วีดีโอ

Very timely subject, love it!

The alternate to a lie is the truth

Good article and good discussion

I am pretty sure I HAVE actually smoked cigarettes while watching a slowly turning fan internally debating the universalism of the Church vs. the particularism of peoplehood. They weren't menthols, but why was this so on the nose.

no man or woman in Christ..

aw young jacob. I was looking for a podcast or article from New Polity about unions and wage negotiations if there is one, you got any pointers?

Love it

Just received our copy in NZ, yet to read McCarthy's article but looking forward to it 😊

Great title

After 29 of these podcasts I can't help but wonder how you two became so well versed in the social teaching. Do you research before each episode? I'm a convert - not a cradle Catholic and drinking from the firehouse.

If we can't attend, could you please share the reading list?

God Bless this journey. I had already liquidated my RRSP and TFSA (Canada) to invest and donate. Some went into my own business which included some QOL upgrades for our guys. Im looking at updating our local Gun Club range, church and my home. I'm not afraid of poverty (been there before) nor death (Pray for me)

The answer had better be pagan.

Kinesis is exactly what your talking about

This interview is horrific. I myself was a priest for 10 years, and I am now a pagan. So much of what was said within this interview is simply devoid of facts. Pagan is a very wide broad term. I would pay good money to join this interview and give an accurate picture of paganism. I also find it so hypocritical the finger pointing at “paganism”, without mentioning the horrific atrocities thats have been committed by Christian governments for hundreds of years. This is just two men cuddling each other’s deluded ideas.

The irony is that the Bible is FULL of slaves. Paganism is a beautiful way of viewing the world that puts us in harmony with nature.

there is no truth, everything is permitted...... not only is that not what pagans believe. , but really ? ripping off the Assassin's creed ? :P

great guest

Paganism is based

This guy believes in a heaven that can only exist by sending a large amount of people *to Hell!* What kind of “not a utopia” is that?!

To pretend there is no slavery in Christianity is more than laughable. And to act like chattel slavery wasn't blessed by the church is just untruthful.

This has me thinking of Academic Agent and his arguments that tastes are shaped by elites.

Register here for New Polity 2025! newpolity.com/events/2025 Early bird price ends on January 31st.

How is this not more popular.

Will the conference be streamed live and/or available to watch afterwards like some of your previous conferences?

May 29-31! It's on my calendar!

I don't get what's so funny about such an important topic. Only the guy on the right was serious.

Definitely going to register; are you accepting papers or abstracts? Would love to contribute in any way.

they pronounce ECCE wrong

Very interesting and thought provoking. I see what you are getting at.

F

I was in Leningrad in 1990. What I saw was everyone for themselves. There wasn’t even communist ideology. Even the members of the Communist party were out for everything they could get, particularly western currency. I was dismayed when businessmen in the west acted as if there could be an easy switch to a market economy and democracy when the Soviet Union fell. The trouble was, there was no real community in place. Even the church had lost the sense of charitable care. There was such a naïveté in the west. One of your descriptions seemed so much like what I saw there.

Love this channel, would love to sit down and discuss all this with your whole group.

An effect cannot exceed its cause...a subset cannot have greater cardinality than the set from which it is taken...in a closed system energy cannot increase but only decay...all these are the same principle.

SMASHED pre-order on this one. Super excited.

By defining a general, you are creating a collection of the specific with common attributes that are the definition of the general

So the brutality of the crusades was…what? And the brutality of Christian nationalism that gave rise to an American militarized imperialist state, capitalism and the formation of a wealthy ruling class is…what? This is boiling down all of society’s problems to some broad assertion of “paganism” in a baseless manner. But I guess if you can write and publish a book you get to share your opinions like they are valid.

@1:09:59 I can’t help thinking of the moment Aladdin defeats Jafar in the Disney movie by tricking him into becoming a genie, and thus imprisoned in a lamp. “Phenomenal cosmic power! Itty bitty living space…”

woah woah woah what's this talking directly to the camera haha

I would love to hear Andrew Willard Jones debate Ivan Illych on this topic...too bad Ivan is no longer with us. His interview with David Cayley on the corruption of Christianity was very intriguing and when looked at from Andrew's position that the state was the corrupting influence vs. Ivan's position that the institutional church was the cause of the state would make for such a good debate.

I’m not seeing it on Amazon or New Polity.

Y'all can't help but speak in circles.

Vitalism sweeping into power.

Dr. Jones is correct in characterizing the Nietzschean right as presenting a more active alternative to Con inc. Bronze Age Mindset was a massive success while only describing the already apparent "longhouse" conditions of modernity, and while only offering an alternative worldview that already existed but had been suppressed. The Nietzschean right says this: Under a truly right wing regime, everything would be the same while also being entirely different, the West would stop hating itself and once again EXPAND, across the earth and into the stars, unapologetically. Liberalism to the Nietzschean is a prison where the least impressive suppress the will of those destined to move history, It is the utilitarian and nihilistic denial of all that is great and the uplifting of what is strife free and comfortable. It is stagnation and weakness.

TL;DR for those who didn't watch >Wholesome chungus Christian conservatives have found out about NRX, BAP, vitalism, and paganism. >They are very upset by this. >"Plato and Jesus say this is bad."

its good cop bad cop

The success of the monasteries to build faith centers with self-sustaining, active economies fostering agriculture, trades, pious craft and friendship is the answer to both masonic and Nietzschean vitalism. Christopher Dawson, Alasdair MacIntyre, Betrand DeJouvenal, even the Back to the Land Movement are some resources to draw principles from to apply to the New Polity. To prudently restore Logos and natural law to society requires an integralist social emergence, including a subsidiarian economy.

Thanks. A critique from inside the right. Solid

You guys should really stream these as X spaces as well - there is a nascent community of serious political philosophers Catholic, Christian, and Nietzschean and others

I'm trying to understand the whole, "profit without labor" thing. Isn't someone still doing labor in order to put money into the 401k since it goes into there from the person's job? Then I guess one could say that they are getting the money from the investments in a 401k without labor, except there are people who are laboring to make those investments, and they are getting paid... Then I suppose one could say that investments in themselves are profit without labor--is that what you mean? And where does the line get drawn on what counts as being "without labor"? I having a renter profit without labor? But you are laboring to upkeep the house for the renter and you bought the house with money that was the fruit of your labor. What about owning a cow? You're not making the cow's milk yourself, but you are feeding the cow and keeping it alive. What about selling anything in general? What about any type of passive income? Also, isn't receiving a donation "profit without labor"? But surely that's not a sin, right? Are there any good sources on this?