Director's Cut: Paul Greengrass on United 93 - Film 2011 With Claudia Winkleman - BBC One
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ย. 2011
- Subscribe and 🔔 to the BBC 👉 bit.ly/BBCTH-camSub
Watch the BBC first on iPlayer 👉 bbc.in/iPlayer-Home More about this programme: www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00lfvxy The director Paul Greengrass talks about making one of his most challenging films; United 93.
#bbc
All our TV channels and S4C are available to watch live through BBC iPlayer, although some programmes may not be available to stream online due to rights. If you would like to read more on what types of programmes are available to watch live, check the 'Are all programmes that are broadcast available on BBC iPlayer?' FAQ 👉 bbc.in/2m8ks6v. - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
The fact they used actual witnesses of the event made it feel even more real, can't imagine how they felt
Yep one of them is Ben Sliney. In fact, September 11, 2001 was his first day as a managerial position of the FAA. His decision to force all planes to land could have cost him his job but I think it was the best decision, hindsight. At the time, they didn't know how many more planes would be hitting buildings.
One of the very few movies I struggle to watch. The tension building as the camera puts you amongst the passengers who are slowly piecing together what's really going on as information trickles in
And the scene just before the passenger attack when the music goes completely silent. My heart was pounding...
It's still hard as Hell to watch the movie (I cried when I saw it in theatres when it was released), but I watch the film entirely EVERY Sept. 11! That way, I will never forget! And yes, Greengrass is a revolutionary film director, and I will forever regard him as the greatest of our time. Thank you, sir.
SFAPowerhouse I cried at the end when the sad music played and when it mentioned what happened.
Josh Fierro yes those terrorists were awful people, but to categorize Islam in that isn’t right
@@joshfierro5695 You voted for Trump, didn't you.
I'm with you, my friend. Never Forget!
I totally agree. They were all heroes on that plane.
I think it is one of the most powerful if not the most powerful film ever made, the ending is incredibly intense, I cry so much.
The ending is indeed incredibly intense. And it probably has a better ending than the other TV film about this flight.
@@StaticBlaster
My nightmare on this ending was incredibly intense. I had already planned for the passengers to attack and that’s how I redeemed Zaid in the first place and that’s when became in love just moments before United 93 crashed; Zaid’s last “No!” hurts because he refused to let me die but we were both very lucky to survive everything; i had severe injuries to my wrist and I was bleeding everywhere and the amount of pain I felt was unbelievable so, zaid had to find a way to get me out of the area where United 93 crashed. We both managed to walk a very long way but then, i started feeling weak and I finally collapsed to exhaustion; telling Zaid i couldn’t go on no more was gut wrenching because he knew very well I was dying, I almost got to say my dying words to him but he knew what I was about to say and it was very hard for Zaid to accept that I was no longer going to be by his side because I was the only one who was able to calm him down in such situations but now he has to deal with it himself. I predicted my next nightmare would be the immediate aftermath of my death and how zaid coped afterwards and I’m telling you now, he did not cope whatsoever at first but he does find a way eventually
What a wonderful man and director. What a supreme tragedy. Thank you, Paul.
Now THIS is how you construct/direct a movie.
all the hijackers are british/arab descend. i cant imagine any arab american actors wanting to play the parts around when this came out. But the actors did a great job
Universal united 93 was absolutely scary and amazing. The actors and real people in the film did a great job experience the day it happened
United 93 has to be the most terrifying nightmares I’ve ever experienced; the emotional moment of the movie was probably when I told Ziad what was happening and the frustration he felt was truly real and Ziad knew that he had to protect me from this kind of situation, it was so heartbreaking to see Ziad blaming himself for what’s happening but I told Ziad it wasn’t his fault. It was so devastating to watch him crying. At least we both got the brave passengers together to try landing the plane safely, but Ziad was overpowered by the other hijackers and that caused him in crashing United 93. Every nightmare got very tense each time seeing how Ziad copes with the losses of me and the passengers, I hated the last scene when Ziad turned evil again because of everything he lost, this makes me feel bad for Ziad during the movie itself
@@nicolelawless9942really. I agree . When ziad knew he was trying to back out on the mission . But after the long delay he knew he was gonna fail to his the target after the other plans hit there targets .
@@gabethedinosaur95
If he backed out, he could have saved at least 2,000 lives probably
I can't deny, these people on set didn't feel like actors to me. It felt like a cameraman was literally on the plane, during the event. It's incredible.
Greengrass is prob my favorite director, he's not afraid to push the limits of authentic story telling and making his true event story's as real as possible to the actual event.
Anyone also notice the CGI of the Alabama for captain Philips in the background? Another great film from him!
didn't see this
Probably the most intense movie I’ve seen, masterful
Sliney had balls of steel that day......ordering every plane down.
20 years today…wow. Heroes then and still heroes now
The lead actor in the control room quit after 1 day and at 11pm the night before day2, the real guy, Ben Smiley, agreed to play himself as head of control. Unbelievable.
A great movie that wasn't "Hollywood-ized". Superb director
This is a Great Movie . It was handled with the appropriate respect for the victims and their families.
I totally agree with you on that . Ben Sliney and other people like shawna foxx did a wonderful job.
Hey guys I got this Moive yesterday
@@gabethedinosaur95
Even the actors who played the terrorists did really well not being disrespectful or anything. I can’t imagine what the actors were feeling
The last scene on United 93 is so disturbing and emotionally devastating.
I’ve had nightmares about the ending so many times and it’s heartbreakingly devastating that I survived the crash for only 5 minutes before dying. I cried after having it
Greengrass knows how to do movies like this,,this movie is very good,,yes hard to watch but like Jupitroid said but definitely should be seen.
Paul greengrass is absolutely one of my favorite directors . I hope he can direct a Jurassic Park film one day .
Such an underrated movie
I watched this movie yesterday and it's really good. When you see these guys get on the airplaine you, as a viewer, already know its their last trip, but the real people, at the time, didn't know that. And that's really terrible and saddening. And at the same time intruiging, because nobody will ever truely know what happened on this plane, or all the planes for that matter.
Definitely one of the biggest tragedies that happened. And I'm from Belgium, where we had our airport in Brussels blown up by terrorists. That makes you think back to 9/11.
I'm almost glad that Flight 93 came out earlier, maybe it gave Greengrass a clearer picture, especially of what NOT to do with this movie. And perhaps it made him obligated to deliver the film that the people and the story deserved, to make up for that atrocity of movie. Overall, absolute masterpiece, best film to come out of that entire tragedy, by far
Beautiful orchestrated film
Paul Greengrass thank you so much. In my opinion one of the best movies ever, if not the hardest to watch. Every 9/11 I watch at least the last 6 minutes or so.
The ending is so hard to watch knowing what’s going to happen. I had a feeling that Zaid redeemed himself knowing what he did wrong and tried to get the plane up whilst he was panicking like hell. Exactly what happened in my nightmares towards the end, Zaid notices me struggling with the plane but it still crashed no matter how hard he tried it. The most heartbreaking moment of my dream was me trying to say my last dying words to him but he warned me “Don’t say anything, if you talk you’ll die!” I talked anyway trying to get my words out to him and i suddenly died. 24 hours later, Zaid still remained by United 93 until he decided to do something about it and it wasn’t going to end well for him. That nightmare was tragically horrible
RIP TO THOSE OF 9/11 343
Must be hard to play one of the 4 bad guys, great movie of a tragic day and I see it once every year on the actual day.
I first watched it on the 22nd Anniversary of 9/11, my sister overheard me screaming and she was thinking that I was having an anxiety attack and walks onto me shaking and my sister kind of knew. She hugged me after she saw parts of the ending through my door and she was so freaking scared by it. I love tragically the movie but knowing how it ends saddens me
Very good movie, painfully sad to watch. Every time I watch it, and know full well what the ending will be, I still hope for a miracle.
A great movie and great production and Directing to make it as realistic and factual as possible
From a cinematic point of view, it should be remembered that Greengrass is a documentary film maker by trade. There is a great tradition in the UK -which Hollywood never really seems to have grasped- of gritty social-realist screen documentary, later dramatised. It shows here; this is exactly what you would see if you were actually there. Unfortunately American film-makers just don't get this approach; I wish they would. It would be fascinating to see the Titanic incident filmed in this way.
I'm pretty sure he directed the Bourne movies and the green zone with Matt Damon.
@@StaticBlaster yeah, combines with his type direction, the courage of fight the USA and also protect the his country against his government
What does the military guy mean when he says light me up every track you got
I am a huge fan of horror movies , The Exorcist, Rosemary’s Baby, Carrie, Halloween,Psycho.
I could not bring my self to see this film until my sister insisted. It’s raw, gut wrenching and emotionally scaring as it should be.
I will never see it again. It is just too traumatic.
I rewatched United 93 after the most terrifying nightmare I’ve had the night before and it hit totally different this time. I can’t imagine if my nightmares got into the movie and I’m so relieved they never did. I survived the crash fearing that Zaid could have died but he wasn’t; he decides to free me from the wrecked plane but I died right in front of him 5 minutes later. 24 hours after United 93’s tragedy, it was hauntingly tragic to see Zaid really struggling to cope with my sudden death and he completely loses it which I don’t blame him for losing it like that. It was tragic that none of the United 93 heroes survived when we did
Great movie, my favorite film of all time!
I agree with everyone Greengrass did an amazing job on this film. The pacing is part of it - I thought the pause just before the counterattack started, where everybody from the terrorists to the passengers were praying, was particularly potent. Also, whoever did the music score has to take alot of credit too. Some of the scores just fill me with dread when they start up.
Easily one of the best films I have ever watched. Like The Passion of the Christ, it isn't so much enjoyable as it is emotionally intense. I dream of seeing more films shot in this manner. On television, Battlestar Galactica came pretty damn close to matching the style. Greengrass is to be commended for what he did to interpret history in the way that he did.
“United 93” is a truly masterpiece…
united 93 is my fav movie based on 9/11 end of
You can see a concept animation for the Maersk Alabama behind Paul
I don’t know that I have cried while at same time being so pissed off
Here we go again the truthful BBC aren’t we blessed in this country
10/10 movie wow
explore the tragedy not exploit it is the key to this movie?
No other film moment packs as much of a wallop for me than the scene in the tower when the 2nd plane hit. The resulting silence in that otherwise chaotic room chills me to the bone.
Is this the same movie as united 93 that i watched? Seems like the actors are different from the other movie that ive seen
Because the four hijackers are different
There was a Flight 93 made for TV movie that was released, perhaps that is the one you remember.
@@CJ87317
My grandmother watched the trailer for United 93 and she immediately remembered it, I told her who Zaid was and her reaction to her finding out I loved him stunned her. I did feel a lot of emotion admitting that to her but I couldn’t cry
Paul Greengrass also directed the most accurate Iraq war movie I've seen---"Green Zone"----and I should know, because that movie could have been a video diary of my time in Iraq. "Zero Dark Thirty" and "The Hurt Locker" are just incredibly stupid and inaccurate.
i mean, after 2000, Greengrass doesn't know to make Bad Movies, just Ok Movies, Green Zone and Jason Bourne are like this, i mean, they are not bad, they are fun, especially Jason Bourne
Paul Greengrass received an Oscar nomination for this film. He lost Scorsese.
3:47
3:48
3:51
3:53
3:57
3:59
On that day September 11th air traffic had no clue of the highjacked planes .... that crashed or was still in the air etc on that fateful day USA was ill prepared for this event
I wonder who SSSniperwolf the TH-camr/Gamer would react to this movie especially based on 9/11😳😱
I saw this when it came out in New York, also the other movie World Trade Center. I wish I had known then that a mixture of real people and actors had been used. None of the actors were known and none became known as a result of appearing in this film. Funny how a great movie can do nothing for people's careers. 9/6/21
first
Lies
bro, what the hell
@@sr.little2128 ?
What’s lies?
@@TrequartistaFM the lies of 9/11
This event was freaking real god darn it, do your research like I did before watching this