Why does the US not seem as cautious with its funding for Israel as it is with Unrwa?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ส.ค. 2024
- Prem Thakker, a reporter at The Intercept, questioned US State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller about the lack of caution in US funding for Israel, despite the International Court of Justice (ICJ) stating that Israel may plausibly be committing genocide. Compared to its immediate suspension of funding for Unrwa over allegations that a very small number of its staff were involved in the October 7th attack.
Matthew Miller responded, 'I think there’s a false equivalency embedded in that question.'
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEas...
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
Great work by this journalist. The answer is predictable, taking into account that this genocide is a joint venture.
Not enough pushback from him, or the other journalist. I get it, if he pushes too much, his permit to be there and ask questions will be revoked. But still, dont let blatant lies like that stand, they are suffocation our humanity. It's becoming more and more us vs them. It's what Israel wants, not realising things will never go back to normal, now that the whole world saw them for what they really are, genocidal and supremacists.
The clown said human shields 😂 dude works for Israel. They killed a 6 year old and here entire family including the ambulance trying to save her. Evil man defending them hypocrite
In the watershed moment, the global South knows there are no human rights or international rules-based order, but the West has now confirmed with all the world to see! These double standards worked as long as might-is-right, with BRICS and equivalent weapons and force available, the West will see this come to haunt them - very short-sighted. The end of the empire
Mind Begs the Question:
- If USA/West Leadership
- Arm,Bankroll a Govt/Nation
- Who use Starvation,Death Camps,Ethnic Cleansing,etc
- Not akin to Architects behind Nazis?
Great question. Shameful pathetic answer.
There's one more difference between the funding of Israel and Unrwa: Funding Unrwa goes to aid refugees and people in need. It's not a military fund, unlike the fund that goes to Israel. It seems that Miller's argument is that 12 out of 30000 people who "might" be involved in a terror attack is a valid reason to stop humanitarian aid to Palestinians before investigation, while actually murdering 30000 Palestinians by the IDF requires thorough investigation while continuing to fund the Israeli war machine. That is the US "moral equivalency". The US proves they are morally bankrupt.
And also was it UNRWA that sent those members to Israel on the 7th October attacks. The US has and never had its moral compass
He represents the Israeli government, not America.
But we're being asked to pledge allegiance to that foreign country. Crazy, isn't it?
This was the best question. Miller was showing his bias with his answer. Very nasty. Went back to his garbage about Hamas.
I absolutely agree . Answer the direct question, Miller Blah blah blah blah
What a white lie from White House as part of their incremental Big Lie series, yet a-gain..!
UNRWA didn't find those allegations “credible”, it merely acted on abundance of caution because UN[O] agencies have to be extremely diplomatic in dealing with its members and accuser is not just a sovereign, it is a perpetrator who directly occupies - that's why the hiring due-diligence of UNRWA is essentially outsourced to them. That's why I can see why they did what they did, even though I feel they should have not - given the all-too-familiar history and pattern.
Are Miller,Blinken,Kirby American?
@@deselby6669 no the representative of Is real!!!
He’s a dual citizen Israeli and pro Zionist it’s not shocking
The hypocrisy
Not hypocrisy. He is showing his loyalty to Israel. He has dual citizenship. We need to do away with the dual citizenship crap. His allegiance should be only to the U.S. not to Israel.
This is proper journalism. These people in Washington are morally bankrupt.
Literally ZERO EVIDENCE of any wrongdoing by those employees as alleged.
1. They defunded **UNRWA** not the “terrorist organisation” so his answer doesn’t make sense at all
2. Whether you frame a criminal as “Prime Minister” or as “terrorist”, if they commit a crime they are still criminals and should be held accountable for committing those crimes.
3. He totally ignores the violations of international law mentioned in the question.
He also lied about UNWRA saying it's a credible accusation. The UNWRA took it seriously, firing all accused, so they wouldn't jeopardize funding for food and water for the civilian population. Still, the West happily cut funding. And Israel, who has tried for decades to achieve this, got what they wanted, the mass starvation of Palestinians.
These answers are so infuriatingly hypocritical that I want to throw my phone across the room whenever I have the misfortune of watching a US press conference
Miller, Kriby, and Patel are disgusting. I have no idea how they sleep at night after saying this stuff.
@@beanpasteposts They don't believe in justice. They're cynics who believe in power, $, might, & their own "inherent superiority" over others.
How does he arrive hamas does it intentionally and Israel does it out of love when they killed 12k children?
Why does this guy have such an evil face?/
Because he’s 👿 evil.
Snake like
Because he is a tyrant, evil pathological liar who was put on the spot with a very difficult question he did want to answer!
i know a villian from a real bad movie
I used to think am the only one who notice, the face looks timid but with Gen side intent
America's hypocrisy has no limit 😅😅
He ignored the part where the International Court of Justice found the case of genocide plausible.
Hypocrite to the core
He's actually not a hypocrite. Miller is defending his true country. His dual citizenship says it all. His loyalty is to Israel first.
We should do away with the dual citizenship crap. Our allegiance should be only to one country not to two. That's how these Zionists yield influence and power. Disturbing, isn't it?
Under international law, if war crimes have been committed by one side, that's irrelevant to the question of whether they have been committed by the other side.
In other words Israel and the U.S. can't use alleged Hamas war crimes to justify their own war crimes, or even (as here) use them to give Israel the benefit of the doubt.
The US can fund or not fund whoever they want for whatever reason they want. Get over it. Right now, we choose to not feed terrorists and that means UNRWA gets no money.
Well, as you can see, international law only applies to "certain" countries.
Indeed. Not only that, but explicitly, genocide is absolutely never justified under international law. There are situations in which a hospital can become a valid military target (none of those situations have applied in Gaza, however) but a genocide can never be justified.
Hold up, are you saying two wrongs don't make a right? 😳🤯
@@DerAptrgangr Since Israel isn't conducting genocide as determined by the ICJ you can stop pretending they are. After all, it's the Palestinians who routinely chant "Death to Israel" in the streets, which is genocidal intent.
A question full of meaning! The answer defines exactly what the American government has long represented, that is to say the total absence of all moral values!🙄
Other than their country,they call every other gulf country fighters as "Terrorist"
This journalist raised a very valid point.
Geez, i hope this guy ends up in jail. Or better yet, working to exhume "human shields" from under the rubble in Gaza.
Would be a fair
from the web: " ... Antisocial personality disorder, sometimes called sociopathy, is a mental health condition in which a person consistently shows no regard for right and wrong and ignores the rights and feelings of others ..."
Matthew Miller is a graduate of the University of Texas at Austin. That is a disgrace to the institution.
Thank you, Mr. Miller, for shedding light on why the US stopped its aid to UNRWA but continues to support Israel with money and weapons. I didn't know that participating in a terrorist attack was much worse than committing a deliberate genocide. That explanation is utterly disgusting!
It’s like he turns a blind eye to the vital facts of the matter. There is overwhelming merit behind the intentional killing of civilians on the IDF side, far more than what hamas did, and yet they still engage in this rhetoric.
This is exactly why the US can not be trusted in participating as an honest mediator.
It seems that the way these spokespeople whitewash the acts of the IDF is by raising the bar of evidence so high on one end and not the other. Many times Miller will say “I don’t know what etc etc circumstances happened surrounding this” or “we asked our counterparts to conduct an investigation” which essentially leaves Israel as the US’s sole source of ground truth regarding the matter.
It should also be noted that given Israel’s commitment of mass atrocities against journalists and pundits, the reporting on these situations and war crimes is also jeopardized. This muddies the waters on what to be absolute certain of, but what is more certain is who is responsible. On the other hand, accusations against 12 members of unrwa is somehow enough to the US as far as evidence is concerned. The end result is the US “playing it safe” when it comes to acts of terrorism but being very loose when it comes to the IDF
In other words, this situation is only a false equivalency as he says if there is a double standard applied.
This is very injustice answer that I ever herd. He must think better about their absolute injustice opinion and decision if he had a little mercy in his heart to innocent children who is dying every hour.
US does not "support" Israel.
US and Israel are not two separate countries.
True, Israel is a military outpost of the US which of course would need defending regardless!!
I'd call it the 51st state, but it doesn't seem to me like it's so far down on the totem pole as 51st.
No. To the US government, Israel is more important than the US.
@@LaurieFloodTeacheractually the us is more accurately a colony of the Zionist state.
@@LaurieFloodTeacher Love you.
51 USrael states so far:
1-Telaviv 2-Delaware 3-Pennsylvania... 51-Hawaii
US is killing 12000 children to expand their occupied land in the middle east. Any other "complicated" explanation would be a sham. Everybody perfectly know it, but they just agree or disagree about if a genocide is justified!
Wow, everything he said about Hamas 💯% applies to Israel.
Absolutely amazing question to highlight their bias. Not that it wasn't already flashing neon all over the place, but that question - and the answer - brilliantly demonstrated it as naked as possible. Streets of the big cities should be flooding with outrage when your govt talks to you like your the dumbest people on Earth.
zionists and nazis 2 sides of the same coin,
Totally opposite.
However....
Hamass = nazi's.
Bingo.
And Zionism will join it with being a part of history and not the future
They are the same in every possible way.
Because the zionists actually ocherstrated the holocaust with the nazis that's why.
Do you expect that guy to be honest with you? Has Netanyahu and his government been honest with you? It is an everyday blatant truth staring at all of us that these people are not truthful. Yet, they expect you to believe them.
And it's so sad that many still do.
Ils ont le mensonge facile c'est inné chez eux je crois que c'est dans leurs gènes
Its the constant manipulative gaslighting by these monsters that I find just revolting , Its like its not 1982 anymore dude its all on video so stop lying about it lol . Its like dealing with old boomers on Facebook who don't understand technology .
Israel and the U.S. are empires of lies and deception
Nah. The journalists ask the questions, they know what the answers will be, but the more these fools continue the lies the bigger the hole they dig for themselves.
I don't know if they realise how fast they're own bosses and "allies" will throw them to the wolves to save themselves when they have to.
Ah, I see now, alleged terrorism against civilians and alleged warcrimes against civilians are two totally different and unequivocal things. I also think he forgot that hes defending cutting off UNRWA which is only allegedge to have involvement.
Clear complicit in aiding the Genocide of our time.
Couple things:
A genocide would be intentional and we have plenty of evidence of intentional and sadistic behavior on the part of IDF with them even having a snuff channel.
Second, theres no evidence that unrwa staff actually did participate in october 7th, so the point about caution with money doesnt reallt make sense. Theyre not terrorists, theyve simply been accused.
Third, this idea that a "whoopsie" is just a forgettable mistake and doesnt require real monetary consequences or cause real harm is stupid. At this point, the whoopsies have killed and harmed more folks than the intentional killing and civilian capture by Hamas. Handwaving that damage away on the basis of intent is just a stupid way to avoid accountability for your clearly damaging actions.
What a white lie from White House as part of their incremental Big Lie series, yet a-gain..!
UNRWA didn't find those allegations “credible”, it merely acted on abundance of caution because UN[O] agencies have to be extremely diplomatic in dealing with its members and accuser is not just a sovereign, it is a perpetrator who directly occupies - that's why the hiring due-diligence of UNRWA is essentially outsourced to them. That's why I can see why they did what they did, even though I feel they should have not - given the all-too-familiar history and pattern.
Who murdered children specifically on Oct 7? THAT is genocide, so stop pretending your precious Palestinians are angels and not demon spawn who care only for violence.
4th) even if there would be a solid case and these allegations are confirmed, that does not mean that the organisation itself is compromised
That's a quite a big "IF", given how the genocidal-occupation rolls - "@@pablolongobardi7240". They have already blown a hole in UN[O]'s hallmark, quite literally.
@@pablolongobardi7240 Maybe you should rethink that because if they are confirmed it actually DOES prove the organization it compromised.
'That UNWRA found credible' is such a twisted spin.
I know, right?
What a white lie from White House as part of their incremental Big Lie series, yet a-gain..!
UNRWA didn't find those allegations “credible”, it merely acted on abundance of caution because UN[O] agencies have to be extremely diplomatic in dealing with its members and accuser is not just a sovereign, it is a perpetrator who directly occupies - that's why the hiring due-diligence of UNRWA is essentially outsourced to them. That's why I can see why they did what they did, even though I feel they should have not - given the all-too-familiar history and pattern.
It's not just spin. It's a lie. UNRWA only let the employees go because they knew the employees' mere presence would be used as an excuse to shut down or impede the agency. They were hoping to avoid that. I doubt they believe this latest attempt to shut them down is anything other than all the ploys and set-ups Israel has attempted before.
My criminal government (USA) defunded them anyway, despite admitting they've seen no proof at all.
I think if we start talking about Israel being a US colony then it's going to make more sense for the US endless support. The US government is not about to criticize themselves. Israel is in the middle east to serve a purpose and that is so the US has full control and dominance over the middle east.
True. And they are our assassins in the region. They do the dirty work for us. But as you already must know, our foreign policy in the region (and other parts of the world) stinks.
Absurd incomprehensible reply except to US and UK citizens, and to the Francoist parties of Spain.
the face of shame
The cough before "military campaign" tells you everything you need to know.
Miller is not answering the question. That is not a falls equivalency.
What a disgusting response! Sickening to the stomach 🤮!
I wish the reporter had followed up with the question "but why are you supporting Netanyahu when he himself has bragged of giving money to H@mas?"
This man belongs in the ICC
Every time I decide to listen to those white house spokespersons i regret that decision
This "GUY", Matthew Miller, has NO HEART... NO SOUL ... Only DARK Evil ... #CeaseFireNow ...
Only 1?
May the sins of the father be visited upon the children. Maybe only then he will feel something.
Textbook narcissist smirk on this guy's face. It's a game to him, and he's laughing at you for playing.
I despise Mr. Miller
Am I the only one who cannot stand anymore the sound of his voice? It is like in my mind: this voice= lies
Palestinians are not only fighting against Israel but also against USA and EU and UK and Canada… brave people.
It's grating on my ears, and I'm not even from the US, or Palestine, I'm not even Muslim.
Liars are the same wherever you go.
Yes, and his evil face. Where the fuq do they find these people??
Me too..cant stand his face too
i feel the same about the israeli spokeshithead
Still using the human shield proven false talking point .
More galling when little Hind Rajab was mentioned by name and we all know how she was simply trying to escape with her unarmed family in the car and they were all mercilessly slaughtered. How can they look at themselves in the mirror every day?
@@hamnaahmad3579 because they have no soul ,most of them don't have mirrors .
No point asking cuz you will get biase answer. US will always support israhell.
I just can’t stomach this creep today. Peace out folks. Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤️ Salam Shalom Wahsalam Halikum, Oseh shalom bimromav. Hu ya'aseh shalom aleinu. V'al kol Yisrael V'imru
Peace to all nations, God bless
This ludicrous answer implicitly defines the political label of "Terrorist" to mean "Any person or group targetted for death by the world's dominant military powers,. The rest of the world should probably treat them as if they are already dead" I'm not sure what civilized moral principle he's defending here.
He's not. He has no moral principles, just rhetoric & propaganda techniques to confuse bystanders who may still have a conscience.
75 years and you expect me to believe that it all started on Oct 7th.
What kind of person defended American slavery? What kind of person defended the holocaust Genocide in Germany? Matthew Miller is that kind of person.
Everyone here can look through him and his rethorics already😂
This guy speaks like he is spokesperson of Israel. Actually it doesn't matter, there is no distinction between two states any more, Ben Gvir can be FM for US for example.
He’s a dual citizen Israeli
He IS a spokesperson for Israel.
Good dogs don't bite their master. He's just being a good lassie
@@TheDivineNightno way. Oh my god
@@penyarol83Very true. We should do away with this "dual citizenship" crap.
Unacceptable. The US must bear the responsibility for what happens in Gaza.
US, West have controlled by Dracula, psychopath, Killer..
Except that they drag all of us to hell with them.
They are demons that's why
That record will never stop playing. It's infuriating.
It's an insult to human intelligence, I believe journalists should avoid attending his press conferences
Journalist should boycott US press conference. You only get lies all the time. why bother?
It's true they should stop attending, it will send a strong message
It would send a moral message but the US would love it unfortunately. They will be able to be complicit in their crimes with less exposure. At least here we can see the hypocrisy when we have good journalists asking the right questions.
With each conference those journalists uncover even more of the US hypocrisy.
The double standards are sickening
Tel aviv colonized washington dc long time ago before they colonized Palestine.. already 130 yrs at least?
We are truly living in Orwellian times.
Get rid of The Israeli Lobby!
AIPAC funds Congress and Senators, fully in control of the USA
Amen!!
Just how exactly? They used usury to sweep up all the world's money and used the money to buy everyone in power.
No chance. That train has left already. - Read ex US Congressman Paul Findley's books They Dare To Speak Out and Deliberate Deceptions.
@@aberserk9512😂😂😂
Prem Thakker thank you for the great question! The answer we got was enough for citizens to understand still does not make sense, considering the statements made by Israel to get rid of the Palestine's completely and continue with a genocide campaign.
What does USA say about Israel´s atrocities since at least 1947 ? The US government is doing what it feels expedient. Remember the rest of the world is not so easily fooled as you think. Don´t think this won´t affect sales of US products, services and USA will have fewer tourists than if their government was humane.
His lips are moving again. When that happens the liessssss fly out!
*Defender of Israel: "To claim that Israeli state leadership is untrustworthy is unfair".*
*Critic of Israel: "Then surely we must take Israeli leadership seriously when they make genocidal statements".*
*Defender of Israel: "No, you can't take Israeli leadership at their word. To do so would also be unfair".*
*Critic of Israel: "If that is the case, then why should anyone take seriously their defense?".*
Good job. Kudos to you.
But now you are accused of being antisemite... Say anything else and you are hamas
There's no reasoning with people who're inherently cynical & selfish with a superiority complex. They're just wasting our time. It's a shame we have to deal with these insincere manipulators just to convince others who might still have a sense of justice but have been fooled by these propagandists.
The israeli leaders that actually matter refer to hamas. The other MP making statements has no effect on the war just like you. YOUR OPINION DOES NOT MATTER IN THIS WAR
@@SDbleezy1 I am anti-occupation, anti-genocide, anti-land theft and anti-Zionist.
My opinions and actions mean EVERYTHING.
He didn't even answer the question 😂
He got mad because it showed his hypocrisy.
What a white lie from White House as part of their incremental Big Lie series, yet a-gain..!
UNRWA didn't find those allegations “credible”, it merely acted on abundance of caution because UN[O] agencies have to be extremely diplomatic in dealing with its members and accuser is not just a sovereign, it is a perpetrator who directly occupies - that's why the hiring due-diligence of UNRWA is essentially outsourced to them. That's why I can see why they did what they did, even though I feel they should have not - given the all-too-familiar history and pattern.
He ran away. Any allegation from them, unproven , act straight away. Spineless.
The universe knows how to settle scores. Might not be right now, but scores will be settled.
Basically he saying we don’t give two shite about Palestinians
Way to go, Prem! Excellent question 👏
He is working for Israel from state department
Pinoccio you know what happens when you don't tell the truth 😅
Pas besoin dans rajouter leurs nezs est mal proportionnes
Classic!
Mathew Miller must be regarded as a spokesperson for American values as a representative of the American government. Is he really representative of the values of the American people? As an Australian I hope not but if so I want out of our "alliance"
The follow-up question should have been why is us taking everything that Israel is saying at face value?
Perhaps because Hamas has a long history of lying about literally everything. You;d know that if you knew anything of the region and history, instead of blindly listening to Palestinian propaganda.
Or maybe simply, are you claiming that Hind and the medics trying to rescue her were terrorists?
Following question is..
Having member ou of 30 K employé suspected of terrorism for him is worst than having à state plosibly or I would say indighted.. for genocide... WOW!!!!..
😂😂😂😂😂
Exactly! There is no proof for the "human shield" argument,not a single shred of evidence! In fact it's israel who's killing civilians by using this "human shields" argument as they regard all Palestinians to be hms sympathisers and human animals!
"Israel" has not said one true thing since 10/7 (longer, actually, but let's be generous). The idea that anyone should trust anything they say is wild.
We can't even trust what they say when they have independent verification anymore. Remember when Biden told us that he saw the pictures of the 40 beheaded babies? Are you sure you saw those pictures, Biden? Are you sure? Because there weren't 40 beheaded babies. There weren't 40 dead babies. There weren't 4 dead babies.
What about the NYT independently confirming the accusations of systematic rape on 10/7... claims that have all shown that there really isn't any evidence at all.
"Israel" can do nothing but lie. We know that. But we're also learning that independent verification can't be trusted, either. Meanwhile, when the Gaza health ministry would update the number of dead Palestinians, "Israeli" leaders would shout that it is a Hamas controlled organization, and therefore terrorist and false. And yet, not only does that Gaza health ministry have a long track record of reliability, but we also found out that "Israel" was using Gaza health ministry numbers internally.
How can anyone say that after so many bombs on Gaza, and intentional targeting of hospitals and food trucks, that this is not intentional harm against civilians by a terrorist organization?? What incredible bias and mental gymnastics to pull that one.
They even target people like journalists.
Well, when a populace created a terrorist enclave and still supports those terrorists after undergoing this much bombing, then YOU thinking that they aren't literally the members of Hamas is pretty stupid.
zionist shill @@TruthFiction
@@norway178 Especially Al Jazeera.
@@TruthFiction What proof do you have that two million people who are currently being st arved are “continuing to support” or supported in the first place? Why don’t you ask Shaytanyahu why he keeps sending that “h” org mula if he’s so concerned about getting rid of it? Seems like it’s an excuse to “wi pe out the se ed of A ma lek”. Don’t think we haven’t seen what you think you say behind closes doors at this point. The tzionishts braowdcast h a te in broawd daylight. Enough lies from you. (Intentional mishpellang for the schensors).
Bla bla human shields bla bla. Seriously?
That was a superb question. The answer was useless and insensitive testifying of hearts with disease lacking compassion and justice..
The question was about the different application of funding decisions for UNWRA and Israel. The answer leapt to Hamas. UNWRA is not a terrorist organisation. If terrorism is defined by actions, how is Israel not a terrorist regime?
a dubious answer from Mr. Miller considering that since October 7th, the Israeli side has committed much more barbarity, including violations to international laws and conventions, than Hamas ever did in their whole history… but somehow, according to him, allegations about 12 or 13 persons possibly participating in one attack is more concerning than a whole army actually slaughtering civilians over a 4-month period, and counting… even when the actions of that army are recognized by significant numbers of international observers, and the ICJ, as plausibly genocidal… and even when cutting funding for the principal humanitarian organization in the region is likely to have catastrophic consequences for the population they're aiding, while cutting funding for the Israeli side will likely merely force them to reconsider their military operations…
Mr. Miller is right to note that there are false equivalencies embedded in there, but they're not the one he expresses : 1200+ is not equivalent to 28000+ and counting… one day of abhorrent rampage is not equivalent to 4 months of indiscriminate carnage and destruction… UNRWA is not Hamas… and through funding UNRWA the U.S. is not in breach of the Genocide Convention, but through funding the Israeli side, they plausibly are…
#Palestine #ceasefire #FreePalestine
🕊 🇵🇸 🍉 🙏🏻 ✌ ☮
Well-said, thank you @christopher.stewart
@@Nishful5 🙏
Ukraine done burned a hole in the bank.
Has no plan for the patch job
Absolute Liar
Sneaky, shady facial expression everytime, never disappoints.
This person needs to be in jail or a mental hospital, not on this seat
Julian Assange, set him free
This spokesperson is a lunatic
How does he sleep at night?
He does not care.
He probably sleeps like a baby because he is a soulless monster!
He thinks of his career prospects and lucrative future.
He watching genocide and death kids and baby,that help him to sleep 👹
In the spare bedroom, I am sure..
At this point, the hypocrisy is clear enough for even the blind to see
His eyes have been blinded by Israeli money.
There's an obvious false equivalency between Matt Miller and a human being.
People need to stop talking about October, 7th. All that happened, was a resistance movement doing resistance movement things, with the oppressor killing its own to make the resistance movement look bad. We didn't judge the resistance for their attacks against the Nazis in WW2, so why are we judging the resistance against the Nazis in the present?
Excellent comment.
Because we are the US government and we don't give a crap about what you and the rest of the taxpayers think. You don't have the intelligence to understand worldly things. Be compliant or else.
Well, the resistance to Nazis wasn't started after the people doing the resisting lost a genocidal war to steal all the land, which is exactly what the Palestinians Arabs tried to do in 1948. Perhaps if you people who say "Ignore Oct 7" actually knew history, you would say something more intelligent like "Oct 7 was yet another example in a long history of Palestinians attacking Israelis."
@@TruthFiction well if you want to talk about facts start with the displacement of 750,000 and murder of 15,000 Palestinians in 1948. Where women were raped and pregnant women were cut open, not like the made up atrocities on Oct 7th. As people say, all Isreali accusations are confessions. Isrealis have the dangerous combination of being both victims and superior and think they are justified in carrying out this genocide.
If you watched what was happening in a film right now would you say the IDF killing kids and luring Red Crescent to places to bomb them were the good guys? I think not. That is terrorism.
@@TruthFictionWhy not talk about zionist terrorist militias like the Haganah, Irgun, or Lehi from the 20s and 30s that later became the IDF? Fact is, muslims, jews and christians all lived peacefully in British Mandate Palestine until the zionists arrived, as early as 1917. They were the ones with extreme supremacist viewpoints, and they were the ones that terrorized the Palestinians first, well before the state of Israel was founded or before the Holocaust even started.
United snakes of denial and gaslighting
Hypocrites!
Excuses, Excuses, Excuses they will never ADMIT their wrong doings!
It’s a waste of time talking to a Ghoul whose only aim is to deflect any criticism that might convince humans to reject this genocide…..
He asked him about UNWRA, not Hamas. I don't understand the false equivalency argument...
He is equating Hamas to Palestinian ppl -what an jerk. It's like saying everyone who voted for Trump is guilty of the Jan 6th 'insurrection'
Brilliant questions 🎯
What a great reporter
US continues to support collective punishment .why not arrest the 12 suspects rather than stop aid?
There is no suspects. Thats the sad reality. Israel made it up.
The smirk on Miller's face every time he responds to questions is disgraceful. There's a clear lack of empathy, but what do we expect from someone who's complicit to the whole prejudice and violence perpetrated against Palestinians. May God have mercy on you, Miller!
Its always the same statement Hamas using civilians as human shields. But no remorse for committing genocide is utterly disgusting.
i wonder what he means about israeli forces not being 'intentionally' killing civilians the guns dont shoot themselves u know
I know, right? And quite antithetical to their position on gun terrorism domestically.