didn't and one of the girls described even arm wrestling with the guards and out of respect to the women he placed a towel over his hand as not to touch her! Conflicting info.
@proronen not one released hostage has testified that they were abused or raped. Doctors and law enforcement have collected NO forensic evidence of rape. No one who experience the attacks of October 7 has testified that they were raped.
How were the original hostages saying something completely different, then everyone else thats clearly paid off contradicts them, that weren't hostages. I have never seen so many people speak for the victims. This is pathetic. There are so many lies, everyone keeps getting caught in. No one cares anymore. Please cover something else.
Lying is a sin. Let them speak for themselves, so it can be believable. It is not part of your job description to speak for them, unless it is a media conference. Have you ever heard of patient's confidentiality?
I felt the same way. When she interviewed the mom who was held hostage and now released her questions were ridiculous and the hostage looked at her in disbelief on 3 or 4 of the questions and refused to answer.
I once respected Sunday Morning. How can you justify Israel's blatant massacre of 30,000 civilians who had nothing to due with Oct7? Israel massacred over 250 civilians during the year preceding Oct 7. When didn't SM report this? These innocent hostages are compensation of Israel's frequent massacres of tens of thousands of Palestinian civilians. Your reporting on this conflict is complicity
So glad that the hostages weren't harmed more than what is inevitable from being kidnapped..and none of the propaganda from Israel's side turned out to be true
Who took them as hostages? Who attacked on Oct 7th. Israel has been wreckless in their overreaction, but it’s worth asking the question would all those People be alive had Hamas not attacked. Yes they would
As bad as it is for these hostages, why is the news mostly just showing their suffering? Why is American media ignoring the humongous suffering of civilians in Gaza? Are they less human? Why don't we talk about THEIR humanity?
@@nicolefall1784people that question why they are quiet are sick people hungry to hear gory details and don't care about those held captive. It's a sick world we live in. I prayed for their healing time and love from family and friends.
"From 2008 until 6 October 2023, 1,434 Palestinian children were reportedly killed, with an additional 32,175 sustaining injuries, primarily at the hands of Israeli occupation forces. Of these, 1,025 children were killed in Gaza alone, since the unlawful blockade began in 2007." - UN Human Rights, ‘Unchilded’ from birth: UN expert calls for decisive protection of Palestinian children under Israeli rule, 24 October 2023
When Mia Shem cried in her mother's arms, I bawled my eyes out. Her cry said it all. No words were needed. Praying for all of the hostages and the ones still there, and their families 🙏God bless this doctor and all treating the hostages/patients 💖
Exactly 💯. It was so heartbreaking 💔 seeing her cry in her Mother's arms. It was very obvious that she had been starved and abused. She is just a shadow of her former self. The HAMMAS MONSTERS tortured her.
@@dextermoore278 Exactly.
One of the Hamas terrorists surrendered 2 days ago was identified as a doctor who previously appeared on tv.
@@crystal2484 show the proof
@@crystal2484 show the proof or stay silent
Wow “how prepared they were with psychological torment, structured and preplanned” separating families. complete psychopaths
Yes. Totally psychopathological.
It comes naturally to demoniacs.
And why did she even ask this Israeli doctor about Gazans? It’s as if some reporters think these people went in there and asked for this. I would lose my mind if people were asking me well what about them? What about them? He can’t do anything anyway. They would not want a Jewish doctor to help if he was the last man on earth.
😢🤧💔
Bless this doctor and staff. It is a heavy weight to carry the suffering of people on your shoulders.
#SUBHANALLAH
#CEASEFIRENO
#STOPTHEGENOCIDE
#STOPTARGETCIVILIANS
#JUSTICEFORPALESTINE
#ICCWARCRIMES
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARCRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCRIMES
#IDFTHELOSSER
#IDFTHEREALTERRORIST
#ZIONISTSHAMEONYOU
Imagine what the doctors in Gaza has had to deal with, and is still dealing with
@@ChrisAlbertH47Seriously? Go back to your University.
@@ChrisAlbertH47 They are complicit. We care about the innocents. Not Hamas or the 90% of Gazans who, when polled, support the Hamas butchers.
@@Ms7of8 You clearly don't understand the context of their "support" for Hamas. And that you would call doctors who are risking their lives to save lives complicit in atrocities simply shows how twisted or ignorant you are about the conflict.
Do a story on why the Red Cross failed the hostages - didn’t even try - defund Red Cross
Ask BiBi.
defund the IDF ... everything then will be fine
Lol bibi is in control not red Cross red Cross can only carry out on the agreements that have been made
Disgusting!!! Agreed!!!
I know some employees from the Red Cross in France and in other countries. They mistreat their employees and they always hated Israel and Jewish. Previously, for the 6 days war and the Yom Kippur war, the Red Cross refused to give medical help to the Israeli soldiers while they are supposed to be neutral.
The doctors eyes when she said exual abuse tells it all. God bless this doctor. I pray peace over his mind in Jesus name Amen.
It's what many of us suspected. I think many of the hostages that have shared their stories so far probably deny having been raped because that degree of trauma and violation is so personal and hard to talk about in comparison to not having enough to eat and being watched like a hawk. And considering that it didn't happen that long ago, I'm not expecting complete transparency in these interviews. If anything, people often downplay trauma in the beginning because it's how they cope.
Please, no Jesus. We are Jews. Respect our beliefs, cultural and religious. I wish you peace.
Beyond sad 😢 Praying for the remaing hostages.
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas.
Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.
Can this doctor explain to us the best way for Palestinian doctors to amputate the limbs of injured children without anesthesia so that they do not feel pain and the doctors do not have to hear their screams?? What hypocrites you are
Palestinian Arabs do not feel 'the same.' They were not hostages. They were not raped or burned alive. Instead, they were celebrating October 7 on the streets. There is hours of footage showing them beating hostages or dead bodies when they arrived in the Gaza Strip.
Probably bc that is done to them day in and day out in the West bank and through previous bombing campaigns of Gaza. Idk but if you were always the victim and all of a sudden this is done to your Oppressor I'm sure you would be thinking finally a taste of your own medicine!
Muslims in Germany were celebrating it; cheering and offering free candy.
You act like Israelis are angels.
That is an article one moth before October 7th.
RAMALLAH, 18 Sept 2023 - At least 38 Palestinian children have been killed by Israeli forces in the occupied West Bank so far in 2023, making it the deadliest year since records began, said Save the Children.
@@gabrielekarl9278 ROFL, i trust you
There was no evidence of hostages or anyone being burnt alive or beheaded babies-this was all fabricated by the idf and their officials.The White House admitted the next day that Biden had not seen photos of beheaded children or burnt bodies.The reporter who wrote that they had seen burnt bodies and photos of beheaded victims retracted their story saying they had also fabricated it as well!!!Get your facts right before you talk BS!!!
"Constant bombardment of Gaza" ? Can you mention that Hamas has not stopped and said it will not stop attacking Israel?!? It seems that the interviewer has no tact in how she's addressing these questions.
Israel bombing Gaza puts the hostages in mortal peril too. Have you thought of that? That is a major concern too. And the women and children of Gaza that are dying. Or is your mind too tiny to accept two truths at once and your heart too mean to only feel sympathy for one side?
WAR is HELL@@Vic82toire
@@Vic82toireyeah, bullying someone to feel compassion for your side -- is that how you run your society too?
@@charwest9449oh, I see. Ok, carry on.
"There are no innocent civilians in Gaza, they don't exist"- Former Hamas Hostage Mia Schem
Thank you for allowing the truth to be told.
Its apalling yet the UN refuse to admit what hamas did . Now they have turned off the comments section because they know that the world is disgusted with them. Thank yoh doctor for helping those tormented people I pray that God gives you strength and the right words for your people
Israel has refused to let the UN conduct an independent investigation. Israel has provided no forensic evidence and has no first-hand testimony from a rape victim.
Reporters constant equations of suffering on both sides is just sickening and ludicrous as it equates victims of massacre with perpetrators ,period
Leslie Stahl appears sympathetic. She is definitely one of my least favorite and one of my least trustworthy journalists but, at least she displays some sympathy.
No it doesn't. She's referring to the civilians, the children etc of Gaza who are swept into this war, which is •really• only between Hamas and Israel. The Palestinians are victims of Hamas too and live in fear of them. Thousands of Palestinians have been tortured and killed by Hamas. And it's Hamas who stokes the fires of hatred in their hearts against Israelis.
It is accurate to say that there is tremendous suffering on both sides.
Bibi says that Palestinians are suffering because of their leaders.
Yes, Israel has suffered much because of this attack! It's heartbreaking!
Exactly. This "both sides" stance is morally perverse. Especially when doing a show on the suffering of hostages. It's a slap in the face to trot out this "both sides" posture, as if the hostages somehow deserved what they got. Or as if the Gazans were just innocently living their lives and this just "happened" to them. 'What? Look how bad they are. Why are they doing this to us now? All we did was ... '
100% right!
@@charwest9449 we know for certain that 12,000 children in Gaza killed are innocent, the 25,000 who gave lost 1or both parents and 22-27,000 injured children. Although there are some beliefs, including military analysts that declare "there are no innocent people in Gaza, even the babies are not innocent".
Anything that happens to innocent people is horrible, just like the stories of survivors of hostage taking.
Either we logically apply this belief, don't apply if at all, or, divulge our racist beliefs by only applying the label to one people worthy as worthy of suffering.
So tragic that young and older women, kids and teenagers had to go through in the hands of the terrorists 😢
What is wrong with people like you?
@@the-noble-pathwhat did he say exactly that makes him “wrong”?
@@Bagelsmoker1945 what is wrong with people like you?
@@the-noble-path I don’t know that’s why am asking you.
@@Bagelsmoker1945 You guys set one criteria for Palestinian Resistance and different for IDF
You are calling Palestinian Resistance Terrorism But when IDF puts innocent people in prison and treat them less than humans that's self defence and not terrorism.
What evil does this to innocent people?! Prayers to all 🙏💔
israel has been doing this for years , Saudia Arabia to yemen and so forth
evil = idf
@@trevorolga4390 Bull. 10-7 was uniquely evil.
@@Sooner-im9qfand the stuff that’s been happening in Gaza rn
@@Kdramaedits530 ALL of which is the fault of Hamas.
I applaud the doctor and staff. Amazing job.
Leslie stahl is the worst reporter on the planet. Her lack of concern or sympathy is staggering
I agree, she is on auto pilot . No emotion in voice or face at all. Cold.
No one else was available for this interview? Time for Leslie to retire
She is the worst. If she had heard about the medication given to the hostages, then why would she ask a horrible question about not looking like some of the hostages where harmed? She is truly at the bottom of the barrel when it comes to reporting 😡
Sadly, I have to agree. She had more emotion when speaking of Gaza which Hamas caused! Leslie , wake up!
This is beyond sad and scary. We can’t begin to comprehend it. Actually just looked up this video because I had a very vivid dream that I somehow wound up in that country and I was one of the hostages. I thought I was gonna die so many times and I just remember talking to God so many times. It was a dream, but surrounded by men with guns. I never felt so terrified. I can only imagine how they feel.
You must be really intuitive to have dreams like that 🙏🙏🇳🇮 definitely a empath ✌️❤️🙏🙏
Or it was from eating chocolate chips at 2 o’clock in the morning when I woke up to go to the bathroom lol whatever the case though, it rattled me.
The thing is people were clinging to a defense of Hamas to the point they’d just reject any contrary information
@@GamerGodPlayz-vx6imalright we don’t gotta make stuff up😂
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas.
Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.
2.5 million Palestinians have tolerated Hamas and didn't expect the responce from the IDF
And still 130 hostages are there! 2 months! Unbelievable
So sad😔
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas.
Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative...
Young kids in Israeli prisons for years .... nbelievable.
@@polpol1005This is a created propoganda bideo
It’s more unbelievable that 30,000 Palestinians have been murdered, with over 10,000 of those being children. 25,000 children are orphaned. 1000 children are now amputees, many had their limbs removed without anesthesia. 350,000 homes destroyed and all institutions wiped out. A complete erasure of their culture
This comment is for all the supporters on both sides. Just remember that all the killing of innocent civilians and children could be stopped right now if Hamas would just surrender. These terrorists know they can’t win and if they truly cared about the Palestinians, they would stop fighting a no win situation and stop all this senseless killing on both sides.
IDF is committing genocide but u are so blind due to your hatred of Islam. Palestine will win eventually. Because God doesn't give victory to oppressors
You are speaking from a place of ignorance, be silent.
@@ttbrown3384 thank u for saying exactly wat I wanted to say ceasefire now.free free palestine
And hamas accepted the resolution 2720 from UN, but Israel did not.
May absolute unbiased objective Truth and Justice prevail for all the concerned people
Amen.
Amen
Unbiased objective? Amen, but it’ll never happen
@@LadyMavenNow Israel is killing thousands of children in Gaza.
and wich truth would that be my unbiased objective friend ?
Ok, what about how Hamas has been starved and abused by Israel for years which led to their backlash?
why is the interviewer leading the doctor into certain answers?
Because she is a raging liberal and wants to portray Israel as the bad guys. She tried her best buy i imagine shell use portions of this in her agenda.
Was looking so long for this comment
Leslie Stahl is reprehensible.
Lol how? She not ask the questions you want?
@@christerry1773she lost sight of what she was being told and put a ridiculous spin on it!
@@Patricia-x9j8w lol oh that’s a good point. Goodness knows other media outlets rarely do that
@@christerry1773 do you have a point? How does what other news outlets do support your sarcastic comment that" they did not ask the questions that you wanted?"
Troll
@@Patricia-x9j8w all media figures do what your first comment said. Ugh good grief.
Why dont you mention how Hamas is continuing the bombing and broke the cease fire??
Israel that do this bombing now
are you out of your mind ou pretend being blind of the truth?
Idf broke the cease-fire by killing two Palestinians
How do you know that? IDF?
This extremely biased interviewer couldn’t wait to bring up the Palestinian’s dilemma. Took her mere seconds. She has to be one of the worst “journalists” on the planet! Inserting her woke views into the doctor describing those poor children he treated. Retire already please. Not sure why I listened to her that long!
there was an interview with two hostages that said the exact opposite thing!!! i would rather take their word than this sorry excuse for a doctor...
report this for misinformation
Does hamas wanted a peaceful and prosperous life for their palestinian/gazan people?
I think not. They are overshadowed by their hate and envy.
Life alone is hard enough and hamas make it more harder for gazan people by putting their land at war.
Always have been. They line their pockets with the billions in aid intended for the people of Gaza, instead blaming Israel for all of their woes. Wake up.
phycology turture ??? they kept the dog with the girl, they teached new games for the hostages...they didn't even touch the women hands
Are you trying to say being held hostage wasn’t so bad? Even if they treated them like welcomed guest, they were still kidnapped and that alone is evil.
We would be far better off without Lesley Stahl. She brings nothing to the table.
May God bless and protect the children of Israel
And palestine, both sides.
Thank you for telling the world the truth ❤
It is important to recognize the attacks by Hamas did not happen in a vacuum
People who are subjected to oppression and almost apartheid ways, will always have the "will" to Fight. #FreePalestine
@@polpol1005 not always but can be. It’s a choice that we ask need to make. Either you stand for peace and care for others or you don’t. There is no way to do both. The only thing Palestine needs to be free from is Hamas and all those who think like Hamas
Pure Evil
Thank you. 😥
Because Palestinian hostages in Israel dont gl through abuses? They are being mercilessly beaten. Small children
Try to keep up. We're discussing the atrocities of Oct. 7. Whataboutism isn't relevant.
@@jackack1429 guess what, on October 7th there were hundreds of Palestinian hostages in Israeli prison undergoing severe tortures. That was the whole point of kidnapping Israeli hostages...to exchange them. Try to keep up.
Praying 🙏 for the release of all the remaining hostages that they be released immediately and be able to return home safely to their loved ones In Jesus name Amen
And yet hamas, Islamic Jihad and Hezbollah cannot renounce their hatred despite the damage it does.
true learning comes from experience.
Is this gonna be like the testimony of the dude from Nova festival who said he SAW 29 of his friends killed - and it turns out he was a complete fraud who wasn’t even there???!! Ffs 🤦♀️ I
You gotta give me name for this, I have to read more
I’ve heard a lot of nonsense but didn’t catch that one yet
You really are ridiculous trying to deny something that Hamas was stupid enough to record on their own go pro cameras and even live stream.
For real?
he not only got an interview, he got a place to stay, therapy sessions, food. until they realized nobody knew him and he wasnt even there.. the people from Nova are one big community that meet each other in such events every now and then. every one of them that has survived, had lost dozens of friends there. most of them are getting therapy in groups together because of that. they are not strangers. many of them were under the effects of drugs, and that makes the emotional trauma even more complexed. the fact that there was a sick dude lying, does not nullify the trauma of the 3000 people that were there.
@@dardas47 everything can happen when you’re on drugs 😉
Evil monsters
what about the Palestinian hostage that Israel has ?
You mean the convicted criminals that Israel has been releasing 3 of for every one Israeli woman and child?
They were not hostages they were in prison, as prisoners
what about them? if you are a relative of one of them, you can get information of where they are, what they eat, their condition, their release date, they have medical care and you can even talk to them. thats because they are PRISONERS, not hostages. the israeli hostages in gaza, we dont even know if they are alive and the red cross is not allowed to visit them or give them their medications.
Why is this not on all US media?
Now imagine a out Palestinians misery for 75 years
They brought it on themselves. Israel had nothing to do with it maybe they should have been using all that money to build up their communities instead of using it for tunnels. It's all on them
This reporter is too smart to then state "some of them don't look abused 🙄😵💫is that deceptive?"😡👎
🤬You cannot sleep well at night after asking that question!
Shocking! Shame on you Hamas! Also, some of those answers were dodgy... But for the most part believable.
What answers were dodgy ?
Every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They we’re treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas.
Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative...
@@polpol1005 lol.
Sounds like those Israelis lived like Palestinians for 2-months.
They endured, for a change.
Love that this interview uses clicks from the hostages, but still tires to say 'Poor Hamas' during the entire subject.
Sexual abuse is a very vague word. Yes it has a meaning which is bad but it is manifested in different ways. The doctor could not confirm there was rape or any other form. So far al the videos of hostages interviewed titled -sexual abuse - have them saying they feared being abused but not actually being abused. Everything is not clear and the media isn't doing their work
Do you think a young married woman who was adopted and raped would openly say it as it is without regard to how her husband would feel?
The IDF dictates what goes out of the hostages mouth, especially after the first few released hostages spoke freely, in uncensored fashion sighting no harm was inflicted on them by their captives. The Israeli propanganda is looking for victory somewhere through unfounded sympathy.
Did you miss the selfies that those Palestinian 'innocent' civilians shared with the naked bodies of their victims on social media?
And ur doing ur work by this coment?
NO MATTER WHAT, you ALWAYS try to make it about Hamas and the Gazans, Gazans who voted for Hamas to rule them, Gazans who beat the hostages coming in and going out and spat on them, Gazans who beat dead bodies paraded around as trophies by Hamas, and who celebrated the horrible massacres, some even entering to loot the attacked areas. Gazans are suffering, yes, but that is the fault of Hamas and consequences of their own actions. Some have begun to speak out against Hamas, but overwhelmingly, the majority still supports them. Most of them are NOT "victims." Even their doctors helped turn hospitals and baby incubators into terror bases and weapon stashes. If you're going to tell it, tell it ALL.
You watch a lot of propaganda Israeli
Yeah, nearly all the claims by Israel against Hamas have been proven as lies so far.
“Anyone who wants to prevent the establishment of a Palestinian state needs to support strengthening H@m@s.” - Netanyahu, 2019 at a Likud party conference
"‘Buying Quiet’: Inside the Israeli Plan That Propped Up Hàmás
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu gambled that a strong H@m@s (but not too strong) would keep the peace and reduce pressure for a Palestinian state." - NYT
I d f has done much worse things just in last two Months (we are not gonna even go into years before last attack) maybe they should be reporting on that too.
@@IdaIda-ur8vxas...
l
What's about Palestine who are kept in Israeli prison... Why there is double standards!!!
Probably because they were actual prisoners. Criminals. Not innocent people that were just living their life.
@@andreawahleithner9640ye for sure😂 pleace get some education and don’t just say smth that’s not true
That poor doctor looked oks shattered
No critical questioning from the interviewer? So sad...
Lol like what? She’s one of the most respected in the industry?
In Gaza
There is a competition of suffering in the Middle East.
"The Israeli military confirmed its troops mistakenly shot and killed three of the hostages in a Gaza gun battle."
A gun battle? Not exactly...
LOL If in WW2 the Germans shot men surrendering with a white flag they would have been called monsters, evil murderers. It is disappointing how the media in the USA always works to dehumanizes one group
Plot twist: the 'doctor' isn't even a real doctor.
you cant handle some truth?
Nah, he is a doctor - only on iDF payroll 😏
I don’t like her tone . It was like interrogating trying to prove the Israelis are lying. I’m glad she got the truth on camera from a credible witness. She acted surprised each time he said yes I saw that
I love Israel.......Am Israel Chai!!!!!
Where are the American hostages Mr. President???
There are no American hostages in Gaza, those are dual citizenship, so they are Israelis
There probably are none, just to get the american tax payer to agree to their war games
His only comments are about demonizing his political opponents, not how he can serve America.
So were just gonna forget that israel has 10 times more hostages that are in much worse conditions. Oh and dont forget the lady who came out and said that they were treated very nicely with food and medications and it wasnt just one but multiple people came out and said this.
Leslie Stahl....." I heard a story...."
Wtf
The Red Cross are animals !
When the United States was created, Dr. Benjamin Rush (a founding father), petitioned for a Department of Peace.
Clearly, it never became reality. 😢
STHU! This has nothing to do with America, or anything we did. This is about radical lslam, and the terrorism always follows it.
That "Department of Peace" is irrelevant against people like Hamas....
It exists several "Peace Institutions" around the world and they haven't avoid any wars...
So scripted very scripted
Stop with your disproportional argument. I’m so glad you weren’t around during the Vietnam war. Plus during the Afghan war and the internet putting the hanging of sadamn Hussein so we could all see it. As a journalist you should remain neutral In private it’s fine but not on the air
it is true that netenyahoo did not care about the hostages when he was carpet bombing it js true ….
Can’t stand Leslie Stahl. She has been a lying pos for years. Haven’t watched… can’t watch 60 minutes for years.
Now, they’ve lost more waiting to be freed. Those poor souls should have had the first priority when it came to this devastation…
sorry but they are telling us third and fourth hand stories, the amount of biasness when it comes to this conflict is staggering.
Sort of amazing that CBS would allow us to see this with their strong bias.
Who cared about PTSD of German civilians in 1945?
branded???
Leslie, retire & let someone with a heart & a brain do your job.
Why hostages don't have access to media?
That's not a very smart question-are you joking?@@eb9720
THE HOSTAGES ARE TRAUMATIZED AND THEY AREN'T HERE FOR YOUR SADISTIC PLEASURE!!
Because if they talk the IDF is fu..
@@dextermoore278No. One of the girls who was kept captive with her dog said in a video that she wasn't truamatized at all. Stop spreading lies.
@@alightinthesky NO. SHE NEVER SAID THAT AT ALL.!!! I SAW THE STORY ON HER. SHE WAS SCARED AND TRAUMATIZED. YOU STOP LYING!!!
Talk about the Palestinians people held as hostages in Israeli prisons men women and children who are suffering abuse from the Israeli prisons guards and what about the 20000 and counting dead Palestinians??? And let the hostages speak for themselves not word by mouth by other people the US media is one sided and the world is watching trauma on both sides of the innocent people
would you talk on TV for the whole world to see if you went through this massacre? so that people from all over the world would laugh at you and call you a liar and ask for proof?
Pretty sure if I was a hostage and told I was being released.... But we have your husband/friend/child/neighbor etc who will pay if you break silence *aka we will find you and all you love* I'd stay quiet too in hope of no retribution for them.
There could b many reasons for choosing silence.
Yet not all of them are. The stories are pouring in.
What about the dead victims of the Israelis.
' War Is A Racket " by USMC General Smedley Butler . 19 pages of the truth of war .
Why has hardly anyone seen this video after a full month? The world doesn't care about the hostages.
Why has hardly anyone seen this video after a ' full month ' . The world doesn't care about the hostages......because the world went into shock on October the 7th.....then they went into mental denial of the horror . They want a rational explanation for irrational acts. They will never get it.
I’m not sure this interview was a good idea, given that the families of detained hostages are already in agony. I think the timing was premature.
That’s true, but at the same time some words need to get out there for people to see it’s not all roses
What "branded" means. Did she say brand? branded?
The released hostages say exactly opposite of what this doctor claims.
no they dont
They gave him permission to talk generally (not identify them by name) about the torture. He can speak they can't. Please be respectful
@@proronen yes they did. One of the ladies said she thought they would abuse her bit they didn't and one of the girls described even arm wrestling with the guards and out of respect to the women he placed a towel over his hand as not to touch her! Conflicting info.
@proronen not one released hostage has testified that they were abused or raped. Doctors and law enforcement have collected NO forensic evidence of rape. No one who experience the attacks of October 7 has testified that they were raped.
Who is the doctor .He seems to be confused with IDF
The news just said shes dead
Hamas started it all.
How were the original hostages saying something completely different, then everyone else thats clearly paid off contradicts them, that weren't hostages. I have never seen so many people speak for the victims. This is pathetic. There are so many lies, everyone keeps getting caught in. No one cares anymore. Please cover something else.
You have lost.
@@janexerikus8021 and no you have lost. Keep believing fake news as trump said
that you for your truth, nice to see that some people have intelligence out there
Truth. Facts. Humanity. Critical thinking. Connection to reality. My respect. You’ve lost so many things.
Because they don't want you to notice the ethnic cleansing taking place in Gaza.
What about Palestinians women and children held in Israeli prisons as hostages?
without the Palestine. Civilians support and help this could not have happened!!
They all are directly and indirectly responsible !!
Lying is a sin. Let them speak for themselves, so it can be believable. It is not part of your job description to speak for them, unless it is a media conference. Have you ever heard of patient's confidentiality?
what you expect from west its a propaganda video
Start your own broadcasting station...then you can tell your truth.
How is patient’s confidentiality broken when the names were never mentioned?
I suspect you want to suppress anything that might make Hamas look bad.
Without lies, Islam dies.
Shame on Leslie Staal and her demeanor and overall tone! Shame! Her attempts at sounding concerned fell flat and disingenuous
I felt the same way. When she interviewed the mom who was held hostage and now released her questions were ridiculous and the hostage looked at her in disbelief on 3 or 4 of the questions and refused to answer.
Gaza in ruins-- just like they did themselves when they got control in 2005.
I once respected Sunday Morning. How can you justify Israel's blatant massacre of 30,000 civilians who had nothing to due with Oct7? Israel massacred over 250 civilians during the year preceding Oct 7. When didn't SM report this? These innocent hostages are compensation of Israel's frequent massacres of tens of thousands of Palestinian civilians. Your reporting on this conflict is complicity
So glad that the hostages weren't harmed more than what is inevitable from being kidnapped..and none of the propaganda from Israel's side turned out to be true
Leslie Stahl -should interview the other side.
Who took them as hostages? Who attacked on Oct 7th. Israel has been wreckless in their overreaction, but it’s worth asking the question would all those
People be alive had Hamas not attacked. Yes they would
60 minutes is a CNN offspring
Is she interviewing him or is she reading a propaganda statement.
So, let's stop supporting war.
The US invasion of Iraq was declared illegal by UN Secretary General Kofi Annan on Sept 15, 2004.
That is totally Un-American!!!
LOL
@@thomasjosullivan9179 Doesn't have to be!
I am Irish and I only say it joking
Maybe I children will know a world where the USA promotes peace.
What will the arms lobby do then....@@PDogB
@@thomasjosullivan9179 It's what our forefathers warned us about. Foreign entanglements.
furthermore, have you heard what Israel does to their male captives? Who do you think trained American forces to go into Iraq
Biased media.
As bad as it is for these hostages, why is the news mostly just showing their suffering? Why is American media ignoring the humongous suffering of civilians in Gaza? Are they less human? Why don't we talk about THEIR humanity?
Who's causing their suffering?
@@73tubsthey are suffering from last 75 years!!! Why u just look at 7th oct.. it doesn't started on 7th oct
"The militant Muslim is the person who beheads the infidel, while the moderate Muslim holds the feet of the victim."
@@73tubs you know who is causing their sufferings, but afraid or embarrass to admit it.
@@evangelinedare6058 there's no embarrassment or fear to state that muslims have brought it upon themselves.
just he says no proof shame on you
Why families of released hosteges are giving interviews instead of themselves?
BMA
There is little for decieving if that's a case!!
Deception = Truth Mixed with Lie!!!
Because they are traumatized and recovering.
@nicolefall1784 did u not hear the woman who went off on the prime Minister
Were they charted?
@@nicolefall1784people that question why they are quiet are sick people hungry to hear gory details and don't care about those held captive. It's a sick world we live in. I prayed for their healing time and love from family and friends.
Horrifying!
Sorry , go Israel
"From 2008 until 6 October 2023, 1,434 Palestinian children were reportedly killed, with an additional 32,175 sustaining injuries, primarily at the hands of Israeli occupation forces. Of these, 1,025 children were killed in Gaza alone, since the unlawful blockade began in 2007." - UN Human Rights, ‘Unchilded’ from birth: UN expert calls for decisive protection of Palestinian children under Israeli rule, 24 October 2023
May haShem bring geula and shalom through Yeshua haMashiach!