วีดีโอ

the fact that the game involves a ship means there are different islands to explore. Possiblility of a multisetting game with multiple villians instead of one cohesive kingdom and villian group.

I really hope Toadsworth will have a role in this game. He's really cool, and the M&L games are largely where he got so much personality. Now with him being back in TTYD remake, I'm just really hoping he'll be appearing more often.

4:15 using a Bros Attack is NOT an indicator of this being a boss. But the design, large size, and it being the only target - yeah, it probably is a boss.

Those shy guy arships are from Dream Team too

That one thorn enemy is from Dream Team. Nintendo allows new species But new variant of Toads are still ellegal

Super paper Mario I need my pixies

Bub-Bulber warned kids about scammers who take advantage of you.

He to me, is a clear indication that the devs pretty much ran out of ideas for Chapter 7, considering the first half of the chapter is literally backtracking, while the snow area itself is literally even smaller than Twilight Town.

Like I always say whenever I replay this game… Fuck General White and all of his hopes and dreams.

As a firm believer in media being able to do anything and make it work, I think this game takes “bad game design” and not only makes it not that bad, but enjoyable. It’d be one thing if this was just bad because the devs didn’t know what they’re doing, but you clearly see this was intentional and that they’re having a laugh about it. I guess I can’t say “it isn’t at our expense” because it clearly was in your case (and many others, I know this part is super decisive) but like, on a scale of 1-10, how BAD is part really?

Honestly I think you make a good point, but I don’t like your solution. Mario already saved everyone, doing so again feels like it would undermine the conflict of that original chapter with, what, some generic mid-boss enemy? It’s a lose-lose because you either don’t flesh out the conflict and make it feel tiny, or give it so much time we start to meander and miss the point of the Chapter (assuming the devs even had the time for all this after how rushed CH 6 was. Always remember Devs are working with realistic expectations, a budget, and deadline!) Now, if you asked me, I think my idea of a solution to this would be incorporating more side quests on revisits. Optional things that give you a reason to stick around a bit, but don’t slow down the hunt either. Essentially an area specific Trouble Center, something like that. That probably wouldn’t build up much hype for the canon cutscene admittedly, but really, it’s STILL a reward for finding General White. An AWESOME one. The hunt being different wouldn’t change that.

You can also see it as an excuse to go back to each and every shop before storming the Fortress AND Palace. This is a fantastic time to purchase items for the rest of the game, even if first time players wouldn’t know that. It’s admittedly a shotty reason, but tell me you wouldn’t wanna pick up a Courage Shell for Magnus 2.0, or at least stock up on Life Shrooms.

Is it tedious? Yes. Is it really fucking funny? Absolutely! The more people complain about it, the funnier it gets. 🤣 I don't care if it's not "good game design". It's like a rite of passage that every Paper Mario fan has to go through. Seeing other players' exasperation of playing this part for the first time is so cathartic. I don't think everything in a game needs to be super satisfying all the time. A little bit of tedium for the sake of comedy is fine by me. Especially if it's as iconic as this little quest. The pipe room made it bearable enough, no need to completely undo it. Media shouldn't just make us feel good, it should also sometimes make us feel annoyed, upset, sad, scared, uneasy, or confused. It's important to feel the full spectrum of emotions, so that the satisfying parts stick out all the better. I've grown attached to this stupid little prank the game pulls and I feel like the big cannon cutscene wouldn't land nearly as well if it had just been another reward for having fun, rather than for doing work. By the way, the first time Mario went to the moon was in Super Mario Land 2.

Shame that no matter how often this part gets criticized, diehard TTYD fans are still gonna defend it anyway. Fahr Outpost is still the worst location in the game because it has virtually nothing in it. Compare that to how rich 64's Chapter 7 is, with a complete location and two whole towns. We deserve a Fahr Outpost that's more fleshed out with it's own level designs as the sole place to find General White in.

Following a walk through elevated some pain

I have the pikachus and the munchlax. I only caught the munchlax because it also comes with self destruct. I didn’t need a munchlax because you can just breed a snorlax. And I never tried getting spiritomb cause I got one in a trade and just hatched more of them. I never knew about the torchic. That’s pretty cool. The bad thing is that the flying and surfing pikachus could only be transferred if you made them forget the HMs. So they are stuck in my heart gold with spiky eared pichu.

hey man wtf this been my profile picture for years now. not cause I like the character but cause I like the sprite.

im so happy the remake fixed it. on the gamecube it was burtal. in the remake it was easyer now. i don.t hate the quest no more. only hated it in the gamecube version of general whites quest. the only thing im wishing for next is a paid dlc for lugi quest with him and hes partners.

simple, because of the backtracking you have to do in chapter 7

I don’t mind running back and forth to give people stuff. What I do mind is doing it 50 times. This is the only part of the game that I said “yeah this ain’t it, chief”

Thank god for the new pipe travel system but oh my lord I will continue to despise this part of the story with all my might.

I feel like Paper Mario 64 is a better option for a remake. Super Paper Mario would probably be fine with just a port

I didn't hugely mind it, since it gave me a good excuse to go to all the chapters before I got Ms Mowz and sniff out anything I missed earlier. Plus thanks to the warp pipe room, you could probably finish the quest super quickly. Like you could probably finish it in less time than the opening cutscene

You see I only have played the remake because I wasn't born in the late N64 early GameCube era so I am not that angry at general white

My favorite thing about this is that there's a help center quest where you have do it all over again. :)

THEY ONLY NEEDED RIBBONS. If they added ribbons it would be all worth it they rewarded you with ribbons

i just got to fahr outpost and had no idea what to do finding out that THIS Is what i have to do makes me want to kill myself

I don't know why the Paper Mario think adding in tedious aspects are funny or make the game better?

As someone who was trying to get as much done to 100% game during the main story I think the backtracking gave a opportunity to get missed star pieces and badges missed on the first visit on all chapters. The back tracking is still very tedious but a small silver lining

So your second solution is to make the quest even longer!?

I think they should have either doubled down and said, "Oh no! The pipe system is down! You can't use the fast travel system!" or just have him at Fahr Outpost, yeah.

I think there is a way for anyone with internet access to post on the trouble center.

I still prefer this over going through Twilight Trail a bunch of times with nigh unavoidable encounters in chapter 4.

Eh I don't think the Bub-ulber is the worst fetch quest. It's rather the post game one a re the worst for me. One is doing the General White bis part and the pit of the 100 Trials. No seriously both of them are not that great to do. Good thing in the remake it gives you some shortcut, but.... eh in the original they were a pain to do. Well General one is just doing all over again the go search General White to a Location and nope it's somewhere else but the locations are different. And as for the 2nd quest is a Bob-Bomb asking to go all the way to the 50th floor of the trial to blow up a graffiti... In the remake it was ok you don't have to challenge (Again) all the floor. But in the original if you for the completionist way... well it's at most your 3rd time you go down there or at worst the 4th times you go... and all that is for a Snow Bunny rewards. Not the best side quest over them all...

I completely understood the hate back in the gamecube days, but the warp pipe room is such a game changer that the quest is only like 5 minutes now.

I HATE HIM man just from seeing the title I have trauma.

As others have stated, I don't think that is what was in the scope of this remake. By choosing to remake TTYD, they were able to focus more on the technical aspects with the game development. The game was completely redone in Origami King's engine, updated the art style of the series in a new layered style, and recreated the legacy combat system for said modern engine. It's a complete modernization that's meant to faithfully augment the original, and likely is a pivot of sorts for future entries.

Super Paper Mario hopefully!

So The White Flute is Useless if you have a pokemon with Sweet Scent (Just an FYI) Also I did get the Pretty Chair

"This is a game for kids" is such a dumb argument because...the original game was meant for kids too??!?!? Are the kid gamers of 2024 somehow intrinsically different from 2004?

You say you want new content but then you say that the significant new content we DID get is crowbarred in? As you said TTYD feels like a complete game (because it is). The story wraps up nicely and there's no room to add anything except minor stuff. Doubtless if they did add new content, you'd probably say, "It's great that they tried to add new content, but it feels crowbarred in and it took away from the experience."

So first of all I wanna be clear you have every right to criticize any game especially Nintendo ones which are so often overpriced and Nintendo themselves as a company sucks my problem is how you went about this video. First is the trouble center and yes it should've been fixed more the fact that you can still only do one trouble at the time and can't remotely accept them from outside rougeport is very stupid and it feels like the devs didn't care about this part of the game. However this is where your critism kinda fall apart first of all prince mush being annoying to obtain I agree you shouldn't have to do the Jolene sidequest before being able to unlock the prince mush fight. Does it really matter, prince mush is the hardest/second hardest boss in the game depending on who you ask, most people aren't gonna want to fight him right away once they realize how insane he is. Now as for wacka I agree it's kinda harsh he doesn't appear if you don't whack him till he goes to the pit, but he point is he's supposed to be a secret fight that you need to prepare for. Also if you messed up why not just reload your save with all your healing items and go and hit the wacka till he disappears you know instead of complaining in the comments about a boss you've never fought? In the remake you can even retry battles you die on making the pit even easier and less tedious. Now you bring up adding new chapters but I don't think this is really fair a rpg isn't a puzzle platformer and adding new chapters is a lot of effort and story telling that takes a lot more then what it would be for a puzzle platformer there's a reason most rpg remakes don't add that much; remember it's a remake not a new game. I think adding a boss rematch mode with harder versions of old bosses like mario and luigi bowsers inside story/dream team would be more then good enough. The last 2 points make the least amount of sense to me you go on this insane rant about the battle master not being obviously for battle tutorials when literally every trailer explained what he was used for, I'm not sure how you missed that. How about taking issues with bowser's 2d sections being boring even though he's not a main character and you only play those levels for like 5% of the game? Complaining about the levels being mindless yeah that's the point they're supposed to be a break from the rpg gameplay, why would they drastically change the gameplay of a side character you only control for small parts of the game? I'm not sure what you expected here, very werid complaint about something most people won't care about. Overall I don't have issues with you criticizing paper mario ttyd switch but this just feels like it was badly done outside of the first point. Here's some issues I have with the remake, the text shouldn't have been made slower, the old sfx shouldn't have been removed, we both agree the trouble center should've been fixed and i think they could've added new troubles in the remake, there also could've been more new bosses and or some kind of boss rush mode, I think there should've been more then 2 badges, even though love the majority of the new ost i agree the nostalgia badge should consistently work for people who don't, vivian, bobbery, and ms.mowz should've been buffed cus they still suck in battle and lastly I do hope a future nintendo console is able to run this game at 60fps. That being said the paper mario ttyd remake is definitely still the definitive version almost any issue you have with the game, you can fix with mods. Honestly after so many horrible remakes like majora's mask 3d, re3 remake and BDSP it's nice to see that for the most part the developers cared and understood what made the original paper mario ttyd so good. But yeah uh this video could've been a lot better.

This video is hilarious, they never promised anything more than a 1:1 remake. Lower your expectations and enjoy the game bro

One thing I didn’t like about the remake were the remixed normal battle music being different for every area because the remixed normal battle music tracks sound too dissimilar to what the original tune sounds like. Another thing they should have kept were the original sound effects such as the sound when you activate an item in the field or in battle, the original sound effects and animations of the Fire Flower and Shooting Star because they are less cool-looking and sounding in this remake, the two unique sound effects when you recover either your HP or your FP, the sound that plays when enemies fall in battle, the scream when you attack an audience member who is about to pelt Mario or a party member with a rock, trash, or a bone and then they run away screaming at a comedically high pitch, 😆 or when the audience are attacked by a boss and they all scream in terror! 😱 The developers just reused that bland, unsatisfying recovery sound effect used in Sticker Star, Color Splash and Origami King for both HP and FP! The original game also had different sound effects for every status effect afflicted on Mario, a party member or enemies. Ones that stood out were a grumbly sound for Poison, a ding-dong bell sound for Sleep, a warbly sound for Dizzy or Confusion and a zany, laugh-like sound for Immobilization!

I think the remake is better than original and I wasn’t expecting them to change much. All the changes they made were positive imo. That being said, I think this game suffers significantly from the level design and lack of content. Outside of battles, this game is a snoozefest. I like the characters tho.

TTYD fans when you make valid criticisms of thier game: 😡😡😡😡😡

or updated

"I didn't want to be THAT guy about this game" Famous last words