The Far-Right Is Winning In Europe Because Left-wing Government FAILED: Michael Shellenberger
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Journalist Michael Shellenberger weighs in on the far-right shift in Europe. #France #Right
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive
A definition to help interpret this video: Far Right=Anything besides communism.
Far-right, also known as right-wing extremism or the radical right, refers to a spectrum of political ideologies and movements that are radically conservative, ultra-nationalist, and authoritarian in nature
And YET the monopoly on authoritarianism is historically held by the left wing. The only sort of example I can find of a right wing authoritarian regime is perhaps papa doc duvalier. The rest have pretty much entirely been socialist/communist aka the LEFT. Seems to me the side that's "authoritarian in nature" as you do eloquently stated, would be the left given the history
@@alphabeta4028you can tell your Soc101 Prof that he’s wrong
@@eonwe1977 I just want to get the message out... Since you saw it, I'm happy.
@@alphabeta4028You probably need to unpack each of those components. For example, currently the left is far more authoritarian than the right in general. Though both have authoritarianism to the extent that all governments and mainstream political parties have authoritarian elements.
With respect to extremism I suggest you read Ayn Rand's 1964 essay Extremism or The Art of Smearing. It’s free on the web and still relevant.
It's not far right, it's common sense
Replacing neoliberal (i.e. right wing) governments that only serve the rich with far-right governments that only serve the rich is common sense. Ok.
@@Rodrifuuu nope, what you just asserted is made up nonsense.
@@johnwatts8346 Which right wing/conservative government in the history of the world did not serve capital? You realize that oligarchs were the ones financing Adolf?
@@Rodrifuuu big goverment only serves big corporations who pay their campaign budgets.... when has a big government actually worked for the betterment of citizen lives. look at any far left liberal budget for goverment spending each year and you tell me if they are actually doing enough for citizens with their proposed higher taxes....
@@xavierpierre1676 What far left government are you talking about? Which government is nationalizing services? You have no idea what "left" means, let alone far left.
Anything one inch to the right of Stalin is considered “far-right” 😂
In new marxism, Stalin are right because denied homosexuallism and abortion for wartime
I rather be right than left .
Absolutely agree!!
Aka better to be right than wrong :)
Why is it always "Far-Right" but never "Far-Left"?
It's "radical" left.
think what far left means in America or Canada.
What does it mean? Feed hungry children? House the poor? Fund education? Tax billionaires?
It's not far left. It's just basic common sense. But the far right, through minority rule, has convinced most people that it's extreme and we can't afford it.
Stop noticing
@@NickYankee, "What (oh what) does the far left mean in America?" Censorship, corporate propaganda BS, lock downs, anti-Semitism, corporate capture of our government, investigate/impeach/indict/ bankrupt/jail your political opponents. Wake up, pal.
Because anyone disagreeing with modern left is labeled far-right for political reason. Right tend not to be as manipulative by nature.
The establishment parties should just form a big "Let Them Eat Cake" coalition government
👍 🎉🎉🎉 😂😂😂
Common sense centrists now look far right.
Wrong. Donald Trump won the election in 2016 despite being extreme. He won because of misinformation spread by rightwing sources. His recent felony convictions outlined the extent to which his campaign spread lies and covered up facts during his campaign.
And he managed to convince millions of people to vote for his extremism, his corruption, and his criminal actions.
The far right is extreme. We now have women traveling across state lines to seek medical care because of the rightwing extremism present on our highest court.
One of the justices recently expressed his profound responsibility to push christian values from the bench, and admitted he refuses to be an impartial justice because he believes he is in a battle against his fellow Americans.
This is rightwing extremism. You're either dimly gullible, or gaslighting.
@@NickYankeeTrump won 2016 because the Democrats chose to nominate chronically unpopular and corrupt Hillary Clinton instead of highly popular Bernie Sanders. It was their own blunder.
They always were right wing. Anyone that thought privatizations would be good (instead of causing societal collapse) is right wing.
@@Rodrifuuu Privatization is why the USA has a high sandard of living and everyone flocks to the USA.
@@vade137 Nope, that's because of imperialism, which not only makes the US richer but caused those other countries economies to be terrible. And privatization works for a while but then becomes unsustainable. Look at the state of healthcare in the US. And look at general quality of life in the US. It is quickly becoming worse and worse. This is the failure of capitalism.
It's not far right, it's just being right.
THREE MEN ON RISING! THREE MEN ON RISING AT THE SAME TIME!!?? THE END IS NEAR! THE END IS NEAR!!!
Thanks Rising for bringing Michael on. He's always the voice of reason.
On the term "Far Right" - I'll say if your labeling the common citizens suffering under a wave of immigration that is both dangerous and unsettling, if you call thsese suffering citizens "Far Right" - then you've bought into a Left wing trope which is a slurr.
Instead of name calling you should dialogue with those on the right.
You might find many find to be aware, concerned for their country and safety, the economy, national security, rational policies, and they have a "Healthy Nationalism!"
Nationalism is not a dirty word, it implies a love of country and fellowman. Hoping for all countries to love their people and nation and cooperate with other free and democratic nations in - Trade, Commerce, Defense, Education, Tourism, Intermarriage, etc., etc.
The individual nation state I believe is the most sensible vehicle or organization to govern large groups of people in distinct geographic areas.
They can retain their harmless local customs, traditions and languages with legislation not from a far away unelected orgainzation but from local politicians close to the people and accountalbe.
This model mostly worked post WW2, not perfect but quite good.
I'll stop there. Stay well Rising hosts, enjoy the summer!
He lost me with the comment that Russia’s behavior is appalling. Shows an extreme lack of knowledge with respect to the Ukrainian war.
Most of the world is on the side of Russia outside Europe and the US. They are appalled by what NATO and the US are doing.
@@davidgmillsatty1900
David I understand your thinking. We on the right in the US believe htat if Trmp were elected, Putin would not have entered Ukraine at all. hamam would not have attacked Israel and Iran would not have amassed 80 t0 100 Billion dollars to fund their proxy wars.
I heard there wsa a peace deal on the table for Ukraine from Putin that was rejected by the Biden administration.
Do you know anything about that? Zelensky was supposedly willing, and I'd have been in favor of it I think, don't know the detais.
Michael is one of my favorite intellectuals actually tacking important issues and getting to the root of the problem. Getting to the root of what is important and matters, supposedly what the radicle left is stands for, but has forgotten caring only for their own power, wealth, and social status built on destroying their opposition. His views, along with James Lindsey and Douglas Murray, made me realize I am a classical liberal, which is why I find the left infuriating today standing in the way of real good progress, instead dividing us more than ever creating systems of oppression for the common person. But my views will be seen as far right, even though they are more center left! 😂
I hope they continue to have reasonable intelligent guests like him, and less divisive and ignorant harpies like those from the View.
@@ErinSmith-jo8td
I'm in agreement Erin
Finally the Hill is discussing Illegal Immigration. Cause its a huge issue where I live in the states. They are artificially elevating them with our tax dollars. While American citizens do without
This is not a new topic for this channel.
@@liuj88 When Briahna was on it was barely mentioned they just end up talking about Palestine somehow and the guy wouldn't push back
@@XcuzeTheMessDeer
It isn't mentioned now more frequently now than when Briahna was a host, if I remember correctly.
The show did talk about immigration when it was in the news (as it is now with elections in Europe), and when it wasn't.
@@liuj88 the word 'illegal' is a new development on this channel.
@@liuj88 key word you miss as did she, illegal.
Everyone is far-right these days.
And racist.
In our country RFK is the only left center/ right center….exactly one of the many reasons he has my support and vote after voting straight Dem ballot for 50 years….until 2020
Trump is basically a 90’s democrat. So…still counts.
Trump is a moderate. Certainly more moderate than the last four presidents not including him.
Bobby Jr is on the left side of the spectrum.
The left is never called far left.
Which left are you talking about? The neoliberal governments of the past 50 years that privatized everything are "left"?
@@Rodrifuuu yeah ,that far left
@@UndersiegeAl Yeah, you don't know what "left" means. Neoliberalism is a firmly right wing ideology. Maybe do some reading.
@@Rodrifuuu call it what you want. Still far left extremism. Argue with the wall
@@UndersiegeAl Far left is when capitalism, got it.
Yeah, the "far right" in France. That would basically be like the 1990's Democrats.
If people don't want that their countries, their homes, their possessions, their culture,... were taken over from them by newcomers so they are "far right".
Dose that make native Americans far right?
@@AD-ln2xu Far Right? NA are racist, nationalistic and xenophobic. Blood and Soil is their motto!
Besides they are native to America. They are native to Siberia from which they came to America.
Leaders in European NATO countries often parrot some US Russiaphobia talking points. That said, however, they are for the most part far from US neocon war-mongers. And the populace of Western Europe is certainly not eager to risk war on its soil.
The current state of politics is what happens when society cannot recognize or accept truth.
Or speak it!
S.B. 6090 ✡️
or even agree to facts.. thats the critical fail today. Millions stil masking alone in their cars..
it's what happens when rightwing nationalism reaches an authoritative presences in government.
Look at Justice alito describing his priority focus to shove christian values down the throats of Americans.
@@l.sophia2803 how about the millions who refuse to get vaccinated and end up dying?
How many died from wearing a mask in a car? Give some examples.
@@l.sophia2803ya know that’s a common CIA tactic. They overwhelm the public with information until nobody can agree whats real. Then revolution happens. Odd how the west is now suffering from this same phenomenon.. now I’m not saying the CIA is doing it. I’m just saying that whats going on looks alot like CIA work.
I'm glad I'm far right
Same!
NATIONALISM IS NOT RUSSIA, IT IS LOVING YOUR COUNTRY. PEOPLE.ARE TIRED OF THE NONSENSE
Center is now far right extremists its so ridiculous
The audacity of Europeans wanting to keep their heritage and culture, not to mention safety.
you only need to read all the comments on you tube to know what people really think about out of control immigration
Far right wins because left-wing is actually far left and far right is common sense
And they keep telling me we have AI....
If you like feeling safe you are far right...
It's similar bc it's actually Globalists vs Populists.
Thanks for covering this. He should’ve spoke more on Farage which is super fascinating right now. He’s back on the scene and he is the UK Trump.
I am an independent democrat. I agree with the right on some issues, and immigration policy is one of them. I think that the U.S. must close our border with Mexico to the extent possible. I don't think that illegal immigrants have the "right" to be in this country. Border security should be the first tenet of immigration policy.
Right is right
Europe is hating to be there under the thumb of Russia while they are U.S proxy.😂
Right is right!
Had Bri not been fired, she would have ruined this segment with her toxic and constant interruptions to push a false leftist narrative. This show is tremendously better without her.
I don’t know, they seem to be pushing a leftist narrative still by labeling everything considered not left as “far right”.
You needed to have Shellenberger on to stop the bleeding. You might want to bring Taibbi, Greenwald, Sachs, Blumenthal, Mate, Mershimer, etc. Hold on to who you have left.
Except it’s usually not an actual far right
Shellenberger is one of the few unbiased journalists.
You can’t have enough housing when you’re bringing in more than you can possibly build.
"Far right" is actually just common sense and NORMAL!
"Europe has done a poor job of integrating......" Sorry guy, I already had to do with this phenomena 40(!) years ago as a comunity worker. It is the other way around: the immigrants have done a poor job of integrating. Because most of them consider their own culture as being superior.
WE are the PEOPLE! and the PEOPLE are RIGHT!
Far right.. ffs
There’s no ‘Left’ in power in Europe. The political establishment in Europe is neo-liberal & therefore Centrist & even centre-right to far right (Neocon) on foreign policy. This is equally true for what is erroneously referred to as the ‘Left’ in America. Its a gross misconception in America to think of the Left as social liberals who embrace liberal pet projects such as transgenderism or the alphabet soup of the gender spectrum, abortion rights etc. Leftists must necessarily have a class analyses of society, the economy & politics. Consequently one can be socially conservative & be on the Left, there’s no contradiction.
As someone who often suits up for a living. I dig the green!
TRUMP TRUMP TRUMP! This is a revolution!
The public are getting sick of the daft leaders.
People are repeating the same script from 2016, and they seem to be completely unaware of it.
Yes, and that keeps balance. One of my favorite political writers sees and acknowledges this. He’s more right, and his wife is left, they don’t let politics ruin their life, and accept the cycles. It’s beautiful, wish more people saw through it. 😂
"Far Right"
Europe has been under neoliberalism for decades, what left-wing governments? Are these left-wing governments in the room right now?
The Right has accomplished nothing until policy & initiatives they support, get carried out
"Far-Right?" But "Left-wing?" Biased much, guys?
"Far right," lol. Yeah, ok...
Hey genius, Russia went into Crimea in response after the United States backed an un democratic coup in Ukraine in 2014 because they must have access to the sea port in Crimea, which they always have had going back to before Russia let Ukraine become its own country. Yes, let Ukraine leave russia . Kyiv was the original capital of the Russian Empire for those who are not informed.
This new paradigme shift is due to Mass imigration and the War in Ukraine too. Mass imigratin does not work unless the mirants and citizens of country in this case France have same values, culture and language. A great example of mass migration that worked is Venizuelans migrating to Colombia. They share those 3 things and it has been seamless. Very few people complain about it although there are very poor people in Colombia.
I wonder why no open borders
Close the borders asap...
"Far right", 😂🎉
Ok I’m done if you insist on using a “left” “right “ dichotomy.
Politics are cyclical, what goes around, comes around. Don’t get too excited.
Both sides end up forming their own downfall by embracing their extremes. Eventually it shifts back.
Had to leave the left for now. Unfortunately it's gonna have to be Trump2024
It is not so much the right wing that appeals in Europe, it is more about the Europeans having had enough of immigration, and voting for the parties that dare to do something about it.
Michael Starr Hopkins and Robby make a great team, with civilized demeanour and discussions.
I voted left for years and am what would be referred to as a classic liberal……and yet the left wing media would call me far right……and yet my views have been the same for years and in previous years aligned with the left’s political policies. The party has completely flipped on most everything. The left actually used to champion limited immigration….videos of Biden can easily be found in prior decades where he and Clinton were all about closed borders. 🤷♀️This is just one example.
Wie geil!
It's probably social media. There's different kinds of knowledge in an administrive setup. It's annoying.
People in the US misunderstand what is happening in the EU.
Firstly the EU, In terms of population, is huge. It has about 440 million people - almost the same as the populations of the USA (330m) and the Russian Federation ( 150m ) combined.
The best projections that I can find predict only around 25% of MEPs in the new EU parliament will be what the American press label as 'far-right', and the individual groups are hopelessly divided on policy. Considering them agglomerated as a single entity is very misleading.
Secondly most EU countries have a plethora of parties. The tendency has been that the right unite under a single banner, while the centre and left remain fragmented.
The rise of the right therefore is not as dramatic as the media would have you believe.
That's not really true though. Sweden, the Dutch & Poland have all called for referendum's on leaving the eu. After watching what the eu has done I don't understand why anyone would want to stay. The president of the eu is VERY similar to California's gruesome, who'd want to live under him as president???
Belgium will be the first to be taken over in the first of the Euro Caliphates to be installed in west Europe… Then UK, France and Germany, likely in this order… If not, France then UK then… At least that’s what I get her from family and friends in Belgium/Feance… Good luck yall!
So glad Bri is gone. Great call.
As long as she can keep living in your head rent free, it's a win for sure.
@@jackcslewis2009 hmmm, I have a feeling that you think that line is original.
why does the US 'need' immigration to have workers - surely the most powerful country in the world can produce enough workers by itself and if not why not? - especially since so many jobs have been shipped out of the US
Never ever in history have Progressive ideas helped people. Not once. Ever.
Progressive ideas bring crime, garbage, diminished government services and a less safe society.
Always.
Anti-warlord fans are winning
It might just be that it's not a good time to be an incumbent
When he says the "far right" in europe is just like MAGA, and the centrist right is just like the never Trumpers in the U.S. you should hear the Actually do somethings vs the never do anythings.
Because that's what it is. 🤨🤨🤨
4:20 Here goes the Democratic party garbage talking points to dismiss people moving toward populism 🙄
So good to see bri gone!
This channel has been a disappointment. So left leaning now. What happened to simply telling the news?
The "far right' in Europe is left of the left in israel.
i think Michael is a sensible, honest journalist But I personally feel he is a little off the mark with his interpretation of how the general majority feel about immigration and climate "deals". I think a vast majority are against immigration, its just that many are too scared to say anything...
Maybe the Overton window has shifted so far to the right, that moderately right positions are called left and there’s really no left left… oh no my eyes just went crossed
No
Labour in uk
Nfp in France lol
I hope you guys are going to do a segment on the Tennessee newpaper owner who is being threatened with jail for not divulging his source on the Trans Christian School shooter
Where is crazy Bri?
This show is so much better when Brianna is not on it
Democracy protested in Europe.
Token? That you?
Blaming Russia with no evidence.
"far right" and "radical left" are just labels relative to the status quo. Both sides are an emerging populism reacting to the long term effects of neoliberalism--a globalized capitalism that has dominated for the last forty years. Both sides have some legitimate grievances, but are exploited for political gain by the use of wedge social issues and disinformation about climate change. This pushes them to opposite extremes when they actually have a lot of overlap in terms of economic issues. Climate change will accelerate immigration (this is already happening), and shutting down nuclear reactors in Germany was a terrible, terrible idea.
Nicely balanced views.
I hope Robby,and this new co-host will continue to work together. They said they had worked together before,and the new man seems intelligent,and nice.
It's weird giving the Hill a thumbs up this week.
Yeah, there are actual conversations happening now that bad Faith Bri is gone.
The title of the video makes no sense
Don’t hide that, try to be human!
Russia is not taking Crimes or Geogia. Who is this host? He has to go.
Extremism is closely linked to ignorance and backwardness, and I have noticed the great similarity between religious extremists and populist extremists. Usually, you find that the biggest extremists are those who have suffered from a loss of meaning in their existence, so they resort to religion or ethnic extremism to give meaning to their existence, and this type of extremists is easy to exploit. For example, some politicians exploit them to gain power.
Democracy protocols such as elections are not enough, especially with the dominance of two parties that represent two sides of the same coin! The main goal of democracy is the peaceful exchange of power and meeting the needs and aspirations of the people. The people have noticed that democracy has turned into a mere decoration behind which fraudsters who seek money and power instead of serving the people hide!
The Hill lost all respect after firing Brianna👎
Please remove this Michael Starr he is so awkward!!!
Bring back Kim or Briahna!!!!!
This is my favorite of the test anchors so far. Did not care for the other two ive seen since they canned Bri.
The Hill is boooooooooorrrrrring these days
No bjg, no truth, just bs.
It’s not far right it’s right
Far right is saddam Hussein
Stop mischaracterizing
Im Pretty sure Saddam was some form of Socialist.
Bring back Briahna!
No
Well, how about that!