Quentin Zusatz They are about the same price here in Washington state. I am a big Wild Turkey 101 fan. But at times the mellower Buffalo Trace sounds good. I buy both. But for $50 I would never buy it
You are absolutely right! I had few bottles of Buffalo last summer in our summercabin and they really made my (and my friend) evenings worth of living..:) Bulleit is also good but very different, it´s taste is strong while Buffalo is smooth and easy to drink.
Two years later, just discovered your channel. Great stuff! I prefer Buffalo Trace as an everyday whisky, but in my opinion Bulleit has more interesting flavours to taste. However Buffalo Trace is thicker with a better mouthfeel. Then again BT is "woody" and that leads to a drier finish than Bulleit. Both are great.
Glad you found me! My preference has moved over time too. I enjoy both, but find more people I share with prefer the sweet, coating BT over the spicier Bulleit. Cheers!
For me, definitely Buffalo Trace is far superior. I drink neat. It is very smooth but interesting. Fuller in the mouth. Bulleit tastes cheaper, thinner and younger, though the peppery kick is quite nice. I think a drop of water helps smooth it out and bring out more subtleties.
Welcome to the channel! Thanks for the comment and I hope your journey in whisky is exciting. If it's like mine, you'll inevitably pick up a few bottles that will just shake your head, but I have really found some great expressions in Bourbon lately and I hope you do too!
I do really love Buffalo Trace. Now in 2019, it's getting tricky to find any of the distillery's products. For the price I really don't think you can beat it. While watching this I just finished a bottle and now I'm having a store select of one of their bottles. SO tasty!
2 years late and seeing this review for the first time...tried buffalo trace and loved it. Drank it neat and in an old fashioned recipe, so good either way. Thanks!
Glad you enjoyed the review. I try to just share what I am tasting. Awesome to know someone is watching from Texas! My parents lived there for years, but that was a long time ago! Cheers!
I just bought this frontier whisky today. Coming from a wild turkey 101 fan that drinks 101 daily, if you’re a WT101 man then try this one here. My new favorite!
Here in Upstate NY Bulleit will run me between $35 and $40 a 1L bottle. I love Bulleit haven't grabbed Buffalo Trace. Love the spicy rye notes in Bulleit, but it is my first bourbon.
njmevec I appreciate the spice in Bulleit too. Holds up in cocktails too. BT is a bit sweeter and maybe smoother IMO. Worth trying if you like drinking neat.
Great review. Buffalo trace is a decent dram . An easy sipper and I like it , but I'm a 101 fan now and it's a few bucks less too . Although It's been a while so maybe I will try it again. Cheers
I enjoy both, the Bulleit rye is also a good drink. I do not mix any bourbons, I enjoy them straight. I can’t understand how jack Daniels is so popular. It tastes like charred wood. Buffalo trace is a fine and smooth drink
I too get the most enjoyment out of straight whiskey. However, there are lots of different preferences out there and I am good with that. Have you given any of the single barrel JDs a chance? Much better than No. 7. Cheers!
I agree, Jack Daniels is popular here in Finland too which i can´t understand, but i love Buffalo Trace and i´m wondering why it´s not well known here like Jack Daniels. Maybe it´s because Jack Daniels has a status of rockstars whiskey..
I recently got both Bulleit and Buffalo Trace. I used to drink Makers Mark and Buffalo trace and liked them both until I got chemical burns from Makers mark, oddly other whiskeys didn't give me the same chemical burn effect as Makers (erven high proof stuff) so I got out of bourbon for a while but have recently got back into it. I got some on sale whiskeys like plain old wild Turkey and while I did not care for it as a sipper, it was amazing as a mixer with Ginger ale.... so I've been starting to experiment again. I've gone into some Rare Breed and loved it (had to water or ice it to really bring out the smell and flavor but now its amazing) Knob Creek is ok but when I have Wild Turkey first and go to Knob Creek 9 a bit after, it's soooo much better not sure why. I tried Bulleit and hated it as a sipper but really love it mixed with Ginger ale... So I like a bit sweeter Bourbon and figured I'd try Buffalo Trace again as it was on sale but I find it way to weak now straight and it seems to be missing something even straight... it also doesn't mix well with anything as its washed out... I don't think I'd ever keep Buffalo Trace anymore but Bulleit, while not my favorite sipper, it is amazing mixed with anything, the rye helps a little, it has a stronger bourbon taste and it even feels like it has more kick. I don't know how I can really enjoy BT anymore.... perhaps I got a bad bottle??? Rare breed though with a bit of ice or water really comes alive, it has a super mouth feel (much thicker feeling) and the flavor is more complex and I love the crème Brule'/vanilla notes I get from it, straight the proof kind of kills the nose and taste but a tiny bit of water wakes it all up ... I've found Craft Cellars in Calgary have Rare Breed on for $39.99, so I think I'm going to get another.. that is something like 40% off!!!
Great walkthrough of your experience and what a fantastic sale at Craft Cellars. I really enjoy Rare Breed. It is on of my "allways on the shelf" releases. Thanks for sharing!
Nice video! Buffalo Trace is most certainly a very good bourbon and whiskey for the price. This, Teacher's and Tomatin Legacy are my go to budget whiskies. Would be interesting to do a blind test between the two Buffalo and Bulleit 😁
Bulliet and Bulliet rye are our faves for old fashioneds. For straight sipping woodford reserve or buffalo trace are so smooth. God I do like that Bulliet spice though. Great video sir from MN (with Canadian roots) :)
It's my 34th birthday today & i'm drinking Bulleit for the first time, i picked it up a few days ago for £18. It's the first bourbon i've bought (I'm normally a JD Man) Really enjoying it 👌🏻
Buffalo Trace is my fav. In Texas I buy it for $26. In Oklahoma $29. Bulleit is around $29. Just paying extra for a cooler bottle. As a mixer, Bulleit Rye in coke or Dr Pepper rocks the house.
Whisky Neighbour one I really am loving at the moment is Noah’s mill, nice abv, on the sweeter side. And bookers is always delicious! Curious to what your favorites are!
@@fishingpro64 for Bourbon, I am enjoying higher proof these days. Rarebreed, Bookers, Knob Creek Single Barrel. With the weather turning cold up here, I am moving more into Scotch though.
As a complete rookie to bourbon (and whisky in general), I find Buffalo Trace similar to a Canadian whisky in regards to sweetness and gentleness on the nose. That being said, I would love a video on how you develop and learn how to smell and taste a whisky! Cheers for another great video. As a fellow Canadian I just appreciate the humbleness and openness that you come with in your reviews.
You are too kind! I do want these moments to be more like sharing a dram then a deep critique. I try to talk about what I'm tasting more in the moment and see where it goes. Thanks for watching, and that is a good idea for a video, I'll think about how to approach it. Cheers!
There both amazing pours, I really like both of them I like the bulleit a lot more I don’t seem to get a headache of it like trace can do . To me at least I’m on medication and I should never really drink 🍹 but! I love bourbon 🥃 real new to it but I’m enjoying it I love the bulleit
Yeah been looking to increase in the future with Makers mark, Bulleit Rye. Also do you think Knobs creek and Wild turkey 101 are worth the extra price :) ?
I enjoy Makers and also Bulleit Rye, though that one is a bit rough or the alcohol is forward. I like the regular Knob Creek 9 year old, but I would not rate it higher than Buffalo Trace. I would rate the "single barrel" version fairly high and do pay more for it to keep it on the shelf. WT 101 is good, but I would look for a sale. Some really love it, I know my nephew does, but I do not regularly stock it. Enjoy the journey finding out what you like!
Hey man great help! Cant wait to start my journey and finding what I enjoy, your videos are very informative and helps me understand more about whiskey! Thank you! :)
What's the difference between Bulleit Frontier and Rye? Also, I had Buffalo Trace and B Frontier, I give a slight edge neat to BT but a decisive edge to the Bulleit mixing it with a coke.
Frontier is their Bourbon, so it is made from a high Rye mashbill. Likely 68% Corn, 28% Rye, 4% Barley. Bulleit Rye is 95% Rye, 5% Barley. The Rye is more cracked pepper and some grass or herb notes.
Nice to hear from a Canadian. I watch the videos also, and can;t believe how cheap bourbon is in the USA either. They are very lucky in that regard.....
I am not sure where you are at. Around here, Welller Special Reserve goes for $35 CND, and would be an excellent introduction to Bourbon. Buffalo Trace, that I talk about here, is really good too, and goes for about $27 CND. It would be tough to find better at that price point.
Is the Buffalo Trace worth $30? I haven't even finished my first bottle of Jim Beam Black yet that I bought for $25 a couple of weeks ago and still have another new bottle in the cupboard. Last Christmas also bought a couple bottles of cheap Ezra Brooks bourbon for just $22 which I still have a bottle left.
@@WhiskyNeighbour Personally I don't like paying more than $25 for bourbon, especially considering how cheap it is down in the States. But there's something about the taste of bourbon that has that certain unique kick in taste that other whiskies do not have. I don't what it is, bourbon always has that extra kick in taste ever since the first time I tasted it, Crown Royal and Canadian Club don't have it and neither does Jack Daniels.
Nice review, I like the Buffalo trace as my sipper..I have both these..and I think the Bulleit is better for cocktails or as a mixer with like coke or ginger ale..but I like the BT neat !. Cheers from Camrose !
Chris Beaton Thanks for dropping in. Bulleit and Ginger Ale ... I have never had that combo, but I think I will give it a go. I bet the rye and Ginger make for a spicy combo. Cheers!
Whisky Neighbour also found the Glenromdach12 u mentioned here at superstore liquor in Camrose for 50.99 regular price. Solo across streets price for same juice is 69.99. Crazy difference
Chris Beaton Wow! It sure pays to look around eh?! I hope you enjoy the GlenDronach. I was surprised how much I did this year. A few years back I did not take to heavy Sherry. Palates evolve I guess! It would be great to see you at a tasting.
A bit different with everyone and their taste preference. I would say start using it in your favourite cocktails, but those that are simple and mostly whisky. Like an Old Fashioned. Then just over ice and small sips. Also, come back to it after a while and you may find you have warmed to it.
Buffalo Trace is very hard to find these days in Maryland, USA. Had to get on a waitlist at one of the local sellers to even have a chance. I just tried Bulleit for the first time yesterday and really liked it. I'm new to bourbon, so I'm still figuring out what I think is good and what I can taste. I got a real good cinammon finish from the Bulleit, is that the rye? If so, maybe I'll need to try more of that style.
Glad you are on the journey! Rye does often give a spice note. Cinnamon or black pepper can be apart of that. Whisky Advocate had a good article whiskyadvocate.com/rye-whiskey-scale-list/
I've been wanting to try Buffalo Trace for a couple of months now. I live in NC near the border with SC and can't find it in any of the liquor stores near me. I've tried Eagle Rare and loved it. Still waiting for a taste of Buffalo Trace.
I like the idea of letting it rest, a minute in the glass for every year. Rolling in the mouth? I am not sure. Certainly give it time, and several sips. More with age, bit l am not sure of making that a rule.
I'm new to bourbon I've bought Buffalo Trace twice ,got some Bulleit yesterday .I like them both ,the Bulleit seems a little smoother for me as a noob though .
Just getting more into whisky and my first couple of bottles are these two. Enjoying both but also BT is what I'd lean too. Also Highland wine and spirits currently has thes on sale here in Edmonton. Also awsome to be a new subscriber to a fellow Edmontonian.
@@WhiskyNeighbour Bulleit is $34.99 and I believe BT is the same regular around $40. Not sure if they are cheaper at diff locations but Thats what they are at Highlands on 170th st. Also a new follower on Insta.
Ever noticed bulleit's sticker is put on sideways on the bottle? is it deliberate or is it the factory workers all drunk and flat out putting it on straight?
Hand labeled johhnie walker probably copied bulleit not the other way around so i was told by a bottling enthusiest and that's all jonnie walker was a blending of other distillers but relied heavy on bottling presentation as for buleit they are a proper distillery @@WhiskyNeighbour
I just grabbed a fifth of Bulleit for Christmas Eve. I usually drink Four Roses small batch or Woodford Reserve. We’ll see. I just drink it neet or occasionally over ice. Hope I’m not disappointed
I've tried several bourbons. They're all great. Buffalo Trace, Knob Creek, Four Roses Small Batch...really hard to say which ones I like over the others. *shrug* Thanks for the review.
Nothing wrong with liking bourbon from a variety of distilleries! Just means they'll have something good in the store when you want. Take care, and enjoy the weekend!
I haven’t tried Buffalo Trace yet , but I really like Bulleit Bourbon and their bottle is cool ,looks like it’s from the old west. But I’ll have to try Buffalo Trace soon. Most of the Time I sip Wild Turkey 101,Jameson or Rock Town 100 proof Apple Pie Moonshine. I purchased Bulliet Bourbon on sale here in Arkansas for $22 ,usually Buffalo Trace is usually $30.
i bought a bottle of buffalo trace tonight and having a dram while i watch your review....its an easy drinking bourbon easy to drink neat no water, and has a short finish with no after burn
Right now, I'm trying to choose between Buffalo Trace & Bulleit, no matter what I choose in the end though, I definitely want to try both of them at some point.
@@WhiskyNeighbour I honestly didnt expect a response but thank you! I haven't done alot of research into buffalo trace but i'm going to look at a few more reviews before I make a final decision. Also I just want you to know that this review was very helpful for a rather inexperienced drinker like myself. Thanks again.
Both are excellent. Buffalo Trace is smoother, fuller taste, but no rye. Bulliet is definitely spicier, you can taste rye and it is quite interesting and refreshing. I go back and forward depending on what I am in mood for and what I am eating. Both are excellent choices.
Both those are 56-65 here and australia but the bad tthing is theyat 40% and only come n 700ml .bbbut yep thats why we allways go for a w.t 101 instead for same price..dnt mind the buffalo travehavnmt tried d bt but
Interesting, Jon, I tried them both some time ago but for some reason didn't got them on my bar, while i still have some regular entry level Four Roses in...I hear diverse opinions about the Bulleit Rye & 10 yo Bourbon but some more limited releases seem more popular (such as the Blender's Select, but it is impossible to find here). Nice comparison...
@@WhiskyNeighbour Yeah good review despite all the mess in the background sound wise (I felt for you !)..my first Bourbon was Maker's Mark, then to answer your question regular Four Roses, Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select (but it seems to have changed a lot, not necessarily for better), Jim Beam Double Black, stuff like that...I still remember a Bourbon I liked a lot called Johnny Drum but that I struggle to find now, but you'll be surprised some of my favorite American whiskeys can't be called Bourbons (Michter's Unblended American Whiskey & Sour Mash are 2 "luxury entry level" whiskies that are for me super well crafted, even if it is sourced they nailed it with those). I also started with Blanton's Special Reserve but I quickly found it a bit weak compared to the Original & even more to my 2012 stunning Gold Edition I still have & to the SFTB...I still have a lot of samples from friends to try, entry level ones but also some high end stuff as well, just want to give them the best opportunity to shine & take decent notes, not knock em down quickly in a live show or else...I have to say also that 2018 for me was a revelation about what Rye whiskies could bring on the table & especially Canadian ones, with great tasting opportunities (samples sent by a generous guy from Oakville) & great meetings too (Don Livermore, of course, in a show but also in my flat to do a Live show), and there'll be more to come about it on my channel soon, btw 😉 Other than that within a month or two I'll have a great story to tell with (spoiler) how Canadian Rye did influence me while blending a French whisky for real (at a distillery) that will be released soon here....
@@GregsWhiskyGuide Wow! I can't wait to hear more about your blending journey. Thanks for sharing more insight into your early Bourbon ideas and so good to know Rye has now influenced your experience. Mine too!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Thanks a lot, Jon, I will keep you posted...I don't wanna sound biased or paid or anything but I could say "Lot 40 changed my life", lol...And I'm happy to own just one bottle ok but what a bottle, the "JP Wiser's "Dissertation' that has a lot in it...Cheers ! PS I see you're on Twitter too so I might send you some stuff on DM 😉
Whiskey neighbor, It's funny because these are the only two Bourbons I like. I am surprised you did a video on them, good! I wanted to tell you that I really like the Bulleit Barrel Strength which I'm sure you have heard, If not give it a try!
MrRaymo88 Barrel Strength .... Sounds awesome, I have not seen it around here, but I do enjoy higher ABV expressions. I find it bring out so much flavour! Thanks for the tip
Your notes on the nose and the pallet are spot on with my experiences. While both whiskeys are perfectly tolerably drinkable neat, Buffalo Trace is my favorite budget sipper. Bulliet can tend to give me a bit of heartburn over Buffalo trace. Both are absolutely fantastic in a gold-rush.(half a lemon juiced, 2oz pour of bourbon, and a measure of honey mixed well shaken over then served on ice)
Good idea for a review of these two, popular bourbons. I have both so I was interested to hear your contrast and comparison. Mash vs rye so a little apple to orange but even so it helps to describe them as you have done. Good to know rye bourbon isn’t as dry and unsweet like a scotch and has at least a bit of floral and fruit and not just spice, leather, peat, burned tire and pepper like some scotch (I hate those kinda scotches). Many thanks!
I loved my first bottle of Buffalo Trace. It went by FAST. But by my third bottle, having also tried Four Roses, Maker's Mark, Bulleit and Wild Turkey 101, Buffalo Trace (in Germany at 40% ABV) became far too watery for me. If we could get it at 45%, it would be great. But at 40%, I prefer Maker's Mark and Bulleit.
Thanks for sharing your journey. I imagine I would be similar. I enjoy Buffalo Trace a fair amount, but if it was only 40% it would likely become to honey sweet and light. I need a little kick in my bourbon! Cheers!
It was a glass of bulliet that re-introduced me to basic American bourbon. Jack Daniels watered down their whiskey back about 1980. Right after Jim Beam had done the same. I thought my tastes had changed and that I now preferred Scotch. That first glass made me think maybe I need to re try bourbon. It turn out that I had been missing out for a number of years. There is a lot of good whiskey out there in this world. Most of it is not that expensive.
What proof was Jack & Jim before the 80s? I remember when I was bartending around 2004 or so Jack went from 90 proof down to 80. When it was reduced we had tons of the old 90 proof stocked up and when Jack drinkers noticed it was the old stuff they were all offering a lot of money to buy a bottle from us.
@@WhiskyNeighbour I'm definitely going to try buffalo trace whiskey l don't mind spend a bit more On buffalo trace better taste then Jack Daniels!😁😁😁😎😎😎
Whisky Neighbour Brand new the the the whiskey game. I like the BT and have never had the Bulleit . My whiskey “experience” is all Jack and Coke in the late 70’s and early 80’s so I need to make up for lost time! Hoping to try as many as I can before I start pushing up daisies! Videos like yours help point me in the right direction so many thanks! Keep your powder dry and the wind at your back! Way too many exclamation points in that little reply.
@@gregusmc2868 I wish you many great drams in the future then! If you enjoy BT, a possible next stop on the journey might be Weller. It is also a little smoother than some yet affordable. Cheers 🥃
Gotta give BT some love... 3.75 Stars. Lol. Bulliet Rye makes the best Old fashioned. Aggree with your review. BT is the best sipper Bulliet the best mixer.
I'm more of a Rye guy but finally got my hands on a bottle of Buffalo to do this comparison against a bottle of Bulleit I've had open for a year now. I agree with many of Jon's notes, Buffalo is more smooth. approachable, rounded but for me Bulleit has a stronger corn mash and an earthy smell and taste. It was the batch or the old open bottle? maybe. Still both are good Kentucky Bourbons to try. Cheers.
I fond myself having difficulties to get over the rye spice, I am more of a scotch guy, but I would like to enjoy a bourbon, not only wheated ones. Am I wack if even with the buffalo trace i got that taste of rye that makes me not wanting another glasse?
Hmm, no, if you taste that, you are spot on. Everyone's palate is different. I am not sure what to recommend. Of the "non-wheated" bourbons, BT is fairly soft. Maybe try a dram of Eagle Rare. Similar, but perhaps a bit smoother due to age. I think Dickle is low Rye, but I am not a fan. Still, might be worth a try!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Thanks for the advices. Also, do you know a little bit about the whisky from Quebec? The government controls the alcohol sells and whiskey is more expensive. If you go on the SAQ.com website, are you able to tell me the good value whiskies for the money. I would love to have the opinion from someone who lives in an other province!
@@FATmonkeyMAMA I would love too. Shopping is a big part of what I do. I always check the LCBO and BCLiqour too. However, they have a very large list. Is there a range or a style you are interested in? That would help!
Well, I took a look. First, I can say your prices are significantly more than I pay in AB. Not for everything, but certainly on average. Best values I saw; Kilkerran 12, Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban, Bruichladdich Classic, Achentoshan Three Wood, Deanston Virgin Oak, Glendronach 12 year, and Tobermory 10year
BULLIET: It as a nice aged 'oily' feel, not harsh, not too spicy, with obvious oak flavor, it does not dry my mouth at all ...Its pretty darn good neat and a real bargain for the price...cheers
Two of my favorite Kentucky bourbons, or any bourbon. I do hope that Bulleit will someday distill their own grain neutral spirits (they buy from MGP, Indiana). Either way, two of the best, at very reasonable prices. Thanks for this vid!
For many years the only booze from the USA I knew was Jack Daniel´s and Jim Beam, which are really not bad at all, but also not that great. A few weeks ago I tasted some Maker´s Mark and my whole point of view changed... until I had some Bulleit. Never tried Buffalo Trace, but I will give it a chance. Blanton Single Barrel is also good, but in my humble opinion, Bulleit tastes better - shoot me for that, but that´s what I think about that. For now, Bulleit is my favorite Whiskey to have a nice sip, Maker´s Mark to mix some good Old Fashioned. Usually I only drink Single Malt Scotch, but obviously there are some really, really good Bourbons out there. Sorry for my bad English, I an German. Have a great time, Ladies and Gentlemen, enjoy the drinks you like :)
Thank you, Sir. As it seems, my preferenced of taste tend to rye, because the ones with more corn, are not really the ones I like, but maybe that´s only a matter of time and I have to taste some more :) Have a good one!
I’m also new to bourbon, acquired a good variety over the last few months and I need to say, when your pallet is adjusted to the bourbon, try four roses single barrel
Great Review. I'm sipping some Buffalo Trace as I write this, I'm not sure what area of the city you reside in? I heard you mention Sherwood Park I recently picked up a bottle of Bookers at the liquor depot in the Southside (23rd ave) for $60 regular $83 & change.. I do believe. I'm Slowly transitioning into a whiskey snob. I appreciate you're honesty in the reviews keep them coming. Subscribed!
Jared Helldrum thanks for the sub Jared. That is a great price for Booker's! Liqour depot has some great sales from time to time, looks like you found one :) I love sharing some of my thoughts, and while they are not the most detailed, they are my experience! I live in St. Albert, but I am often in the city since my folks are on the Southside. Enjoy the Bourbon!
John Belushi sorry for the late response it was a 6yr 1mo batch #2016-01E 63.85%(127.7 proof I'm hoping to one day see a sale price on Jefferson's aged at sea!
dylan dewalt I would say, BT is smoother and a little sweeter. Bulleit has a little more flavour and spice, but lacks that sour edge that many people like in Wild Turkey. I am not a big Wild Turkey fan though, so no doubt I am biased.
after sipping talisker "storm", laphroig 10, rittenhouse and george dickel "rye" for the last few days, it's time for a bourbon. i planned on buffalo trace and went back a little ways to find this video to get your opinion. i'm sure i won't be disappointed. thanks for the video
Thanks for the review. I usually drink Bulleit, but tonight is my bday and I want to try something new. So I think ill get some Buffalo Trace and try it neat. Not a big fan of mixing my Whiskey with anything
Richard Nelson - Happy belated birthday!! In my experience, Buffalo Trace really benefits from adding a little bit of water and letting it sit for five minutes or so. It's like all of the flavor that's locked within is set free to dance on your tongue.
Hey, nice review. Where are you in Canada ? I'm in Québec and Buffalo Trace is 43$ and I bought a Bulleit bottle on sale for 35$. It's my first ever Bourbon and I'm really enjoying it so far!
Glad you are enjoying it! I think these are both tasty, but different enough to appeal to different tastes or moods. I am in Alberta. Both continue to be the same price out here. Cheers!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Ok cool! I'll definitely want to try Buffalo Trace at some point in the future. But I was planning on trying Maker's Mark next. It is sold at 39$ for the 750 ml bottle and I've seen very good reviews on it. Have you tried it ?
@@drax14QC yes! Many people enjoy MM. I do too, but not my favorite. For wheated, I like Weller's a little more. I also enjoy Elijah Craig a lot, but it can be pricey. I good value is Wild Turkey 101. It has a sour note that can out some people off, but great for the price usually.
Funny how people's taste varies; I've tried Buffalo Trace twice (that's two bottles). Thought it was thin. The second time I tried Bulleit, I was sold.
Mark Antony Neil Bulleit Rye! I like that too, but most find it rough or alcohol forward. I think that one also holds up well in cocktails. Sadly I can only get 4 Roses yellow label around here and not any of their small batch or single barrel I here so much about.
Whisky Neighbour it is surprisingly rare here as I only know of the store Marks and Spencers that sells small batch and only in their major stores (no even on their website)
Started my bourbon journey with Buffalo Trace, and I liked it, but wanted to try others too. After many great bourbons Buffalo Trace is still my favourite for the price. I came from Japanese and Irish whiskys, and I have to admit now that I really like bourbons too, and not only bourbons, but Rye too. Bulleit Rye is definitely a nice whiskey, sweet and spicy at the same time, fresh and well balanced.
Buffalo trace has an awesome tour. It's a bourbon must! If you're in the area of Lexington KY hit up liquor barn (the larger one) they have a wide selection.
Bruh the first time I tried bulliet I ended up using it as fire ignition lol, it was too strong for me. I’ve built up my taste much since then so maybe I’ll try it again
Hello John! To my taste Bulleit Bourbon is far more interesting, so Iove it and don't find it astringent at all by smell or whatsoever but "one man's meat is another man's poison"))) Cheers buddy!)
Yep, all-on mood buddy. But I don't like a lot of sweetness in rum, whisky, gin-whatsoever and prefer okyness and spices (Am I correct in spelling "okyness", is there such a word?)
I just this weekend picked up a bottle of Buffalo Trace at the recommendation of the clerk at the liquor store. Absolutely love it! Hooked!
Sorry I missed this comment! So glad you picked it up and enjoy it!
Well good 4u
I love how life gets involved. The roofers in the background is just life. Good reviews.
Thanks! My conversations are a hobby and something I enjoy. I am glad when they work out and can be something other people enjoy too.
I highly recommend Buffalo Trace
It is a 100% sipper at a mixer price point.
it's 50canadian$ unfortunately! For 10$ less we have Wild turkey 101!
Quentin Zusatz They are about the same price here in Washington state. I am a big Wild Turkey 101 fan. But at times the mellower Buffalo Trace sounds good. I buy both. But for $50 I would never buy it
You are absolutely right! I had few bottles of Buffalo last summer in our summercabin and they really made my (and my friend) evenings worth of living..:) Bulleit is also good but very different, it´s taste is strong while Buffalo is smooth and easy to drink.
Buffalo is a wheated Bourbon, so smooth is it’s strength!
I’m a beginner...beer drinker for years!! Buffalo Trace is very very god for the price
Two years later, just discovered your channel. Great stuff! I prefer Buffalo Trace as an everyday whisky, but in my opinion Bulleit has more interesting flavours to taste. However Buffalo Trace is thicker with a better mouthfeel. Then again BT is "woody" and that leads to a drier finish than Bulleit. Both are great.
Glad you found me! My preference has moved over time too. I enjoy both, but find more people I share with prefer the sweet, coating BT over the spicier Bulleit. Cheers!
For me, definitely Buffalo Trace is far superior. I drink neat. It is very smooth but interesting. Fuller in the mouth. Bulleit tastes cheaper, thinner and younger, though the peppery kick is quite nice. I think a drop of water helps smooth it out and bring out more subtleties.
Sounds like you have found a way to enjoy both; neat or a drop to bring out some layers. Glad you dropped in. Cheers!
@TheCountryBumpkin7 thank you for your comment. I too prefer EC, but around here it costs about $10 more than these bottles.
Nice reviews. I have both. Very new to bourbons and find this type of review very helpful to my developing palate.
Welcome to the channel! Thanks for the comment and I hope your journey in whisky is exciting. If it's like mine, you'll inevitably pick up a few bottles that will just shake your head, but I have really found some great expressions in Bourbon lately and I hope you do too!
I do really love Buffalo Trace. Now in 2019, it's getting tricky to find any of the distillery's products. For the price I really don't think you can beat it. While watching this I just finished a bottle and now I'm having a store select of one of their bottles. SO tasty!
Just good Bourbon! Thanks for watching.
2 years late and seeing this review for the first time...tried buffalo trace and loved it. Drank it neat and in an old fashioned recipe, so good either way. Thanks!
Great to hear! I still enjoy Buffalo Trace a lot, and it is affordable enough to keep on the shelf.
Both of these are at the top of my favorites list.
Awesome! Though different for me, I enjoy them both very much too!
Great stuff man, recently got into whisky and these videos are really interesting! Cheers.
Thanks, enjoy the journey!
Cheers! Happy Fall! Look forward to watching your videos!
Thanks. I hope you have an excellent fall too!
Really enjoy your reviews. Friendly, informative and fun! In terms of the whiskys, I do enjoy a buffalo trace now and again.
Thank you for the encouraging words! BT is a great dram for the price, a little soft for me when grabbing Bourbon, but good liquid. Cheers!
Really nice review. Thank you.
@@CPA1535 Thank you!
Great review! Perfect name too. It felt like I was relaxing with a neighbor. Greetings from Texas. Subscribed!
Glad you enjoyed the review. I try to just share what I am tasting. Awesome to know someone is watching from Texas! My parents lived there for years, but that was a long time ago! Cheers!
I just bought this frontier whisky today. Coming from a wild turkey 101 fan that drinks 101 daily, if you’re a WT101 man then try this one here. My new favorite!
Certainly agree that Bulleit drinks much closer to 101 than BT. BT is much more honey sweetness than bold spice. Thanks for sharing!
@@WhiskyNeighbour I totally agree with you. Much more like 101 than BT
Here in Upstate NY Bulleit will run me between $35 and $40 a 1L bottle. I love Bulleit haven't grabbed Buffalo Trace. Love the spicy rye notes in Bulleit, but it is my first bourbon.
njmevec I appreciate the spice in Bulleit too. Holds up in cocktails too. BT is a bit sweeter and maybe smoother IMO. Worth trying if you like drinking neat.
Great review.
Buffalo trace is a decent dram . An easy sipper and I like it , but I'm a 101 fan now and it's a few bucks less too . Although It's been a while so maybe I will try it again.
Cheers
I prefer 101, but BT is certainly descent, especially if you are in a mood for something sweeter.
I enjoy both, the Bulleit rye is also a good drink. I do not mix any bourbons, I enjoy them straight.
I can’t understand how jack Daniels is so popular. It tastes like charred wood.
Buffalo trace is a fine and smooth drink
I too get the most enjoyment out of straight whiskey. However, there are lots of different preferences out there and I am good with that. Have you given any of the single barrel JDs a chance? Much better than No. 7. Cheers!
My next step is to visit some of the distilleries in Kentucky. I made a still about 2 years ago and it has become a passion for me.
No I haven’t, I’m a reformed beer drinker, I made a still a couple years ago and it has become a passion.
@@trebor66n2 awesome. One day I would like to do that. Hopefully I can!
I agree, Jack Daniels is popular here in Finland too which i can´t understand, but i love Buffalo Trace and i´m wondering why it´s not well known here like Jack Daniels. Maybe it´s because Jack Daniels has a status of rockstars whiskey..
I recently got both Bulleit and Buffalo Trace. I used to drink Makers Mark and Buffalo trace and liked them both until I got chemical burns from Makers mark, oddly other whiskeys didn't give me the same chemical burn effect as Makers (erven high proof stuff) so I got out of bourbon for a while but have recently got back into it. I got some on sale whiskeys like plain old wild Turkey and while I did not care for it as a sipper, it was amazing as a mixer with Ginger ale.... so I've been starting to experiment again.
I've gone into some Rare Breed and loved it (had to water or ice it to really bring out the smell and flavor but now its amazing) Knob Creek is ok but when I have Wild Turkey first and go to Knob Creek 9 a bit after, it's soooo much better not sure why. I tried Bulleit and hated it as a sipper but really love it mixed with Ginger ale... So I like a bit sweeter Bourbon and figured I'd try Buffalo Trace again as it was on sale but I find it way to weak now straight and it seems to be missing something even straight... it also doesn't mix well with anything as its washed out... I don't think I'd ever keep Buffalo Trace anymore but Bulleit, while not my favorite sipper, it is amazing mixed with anything, the rye helps a little, it has a stronger bourbon taste and it even feels like it has more kick. I don't know how I can really enjoy BT anymore.... perhaps I got a bad bottle???
Rare breed though with a bit of ice or water really comes alive, it has a super mouth feel (much thicker feeling) and the flavor is more complex and I love the crème Brule'/vanilla notes I get from it, straight the proof kind of kills the nose and taste but a tiny bit of water wakes it all up ... I've found Craft Cellars in Calgary have Rare Breed on for $39.99, so I think I'm going to get another.. that is something like 40% off!!!
Great walkthrough of your experience and what a fantastic sale at Craft Cellars. I really enjoy Rare Breed. It is on of my "allways on the shelf" releases. Thanks for sharing!
Nice video! Buffalo Trace is most certainly a very good bourbon and whiskey for the price. This, Teacher's and Tomatin Legacy are my go to budget whiskies.
Would be interesting to do a blind test between the two Buffalo and Bulleit 😁
Teacher's and Legacy are excellent budget Scotch for me too! Blinds are fun. Often humbling for me, but always a good experience. Cheers!
Cute cat! Thanks for the review.
Moses Germann sometimes a little too much mischief
Bulliet and Bulliet rye are our faves for old fashioneds. For straight sipping woodford reserve or buffalo trace are so smooth. God I do like that Bulliet spice though. Great video sir from MN (with Canadian roots) :)
Right! BT or Woodford are easier, and tasty, but sometime the spice is just what I need. Cheers!
Fantastic review my man. Subscribed !
Thank you. I enjoy comparing a couple bottles when I can. Cheers!
Nice review. I just got a bottle of bulleit and really like it
Just cleaning up old comments. Thanks for dropping in!
Great video. I pick up cherry quite often on bourbon.
An awesome fruit note to catch!
It's my 34th birthday today & i'm drinking Bulleit for the first time, i picked it up a few days ago for £18. It's the first bourbon i've bought (I'm normally a JD Man) Really enjoying it 👌🏻
Awesome! Happy Birthday!
Whats your fav bourbon now for the price
@@joeyjuandiaz6195 if i can get a litre of Jack Daniels for £25 or under it's that,bulleit is very nice but they dont do a 1 litre
@@ORIGINOLINDIVIDUAL how can you do jd eww that's what made me stay away from whiskey but to each iss own haha.
@@joeyjuandiaz6195 I prefer Bulleit, but for the price i prefer Jd
Buffalo Trace is my fav. In Texas I buy it for $26. In Oklahoma $29. Bulleit is around $29. Just paying extra for a cooler bottle. As a mixer, Bulleit Rye in coke or Dr Pepper rocks the house.
Thanks for sharing thoughts and how you enjoy each!
The video that got me into whiskey last year
Awesome! I am glad you found it, and it cought your interest. What is a favourite bottle you are into now?
Whisky Neighbour one I really am loving at the moment is Noah’s mill, nice abv, on the sweeter side. And bookers is always delicious! Curious to what your favorites are!
@@fishingpro64 for Bourbon, I am enjoying higher proof these days. Rarebreed, Bookers, Knob Creek Single Barrel. With the weather turning cold up here, I am moving more into Scotch though.
As a complete rookie to bourbon (and whisky in general), I find Buffalo Trace similar to a Canadian whisky in regards to sweetness and gentleness on the nose. That being said, I would love a video on how you develop and learn how to smell and taste a whisky! Cheers for another great video. As a fellow Canadian I just appreciate the humbleness and openness that you come with in your reviews.
You are too kind! I do want these moments to be more like sharing a dram then a deep critique. I try to talk about what I'm tasting more in the moment and see where it goes. Thanks for watching, and that is a good idea for a video, I'll think about how to approach it. Cheers!
Great review Jon! Hopefully there is a whisky tasting this November again! I’ll be there and hopefully we can chat!
That would be fantastic! Trends are poor right now in the province though.
There both amazing pours, I really like both of them I like the bulleit a lot more I don’t seem to get a headache of it like trace can do . To me at least I’m on medication and I should never really drink 🍹 but! I love bourbon 🥃 real new to it but I’m enjoying it I love the bulleit
Glad you enjoy Bulleit. A bit worried about your medication comment. Maybe check with your doctor about that. Thanks for dropping in!
Thank you 🙏 you the first to say that
Hey nice review, just bought my first bourbon! Buffalo trace. Will make it neat and in a few drinks :), cant wait! Thank you
Felixo Great choice when trying out Bourbon! I hope you enjoy it and thanks for dropping in. Cheers!
Yeah been looking to increase in the future with Makers mark, Bulleit Rye.
Also do you think Knobs creek and Wild turkey 101 are worth the extra price :) ?
I enjoy Makers and also Bulleit Rye, though that one is a bit rough or the alcohol is forward. I like the regular Knob Creek 9 year old, but I would not rate it higher than Buffalo Trace. I would rate the "single barrel" version fairly high and do pay more for it to keep it on the shelf. WT 101 is good, but I would look for a sale. Some really love it, I know my nephew does, but I do not regularly stock it. Enjoy the journey finding out what you like!
Hey man great help! Cant wait to start my journey and finding what I enjoy, your videos are very informative and helps me understand more about whiskey! Thank you! :)
What's the difference between Bulleit Frontier and Rye? Also, I had Buffalo Trace and B Frontier, I give a slight edge neat to BT but a decisive edge to the Bulleit mixing it with a coke.
Frontier is their Bourbon, so it is made from a high Rye mashbill. Likely 68% Corn, 28% Rye, 4% Barley. Bulleit Rye is 95% Rye, 5% Barley. The Rye is more cracked pepper and some grass or herb notes.
Nice to hear from a Canadian. I watch the videos also, and can;t believe how cheap bourbon is in the USA either. They are very lucky in that regard.....
Bourbon still has a little more value than Scotch, but prices are on the rise. Thanks for watching, do you have a favorite between these?
What do you think the best smooth, sweet east for a beginner, inexpensive but not cheap bourbon / whiskey 🥃 I should try?
I am not sure where you are at. Around here, Welller Special Reserve goes for $35 CND, and would be an excellent introduction to Bourbon. Buffalo Trace, that I talk about here, is really good too, and goes for about $27 CND. It would be tough to find better at that price point.
Whisky Neighbour Thank you so much! Love your page and your thoroughness.
Is the Buffalo Trace worth $30? I haven't even finished my first bottle of Jim Beam Black yet that I bought for $25 a couple of weeks ago and still have another new bottle in the cupboard. Last Christmas also bought a couple bottles of cheap Ezra Brooks bourbon for just $22 which I still have a bottle left.
Hard to say. I think it is good bourbon, but not exceptional. Better than the Ezra IMO
@@WhiskyNeighbour Personally I don't like paying more than $25 for bourbon, especially considering how cheap it is down in the States. But there's something about the taste of bourbon that has that certain unique kick in taste that other whiskies do not have. I don't what it is, bourbon always has that extra kick in taste ever since the first time I tasted it, Crown Royal and Canadian Club don't have it and neither does Jack Daniels.
Nice review, I like the Buffalo trace as my sipper..I have both these..and I think the Bulleit is better for cocktails or as a mixer with like coke or ginger ale..but I like the BT neat !. Cheers from Camrose !
Chris Beaton Thanks for dropping in. Bulleit and Ginger Ale ... I have never had that combo, but I think I will give it a go. I bet the rye and Ginger make for a spicy combo. Cheers!
Whisky Neighbour all good subscribed as well. Maybe I will see you at a whisky tasting Or something in Edmonton !
Whisky Neighbour also found the Glenromdach12 u mentioned here at superstore liquor in Camrose for 50.99 regular price. Solo across streets price for same juice is 69.99. Crazy difference
Chris Beaton Wow! It sure pays to look around eh?! I hope you enjoy the GlenDronach. I was surprised how much I did this year. A few years back I did not take to heavy Sherry. Palates evolve I guess! It would be great to see you at a tasting.
Whisky Neighbour well I didn't buy the glendromach yet. I went with the Caol ila 12. Haven't tried it yet
Great review thank you sir.
You are welcome!
Just got a bottle of bulleit any tips on how to get used to a higher rye bourbon
A bit different with everyone and their taste preference. I would say start using it in your favourite cocktails, but those that are simple and mostly whisky. Like an Old Fashioned. Then just over ice and small sips. Also, come back to it after a while and you may find you have warmed to it.
Buffalo Trace is very hard to find these days in Maryland, USA. Had to get on a waitlist at one of the local sellers to even have a chance. I just tried Bulleit for the first time yesterday and really liked it. I'm new to bourbon, so I'm still figuring out what I think is good and what I can taste. I got a real good cinammon finish from the Bulleit, is that the rye? If so, maybe I'll need to try more of that style.
Glad you are on the journey! Rye does often give a spice note. Cinnamon or black pepper can be apart of that. Whisky Advocate had a good article whiskyadvocate.com/rye-whiskey-scale-list/
Might help in thinking what to try next!
I've been wanting to try Buffalo Trace for a couple of months now. I live in NC near the border with SC and can't find it in any of the liquor stores near me. I've tried Eagle Rare and loved it. Still waiting for a taste of Buffalo Trace.
Eagle Rare is a nicer Bourbon in my opinion, but I enjoy BT and it is half the price of Eagle up here! I hope you get a chance to try it soon.
Many be too many BT export to overseas
@@yujiahuo8442 :)
i presume your near charlotte get across the border to frugal mcds and get some screw ABC stores lol both bourbons are awesome
That´s funny, because Buffalo Trace is available here in Finland too, but it´s not cheap, 38e..
What do you think about a second rolling around in the mouth for every year of age for whisky when sipping neat?
I like the idea of letting it rest, a minute in the glass for every year. Rolling in the mouth? I am not sure. Certainly give it time, and several sips. More with age, bit l am not sure of making that a rule.
I'm new to bourbon I've bought Buffalo Trace twice ,got some Bulleit yesterday .I like them both ,the Bulleit seems a little smoother for me as a noob though .
Cool. Usually BT has a broader appeal and Bulleit has more spice, but it is always personal taste!
I deffo prefer bulliet
Gonna try both
@@arlisaustin5177 Cant go wrong with double whisky lol
Just getting more into whisky and my first couple of bottles are these two. Enjoying both but also BT is what I'd lean too. Also Highland wine and spirits currently has thes on sale here in Edmonton. Also awsome to be a new subscriber to a fellow Edmontonian.
Welcome to the channel!! Both on sale eh? I may need to restock. Thanks!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Bulleit is $34.99 and I believe BT is the same regular around $40. Not sure if they are cheaper at diff locations but Thats what they are at Highlands on 170th st. Also a new follower on Insta.
@@nathanwelton1385 good prices! Thanks
@whiskeyneighbor much love! Thanks for this video bud!
You are most welcome!!
My family name brewer is the best thing that ever happened to my family!Proud to have the same last name Great whiskey!
@@ronaldwheatley.5434 great whisky indeed. Cheers!
Ever noticed bulleit's sticker is put on sideways on the bottle? is it deliberate or is it the factory workers all drunk and flat out putting it on straight?
Lol, I don't know. If it is deliberate, I would like to know the story!
Hand labeled johhnie walker probably copied bulleit not the other way around so i was told by a bottling enthusiest and that's all jonnie walker was a blending of other distillers but relied heavy on bottling presentation as for buleit they are a proper distillery @@WhiskyNeighbour
I just grabbed a fifth of Bulleit for Christmas Eve. I usually drink Four Roses small batch or Woodford Reserve. We’ll see. I just drink it neet or occasionally over ice. Hope I’m not disappointed
I hope you enjoy it too!
I've tried several bourbons. They're all great. Buffalo Trace, Knob Creek, Four Roses Small Batch...really hard to say which ones I like over the others. *shrug* Thanks for the review.
Nothing wrong with liking bourbon from a variety of distilleries! Just means they'll have something good in the store when you want. Take care, and enjoy the weekend!
@@WhiskyNeighbour
Thanks, you, too!!
I haven’t tried Buffalo Trace yet , but I really like Bulleit Bourbon and their bottle is cool ,looks like it’s from the old west. But I’ll have to try Buffalo Trace soon. Most of the Time I sip Wild Turkey 101,Jameson or Rock Town 100 proof Apple Pie Moonshine. I purchased Bulliet Bourbon on sale here in Arkansas for $22 ,usually Buffalo Trace is usually $30.
I think with the whiskey you highlight, Buffalo Trace should be a good pick. I hope you find it on sale !
I’d pass on Buffalo Trace especially at that price. Bulleit and Wild Turkey 101 are both better. BT has a nasty astringency to it.
i bought a bottle of buffalo trace tonight and having a dram while i watch your review....its an easy drinking bourbon easy to drink neat no water, and has a short finish with no after burn
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I continue to enjoy it from time to time. As you said, easy to relax with.
Right now, I'm trying to choose between Buffalo Trace & Bulleit, no matter what I choose in the end though, I definitely want to try both of them at some point.
They are both good, so you can't go wrong. Recommending blind is tough, but in general I would say try Buffalo Trace first. Enjoy!
@@WhiskyNeighbour I honestly didnt expect a response but thank you! I haven't done alot of research into buffalo trace but i'm going to look at a few more reviews before I make a final decision. Also I just want you to know that this review was very helpful for a rather inexperienced drinker like myself. Thanks again.
Very nice vid!
Thanks!
Both are excellent. Buffalo Trace is smoother, fuller taste, but no rye. Bulliet is definitely spicier, you can taste rye and it is quite interesting and refreshing. I go back and forward depending on what I am in mood for and what I am eating. Both are excellent choices.
Totally agree! Thanks for dropping in!
Exceptional review!
Just cleaning up old comments. Thanks for dropping in!
I’ve been looking for a bottle of Buffalo trace, no luck yet
Worth the search. Just good bourbon.
Im from mexico and i just find one, is that dificult to find in us?
@@sergiozl10 You can find it but it depends where you live. I haven’t seen it in a store yet
Both those are 56-65 here and australia but the bad tthing is theyat 40% and only come n 700ml .bbbut yep thats why we allways go for a w.t 101 instead for same price..dnt mind the buffalo travehavnmt tried d bt but
Awesome you can get WT 101 at full proof! Cheers!
Interesting, Jon, I tried them both some time ago but for some reason didn't got them on my bar, while i still have some regular entry level Four Roses in...I hear diverse opinions about the Bulleit Rye & 10 yo Bourbon but some more limited releases seem more popular (such as the Blender's Select, but it is impossible to find here). Nice comparison...
Thanks. This is getting old, but it seems to still pop up in searches! What are some of your favourite entrance Bourbons?
@@WhiskyNeighbour Yeah good review despite all the mess in the background sound wise (I felt for you !)..my first Bourbon was Maker's Mark, then to answer your question regular Four Roses, Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select (but it seems to have changed a lot, not necessarily for better), Jim Beam Double Black, stuff like that...I still remember a Bourbon I liked a lot called Johnny Drum but that I struggle to find now, but you'll be surprised some of my favorite American whiskeys can't be called Bourbons (Michter's Unblended American Whiskey & Sour Mash are 2 "luxury entry level" whiskies that are for me super well crafted, even if it is sourced they nailed it with those). I also started with Blanton's Special Reserve but I quickly found it a bit weak compared to the Original & even more to my 2012 stunning Gold Edition I still have & to the SFTB...I still have a lot of samples from friends to try, entry level ones but also some high end stuff as well, just want to give them the best opportunity to shine & take decent notes, not knock em down quickly in a live show or else...I have to say also that 2018 for me was a revelation about what Rye whiskies could bring on the table & especially Canadian ones, with great tasting opportunities (samples sent by a generous guy from Oakville) & great meetings too (Don Livermore, of course, in a show but also in my flat to do a Live show), and there'll be more to come about it on my channel soon, btw 😉 Other than that within a month or two I'll have a great story to tell with (spoiler) how Canadian Rye did influence me while blending a French whisky for real (at a distillery) that will be released soon here....
@@GregsWhiskyGuide Wow! I can't wait to hear more about your blending journey. Thanks for sharing more insight into your early Bourbon ideas and so good to know Rye has now influenced your experience. Mine too!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Thanks a lot, Jon, I will keep you posted...I don't wanna sound biased or paid or anything but I could say "Lot 40 changed my life", lol...And I'm happy to own just one bottle ok but what a bottle, the "JP Wiser's "Dissertation' that has a lot in it...Cheers ! PS I see you're on Twitter too so I might send you some stuff on DM 😉
Fun video!
Thanks!
I love BT but it kinda bugs me that they won’t release their mash bill.
I agree. I appreciate as much transparency as possible. Take care!
Bulleit is delicious, but then again everyone is on its own taste, love and peace!
Yes to to both! Cheers!
Whiskey neighbor, It's funny because these are the only two Bourbons I like. I am surprised you did a video on them, good! I wanted to tell you that I really like the Bulleit Barrel Strength which I'm sure you have heard, If not give it a try!
MrRaymo88 Barrel Strength .... Sounds awesome, I have not seen it around here, but I do enjoy higher ABV expressions. I find it bring out so much flavour! Thanks for the tip
Your notes on the nose and the pallet are spot on with my experiences. While both whiskeys are perfectly tolerably drinkable neat, Buffalo Trace is my favorite budget sipper. Bulliet can tend to give me a bit of heartburn over Buffalo trace. Both are absolutely fantastic in a gold-rush.(half a lemon juiced, 2oz pour of bourbon, and a measure of honey mixed well shaken over then served on ice)
Mmm that sounds delicious! Thanks for sharing!
Whisky Neighbour delicious doesn’t start to describe it. Haha it’s my favorite summer drink. You gotta be careful though, they can sneak up on you. H
Great review! Buffalo trace punches way above its weight class! Good sipper for the price! Bulleit makes great cocktails though.
Great thoughts! Thanks for sharing, cheers!
Good idea for a review of these two, popular bourbons. I have both so I was interested to hear your contrast and comparison. Mash vs rye so a little apple to orange but even so it helps to describe them as you have done. Good to know rye bourbon isn’t as dry and unsweet like a scotch and has at least a bit of floral and fruit and not just spice, leather, peat, burned tire and pepper like some scotch (I hate those kinda scotches). Many thanks!
Thanks for dropping in. Yep, the higher Rye is still not like a peated Scotch. Both here have sweetness to offer! Cheers!
Very good Video
Thanks!
Might grab a bulliett 2 try thou.just was worried i was gonna think shoould have just grabbed the turkey lol
More than fair. These are good drams IMO though. Worth trying at least once.
I loved my first bottle of Buffalo Trace. It went by FAST. But by my third bottle, having also tried Four Roses, Maker's Mark, Bulleit and Wild Turkey 101, Buffalo Trace (in Germany at 40% ABV) became far too watery for me. If we could get it at 45%, it would be great. But at 40%, I prefer Maker's Mark and Bulleit.
Thanks for sharing your journey. I imagine I would be similar. I enjoy Buffalo Trace a fair amount, but if it was only 40% it would likely become to honey sweet and light. I need a little kick in my bourbon! Cheers!
It was a glass of bulliet that re-introduced me to basic American bourbon. Jack Daniels watered down their whiskey back about 1980. Right after Jim Beam had done the same. I thought my tastes had changed and that I now preferred Scotch. That first glass made me think maybe I need to re try bourbon. It turn out that I had been missing out for a number of years. There is a lot of good whiskey out there in this world. Most of it is not that expensive.
Thanks for sharing your journey. I certainly agree, if a person is willing to look, there are good bottles to share. Cheers!
What proof was Jack & Jim before the 80s? I remember when I was bartending around 2004 or so Jack went from 90 proof down to 80. When it was reduced we had tons of the old 90 proof stocked up and when Jack drinkers noticed it was the old stuff they were all offering a lot of money to buy a bottle from us.
Is buffalo trace better taste and flavor than Jack Daniels number 7 ?? I want something better then Jack Daniels number 7 ?
For me, yes, a lot better. Less banana and more caramel and vanilla
@@WhiskyNeighbour I'm definitely going to try buffalo trace whiskey l don't mind spend a bit more On buffalo trace better taste then Jack Daniels!😁😁😁😎😎😎
Great review. Well done brother!
Thanks! Which one of these do you usually reach for?
Whisky Neighbour Brand new the the the whiskey game. I like the BT and have never had the Bulleit . My whiskey “experience” is all Jack and Coke in the late 70’s and early 80’s so I need to make up for lost time! Hoping to try as many as I can before I start pushing up daisies! Videos like yours help point me in the right direction so many thanks! Keep your powder dry and the wind at your back! Way too many exclamation points in that little reply.
@@gregusmc2868 I wish you many great drams in the future then! If you enjoy BT, a possible next stop on the journey might be Weller. It is also a little smoother than some yet affordable. Cheers 🥃
Whisky Neighbour Thanks for the recommendation. I’ll see if I can’t find a bottle here this weekend. 👍
Gotta give BT some love... 3.75 Stars. Lol. Bulliet Rye makes the best Old fashioned. Aggree with your review. BT is the best sipper Bulliet the best mixer.
Randy O'Connor yep. BT deserves more!
Your comment about Bulleit Rye and old fashioneds is spot on ;)
I'm more of a Rye guy but finally got my hands on a bottle of Buffalo to do this comparison against a bottle of Bulleit I've had open for a year now. I agree with many of Jon's notes, Buffalo is more smooth. approachable, rounded but for me Bulleit has a stronger corn mash and an earthy smell and taste. It was the batch or the old open bottle? maybe. Still both are good Kentucky Bourbons to try. Cheers.
Great notes, thanks for sharing your experience. Next time I have Bulleit around I will look for the earthy nature. Cheers!
I fond myself having difficulties to get over the rye spice, I am more of a scotch guy, but I would like to enjoy a bourbon, not only wheated ones. Am I wack if even with the buffalo trace i got that taste of rye that makes me not wanting another glasse?
Hmm, no, if you taste that, you are spot on. Everyone's palate is different. I am not sure what to recommend. Of the "non-wheated" bourbons, BT is fairly soft. Maybe try a dram of Eagle Rare. Similar, but perhaps a bit smoother due to age. I think Dickle is low Rye, but I am not a fan. Still, might be worth a try!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Thanks for the advices. Also, do you know a little bit about the whisky from Quebec? The government controls the alcohol sells and whiskey is more expensive. If you go on the SAQ.com website, are you able to tell me the good value whiskies for the money. I would love to have the opinion from someone who lives in an other province!
@@FATmonkeyMAMA I would love too. Shopping is a big part of what I do. I always check the LCBO and BCLiqour too. However, they have a very large list. Is there a range or a style you are interested in? That would help!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Scotches between 50$ and 100$
Well, I took a look. First, I can say your prices are significantly more than I pay in AB. Not for everything, but certainly on average. Best values I saw; Kilkerran 12, Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban, Bruichladdich Classic, Achentoshan Three Wood, Deanston Virgin Oak, Glendronach 12 year, and Tobermory 10year
BULLIET: It as a nice aged 'oily' feel, not harsh, not too spicy, with obvious oak flavor, it does not dry my mouth at all ...Its pretty darn good neat and a real bargain for the price...cheers
Well said! I"m glad you enjoy it, and I am very thankful it is so affordable!
You can let that kitty run around in the background. We don't mind.
😄 She has shown up in a few videos now!
That's a good cat 🐈
@@thepinballzone She is!
Tried them both and liked them
Great! I enjy them both too, but lean toward BT neat and Bulleit in a good old fashioned.
Two of my favorite Kentucky bourbons, or any bourbon. I do hope that Bulleit will someday distill their own grain neutral spirits (they buy from MGP, Indiana). Either way, two of the best, at very reasonable prices. Thanks for this vid!
Sector 001 these continue to hold up well for me too! Cheers!
I love them both. I prefer the taste of bulleit though, it’s very floral, somewhat like a four roses.
Definitely some floral notes for me too.
For many years the only booze from the USA I knew was Jack Daniel´s and Jim Beam, which are really not bad at all, but also not that great. A few weeks ago I tasted some Maker´s Mark and my whole point of view changed... until I had some Bulleit. Never tried Buffalo Trace, but I will give it a chance. Blanton Single Barrel is also good, but in my humble opinion, Bulleit tastes better - shoot me for that, but that´s what I think about that. For now, Bulleit is my favorite Whiskey to have a nice sip, Maker´s Mark to mix some good Old Fashioned.
Usually I only drink Single Malt Scotch, but obviously there are some really, really good Bourbons out there.
Sorry for my bad English, I an German.
Have a great time, Ladies and Gentlemen, enjoy the drinks you like :)
Great comments here. It is always good to hear how journeys unfold and tastes evolve. The rye in Bulleit is excellent and certainly a drink I enjoy!
Thank you, Sir. As it seems, my preferenced of taste tend to rye, because the ones with more corn, are not really the ones I like, but maybe that´s only a matter of time and I have to taste some more :)
Have a good one!
I’m also new to bourbon, acquired a good variety over the last few months and I need to say, when your pallet is adjusted to the bourbon, try four roses single barrel
I didn't notice anything wrong with your English other than "I an German" instead of "I am German," and I'm pretty sure that was just a typo.
Great Review. I'm sipping some Buffalo Trace as I write this, I'm not sure what area of the city you reside in? I heard you mention Sherwood Park I recently picked up a bottle of Bookers at the liquor depot in the Southside (23rd ave) for $60 regular $83 & change.. I do believe. I'm Slowly transitioning into a whiskey snob. I appreciate you're honesty in the reviews keep them coming. Subscribed!
Jared Helldrum thanks for the sub Jared. That is a great price for Booker's! Liqour depot has some great sales from time to time, looks like you found one :) I love sharing some of my thoughts, and while they are not the most detailed, they are my experience! I live in St. Albert, but I am often in the city since my folks are on the Southside. Enjoy the Bourbon!
Which Booker's expression/batch/release did you happen upon Bourbon Neighbour to the North?
John Belushi sorry for the late response it was a 6yr 1mo batch #2016-01E 63.85%(127.7 proof I'm hoping to one day see a sale price on Jefferson's aged at sea!
Here in the UK you can pick up a bottle of Buffalo Trace for £19, great value
That is good!
in quebec bulleit is 38 but often drops to 34 while buffalo trace is at 43
Interesting. Here, both are often in sale, usually very close in price. Which do you prefer?
How do these compare to wild turkey
dylan dewalt I would say, BT is smoother and a little sweeter. Bulleit has a little more flavour and spice, but lacks that sour edge that many people like in Wild Turkey. I am not a big Wild Turkey fan though, so no doubt I am biased.
after sipping talisker "storm", laphroig 10, rittenhouse and george dickel "rye" for the last few days, it's time for a bourbon. i planned on buffalo trace and went back a little ways to find this video to get your opinion. i'm sure i won't be disappointed. thanks for the video
I still enjoy Buffalo Trace, and since it is affordable, its always on the shelf
Thanks for the review. I usually drink Bulleit, but tonight is my bday and I want to try something new. So I think ill get some Buffalo Trace and try it neat. Not a big fan of mixing my Whiskey with anything
Richard Nelson Happy birthday! Let me know what you think. Trying new whisky is a great hobby !
Richard Nelson - Happy belated birthday!!
In my experience, Buffalo Trace really benefits from adding a little bit of water and letting it sit for five minutes or so. It's like all of the flavor that's locked within is set free to dance on your tongue.
Hey, nice review. Where are you in Canada ? I'm in Québec and Buffalo Trace is 43$ and I bought a Bulleit bottle on sale for 35$. It's my first ever Bourbon and I'm really enjoying it so far!
Glad you are enjoying it! I think these are both tasty, but different enough to appeal to different tastes or moods. I am in Alberta. Both continue to be the same price out here. Cheers!
@@WhiskyNeighbour Ok cool! I'll definitely want to try Buffalo Trace at some point in the future. But I was planning on trying Maker's Mark next. It is sold at 39$ for the 750 ml bottle and I've seen very good reviews on it. Have you tried it ?
@@drax14QC yes! Many people enjoy MM. I do too, but not my favorite. For wheated, I like Weller's a little more. I also enjoy Elijah Craig a lot, but it can be pricey. I good value is Wild Turkey 101. It has a sour note that can out some people off, but great for the price usually.
@@WhiskyNeighbour Ok, thanks for the recommandations! I've seen Wild Turkey 101 in many favourite Bourbons lists
Enjoyed the review.
Daniel Brown Thanks for dropping in!
Drank a whole bottle of buffalo trace yesterday. Helluva hangover man that 45 percent will sneak up on you
Lol!
Really? One of the few bourbons that didn't give me a hangover after a bottle/fifth. Smooth and nice! Cheers!
Funny how people's taste varies; I've tried Buffalo Trace twice (that's two bottles). Thought it was thin. The second time I tried Bulleit, I was sold.
Yes, it is very personal. Usually we can agree with some general tastes; BT sweeter, Bulleit spicier, but preference is totally up to the drinker!
Interesting, Bulleit was my favourite for the longest time, but Buffalo Trace became my favourite as it, to me, had a fuller flavour l.
@@Reverend_Nada And now I'm much more into WT 101. Ain't variety great?!?!?!
My faves are 4 roses and bulleit rye. I think bt is like maker's mark and jack single barrel....
Mark Antony Neil Bulleit Rye! I like that too, but most find it rough or alcohol forward. I think that one also holds up well in cocktails. Sadly I can only get 4 Roses yellow label around here and not any of their small batch or single barrel I here so much about.
Whisky Neighbour it is surprisingly rare here as I only know of the store Marks and Spencers that sells small batch and only in their major stores (no even on their website)
Mark Antony Neil if you find them, they become even better then. Cheers!
Like both makers and jack single barrel? Being like both of those is like saying your pizza is like a curry but also a burrito.
Started my bourbon journey with Buffalo Trace, and I liked it, but wanted to try others too. After many great bourbons Buffalo Trace is still my favourite for the price. I came from Japanese and Irish whiskys, and I have to admit now that I really like bourbons too, and not only bourbons, but Rye too. Bulleit Rye is definitely a nice whiskey, sweet and spicy at the same time, fresh and well balanced.
Sounds like a great whiskey journey! I enjoy Rye too. Sweet and spicy. Cheers!
Have not yet tried Bulleit but I have a fondness for Buffalo Trace.
I would not immediately jump to Bulleit if BT is your go to. Perhaps Weller? I like Bulleit for what it is, but it can be a little rough.
Enjoyed this review and going for the Buffalo Trace as my first ever Bourbon 👍 Currently £19 UKP 😉
I hope you enjoy it!!
Whisky Neighbour Will let you know 👍
Buffalo trace has an awesome tour. It's a bourbon must! If you're in the area of Lexington KY hit up liquor barn (the larger one) they have a wide selection.
Just cleaning up old comments. Thanks for dropping in!
i just bought a bottle of bulleit bourbon and cant wait to give buffalo a go
Just cleaning up old comments. Thanks for dropping in!
I went to my local total wine and the buffalo trace was cleaned out
I believe this one is reasonably common. Likely they will get more in. I would think anyway.
Bruh the first time I tried bulliet I ended up using it as fire ignition lol, it was too strong for me. I’ve built up my taste much since then so maybe I’ll try it again
I hope this time it bring flavor, not just heat!
Hello John! To my taste Bulleit Bourbon is far more interesting, so Iove it and don't find it astringent at all by smell or whatsoever but "one man's meat is another man's poison"))) Cheers buddy!)
I enjoy both, depending on mood. O er the years BT has become much sweeter, and Bulleit bit more spice and oak.
Yep, all-on mood buddy. But I don't like a lot of sweetness in rum, whisky, gin-whatsoever and prefer okyness and spices (Am I correct in spelling "okyness", is there such a word?)