Ranking EVERY My Singing Monsters… Monster (Cold Island)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- You didn’t expect to see MSM return on my channel, did you? Almost exactly one year ago I ranked the Plant Island Monsters, so naturally we’re moving to the next world on the list, Cold Island.
Why are there so many bird monsters here? How have my opinions changed over the last year? Who’s gonna make me so mad I yell F tier out of pure rage? Only one way to find out!
I'll be reranking the classics like Mammott, Furcorn, Maw, and all their Rare and Epic versions that return from the first island, then get into the new ones like Tweedle, Spunge, Strombonin, and so on. These monsters are so classic, and some of my favorites of all time appear on this list. Let me know who your favorites are, and if you’d like to see me cover Air Island, Water Island, and all the rest.
Thank you Enchanted for sharing your islands with me! Add them on MSM with this friend code: 63874451IJ
• Babe! Please Stop! I d...
Make this exact tier list yourself! / jakemillerpatreon
Join my Discord! / discord
Become a channel member! Exclusive shout-outs, badges, and emojis! / @jake.miller
Timeline:
0:00 Intro
0:46 EVERY Monster
1:12 Plant Island Monsters
2:09 Tweedle
3:29 Dandidoo
4:44 Quibble
6:14 Pango
7:23 Spunge
8:36 Thumpies
9:30 Congle
10:34 Deedge
11:39 Strombonin
12:42 Wubbox
13:22 Tawker and Maggpi
14:41 Grumpyre
15:55 Yool
16:59 Final Rankings
I like how the backgroung music is cold island, but it gets expanded with the monsters that he already talked about
Yea that’s my favorite part of these videos!
One fun detail that makes Strombonin even cooler: The movements of the Strombone (the shellfish guy) actually match up with the slide of a trombone when playing those notes. That’s a crazy amount of attention to detail.
That is awesome, I would’ve had no idea!
1. Yes, you should rank the other islands.
2. You forgot about the Colossals (Natural islands), [for future vids] Titans (Magical islands).
The Colossals and Titans are the islands themselves (the thing that the monsters Stand, Eat, Sleep and Sing on)
I purposely just haven’t been including the colossals, for the same reason I haven’t included the castle
@@Jake.Miller The collosals are monsters though. I also believe you should include castle too.
You should absolutely read the bios! They give the monsters so much more personality and everyone's bio makes me love them so much more!
Tbh its a waste of time. I dont want the video length to be doubled by bios.
@Nerd_d yes!!
He does read bios from time to time. Just look at what he said about Rare Dandidoo or Rare Quibble for example
OMG, your plant island video is what got me into MSM! I love the game and I've waited forever for this sequel and now, I'm grateful to see it. ☺️
Nice! I’m sure you’re a lot further in the game than me haha
The reason there’s so many bird monsters is because all 2-element monsters with the air element (sans Cybop) are birds. If/when you get to the Fire Islands, you’ll see Glowl as well
LETS GOOOO!!! I’m so glad you decided to make another msm video. And thanks for defending my boy pango, although I think he deserves higher than B, i’ll take it. (also I agree, I also love cold island, its one of my favorite islands in the game)
Hi, I love your videos
MSM Content
I'm glad you enjoyed it, and I do think Pango is great haha
MSContent spotted in the wild
Holy noggin is that the content of the msm
Ive never played these games before, but i still love watching content about it, espacially on this channel
Oh how long I’ve been waiting for this my love
Haha woah prepare to be friendzoned buddy
Both rare and epic quibble are from the dawn of fire, with rares being quibbles that never truly accepted growing up, and epics being surviving prismatic from the cataclysm
Also with rare deedge and rare quibble being "lgbt icons" just wait until rare quarrister (literally is in its bio) and whiz-bang
Also epic grumpyre has a morbius reference in the bio
5:50 yay i get to explain something! Ok, so Epic quibble is a Red Prismatic Quibble from Dawn of Fire. According to the lore, Due to corkscrew base design things they survived into the contemporary (current) era. Also prismatic come from the prism gate which changes monsters on a molecular level, which is why it looks so diseased.
8:36 Thumpies are from the game Thumpies! All of them are based on thumpies from the game thumpies, along with the "thumpies totem" and "thumpies totem, too" and every "Thumpiepalooza" costume as well
"thumpies are from the game thumpies, all of them are based on thumpies from the game thumpies" 🔥✍️
Jake, you were asking about the birds, pretty much every single element natural or fire bred with tweedle results in a bird of the other elements type, for example mammot and tweedle makes a cold bird, pango. Not sure why they decided to do that but it resulted in a bunch of double elemental bird monsters.
I suppose that makes sense, tweedle has a dominant gene huh
The only exception being cybop, which is a, uh... Robot flying shrimp thing?
@@Jake.Miller Actually in game code it's actually the prioritized elements (Goes first from left to right in display stuff) so kinda?
@@franciscapicornellarrom4518its a machine bird
Can’t wait to see what Jake has to say about Epic Quibble
Haha that was a good one
Wait why did the epic quibble blue in your comment
@@Privatebean9183 What
This is a sequel I’ve been hoping for for a long time, and it’s quite nice that it has come out at a rough patch in my existence. Now I can enjoy more ranking of musical monsters of a game series I’ve never played aaaa
I was waiting for part 2, glad you actually did it!
Hope it was worth the wait!
OMG ITS BEEN FOREVER! Tysm for still doing this series for msm, they're actually very enjoyable for me. I hope we can keep continuing this one :)
I’m excited to see you rank the next island! Y’know, the least liked Natural Island because of how crowded it is! (Also I’m excited for when you rank Psychic Island, because it has my 2nd fav monster: Edamimi!)
Yea I share that opinion unfortunately haha. But I’m glad you’re excited!
ABOUT TIME 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
No way, i found out about your channel yesterday and found your way of ranking super entertaining, but got dissapointed when i saw you hadn't posted a MSM ranking video in nearly a year, and today this pops up in my feed.
What crazy timing! You joined at just the right moment
the congle ranking hurts me for now, but just you wait for its future appearances. the crab shall rise one day, and you shall witness it firsthand.
great video can't wait for more :D
Ok I will wait and see! Thanks!
Been waiting for this for a long while! Hopefully the series continues
Yea we’ll see!
Okay, wow that blackface Yool joke caught me off guard... well played, Jakey boy. Well played indeed.
Haha I’ve made that exact joke twice now which is crazy
@Jake.Miller If I had a nickel for every time Jake Miller made a blackface joke, I'd have 2 nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice...
There it is haha I was gonna say it myself
This was a super cool video! I'd love to see Air Island sometime soon
So coooool. Yea we’ll see!
The are so many birds because they have the Air element, which wasn't on Plant Island since Tweedle wasn't there
This is so hype I’m so happy this series is returning 🙏🙏🙏
This is your collest video yet and im chill with most of your opnions so great video
Wowwww very cold puns there
Great video! I hope to see the series continued further. :)
Next time would you want to consider including the castle in your rankings? I believe it warrants a ranking akin to the other monsters, as it generally produces an impactful bass sound.
I’ll consider it but I’m just not sure about it
@ That’s alright. Personally I’d consider it, though! The Castle Bass adds a surprising amount of character to most islands.
Also, the castle can be muted if you want to remove it from the segments where you showcase monsters individually.
I don’t think I knew it could be muted, good to know
13:39 Oh no, He’s straight up doing Sundae Face 💀
i love how you made this video in the winter
It is indeed cold outside
Epic Quibble has some very cool lore. Made me like it more.
What’s the lore?
@@Jake.Miller
from my understanding, Epic Quibble is a surviving prismatic from the prequel game (if u dont know, prismatics are alien-like variants that come in different colors)
Every prismatic got swallowed by a portal (or something) except for Quibble's red prismatic (which shares the same design as Epic Quibble), the bio says it is able to "anchor itself into the ground, granting it exceptional resistance to 'extreme weather' and making it difficult to uproot", which I believe is why it's the only one to survive getting sucked into the portal
And also the bio is the only one that has "epic!" Instead of "extraordinary!"
you don't know how long I've been waiting for this video 😭 great stuff🙏
Haha probably about a year if I had to guess
I’ve waited a year for this
Hopefully worth the wait?
The Thumpies are from another game and in lore another universe and each one from the common, rare, and epic have cannon names
I do know about the game they made for them, I assume that came after their addition here tho
Also, that means the Thumpies aren't monsters
@@Jake.MillerActually, the original Thumpieverse came out on 2010, 2 whole years before MSM
wow
@@Jake.Miller You think you could rank all the Thumpies
Just fitting as I went to the mountains for the winter with my family.
Very cold
Thx for calling me melodic. Appreciate it my G 👍🏻
Also where did you get that image at 2:50
Haha I just looked up tweedle memes. And you’re welcome
I like the new channel icon!
Thanks! It’s supposed to mimic the msm logo
6:12 YESSS FINALLY, FINALLY SOMEONE WHO DOESN'T THINK EPIC QUIBBLE IS A FREAK OF NATURE I LOVE EPIC QUIBBLE (btw, epic quibble is the same monster as Red Prismatic Quibble from Dawn of Fire)
Haha I don’t know how you could hate that it’s awesome
On Air Island, you better rank Riff high
Haven’t watched yet but if Boggart isn’t at the top of the list imma be mad
Edit: I am satisfied
I thought Strombonin was an Armadillo
I also didn’t know there was an Epic for him
Bro actually forgot noggin
Not on cold island
@@Jake.MillerYes he is, behind the castle
Noggin-msm-u6p are you stupid
@bgozeno, im noggin from msm
No you’re not your a 7 year old kid
The grand return!
Very grand
I already know that Jake is going to LOVE earth island🙏
How’d you know?
Cant wait for more!!
I hope we get air island soon, it has always been my favourite!
S tier: I love you you're the best!
A tier: You're pretty damn good
B tier: I like you
C tier: You're ok
D tier: I don't like you
F tier: Why do you exist? Get out of my game!
Haha yea that’s pretty accurate
1:02 This line is actually crazy good
I’m soooo clever
I kinda hope the Air Island tierlist doesn't take too long. It's my favorite island out of the Natural Islands.
Well you might not want to see it from me then, I’m not a huge fan of that island haha
@Jake.Miller well either way, I'm just hoping it won't take long to come out. I NEED THE MY SINGING MONSTERS-
8:35 YES LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
30 years of msm rankings at this rate, sign me up
Haha I wonder how many people would actually come back for 30 years
Few steps closer to Wublin island. Better not do Gheegur dirty
you're... doing a sequel? You're back by popular demand!? Come on everybody! Strike up the band!
Strike it up NOW!!!
KEEP EM COMING
Yep just one short year and we’ll be on a roll!
wow first time seeing this channel in a long time
Well I haven’t been anywhere so that’s on YOU 🤬🤬🤬😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬😁
@@Jake.Miller don’t worry I’ll disappear for another year and come back again
Epic quibble actually has a reason to look like that but its in the games prequel
"The colossals will be ranked next time" he said with a masive amount of copium
Dang Congle slander. That’s unfortunate. It sounds really cool in other islands. At least according to me.
I’ve only ever owned it here so I guess we’ll see
PLEASE DO MORE OF THESE
OK I WANT TO
Hey, i like the Baritone! And play it too!
Yay msm
Did not realise the first my singing monsters video was 1 year ago
Yep a FULL year
epic wubbox also has a singing part
Nice new vid Jake
Also quick question when is the all Chompers ranked vid releasing?
Soon
@ Ok but what day of the month like the date
WE ARE SO BACK
Whoa more MSM! Do Mythical Island as I hate the natural islands.
MULTICOLOR PROFILE? THIS IS INSANE
Haha I’M FREAKING OUT
@ YUP MY REACTION ENTIRELY. I also think because you’ve got a lot of colors in your profile now you technically don’t have to change it whenever you do pvz or angry birds. Still cool you do this though
I did not know deejus had no legs
Now i am traumatized
Thanks jake
haha deejus
When is the ranking every single rabbids invasion episodes from seasons 1-4 coming Jake?
Not related to msm
I want you to make every Sonic characters ranked
Creepypasta count
You should rank the colossals aswell
"Nobody likes me. Everyone's afraid of me. It's because I am...weird."
🔥✍
Finally part 2
FINALLY
Bro why have I been getting none of these video notifications???? I genuinely thought Jake quit the channel tbh.
5:27 if u don't like a humanoid mon on a piano, I don't think ur gonna like Loodvigg...
Haha I didn’t know there was actually a monster that fit that description
I plan to Rank all 288 Episodes of it from Worst to Best, so I might just have you rank the first 72 AstroLOLogy Episodes.
Chapters (A Set of 12 Episodes with 1 for each Star Sign include)
Rom-antics
Cat-astrophe
On Duty
Off Duty
Starry Nights
On the Move
I remember when this guy used to did DHBM :)
Good times good times
I Think After Cold Island, The Next One Is Air Island. (Pom Pom Became The Third My Singing Monsters Mascot)
This is a good vid
jake at this rate you're not gonna make it to earth island with all the hitmen the fans are sending out
Haha why would the fans do that
Ok y'all gonna pay for that
Haha uh ohhhh
9:57 sleep with one eye open...
Oh no congle fans weren’t supposed to see this!!!
Cant wait for air island
In 2026 haha
Or maybe August
Yeah, I don´t see the Appeal in this Game.
FINALLY
I feel like you upload every Sunday
I do! Haha
@ knew it
Do you have a discord?
The first frame is water island
I already want more
Haha don’t worry one year isn’t THAT long
Fun fact The concept art you showed for Thumpies was there design from the original Thumpies game
Also the Thumpies all have names. Common Thumpies NoObiE and FurFacE. Rare RawT and ReeCesS. Epic Izzy and RhooTz
I do know about that game, I guess I forgot to mention it
@Jake.Miller it’s okay it a spin off
I feel like you undervalue potbelly automatically, he adds a lot to his verse, him and oaktapus go together wonderfully and add rhythm to their verse
that's a fair take, I just didn't think they were that great here
Out of curiosity where would you rank epic gjoob on your plant island tier list
I genuinely have not looked at its design yet I’ll have to look it up
WE NEED MORE SMS VIDEOS! ❤️
Haha ok I’ll get to work on some sms sasp!
Ive waited a year for this
Hopefully worth the wait?
Haven’t heard your voice in months
Haha that’s you’re fault I haven’t gone anywhere
@ I haven’t been on your channel in a while
Jake will you also rank dawn of fire songs? Or just msm
Like the baby versions of the monsters?
I predicted that the Epic Tweedle and Epic Grunpyre would be F Tier just as much as you.
Haha they’re awful
Yep, they’re really awful
I would say Sponge is S. He carries his section of the song.
wow this video sure is cool haha get it like cold is-
Heheehhahahaha
pls more of this
12:11 excuse me what?! 💀
0:00 no its pretty sunny but thanks for asking
Haha where I live it’s very snowy and cold