She’s really embracing her darker tone , and it’s so beautiful . I think she’s adapting to the 5th octave belts .. it seems harder to do it when she’s not nasally 😻
She had a naturally darker tone than what she is known for anyways; I wonder if it she wasn't forced to do a lot of those high belts from like 1993 onwards would her voice be in better shape. Like her first album and emotions, while technically less consistent and more strained, was a big showcase for her darker tone and then she got vocal lessons. 1993 was a great year where she retained some of that soulful/fuller/darker sound but also could belt/mix well and then after that she was belting extremely high by 1994. Listen to the demo that she did in either 1986 or 1987 of Weakness of The Body in it's original key. She had a naturally deep voice there. Also when she was singing hero at the basketball game where Michael Jordan was watching, specifically when she was singing 'The way' part in the sound. It sounded so full and darker, kind of like the f#4 in this video at 4:44 and I'm pretty sure there is another thing I can link but I can't remember what it was off the top of my head that showcased her darker tone.
@@thelegendofmimi3151 I KNOWWW I JUST REALIZED SHE JUST NEEDED HER BELTS and also falsetto too but early to mid 2022 she had an accessible falsetto but her head-voice is treating her well this era. Atleast her mid belts were great.
Toronto 2nd night was the best of the tour, she sounded pretty good there, strong lows, belts were more accessible and free, more controlled, like the whistles
Her chest voice sounds resonant and clear here it’s just the first MSG date it got tired towards the end and her fluidity and whistles have been at its best since 2013
@@benriveranav nah I think 2022's whistles are for the most part better than 2019's whistles because 2022 had better pitch for the most part, plus her whistles in 2022 are airier and don't have that head voice/scratchy quality Caution's whistles had
It’s odd how touring tires her voice but not touring seems to tire it out too. Like when she was performing through 2017 her voice tired out but then by the end of 2017 her voice was in a better place for the Christmas shows. Same thing in 2018 with the butterfly returns and then the Asia tour where her voice improved.
That also happens with 2014. Like her 2014 voice is great its just very inconsistent but in her xmas shows on that year shes like literally almost on her prime level.
I think it’s like a difference of how bad/inflamed her voice is. Like rainbow, Butterfly, TAOM tours all were inflamed, so she would benefit from rest (as is the case in 2022). But when her voice is not that inflamed it can improve with use- like 2016, 2018, 2003, etc. I think Mariah may not understand this difference, but I’m confidence that she’s adapting to a new voice , even if it’s one that’s not live onstage😭
Mariah doesn’t owe us anything at all so I’m very grateful for her to have done these shows but after 2 years of rest she shouldn’t sound like this. Rest is necessary but it’s not the only factor into having an overall better voice, while her fluidity and lows have improved she has a plethora of other issues that can only be helped by a vocal coach and I’m aware Mariah thinks that if she learns the rules that they’ll limit her creative freedom but I just want her to know that there’s a way for her to do what she wants more easily and more consistently as her vocal problems are very apparent rn, ik she’s a singer and all singers have bad days and with Mariah’s nodules that’s times 5 but a vocal coach will help her navigate those bad days much better than she has been but bottom line I’m grateful for anything Mariah puts out for me to enjoy I just had a thought
I didnt realize how good some of her vocals were this tour. I was assuming her voice was just inconsistent and horrible but now i realized it was actually better
Mariah The QueenDiva❤❤❤. nobody is better than her because her voice is very unique and very very special.. everytime she sings a lot of surprises are there for us to be inspired and amazed❤❤❤
That f#4 at 4:44 sounded like when she was singing hero at a basketball game in front of michael jordon, right when she was singing 'the way;. it was so full and dark, and not like her usual way of belting and making it very bright and light .
we need to embrace her ligher tone is gone and she has a darker one. she should make new albums with this new tone she has. i think the reason why people think she can't sing anymore is because her voice doesn't suit her old songs anymore. She's really a butterfly who goes to another metamorphosis
We're acting as if she didn't have a "darker tone" in her debut..? And she doesn't have that much of a tone difference, she still has a very light timbre.
@@mar-ui2sr true, but clearly, her tone now is more relaxed in the darker tone than before. And people who listened to her a lot would know she has had this since her debut than what she's mostly known for with the lighter tone. Idk what's the point of your comment tbh. It's like you're trying to be sarcastic, but also leaving it blank.
Her voice is in such a tragic state that I almost feel sorry for her. Seeing the comment section filled with delusional fans praising her for lip synched vocals or for sounding merely decent is kinda sad, considering her peak.
Her belting is damn near gone yall only talk about the alright stuff or it’s lipped stop being delusional and let her rest for at least a few years….and I know Mariah loves seeing her fans but there’s other ways of doing it rather then trying to hit notes you did 30 years ago she needs proper vocal warmups too😢😅hopefully this year isn’t that bad not hating I’m genuinely concerned
I don’t know why people think that she sings live just when she do something that they was not waiting for I undertand that all was live alllllllllll cause could hear her voice out of playback so I don’t know why live is just the normal. Notes why is not live the f5 of o holy night
she sound out of breath in a lot of occasions really. but the creative adlibs, the runs, the lows, mid-chest and whistles are great. most of the "I love her but..." lambs are her worst enemy. because most of the time it's not a constructive criticism, it's plain hate. oh, if you're not one of those, don't feel attacked, this comment is not target to you.
Tho theres no need for collab 😭. You can ask me if you want help tho but you can make the MSG version without the need to credit me. I rlly wanna do the MSG part cuz i wanna do something after its released. And I kind of already collected the clips for it but i wanna wait for the professional recorded one. Ty for asking me to collab which is actually a big deal for me but as i said i wanna do something else tho 😭. But I’m willing to help if you ever feel the need to bestoe ❤️. We could collab for some other vids tho.
So many wrong notes like instead of E6 in When Christmas Comes, you made F6 & Fly Like A Bird's G#6 was actually G6 And you included many lipped notes like intro of Emotions 😔
Before you say she lost her voice and not capable of singing,remember Olivia rodrigo, Billie eilish, Selena Gomez, taylor swift, halsey,justin bieber,jungkook,britney spears,Jennifer lopez, none of them can even do what mariah is doing post prime let alone during here prime
Her belts werent on point it is obvious the damage in her chords and the age is another important factor What about to remove her nodules and start again she would suffer like this in the hard parts as a big fan it hurts me to see a perfeccionist like her Without being able to sing almost effortlessly even if the key of the songs were lowrr
Her vibrato is at its best since 2014
I agree 😭
2017riah Paris Christmas Concerts also gave us huge vibrato moments in most of the songs
Agree
The whistle at 2:47 was so pretty 😭😭
yasss
If she only had her belts these shows would have been perfect😭
yehhh 😭
@@DaydreamCarey1234 she didn't have her tea those days💔
Falsetto and belts*
And her head voice too because it seemed inconsistent and not fluid
Joann.IOVES.IOVES.IOVES.IOVES.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
She’s really embracing her darker tone , and it’s so beautiful . I think she’s adapting to the 5th octave belts .. it seems harder to do it when she’s not nasally 😻
Same I love her dark tone 🤩
Sadly she only did it because she was sick during the whole tour and when shes sick shes forced to do a darker tone. I wish she embraced it tho
She had a naturally darker tone than what she is known for anyways; I wonder if it she wasn't forced to do a lot of those high belts from like 1993 onwards would her voice be in better shape. Like her first album and emotions, while technically less consistent and more strained, was a big showcase for her darker tone and then she got vocal lessons. 1993 was a great year where she retained some of that soulful/fuller/darker sound but also could belt/mix well and then after that she was belting extremely high by 1994.
Listen to the demo that she did in either 1986 or 1987 of Weakness of The Body in it's original key. She had a naturally deep voice there.
Also when she was singing hero at the basketball game where Michael Jordan was watching, specifically when she was singing 'The way' part in the sound. It sounded so full and darker, kind of like the f#4 in this video at 4:44 and I'm pretty sure there is another thing I can link but I can't remember what it was off the top of my head that showcased her darker tone.
@@butterflyera she actually wasn't sick at all during that tour!!
The confidence and creativity is through the roof now we just need some hot tea
yehhh her hot tea is missing again 😭. But she slayeddd
11:26 that quick run tho!!! Plus the vibrato before!! 😍
She did the original run so many song😭 the details!!!
I knowww 😭 and we didn’t even realized that she used to put those runs until. 2022 is definitely something.
specially 7:42
@@DaydreamCarey1234 Ikr if next year her belts are back. 2023 its gonna be another best year for vocal!!!😭😭😭😭😭
@@thelegendofmimi3151 I KNOWWW I JUST REALIZED SHE JUST NEEDED HER BELTS and also falsetto too but early to mid 2022 she had an accessible falsetto but her head-voice is treating her well this era. Atleast her mid belts were great.
Toronto 2nd night was the best of the tour, she sounded pretty good there, strong lows, belts were more accessible and free, more controlled, like the whistles
Also the way her voice as a whole sounded more light and relaxed/free compared to other days 💅
Even at her mature voice it's still so hard to copy her singing style.
Mariah is real the one and only
Her chest voice sounds resonant and clear here it’s just the first MSG date it got tired towards the end and her fluidity and whistles have been at its best since 2013
I think actually these whistles been at its best since 2018 (bcuz of caution world tour) but i agree with fluidity
@@benriveranav nah I think 2022's whistles are for the most part better than 2019's whistles because 2022 had better pitch for the most part, plus her whistles in 2022 are airier and don't have that head voice/scratchy quality Caution's whistles had
It’s odd how touring tires her voice but not touring seems to tire it out too. Like when she was performing through 2017 her voice tired out but then by the end of 2017 her voice was in a better place for the Christmas shows. Same thing in 2018 with the butterfly returns and then the Asia tour where her voice improved.
That also happens with 2014. Like her 2014 voice is great its just very inconsistent but in her xmas shows on that year shes like literally almost on her prime level.
I think it’s like a difference of how bad/inflamed her voice is. Like rainbow, Butterfly, TAOM tours all were inflamed, so she would benefit from rest (as is the case in 2022). But when her voice is not that inflamed it can improve with use- like 2016, 2018, 2003, etc. I think Mariah may not understand this difference, but I’m confidence that she’s adapting to a new voice , even if it’s one that’s not live onstage😭
2:47 this whistle has the same tone as the one she did at the end of My All in 2014
3:09 her tone through this whole song oh my god especially the first “glory”
12:34 mygoshh
that run is such a slayyy 😭💅
Toronto night 2 was the best of all shows. Period
I agree 💅💅
I’m LOVING her vibrato her runs…and her deep tone omg so good. 🤩🤩🤩
Ik and her deep tone>>> caution tone 😭
Mariah doesn’t owe us anything at all so I’m very grateful for her to have done these shows but after 2 years of rest she shouldn’t sound like this. Rest is necessary but it’s not the only factor into having an overall better voice, while her fluidity and lows have improved she has a plethora of other issues that can only be helped by a vocal coach and I’m aware Mariah thinks that if she learns the rules that they’ll limit her creative freedom but I just want her to know that there’s a way for her to do what she wants more easily and more consistently as her vocal problems are very apparent rn, ik she’s a singer and all singers have bad days and with Mariah’s nodules that’s times 5 but a vocal coach will help her navigate those bad days much better than she has been but bottom line I’m grateful for anything Mariah puts out for me to enjoy I just had a thought
The greatest vocalist of all time
I didnt realize how good some of her vocals were this tour. I was assuming her voice was just inconsistent and horrible but now i realized it was actually better
Mariah The QueenDiva❤❤❤. nobody is better than her because her voice is very unique and very very special.. everytime she sings a lot of surprises are there for us to be inspired and amazed❤❤❤
14:40 the frist "hold on" it's eb5
incredible video! The best I've seen of mariah's vocals on Christmas 2022, congratulations!
it was actually a fan 😭
7:00 now let's not be delusional😭😭
opinion exists dahhling. I said “for me”
@@DaydreamCarey1234 I know but still😭😭 I respect your opinion but like....2014 exists☠️
@@Fishriah_Ari thats exactly the point if why i said that cuz of “2014”
@@DaydreamCarey1234 what about 2014?😭
@@Fishriah_Ari they flopped for not doing the C5.
Toronto Day 2 should’ve been the one recorded for the special
Queen thingz only babess 💅
12:00 was the magical christmas special's vocal.
the magical has a vibrato in it. This one doesn’t. And also xmas magical sounded more thin and bell like sound.
10:59 did not know that existed, but i like how it sounds really light (she could go into the seventh octave in that way)
yassss also that would probably be the first time she did a flab whistle live on stage.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 girl kudos to u. The mere thought of a 15 min video is exhausting (it takes me months to even start lol)
@@yeetvocals3786 Well i mean my videos were low edited unlike yours 😭😭. Ty anyways tho ❤️❤️ u still outsold in many ways 💅
@@DaydreamCarey1234 ACTUALLY SHE DID A VERY VERY SIMILAR ONE I THINK BACK IN 2006 IDK
@@ellegimeno wait where? Omggggg
3:59 🥺✨🌹
beautiful gowns
Thanks for uploading these!
❤️❤️
That f#4 at 4:44 sounded like when she was singing hero at a basketball game in front of michael jordon, right when she was singing 'the way;. it was so full and dark, and not like her usual way of belting and making it very bright and light .
we need to embrace her ligher tone is gone and she has a darker one. she should make new albums with this new tone she has. i think the reason why people think she can't sing anymore is because her voice doesn't suit her old songs anymore. She's really a butterfly who goes to another metamorphosis
We're acting as if she didn't have a "darker tone" in her debut..?
And she doesn't have that much of a tone difference, she still has a very light timbre.
@@mar-ui2sr true, but clearly, her tone now is more relaxed in the darker tone than before. And people who listened to her a lot would know she has had this since her debut than what she's mostly known for with the lighter tone.
Idk what's the point of your comment tbh. It's like you're trying to be sarcastic, but also leaving it blank.
"Caution" is the album with the darker tone.
Urgente ejercicios con vocalcoach, por presión todavía trata de cantar como cuando era más joven, me encantan sus graves ojalá los aproveche a futuro
9:20 for nowdays Mariah 2023 and later 😂
6:19 rainbow who
I am a broadway singer...thank you Jesus Christ for my best vocal range like MARIAH C....PSALM 40, PSALM 100🎶🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎶🎶🎤🦋🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
the edge in her voice seems to be getting more prevalent
Wdym?
@@shadowcArey the lack of fluidity and rasp
@@shadowcArey more rasp and grainy sound creeping to the fourth octave
I think is not completala live …but is same!!!❤️love you mariah 🎉the best !!!
Her voice is in such a tragic state that I almost feel sorry for her. Seeing the comment section filled with delusional fans praising her for lip synched vocals or for sounding merely decent is kinda sad, considering her peak.
I agree and shes my favourite singer 😢
Agree with you, the holy night whistles and high belts are lipped
10:18 is this live?!! Even if it isnt that intro was AMAZING 😭😭
14:40 that first hold on is an Eb5
The emotions intro isn't live unfortunately🥲
Also there is no Eb5, it was a fan. There's other angles from the same date showing her hitting a Bb4😭
Her belting is damn near gone yall only talk about the alright stuff or it’s lipped stop being delusional and let her rest for at least a few years….and I know Mariah loves seeing her fans but there’s other ways of doing it rather then trying to hit notes you did 30 years ago she needs proper vocal warmups too😢😅hopefully this year isn’t that bad not hating I’m genuinely concerned
2023 litterly 10× better than 2022
Thank u for this
Can we stop pretending as If this is good???
? her dress is fabulous
Can you do Monroe and her vocal showcase performance.....what low notes Monroe hit?
why does she always act like she' s got parkinson when the playback comes in? hahaha
we stan parkinsonriah tho 💅
8:19 Parkinsonsriah unleash!! 😍😍😍
I’m dead
I don’t know why people think that she sings live just when she do something that they was not waiting for I undertand that all was live alllllllllll cause could hear her voice out of playback so I don’t know why live is just the normal. Notes why is not live the f5 of o holy night
she sound out of breath in a lot of occasions really. but the creative adlibs, the runs, the lows, mid-chest and whistles are great.
most of the "I love her but..." lambs are her worst enemy. because most of the time it's not a constructive criticism, it's plain hate.
oh, if you're not one of those, don't feel attacked, this comment is not target to you.
FINALLY SOMEONEE 💅💅💅
A lot of that "live" vocals are actually pre recorded
GIRL WHAT iF WE DO THIS A COLLAB AND I DO A PART 2 WITH MSG SHOWS 😍
That would be great actually!
Tho theres no need for collab 😭. You can ask me if you want help tho but you can make the MSG version without the need to credit me. I rlly wanna do the MSG part cuz i wanna do something after its released. And I kind of already collected the clips for it but i wanna wait for the professional recorded one. Ty for asking me to collab which is actually a big deal for me but as i said i wanna do something else tho 😭. But I’m willing to help if you ever feel the need to bestoe ❤️. We could collab for some other vids tho.
@@DaydreamCarey1234 okie❤
Can you do the same for MSG
Im actually gonna do it. I might release after the CBS thing for pro footages of it.
You did some notes wrong. For example my all is B4-A4 not Bb and G#
I thought the B4-A4 were the climax part?
So many wrong notes like instead of E6 in When Christmas Comes, you made F6 & Fly Like A Bird's G#6 was actually G6
And you included many lipped notes like intro of Emotions 😔
Before you say she lost her voice and not capable of singing,remember Olivia rodrigo, Billie eilish, Selena Gomez, taylor swift, halsey,justin bieber,jungkook,britney spears,Jennifer lopez, none of them can even do what mariah is doing post prime let alone during here prime
yasss
jungkook is so random lol. you should've just said bts in general
@@batch9518 i mean he is the main vocalist of the group
@@batch9518 I mean i think hes the only one who could atleast sing on the group 😭
Her belts werent on point it is obvious the damage in her chords and the age is another important factor What about to remove her nodules and start again she would suffer like this in the hard parts as a big fan it hurts me to see a perfeccionist like her Without being able to sing almost effortlessly even if the key of the songs were lowrr
I'm sorry. This was horrible! The background singers were better