Well I have a few major issues w/the prosecutor's & police theories! Let's start here: 1.) The autopsy stated she was disemboweled. That means at minimum one or more internal organs where physically removed out of her body. If she were disemboweled there's no way for her to stand up or be in any erect position without all of her internal organs falling out onto the floor & blood being literally ALL over the floor from the wine cellar door to where her body initially was found. 2.) The fact that there was no blood in or around the cuticles of her fingernails & not even under the nails is THE #1 proof that she did NOT write that on either door. I think the killer scribbled the 1st note on the boiler room door, trying to make it look as if someone in a dying position had written that & then thought about it & thought "what if the police can't make out what it says?" So the killer wrote it a 2nd time on the wine cellar door making sure this time there would be no guessing as to what it was saying. 3.) I take up issue that the law enforcement, prosecutor, & judge seemed to be hell-bent on pinning this on Omar. Therefore, I have a theory. The fact that the judge gave quick approval for her cremation & the fact that the police had destroyed all the pictures on her camera makes me wonder if the actual killer was not related to the judge or maybe it was the judge himself? Maybe he was married & had been having a secret affair w/her & she wanted him to leave his wife so she threatened exposure of their affair or who knows maybe it was the judge's wife who committed the murder out of jealousy. Either way I find it extremely suspicious that the legal system seemed to make sure somebody's tracks were covered imo. If that wasn't it then I'd have to say it was either the maid/cook or a family member. I agree w/what you said about the past tense form of the wall statement. Why would someone even write so & so killed me while you're still alive? Wouldn't it make better sense to write so & so did this to me? Also it wasn't said if There was another way out of that cave or not. I think There was & that the killer blocked that door hoping it would make the police believe that she had done it herself. There are so many injustices that were done to Omar that you can't hardly wrap your head around it. I feel that there were 2 victims in this murder case, Ghistlaine & Omar imo. Great delivery of this mysterious who done it. I truly enjoy listening to how you cover these stories.
i think you are starting from a pre-judged conclusion and reasoning backward. having said all that, i would have to spend a long long time to make sense of this. i know the official allegations . to be fair to this case, i would need a year of investigation - being onsite and everything. I spent years on " 911 " - the investigation of the true story - not the fairy-tale sold to the world .
Another insane case, where if the police had been more competent, things could have been ruled out or not. Why on earth would they not go in the wine cellar to check things in there, even if it was locked, it could have been full of evidence for all they knew. To not make sure you went to the correct boulangerie too!!!!
only a gen Z would say " one of the most popular cases in France " while describing a brutal murder and possibly a man jailed and convicted wrongly of murder.
1:15:06 In fact it should be "Omar m'a tuée", because the victim is female and it is "Les pronoms compléments d'objet direct", so we would change the ending of the world depend on gender of the object not the subject of the sentence and only in third person (a friend told me that, I don't speak french very well)
You’re almost right! This is definitely a rule in French, but it doesn’t apply to the “auxiliaire avoir”. So if you’re using “have”, you do not apply the feminine gender at the end of the verb. If it’s “be”, then the rule applies :)
@@lindseyolson4 Oh, okay. Thank you for answering. But shouldn't it be "be" because "be" is used when there is the change of state (like wake up, born, die). That's an italian rule so I'm not sure if it applies in this case? Or in french generally?
@@agnieszkanowak5619 to be honest none of the rules in French make any sense, and there are more exceptions than rules anyway 😂 I’m not sure what the reasoning is behind this specific rule, I’m just glad I never had to learn French as a second language
@@lindseyolson4 Yeah, I agree. Anyway your video is really detailed and I learnt many new things from it. And it's a huge advantage that you know french and because of that I think/rely on that these information you said aretaken from french webpages and not just "lost in translation" english, where I found some mistakes. And I cannot really use french webpages because I don't really understand it and there is you making french information in english. Perfect :D
Your video format is fantastic! You have a great way of presenting and talking about things. Keep up the great work!
I particularly liked your comparison/contrast of this case with that of Orinthal Simpson!
Well I have a few major issues w/the prosecutor's & police theories! Let's start here:
1.) The autopsy stated she was disemboweled. That means at minimum one or more internal organs where physically removed out of her body. If she were disemboweled there's no way for her to stand up or be in any erect position without all of her internal organs falling out onto the floor & blood being literally ALL over the floor from the wine cellar door to where her body initially was found.
2.) The fact that there was no blood in or around the cuticles of her fingernails & not even under the nails is THE #1 proof that she did NOT write that on either door.
I think the killer scribbled the 1st note on the boiler room door, trying to make it look as if someone in a dying position had written that & then thought about it & thought "what if the police can't make out what it says?" So the killer wrote it a 2nd time on the wine cellar door making sure this time there would be no guessing as to what it was saying.
3.) I take up issue that the law enforcement, prosecutor, & judge seemed to be hell-bent on pinning this on Omar.
Therefore, I have a theory. The fact that the judge gave quick approval for her cremation & the fact that the police had destroyed all the pictures on her camera makes me wonder if the actual killer was not related to the judge or maybe it was the judge himself? Maybe he was married & had been having a secret affair w/her & she wanted him to leave his wife so she threatened exposure of their affair or who knows maybe it was the judge's wife who committed the murder out of jealousy.
Either way I find it extremely suspicious that the legal system seemed to make sure somebody's tracks were covered imo.
If that wasn't it then I'd have to say it was either the maid/cook or a family member.
I agree w/what you said about the past tense form of the wall statement. Why would someone even write so & so killed me while you're still alive? Wouldn't it make better sense to write so & so did this to me? Also it wasn't said if There was another way out of that cave or not. I think There was & that the killer blocked that door hoping it would make the police believe that she had done it herself. There are so many injustices that were done to Omar that you can't hardly wrap your head around it. I feel that there were 2 victims in this murder case, Ghistlaine & Omar imo.
Great delivery of this mysterious who done it. I truly enjoy listening to how you cover these stories.
i think you are starting from a pre-judged conclusion and reasoning backward. having said all that, i would have to spend a long long time to make sense of this. i know the official allegations . to be fair to this case, i would need a year of investigation - being onsite and everything. I spent years on " 911 " - the investigation of the true story - not the fairy-tale sold to the world .
I am impressed that you speak good English but good French too :) nice story btw.
Another insane case, where if the police had been more competent, things could have been ruled out or not. Why on earth would they not go in the wine cellar to check things in there, even if it was locked, it could have been full of evidence for all they knew. To not make sure you went to the correct boulangerie too!!!!
only a gen Z would say " one of the most popular cases in France " while describing a brutal murder and possibly a man jailed and convicted wrongly of murder.
I could do without trying to live in a country where I cannot speak the language! Sounds like a recipe for trouble!
Haha it’s never too late to learn!
woohoo for more hamster content and 1K subscribers
1:15:06 In fact it should be "Omar m'a tuée", because the victim is female and it is "Les pronoms compléments d'objet direct", so we would change the ending of the world depend on gender of the object not the subject of the sentence and only in third person (a friend told me that, I don't speak french very well)
You’re almost right! This is definitely a rule in French, but it doesn’t apply to the “auxiliaire avoir”. So if you’re using “have”, you do not apply the feminine gender at the end of the verb. If it’s “be”, then the rule applies :)
@@lindseyolson4 Oh, okay. Thank you for answering. But shouldn't it be "be" because "be" is used when there is the change of state (like wake up, born, die). That's an italian rule so I'm not sure if it applies in this case? Or in french generally?
@@agnieszkanowak5619 to be honest none of the rules in French make any sense, and there are more exceptions than rules anyway 😂 I’m not sure what the reasoning is behind this specific rule, I’m just glad I never had to learn French as a second language
@@lindseyolson4 Yeah, I agree. Anyway your video is really detailed and I learnt many new things from it. And it's a huge advantage that you know french and because of that I think/rely on that these information you said aretaken from french webpages and not just "lost in translation" english, where I found some mistakes. And I cannot really use french webpages because I don't really understand it and there is you making french information in english. Perfect :D