ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ย. 2024
- A song originally written by Joe Hill for the IWW to satirise the Salvation Army, an organisation which tried to drown out IWW with their religious music. In this version the lyrics were slightly altered to be more revolutionary by the Progressive Labor Party.
Performer: Progressive Labor Party
Year recorded: 1970s
Composer: Joseph P. Webster (From "In the Sweet By-and-By")
Year Composed: 1868
Lyricist: Joe Hill
Year Written: 1911
Source: Vinyl Record "A World to Win"
Image: Soviet poster "The Triumph of Christianity" (Торжество Христианства), 1923.
I love how in the end they basically say that when the world is free of the bosses, the bosses will have to now learn how to do stuff for their own lol
Also says "And you'll eat in that sweet by and by" after it, telling the important message that heaven can be created on Earth if humanity is united in struggle.
IWW music needs more recognition and use by the American left. A lot of the lyrics can be easily changed to match our modern struggles.
this song still works today lmao
Yes ! It is important and relevant . Both as history and in design.
"the us-american left" is far removed from this spirit and you know it
would be great if they'd recalibrate their values and get a bit more in line with the tradition they appropiate and claim to be the inheritors of, but you know this also, that they won't
they killed Joe Hill for a reason! these songs are powerful!!!
A lot of those songs (including this one) are already adaptations. This is already the result of lyrics being changed to suit the needs of whoever was singing and the lyrics vary from rendition to rendition.
I love these communist folk songs
@@davyd_1 folk can also be a style of music
@@davyd_1 actually Communism (and in specifity Marxism-Leninism-Maoism) is a science not a ideology
@@davyd_1 Its a Scientific Ideology, its about political science.
@ddavwvidd there can be folk songs of ideologies and one that is based around giving a voice to the folks can definitely have folk music
@@trotskygdits a set of theories. calling it a science is rather grandiose, its like saying string theory is "a science".
I loved it! Much love from Brazil to the american comrades!
Always good to see a brazilian comrade. Abraços camarada, fique bem.
Love from an English comrade
One of the best ones lately
as a christian I am sad to see what capitalism has done to my religion and the art used in this video is a very true depiction of religion in capitalist countries. also good song :)
How are you?
As a Christian who literally has the funding reports of my church, you people don’t know what the hell you’re talking about, you’re ignorant, and I highly doubt the validity of your claim to be Christian. “Religion in capitalist countries” why don’t you tell me how religion held up in China, North Korea, Cambodia, and Laos? Cuba and the Soviet Union were majority Christian and there was still some amount of suppression.
Christianity is not socialist. Christianity wants US to aid eachother, not have a government that forces us to live and work how it wants
Yeah
This reminds me of Zionists and the genocidal Apartheid state of the Israel often abuses Judaism and uses it to it's advantage, even weaponizing anti-Semitism to whoever their opponent is
"Come now, you rich, weep and howl for your miseries that are coming upon you! Your riches are corrupted, and your garments are moth-eaten. Your gold and silver are corroded, and their corrosion will be a witness against you and will eat your flesh like fire. You have heaped up treasure in the last days. Indeed the wages of the laborers who mowed your fields, which you kept back by fraud, cry out; and the cries of the reapers have reached the ears of the Lord of Sabaoth. You have lived on the earth in pleasure and luxury; you have fattened your hearts as in a day of slaughter. You have condemned, you have murdered the just; he does not resist you." - James, the brother of Jesus Christ
straight to the point
Such a good song
Shows clear truth!
Joe Hill - Swedish hero ✊🇸🇪
And America killed him 😔
Laal salaam from India
Thousands of Desi workers are here, getting doubly exploited by "Indo-Canadian" "recruiters" (READ: scammers), and capitalists from everywhere. The scammers tell their "marks" (victims) that everyone in Canada drives a Mercedes and lives in a fancy condo or single-detached home; once they arrive, the myriad capitalists and petit-bourgeois labour-buyers then stick the knife in with minimum wage, irregular hours, and the ever-present threat of revoking the "LMIA" and sending them back to India, often in tens of thousands of dollars in debt to the scammers.
Oh yeah, I forgot to mention that the scammers often "arrange" housing, and that sometimes with the employer; these scumlords will subdivide a dwelling that used to house 4 people into 12 rooms, and then charge exorbitant rent (e.g. C$1500 a month). This is on purpose, so that there's no chance anyone can just come for 2 years, save up cash and go back home. Porky doesn't want partners. He wants slaves.
Laal salaam, saathi, from Anishinaabe Country (a.k.a. so-called Ottawa, Canada) on Turtle Island, a few kilometres upstream of Aladdin Trudeau's imperial occupation palace.✊🟥🐢
Laal Salam from a Pakistani American
Cool song! What's the poster?
Edit: Soviet poster "The Triumph of Christianity" (Торжество Христианства), 1923 (from description)
Найкраще виконання, яке я чув.
а зеля хуже исполняет.....???????
@@dimonklewort6291 это тут при чём?
Привет из России, товарищ
Никакой войны, кроме классовой
@@somebodynobody8701 ну , а вы то каким боком . Вы никто и зовут вас......😜
Nice one. I love communist country songs it's two worlds colliding.
drawing of this video says a lot without a single word also beutifull lyrics !
I hope that wherever you are, you are safe the government in most countries does not take very kindly to bad guys like us!
Thanks comrade:)
You're welcome@@Imulti
@@KohanKilletz Hey! Fancy seeing you here. ✊
Unironically based
Sing this to Bezos, Koch, Slim, Buffett, Walton, Mnuchin, and all the heads operating the private equity firms. Oh, and all the sports billionaire owners who thrive on corporate welfare, too.
Workers of the world, unite!
You know, the ones that hate Christianity and persecute them…
This cartoon is actually shows what the Catholic Church really is! The greatest institution of capitalists brutes in the world! It never was Christian at all!
Protestants too. Many of them.
@@arthurpaivabarros6749 None so near like the Catholic church and its Jesuits!
This song talks about protestants because it was made in the USA
you just make up lies based in nothing because you are a heretic
@@VLSMITH1000No
This song talks about protestants because it was made in the USA
Thanks for this song ! Making it avialble is collective wealth on a mostly open forum ! Cheers from Texas @
The cross is still standing while the hammer and sickle have fell.
The old realities don't go away.
Great
"Jesus said to rich give your goods to the pour so they sent Jesus to his grave"
I clicked on this video because the picture is included in my reprint of the communist manifesto
Do you have the full album and if so will you please upload the rest of the songs from it?
Religion and socialism, together forever! Fight evil capitalism!
Liberation theology is the path to freedom!
Amazing find
is peggy seeger singing on here?
No
Love this song.. ❤😂
I prefer the original version myself since this one is more heavy-handed with it at the cost of its charm, but nice performance nonetheless
Jesus carries the cross for us
Atheism gang, comrades. ⚛️✊️🚩
Otherwise known as the oldest suicide pact in human history.
@@luigimrlgaming9484For religion, yes, it is the oldest suicide pact in human history, as it was a reactionary tool that brainwashed the minds of the people to ignore reality, and the history of humanity, including human evolution. Religion is a fairytale (including fairytale characters like God) and a Utopia that doesn't exist in reality.
Autistic gang*
Meh marxism isn't inherently atheist.
@@luigimrlgaming9484For religion, yes. Religion is known as the oldest suicide pact in human history.
#down with the gods and their lies
Note that Jesus preached a present tense kingdom of heaven, not one in the by and by/after you die or "high above the sky":
His disciples said to him, "When will the kingdom come?"
"It will not come by waiting for it.
It will not be a matter of saying 'Here it is' or 'There it is.'
Rather, the kingdom of the Father is spread out upon the earth,
and men do not see it."
Also:
Jesus said,
"If those who lead you say to you, 'See, the kingdom is in the sky,'
then the birds of the sky will precede you.
If they say to you, 'It is in the sea,' then the fish will precede you.
Rather, the kingdom is inside of you, and it is outside of you.
-
When you come to know yourselves, then you will become known,
and you will realize that it is you who are the sons of the living Father.
But if you will not know yourselves,
you dwell in poverty and it is you who are that poverty."
Also:
His disciples said to him,
"When will the repose of the dead come about,
and when will the new world come?"
He said to them,
"What you look forward to has already come,
but you do not recognize it."
But then you say this to a priest and they will balk at you. "No, don't perpetrate violence against people (our capitalist ruling class)! Some of them (all of them) are bad, sure, but you can't just use violent revolution to solve it! (you can.)"
The churches are instruments of control. People who worship God on one day and then go to enslave their fellow man on the next are no more than agents of evil.
So Jesus was a commie?
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Ну вы блин даёте , круто !
Amazing
💀
💀
Que fazes aqui? 😂
@@danielescalantedemedeiros. Estava pensando o mesmo rsrs
This is why that no one got feared when Stalin blew off a big church 😂
What is mean the "Starvation Army"? Isn't it Salvation Army?
Its making fun of them
The criticism is that the Salvation Army preys on poor people.
The critic is about the use of the salvation army to maintain thr exploitation of labour. The lyrics says about the preaching assisting the interests of the rich, not the poor as it should.
Please look up the IWW and / or Joe Hill.
😍😍🇦🇱❤️🇺🇲
moku la, sina nasa
jan li jo anu jo ala la pona
suwi a
pan suwi li lon ma sewi
ona li pan nanpa wan tawa jan
This song has obviously Darkside it states that we’re just emotional meat buckets
0:42 of course you won’t get pie in heaven
You will get steak
.......
This song is fucking MINT on a banjo downtuned to a minor btw
oh lol I get 'minor problem' now lmao
Ahahahah
Psalms 14:1 “Only fools say in their hearts, “There is no God.” They are corrupt, and their actions are evil; not one of them does good!”
My God is not for sale, neither is He your enemy. Repent, and you shall be saved, and for your earthly struggle, you can overcome for God will move entire mountains if necessary for those true and faithful only to Him. We are all wretched sinners but give your heart to the Lord, and He will give you a new one, more pure and lively than the one you had before. He will change you in ways you cannot imagine, and He will forgive you of all your transgressions against Him, offering you entrance into His kingdom on the condition of the mutual love between His subjects. In the end, the choice is up to you whether you want to live with God or against Him, but in the end, everyone will do the same thing.
|
V
Philippians 2:9-11 “Therefore God exalted him to the highest place and gave him the name that is above every name, that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue acknowledge that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father.”
Socialism isn't a sin in Christianity.
Bible, famous for being good and not promoting genocides and sexual slavery of children
@@DonutOfNinjasource: I dreamt it
@@DonutOfNinjaBro, That's Islam. At the beginning of the socialist movements, many Christians, Churches, (Orthodox) were a part of it. Until the Atheists tried to remove God and make the state God.
Кого?
In hindsight, it is too arrogant to dismiss the value of religion and internal spirituality; Marxists invented psychoanalysis when they discovered that they still need some sort of religion. However, the criticism at the usage of God to justify oppression and alienation of man is apt, although nowadays people will just use Race instead of God to do so
nowadays using God/religion as a justification for suffering here on earth won't work for the average Christian at least
Psychoanalysis was invented by Freud, not by Marxists. Freud famously tried to keep his psychoanalitic organization politically unaligned. However, I agree with your broader point. The void left in people after the death of God is prone to be abused, for example, by elevating mere men to godhood, like happened with Stalin.
Based profile pic @@soulplexis
This is not attacking religion, it is attacking the use of religion as a means by which the rich control the poor. There are religious communists and progressives too. Irish Catholics are one big example but if you want specific leaders there were also Z.A. Bhutto from Pakistan, Ghadaffi in Libya and Mossadegh in Iran, among several others I can't remember.
Jesus is LORD.
Opium of the masses, opium of the masses
@@joaquinvideo2959 opium can utilize to ease the pain. To consume much, doom ensures.
Jesus drove the moneychangers from the temple.
The only lord you have is the boss. You have rejected God out of your hand and feverishly embraced your rulers while chanting in your head the inane mantra "Jesus is LORD! Jesus is LORD!" You are a slave.
Cool story bro
Womp womp
Sounds like Communism and Antheism Mix...
🤣🤣🤣
This is not a Communist song, this is an IWW song. We have never had any official ideology. Still a good song
The IWW is filled with socialists tho
fair, but the progressive labor party (the group singing this) was, and they did change some of the lyrics around as well
To this point, surely the video will garner more clicks with "IWW" in the title than without.
@@fun_ghoul But it's a Communist version of an IWW song - so calling it an IWW song would be incorrect, since this isn't the version of the lyrics that the Wobblies sung.
IWW version of verse 5:
"Workingmen of all countries, unite,
Side by side we for freedom will fight,
When the world and its wealth we have gained
To the grafters we'll sing this refrain:"
PLP version:
"Working people of all countries, unite,
Side by side we for Socialism will fight,
When the world and its wealth we have gained
To the bosses we will sing this refrain:"
As others have mentioned, these lyrics have been altered by the Progressive Labor Party. The IWW indeed never had an official ideology, thus it would be strange to label a version of the song that talks about fighting for socialism as an IWW song, wouldn't it?
bv. germanigi la kantvortojn
BOOOO! BOOO! ✝️✝️✝️✝️
Oh no
Imma just
🚩🔛🔝
You're a bad Christian.
You don't understand the song at all
😂 The irony never dissapears
by and by, hmm i think that is bye and bye ?
No.
@@fun_ghoul really ?
@@ThuanGenosse Search it up for yourself, dong chi. There's even a(n English) Wikipedia article for both this song and the one it parodies ("In That Sweet By-and-By"). The article also informs me that this song is the origin of the phrase "pie in the sky", which is pretty cool and notable. Cheers from Ottawa. ✊🇻🇳🛠️
@@fun_ghoul thanks comrade, from Vietnam to Canada, Proletarian/ working class will be win ! The Workers of the World ! United !
the poster is a nonsense take though. christ carried his own cross.
The poster is meant to symbolize how Christ is used as a carrot to lead us all away from the fact that we're the only ones burdened by the cross while the rich sit on top of it. It is completely accurate.
@@tetra. the rich still die you know, they are indeed burdened by the horror and misery of life: precisely as such do they fall to violent greed, no? but the proper marxist criticism does away with greed and such comparisons at all: the bourgeoisie function as they do due to simple economic self interest. their sins are due to their self-de-humanisation, viewing themselves as cogs in the machine they perpetuate. Christianity says otherwise to them, but most people ignore what religion actually says about their actions when convienient.
did you even listen to the song the whole message is that religion itself is used to keep people in line and blind to their own oppression after all why care if your boss cut your pay to go pay for his third house he's going to end up in hell while you go to heaven the songs saying you should try to improve stuff on earth and a overfixaction on the afterlife will only stop any progress that can be made@@OsirusHandle
@@lt4109religion is adherence to a set of teachings it's not what keeping you down it's atheism and lack of God
@@tetra.Correct.
ok but why replace freedom with socialism? At least choose something with the same number of syllables.
Other than that it's a good version though
Capitalist freedom is a lie the government spreads you have the freedom to choose but that choice is either starve to death or work in a wage job the lucky ones can some what get out of this by going to college but all that gets you is a mountain of debt and unaffordable housing and again you have the freedom to choose either go to prison or pay off your massive debt that will put a massive financial strain on you while under socialism we have none of those things and before you mention free speech would you rather have the government killing Neo Nazis or protecting them
@@Surge1music-ve9sq I think you missed the point of their comment.
Lol "freedom". That is the funniest description of modern democracy ive heard. What a joke.
@@mrnanner5162 the original wasn't even about fighting for bourgious democracy though!?!
It's always been about socialism.
@@jownadel1526 no like ik what you mea. But hate to break it but western democracies arent as free as you think.
keep our song out of your mouths
Whose mouths?
@@okarthegreat sorry it was a Chris rick will Smith reference
May the LORD forgive you
I do approve socialism, but this song straight up makes my head hurt. Awful.
listen to the joe glazer version its better
Heretics
Very cringe
Your comment is
BASED@@itacom2199
wholesome
Hope we can witness socialism with American characteristics in our lifetime
no lol
The american identity is one founded on 13 slave colonies and 50 genocides. "Socialism with american characteristics" is imperialism and revisionism. Though it may be uncomfortable for you to accept, nationalities and religious institutions are just diversions to distract from the fact that none of us are in control of our own lives.
I hope we can witness socialism, not just on the land that is now the USA, but all over the world, in our lifetime. And I hope this central North American socialism will hold fewer and fewer of the characteristics of the empire that once existed there with each passing day.
@@Commietaku Exactly 🙏