1883 had to be the hardest series I ever tried to watch. Talk about a roller coaster of emtions it put us through. Impossoible to binge watch that's for sure. I hope 1923 isn't more of the same..lol..
The fact that tate is half Lakota is interesting since he is 7th generation Dutton. They may still have the ranch and the same with the Lakota through tatar
What l don't understand is why the shows didn't start out with. 1883-First 1923-Second Yellowstone -Third. Then maybe 🤔 Us Fans Wouldn't Be So Confused As To Who Is Who In The Dutton Generation? Someone Please Explain This To Us True Fans. Love Them All. Rip Is My Favorite On Yellowstone ❤️. Elsa Was My Favorite On 1883 ♥️. Spencer and Cara is My Favorite On 1923 ♥️.
So, in Yellowstone, “Keep the Wolves Closer”. John says his great grandfather built the main house to keep his family from leaving. But in a 1883 flashback, it shows James dying in a cabin home. In 1923 episodes, Jacob talks about building the house for Claire and the boys, Spencer and John
@@dianelowrey4339 I actually just re-read what I wrote. James would be John’s great great grandfather. But to your response, yes I know that, the tribes leader even said that in 7 generations, the land will go back to the natives. Which would be Tate. But this article is more about the Dutton family lineage. Speculation around who’s John grandfather is. Since some say it’s Jake while others say it’s Spencer. Will we ever find out? Who knows. The series and such seems to of lost its luster with the in fighting of writer and actors.
@@dannermanner5506 It is Jack Dutton (not Jake). Johns father is the son of Jack Dutton who is the son of John Dutton Sr who is the son of James Dutton. It is in their family tree. Yes spencer is the one son of James that survives, but it is also John Dutton Sr's legacy that continues. Look at John Dutton Sr's family tree that alone says that Jack Dutton is John Dutton III's grandfather.
@@seximexi5820 clearly you haven’t watch the series much. Cause I explain what what is said in both Yellowstone and in 1923. Both statements are said which makes everything confusing. In the episode mention, John says his great great grandfather and in 1923, Jacob says he built the house. But at this point, I don’t care anymore. Show/series has lost its appeal.
@@dannermanner5506 I have watched every single episode of all 3 shows actually. Jacob building the house wouldn't be that far off. Jacob is the reason the ranch even survived so building a house for the family instead of living in a small cabin makes plenty of sense to me. James maybe build the cabin but Jacob turned it into a house.
1. James Dutton 1883 2. John Dutton Snr 1923 3. Jack Dutton 1923 4. John Dutton Jnr 5. John Dutton the 3rd (Kevin Costner) 6. Kacey Dutton 7. Tate Dutton (7th Generation) his mom is from Broken Rock - the Native American tribe that will rise up and take Yellowstone back
Exactly. Many believes, that Spencer and Alexandra are John's (Kevin Costner) grandparents. But they have no kids in 1923. That's only 32 years before John Dutton III is born. Spencer and Alexandra having a child who should be John Dutton III's father just doen't add up. Spencer is 2nd generation. John Dutton III is 5th generation. That means that 2 Dutton children has to be born and get children of their own in less than 32 years.
Anyone know which Dutton built the huge house? The house Costner lives in. Is it the same house as in 1923? When was it commissioned/built? That's all I want to know.
Agreed, Spencer is the one that Elsa was speaking of that carries the family into the next century. Jake and Elizabeth will give birth to Patience after she has a miscarriage we saw in season 1
So does one of the Dutton men have a kid with the native woman? If so, that's interesting bc you don't see many storylines including half white half native kids. Last show I watched with that is Walker, Texas Ranger.
I remembering hearing there might be a cousin who comes into play (I think as their explination of bringing in whoever Matthew Maconohee was supposed to play?) but it sounded to be a brother/half brother/cousin to Cosner's character.
In season five episode one Jaime blatantly introduces his father by saying “welcome 5th generation Montanan” to clear up all confusion about who is what generation.
The generations get too confusing, one reason is that Tim McGraw said he was John's great grandfather, and not his great great grandfather in an interview. Too some things point more to Spencer than Jack. In the episode Phantom Pain John told that his grandfather lost his leg. In 1923 we see Jack get his leg caught under his horse, then we see Spencer talk about his broken leg in the war scene, and later his leg is trapped under the lion he kills. Who knows for sure but it's hard to ignore all the Easter eggs. Lastly I'm starting to wonder if the 7 Generation Principle from the ancient writings (Iroquois) philosophy could be misinterpreted. Native American tribes use the same principles, here's an example from Crazy Horse who said "I see a time of seven generations when all the colors of mankind will gather under the sacred Tree of Life and the whole Earth will become one circle again. In that day there will be those among the Lakota who will carry knowledge and understanding of unity among all living things, and the young white ones will come to those of my people and ask for this wisdom. I salute the light within your eyes where the whole Universe dwells. For when you are that center within you and I am that place within me, we shall be as one.” Idk what to believe but I think it keeps people interested in the shows.
Wait, we gonna do a prophecy like GoT? In 1883, they said the Native American people would reclaim the land. So Tate taking over the ranch might fulfill that prophecy
@@brianmcmurter4415 Emma is John Sr's wife, she kills herself in 1923 after he's killed by Banner Creighton. Margaret Dutton dies in a snowbank in 1894, who's the wife of James Dutton.
@@brianmcmurter4415 There's a lot of characters throughout the Yellowstone universe (1883/1923/Yellowstone) , it's very easy to mis-remember a name. A typo...
Who are your favorite Duttons?
Beth Dutton Beth’s father John Dutton and Spencer and Elsa was awesome
Elsa
Kacee
John (Beth’s Dad), Elsa, and Elsa’s dad. Rip also, but he’s not a Dutton.
1883 had to be the hardest series I ever tried to watch. Talk about a roller coaster of emtions it put us through. Impossoible to binge watch that's for sure. I hope 1923 isn't more of the same..lol..
The fact that tate is half Lakota is interesting since he is 7th generation Dutton. They may still have the ranch and the same with the Lakota through tatar
Just a theory but if tate becomes the owner of the ranch doesn't that mean the native take the land back because he is half native.
A continuation of James and Margaret Dutton would have been cool. Instead of little clips
What l don't understand is why the shows didn't start out with.
1883-First
1923-Second
Yellowstone -Third.
Then maybe 🤔 Us Fans Wouldn't Be So Confused As To Who Is Who In The Dutton Generation?
Someone Please Explain This To Us True Fans.
Love Them All.
Rip Is My Favorite On Yellowstone ❤️.
Elsa Was My Favorite On 1883 ♥️.
Spencer and Cara is My Favorite On 1923 ♥️.
Yes they should’ve started in that format lol would’ve Been less confusing
You r so right, so confusing wish they did it like you said. I want more story. And Yellowstone ending was awful.. disappointed
I have so many things to say. I need a support group for the Yellowston universe
@@rmile1980the second half of season 5 is yet to come
So, in Yellowstone, “Keep the Wolves Closer”. John says his great grandfather built the main house to keep his family from leaving. But in a 1883 flashback, it shows James dying in a cabin home. In 1923 episodes, Jacob talks about building the house for Claire and the boys, Spencer and John
Remember kacey Dutton ‘s wife is of the tribe that gave the land to them‼️
@@dianelowrey4339 I actually just re-read what I wrote. James would be John’s great great grandfather. But to your response, yes I know that, the tribes leader even said that in 7 generations, the land will go back to the natives. Which would be Tate. But this article is more about the Dutton family lineage. Speculation around who’s John grandfather is. Since some say it’s Jake while others say it’s Spencer. Will we ever find out? Who knows. The series and such seems to of lost its luster with the in fighting of writer and actors.
@@dannermanner5506 It is Jack Dutton (not Jake). Johns father is the son of Jack Dutton who is the son of John Dutton Sr who is the son of James Dutton. It is in their family tree. Yes spencer is the one son of James that survives, but it is also John Dutton Sr's legacy that continues. Look at John Dutton Sr's family tree that alone says that Jack Dutton is John Dutton III's grandfather.
@@seximexi5820 clearly you haven’t watch the series much. Cause I explain what what is said in both Yellowstone and in 1923. Both statements are said which makes everything confusing. In the episode mention, John says his great great grandfather and in 1923, Jacob says he built the house. But at this point, I don’t care anymore. Show/series has lost its appeal.
@@dannermanner5506 I have watched every single episode of all 3 shows actually. Jacob building the house wouldn't be that far off. Jacob is the reason the ranch even survived so building a house for the family instead of living in a small cabin makes plenty of sense to me. James maybe build the cabin but Jacob turned it into a house.
1. James Dutton 1883
2. John Dutton Snr 1923
3. Jack Dutton 1923
4. John Dutton Jnr
5. John Dutton the 3rd (Kevin Costner)
6. Kacey Dutton
7. Tate Dutton (7th Generation) his mom is from Broken Rock - the Native American tribe that will rise up and take Yellowstone back
Exactly. Many believes, that Spencer and Alexandra are John's (Kevin Costner) grandparents. But they have no kids in 1923. That's only 32 years before John Dutton III is born. Spencer and Alexandra having a child who should be John Dutton III's father just doen't add up. Spencer is 2nd generation. John Dutton III is 5th generation. That means that 2 Dutton children has to be born and get children of their own in less than 32 years.
Hurry up 1923cant wait love Spencer
Anyone know which Dutton built the huge house? The house Costner lives in. Is it the same house as in 1923? When was it commissioned/built? That's all I want to know.
This video doesn’t explain anything it’s just your opinion and proves that you haven’t paid attention or watch half the show lol
Agreed, Spencer is the one that Elsa was speaking of that carries the family into the next century. Jake and Elizabeth will give birth to Patience after she has a miscarriage we saw in season 1
@@Notarobot310 Spencer’s mustache is a dead give away that he’s where modern day John Dutton comes from
@@jordancrumpton5285I’m pretty sure spencer never had children. John is from the offspring of Jack
We shall see if it ever comes back lol
You didn’t think Looper would actually spend time researching any other their topics beyond the surface level did you.😂
So does one of the Dutton men have a kid with the native woman? If so, that's interesting bc you don't see many storylines including half white half native kids. Last show I watched with that is Walker, Texas Ranger.
yes
I think she's the ancestor of one of the Native characters on the present-day show.
😂oh yes this movie is awesome it's a MUST WATCH I LOVE EVERY EPISODE HE is explaining it very well❤
I remembering hearing there might be a cousin who comes into play (I think as their explination of bringing in whoever Matthew Maconohee was supposed to play?) but it sounded to be a brother/half brother/cousin to Cosner's character.
Please someone tall me in which season is the seane on 0:57 10 years later
In season five episode one Jaime blatantly introduces his father by saying “welcome 5th generation Montanan” to clear up all confusion about who is what generation.
"To her husband's brother Jacob" Margaret's brother inlaw to lead the Dutton's ranch. And when he got there... have fun!
3:41 you call Jack 'Cara's grandson.' Nope. Jack is Cara's grand nephew, not her grandson. Correct?
I heard Spencer had a baby boy and they named him Dabney Coleman. How does that work with your tree?
I thought JD3 said he was a 5th generation, not 6th.
You know, continuity is not really a strong suit with this franchise.
The generations get too confusing, one reason is that Tim McGraw said he was John's great grandfather, and not his great great grandfather in an interview. Too some things point more to Spencer than Jack. In the episode Phantom Pain John told that his grandfather lost his leg. In 1923 we see Jack get his leg caught under his horse, then we see Spencer talk about his broken leg in the war scene, and later his leg is trapped under the lion he kills. Who knows for sure but it's hard to ignore all the Easter eggs.
Lastly I'm starting to wonder if the 7 Generation Principle from the ancient writings (Iroquois) philosophy could be misinterpreted. Native American tribes use the same principles, here's an example from Crazy Horse who said "I see a time of seven generations when all the colors of mankind will gather under the sacred Tree of Life and the whole Earth will become one circle again. In that day there will be those among the Lakota who will carry knowledge and understanding of unity among all living things, and the young white ones will come to those of my people and ask for this wisdom. I salute the light within your eyes where the whole Universe dwells. For when you are that center within you and I am that place within me, we shall be as one.”
Idk what to believe but I think it keeps people interested in the shows.
@@southerncross5360 Leaving that aside, last I checked, everybody has two grandfathers. He could mean the one in England. ;)
I guess you have to know when John ll was born exactly
Wait, we gonna do a prophecy like GoT?
In 1883, they said the Native American people would reclaim the land. So Tate taking over the ranch might fulfill that prophecy
Suurepärane seriaal. Taylor Sheridan on geenius!
In which episode and which one of the Duttons first came up with the concept of fascism?
I'm more confused now.
Why you up so early?
John and Emma are both now dead , John was killed in the ambush by the Sheep famers and Emma took her life because she couldn't live without her John.
Emma died in a snowbank have you not been watching the series, Elsa was narrating the beginning of 1923, you should watch 1923!
@@brianmcmurter4415 That’s margaret, youre speaking about, you fool. Make sure of what youre saying before accusing somebody that theyre wrong
@@brianmcmurter4415 Emma is John Sr's wife, she kills herself in 1923 after he's killed by Banner Creighton. Margaret Dutton dies in a snowbank in 1894, who's the wife of James Dutton.
@@curtisslove you're very right 👍 I was wrong, thank you for correcting me I should have known that because I watch the series 😊
@@brianmcmurter4415 There's a lot of characters throughout the Yellowstone universe (1883/1923/Yellowstone) , it's very easy to mis-remember a name. A typo...
...Dutton family mission fails everytime.... When at the ranch.
how confusing!!!
Country bumkins with guns... I'll pass