The title is missleading. Brian Cox is not narrating and it is just a supposed quote from him which seems to have little or nothing to do with the content of the video. Overall it’s a nice video, but nothing new as the title seems to suggest.
I stopped watching when it became obvious that this was simply someones 8th grade science project and as you say, literally nothing to do with Brian Cox. If he said something, I'd rather hear it from him.
I love pondering and musing these topics. I find it more relaxing, fulfilling, satisfying, and rewarding than anything on social media. Thank you, Space Wind channel and keep up the good work!
This is what I think, there has been something and always will be something for ever, never any real beginning or real end, for if any thing came about from something (logically it has to come from something rather than nothing) there would have to have been a preceding cause or event, ergo there would be a cause of the cause ad infinitum, if there were truly nothing and I mean truly nothing, then surely there would/could be only be nothing...
There can't be anything without an beginning. That is what we think. But as you said, maybe we need to begin thinking more in the range of what if something didn't begin and was always there therefore our whole way of thinking can change we we can start using that knowledge to understand some very difficult questions.
I am fascinated by this subject but can only watch/think about it for so long before its magnitude starts to fry my brain, so I switch off...til the NEXT time.
I like to think of the universe like a quantum particle. It decides where it’s at when observed. Since we are in the middle of this big bang cycle we can observe it in motion. The existence of the universe is fleeting. Probably no longer than fractions of a second on a greater cosmic level. Living in a microcosm of space time has our perspectives altered, seeing the universe as something ancient. But I enjoy the fact that us being present in the moment has slowed things down. We get to see the universe in action, in slow motion. Sometimes I wonder if the universe is just a micro particle, in the middle of a reaction. And we (the universe) happen to exist in this fraction of a second
Why is there something rather than nothing? First you gotta define nothing. Then realize there is no such thing as nothing. Nothing is a concept we made up. There was never nothingness.
Also what about the concept of matter was born after the nothing ? Allah says that first there was nothing except him and then he created every thing . So how are you sure there’s no concept of nothing ? We are bound to matter but not Allah . He can do whatever he wants . We are bound to space , Matter and physical laws but not Allah . So don’t ever say that there is no nothing . You never know until you have proof otherwise .
I really love that people, instead of saying we need to start again because we're probably wrong, just add time to the Big Bang from 13 to 26 billion years... Stay humble and start again, my friends
So, burn the ladder that got us here in the first place? That is not how progress works. You don't just burn down the house because you mis measured a window.
Discarding the theory of the big bang is not the same as burning the ladder. It is more akun to tracking back when you realize youre on the wrong path.
Buddha had said about this for 2600 years. There were all written in Tripitaka. He even stated about existence of extraterrestrial beings and the birth and death of universe. He also mentioned about multiverse too.
So the next question, if that answers part of the big bang... What caused the "inflation"? How long has the universe been (possibly) going through this cycle? What happened at the start of the Universe? Was there something before that, or maybe multi universes that spin in the same way a galaxy does...?
That dense tiny point that once existed, Inflated and thus caused the big bang must have begun somehow. So the question should be: What caused that tiny dense point to exist?
Most people still dont comprehend that tine is not measured in a straight line. "Before the big bang." Gravity compresses time, theory of relativity. All of the universe compressed to a singularity means that there was no time until inflation. Time and absolute gravity were one... There are still many questions, and maybe we will throw it all out some day, but asking "before the big bang" doesnt understand the discussion in the first place.
Just because it's expanding doesn't mean it always has been expanding? Our planet is heating but it was not always heating. Maybe the universe has an atmosphere, maybe things in the universe affect its atmosphere. Maybe these effects have caused it to expand.
These scientists change their mind constantly. They're always claiming they've solved the mystery or 3xisrence only 10yrs later vlaiming its something else
Did anyone question why at the speed of light time is ZERO? .... what if at the beginning of time there was exactly an equal amount of matter and antimatter, and were slingshot in opposite directions in time in that instance.... Matter forward in time and antimatter backward in time. We are treating time like a normal dimension but it isn't.
search VSL, variable speed of light. it also has lots of math behind and supports things much better then inflation theories. I read about everything they talked on this video about 20 years written in books in the 1980s and 1990. M Theory and string theory support the big bang and microwave background but require many dimensions. Also the math shows the strings are too massive to exist is our reality. thus 9, 10, 13 whatever number they pic dimensions required for the math to work.
"The big bang" is just the start of a new universe through a black hole. The supervova implodes sucking in matter and space and blows out the other end creating a new universe from the nebulas mass.
Nothing comes from nothing any sane person should know this complex universe with the most complicated being within it, human impossible to come up from nothing. There must be a creator, the one and only
Okay, but logically before the big bang there could have been a universe that collapsed on itself, there could be some multiverse theories, anotger dimension. However you can always, always go back to yeah there probably was a point in time where we get to no time and or matter, nothingness? No?
Honestly I love thinking and philosophical spitballing of what if? But truly we do not know our size and perspective scope in comparison to the size of cosmic events. So a small point of an atom to us, may be a quark to the universe or is actually a universe to those within said atom. It’s relative to your point of space time, and own level of size. I say this in that when you take things back to a potential primordial existence, the normal physics don’t exist yet, and so the paradigm has changed. There could be an entire universe inside said point, that is just immolated or shifted out of plane to what is born from that point. Forming an infinite chain of existence and universes. Sort of like a proverbial Russia Doll, but the mechanism of existing inside and its expression of expanding to the outside doesn’t follow the laws of physics. What’s to say that original inner universe isn’t still in existence? Or what if it is now existing with In us? I kinda picture it as the layers of matter of our planet and the stratospheres. Layers of an onion but on an infinite and multidimensional scale. And the relationship of the macro verse to the micro verse. They are reflections of each other, bound together and interlinked, but they also are opposing sides of a spectrum. So what if to a being far outside of our universe would view us now as an infinite hot point in space, because all it can really see is what’s around it, and the context in relation to them. Which is the same flaw in our own observations. Where we looking back to the “origin” can only see that infinitely hot point, never knowing what exists beyond the plane or membrane or event horizon of said point?
In the begging only Allah Existed and there will be a brief time period when every thing vanishes and only he exists and then he will recreate every thing . For the universe there’s a begging and and end but for Allah there’s is none meaning when nothing existed or will exist Allah will exist . The concept of time was also born at a certain point . Allah says in the Quran that he Created the Arsh then created the heavens and earth and placed his Arsh on a body of water and then sat on his arsh. There are hadiths about how the Arsh is and the Hadith is like our universe is like a ring in a desert compared to the 2nd heaven and then the second is like ring on desert to 3rd heaven and so forth until 7th heaven and then the 7th heaven is like a ring in the desert to the Arsh. So now you can imagine how big the Arsh of Allah is and how slow time is there and then think that above the Arsh is Allah so Allah is not bound to time infact he created time and there will be a time when he destroys every thing including the arsh. There will be nothing for many many years and he will ask 3 times whos out there now ? No body will answer and then he will answer himself I am . So praise your Allah before you die and every thing in the universe die and is recreated and the time is upon us where we have to account for every action in front of Allah . May Allah guide us like those who he favored . Ameen
If time stops for you, you won't notice, when it starts flowing again you won't feel a thing - The adjustment bureau film has this concept. If time stops for something else, and is moving for you, only then you will know Either that item is travelling at speed of light, matching the speed of time Or it will just disappear, meaning it's existence was till that specific time, and it's stuck exactly at that point, and you've moved on, so it doesn't exist for you anymore.
Academia love to spin wild wonderful tales. Say it with confidence and a British accent and wala, you have willing suckers hanging on every false made up word.
That's fine, but maybe he wants to know how he did it otherwise what's with all this space ? Is every human on the planet supposed to one day own their own world or several of them or their own Galaxy?
@@Spartacus547 it was part of his school project. He had to demonstrate how energy singularities are created and maintained but it exploded on his way to school The space, 3d nothingness, is just us watching something displayed on greenscreen like CGI inside the box thinking it to be lightyears away We're probably already in the trash right now
![[Live] : ONE 169 วันนี้!! "อนาโตลี vs อูมาร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IK3YZVWuFJg/mqdefault.jpg)
The title is missleading. Brian Cox is not narrating and it is just a supposed quote from him which seems to have little or nothing to do with the content of the video. Overall it’s a nice video, but nothing new as the title seems to suggest.
I stopped watching when it became obvious that this was simply someones 8th grade science project and as you say, literally nothing to do with Brian Cox. If he said something, I'd rather hear it from him.
It’s click bait
Thanks for saving my time
I love pondering and musing these topics. I find it more relaxing, fulfilling, satisfying, and rewarding than anything on social media. Thank you, Space Wind channel and keep up the good work!
This is what I think, there has been something and always will be something for ever, never any real beginning or real end, for if any thing came about from something (logically it has to come from something rather than nothing) there would have to have been a preceding cause or event, ergo there would be a cause of the cause ad infinitum, if there were truly nothing and I mean truly nothing, then surely there would/could be only be nothing...
There can't be anything without an beginning. That is what we think.
But as you said, maybe we need to begin thinking more in the range of what if something didn't begin and was always there therefore our whole way of thinking can change we we can start using that knowledge to understand some very difficult questions.
I am fascinated by this subject but can only watch/think about it for so long before its magnitude starts to fry my brain, so I switch off...til the NEXT time.
I like to think of the universe like a quantum particle. It decides where it’s at when observed. Since we are in the middle of this big bang cycle we can observe it in motion. The existence of the universe is fleeting. Probably no longer than fractions of a second on a greater cosmic level. Living in a microcosm of space time has our perspectives altered, seeing the universe as something ancient. But I enjoy the fact that us being present in the moment has slowed things down. We get to see the universe in action, in slow motion.
Sometimes I wonder if the universe is just a micro particle, in the middle of a reaction. And we (the universe) happen to exist in this fraction of a second
Why is there something rather than nothing? First you gotta define nothing. Then realize there is no such thing as nothing. Nothing is a concept we made up. There was never nothingness.
So define space ? The space between electrons and protons whats that space called ? Nothing doesn’t mean nothing 😮 lol
Also what about the concept of matter was born after the nothing ? Allah says that first there was nothing except him and then he created every thing . So how are you sure there’s no concept of nothing ? We are bound to matter but not Allah . He can do whatever he wants . We are bound to space , Matter and physical laws but not Allah . So don’t ever say that there is no nothing . You never know until you have proof otherwise .
I really love that people, instead of saying we need to start again because we're probably wrong, just add time to the Big Bang from 13 to 26 billion years... Stay humble and start again, my friends
So, burn the ladder that got us here in the first place?
That is not how progress works. You don't just burn down the house because you mis measured a window.
Discarding the theory of the big bang is not the same as burning the ladder. It is more akun to tracking back when you realize youre on the wrong path.
Buddha had said about this for 2600 years. There were all written in Tripitaka. He even stated about existence of extraterrestrial beings and the birth and death of universe. He also mentioned about multiverse too.
Maybe see this video: joe rogan about psychedelic dimensions and entities
The universe is older than we think
Finally! Now I can live in peace. Thank you B. Cox.
Great video and narration.
So the next question, if that answers part of the big bang...
What caused the "inflation"?
How long has the universe been (possibly) going through this cycle?
What happened at the start of the Universe?
Was there something before that, or maybe multi universes that spin in the same way a galaxy does...?
That dense tiny point that once existed, Inflated and thus caused the big bang must have begun somehow.
So the question should be:
What caused that tiny dense point to exist?
Most people still dont comprehend that tine is not measured in a straight line. "Before the big bang." Gravity compresses time, theory of relativity. All of the universe compressed to a singularity means that there was no time until inflation. Time and absolute gravity were one... There are still many questions, and maybe we will throw it all out some day, but asking "before the big bang" doesnt understand the discussion in the first place.
Just because it's expanding doesn't mean it always has been expanding?
Our planet is heating but it was not always heating.
Maybe the universe has an atmosphere, maybe things in the universe affect its atmosphere.
Maybe these effects have caused it to expand.
When you are nothing, you become Perfect.
I think the big bang, with all ,of its unanswered questions, as become scientific dogma, and the JWST is now challenging that dogma.
These scientists change their mind constantly. They're always claiming they've solved the mystery or 3xisrence only 10yrs later vlaiming its something else
I really like Brians Coxs
Did anyone question why at the speed of light time is ZERO?
....
what if at the beginning of time there was exactly an equal amount of matter and antimatter, and were slingshot in opposite directions in time in that instance.... Matter forward in time and antimatter backward in time.
We are treating time like a normal dimension but it isn't.
search VSL, variable speed of light. it also has lots of math behind and supports things much better then inflation theories. I read about everything they talked on this video about 20 years written in books in the 1980s and 1990. M Theory and string theory support the big bang and microwave background but require many dimensions. Also the math shows the strings are too massive to exist is our reality. thus 9, 10, 13 whatever number they pic dimensions required for the math to work.
"The big bang" is just the start of a new universe through a black hole. The supervova implodes sucking in matter and space and blows out the other end creating a new universe from the nebulas mass.
Idk why no one thought that anything didn't exist before the bang. No shit. Of course matter had to come from somewhere.
universe expands to its max and then will collapse again just to expand again. its like an yoyo....
What I like about channel like this made by AI is I can block them. And never see them again.
So pretty much we are all doomed no matter what and everything is pointless.
Spoiler alert. We just guessing we don’t know and let’s face it, we will NEVER truly know
Nothing comes from nothing any sane person should know this complex universe with the most complicated being within it, human impossible to come up from nothing. There must be a creator, the one and only
Who made the creator?
We grow from an egg and a sperm then expand by eating and drinking, the universe
Physics has to defy Physics for any of this to work
time has always existed
Your Right, because there is no time before time started to exist
Time existed before the beginning of our time
But time then was timeless, before time was time itself. Time.
''you can't argue with that, cause we can see it''. That's the end of me watching this video.
These people don’t know anything they’re 99% wrong all the time. “Oops, we were wrong”.
Apparently you are just figuring out how science works.
@@thisguyoverhere001 it’s something I’ve known for a long time now
Yep, it’s called “West Ham”
Pull force, is why it's still expanding.
Pull? What is pulling us?
For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction ie they cross each other out and come to nothing
Its not spacetime fabric in the universe its space time fluid
I believe in the before 1927 Universe
Okay, but logically before the big bang there could have been a universe that collapsed on itself, there could be some multiverse theories, anotger dimension. However you can always, always go back to yeah there probably was a point in time where we get to no time and or matter, nothingness? No?
Honestly I love thinking and philosophical spitballing of what if? But truly we do not know our size and perspective scope in comparison to the size of cosmic events. So a small point of an atom to us, may be a quark to the universe or is actually a universe to those within said atom. It’s relative to your point of space time, and own level of size. I say this in that when you take things back to a potential primordial existence, the normal physics don’t exist yet, and so the paradigm has changed. There could be an entire universe inside said point, that is just immolated or shifted out of plane to what is born from that point. Forming an infinite chain of existence and universes. Sort of like a proverbial Russia Doll, but the mechanism of existing inside and its expression of expanding to the outside doesn’t follow the laws of physics. What’s to say that original inner universe isn’t still in existence? Or what if it is now existing with In us? I kinda picture it as the layers of matter of our planet and the stratospheres. Layers of an onion but on an infinite and multidimensional scale. And the relationship of the macro verse to the micro verse. They are reflections of each other, bound together and interlinked, but they also are opposing sides of a spectrum. So what if to a being far outside of our universe would view us now as an infinite hot point in space, because all it can really see is what’s around it, and the context in relation to them. Which is the same flaw in our own observations. Where we looking back to the “origin” can only see that infinitely hot point, never knowing what exists beyond the plane or membrane or event horizon of said point?
In the begging only Allah Existed and there will be a brief time period when every thing vanishes and only he exists and then he will recreate every thing . For the universe there’s a begging and and end but for Allah there’s is none meaning when nothing existed or will exist Allah will exist . The concept of time was also born at a certain point . Allah says in the Quran that he Created the Arsh then created the heavens and earth and placed his Arsh on a body of water and then sat on his arsh. There are hadiths about how the Arsh is and the Hadith is like our universe is like a ring in a desert compared to the 2nd heaven and then the second is like ring on desert to 3rd heaven and so forth until 7th heaven and then the 7th heaven is like a ring in the desert to the Arsh. So now you can imagine how big the Arsh of Allah is and how slow time is there and then think that above the Arsh is Allah so Allah is not bound to time infact he created time and there will be a time when he destroys every thing including the arsh. There will be nothing for many many years and he will ask 3 times whos out there now ? No body will answer and then he will answer himself I am . So praise your Allah before you die and every thing in the universe die and is recreated and the time is upon us where we have to account for every action in front of Allah . May Allah guide us like those who he favored . Ameen
What is time anyway. Would anybody notice if it stopped. Would all the clocks in the world stop
I mean and i could be wrong but isnt time just a man made construct to measure orbit around the sun
Time is entropy. Always moving in the same direction from one state to another.
How would you stop time ignoring time does not stop time and yes you would notice
If time stops for you, you won't notice, when it starts flowing again you won't feel a thing - The adjustment bureau film has this concept.
If time stops for something else, and is moving for you, only then you will know
Either that item is travelling at speed of light, matching the speed of time
Or it will just disappear, meaning it's existence was till that specific time, and it's stuck exactly at that point, and you've moved on, so it doesn't exist for you anymore.
I think white holes are big bangs
Sikhism in a nutshell The singularity has no beginning and no end
No one will ever know, its all guess work.
Thumbs down for posting old content + misleading title.
This is mostly word soup filler with a bit of Brian Cox at the beginning, yawn
What was before the beginning of time?
What natural number is smaler then 1?
Where is the brain in Trump?
Same place yours is.
@@fkxfkx i am not sure.
What is a woman?
Academia love to spin wild wonderful tales. Say it with confidence and a British accent and wala, you have willing suckers hanging on every false made up word.
Let's see any proof for dark matter
Something massive!? These devils have never heard of God?😂😂
Pointless questions and pointless answers
...and pointless comments. Round and round and round we go.
Lots of hot air here and no substance.
Wuhan??? Lol...what you speaking is just pure english and what you know based on your vocabulary. Sigh.
the anwser is God .
That's fine, but maybe he wants to know how he did it otherwise what's with all this space ? Is every human on the planet supposed to one day own their own world or several of them or their own Galaxy?
@@Spartacus547 nobody knows
@@Spartacus547 it's more likely that all this space is what it takes to create the balance required for us to exist
@@Spartacus547 it was part of his school project. He had to demonstrate how energy singularities are created and maintained but it exploded on his way to school
The space, 3d nothingness, is just us watching something displayed on greenscreen like CGI inside the box thinking it to be lightyears away
We're probably already in the trash right now
*shiva - That which is not 🙏*
The religious are ready to claim whatever is discovered in the name of religion 😂