วีดีโอ

I don't think Victor is a malevolent actor but the town "needs" him for a purpose. So his 40 years of solitude was somehow protected. If the FROM has the ability to know so many things, it wouldn't be hard to retconn one boy. Though Victor has his issues, he's relatively intact for someone who's experienced that extended period of trauma/fear/isolation. Whether he's been spared to be a force of good or to put something much worse in motion I guess we'll find out. Soon. I hope. I guess the burning question is how he'll react to Tabitha's adventure and his father's presence?

Everyone(TH-camrs)is talking about "the reset." Was there ever a reset? IMO, there's not enough info to say so. Everyone assumes that when Victor was left alone, everything reset. Reset from what? The only reason we THINK Victor's group wasn't the first is because of the monsters' 40s/50s clothing and Jade seeing ww1 soldiers, etc, but We don't know for sure.....is that a 1950s diner? Was colony house and the townhouses built it they 50s? There's a whole lot we just don't know

If the crows are warning ppl at the tree in the road...... they are not helping 😂 we have no idea if finding away around the tree saves you from fromville(i think it's worse), but the crows only make you want to turn around because that's creepy

I'm not sure why things are changing in fromville except for Boyd killing the monster and the aftermath(cicadas)of that and also the monsters changing tactics to break Boyd. I do believe there's someone overseeing everything (radio voice)that might explain the monsters changing but not the weather. "It's never snowed before" - Victor

Victor should not die🗣 Victor is the key🗣 OG in fromville, his mom and her visions, his dad with his insight on mom, his knowledge of the wayward trees and the bottle tree, etc.

He did move those cars when he became a grown man. remember his been in Fromvile for 40 yrs. He hast times and lots or workout. but food is scarce at the same time

My big question is how are the Ankooey children made.

Im loving the conversation..

I think tillie is evil.. she mentioned she's had 4 kids.. 7 grandkids... 7 of the hatueeee (absolutely not spelled right) kids.. she is always everywhere or nowhere.. why did she put the cards in that table and not her fanny pack? How did she know the cards where there if she didn't put them there.. if tillie doesn't read someone a reading I'm going to assume she can't read the cards.. and the crow coming in the window was a sigh to tillie that she is the one..

Christopher is alive and well and was shopping at the vintage flea market in town just steps from Tabitha. He has on a light blue and white striped shirt. There are at least 6 other people from the other side in the real world. Different hair, dressed differently, they are there.

25:39 Victor was 10 (1978) when he, his sister and mom went missing. He is about 56 now (54 in 2022 when the show first aired). BasicallyATraumatized 10Y trapped in a 56YO man's body.

17:17 I have to agree with you, crows get a bad rap in modern times but have generally been seen as chaotic "neutral" or as a warning signs when dark shady stuff is happening or about to happen - trying to give people a heads-up. Also Nordic gods like Odin, was represented by Crows...and a few others. I don't see them as out rightly malevolent.

Est638 🎉my sister crave white dirt. There were places in the south that actually sold the stuff, when she couldnt get the dirt she would eat argo starch. She would buy the powered kind and pour water on it and let it dry so it would be crunchie. I didnt know the weird cravings were called pica.

Ngl I think the nightmare creature killed everyone including Christopher, or Christopher killed everyone like Boyds wife then ripped them apart like Sarah did that new guy in S1

I think after Christopher left the doll talked to Victor and the reason Victor is traumatized is because Victor told Jasper where people were hiding and doesn’t wanna remember it. It will be revealed Chris was looking for Victor to find out what Victor told the puppet

How much are they paying heckle and jeckle and the crow posses to spy and snitch on peoples. they havent worked since the omen when we saw them then they wereup to no good. Whenever they showed up somebody were going to die a tragic death.

The boy in white helped him he said it

The monsters aren’t from his cycle. People running with that theory have been the worst lmao

I loved it. I’m excited to see what everyone is looking at in the pool in whatever promo I saw for episode 5. Grace love and peace to all in the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth ✝️❤️ <-- if that offends you, I’m not sorry.

My question was about the bodies. But now that we see the mosters plotting and planning, it could have been them. If you look at any scene you will see Jasper in the TV. Is he the one that's watching and giving information and calling ? Or is the crows doing it? I have soooo many questions! Love your channel 🎉

30:18 he had 30 years to move those cars and move those bodies

22:34 all I’m saying is that Victor is not catching a cold because there’s no other people really, he’s not catching any STDs. He’s not catching the flu if he’s not around other people. The only thing that could take him out would be something that started in his own body like cancer or some autoimmune disease or an injury

Maybe Victor's dad is really Christopher. Thats why Victor is so traumatized. I know his name is Henry but there is still something wrong with his story. He knew his wife was dead. He suspected his son was dead. But he never once asked about the daughter.

Some fans think the CROW came in to wake Elgin, not to interfere with the TArot cards. I don't though.

From the actor that plays Victor. He was 12 when his mom leaves and he’s now 52 that 40 years. His father is in his mid 70’s. Victor said he did NOT move all the vehicles. Kids on farms start driving at 10 so nothing new here. He had a lot of time to move the cars what else did he have to do go to work? LOL? Donna is the next person to come along she’s been there a bit over 3 years. Boyd has been there 1.5 yrs. All the questions re who buried what did he eat etc-this is a mystery. This is not a show that has rational answers like we have in our lives. The answers will not be ones we will ever think of.

So here is a thought… What if Victor is actually evil but he don’t even know it. Think about it. He has been around all this time but how?! Victor has suppressed memories and can not remember things due to trauma and probably wanting to forget what has happened. Out of all the ppl in the town, we keep getting info about Victor and his family and now his dad has entered the chat? Idk, something is telling me Victor plays a huge part in ALL of this.

Most of the monsters are wearing costumes, uniforms, or attire that lets you know more about them, (for example, the monster in the wedding dress and the cheerleader monster). During all 3 seasons, we have not seen any human arrive and survive who was wearing a uniform, until police officer Acosta and bus driver Bakta. So, we have a milkman monster, a cowboy monster, a nurse monster, a mechanic monster, a truck driver monster, etc. But, there is no police officer monster or a bus driver monster. (Smiley the Monster pretended to drive the bus, but he was not wearing a bus driver uniform.) Since Acosta & Bakta arrived and survived wearing uniforms, will they, sometime down the road, turn into a cop monster and a bus driver monster?

There is an issue some pregnant women suffer from during pregnancy it’s called Pica. It causes women wanting to eat dirt, chalk and other very odd things. Check it out it’s real. I think Tilly and Fatima are just a nothing burger. Nothing will be what most people think. I do believe all the answers are contained in the first episode. It’s a game to start with.

Something is definitely going on with the names of the characters on the show. I think that some of these people are related to each other: You have Gertie (the lady who gave Tilly the tarot cards) and Trudy, the young woman who took Julie's blouse in Colony House. Trudy was also the one who flirted with Jade. Gertie and Trudy are nicknames for the name Gertrude. You have Thomas and Tom the Bartender. You have Christopher and Kristy. You have Mari and Martin. You have Ethan and Ethan Clarke. (Ethan Clark is the name of the reporter who wrote the newspaper article about the Matthews family that Tabitha googled and showed to Henry.) And, you have Ellis and Elgin (who I think are half-brothers). Is this all a coincidence or something more?

I have lots of questions about the diner. Why is the diner now always unlocked when: 1) there is an alleged food shortage, 2) the diner is no longer in business since there is no new "chef", and 3) Mrs. Liu always kept the diner locked up each day when she went home from the diner? So, after Mrs. Liu's death, who took Mrs. Liu's keys to unlock the diner, and why? Also, if there allegedly was no food, why was Ethan scrubbing pots and pans when Bakta found Ethan in the diner? As Ethan said himself, Mrs. Liu wasn't in the habit of leaving the diner in a mess. Therefore, those weren't unwashed dishes from when Tian Chen was still alive. So, who was cooking in the diner and dirtied up those dishes that Ethan found, and what were those people cooking since there was allegedly no food? I know that Jim and Kenny "found" veggies by the lake and cabins, but we didn't see them or anyone else bring the veggies back to the diner that has no chef to cook the veggies. When Clara left the flower in the diner right after Mrs. Liu's death/funeral, the diner counter was clean as a whistle. But, a short while later when Bakta showed up at the diner, the diner counter was full of dirty dishes. What happened in that short amount of time? Who was cooking? What were they eating? And why so soon after Tian Chen's sad demise, did they disrespect her memory by not cleaning up after themselves? I think I have the answer...

I think Victor has been in the town alone most of his time. He has been there 40 years. He could’ve moved those cars over the years and moved bones and not bodies.

Remember in the beginning, Tabitha told Ethan a group of crows can be known as an ,'unkindness' to downgrade the fear about them, also Tabitha a reentry was similar to Elgin, the no no, realization, she didn't have the physical reaction but her words, very similar, again making me think Elgin knows was there before

I LOVED Margo's comment "Victor just gave Sarah her 13th reason Why"... stealing this quote... beautiful!!

Observations: A: Isn't it interesting that Donna broke protocol the first time the policewoman comes into Colony House? And the puzzled look on her face followed by "Who else was with you on the ambulance?" Donna knows something. Is she working with the cop? Its sus. B: Julie watches in horror as Jim shakes Ethan and demands he tell him the truth. Is it possible angry Jim is not a saint and that is why Tabitha and him are getting a divorce. And possible it was Jim's fault the child Thomas died? C: Tabitha confides in a priest when she gets out of fromville. He knows she had a son. "What was his name?" he says. I believe someone on the outside is watching the people in fromville and the Priest is somehow connected to that group.

Victor's memories is sketchy. He can't remember, so his information is untrustworthy. I think he hasn't passed on somehow. He don't know he died. Also, i don't blame his sketchy memories. this show has given us two storylines with Older men and young boy storylines. Father Khatri told Boyd his story of how he got to Fromville and to date his story is the longest ever. Watch Boyd's face and the priest talks about a boy and chocolate. Like maybe the priest lied and he did something to the boy. Same thing with this Christopher storyline and Victor walking in on him and the dummy. Basements are for secrets Victor said. this probably means nothing, but it can't be overlooked how creepy and errie to even make that plausible. Victor is traumatized and was hiding from Christopher. Hopefully, Victor's dad will be able to talk to Victor in a way no one else can and get answers.

What if Christopher is still alive and is living in that old abandoned village. Maybe the footsteps belonged to him?

#1. Why did Sarah kill Tobey & make it seem like the monsters did it? Was Toby destined/chosen and it was against the rules to kill him? #2. Why the Cromenockle emphasis without much information on what it all means? Is this a device to lure children to this dimension/lair? #3. This place uses a variety of evils all contained in this one place for what purpose? Is this killing playground for alien children to play? A military experiment? A dark place where all kinds of evil nourishes? Or a cursed place for cursed bloodlines that vary dependent on their previous crimes? #4. Things are repeating why? Tien Chen broke a glass and cut her hand and Kenny said "You need to rest." Tabitha broke a glass and cut her hand and henry said "You need to rest?" Something here wants the people to play out a certain series of events. #5 Tilly says to Jim "I travel from place to place playing the ponies". Is Tilly playing a real live game as a monster and the humans are the ponies? #6 I don't Victor survived for 40 years. He was alone age 8-10years in a place filled with monsters. If he isn't dead, then the B.I.W. must have done something to make him a constant in FROMVILLE. Thus he can't die, but he can't leave Fromville either.

True, Tilly does seem quite focused on Fatima...🤔

Before Boyd, if you saw a monster it's probably because you were in trouble. After Boyd, you could be in a protected property and look out at the monsters. Victor has a child's mind But in addition I believe is deeply affected by PTSD. I like your theory on Jasper trying to get Christopher to do some bad and on Christopher being the resident of the cabins. The cabins have been made for a reason so your theory is viable. But the sad news with alot of this is that it's mear conjecture, we don't really have enough sound facts to make a strong argument. Anyway ... a good channel, a good discussion. Keep up the good work.

I like the cycle reset theory but Victor's survival preventing the reset doesn't make sense because if it didn't reset because of him, then why is that year listed as one of the reset years?

Victor is sus. He's a participant in some way but made to forget his previous sinister actions.

And another thing when Tabatha saw the tree for the second time why didn’t she try to walk over the tree instead of letting them continue to drive over and over. Do you think that would have stopped the curse on from Ville?

Sooooo....the evil wants to get out of the town. The seal has to be broken for that to happen. The evil wants Victor to live so that the town cannot reset the seal. The guardians of the town want Victor to die so that the seal can be replenished and the reset to happen. So in effect, the longer Victor lives, the more unstable the town will get until it breaks down and then big evil jailbreak. So the "help" that Victor got all these years to survive was supplied by the evil beings in the town. So basically, there are 2 opposing forces here...the prisoners (evil beings) and the prison guards (need to have the mass sacrifice for the reset). All that being said...the boy in white is evil.

I have a next question when When Boyd went into the woods and Martin gave him the worms how did Martin throw the rope into the well and was handcuff? How is that possible and with Fatima is she the woman in Elgin’s dream and does Tilly know who she is going to become that’s probably why she is helping her.

I also heard people saying😮 That the writing on Sarah hands might not have been for Ethan, but could possibly be for Victor When they told her to kill the boy, could they meant Victor or they meant Boyd?

I love the Victor reset theory! It makes perfect sense! The latest trailer shows everyone standing by the pool with the car in it, looking worried. Im wondering if someone goes into a tree next episode and ends up getting trapped under the car or falling from the sky and landing on the car.

Omg. You said you thought the crows might not be evil minutes after I was just wondering the same thing! I'm telling you, the show is meta, once you start the show and see that fallen tree, you're mentally trapped in Fromville. 😉😆

Something that has allowed me to examine theories is by using Google Notebook LM. I Google Reddit posts about theories I'm interested on, and load them into Notebook LM and generate a podcast discussion from it to listen to. It's really good at breaking things down and allowing me to examine theories whole multitasking. The dialogue might even give new ideas and jokes

Woot! My other favorite From channel! Thank you for your show. I'm just working on Godzilla news, and that takes work. Your show has to take quite a bit. I appreciate you all