How We Get Around
How We Get Around
  • 10
  • 249 737
America's Best Railroad has a MASSIVE Problem. Here's What Will Fix It.
The Northeast Corridor is the fastest, busiest and most important rail line in all of the Americas. For nearly 200 years, the line has been a backbone of transportation in the Northeastern US as it was becoming connected together, and for nearly 100 years, the line has been powered by the objectively best way to power a train: overhead line electrification. This system has enable the line to be the fastest railroad line in America for decades. However, the system has been having a common nemesis in recent years: Heatwaves, which are causing havoc on the near century old catenary systems. It has caused constant delays, slow operations and even damage to trains and the infrastructure. And all of this boils down to one common problem. It's a problem that has hindered the Corridor's sky-high potential for decades, but is a problem that can actually be fixed relatively easily and also relatively cheaply compared to other infrastructure investments, and it's one that can provide by far the most notable benefits.
Oh, and I casually correct something that Wendover got very wrong when he made a video on this topic a little bit ago.
Good article on this topic: www.curbed.com/article/amtrak-northeast-corridor-power-supply-catenary-failing.html
Sources:
media.amtrak.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/NEC-Terms-primer-v1.pdf
thebhc.org/sites/default/files/beh/BEHprint/v009/p0143-p0151.pdf
x.com/alanthefisher/status/1803888141679358334
web.archive.org/web/20010405163348/www.shwpc.com/about.html
Chapters
0:00 Introduction
2:08 What is the Northeast Corridor?
7:39 Chaos, Confusion and Delay
9:56 Hot and Heavy
15:35 This is Not a New Problem...
18:00 Why is NJT getting it worse than Amtrak?
22:22 The Solution: Something that Everyone Else Uses... including Amtrak!
27:06 What This Fix Will Allow
29:20 How Much Will It Cost? Not As Much as You'd Fear!
33:38 It's Already Beginning...
37:51 Conclusion
Keywords: #amtrak #newjerseytransit #highspeedrail #trains #infrastructure #highspeedtrain #electrictrains #newyork #americantrain #usarailway #passengertrain #acela #acelaexpress #history #pennsylvaniarailroad #washingtondc #boston #philadelphia #urbanism #highway #bridges #intercitytrain #commutertrain #wendover #halfasinteresting #wrong
มุมมอง: 48 659

วีดีโอ

A Streetcar City Reborn: The Rise, Fall and Rise Again of Philadelphia's Trolleys
มุมมอง 31K3 หลายเดือนก่อน
On June 16th, 2024, after four years of waiting and wondering if they would ever be seen again, the SEPTA's Route 15 service on Girard Avenue in North Philadelphia were met with a long loved sight: A fleet of green and cream colored 1940s Streetcars began serving passengers again for the first time in four years. In revenue service. With cars that are nearing 80 years old. While a fantastic sto...
High Speed Rail in America: It's Finally Happening. | A Ramble about American HSR projects.
มุมมอง 39K4 หลายเดือนก่อน
High Speed Rail in America. It's a phrase that so often has been a dream, and one that elicits either a laugh or a groan. While the world at large has reaped the benefits of high speed rail since the technology came to the fore in the 1960s, America has had some half-hearted attempts that came nowhere close to their potential, despite the overall popular demand for it. However now, particularly...
Railroad Crossings are Even Worse than You Thought. Here's What We Can Do.
มุมมอง 16K5 หลายเดือนก่อน
From the cities to the countryside, from California to Maine, and everywhere in between, one of the biggest annoyances of everyday transportation is dealing with Railroad Crossings. Drivers, cyclists and pedestrians hate these crossings. The trains block traffic, create noise and cause a major safety risk for cars, cyclists and pedestrians alike. The trains hate them too. It legally limits thei...
Is this the return of American Streamliners?: A Ramble About The FRA Long Distance Trains Proposal
มุมมอง 32K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Nearly 100 years ago, overnight sleeper trains, best epitomized by the legendary Streamliners, were true household names, the epitome of long distance transportation, and symbols of American pride, but today not so much. They're constantly delayed, slower than flying, and simply don't get service to a lot of places like they used too. However, there are plenty of people out there (including mys...
A Philly Transport Icon: 50 Years of the Silverliner IVs and What's Next? | How We Get Around Philly
มุมมอง 6K8 หลายเดือนก่อน
It's been a familiar face for the people of the Philadelphia area, and it's likely older than you and maybe even your parents. The Silverliner IV electric trains have been the face of SEPTA's regional rail operations for the last 50 years, and it's only NOW that SEPTA has gotten serious to find a replacement for them. It's amazing to consider how something has lasted 50 years in regular use, se...
America: Land of the Train Again!?: A Ramble about the Corridor ID Program | How We Get Around
มุมมอง 57K9 หลายเดือนก่อน
America's passenger rail sector has a reputation for barely existing in many parts of the country. Since Amtrak's inception in the 1970s, it has been besieged on all sides by forces seeking its demise, while its attempts at expansion have been haphazard and without a cohesive strategy. That's all changed now. Last month, the FRA's Corridor ID Project has released its choices for support for the...
Leveling with You: Conshohocken Station and Good Station Design | How We Get Around Philly Episode 2
มุมมอง 3.9K10 หลายเดือนก่อน
It's funny the kind of rabbit hole a single picture can lead you down. A humorous story of a misspelled sign at a SEPTA station led me to realize that said station was undergoing a major rebuild that makes it objectively better for everybody who ever uses it going forward. Alongside the replacement of a station with a port-a-potty as the main facility with something far more fitting for the com...
The SEPTA West Chester Line: Of Ambition and Reality | How We Get Around Philly Episode 1
มุมมอง 16Kปีที่แล้ว
It may be just under 10 miles, but it has quite the story to tell... If you ride SEPTA's Media/Wawa line out of Philadelphia to the end of the line at the (kind-of) brand new Wawa station, you may notice that the tracks keep going into the woods beyond. That line used to go all the way to the town of West Chester, Pennsylvania until 1986, and in the time since then, the effort to preserve the l...

ความคิดเห็น

  • @john-ic9vj
    @john-ic9vj 5 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Disantis thinks rail travel should be a private entity's responsibility, but he just signed $970 billion of public funding for roadway improvements the next five years. Please someone explain that logic to me

  • @pleappleappleap
    @pleappleappleap 13 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Adding a fourth track to the three track sections might be of benefit, since the right of way still exists.

  • @pleappleappleap
    @pleappleappleap 13 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    That's not how to pronounce Kearny. More like carnie.

  • @stevejenkins2893
    @stevejenkins2893 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I vote for "TheRocket"

  • @PeterVanDeMotter
    @PeterVanDeMotter 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Conversion to the standard 60-Hz frequency is long overdue. Amtrak is one of the very few users of 25 Hz power and it is getting harder and harder to get parts or even power at that frequency.

  • @herbertallanmclane2305
    @herbertallanmclane2305 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I live on the Coast Starlight route in the town of Mount Shasta. The route I’d like to promote is from Davis (Sacramento) CA to Eugene OR up the I-5 corridor. There is an existing Class 3 RR from Davis north to Tehama Junction where it joins the UPSP. Then it goes through Redding CA up the Sacramento River Canyon to Black Butte Junction. There is descends into the Shasta River Valley, crosses the Klamath River and summits of the Siskiyou Mountains. It then continues to Ashland, Medford, Grants Pass, Roseburg and finally Eugene Oregon. this would connect the California Amtrak routes with the OR/WA Cascades.

  • @Noah-r5b
    @Noah-r5b 8 วันที่ผ่านมา

    YOOO, I didn’t know safe harbor supplies energy to the NEC I thought it was just power for homes, I used to fish off of safe harbor, Best catfishing I’ve ever done. Very good video and a great explanation on the problem 😁

  • @roadie24
    @roadie24 9 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Unexpectedly good video, keep it up 👍

  • @PeterWarner-yz7tb
    @PeterWarner-yz7tb 11 วันที่ผ่านมา

    National City (not San Ysidro) the original SF route goes to National City, 6.5 miles from downtown SD.

  • @PeterWarner-yz7tb
    @PeterWarner-yz7tb 14 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Crescent Star

  • @PeterWarner-yz7tb
    @PeterWarner-yz7tb 14 วันที่ผ่านมา

    San Francisco Chief

  • @PeterWarner-yz7tb
    @PeterWarner-yz7tb 14 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The Floridan is coming back as an amalgamation of the Capitol Limited and Silver Star..

  • @jameshill1740
    @jameshill1740 16 วันที่ผ่านมา

    While rails to trails has a lot of upside, there was so much shortsided thought that cant be seperated. To me, no high speed idea will work until routes are completely void of at-level roads crossings. This means brigde all of them. Only then will it be viable

  • @Harvey-x7d
    @Harvey-x7d 18 วันที่ผ่านมา

    CSSSB completed conversion to constant tension catenary.

  • @Harvey-x7d
    @Harvey-x7d 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Stainless steel is timeless.

  • @Harvey-x7d
    @Harvey-x7d 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Seems reasonable to a point for freight and passemger to share a row with gentile curves and good population for added grade separation rather than needing to diplicate improvements on both lines (read this NC?).

  • @Harvey-x7d
    @Harvey-x7d 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I'm glad that Amtrak seems tp be reconsidering all-single 45:44 level cars.

  • @Harvey-x7d
    @Harvey-x7d 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    MSP - KCY could connect with both the Zeph and SW,

  • @Harvey-x7d
    @Harvey-x7d 19 วันที่ผ่านมา

    After a Amtrak - auto collision n of Ocala, FL, I clocked my Floridian at 100 mph to Jacksonville behind an SDP40.

  • @pauld6967
    @pauld6967 20 วันที่ผ่านมา

    As someone who will likely be using the VRE in the near future, this upgrade to the lines in Virginia is welcome news. Thank you.

  • @tonyburzio4107
    @tonyburzio4107 20 วันที่ผ่านมา

    "Well that didn't work". Time traveling into the future...

  • @anthonyrowland9072
    @anthonyrowland9072 23 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I just want them to be faster and on time. It's doesn't have to be "high speed rail" but get it up near 100mph average and the let the ore and ammonia tank trains wait *their* turn.

  • @qjtvaddict
    @qjtvaddict 24 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Want Acela to be high speed? Upgrade catenary add more track for local trains. Then add bypass line in LI. And bridge/tunnel

  • @johnarnehansen9574
    @johnarnehansen9574 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    They could have utilized Thermal- and Renewable power stations for railroad electrification!

  • @WillsJazzLoft
    @WillsJazzLoft 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I think that what a lot of Americans aren't aware of is that 20% of the GDP in the United States is generated within the Boston - Washington megalopolis. If the NEC is not maintained into the future, it could have significant though indirect economic consequences for the rest of the country

  • @WillsJazzLoft
    @WillsJazzLoft 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    It was good that you made mention of the Baltimore to Newark, Delaware section of the line.

  • @WillsJazzLoft
    @WillsJazzLoft 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I'd always believed that the chief technical issues with the NEC involved track geometry. I'm reminded by your expository that improvements in the catenary wiring are of relatively equal value. Thank you for sharing your insights

  • @JeredtheShy
    @JeredtheShy 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The Nalaxone ads on the sides of the train are a great look for Amtrak.

  • @OperatorLogan
    @OperatorLogan 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Please remember, The now operating PCCs are technically PCC-llls. There are no original operating components in them. Also these new components are not like the PCC in San Francisco with Modern PCC technology, based off the original design. These have been fully overhaul 2 times and do not even have the original trucks….sadly. It is great to see these back on the streets! Great video! If you come to Baltimore you can operate a PCC!

  • @OperatorLogan
    @OperatorLogan 28 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I would love to do one of these with you! Great video!

  • @GeraldGreen-s4x
    @GeraldGreen-s4x หลายเดือนก่อน

    Get the high-speed corridors in place first & running , and then you can increase the trains later with improvements...

  • @ilikehardplay
    @ilikehardplay หลายเดือนก่อน

    I remember riding Amtrak's combined Desert Wind/California Zephyr back in the mid 1980s from Los Angeles, CA to Glenwood Springs, CO.....but the Desert Wind certainly did not extend to Denver or Cheyanne. Rather both the Desert Wind and the Pioneer ran from their respective coasts to meet at Salt Lake City with the California Zephyr, where through cars headed east were added to the Zephyr (...and presumably, the Westbound Zephyr detached through cars for Los Angeles and Portland...) It was timed with all three Eastbound trains arriving in the early a.m. hours. I was woken at about 5 a.m. by our arrival in SLC, and watched the switching from the station platform while I ducked out to get a newspaper. I'll be honest. I think a return to these two routes by this model is a lot more practical than your Desert Wind routed over Sherman Hill to Cheyanne and then Denver from the North.

  • @GunHillTrain
    @GunHillTrain หลายเดือนก่อน

    The problem with restoring the National Limited in Ohio is that the original train did not go through Cincinnati; the route would have been too circuitous. Now the only choice would be just the opposite; it would have to go that way because all of the trackage that once connected Columbus to Indianapolis is gone. A train would have to go Cincinnati and then back-track a long way, presumably via the Cardinal route. It could be done, but it's a considerable detour for passengers wanting to get to Indianapolis and beyond.

  • @295g295
    @295g295 หลายเดือนก่อน

    15:51 - These Metroliners by Budd are not boxy. They are rounded as a fast airliner fuselage.

  • @pancakefish
    @pancakefish หลายเดือนก่อน

    Septa cars do have plugs in the very front and the very back!

  • @johnkeepin7527
    @johnkeepin7527 หลายเดือนก่อน

    It’s an interesting production. Some years ago (1994) I did travel from Boston to Washington along that route (with a few days in NY), and didn’t know anything about the set up of the overhead line electrification (OLE), although I noticed via signage etc that it operated at reduced frequency, not your standard 60 Hz. As a (now retired) engineer in the UK, the financial problems to with the upgrade is quite familiar. While I was a railway signalling engineer, I was familiar with a lot of electrification and permanent way issues that my colleagues dealt with in detail. A project that ended up with financial difficulties recently was the Great Western Main Line one, which got out of jail on account of many of the new trains being dual mode, made by Hitachi, so instead of electrifying the whole route, it ended part way. There are services between London & Cardiff that carry a fair bit of unused diesel generators and fuel etc that are not used en route, unfortunately. At present it is electrified from London Paddington to Cardiff, and to Newbury and Chippenham only, at 25 kV on the contact wires with 50 kV transmission most of the way from grid connections via autotransformers set up to -25/0/+25 roughly every 10 km or so. Part of the problem can be unbalanced loads with grid connections. Sometimes being a relatively small customer at the point of delivery can be tolerable, sometimes not. There are some locations elsewhere at which modern “static frequency converters” (SFC) which actually rectify the incoming 3 phase, and generate the output required for the contact wiring. A bit like frequency changing, I suppose, and no doubt with some thermal waste as well. Constant tension has long been the norm on 25 kV OLE in the UK, much of it using weight loads, but the latest sections use spring tension. There are some stretches that use overhead contact rail where there is not enough clearance otherwise - typically old tunnels that are too tight otherwise.

  • @dgmithril
    @dgmithril หลายเดือนก่อน

    As someone who lives in NJ and regularly takes the NEC to DC, this video was incredibly enlightening. There isn't a soul in NJ that will claim NJ Transit brings joy into their lives, but videos like this help explain why so many problems exist and what can be done about them instead of just complaining about them.

  • @jonharris9259
    @jonharris9259 หลายเดือนก่อน

    If you look at the catenary now thru Princeton Junction, you will see they have spaced the auxiliary further away from the contact wire. Because the auxiliary wire expands and contracts faster than the other two. Problem solved ?

  • @RaisedLetter
    @RaisedLetter หลายเดือนก่อน

    You could have used many other examples of catenary for your thumbnail but use you use the new stuff east of New Haven that was built in the 90s XD

  • @PositionLight
    @PositionLight หลายเดือนก่อน

    Major issue with West Chester service is that its way quicker for someone around West Chester to drive to Exton and catch an R5 (or Keystone) instead of go to a closer R3 station and take the curvy route in.

  • @PositionLight
    @PositionLight หลายเดือนก่อน

    The reason they are looking at 80 is likely lower certification costs. Also the design should focus on passenger, not crew comfort. Both the LIRR and MNRR have had issues with the full cabs becoming defacto crew lounges where they hang out and avoid doing their jobs. The LIRR especially since there is no way to see in from the passenger area.

  • @PositionLight
    @PositionLight หลายเดือนก่อน

    Also you know that the fires at Metra TOWER A-2 are just for ice and snow melting. Its a low pressure natural gas system so instead of small blue flames they are large and orange.

  • @jimwhitman3678
    @jimwhitman3678 หลายเดือนก่อน

    This is what happens when you hire airline executives to run a railroad. I’ve worked for Amtrak for 32 years. It’s so sad to see the lack of standards allowed. I’m actually embarrassed to say I work there.

  • @dhyde153
    @dhyde153 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Where is that charming model railroad park in your film located? I'd love to visit it!

  • @OperatorLogan
    @OperatorLogan หลายเดือนก่อน

    I have alot of stronge feelings about this, i know the guys that will be working on the new SEPTA LRV “Snakes” from alstom. I honestly would love to sit down with you and have a dialogue about phillys future and some of the issues thatll face them, as it has with other transit systems updating equipment.