But had the conditions on that planet not been so hostile she would have had the highest chance of being rescued of anyone on the Lazarus missions, irrespective of whether her planet could support life or not. The Lazarus missions left Earth ten years before the mission the movie is focused on does, so assuming she spent as much time traveling to her planet as they did then they arrived there about ten years after she did. That's an hour and a half on her planet with the time dilation. Even if she sent a signal of "woops this planet is trash don't come here" she could still have been rescued later on by humans after they colonized a planet that could support life. While the other scientists would have been long dead (assuming their hibernation chamber eventually fails or they run out of resources or something), for her 100 years to an outside observer is about 14 hours on her clock. Even if no one came to rescue her until a millenium had passed it would only be a few days for her. When she was told she'd be sent to a planet with such extreme time dilation she probably thought "I'm getting a pretty sweet deal here". But in retrospect NASA should have known that a planet this close to a black hole wouldn't be able to support life anyway for the reasons Brand mentions after they return from said planet
That has to be one of the saddest deaths, in a way, in movie history. This astronaut, with his suit on, who sacrificed his turn to jump into the craft, is now just rolling around wave after wave...decomposing on an alien world, never to be found or celebrated...for eternity.
@@kuhvn1487 He didn't exactly stare at it like "damn i really like waves, i might be here for a bit" He turned around and was shocked since there's a 4000ft wave about to swallow you in a second.
Because of relativity, his body might be found by the humans colonizing that system. If Cooper informs them that they lost a man on the planet, surely a recovery team will be sent. By the time they get there, he may have only been dead for a little over thirty minutes.
If you want to pretend that she died 5 minutes ago. *_For contexts, 15 minutes here equals 15 months on Earth._* So in other words, the 5 minutes ago here was actually 5 months ago, which was most likely around the time that they were on their way to her planet. Most likely, as they ascended, she passed. Terrifying.
Imagine Doyle survived, yet we see him unconcious. He wakes up on a water covered planet, no sign of the rest of his team who left millenia ago, and no way to survive.
The only thing left to think about then is how to die. Starvation? Or drowning? There's probably a few more options, but I can't think of many with a planet basically consisting of only water.
@@WanderTheNomad That water is basically the opposite of seawater - so sterile there are not even bacteria. Funnily enough, such pure water is also toxic - the body needs some basic minerals that are present in natural water, missing which will cause health issues.
@@JohnsonTheSecond This is way worse than Subnautica's planet mate. No tools, nothing to eat nor drink, no contact with other humans. Just you and constant towering waves slamming into you until you are dead.
Damn this was terrifying. 1. I hated it when Doyle died. He seemed like a cool guy. 2. Just thinking about Miller's situation sends shivers up my spine. Just landed on a lonely planet that seemed nice at first glance, only to notice a huge wave coming. Staring death in the face and you're powerless to do anything to save yourself. And then come to find out she was literally MINUTES away from rescue. My god.
But minutes in her time frame, which isn't the correct one to be counting from. Help would come from the outside, and every "Miller minute" is years. So that's the timescale she's been dead in practice. But it's more shocking to us if we think of it in minutes, because then we feel like it was close to saving her. Which it wasn't at all.
@@benghazi4216 It would take us years to reach her, but those years would be minutes to her. She was only minutes from rescue. Time flow is relative and so she was truly only minutes from rescue while on that planet.
@@Yeshayahu. She had only just died when they got there. Had she held on a few more minutes, they could have possibly saved her. Not sure if she could have fit in the ship, but they could have saved her.
@@score4817 And they only approached Miller’s planet first because she sent out an initial status at all, minutes earlier, yet they’ve been receiving it and registering it and interpreting it and analyzing it for years already. A year or two less of doing all that by launching sooner...barely would’ve made a difference.
She was talking about humans 3rd dimensional She said a 5th dimensional being could possibly see time as a cannon they could climb into and the future a mountain they can climb up.
@@shiznik19 yes, really minutes. You’re the one not getting it. The time on the planet is real, just like the time on earth is real. Time is real. Everywhere.
Since they knew the planet is a water-planet and stands right next to a black hole with enormous gravitational pull, they should have calculated the tides. And they should also have predicted that a civilization cannot be created in a waterworld with cyclic water mountains. So, the rescue mission was a waste of time, resources, and life
They honestly wouldn’t have lost anybody or too much time if she hadn’t insisted on getting the data. It took them seconds to launch off they could’ve dipped fast
Why the hell did they decide to go on a planet first which has an hour of time for 7 years of Earth time?! That decision itself would have doomed Earth if not for the 5D beings.
I agree 100%, given how intelligent these people were and how much they knew about what they were dealing with in regards to time, relativity, physics etc. surely they would've figured out coming to this planet would be pointless and costly and the correct move instead to try the other planet. Bit of a hole in the plot in an otherwise awesome movie.
That's why Cooper says they are less prepared than boy scouts. He's chastised Brand but realizes that he made a stupid mistake too in voting to head to the planet. They talked about the time slippage but only from their own point of view. They didn't think from Miller's angle that it had been about an hour since land and sending out the one brief message. That's why there was no difference in the message or even follow up messages once they realize that was just a recycled loop. Even if Miller was alive, there wouldn't have been much time to gather any data at all and therefore no why at all to know if it was a viable option. If that had been discussed beforehand, I'm certain they would have opted for one of the others first.
This planet was sterile with no life as the characters said. Who else thinks that the crew introduced just enough bacteria to the planet where some form of life will evolve eventually?
Well, not really. There’s not much to do with that planet. Well, imo anyways. They should create a movie on the Lazarus Missions like this one dude(forgot the name, will come back to edit it later) said on another Interstellar video I saw , that’s a good idea. That’s if they want to revisit Interstellar and milk it one more time.
I forgot how hardcore McConaughey goes in his acting. The raw emotion and distress in his gestures and voice is so amazing. Nolan always seems to pull off amazing casting in his films.
Lol guys. For people saying Doyale survived, look at the damage tsunamis we have had in history. Now imagine a wave that reaches the clouds coming at you. Unconscious? Bro this guy died, and then the wave dragged him out of hell and killed him again. Then for good measure fucked him sideways.
Not to _that_ level, she didn't. He's being such a bitch - and he keeps _being_ a bitch to her for a while afterwards, too. I understand him overreacting in the moment, but his spite towards her is completely irrational. Did really no one look at that hot mess of a planet from orbit and go, "Hm, 7 years per hour + too close to a black hole + 130% earth gravity + all water = LOL NOPE sorry Miller we'll build a statue in your honor, see ya"
Hathaway’s acting isn’t good. A good actress would have conveyed some of the anguish that brand is supposed to be feeling rather than just seeming defensive and petulant. This role was honestly the worst possible role for her.
2:08 he’s trying to do everything he can to get the ship started as fast as possible, and in this moment looks like the worst feeling when he realizes all he can really do for right now is sit down and wait
@Knight Light it actually would, compared to pretty much everywhere else, evolution on this planet would take trillions if not quadrillions of years. Think about it, one hour here is 7 years on earth "or other parts of the galaxy", considering that it took some 2 billion years on our planet for life to develop, and assuming things are as lucky here, it'd still be 2 billion years on this planet, where each fucking hour of those years is 7 years everywhere else. The planet, and possibly the entire galaxy would die out long before any life could develop here. This is actually one of my main problems in this movie, why the hell would this planet be considered as even Remotely viable for life, even if humanity makes it there safely and managed to survive and develop, they'll always be stuck with living on that planet and not being able to leave.
No. One human body as opposed to how many waves? Look at just one ocean on earth and imagine the impact one human body or even one whale. Nothing. This planet is way more powerful than every single ocean together
@@liorasitelman1856 He said life, that could be single cell organisms, or small multicell ones, could be like micro floating plants. The sky is blue and there was definetely light similar to the sun's I can see it happening. Why you assume that Whales will happen in that planet?
Did anyone else notice that they needed two booster rockets just to leave Earth but on Miller's planet with "punishing gravity", the ship had engine technology that was able to fly off on its own without any booster assistance?
Someone gave a logical explanation on it on a video on TH-cam I can't remember. But it seemed a plausible explanation. Will comment here if I find it someday.
NASA in the movie probably didn’t have that many resources at their disposal so they used old rocket technology to save on fuel and money and spent most of their money on more advanced technology for the ships the crew of the endurance we’re going to use far from earths help.
@@alejandrop.s.3942 sure but say he has enough oxygen to survive for a day (doubdful but who knows). That's 168 years, and by then Humanity would have far more advanced technology.
@@flisko123 idk, i just enjoy the movie a lot, does it mean i am dumb? ppl be watching same tik tok 20 times does that also mean they dumb? lmfao. you gotta chill bro
The chances of someone finding him would be slim to none but, thousands of years would have passed if not millions by the time someone found or just stumbled across his body. Explorers that have no family may not care about a time lapse as I would assume it could benefit many who travel there. Maybe reanimation might exist by then. There may be hope lol.
It's a factor of 200,000... so Doyle really wouldn't be much different even if someone came for him after a thousand years. Millions, no one would really even remember, let alone care.
3 days on Miller's planet is 504 days to the humans who are right by the wormhole by Saturn that connects to this solar system. They still have a century to colonize their new planet before Doyle's body has been there a single day.
This is interesting. Say Miller stays alive for a couple days, riding the waves as they come and go. The time slippage is 168 years per day. This would mean that, in just two days in Miller's planet, Humanity would have already established a colony on Edmund's planet, with far more advanced technology at their disposal, and may be able to organize a rescue.
Omg this scene is so good. It really just goes to show that time is the ultimate. It knows everything that has happened and everything that will happen relative to whoever is reading this. From times perspective everything that will happen from our perspective has already happened. Makes you think about the quote unquote “afterlife.” If we’re able to move around in the “afterlife” then time knows everything that happens there too. Wild.
So the fact that the planet was orbiting the throat of a 100 million solar mass supermassive black hole (so close, in fact, that Kip Thorne calculated that in order for gravitational time dilation to be this extreme, the black hole would have to be rotating at 99.7% the speed of light just to give the planet a stable orbit) wasn't enough of a red flag, eh? Lol
A major problem with this plan, is that by Romilly staying in the Endurance while it drifts along side Miller planet, while cooper and Brandt go down to Miller planet is that it does not save any time (even if you account for the accident). It is like crossing a road with a slow old lady, or walking past her and waiting for her to catch up to you. It would take the same amount of time. Had the Endurance orbited Miller, rather than staying in a parallel orbit to Gargantua alongside Miller, then Romilly would not have waited 23 years. Everyone on Earth would have waited just the same, but Romilly would not have been by himself for decades. Perhaps being younger would have helped the crew detect and stop Mann's madness.
The Gargantua time shift zone is all around Miller’s planet. Getting in and out of the time shift zone is faster in the Ranger than using the Endurance to go into orbit. Ron sacrifices himself as someone has to stay on the Endurance while the others do in the quickest in and out they can.
@@TruthFreedomStrength They dont, but in an earlier scene, Romily says he's going to stay there to gather all the black hole data, process it and use it for scientifc gains. He stayed to work as going down to the planet was kinda pointless for him when he could stay on the ship and deal with Gargantua's data.
@@Phoenix258 no... That doesn't work, because even after being on the endurance for 23 years waiting for Cooper and Brandt, Romilly says that he couldn't make a breakthrough because there was only so much he could figure out without the quantum data. Sounds like at least some of the time he was alone, was wasted.
So Case says it's going to take 45 mins to an hour to drain the engines. They talk for 5 minutes. Then the wave comes and Case says 1-2 mins then Coop gets the idea of blowing the cabin oxygen out of the thrusters. Just WTF? Did anyone proof read this script?
I wonder if Miller activated her beacon out of shear terror because of the time slippage. She hoped that in the minutes she had before the wave hit she knew that there was the tiniest chance that decades had passed on earth and another expedition could rescue her by then.
Very underrated scene! Thank you for uploading it. It gives a hell of a clue of what's to come. I remember watching this in the cinema and shouting "Gravity" when she says "the only thing that can move across dimensions like time is ..." Then I remembered the books falling off Cooper's daughter library 😲😯 I almost burst to tears
What I don't understand is how they needed a full rocket to get this exact craft to orbit on earth but on Miller's planet which has 130% the gravity of earth they are able to take off and get into orbit with just the lander.
According the interview. The waves are fixed and pulled because the strong gravity. The only one moving in that planet is it’s self. So imagine the planet is rotating while the waves are fixed. That’s scary shit
Something that bugs me about the whole affair with Miller's planet is that the crew (or at the very least Cooper) seemed not to be fully aware of the fact that, due to the extreme time dilation, Miller had just arrived there from her perspective and had been sending data for only an hour at most (assuming she got there 7 years ago in Earth's time). But then again, on board the Endurance they do mention that 'Miller hadn't sent much, but the data was promising'. So I don't know if I'd call this a plothole or not. Perhaps they knew that the data only covered an hour or so but found it promising enough to investigate, but didn't know about the tidal waves and that Miller was dead.
@@NightWanderer31415 by promising, they probably meant that the planet had water. Also they were closer to miller's planet than the other two and they were probably tempted by the existence of water. But yea the should have calculated the supermassive tsunamis
Script writing mistake they like let didn’t catch until they were filming. It’s clear when they are discussing it that they are overlooking that it’s only been an hour or so on millers planet. Especially when you consider that Cooper rules out dr edmunds planet because Edmund stopped transmitting when he would have nonetheless transmitted far more data than Miller had.
Interesting how at 4:40 you can't make out the suit trim colors (olive grey for Endurance vs. red for Lazarus) so you're never quite sure if it is Doyle or Miller floating face down in the water.
so 23 years passed which means they must have been there for a little over 3 hours given the fact that it was 7 years per hour. Yet, case said the engines to drain which would be 45 minutes to an hour. So it took them 2 hours to search, get hit by the wave, and slide down the other side?
The transit down to the planet took about 45 minutes. They searched for about 10, had to wait 45 minutes for the engines to dry, and 45 more minutes to return to the station.
@@Davedio that's only 16 years. I'm just saying they at least should have made a few more scenes to give a timeline so when they returned it made sense
Question, why couldn't they do the air blow thing through the engines to spark them as soon as the wave passed? Why wait and lose precious time for everything to dry off?
@Alexander Solicari But it still doesn't make sense. Every hour was 7 years. If there was another way to get off the planet quicker than waiting for everything to dry then you would think they would exhaust all quicker possibilities first
If Romilly orbited the Miller planet, he would have waited 3 hours and 20 minutes for them. Cooper screwed up with this plan. All that mattered was how long they would be on planet Miller. Romilly situation was irrelevant. But Nolan had to create a drama. I respect this. Brilliant movie.
Dammit, I love the IDEA of this scene but it's so frustrating that they don't mark the passage of time properly! In a sequence where time has huge consequences, how did no one think to make it clearer?? Case says repairs will take 45 to an hour, and then we get approximately 2 minutes of dialogue WITH NO CUTS before the next wave comes. There are no cuts! So either Case is wrong by 43 minutes in his estimate, in which case they are on the planet for a total of less than 10 minutes and the 23 years that pass makes no sense, OR the film lies to us about what we're seeing. If 45 minutes are supposed to pass then cut the scene and transition to 43 minutes later! I just don't get this decision and it undermines all the scientific accuracy that the film is going for. Am I missing something??.
It’s just bad film making. They are clearly interrupted by the robot- even if they didn’t want to do a cut they could have maintained some ambiguity in the passage of time by not panning back to cooper and brand. but they pan back and brand is literally in the same position she was seconds before. The movie would have us believe she held her pouty face for 43 minutes lol. I think what happened is Nolan was hemmed in by the need to create dramatic tension but also the need to make the time dilation on the planet not so extensive that it would have been immediately ruled out by the astronauts. This necessitated playing loose with just how much time was wasted by the “mistake” vs how much time would have been consumed just by the logistics of reaching the planet at all. Even if they “wasted” 45 minutes they trip itself would have taken 130 minutes so yea it sucks but they already lost 14 years just making the trip.
A the end of this scene, who's to say that rather that what we think is the body of Doyle floating in the water, it was ACTUALLY Miller? I say this because Nolan is the kind of director who would put that kind of question in there. We don't see in good detail who the person is floating in the water.
Always found it funny that they needed a rocket to send up the ranger into Earths orbit, but it can just dip out of a planet with even more gravity lol.
@@Blue-wh7mz No, that's not what I mean. The ranger that Coop went up on was on a regular rocket. But the 7 year planet had even more gravity and it just zips out without a booster.
@@newguy3588 Yeah and a planet with gravity that high also has a massive wall of water floating up towards gargantua. Coop flew right along that wave all the way up. If the gravity is strong enough to do that to waves then I’m sure the ship had a little help from gargantua when he left.
Yea, but I'm wondering why they didn't anticipate these complications before even setting out. Given the 7 years per hour time-dilation, it's likely that they could have considered Miller's likely mission status. It means she would have had a mission duration of less than 3 hours before they got there. That's not enough time to make a proper assessment of the planet.
This is definitely a weak spot in the script. But What I can’t figure out is at what point does the time dilation kick in. With the dilation schedule of 1 hour= seven years of earth time the only way for 21 years to have elapsed is for them to have spent 3 hours on millers planet or for the dilation to have also applied while they are traveling to and from millers planet. Conceding that this film isn’t shot in real time but still even with allowances for “movie time” there’s no way they spent three hours there. They likely spent an hour on planet (7 earth years). Which logically means that 14 of those earth hours had to be consumed traveling to and from millers planet. But the scientist that remains thinks they’ll be gone 3 or so years at most his time so clearly the dilation can’t apply to their journey there and back otherwise he’d know they’d be gone for at least 14 years just on the basis of traveling there and back. The movie seems to be implying that the dilation only occurs on the planet itself in which case their travel time wouldn’t be affected but by this logic where did the three hours go.
Time is a projection from consciousness shifting itself through billions and billions of still-3D-frames per sec, thus creating the illusion of movement and change. Movies and animation have had this law since the beginning. Its all just frames per second
1:31-1:40 If y'all want to pretend that she died 5 minutes ago. *_For contexts, 15 minutes here equals [approximately] 15 months on Earth._* So in other words, the 5 minutes ago here was actually 5-6 months ago, which was most likely around the time that they were on their way to her planet. Most likely, as they descended. Terrifying
Time dialation is weird to think about. Think, you are an astronaut, you have the best technology available and you go Millers planet. Not after 5-6 hours later some other ranger appears with tech at least 30 years newer and more advanced. That is just weird. The new astronauts were kids when you left. No one has heard from you, they assumed you were dead. That is just wild to me. And to think about that, while the film is science-fiction the reality actually checks out. We don't know the fact that you would experience time dialation like this, but it is real. That is just amazing and terrifying at the same time
That should be a message for Anna Hathaway too from Miranda Priestley really old on a hospital telling her how dissapointed she is she didnt get her coffee in time
“Time is relative… It can stretch, it can squeeze, but it can’t run backwards.” One of the main issues with this movie is the premise of going back in time, which is what the 5th dimensional humans are doing. They-Dr. Thorne and the writers-actually knew of the paradoxes (e.g., “the grandfather paradox”, where if you go back in time and kill your grandfather, you would cease to exist), and just chose to ignore it to advance the movie’s story. Basically, the future humans are going back in time to create their present and future, which violates the laws of cause and effect. So far as we know, we can go as far into the future as we like, in theory, but we cannot go back in time. The early universe’s low entropy, cause and effect relationships, e.g., effects happening before causes, like “the grandfather paradox”, objects moving before they’re touched, etc. are among some of the main reasons. It would also require an unimaginable amount of energy to do so, possibly equal to the entire amount of energy in the entire universe or more, which just isn’t possible. For 5th dimensional beings, should they exist, time might be, for them, as rudimentary and as easy to understand as 3-dimensional beings looking at 2-dimensional shapes. But we, as we are now, are not 5th dimensional beings, and therefore, are incapable of understanding higher dimensions intuitively. A 3-dimensional person in a 4-dimensional world would not be able to perceive, or perceive very well, time, which is inherently 4-dimensional, in a 3-dimension conception. To look at yourself in a mirror in the 4th dimension, you would see yourself as a long, undulating figure, stretching from your embryonic self, all the way to your dead self. Can’t imagine that? Exactly the point. Now, try to perceive of the 5th dimension? No way. Maybe one day, if we live long enough as a civilization, we may be able to design a 4th dimensional world that’s able to be perceived by our 3-dimensional minds through quantum computing or AI, or by some other methods, or we may evolve so our perception becomes attuned to higher dimensions, or maybe higher order physics are discovered that provide solutions to the paradoxes inherent. But, for what we know right now, and what the evidence points to, is that time is a one-way street.
yes, and while a storyline where he’s unconscious would certainly be cool or more dramatic, the ‘unconscious body’ is far more likely a ‘dead body’ in reality…
Bruhh! If i would given a mission to miller planet, i would fuckin' rush my ass out like i'm on a minute to win it game show 😂😂😂, i don't wanna waste and miss my stuffs on earth like duhhh. Ain't nobody got time for that!
Before they ever think to land. Does not even they can imagine what would be happen with the Miller planet? I mean they can just think like “We have wave because of the moon, what if we have black hole instead?”.
Because they didn't want to waste precious fuel using the Ranger to escape Earth when they could just use multi-stage rockets. Remember the Ranger and Lander were their only modes of transportation in and out of the planets and fuel was a scarce resource that they had to conserve.
@@marcosfloresiii4401 The ranger is very flat and small. i doubt it's fuel tanks could have even a few tonnes of fuel.... There is no goddamn way it's lifting off from a 1.3 g world. Also, it's take off is pretty damn weird too considering were the engines are located.
No one gonna talk about miller she literally died minutes before they arrived it’s scary to think about
Yes, that freaked me out first time I heard it. Very sad.
But had the conditions on that planet not been so hostile she would have had the highest chance of being rescued of anyone on the Lazarus missions, irrespective of whether her planet could support life or not. The Lazarus missions left Earth ten years before the mission the movie is focused on does, so assuming she spent as much time traveling to her planet as they did then they arrived there about ten years after she did. That's an hour and a half on her planet with the time dilation. Even if she sent a signal of "woops this planet is trash don't come here" she could still have been rescued later on by humans after they colonized a planet that could support life. While the other scientists would have been long dead (assuming their hibernation chamber eventually fails or they run out of resources or something), for her 100 years to an outside observer is about 14 hours on her clock. Even if no one came to rescue her until a millenium had passed it would only be a few days for her. When she was told she'd be sent to a planet with such extreme time dilation she probably thought "I'm getting a pretty sweet deal here". But in retrospect NASA should have known that a planet this close to a black hole wouldn't be able to support life anyway for the reasons Brand mentions after they return from said planet
He had life support system, he should be survive
@@blunderbuss9984 yeah yeah yeah gimme a break I made this account when I was like 13, I'm 27 now
@@yomama629 And in 14 years it never occurred to you to change your name?
That has to be one of the saddest deaths, in a way, in movie history. This astronaut, with his suit on, who sacrificed his turn to jump into the craft, is now just rolling around wave after wave...decomposing on an alien world, never to be found or celebrated...for eternity.
OneEyedKeys he had enough time to go inside the damn ship, his loss for wasting time especially for turning around and just staring at the wave
@@kuhvn1487 He didn't exactly stare at it like "damn i really like waves, i might be here for a bit" He turned around and was shocked since there's a 4000ft wave about to swallow you in a second.
Because of relativity, his body might be found by the humans colonizing that system. If Cooper informs them that they lost a man on the planet, surely a recovery team will be sent. By the time they get there, he may have only been dead for a little over thirty minutes.
Hhj
You know what? Everything it’s fake so don’t think about that 🤣🤣🤣
"she probably only died minutes ago"
That line sinks your soul.
no, no it doesn’t
Personally I'm partial to "you eggheads have the survival skills of a boyscout troop".
If you want to pretend that she died 5 minutes ago. *_For contexts, 15 minutes here equals 15 months on Earth._* So in other words, the 5 minutes ago here was actually 5 months ago, which was most likely around the time that they were on their way to her planet. Most likely, as they ascended, she passed.
Terrifying.
Imagine Doyle survived, yet we see him unconcious. He wakes up on a water covered planet, no sign of the rest of his team who left millenia ago, and no way to survive.
The only thing left to think about then is how to die. Starvation? Or drowning? There's probably a few more options, but I can't think of many with a planet basically consisting of only water.
@@WanderTheNomad That water is basically the opposite of seawater - so sterile there are not even bacteria.
Funnily enough, such pure water is also toxic - the body needs some basic minerals that are present in natural water, missing which will cause health issues.
SUBNAUTICA
@@JohnsonTheSecond This is way worse than Subnautica's planet mate. No tools, nothing to eat nor drink, no contact with other humans. Just you and constant towering waves slamming into you until you are dead.
@@WanderTheNomad getting thrown around in a wave that size would be a death sentence.
Damn this was terrifying.
1. I hated it when Doyle died. He seemed like a cool guy. 2. Just thinking about Miller's situation sends shivers up my spine. Just landed on a lonely planet that seemed nice at first glance, only to notice a huge wave coming. Staring death in the face and you're powerless to do anything to save yourself. And then come to find out she was literally MINUTES away from rescue. My god.
But minutes in her time frame, which isn't the correct one to be counting from.
Help would come from the outside, and every "Miller minute" is years. So that's the timescale she's been dead in practice.
But it's more shocking to us if we think of it in minutes, because then we feel like it was close to saving her. Which it wasn't at all.
She was minutes, but years, so there was no way.
@@benghazi4216 It would take us years to reach her, but those years would be minutes to her. She was only minutes from rescue. Time flow is relative and so she was truly only minutes from rescue while on that planet.
@@Yeshayahu. She had only just died when they got there. Had she held on a few more minutes, they could have possibly saved her. Not sure if she could have fit in the ship, but they could have saved her.
She's probably panic and activated the beacon hoping for help
Like the other guy on ice planet (forgot the name)
The fact that Miller died less than an hour ago in the planet’s time is so chilling
Depending on how exactly he died he could still be alive here
@@thegreatnahwhaile Her ranger was crashed. She landed there probably minutes before they did. Crazy universe.
@@score4817 And they only approached Miller’s planet first because she sent out an initial status at all, minutes earlier, yet they’ve been receiving it and registering it and interpreting it and analyzing it for years already.
A year or two less of doing all that by launching sooner...barely would’ve made a difference.
@@Wired4Life2 She may have survived the crash but knocked unconscious there.
"Time is relative. It can stretch and it can squeeze but it can't run backwards"
That aged well
Unless you have gravity😂
She was talking about humans 3rd dimensional
She said a 5th dimensional being could possibly see time as a cannon they could climb into and the future a mountain they can climb up.
It doesn't make sense
@@bobshanery5152 It was a TENET joke
@@fone5003 that’s what I thought lol
If you were on Miller's planet: by the time you have finished watching this video, 285 days has passed on earth.
God damn scary
That she literally died only a few minutes before Coop and Brand could rescue her, is heart shattering...
Not really only in millers time frame.for her yes minutes but for the crew it took years to reach her and the planet
Time is relative
@@shiznik19 yes, really minutes. You’re the one not getting it. The time on the planet is real, just like the time on earth is real. Time is real. Everywhere.
@@xyz7572yet, he is right. It were minutes only from her perspective.
@@xyz7572You’re wrong. Shiznik is right
Crazy how some minutes or some hours is years to other people who aren’t on the planet..
Since they knew the planet is a water-planet and stands right next to a black hole with enormous gravitational pull, they should have calculated the tides. And they should also have predicted that a civilization cannot be created in a waterworld with cyclic water mountains. So, the rescue mission was a waste of time, resources, and life
They honestly wouldn’t have lost anybody or too much time if she hadn’t insisted on getting the data. It took them seconds to launch off they could’ve dipped fast
Why the hell did they decide to go on a planet first which has an hour of time for 7 years of Earth time?! That decision itself would have doomed Earth if not for the 5D beings.
I agree 100%, given how intelligent these people were and how much they knew about what they were dealing with in regards to time, relativity, physics etc. surely they would've figured out coming to this planet would be pointless and costly and the correct move instead to try the other planet. Bit of a hole in the plot in an otherwise awesome movie.
@@CST1992They were supposed to do everything as fast as possible, but the waves and Dr.Brand fucked everything up.
That's why Cooper says they are less prepared than boy scouts. He's chastised Brand but realizes that he made a stupid mistake too in voting to head to the planet. They talked about the time slippage but only from their own point of view. They didn't think from Miller's angle that it had been about an hour since land and sending out the one brief message. That's why there was no difference in the message or even follow up messages once they realize that was just a recycled loop. Even if Miller was alive, there wouldn't have been much time to gather any data at all and therefore no why at all to know if it was a viable option. If that had been discussed beforehand, I'm certain they would have opted for one of the others first.
This planet was sterile with no life as the characters said. Who else thinks that the crew introduced just enough bacteria to the planet where some form of life will evolve eventually?
Well, Doyle's corpse is still there in discomposition
@@netoarriola7251 I totally forgot about his corpse! Thank you
@@DAV1979 haha ur welcome 4:38
the planet is unstable with constant waves crashing, life forms cannot form
No, life won't evolve, because life doesn't macro evolve. Life was created, nothing didn't create everything.
They could've had a whole movie on this planet alone...
Well, not really. There’s not much to do with that planet. Well, imo anyways. They should create a movie on the Lazarus Missions like this one dude(forgot the name, will come back to edit it later) said on another Interstellar video I saw , that’s a good idea. That’s if they want to revisit Interstellar and milk it one more time.
Oh and it should be longer than a couple of hours. I love Interstellar.
I forgot how hardcore McConaughey goes in his acting. The raw emotion and distress in his gestures and voice is so amazing. Nolan always seems to pull off amazing casting in his films.
Plot twist: Doyle didn't die, and neither did Miller. They found each other and started life on this planet.
They rode the mountains together.
@@XXLRebel LMAO
They are both male I think
@@ayushpurohit9114 Miller was Female; her picture was in the...conference room, I think.
@@grmrpr3599 oh I didn't knew
Lol guys. For people saying Doyale survived, look at the damage tsunamis we have had in history. Now imagine a wave that reaches the clouds coming at you. Unconscious? Bro this guy died, and then the wave dragged him out of hell and killed him again. Then for good measure fucked him sideways.
Calm down dude " the wave fucked sideways" how would that work
@@qui-gonjinn8350 ask Doyle
@@thephenom_7231 what happened when the wave finished ?
Round 2 after 45 minutes. @@qui-gonjinn8350
@@qui-gonjinn8350a new one came.. and the process repeated itself
The acting here is incredible. Love the way Cooper chews her out(and she had it coming).
Not to _that_ level, she didn't. He's being such a bitch - and he keeps _being_ a bitch to her for a while afterwards, too. I understand him overreacting in the moment, but his spite towards her is completely irrational. Did really no one look at that hot mess of a planet from orbit and go, "Hm, 7 years per hour + too close to a black hole + 130% earth gravity + all water = LOL NOPE sorry Miller we'll build a statue in your honor, see ya"
@@theanafront3746 Like I said, she had it coming
Hathaway’s acting isn’t good. A good actress would have conveyed some of the anguish that brand is supposed to be feeling rather than just seeming defensive and petulant. This role was honestly the worst possible role for her.
@@dannytallmage2971Brand is in a different situation/mindset than Cooper keep that in mind, I think Anne was great for this role.
2:08 he’s trying to do everything he can to get the ship started as fast as possible, and in this moment looks like the worst feeling when he realizes all he can really do for right now is sit down and wait
@Smmm Dddd - do your best everyday homie, but sometimes you just gotta take that L
Just imagine you we're the guy waiting on that ship alone, in dark cold space for 23 years.
exactly why this was a dumb plan
@russiasvechenaya58 Right what were they thinking? Lol
And then he gets blown up shortly after Cooper and Brand return to him
What if the bacteria/ in doyle and millers body became the building blocks of life in that planet?🤔
General Ramos shit, that might happen lol
still would take trillion year for life on it to evolve and grow thanks to relativity, this planet is just not suitable at all
@Knight Light it actually would, compared to pretty much everywhere else, evolution on this planet would take trillions if not quadrillions of years. Think about it, one hour here is 7 years on earth "or other parts of the galaxy", considering that it took some 2 billion years on our planet for life to develop, and assuming things are as lucky here, it'd still be 2 billion years on this planet, where each fucking hour of those years is 7 years everywhere else.
The planet, and possibly the entire galaxy would die out long before any life could develop here.
This is actually one of my main problems in this movie, why the hell would this planet be considered as even Remotely viable for life, even if humanity makes it there safely and managed to survive and develop, they'll always be stuck with living on that planet and not being able to leave.
No. One human body as opposed to how many waves? Look at just one ocean on earth and imagine the impact one human body or even one whale. Nothing. This planet is way more powerful than every single ocean together
@@liorasitelman1856 He said life, that could be single cell organisms, or small multicell ones, could be like micro floating plants. The sky is blue and there was definetely light similar to the sun's I can see it happening. Why you assume that Whales will happen in that planet?
Biggest rollercoaster in a lifetime
Of*
@@rawdawgg_ oh woops sorry my english sucks I know I’m dutch
anne hathaway was such a revelation in this role
"Time can be stretched, it can bs squeezed. It can't run backwards."
TENET BACKWARDS SWAT MAN ENTERS
I love how they don’t even think about looking for doyle, he legit surfin or someshit
Theres no way he survived it
Did anyone else notice that they needed two booster rockets just to leave Earth but on Miller's planet with "punishing gravity", the ship had engine technology that was able to fly off on its own without any booster assistance?
Good catch!
Someone gave a logical explanation on it on a video on TH-cam I can't remember. But it seemed a plausible explanation. Will comment here if I find it someday.
NASA in the movie probably didn’t have that many resources at their disposal so they used old rocket technology to save on fuel and money and spent most of their money on more advanced technology for the ships the crew of the endurance we’re going to use far from earths help.
Maybe they wanted to save fuel while leaving the earth
It was also a smaller ship with less mass
God i love that spool up - sound at 04:23
Jumping to mach 3 in a short distance would be awesome
I think the most haunting thing is that he may have survived that wave. Imagine waking up, only to get wrecked by another giant wave.
I don't think a human would take loosing 30 earth years without beating shit up.
It's basically like being in a solitary cell for 23 years, 4 months, 8 days. Just that you don't have to wait the duration.
Beating *her* up, lol
This is a decade sex
That scene destroyed my mood for half of the movie, it's so heartbreaking
If doyle survive for 2 hours they have 23 years to go back and save him.
And what makes you think in that two hours, his spacesuit can endure another 2 mega waves?
The slingshot maneuver already took 50 something years.
Wasn't an hour on Miller's planet, 7 years on Earth?
@@alejandrop.s.3942 sure but say he has enough oxygen to survive for a day (doubdful but who knows). That's 168 years, and by then Humanity would have far more advanced technology.
1:30 thats terrifying
the only movie that i watched like 10 times in my life. and now i am going to watch again.
10 times the same movie? u dumb?
@@flisko123 idk, i just enjoy the movie a lot, does it mean i am dumb? ppl be watching same tik tok 20 times does that also mean they dumb? lmfao. you gotta chill bro
The chances of someone finding him would be slim to none but, thousands of years would have passed if not millions by the time someone found or just stumbled across his body. Explorers that have no family may not care about a time lapse as I would assume it could benefit many who travel there. Maybe reanimation might exist by then. There may be hope lol.
It's a factor of 200,000... so Doyle really wouldn't be much different even if someone came for him after a thousand years. Millions, no one would really even remember, let alone care.
3 days on Miller's planet is 504 days to the humans who are right by the wormhole by Saturn that connects to this solar system. They still have a century to colonize their new planet before Doyle's body has been there a single day.
This is interesting. Say Miller stays alive for a couple days, riding the waves as they come and go. The time slippage is 168 years per day. This would mean that, in just two days in Miller's planet, Humanity would have already established a colony on Edmund's planet, with far more advanced technology at their disposal, and may be able to organize a rescue.
Omg this scene is so good.
It really just goes to show that time is the ultimate. It knows everything that has happened and everything that will happen relative to whoever is reading this.
From times perspective everything that will happen from our perspective has already happened.
Makes you think about the quote unquote “afterlife.” If we’re able to move around in the “afterlife” then time knows everything that happens there too.
Wild.
So the fact that the planet was orbiting the throat of a 100 million solar mass supermassive black hole (so close, in fact, that Kip Thorne calculated that in order for gravitational time dilation to be this extreme, the black hole would have to be rotating at 99.7% the speed of light just to give the planet a stable orbit) wasn't enough of a red flag, eh? Lol
A major problem with this plan, is that by Romilly staying in the Endurance while it drifts along side Miller planet, while cooper and Brandt go down to Miller planet is that it does not save any time (even if you account for the accident). It is like crossing a road with a slow old lady, or walking past her and waiting for her to catch up to you. It would take the same amount of time. Had the Endurance orbited Miller, rather than staying in a parallel orbit to Gargantua alongside Miller, then Romilly would not have waited 23 years. Everyone on Earth would have waited just the same, but Romilly would not have been by himself for decades. Perhaps being younger would have helped the crew detect and stop Mann's madness.
He only got to know that Mann's data doesn't make sense after he decrypted KIPP (Mann's robot). So, he would still be dying.
The Gargantua time shift zone is all around Miller’s planet. Getting in and out of the time shift zone is faster in the Ranger than using the Endurance to go into orbit. Ron sacrifices himself as someone has to stay on the Endurance while the others do in the quickest in and out they can.
@@mfreedom1 why does someone have to stay on the endurance?
@@TruthFreedomStrength They dont, but in an earlier scene, Romily says he's going to stay there to gather all the black hole data, process it and use it for scientifc gains. He stayed to work as going down to the planet was kinda pointless for him when he could stay on the ship and deal with Gargantua's data.
@@Phoenix258 no... That doesn't work, because even after being on the endurance for 23 years waiting for Cooper and Brandt, Romilly says that he couldn't make a breakthrough because there was only so much he could figure out without the quantum data. Sounds like at least some of the time he was alone, was wasted.
Omg was that Doyle’s body at the end?
Probably, but considering Brand said Miller probably died only minutes ago, it could be her body as well.
Ahmed Abdullah no they had orange suits I guess
@@louislaude8240 Exactly.
@Disproportionate Pub I don't know if this is sarcasm or not
AndresGarciaMovies He actually could survive the wave ngl
Doyle was such an idiot, just waiting to get swept rather than getting inside. There was no reason for him to wait around outside 🤣
Probably paralyzed by fear.. and don’t forget the stronger gravity which makes it harder to move around..
Creepy to think that doyle could have just been unconscious and woke up hours later on a lonely planet and died of oxy loss
Omg....:((
If he was alive he'd probably end up being saved. Spend a day there and a century has passed. Somebody could pick him up.
I don't think he survived he got picked up by that wave and then slammed into the ground
@@outbreak8184 no thats not it. If it happened like that then Brand and Cooper would have died when the ranger slammed into the ground
It was trillions of tons of water crashing. That would easily kill a human.
So Case says it's going to take 45 mins to an hour to drain the engines. They talk for 5 minutes. Then the wave comes and Case says 1-2 mins then Coop gets the idea of blowing the cabin oxygen out of the thrusters.
Just WTF? Did anyone proof read this script?
I wonder if Miller activated her beacon out of shear terror because of the time slippage. She hoped that in the minutes she had before the wave hit she knew that there was the tiniest chance that decades had passed on earth and another expedition could rescue her by then.
Now I definitely need to see that film in original. McConaughey plays so realistic with his intonation
1:56 Cooper: now it's my time to shout
Very underrated scene! Thank you for uploading it. It gives a hell of a clue of what's to come. I remember watching this in the cinema and shouting "Gravity" when she says "the only thing that can move across dimensions like time is ..." Then I remembered the books falling off Cooper's daughter library 😲😯 I almost burst to tears
Good job in the translation, you were able to format sentences that make their speech understandable out of movie context. 👏
What I don't understand is how they needed a full rocket to get this exact craft to orbit on earth but on Miller's planet which has 130% the gravity of earth they are able to take off and get into orbit with just the lander.
To save fuel and engine lifespan? Probably carried a whole bunch of other payload of supplies.
The gravity isn't from the planet (which is small) but the black hole itself...so leaving it would not be tat heard
That last shot is powerful. No beings could stand the element
4:40 there's a slight possibility that this is Miller.
wave: 🌊
Doyle: 😳😳😳
wave: 👁️👄👁️
This shows us, human's are inadequate for space.
Me when I first watched this movie
Her: the only thing that can move like time is...
Me: love😃
Her: gravity
Me: oh ☹️
And then she goes on to say love later on that movie 😂
She was right tho 😏
2:07 one of the best acting I have ever seen.
Remember, if you ever miss something really nostalgic yet from the 2000s, *it was only hour ago*
If only time could go back......I wish. 🤍💔
According the interview. The waves are fixed and pulled because the strong gravity. The only one moving in that planet is it’s self. So imagine the planet is rotating while the waves are fixed. That’s scary shit
Something that bugs me about the whole affair with Miller's planet is that the crew (or at the very least Cooper) seemed not to be fully aware of the fact that, due to the extreme time dilation, Miller had just arrived there from her perspective and had been sending data for only an hour at most (assuming she got there 7 years ago in Earth's time). But then again, on board the Endurance they do mention that 'Miller hadn't sent much, but the data was promising'. So I don't know if I'd call this a plothole or not. Perhaps they knew that the data only covered an hour or so but found it promising enough to investigate, but didn't know about the tidal waves and that Miller was dead.
1:30 they were aware, they literally pointed it out
@@JayF2912 yes but that was after the fact, and Cooper seems surprised about it. They should have known about this before even landing.
@@NightWanderer31415 by promising, they probably meant that the planet had water. Also they were closer to miller's planet than the other two and they were probably tempted by the existence of water. But yea the should have calculated the supermassive tsunamis
Script writing mistake they like let didn’t catch until they were filming. It’s clear when they are discussing it that they are overlooking that it’s only been an hour or so on millers planet. Especially when you consider that Cooper rules out dr edmunds planet because Edmund stopped transmitting when he would have nonetheless transmitted far more data than Miller had.
2:22 Tenet would disagree lmao
No, it’s not contradictory. In tenet, time still moves clock wise but only the protagonist functions counter clockwise.
@@leonchou870814 Without having seen Tenet, that sounds like Strugatskies "Monday begins on Saturday"-Novel. Nice idea.
No, you don’t understand the film
I mean, reversing entropy doesn’t cause someone to go backwards in time relative to everyone else’s so lol
Time is still relative in Tenet. Reverse for inverted person. Normal for normal person.
Curiousity and the mad scramble to save ourselves will be the very glyphs to adorn our tombs
Interesting how at 4:40 you can't make out the suit trim colors (olive grey for Endurance vs. red for Lazarus) so you're never quite sure if it is Doyle or Miller floating face down in the water.
'those aren't mountains'
Im sad now
Blowing the cabin oxygen through the main thrustsers makes me sad every time. O:(
Poor Doyle, left alone there like a used water bottle.
so 23 years passed which means they must have been there for a little over 3 hours given the fact that it was 7 years per hour. Yet, case said the engines to drain which would be 45 minutes to an hour. So it took them 2 hours to search, get hit by the wave, and slide down the other side?
The movie edits out the 3 hours
it's a big wave
Yes, it's a little more than 3 hours.
The transit down to the planet took about 45 minutes. They searched for about 10, had to wait 45 minutes for the engines to dry, and 45 more minutes to return to the station.
@@Davedio that's only 16 years. I'm just saying they at least should have made a few more scenes to give a timeline so when they returned it made sense
'When you become a parent, many things will become apparent'
4:40
Whoa...
Imagine if that another wave hit him and the another... :(
He's dead though right?
Me when I was 10 years old playing dead in the pool to see if anyone cares
@Dispropub Gaming you can’t survive that wave dude
0:09 having a poo after spicy ramen
4:40, “Hey guys did you forget about something????”
Question, why couldn't they do the air blow thing through the engines to spark them as soon as the wave passed? Why wait and lose precious time for everything to dry off?
@Alexander Solicari But it still doesn't make sense. Every hour was 7 years. If there was another way to get off the planet quicker than waiting for everything to dry then you would think they would exhaust all quicker possibilities first
They needed to wait for the water to be drained from the engine, the spark would've failed if there was a lot of water left inside.
@@husamstarxin4626 ohh that makes sense!
The length of the wave is also terrifying if you think about it - it probably crossed half the planet.
She was trying to do the right thing by collecting data on a planet that was clearly uninhabitable
For maximum horror, they should have had him sit up at the last moment of the camera shot.
Exactly. He was actually just reaching down to pull up Miller trapped under debris.
If Romilly orbited the Miller planet, he would have waited 3 hours and
20 minutes for them. Cooper screwed up with this plan. All that mattered
was how long they would be on planet Miller. Romilly situation was
irrelevant. But Nolan had to create a drama. I respect this. Brilliant
movie.
Ok i understood my mistake.
1:26 fuck's sake Cooper keep up
imagine being stuck on a planet with years flying by in mins. what would be your first thought?
Wtf bro , when I was 5 , I could tell by looking at globe what parr is land and what part water !
Dammit, I love the IDEA of this scene but it's so frustrating that they don't mark the passage of time properly!
In a sequence where time has huge consequences, how did no one think to make it clearer??
Case says repairs will take 45 to an hour, and then we get approximately 2 minutes of dialogue WITH NO CUTS before the next wave comes.
There are no cuts! So either Case is wrong by 43 minutes in his estimate, in which case they are on the planet for a total of less than 10 minutes and the 23 years that pass makes no sense, OR the film lies to us about what we're seeing.
If 45 minutes are supposed to pass then cut the scene and transition to 43 minutes later! I just don't get this decision and it undermines all the scientific accuracy that the film is going for.
Am I missing something??.
Yeah idk if it’s just the TH-cam clip or not good point tho doesn’t make sense
It’s just bad film making. They are clearly interrupted by the robot- even if they didn’t want to do a cut they could have maintained some ambiguity in the passage of time by not panning back to cooper and brand. but they pan back and brand is literally in the same position she was seconds before. The movie would have us believe she held her pouty face for 43 minutes lol.
I think what happened is Nolan was hemmed in by the need to create dramatic tension but also the need to make the time dilation on the planet not so extensive that it would have been immediately ruled out by the astronauts. This necessitated playing loose with just how much time was wasted by the “mistake” vs how much time would have been consumed just by the logistics of reaching the planet at all. Even if they “wasted” 45 minutes they trip itself would have taken 130 minutes so yea it sucks but they already lost 14 years just making the trip.
A the end of this scene, who's to say that rather that what we think is the body of Doyle floating in the water, it was ACTUALLY Miller? I say this because Nolan is the kind of director who would put that kind of question in there. We don't see in good detail who the person is floating in the water.
Always found it funny that they needed a rocket to send up the ranger into Earths orbit, but it can just dip out of a planet with even more gravity lol.
Yea they need fuel
@@Blue-wh7mz No, that's not what I mean. The ranger that Coop went up on was on a regular rocket. But the 7 year planet had even more gravity and it just zips out without a booster.
@@newguy3588 Yeah and a planet with gravity that high also has a massive wall of water floating up towards gargantua. Coop flew right along that wave all the way up. If the gravity is strong enough to do that to waves then I’m sure the ship had a little help from gargantua when he left.
Also its the blackhole that made the gravity punishing not the tiny planet@@dustybawls3561
Yea, but I'm wondering why they didn't anticipate these complications before even setting out. Given the 7 years per hour time-dilation, it's likely that they could have considered Miller's likely mission status. It means she would have had a mission duration of less than 3 hours before they got there. That's not enough time to make a proper assessment of the planet.
This is definitely a weak spot in the script. But What I can’t figure out is at what point does the time dilation kick in. With the dilation schedule of 1 hour= seven years of earth time the only way for 21 years to have elapsed is for them to have spent 3 hours on millers planet or for the dilation to have also applied while they are traveling to and from millers planet. Conceding that this film isn’t shot in real time but still even with allowances for “movie time” there’s no way they spent three hours there. They likely spent an hour on planet (7 earth years). Which logically means that 14 of those earth hours had to be consumed traveling to and from millers planet.
But the scientist that remains thinks they’ll be gone 3 or so years at most his time so clearly the dilation can’t apply to their journey there and back otherwise he’d know they’d be gone for at least 14 years just on the basis of traveling there and back. The movie seems to be implying that the dilation only occurs on the planet itself in which case their travel time wouldn’t be affected but by this logic where did the three hours go.
Time is a projection from consciousness shifting itself through billions and billions of still-3D-frames per sec, thus creating the illusion of movement and change. Movies and animation have had this law since the beginning. Its all just frames per second
that's nice, but you need to eat the bread i baked you, you've not eaten any
When you become a parent you make sure their world is safe.
0:40 GODDAMMIT
4:40 wtf is that ??
It's Doyle's corpse
The scary thing is we dont know who that is floating down there. It coul be Doyle or Miller. This scene always makes me so sad
3:36 When you become a parent, one thing becomes really clear
1:31-1:40 If y'all want to pretend that she died 5 minutes ago. *_For contexts, 15 minutes here equals [approximately] 15 months on Earth._* So in other words, the 5 minutes ago here was actually 5-6 months ago, which was most likely around the time that they were on their way to her planet. Most likely, as they descended.
Terrifying
Time dialation is weird to think about. Think, you are an astronaut, you have the best technology available and you go Millers planet. Not after 5-6 hours later some other ranger appears with tech at least 30 years newer and more advanced. That is just weird. The new astronauts were kids when you left. No one has heard from you, they assumed you were dead. That is just wild to me. And to think about that, while the film is science-fiction the reality actually checks out. We don't know the fact that you would experience time dialation like this, but it is real. That is just amazing and terrifying at the same time
That should be a message for Anna Hathaway too from Miranda Priestley really old on a hospital telling her how dissapointed she is she didnt get her coffee in time
In this scene alone, they waste 9.37 months back on earth.
they cant do anything about it, they are waiting for the engines to clear, they even left a minute early.
“Time is relative… It can stretch, it can squeeze, but it can’t run backwards.”
One of the main issues with this movie is the premise of going back in time, which is what the 5th dimensional humans are doing. They-Dr. Thorne and the writers-actually knew of the paradoxes (e.g., “the grandfather paradox”, where if you go back in time and kill your grandfather, you would cease to exist), and just chose to ignore it to advance the movie’s story. Basically, the future humans are going back in time to create their present and future, which violates the laws of cause and effect. So far as we know, we can go as far into the future as we like, in theory, but we cannot go back in time. The early universe’s low entropy, cause and effect relationships, e.g., effects happening before causes, like “the grandfather paradox”, objects moving before they’re touched, etc. are among some of the main reasons. It would also require an unimaginable amount of energy to do so, possibly equal to the entire amount of energy in the entire universe or more, which just isn’t possible. For 5th dimensional beings, should they exist, time might be, for them, as rudimentary and as easy to understand as 3-dimensional beings looking at 2-dimensional shapes.
But we, as we are now, are not 5th dimensional beings, and therefore, are incapable of understanding higher dimensions intuitively. A 3-dimensional person in a 4-dimensional world would not be able to perceive, or perceive very well, time, which is inherently 4-dimensional, in a 3-dimension conception. To look at yourself in a mirror in the 4th dimension, you would see yourself as a long, undulating figure, stretching from your embryonic self, all the way to your dead self. Can’t imagine that? Exactly the point. Now, try to perceive of the 5th dimension? No way.
Maybe one day, if we live long enough as a civilization, we may be able to design a 4th dimensional world that’s able to be perceived by our 3-dimensional minds through quantum computing or AI, or by some other methods, or we may evolve so our perception becomes attuned to higher dimensions, or maybe higher order physics are discovered that provide solutions to the paradoxes inherent. But, for what we know right now, and what the evidence points to, is that time is a one-way street.
At the end of the video, was the unconcious body was Doyle's?
yes, and while a storyline where he’s unconscious would certainly be cool or more dramatic, the ‘unconscious body’ is far more likely a ‘dead body’ in reality…
Terrifyingly iconic scene👏what an incredible movie!
"Who left a dead body in section C13215?"
Has anyone check if Doyle is still alive?
Bruhh! If i would given a mission to miller planet, i would fuckin' rush my ass out like i'm on a minute to win it game show 😂😂😂, i don't wanna waste and miss my stuffs on earth like duhhh. Ain't nobody got time for that!
shut up
@@eeevoo I'll agree with that
@@eeevoo i agree
This planet made for a great thought experiment but in all practicality why would they send anyone there with all the time dilation knowing about it?
Before they ever think to land. Does not even they can imagine what would be happen with the Miller planet? I mean they can just think like “We have wave because of the moon, what if we have black hole instead?”.
I never understood why they went to a water planet near a BLACK HOLE. Surely any planet near a blackhole is automatically inhabitable ????
What´s up everyone! How are you doing! I´d like to share with you my piano suite of this beatiful soundtrack, you are welcome to watch it. Thank you
How are they able to escape a 1.3g gravity Planet, with a single ranger, while it required a 3-stage rocket to leave the Earth ?
Earth has a high atmosphere thats why it requires many rockets
pretty sure it's also like 100 years farther in the future than us rn so they have the tech too I guess space x helped them or something
Ethan L True there were no armies so
Because they didn't want to waste precious fuel using the Ranger to escape Earth when they could just use multi-stage rockets. Remember the Ranger and Lander were their only modes of transportation in and out of the planets and fuel was a scarce resource that they had to conserve.
@@marcosfloresiii4401 The ranger is very flat and small. i doubt it's fuel tanks could have even a few tonnes of fuel.... There is no goddamn way it's lifting off from a 1.3 g world. Also, it's take off is pretty damn weird too considering were the engines are located.
Hello to everyone from California USA
just kidding
BGM “Surfing USA ”
pleaseTARS 😅
If this planet sorted out it’s waves.. this planet could breed the most technologically advanced aliens real fukn quick