CA State Parks of Santa Cruz
CA State Parks of Santa Cruz
  • 207
  • 74 564
Spikey Pancake Lizards in the Santa Cruz Mountains
Join one of our team members, Dylan McManus, as he sets out to find and observe one of the most interesting and unique lizard species in the greater San Francisco area: The Horned Lizard.
This species is believed to have been extirpated from the Sandhills areas of Henry Cowell Redwoods but persists at alternate sites. Watch this video to learn a bit about these lizards, why they've been extirpated, and why we should care.
Video Notes:
Enormous thanks to Zach Lim, Ryan Sikola, and James Maughn, for allowing us to use some of their images.
Deep dive video located here: th-cam.com/video/9VzX31rH57g/w-d-xo.html
มุมมอง: 196

วีดีโอ

An Artist's Book by Donna Thomas
มุมมอง 51วันที่ผ่านมา
A companion film to Donna Thomas's handmade accordion-fold book with watercolor and mixed media pictures and text that documents her and other Art Aboutists' experiences during their 2023 Big Basin backpacking trip. The film includes the author's narration of the pages.
Cycles by Patrick Hart - Trailer
มุมมอง 5414 วันที่ผ่านมา
This is the trailer for Cycles, a musical composition with visual elements that refreshes each time you play it. The piece is about appreciating a forest through all parts of its life cycle. Visit tapes.club/cycles to learn more about the project and view full length compositions. Cycles lives inside a free software application (Steam or Epic Games). When you launch Cycles, you can view a perfo...
Horned Lizards with Sarah Wenner
มุมมอง 7314 วันที่ผ่านมา
Watch this video to learn all about an extirpated lizard species of Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park; the Horned Lizard. This unique species once occurred in Sandhills habitat of the park, but has experienced a local disappearance and are generally believed to be removed from the area. Sarah Wenner is a PhD student at UC Berkeley studying CA Red-legged Frogs, but focused her master's thesis on ...
Roots and Fungi by Mary and Steven Albert
มุมมอง 8414 วันที่ผ่านมา
This five-minute film reveals and explains the vast network of underground mycorrhizae (aka fungi aka mushrooms) in the redwood forest along Big Basin’s Meteor Trail.
This Tree by Mary and Steven Albert
มุมมอง 12714 วันที่ผ่านมา
A journey up an old-growth redwood tree in Big Basin in one continuous shot, with delightful scientific and historical illumination along the way.
A Love Letter in the Time of Climate Change by Robin Lasser
มุมมอง 31414 วันที่ผ่านมา
This eight-minute film is an interview with State Park Senior Environmental Scientist Portia Halbert about why she chose the career she did and the importance of prescribed burns for land management. Per Portia: Burning has been a part of Big Basin since time immemorial, but for the past 150 years the park has not seen fire like it once did. With the CZU Lightning Complex fire we have a reset. ...
Breathing Prescribed Fire by Robin Lasser
มุมมอง 36414 วันที่ผ่านมา
Breathing Prescribed Fire is a ten-minute film that speaks to the agency of controlled burns. It includes interviews with fire scientists and juxtaposes the science of fire with the history, philosophy, and poetry of fire as a land management practice. This documentary takes place at Blodgett Research Forest in the Sierra Nevada. The film recognizes fire as a critical ecological process that ma...
Tent Talks by Robin Lasser
มุมมอง 4814 วันที่ผ่านมา
The 10-minute Tent Talks film is narrated by Susan Blake, state park interpreter I, and Estrella Bibbey, park volunteer and naturalist. The two narrators convey their mesmerizing and intimate accounts of living in and near the park for decades prior to the CZU Lightning Complex Fire, the experiences of camping within the park, and their roles as docent and interpreter. In turn they share their ...
A Conservation Story by Robin Lasser
มุมมอง 5314 วันที่ผ่านมา
A Conservation Story is an 8-minute short film addressing the early history of Big Basin Redwoods State Park. The transformation of this old-growth forest from a potential logging site to a protected park “to be preserved in a state of nature.” Historian Traci Bliss, author of Big Basin Redwood Forest: California’s Oldest State Park, narrates the first half of the film, bringing to life the wor...
Big Basin Art About Documentary by Nicky Gaston
มุมมอง 8514 วันที่ผ่านมา
After the August 2020 CZU Lightning Complex Fire destroyed or damaged 97% of Big Basin Redwoods State Park, the recovery and reimagining process began. As part of that process, the idea of the Big Basin Art About was developed. California State Parks publicized the opportunity for artists to join CASPBA (California State Parks Backpacking Adventures) staff in the spring of 2023 and received wel...
Endangered Plants!
มุมมอง 143หลายเดือนก่อน
Join one of our staff members as he checks out two endangered plant species of the SC Sandhills and learn more about their life histories, distributions, ecological roles, and conservation statuses. Caring for these rare plants through responsible recreation and stewardship is important, and this video will explain why. Video Corrections: Traditional land management practices involved the use o...
The Sandhills Extension of Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park
มุมมอง 6Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Watch this video to learn about the importance of recreating responsibly in the Sandhills Extension (i.e. "new acquisition"), and furthermore, the sensitive dispositions of many organisms that occur in this fascinating landscape. The Sandhills Extension was absorbed into Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park in 2007 and contains the 2nd largest contiguous patch of Santa Cruz Sandhills left on the pl...
Redwood Forest Recovery with Dr. Will Russell
มุมมอง 142หลายเดือนก่อน
Watch this video to learn about the recovery processes of redwood forests! Dr. Will Russell is a professor in the Environmental Studies Department at San Jose State University. His research focuses on the recovery of forests in the wake of disturbances like timber harvesting and wildfire events.
The League, Redwoods and Climate Change Initiative with Deborah Zierten
มุมมอง 912 หลายเดือนก่อน
Watch this video to listen to Deborah Zierten, education and interpretation manager with Save the Redwoods League, talk about the dynamic between Coast Redwoods and the changing climate, and the important research coming out of the League's Redwoods and Climate Change Initiative (RCCI).
Random Day Salamandering at Henry Cowell Redwoods
มุมมอง 7214 หลายเดือนก่อน
Random Day Salamandering at Henry Cowell Redwoods
Pigeon Point Optics: Fresnel Lens
มุมมอง 1535 หลายเดือนก่อน
Pigeon Point Optics: Fresnel Lens
Volunteer at Pigeon Point Light Station SHP
มุมมอง 165 หลายเดือนก่อน
Volunteer at Pigeon Point Light Station SHP
Introduction to Natural Bridges State Beach
มุมมอง 6056 หลายเดือนก่อน
Introduction to Natural Bridges State Beach
Natural Bridges Migration Festival
มุมมอง 546 หลายเดือนก่อน
Natural Bridges Migration Festival
Mission Myths: Native Americans are in the Past
มุมมอง 3548 หลายเดือนก่อน
Mission Myths: Native Americans are in the Past
Mission Myths: One Day's Ride
มุมมอง 1338 หลายเดือนก่อน
Mission Myths: One Day's Ride
Mission Myths: Native Americans had a Hard Life Pre-Contact
มุมมอง 7268 หลายเดือนก่อน
Mission Myths: Native Americans had a Hard Life Pre-Contact
Mission Myths: All Fragrant Flowerbeds
มุมมอง 548 หลายเดือนก่อน
Mission Myths: All Fragrant Flowerbeds
Mission Myths: Just a Church
มุมมอง 768 หลายเดือนก่อน
Mission Myths: Just a Church
151st Anniversary of Pigeon Point
มุมมอง 708 หลายเดือนก่อน
151st Anniversary of Pigeon Point
Why We Burn - Prescribed Burns in the Santa Cruz District of California State Parks
มุมมอง 2628 หลายเดือนก่อน
Why We Burn - Prescribed Burns in the Santa Cruz District of California State Parks
History and the Ohlone People with Martin Rizzo Martinez
มุมมอง 8369 หลายเดือนก่อน
History and the Ohlone People with Martin Rizzo Martinez
Wilderness Patrol
มุมมอง 749 หลายเดือนก่อน
Wilderness Patrol
Steelhead Trout and the San Lorenzo River!
มุมมอง 53511 หลายเดือนก่อน
Steelhead Trout and the San Lorenzo River!

ความคิดเห็น

  • @GTFB66
    @GTFB66 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Dylan, great video thanks for sharing. You talk about being mindful about recreational habits and staying on designated trails. On the other side of Highway 9 (the UCSC side) there is a crazy network of mountain bike trails built by “volunteers”. There are no sanctioned trails in this area of Cowell. I wonder why managers do nothing about this? Also I went bike camping for two nights at Portola Redwoods State Park weekend before last. We did a hike out to the Peter’s Creek Loop. Beautiful place too! Saturday morning there was a researcher by the park HQ who was very upset about a fir tree that was cut down right next to the park HQ on Monday June 24th. This tree was supporting a colony of Pedicularis Dudleyi, or Dudleys Lousewort, a plant that's on the rare plants list too. A ranger named Andrew Dobbs happened to pull up. He was asked to provide a permit and CEQA approval to remove this tree by this gentleman and would not produce any of this information for him. None of the staff inside knew anything about this tree removal and were unable to provide this information either. A bunch of the Lousewort had been trampled and destroyed by the crew that did the tree removal. No protection was given to these rare plants and removing their supporting tree will most certainly kill them. This was very disturbing for me. I'm trying to figure out who to contact about this and would like any direction you can provide. This is also probably an example of improper land management, which you spoke of as well. It’s important to protect these plants!

  • @brynnbate1043
    @brynnbate1043 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Fascinating, info-packed film, deserves an award! I learned many new things…and appreciated the elements of hope following Redwood Forest fires, they otherwise make me feel so heart-broken.

  • @riskey6788
    @riskey6788 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wow‼️ Great video

  • @AnaHiatt
    @AnaHiatt 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Awesome video!! Loved it, thank you. I found a rubber boa on a trail near my house about a week ago. I'd never seen one here before, so it was pretty exciting!

  • @mendynoma4272
    @mendynoma4272 9 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great video!❤

  • @KaliFraser
    @KaliFraser 10 วันที่ผ่านมา

    So cool!

  • @KaliFraser
    @KaliFraser 12 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Just saw this! Beautiful video

  • @patricialarenas6670
    @patricialarenas6670 13 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I love this- well done!

  • @joevelasquez2757
    @joevelasquez2757 13 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Amazing content 👏

  • @christopheralan5666
    @christopheralan5666 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Stop burning our Forrest!

  • @Absaalookemensch
    @Absaalookemensch 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Even the Left doesn't believe that humans cause global climate change because they don't heed their own recommendations.

  • @Rozdraws
    @Rozdraws 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

    This is literally unwatchable

    • @michellesmithunroe2463
      @michellesmithunroe2463 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Wow. I did not see that coming. It's unfortunate that the presentation was not only distracting from what I find to be a very interesting topic but left me feeling oddly like I've just watched an episode of Night Gallery. I read in the description that the music was supposed to be the song of the trees but I can say for certain that mine don't sing that way at all. 😵‍💫

  • @joelcornes2095
    @joelcornes2095 16 วันที่ผ่านมา

    It can all be reversed with YOUR money.

  • @libertyforever836
    @libertyforever836 16 วันที่ผ่านมา

    We have climate change here in the Midwest also. In the summer, it’s hot, and then fall comes, and it cools off a bit and the leaves fall. Then we have winter when it’s kind of cold and it snows quite often and then we have spring when the snow melts and it warms up again. It’s been going on for a long time we like our climate change. We used to call it the change of seasons, which is what we still call it here. But I guess technically you could call it climate change.

    • @Deletedcommentfactory
      @Deletedcommentfactory 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I live in the Midwest, too. It used to snow a lot in the winter when I was a kid, now it barely ever does. If it gets cold, it might last a week and then just jumps up to 60 or 80, in the winter. I’ve seen the climate change in my lifetime. If you don’t think you have, you’re either not paying attention, or you’re pretty comfortable with denial.

    • @Absaalookemensch
      @Absaalookemensch 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@Deletedcommentfactory We're probably heading back into a natural cooling cycle, so you may get your snows back. It's actually better if we do warm-up a bit. It takes less energy to cool a house from 90s to 72 than to warm it from 30s to 68. Aircraft wrecks have been recovered from Greenland under 70-100' of ice. The glaciers are alive and well. In fact, polar ice pack is at a 20 year high. Even the Left doesn't believe in human caused global climate change because they are not heeding their own recommendations.

    • @libertyforever836
      @libertyforever836 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@Deletedcommentfactory Your thinking of the last few years where it true that we have not had as much snow the last few years. And there have been some warmer days. But if you look at it over the long-haul, several hundred years, you will see that it’s gone up and down in the normal fashion. In 1998 we had 30 straight days below zero. The next couple of years it was warmer. Even each season has its cold and warm changes from year to year. It’s very possible this winter we will get a lot of snow. It’s all subjective and we never know what we’re going to get. To tell you the truth, I kind of like warmer winters!

    • @Deletedcommentfactory
      @Deletedcommentfactory 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@libertyforever836 It’s more than that. Southern species are moving in and some of ours are moving north. Our way of life is going to change, like it or not. Don’t believe facebook, and don’t believe industry “science”. They’ve known what’s happening for decades.

  • @aqua_riumplant
    @aqua_riumplant 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I didn't know this park exists. Thank you for sharing :D the landscape looks so unique! :3

  • @PersianWombat
    @PersianWombat 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Stellar!!

  • @OoDoRFoO
    @OoDoRFoO 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank you to all the fungi for making existence possible for me

  • @jasonksepka7439
    @jasonksepka7439 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    What a fantastic video, I love your enthusiasm and how you are bringing awareness to such a unique environment.

  • @swithinbarclay4797
    @swithinbarclay4797 21 วันที่ผ่านมา

    For these gullied trails, might The Park want to permanently shut these down? Could work, and the plants generating duff, to fill them in. What more might you want to tell us the Ponderosas and Knobcones that not only hold their own, but sometimes mingle freely, within the Redwoods? And, are there, or are there NOT Coulters and BIG CONE Douglas Firs, in The Park? Some insist that there are. Along the Klamath and Trinity greater watersheds, are places where Sugar Pines and Ponderosa Pines make uncharacteristic dips in elevation, to share territories with the Redwoods up there, and sporadic Grey Pines, too. Coulters mingle with Redwoods in Big Sur.

  • @debijane6747
    @debijane6747 21 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank you! What a treat!

  • @paulaubrey3790
    @paulaubrey3790 22 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Great video but i have to ask why is his top shirt button fastened, shoul only be fastened when wearing a tie, unless of course theres a personal reason

  • @acccardone7679
    @acccardone7679 25 วันที่ผ่านมา

    That was a lovely, interesting, and informative video. Thank you for sharing it. You called it a park expansion. Where is it / how do we get there? I wish you had included a map so we had a better idea of where you are talking about. The major downside that I see about this park, as well as for attempting to keep everyone on the trails, is how the narrowness of the trails you showed. Those narrow trails make it impossible for mobility impaired to use and stay.

  • @GaiaCarney
    @GaiaCarney 25 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Thank You for creating & sharing this informative video! I’d never heard of this ecosystem before 🤗 When a plant, like monkey flower, is threatened, do you gather seeds and attempt to propagate it?

    • @fugueine
      @fugueine 15 วันที่ผ่านมา

      There are many native plant nurseries and other groups in California that perform plant surveys and sustainably collect propagules to grow plants for habitat restoration and low water gardening. I was involved in that when working for The Watershed Nursery.

  • @stephaniekingdom4481
    @stephaniekingdom4481 หลายเดือนก่อน

    This Gorgeous area has been my playground since 1978.... So very blessed

  • @barbaragodshall4171
    @barbaragodshall4171 หลายเดือนก่อน

    What a fabulous video. Never knew about the Sandhills before. Can't wait to see that part of the park also. Thanks.

  • @RACCOONSQUID
    @RACCOONSQUID หลายเดือนก่อน

    Shouldn't there be a couple coast redwood groves growing in the sandhills? I didn't see any in the video, but with all that coastal fog and occasional thick needle substrate, it should at least be encroaching on the outskirts right? Seems to me like this area has way more in common with El Dorado national forest than it naturally did in the past.

    • @shredchic
      @shredchic หลายเดือนก่อน

      Yes, coast redwoods are adjacent to, and you even see the odd small grove in the creek beds of the sandhills! It's so unique.

  • @RACCOONSQUID
    @RACCOONSQUID หลายเดือนก่อน

    I've seen the ben lomond spineflower popping up around the carmel highlands! I'll have to mark it on iNat next time I'm out there! :)

  • @cjverburg465
    @cjverburg465 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Amazing & wonderful!

  • @wallyr935
    @wallyr935 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thanks for the video! One of my favourite habitats in one of favourite parks. First place I ever saw velvet ants and a huge variety of lizards. Looking forward to the next video :)

  • @JustinC831
    @JustinC831 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Great video!

  • @johnnash5118
    @johnnash5118 หลายเดือนก่อน

    @19:20, transform faults can also be formed by adjacent plates, terranes or blocks moving in the same direction, at different average speeds and rates; but the relative motion makes the fault appear that the land masses are in opposing directions, much like the lanes of a freeway in the same direction. I respectfully disagree with the status quo consensus that the Farallon Plate was consumed by pushing the plate North en bloc into subduction; imho, the South Gorda plate's accomodational distortion and lack of distortion in the North Gorda and JDF plates strongly shows no en bloc movement, just the Southern margin localized compressional truncation via the Pacific plate's oblique NW passive thrust of the ESE South Gorda plate. Franciscan meta-sedimentary and meta-igneous rocks can be found 90 miles North of the Or-Cal border @Bandon, Oregon's Merchants, Agate and Sacchi beaches; parts of Bandon's South Coquille river jetty is made from a local blue schist quarry. Blue and green schists, greenstone, gabbro and quartzite can be readily found as egg-sized to bread loaf-sized cobbles on these beaches; the hidden outcrops offshore these beaches indicate that the Franciscan Assemblage is indeed in (rear-end) collision with the Siletz Terrane, thus being the mechanism for the 1 degree per million year NW rotation of Western Oregon and Washington.

  • @patricialarenas6670
    @patricialarenas6670 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Great presentation answering some of my burning (excuse the bad pun) questions about fire recovery in our beloved Sanat Cruz Mountains! Thank you for your work...

  • @zunairadurrani
    @zunairadurrani 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thank you so much for posting the recording!!! I missed the virtual meeting and grateful to watch Dr Russell's talk! 😀

  • @TellsThaTruth
    @TellsThaTruth 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    He needs to stick the videography. He don’t know shit about true California Indian history. Why these Anglos think they can come in and tell OUR story GTFOH

  • @sddirt6840
    @sddirt6840 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    These are one of the most common species in the U.S. 🙄 Just because you don't see them, it doesn't mean they are endangered. They are naturally shy and spend most of their time underground or in root masses, rotted logs, dead foliage, etc.

  • @thomash3292
    @thomash3292 5 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Will - something to also consider. Beaver were exterminated on the west coast in the mid-late 1800's. Beaver ponds would of course raise river levels, even in the summer, and then potentially and naturally be destroyed in flood event rains, only to be rebuilt again in the Spring. Since beaver on most (if not all) of the Santa Cruz rivers and creeks are gone, seems this would also be a significant detriment to the river, salmon, steelhead and other species and show areas of "incision" that are old. Couple that with the onslaught of logging it's a double whammy for the river and wildlife. Undoubtedly, logging would have also stripped beaver dams if any were left by then. Our problem presently is the greed Santa Cruz is filled with, taking all the water from the SLR in critical rearing months when the river is no longer a river anymore - all for the sake of building more and taking more water.

  • @sandinogomez8605
    @sandinogomez8605 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thank you for sharing this. Much appreciated.

  • @Jacob-oc
    @Jacob-oc 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Ok

  • @ElysiumLeoSK
    @ElysiumLeoSK 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Somehow, TH-cam recommended this to me and this is amazing. It's great to know that native Americans have been doing well pre-contact and have been living off very well in handling their own. Great video. Keep it up.

  • @peterplotts1238
    @peterplotts1238 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Thanks for reminding us that everyone born before 1995 was a "racist." Now be quiet.

  • @cozysheltie3297
    @cozysheltie3297 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    My current understanding is Native American culture, including the conflicts and diplomacy between tribes, definitely had complexity of it's own; as for being advanced, my current understanding is their cultures & spiritual beliefs were not conducive to fostering the drive to develop technologies other civilizations had.

  • @brokenToastable
    @brokenToastable 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Never believe state funded info

  • @Moja_Bosna_Ponosna
    @Moja_Bosna_Ponosna 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    So Horrible 😢

  • @pscm9447
    @pscm9447 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I've always found it ridiculous how people studying Native Americans use "complexity" as an argument to try and prove that these cultures were somewhat "advanced" or well "organized"... "Complex societies" is a pretty loose description that doesn't mean much. All human societies in history were "complex" in their own ways. All human societies were "organized" as well, and had "complex" relations with their environment and neighbouring cultures... I get that the first European settlers might have had an arrogant perspective on these societies, but the real issue is whether or not their organization and complexity led to security, prosperity, free-will and capabilities to accomplish greater things than just survival. Sure, Native Americans had "complex" societies, but it doesn't mean that it brought them safety against raids, conquests, famine, injustice, brutality, etc. The very fact that they were invaded by European is, in itself, a proof that their "complex" organization wasn't able to protect them efficiently against the rough conditions here on earth.

    • @fahadbawany8563
      @fahadbawany8563 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      While it is true that complexity is a relative term, here it is being used to dismiss the myth that there was no diplomacy or organized society before European savagery nearly drove them to extinction and brought them "civilization" that's another loose description for you that's both subjective since what they had didn't meet European's concept of civilization. And since then it has become abundantly clear why Europeans at the time thought that and why you are thinking along the same line. Native Americans had a symbiotic relationship with their environment and saw it as sacred, europeans on the other hand sought to bleed it dry. They focused on spiritual growth while european culture devoted to making better and better tools for killing other peoples and taking their land. Europeans weren't even technologically advanced for a long time, lagging far behind eastern and southern parts of the world, so they recognised that they can just develop better tools for killing and steals other peoples technology. You might want to read some real history that isn't white washed. Further more I would argue that the indigenous peoples all over the world are much more intellectually advanced since they are at the forefront of climate change. While europeans to this day think they can fix it by becoming better stealers of technology. Your perception of what advanced means is out of whack and you don't realise it because it's the norm.

    • @pscm9447
      @pscm9447 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@fahadbawany8563 Ah, spare me the good savage narrative and go signal your vertue elsewhere would you? I get it, European bad, muslims and every other culture good. It's getting old seriously. And this "Europe was lagging behind" during the middle ages is as much a myth than the strawman you bring about people somewhat thinking Native Americans didn't have any "diplomacy or organized societies". While arabs were doing maths and astronomy without putting it to use, the christian world was creating new new techniques (agriculture, mills, gear machinerie, metallurgy, etc) that boosted their food supply, energy capabilities, transports, weaponery, etc. As soon as we discovered new formulas, we USED it instead of letting it rot on a shelf or debate about it for centuries. That's the main difference. At the begining of the Middle Ages, Europe is getting invaded from all parts, at the end of it, it conquers the world and surpasses other civilizations on every metrics (apart, maybe, on medicine)... It's hardly a stagnation my dude. Give me a break... Your manichean "analysis" is just a litany of overused slogans and preconception with absolutely no basis on "real history", so before saying that I must educate myself, you should first look in a mirror and realize how unreasonable you sound.

  • @boomgatbing
    @boomgatbing 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    there's a categorical complexity difference between civilizations with aqueducts, sewage systems, cathedrals, ocean-faring vessels, star maps, and gunpowder and civilizations with stone-age tech and no writing. One major difference is life expectancy - another is the ability to defend yourself from outsiders. The idea that illiterate tribespeople had a "complex" society on par with Spain (or China, or Japan, or the Abassid Caliphate for that matter) is laughable. What's next? Headhunters in Taiwan had the same civilizational complexity as Meiji Japan? Aborigines have the same civilizational complexity as a civilization that split the atom and sent a man to the moon? Don't be disingenuous and don't spread propaganda, however well-intentioned. Complexity is a real feature. Perhaps your organization are Ted Kaczinskyists and think that industrialization led to a "worse" civilization and that we should return to foraging for acorns and dying of parasitic infection, but you can't argue that such societies are equally complex.

  • @michaelwarren5616
    @michaelwarren5616 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I don’t hear this “myth” coming from the Missions today. Every Mission I visit display Native Californians with respect and recognize the complexities of that era. If there is a “myth” here, it is that the Missions still promote the viewpoints expressed in this video.

  • @guidoconvertino3571
    @guidoconvertino3571 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I think in the USA you have a lot of confusion about what is the difference between studying History, and "celebrating" History as a model. Celebrating History is almost a medieval concept, very distant from modern critical thinking. Nowadays, for example, we study George Washington, not because we think he was a great man, celebrating him as we would like to be like him, but because we think that studying the past is important and necessary to know the present and who we are. In this way, it's understandable the shock of those people who, lack critical thinking, when they discover that the great man also owned slaves, or that the great works have something in them that doesn't correspond to their values, they panic because don't have the critical maturity to say: "who gives a s**t? I don't study the Greeks because I wish the world was still like it was in their time, I study the Greeks because they developed things that are still valuable, and without them, I understand less the world where I live". On the contrary, If you already reached the level where you keep a statue of George Washington until you discover that he owned slaves, then you're already at the bottom. Now, talking about this video, the title was very promising, but who made it probably has a huge lack of critical thinking. On one side very generous in using words such as "eurocentric, racist, ignorant", and so on, talking about the only ones who wrote something about the natives, but on the other side they give no clues or proof of what they are asserting. Someone would expect that they found some archeological pieces of evidence, but here I see only some cartoons of the supposed cornucopia of goods and a confused map of the California tribes. Probably answering questions like "What was the pre-contact child mortality among the natives?" or "Which was the average expectation of life?" would answer the question. But probably those questions would bring the need for historical research and critical thinking, which this channel or the girl speaking clearly lacks. The modern trend is to judge past civilizations (like 17th-century Spaniards), showing off how superior we are, and how we despise them and their values, it's the same attitude that Westerners used to have in front of other civilizations they were conquering during the age of colonies. So don't polish yourself.

  • @seanrider4410
    @seanrider4410 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Whether you like it or not, the Spanish accounts that the natives lacked basic non-astronomic time keeping, complex social organizations, and a deep understanding of agriculture is just true. Europeans too could have simply subsisted off the signs of the night sky, tribal leaders, and hunting and gathering. Europeans, however, developed methods to create a surplus of resources that allowed for further civilizational complexity. These accounts were not "racist," they were accurate.

  • @swato547
    @swato547 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    so cute bird