Now this is when Emily being mad works, it will not work if she was like bossy and always shouts at other engines, but if she was mad when the other engines does shit and stuff, then it would 100% work. Also love the motherly figure that she has here too.
She actually got mad at Donald and Douglas in the episode "Emily in the middle" after a piece of coal turned into a giant snowball that knocked her off the rails. And when Donald and Douglas kept blaming eachother, she blew her whistle very loudly and started shouting at them
@@WonderfulWoodenRailwayofficial No, he's right. Just putting up an example. Also, the CGI series continues from the model series in the same show and references some classic episode events thus same canon despite differences.
"I am not rolling my eyes! This is rolling my eyes! (begins to spin them around) See? Oh that made me dizzy." XD! Now this is how HiT era Emily should've been instead of being this typical bossy type character. This is well thought out and her and Thomas' heartfelt talk is very wholesome. Indeed, there are some steam engines who can be just as bad as diesels, even our main heroes too on this side of the conflict.
Boco and Daisy are just sitting on a sideline thinking 'You know, WE can help, right?' But nice talk with Emily and Thomas, and I love the wind rushing throughout. Really helps build the atmosphere.
What I love about this is how Emily's S8 personality works in helping Thomas to understand what he has done. Emily being cross and scolding Thomas for his actions helps to make the scene work. This really could have worked in the Special :D .
Fantastic video. This is tied as my favourite of the Re-Shorts along side “All Work and No Railway.” I like Emily’s characterisation in this rewrite. This is what they should of written her in the official movie. I also like that you gave her a Scottish accent like she had in the UK.
I like Emily in the HiT Era for the most part, but this is so much better. It’s a good thing that I asked for a wooden Emily for Christmas, so I can do a remake of this lovely short. I genuinely can’t wait to see what the next short is like.
You managed to bring out the best qualities of Emily in this little scene. Emily can often be frank, but still be kind and understanding- like a big sister figure to Thomas. Brilliant work on this reimagining!
There's the Emily we know and love in Series 7 with that stern personality shown since "Salty's Story Tale", one of the few rare examples of mixing Michael Brandon's narration with Mike O'Donnell and Junior Campbell's music!
Well lucky I found most of these US Season 7 episodes in classic material with 98% audio, right here: th-cam.com/play/PLV4A7G4mVBxsgn3YFpfBcG8gwQCYbhy-y.html&si=XKUvn-1NboPu8SQY
Can’t wait to see the part where the meeting takes place and the part where James gets told off for his trick on Diesel causing this mess the whole time. Keep it up mate!
Combining Emily's S7 and HiT era personas makes for the best portrayal of her character, in my opinion. It also works with her basis; the Stirling Singles were express engines and Emily was built in 1895, making her 1 year older than Edward. Combine the pride and confidence of an important express engine like Gordon with the wisdom and experience of an Edward, and you've got a very unique character. Really liked your "Calling All Engines!" rewrite and these clips are a lot of fun. It's too bad the show's ownership couldn't be transferred to Thomas and Friends TH-camrs; the show's quality would instantly improve LOL
Which one? There are multiple movies released in 2019 that featured birds such as _Spies in Disguise_ and _Angry Birds 2_ , both of which I didn't even know they were released in that year.
@@1685Violin The Angry Birds Movie 2… I have gone on and on about why I hate The Angry Birds Movie 2 and why it’s the worst piece of Angry Birds Media ever
@@PlayDontPause Imagine a movie releasing on an Anniversary Year for a series… only for that same movie to disrespect the source and have its villain suddenly “redeem” herself out of nowhere
@@PlayDontPause I rant about that movie too much for my own good to be honest. But that film still makes me mad. My feelings on it are basically how a majority of Thomas fans see the Miller Era, with how the characters are portrayed
I feel like I’m relating to Thomas here. I’ve been in this situation before. Any chance we can still have that dream where Thomas sees Lady and Rusty? It could still add motivation to Thomas’s plan.
Also giving the style of your takes on these scenes i like to think that all the thomas specials/movies beyond TATMR wouldn't of had any narration just character dialogue I'd also like how in your version that Thomas redem's himself by seeking help while James learns on his own even tho James later got in into trouble with the other engines he didn't got into with the fat controller this time its a nice of pace for his character (personally i prefer if he and thomas situations were the other way around) good job luke im locking forward to more of your takes on your version of calling all engines.👍
Now, I don't mind Emily's Season 8 persona (As it gives her more leads), but I will admit that this is really good! Edit: Your Thomas voice reminds of Ten Cents.
This is undoubtedly the best short for me! 10/10! This is how you make Emily IN character. And if you ask me, Emily’s bossy behavior isn’t really frustrating in my opinion.
Hey Luke, I wanted to say that your videos have helped me get through some rough times (lost my secondary TH-cam channel as it was falsely terminated and other things) I've been during this year and I appreciate it greatly! Thought I'd let you know. Keep it up man! ❤
Emily was like Thomas I..I didn't mean to yell at you Thomas was like no no it's okay I deserve that sidlers and ashes what have I done I messed it all up Emily was like hey hey it's alright Thomas clam down
Thomas was like I..I don't want to lose you Emily you are the adorable green tank engine I ever met said Thomas was puffing away from her Emily was like Thomas I love you too Thomas Thomas was like really you love me
Thomas was like cinders and ashes what have I done I.. I'm sorry for being mean to you Emily it's just that..I don't want to lose you I'm very afraid that I might lose you said Thomas gets even scared of losing his friend Emily was like Thomas calm down I'm not going to be dead I'm here for you when you need me
2:07 I can defiantly imagine this scene playing out in a similar way to one of the scenes from Zootopia like this. Thomas: No Emily your right, I was ignorant, I was selfish and down right pesky. Diesel, Arry and Bert shouldn't have to suffer from my pranks that have pulled and when we finish building the airport they can hate me all they want. (Sobbing) And that'll be fine because I have been a horrible engine and they can leave knowing they were right all along, I really am just a silly steamie!
Not a full version no It's not that I'm against the idea, I just know writing something to that extent would be so daunting and might take the fun out of it
Well i had a feeling that you would do this scene i said it once before and l'l say it again your version of CAE is definitely better than the original however i think Thomas was a bit out of character here why would he have a prejudice for diesels he trusts Diesels like Rusty Daisy Mavis overall your take on this story was pretty good.
Hate to be brutally honest here but Your take on scene with Thomas and Emily is slightly better than how the original handled it. Emily is depicted perfectly in this short. Her being bossy and stern comes from the engines doing stupid shit. But the only the problem that frustrates me just like some people’s fan content, is Thomas regressing as a character by going back to his S1 personality as a regressed child. Also why does he have one of Percy’s traits of questioning words with high vocabulary? This is just my opinion. This is your take and l have no right to dictate what you do. Decent job by the way. Keep up the good work.
@@talenbrigham1684 l mostly agree on Oliver. Him having animosity towards diesels actually make sense since he had to escape the Mainland and search for a new home in order to not to withdrawn for scrap just to make way for diesel locomotives during Modernisation
Now this is when Emily being mad works, it will not work if she was like bossy and always shouts at other engines, but if she was mad when the other engines does shit and stuff, then it would 100% work. Also love the motherly figure that she has here too.
She actually got mad at Donald and Douglas in the episode "Emily in the middle" after a piece of coal turned into a giant snowball that knocked her off the rails. And when Donald and Douglas kept blaming eachother, she blew her whistle very loudly and started shouting at them
@@ritchiesiepman5511thats the cgi cannon, there’s a difference
@@WonderfulWoodenRailwayofficial No, he's right. Just putting up an example. Also, the CGI series continues from the model series in the same show and references some classic episode events thus same canon despite differences.
Emily being kind and caring but sometimes bossy and stern. Keyword: sometimes.
Well done, sounds like something from the Railway Series.
"I am not rolling my eyes! This is rolling my eyes! (begins to spin them around) See? Oh that made me dizzy." XD!
Now this is how HiT era Emily should've been instead of being this typical bossy type character. This is well thought out and her and Thomas' heartfelt talk is very wholesome. Indeed, there are some steam engines who can be just as bad as diesels, even our main heroes too on this side of the conflict.
Thomas rolling his eyes was funny
Now this, this is how you make strict Emily work!
How Emily should be characterised her season 7 and 8 personality
This is actually accurate Emily in her season, seven personality, talking down to Thomas for being naughty
This conversation is brilliant. It would go very nicely for a full scripted remake.
This is how Emily should’ve been like 100% as before, her conversation with Thomas is very meaningful! You did it again, great job dude!
Boco and Daisy are just sitting on a sideline thinking 'You know, WE can help, right?' But nice talk with Emily and Thomas, and I love the wind rushing throughout. Really helps build the atmosphere.
What I love about this is how Emily's S8 personality works in helping Thomas to understand what he has done. Emily being cross and scolding Thomas for his actions helps to make the scene work. This really could have worked in the Special :D .
This was great! I love how you incorporated Emilys S7 motherly side along with her HiT era side. If only the show did it like this
Emily is incredible here. Your voice-acting for her is so damn good.
Fantastic video. This is tied as my favourite of the Re-Shorts along side “All Work and No Railway.”
I like Emily’s characterisation in this rewrite. This is what they should of written her in the official movie. I also like that you gave her a Scottish accent like she had in the UK.
I like Emily in the HiT Era for the most part, but this is so much better. It’s a good thing that I asked for a wooden Emily for Christmas, so I can do a remake of this lovely short. I genuinely can’t wait to see what the next short is like.
This is amazing!!!!!
I love the fact that Emily acts like the motherly figure from S7
I love the fact that she feels sorry about raising her voice
In my mind she’s more of like a girlfriend to Thomas
Wow, very impressive. I'm glad Thomas got scolded for paying 'Arry and Bert back!
You managed to bring out the best qualities of Emily in this little scene. Emily can often be frank, but still be kind and understanding- like a big sister figure to Thomas. Brilliant work on this reimagining!
She’s more of a girlfriend figure to Thomas in my mind
But I respect your opinion as well as my own
There's the Emily we know and love in Series 7 with that stern personality shown since "Salty's Story Tale", one of the few rare examples of mixing Michael Brandon's narration with Mike O'Donnell and Junior Campbell's music!
Well lucky I found most of these US Season 7 episodes in classic material with 98% audio, right here: th-cam.com/play/PLV4A7G4mVBxsgn3YFpfBcG8gwQCYbhy-y.html&si=XKUvn-1NboPu8SQY
Which actually works quite well
Now if Emily was written like this (the way HIT probably meant to write her), then I would've liked her more.
And in the CGI series.
Thomas could’ve lashed out at Emily since she was mean to him and the railway series sheds a.k.a. the original station shed
I like how you made Emily’s bossy character and Series 7 motherly figure work well together. Sh does remind me a little of Marge Simpson.
As opposed to Lucy Van Pelt?
@@1685Violin Yes
forgot to add the "e" in "she".
Honestly this works so much better than the original
The Series 10 review can wait until 2024.
Just give us more of that CAE Remagining!
That was good! I could see Emily as the mother figure, and I love the conversation.
Can’t wait to see the part where the meeting takes place and the part where James gets told off for his trick on Diesel causing this mess the whole time. Keep it up mate!
I love how Emily is like Thomas's mother figure
or a big sister you could say
to me she's basically his girlfriend
@@pikachuthebananasplit9061 WTF
@@pikachuthebananasplit9061It Would’ve Worked For Lady
Thomas’s Relationship With Emily Is A Brother/Sister Thing.
@@calebanderson4155 not in my mind.
but I respect your opinion
1:00 That sound Thomas made was funny 🤣🤣🤣
I just love the fact that the video was released on my birthday. Thank you Luke!.
Combining Emily's S7 and HiT era personas makes for the best portrayal of her character, in my opinion. It also works with her basis; the Stirling Singles were express engines and Emily was built in 1895, making her 1 year older than Edward. Combine the pride and confidence of an important express engine like Gordon with the wisdom and experience of an Edward, and you've got a very unique character.
Really liked your "Calling All Engines!" rewrite and these clips are a lot of fun. It's too bad the show's ownership couldn't be transferred to Thomas and Friends TH-camrs; the show's quality would instantly improve LOL
Emily, Thomas deserved it. At least you’re giving Thomas a proper redemption arc… unlike a certain 2019 movie about agitatied birds that I won’t name
Which one? There are multiple movies released in 2019 that featured birds such as _Spies in Disguise_ and _Angry Birds 2_ , both of which I didn't even know they were released in that year.
@@1685Violin The Angry Birds Movie 2… I have gone on and on about why I hate The Angry Birds Movie 2 and why it’s the worst piece of Angry Birds Media ever
My man is still angry about Angry Birds.
@@PlayDontPause Imagine a movie releasing on an Anniversary Year for a series… only for that same movie to disrespect the source and have its villain suddenly “redeem” herself out of nowhere
@@PlayDontPause I rant about that movie too much for my own good to be honest. But that film still makes me mad. My feelings on it are basically how a majority of Thomas fans see the Miller Era, with how the characters are portrayed
THIS IS THE EMILY I ADMIRE BRAVO
I feel like I’m relating to Thomas here. I’ve been in this situation before. Any chance we can still have that dream where Thomas sees Lady and Rusty? It could still add motivation to Thomas’s plan.
Also giving the style of your takes on these scenes i like to think that all the thomas specials/movies beyond TATMR wouldn't of had any narration just character dialogue I'd also like how in your version that Thomas redem's himself by seeking help while James learns on his own even tho James later got in into trouble with the other engines he didn't got into with the fat controller this time its a nice of pace for his character (personally i prefer if he and thomas situations were the other way around) good job luke im locking forward to more of your takes on your version of calling all engines.👍
Now, I don't mind Emily's Season 8 persona (As it gives her more leads), but I will admit that this is really good!
Edit: Your Thomas voice reminds of Ten Cents.
This is undoubtedly the best short for me! 10/10! This is how you make Emily IN character. And if you ask me, Emily’s bossy behavior isn’t really frustrating in my opinion.
Beautiful we need like ba full feature of this
Hey Luke, I wanted to say that your videos have helped me get through some rough times (lost my secondary TH-cam channel as it was falsely terminated and other things) I've been during this year and I appreciate it greatly!
Thought I'd let you know. Keep it up man! ❤
Great videos🎉❤
Emily was like Thomas I..I didn't mean to yell at you Thomas was like no no it's okay I deserve that sidlers and ashes what have I done I messed it all up Emily was like hey hey it's alright Thomas clam down
Now. This is perfect!
Thomas was like I..I don't want to lose you Emily you are the adorable green tank engine I ever met said Thomas was puffing away from her Emily was like Thomas I love you too Thomas Thomas was like really you love me
imagine if james was the main character in calling all engines instead of thomas.
This is HiT Era Emily done right!
Thomas was like cinders and ashes what have I done I.. I'm sorry for being mean to you Emily it's just that..I don't want to lose you I'm very afraid that I might lose you said Thomas gets even scared of losing his friend Emily was like Thomas calm down I'm not going to be dead I'm here for you when you need me
Sweet, I love it
Wholesome
Now If Emily Was Written Like This It Would've Made The Hit Era Less Disliked.
So much better than the original. Great job on this.
In Thomas’ defence he just wanted those Stupid Diesels to behave
This is rolling my eyes! Yeyeyeyeyeyeyeyeye!
"What are your eyes doing?"
"Docking"
*intersteller music blares*
The actual hit era wouldn’t go that stern
Calling all engines trampy and I love trampy so I love this
I think your rewrite of Calling All Engines would work better with James and Duck as the main characters.
2:07
I can defiantly imagine this scene playing out in a similar way to one of the scenes from Zootopia like this.
Thomas: No Emily your right, I was ignorant, I was selfish and down right pesky.
Diesel, Arry and Bert shouldn't have to suffer from my pranks that have pulled and when we finish building the airport they can hate me all they want.
(Sobbing) And that'll be fine because I have been a horrible engine and they can leave knowing they were right all along, I really am just a silly steamie!
Would you be doing a full version of the calling all engine rewrite?
Not a full version no
It's not that I'm against the idea, I just know writing something to that extent would be so daunting and might take the fun out of it
it kinda sucks how you cut the lady dream out of the story that felt like one of the only good scenes the original movie.
When does this take place?
Nice work!! Do you mind if I try using this to voice Emily? Just as practice?
As in you'd adapt this short voicing the characters yourself?
Yeah of course
@@usualblokeluke Thanks!! I just want to practice my Emily voice for creative reasons! Your writing of this is brilliant BTW!
Well i had a feeling that you would do this scene i said it once before and l'l say it again your version of CAE is definitely better than the original however i think Thomas was a bit out of character here why would he have a prejudice for diesels he trusts Diesels like Rusty Daisy Mavis overall your take on this story was pretty good.
What IS copper mice?
A snazzy house ornament
Hate to be brutally honest here but Your take on scene with Thomas and Emily is slightly better than how the original handled it. Emily is depicted perfectly in this short. Her being bossy and stern comes from the engines doing stupid shit. But the only the problem that frustrates me just like some people’s fan content, is Thomas regressing as a character by going back to his S1 personality as a regressed child. Also why does he have one of Percy’s traits of questioning words with high vocabulary? This is just my opinion. This is your take and l have no right to dictate what you do. Decent job by the way. Keep up the good work.
I think Duck or Oliver would've made more sense than Thomas.
@@talenbrigham1684 l mostly agree on Oliver. Him having animosity towards diesels actually make sense since he had to escape the Mainland and search for a new home in order to not to withdrawn for scrap just to make way for diesel locomotives during Modernisation
@@samsea0489yeah I don't think thomas would have anything too much against diesels oliver makes more sense the more I think about it.
is this audio free to use?
It is yes
All I ask is that you credit me in your adaptations
great. thank you
love your take on conversation between this two
0:37