Fabian Cancellara Vs Tom Boonen - Who Is The Greatest Classics Rider?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 มิ.ย. 2024
- Tom Boonen and Fabian Cancellara are, without a doubt, two of the greatest classics riders of their generation, if not ever. But, who is the greatest? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments.
Subscribe to GCN: gcn.eu/SubscribeToGCN
Get exclusive GCN gear in the GCN store! gcn.eu/BuyGCNKit_
Sign up to the GCN newsletter: gcn.eu/gcnnewsletter
Have your say down in the comments: TOM or FABIAN...
Cancellara and Boonen have dominated the cobbled classics for the last decade or so. Even when they haven't won the races, they've still been central to the action, or a least central to the media build up. But, they're not just good at cobbled classics. Both have world titles, national titles and Grand Tour stage wins. Plus, a fan club or two.
Watch more on GCN...
Cipollini vs Cavendish ▶︎ gcn.eu/1MDTRj9
Our top 10 facts about the cobbled classics ▶︎ gcn.eu/1T7jorE
Buy GCN winter kit, casual wear and accessories in the GCN Shop: gcn.eu/TheGCNShop
Music:
Sunharbour feat. Junior - Wisdom (Science Frontiers Remix): gcn.eu/1RBb8zV
Photos: © Bettiniphoto / www.bettiniphoto.net/ & ©Tim De Waele / www.tdwsport.com
About GCN:
The Global Cycling Network puts you in the centre of the action: from the iconic climbs of Alpe D’Huez and Mont Ventoux to the cobbles of Flanders, everywhere there is road or pavé, world-class racing and pro riders, we will be there bringing you action, analysis and unparalleled access every week, every month, and every year. We show you how to be a better cyclist with our bike maintenance videos, tips for improving your cycling, cycling top tens, and not forgetting the weekly GCN Show. Join us on TH-cam’s biggest and best cycling channel to get closer to the action and improve your riding!
Welcome to the Global Cycling Network | Inside cycling
Thanks to our sponsors:
Santini cycling kit: gcn.eu/1SFf8PV
Kask helmets: gcn.eu/1FrbcHK
fi’zi:k shoes and saddles: gcn.eu/1tsXI7S and gcn.eu/1KxBGd5
SCOTT bikes: gcn.eu/1Btx0Bj
Ridley bikes: gcn.eu/1EDbfPy
Topeak tools: gcn.eu/1Lc4HAj
Canyon bikes: gcn.eu/1Oge4gz
Muc-Off: gcn.eu/1XlT5Og
Science in Sport: gcn.eu/1GrXo6n
Ass Savers: gcn.eu/1XlTmkm
Orbea bikes: gcn.eu/1oks6GH
TH-cam Channel - gcn.eu/gcnYT
Facebook - gcn.eu/gcnFb
Google+ - gcn.eu/gcnGPlus
Twitter - gcn.eu/gcnTW
GCN newsletter - gcn.eu/gcnnewsletter
Leave us a comment below! - กีฬา
![[TH] VCT Masters Shanghai Playoffs DAY 3 // FNC vs FUT | EDG vs PRX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pw2T5v0ogDI/mqdefault.jpg)
As others are saying, Boonen is the better classics rider but Cancellara is better overall.
With a electric bike!!
@@vlaamstugaproof?
Tom Last is the Classic Rider of the whole world!!
Flor.e.Cultura John Degenkolb
I'd give Boonen the edge in classics but I think Cancellara is the slightly better and more impressive overall rider.
But what if you take away his motor?
Yep. Cancellara is a better and more impressive overall rider. Furthermore, he is a much better time trial rider than Boonen. Perhaps the best ever.
@@sitopot sure
There is no proof at all of him doing it y'all just say his bike changes were suspicious🤦♂️
Also, he has proven himself to be a beast more then once
Stop whining about it
@@lennertdevoldere7000 unnatural acceleration with no changes in bodylanguage????
@@pennyblue6372🤣🤣🤣 still crying about 2010? Crying because y'all fav lose.
Spartacus is proving his quality as a rider right this moment in E3 Harelbeke, coming back in the front group after a mech failure that left him at the back of the race. He's huge!
Fabian Cancellara
I get you want to stay on his good side and get interviews the rest of the year, but there are more than a few rumors about Fabs using motors in his bike (including the time he rode Tom off his wheel). It seems like something that needs to at least be discussed in this debate.
+Matthew Martin if he had only won races that year, I might also be suspicious. However, he's won pretty consistently at the biggest races throughout his career. Those two monuments in 2010 aren't anomalies. Dan
+Matthew Martin if he had only won races that year, I might also be suspicious. However, he's won pretty consistently at the biggest races throughout his career. Those two monuments in 2010 aren't anomalies. Dan
Global Cycling Network I don't really believe the rumors. I also generally agree with your statements that it is not something that has been going on hidden for years, but I think it did warrant a mention.
+Matthew Martin Fabian Doesn't even trust electronic groupsets and uses a single layer of bar tape for Paris Roubaix. I highly doubt he would trust a motor, and a hard man like him wouldn't stoop that low. He's a multiple world time trial champion, I would give him some benefit of the doubt and assume he didn't use a motor.
+Matthew Martin They should have brought it up! To think that many believed that he HAD to use a motor to be that strong is a great point for him.
Tom Boonen is the better classics rider, where Cancellara is the best overall cyclist
yhep, have to agree with that. Tom out shines him in the classics but Fab is definitely the stronger rider over all. His TT ability puts him head and shoulders above in general terms as he can ride away from a peloton like only maybe Wiggins and Martin can match, Tom definitely can't. However Tom seems to be able to lay it all down in one long day better than anyone else and his bike handling over odd terrain is better
+Paul Liptrott And perhaps more accurately, Tom is the better sprinter (as most of his victories are on flat courses) whereas Fabian is a better all-arounder and much better time trialist.
Flat courses? These classics are in Netherlands ya know. They are both good at "short" steep climbs. Although it was those short steep climbs that had them both dropped yesterday but Cancellara put up a good fight
@@paulliptrott2523 Which classics are in Netherlands?
Paul Liptrott in the Netherlands?! What are u on about
Great vid guys. Two beasts of the sport. Only wish injury and sickness hadn't kept them from facing off against each other over the last few years. Hope Tom is up for the cobbles this year, because Cancellera is on fire at the moment. (he would have gone Top 10 at MSR too if not for Gaviria going down in front of him and Sagan too)
That was awesome! Thank you guys!
I think we're lucky to have two such outstanding riders in this generation.
Tornado Tom was my idol growing up and is still one of my favourites regardless of wins as he suits the early season whilst sparticus is great all season long
Spartacus is far more versatile.
But what if you take away his motor?
Cancellara's days in the yellow jersey are almost all due to winning the prologue and then wearing the jersey for the first week when the GC hardly changes.
Great video guys
Both are just beasts. Lucky to have seen them both competing against each other at their best. But let's see how this comparison goes mid April after Fabian adds a few more :)
Don't you think Fabian's victory on flanders 2010 is suspicious ?
Great video. I recall Fabian had a couple poorly-time collar bone fractures that kept him out of races. May be true for Tom as well (injury reducing opportunities).
Great video... I thought I saw a vain popping out on Matt's neck as he was trying to make his point... Both are great riders and one of the many reasons I enjoying watching pro cycling..
it's like comparing caviar and truffles!! two completely different riders but both as exquisite as each other in their own right!!! after watching E3 today i doubt boonen would have made the comeback to the main bunch like spartacus tho? both amazing riders, can't really compare them as different types of rider, they are both awesome and will go down in history :0)
tom boonen is de beste van de wereld
Probably the toughest comparison to pick just one favorite. Fans of cycling are likely to miss both when these two retire. Just for my own view, the ability to come back strong from injuries, makes Cancellara an inspiration to me in my return to cycling. True to his nickname Spartacus, he is a true warrior.
You should also make a:
Pantani vs Nibali
or a:
Pinot vs Bardet
or a:
Valverde vs Rodriguez
I would really like one of those :D
All the best guy's
Boonen is an outstanding cyclist. Cancellara is a freak, and we love this freak.
Tough to choose but ill pick Fabian.
I'm a big Spartacus fan, and I didn't need Dan to convince me. But when I think of Cancellara and Boonen, beyond their rivalry in the spring classics, I think of the great respect they have for each other. That respect was visible when, a couple of years ago, right after the announcement of Boonen's wife miscarriage, Spartacus showed his support at the beginning of a race (was it Strade Bianche?). A touching moment.
Cancellara :)
Boonen for me! Could you please do a Sagan vs Zabel video? Cheers!
Sagan -v- Kelly would be an interesting comparison. I'd go with Kelly.
Both Boonen and Cancellara have been great riders for the ages. Both have seven monument wins. Cancellara was also perhaps the greatest time trialist of all time with two Olympic gold medals which also helped him win many yellow jerseys. Boonen was the superior printer which helped him win more races overall. Along with Contador they are clearly the greatest riders of their generation and we should enjoy that we were able to delight in their achievements!
The better classics rider? Tom. The better cyclist? Fabian. I really love these keep doing them, hey Contador is retiring too! best climbers ever? Contador vs Froome?
+Mannuel Corona hard one too but i think contador is the best tour (tour, giro and vuelta) rider of this generation , off course he is older now and therefor maybe not anymore at his prime but he is on top for almost 10 years and eachtime there were other rivals yet always his name was at the favo list
I can't choose they are both my cycling heroes. (Btw Boonen won Kuurne 3x not 2x). But it was real fun to watch the two being compared, I give you that.
How about we all just click on that great looking espresso machine and chillax. They're both fantastic cyclists and I look forward to watching them race on the cobbles at least one more time this Spring.
Fabian, all the way. Boonen was amazing but not in the same way. Fabian was monstrous. His power was unrivaled. He was better alone (TT) and he was better in the mountains, for his team.
"Well, shall we just agree to disagree?"
"No!"
"Well, shall we just disagree?"
"Yes."
This got to be the best delivered joke since Monty Python.
Tom Boonen 👊🚴🇧🇪
These two have great chemistry!
+Andrew S Fabian and Tom or Matt and Dan?
+Global Cycling Network Yes.
Tomeke, Tomeke, Tomeke!!
Thing is Fabian had a gradual career but Boonen 2004, 2005 and 2006 was simply mental. Probably the most dominant riding we've seen since Merckx and haven't seen since. In 2007 and 2008 he was still good but because he was a little bit less and everyone rode his wheel that gave his teammate Devolder 2 wins in Flanders even though Boonen was probably the best rider in those races. After that he was good but not great with the exception of 2012.
Boonen was the best classics rider, overall I place them on equal footing.
Yeah but most importantly the Belgian Champs jersey with the rainbow bandings on the sleeves and collar is 😍😍🔥🔥🔥🔥
Spartacus
good banter
You're forgetting the most important comparison:
Mechanical doping scandals
Cancellara: 1
Boonen: 0
+whydoihavetousemyrealnamefuckyou troll
+Detmer oh year
+whydoihavetousemyrealnamefuckyou oh year
I can't wait to see the Matt Stephens vs Dan Lloyd video .....2 Titans of their own cycling postcodes :o)
6:24 - 6:26 reminds me of a scene from one of the Ocean's films with the two brothers who are always arguing and talking over each other. Funny :))
Boonen!
WITHOUT A DOUBT TOM IS THE BEST
Great video guys, loved it. Btw sorry Matt but cancellara is the best
Tom Boonenen!!!!!!
Cancellara is the best for sure
Sorry for being late! I don't think that this is a fair question. Tom is a classic rider(an excellent one) while Fabian was (now retired) a legend of power cycling!
Both are great cyclists (look at their stats) that provided us with incredible moments. Truly, I have enjoyed them both
Tough one..my fav 2 riders after Matt! No one crashes into logs like him.
We are all winners for having these two be rivals all these years. Spring won't be the same without them.
Dan should have mentioned Fabian being the patron of the peloton and how much respect he commands from his fellow riders.
strangely, there was never that much of a rivalry between them. Boonen dominated early on and then Cancellara did for a while. Didn't even exchanged words or anything.
Tom Boonen
Tom is way better overall, Fabian was the better time trial rider, maybe the strongest ever in that part, still Tom has tons of more credit. Respect to both!
Great product placement for Rocket Espresso
The day of Cancellara's hidden motor
Please tell us about 21 stages of tour de France and why Fabian cancellara is greatest winner of tour de France because Tom Burton was the greatest competition he got. The pressure of riding tour de France in which BMW bikes were used to film the race and Skoda cars were used by teams to repair a puncture which carried the tools and personell who did the repairs
I love both.
Tom Boonen !
Tom is the best 😉
Boonen won without using e-bikes. Cancellara has suspicions over him in that.
Boonen, Boonen, Boonen, Boonen.
looks like the decider is this year! How about which ex pro cyclist has his name on the best bikes? Merckx, Boardman, Cippo, Lemond etc.... :)
Oops, just saw the list of GCN sponsors... Answered my own question using Wikipedia anyway, Giovanni Pinarello was a pro cyclist before he became a frame/bike maker...
can it be a tie? theyre both phenomenal with slightly different specificity in the way they ride. in an outright sprint in their prime boonen wins, in a tt fabian wins, in an endurance based effort they come out equal and when it comes to getting over the mountains they both ride together and suffer through it.
Awsome video Guys..But I still think Fabian is The best of all ..But from now till a few years , Peter Sagan will be the Best of All Time ..He is just and other Monster
Cancellara walked on to the road in E3 2016, put his hand up casually and stopped a tinkoff car and all other support cars behind it as well as blocking some riders,
just to get to his spare bike.
Not considering he chased the leading group back after his mechanical cost him 2 minutes.
That's boss.
BOONEN 👊🚴🇧🇪
good vid. cancellara for me!!
Nice espresso machine. top10 coffee machines of the pros?
+Rich Hatton ours wins, all the way
YAY! I made the GCN show! My life is complete.
Seriously though, you should make this video. Or top 10 coffee's of the peleton. Hands up for a Cortado? Anyone? Bueller?
Of course it's Spartacus, don't know why this is even a question. He's won literally every type of classic, and multiple times too for many of them. Boonen is good too, but his dominance is limited to the cobbled races.
Every type of classic? Other than MSR (and Boonen's been on the podium of it)he's won only the same type of classics than Boonen! In the end it all comes down to: Cancellara is the better ITT, Boonen is the better sprinter. Personally, I find Boonen just cooler.
One more fun fact about Fabian. Fabian has a bridge named after him when he won his first of two double Flanders-Roubaix victories in 2010. The bridge is in his hometown in Ittigen.
He's getting a road named after him that appears in the race he's just won the other week, that in Belgium now that says it all about his over all ability. Can't remember which race it is but it was his 4th win this time.
Think it's a road used in the E3...
Cancellara is the only rider to win Strade Bianche more than once.
At 20:19 the grottiest male camel toe of all time.Check it out. It may be a new rival to Dan's (now) classic white cycling shorts.
Tom, by 1/2 a wheel.
Boonen has the better palmares. World road race & green jersey, which Cancellara lacks, co record holder in Paris Roubaix
Fabian is clearly stronger, but Tom has the edge when it comes finesse, elegance and style (only just). Which is more important that watts.
+Chris 987654 An fun but totally pointless argument
boonen is best
Boonen is Flemish. Case closed.
Both are pretty impressive riders, i do think cancellara would be a worldchampion one day if Switserland had a better national team. But Sagan is coming if there is one rider who can break their records its sagan. Too bad most battles between boonene and cancellara at their best shape never happend because there was always one of them injured unfortunately
4ever spartacus🚴🏽
no doubts, Spartacus, in and out of the pro peloton!
Tom has a Donkervoort, fair to say he's the coolest dad every.
Whoa nice espresso machine!
BOONEN!!!!
A bit off topic, but I am sure by now everyone has seen Sagan and Cancellara avoid going down in Milan Sanremo?
1. Has Sagan EVER come off the bike?!!
2. That sprint makes me seriously question whether disc brakes are needed. Sagan does bot lock up at all, and Cancellara locks up completely, does a controlled skid and rights himself.
In dry no, maybe in wet though.
Boonen better, simple as that!
I always thought Fabian was best,but Matt has changed my mind and I have to go with Tom on this one.
Its impressive how much Cancellara has won, considering, he is not a good sprinter. Also he has been riding on bad teams at times. And other riders just sitting on his wheels. Bonnen has had one of the best classics team on his side since the beginning.
I know this comment is 2 years old..though boonen had a stronger team cance was always the leader, where boonen has lost classics because of his teammates think devolder terpstra etc
Peter Sagan
+gweflj oh that's cold but true
Tornado
not only can boonen smash up in the classics he can also sprint like a beast!
Cancellara a great rider. But as a classics rider, Boonen is better.
Co record holder in two of the 5 monuments.
World road race champ - TT doesn't count for assessing them as classics riders.
boonen for me geoff
Their both reasonably good, but I'm better, though l don't like to talk about it.
King Spartacus of Flanders!
I bet Dan has been searching up his facts for whole night. Look at those eye bags!!
Tom Boonen all the way!
Cancellara destroyed Tom over and over again on the wall.
What about how much time Fabian has sat on the front of the grand tour peloton for other's GC hopes? #teamspartacus #teamplayer