Excellent model work, as always. These are not only very entertaining, but they really let you wrap your head around how these things work. Something that can often be very hard to do with just words or a simple illustration.
The best channel going explaining how these old weapons were designed and worked.....simple, clear and concise and not cluttered by a bunch of needless verbiage. Please keep up the excellent and interesting work.....ps. music choice is great as well.
Thank you, Mr. Brassington. I'm reading David Weber's Safehold scifi book series right now, and they talk about building guns just like this, jumping from effectively 16th-century tech to late 19th-century in a matter of years. It's very helpful to see what this intermediate gun technology actually looked like/operated. (I had no idea there was a vent block like that in Armstrong guns, for example.)
An excellent display of a 110 lb armstrong gun! When I was with the Palmerston Artillery volunteers we went to Crownhill fort for a weeken special. Sadly at the time their Moncrieff gun was in poor condition and we couldn't elevate it. But they have fixed it now and it's impressing to see. The one we had at Fort Nelson was always good for display and I still have "fond" memories of how heavy the breach block was and keeping your footing with hobnail boots. If I may, I'd suggest the 32lp SBBL gun next . This was a 32 pounder with the rear cut away and replaced with a sliding breech. They were mainly used in caponiers to act as anti infantry guns. Firing Case shot and Grape shot down the ditch and clearing away enemy forces trying to scale the walls.
vectorbrony. Thanks for your comment. As a PAV team member you will, perhaps, have noted that at Fort Nelson, the gunner on the left fires the gun, while in the video, he is on the right. I am informed that the PAV team are working from the 1885 drill book, while the video drill is from the 1992 manual. So both are correct. I will see if I can find drawings (essential) and a manual for the 32 pounder SBBL gun, but no promises. R
Absolutely excellent work! The RBL Armstrong was always a bit curious to me. I never knew about the tin gas seal which makes a lot more sense in hindsight than a straight conical fit between the breech-piece and breech face, but I still have to wonder why he went with a plug-secured block to close the breech, since it kind of seems you get the disadvantages of both sliding-block and screw-plug breeches. I will say, the combination of the gas seal, booster charge, loading tray breech insert, and uninterrupted screw explain why the RN felt the guns were excessively labor-intensive. Though, next to the RML 12.5-inch this seems positively convenient.
Amazing work as always detailing how these amazing Victorian era marvels work. Thank you so much for everything you do and as usual I look forward to your next video with great anticipation. If possible do you think you could do a history of shell development in one of your future videos? I would really be interested in seeing how they evolved over time all in one video. But no matter what you do I know I will love it!
The shell simulation is very interesting! You should try making a video on the Type 3 "San Shiki" AA rounds that Japan used in WW2. Or if you want to try something rarer, the "Brandshrapnell" incendiary AA rounds Germany made in WW2.
I just discovered this channel yesterday, and I've already watched almost every video. Wonderful rendering and animation! I really get a truly inside look at how these weapons work. Your channel deserves 100 times the subscribers!
Amazing renderings. The descending carriage gun was made obsolete when battleships gained very thick side armor. Then a gun needed to drop a shell onto the deck from a high angle to be successful. Like happened with the HMS Hood.
@ZaHandle My understanding is that she got hit behind her funnel from behind as she turned in an area they had planned to upgrade the armor to but spent time showing the flag around the world instead>
More likely the descending carriage guns could not be scaled up to WW 1 level battleship gun size effectively and rate of fire for WW 1 5-8" guns was was much faster, you also lacked overhead protection who was bad as air-burst became more accurate.
Wonderful! This video certainly answered questions for me. I am a long time fort and ordnance historian. Across the Pond, we had our wonderful Buffington-Crozier disappearing carriages, with weapons from 6" to 16". There is a lot of documentation as well as early movies, with some guns active during WW 2. I would love to see your work on U.S. coastal defense weapons. By the way, this past weekend, I visited Fort Fisher, in North Carolina. The famous Armstrong RML is well documented with photos and a copy on the standard friction recoil mount.
John, thank you for your comments. I have been considering a project on the 8inch or 10inch Rodman coastal guns. Can you recommend any sites where I can get drawings of the guns, their carriages, ammunition and loading drills, and especially details of the Rodman manufacturing process. I would be grateful if you could. Regards Rob
I have been fascinated by artillery for the past 60 years. Rodman cast both 15" and 20" smoothbores. There is a wonderful painting, by John Ferguson Weir, titled "The Cannon Foundry", painted at the West Point Arsenal, showing one Rodman vertical mould being poured and another set up with the water cooling plumbing. I have also been a member of the Coast Defense Study Group, CDSG, for the past 35 years. I will send in an inquiry to our journal, with your site contact information, or your e-mail, if that's ok. My colleagues have tons of primary source material.
An excellent visual descriotion of how those guns worked! My only quibble, (and it is a minor one) is at the end where you demonstrated the explosion of the shrapnel shell. While the individual bits would fly apart like that, the over all trajectory of the pieces would continue on the same trajectory as the shell. This would tesult in a cone shaped pattern of fragments moving at rifle speeds! Quite deadly to exposed personal! It was this and the machine gun which made WW1 fighting so deadly, and made mass troop assaults a thing of the past!
I think they had one of these in the fort that is now part of the Wellington Botanic Gardens. Now part of an area with a weather station, a Cub Scout hall and several observatories.
Fascinating! Did this model have the flash problem around the breech that the naval versions did? Did that problem result in their being removed from ships?
I can certainly understand (if not agree) with why the Victorian establishment discontinued Armstrongs and went back to muzzleloaders for a while. This is fiendishly complex and the tech just probably wasn't quite mature enough yet when these were first introduced. It took until Krupp to perfect the breechloading cannon.
Great start to the year, thank you. The tin cup used to obturate is something I wasn't aware of, was it hooked out and re used or a new one every time?
The tin cup was the hardest item to research. I have not found an existing example or drawing (so far). It should have been removed from the vent piece after each shot using a special tool, but again I haven’t got the drawing. The tin cup, however, was essential. If, in the heat of battle, the old one was not removed, or a new one fitted in place correctly, there was a great risk of the blast expelling the vent piece explosively, to the detriment of the crew and surroundings. R
Very nice video and explanation of the mechanism 👍😀 I was wondering how the recoil forces are dampened in this construction…. The recoil is huge and on other guns there are hydraulic dampers to absorb the recoil. But how does it work on this mechanism and they prevent the gun from banging back down. Is there a mechanical brake on the ratchet mechanism ?…. That acts like a brake and this friction dissipates the recoil energy ?…
At the base of the carriage is a heavy weight, When the gun fires, the carriage rotates, lifting the heavy weight up, like a pendulum. There are 2 sets of ratchets, one on the top of the yellow arm, which stops the carriage from falling back, and the second set within the brake drum. The clever design means that the recoil force is entirely absorbed by lifting the weight while rotating the carriage to its loading position.
Amazing animations, as always, right on the point. Great detail too, keep up the good work. Have you considered making an animation of the type 93 japanese torpedo? It's quite the machine.
Excellent as always. You really should approach the likes of English Heritage etc with regards to having these videos shown at places like Landguard Fort (Felixstowe), and the fort at Harwich which used artillery of this era.
Yes. In the smooth bore shell guns, this Boxer (Colonel Edward Mounier Boxer, RA) type time fuze was initiated simply by the blow-by of gunpowder combustion gases. This was obviously not feasible or reliable in a rifled gun with gas seals, so inertia initiation was used.
I really enjoyed the demonstration of the disappearing gun mechanism.
Aka: The Peeka-Boom
I found the fuze system very interesting.
Wonderful Rob! Love the gun system videos! So much work and it shows.
Excellent model work, as always. These are not only very entertaining, but they really let you wrap your head around how these things work. Something that can often be very hard to do with just words or a simple illustration.
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
@@vbbsmyt Hello, could you please send me a 3D drawing of the Moncrieff RBL 7-inch gun? I want to make it into a model. Thank you very much.
You sir are an artist. This level of skill is incredible.
The best channel going explaining how these old weapons were designed and worked.....simple, clear and concise and not cluttered by a bunch of needless verbiage. Please keep up the excellent and interesting work.....ps. music choice is great as well.
Brilliant work. I wish this content was around when I was decades younger! Anyway, now I get to see it.
Wow. That fuse timer mechanism is sweet. Love the video!
Thank you, Mr. Brassington. I'm reading David Weber's Safehold scifi book series right now, and they talk about building guns just like this, jumping from effectively 16th-century tech to late 19th-century in a matter of years. It's very helpful to see what this intermediate gun technology actually looked like/operated.
(I had no idea there was a vent block like that in Armstrong guns, for example.)
Thats series is a great read
@@battleoid2411 You saw Weber got pretty tired of writing it (or maybe was forced to to tie it off) towards the last book. The man writes too much!😂
@@MM22966 yeah, he goes all out on his books, its what I love about them but yeah it takes a lot of effort for him to write them
Late Christmas Gift. Thanks
An excellent display of a 110 lb armstrong gun! When I was with the Palmerston Artillery volunteers we went to Crownhill fort for a weeken special. Sadly at the time their Moncrieff gun was in poor condition and we couldn't elevate it. But they have fixed it now and it's impressing to see. The one we had at Fort Nelson was always good for display and I still have "fond" memories of how heavy the breach block was and keeping your footing with hobnail boots.
If I may, I'd suggest the 32lp SBBL gun next . This was a 32 pounder with the rear cut away and replaced with a sliding breech. They were mainly used in caponiers to act as anti infantry guns. Firing Case shot and Grape shot down the ditch and clearing away enemy forces trying to scale the walls.
vectorbrony. Thanks for your comment. As a PAV team member you will, perhaps, have noted that at Fort Nelson, the gunner on the left fires the gun, while in the video, he is on the right. I am informed that the PAV team are working from the 1885 drill book, while the video drill is from the 1992 manual. So both are correct.
I will see if I can find drawings (essential) and a manual for the 32 pounder SBBL gun, but no promises. R
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage
My idea is to cooperate with the local cultural relics bureau to sell these models, or to keep them in private collections.
Absolutely excellent work! The RBL Armstrong was always a bit curious to me. I never knew about the tin gas seal which makes a lot more sense in hindsight than a straight conical fit between the breech-piece and breech face, but I still have to wonder why he went with a plug-secured block to close the breech, since it kind of seems you get the disadvantages of both sliding-block and screw-plug breeches. I will say, the combination of the gas seal, booster charge, loading tray breech insert, and uninterrupted screw explain why the RN felt the guns were excessively labor-intensive. Though, next to the RML 12.5-inch this seems positively convenient.
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
My man Rob back at it with the most baller Victorian era weapon breakdown
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
Amazing work as always detailing how these amazing Victorian era marvels work. Thank you so much for everything you do and as usual I look forward to your next video with great anticipation. If possible do you think you could do a history of shell development in one of your future videos? I would really be interested in seeing how they evolved over time all in one video. But no matter what you do I know I will love it!
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
he is back!
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
@@vbbsmyt i will, godspeed and good luck on future work.
The shell simulation is very interesting! You should try making a video on the Type 3 "San Shiki" AA rounds that Japan used in WW2.
Or if you want to try something rarer, the "Brandshrapnell" incendiary AA rounds Germany made in WW2.
Excellent as always. Nothing like a cup of tea and a good weapon animation.
New year, new video.
As every 3d work - PERFECTION!
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
I just discovered this channel yesterday, and I've already watched almost every video. Wonderful rendering and animation! I really get a truly inside look at how these weapons work. Your channel deserves 100 times the subscribers!
Thank you, could I ask you to subscribe, if you haven't already done so. Getting close to 100K.
@@vbbsmyt done!
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
so nice to see a new video from you..
It's a good day when Robert uploads. I feel the wooden fuse is more impressive that the bigger stuff. Happy New Year!
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
@@vbbsmyt Already subscribed for a while. Good luck!
many thanks R
another outstandingly made video. complex breech lock mechanism and shells. Ahead of its time. thank you
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
Excellent video!
Greetings from the Netherlands 🇳🇱.
This is outstanding. Thank you for the time and effort in sharing. We really appreciate it. This is amazing knowledge
Astonishing level of detail. Outstanding work! Thanks for being so meticulous and presenting this so well.
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage
Damn! I remember watching these animations so many years ago and he's still making them! Keep it up!
Thank you, could I ask you to subscribe, if you haven't already done so. Getting close to 100K.
Amazing renderings. The descending carriage gun was made obsolete when battleships gained very thick side armor. Then a gun needed to drop a shell onto the deck from a high angle to be successful. Like happened with the HMS Hood.
@ZaHandle My understanding is that she got hit behind her funnel from behind as she turned in an area they had planned to upgrade the armor to but spent time showing the flag around the world instead>
More likely the descending carriage guns could not be scaled up to WW 1 level battleship gun size effectively and rate of fire for WW 1 5-8" guns was was much faster, you also lacked overhead protection who was bad as air-burst became more accurate.
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
Bravo! Im very glad I was not an artillery man of that era.
Wonderful, so much effort taken to make it easily understandable for newcomers like me. Thank you for the video.
Ah, the really good surprise of the day : A video from vbbsmyt ! Thank you.
Thank you, if you have not already done so, please could you please subscribe to this channel - I hope to reach 100K subscribers. Regards R
These never cease to amaze me.
Complimenti! Non ci avrei mai creduto se non lo avessi visto.
Pensavo che nel 1860 fosse tutto più rudimentale. Ottima creazione 3D. GRAZIE!
back when we needed him most
Wonderful visualization....these looked pretty accurate for their day too....thanks for posting.
Glad you like it. If you are not already a subscriber, please subscribe and help me get to 100K subscribers
HAPPY NEW YEAR BREECHLOADER FANS!! LONG LIVE THE ROYAL NAVY, HOPE THE ROYAL NAVY IS ON OUR SIDE!!
Another masterpiece. Sir, you're an artist.
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
sweet music. like mid period grateful dead meets post-rock
Fascinating animation. Impressive.
Mark from Melbourne Australia 🇦🇺
This was the gun used on HMS Warrior. It also helped convince the RN to stick with muzzle loads for a lot longer. Thanks for the work though!
Wonderful! This video certainly answered questions for me. I am a long time fort and ordnance historian. Across the Pond, we had our wonderful Buffington-Crozier disappearing carriages, with weapons from 6" to 16". There is a lot of documentation as well as early movies, with some guns active during WW 2. I would love to see your work on U.S. coastal defense weapons. By the way, this past weekend, I visited Fort Fisher, in North Carolina. The famous Armstrong RML is well documented with photos and a copy on the standard friction recoil mount.
John, thank you for your comments. I have been considering a project on the 8inch or 10inch Rodman coastal guns. Can you recommend any sites where I can get drawings of the guns, their carriages, ammunition and loading drills, and especially details of the Rodman manufacturing process. I would be grateful if you could. Regards Rob
I have been fascinated by artillery for the past 60 years. Rodman cast both 15" and 20" smoothbores. There is a wonderful painting, by John Ferguson Weir, titled "The Cannon Foundry", painted at the West Point Arsenal, showing one Rodman vertical mould being poured and another set up with the water cooling plumbing. I have also been a member of the Coast Defense Study Group, CDSG, for the past 35 years. I will send in an inquiry to our journal, with your site contact information, or your e-mail, if that's ok. My colleagues have tons of primary source material.
Great show!
Happy new year!
Many successful presentations. I didn't realize shooting this gun was so complicated.
Yet again you have excelled yourself with another high quality presentation .Well Done .🥇
Another masterpiece thank you.
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
Fascinating, thanks for including the bursting shell.
What a Happy New Years gift.😊
Very cool, much appreciated, the wooden fuse is super neat!!
Very good video. Thank You Sir.
Nice job on the animation! I'm always excited to see a new vbbsmyt upload!
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
Impressive video as always!
Brilliant as always
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
Magnificent, as usually
Stunning video. Thank you.
We have one (or 2 actually I think) of those cannons at my job. Beautiful pieces of engineering
Thank you a lot. It is so impressive!
Excellent as always.
There is a gun in Whampoa, HKG & I wondered how it would actually work. These videos make it very clear.
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
An excellent visual descriotion of how those guns worked!
My only quibble, (and it is a minor one) is at the end where you demonstrated the explosion of the shrapnel shell. While the individual bits would fly apart like that, the over all trajectory of the pieces would continue on the same trajectory as the shell. This would tesult in a cone shaped pattern of fragments moving at rifle speeds!
Quite deadly to exposed personal!
It was this and the machine gun which made WW1 fighting so deadly, and made mass troop assaults a thing of the past!
Veey fascinating animations. Great job!
Ayo dats really cool rob
Emplaced in HMS warrior I believe.
С наступившим! Спасибо!
bravo sir!
to the youtube library of congress with this level of quality once again
Glad you like it. If you are not already a subscriber, please subscribe and help me get to 100K subscribers
Brilliant animation!
Very interesting video, I did like that you included how the shell was assembled and what happened after it was fired
Fascinating, thank you.
I think they had one of these in the fort that is now part of the Wellington Botanic Gardens. Now part of an area with a weather station, a Cub Scout hall and several observatories.
Thank you!
excellent as usual
Wow, I loved the internals of the shell, that fragmentation would have been hell
Thank you.
Amazing work as usual!
Amazing work!
wristwatches and guns - amazing mechanical machines
Fascinating! Did this model have the flash problem around the breech that the naval versions did? Did that problem result in their being removed from ships?
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
That's one big gun
Excellent video, with step by step explanation of the mechanics involved. Could the CAD files be used to make a 3D model?
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
Amazing work.
Great stuff
Happy new year :)
I can certainly understand (if not agree) with why the Victorian establishment discontinued Armstrongs and went back to muzzleloaders for a while. This is fiendishly complex and the tech just probably wasn't quite mature enough yet when these were first introduced. It took until Krupp to perfect the breechloading cannon.
Great start to the year, thank you. The tin cup used to obturate is something I wasn't aware of, was it hooked out and re used or a new one every time?
The tin cup was the hardest item to research. I have not found an existing example or drawing (so far). It should have been removed from the vent piece after each shot using a special tool, but again I haven’t got the drawing. The tin cup, however, was essential. If, in the heat of battle, the old one was not removed, or a new one fitted in place correctly, there was a great risk of the blast expelling the vent piece explosively, to the detriment of the crew and surroundings. R
Very nice video and explanation of the mechanism 👍😀
I was wondering how the recoil forces are dampened in this construction….
The recoil is huge and on other guns there are hydraulic dampers to absorb the recoil.
But how does it work on this mechanism and they prevent the gun from banging back down.
Is there a mechanical brake on the ratchet mechanism ?…. That acts like a brake and this friction dissipates the recoil energy ?…
At the base of the carriage is a heavy weight, When the gun fires, the carriage rotates, lifting the heavy weight up, like a pendulum. There are 2 sets of ratchets, one on the top of the yellow arm, which stops the carriage from falling back, and the second set within the brake drum. The clever design means that the recoil force is entirely absorbed by lifting the weight while rotating the carriage to its loading position.
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
Firing and reloading this early breech loading gun takes forever! Not sure if it was significantly faster than muzzle loading guns?
Very informative.
Amazing animations, as always, right on the point. Great detail too, keep up the good work.
Have you considered making an animation of the type 93 japanese torpedo? It's quite the machine.
As always, I would need good drawings. Where can I get these from?
Love the channel, can you do the 16’/50 MK7 naval cannons eventually? Those are my favorite big gun of all time
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
I'm surprised that it took until 1897 for hydraulic recoil mechanism to be added to artillery.
Interesting breech loading system.
Excelente apresentação. Percebemos como era complicado usar canhões como esse. Em que lugares eles foram utilizados?
Could you do a video on the battleship turrets at the Maxim Gorky Fortresses (Coastal Batteries No. 30 and 35)? I'd love to learn more about them!
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
Excellent as always. You really should approach the likes of English Heritage etc with regards to having these videos shown at places like Landguard Fort (Felixstowe), and the fort at Harwich which used artillery of this era.
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
Большое спасибо за познавательные ролики!
"Wanna see a magic trick?"
BOOOM!!!
"-and it's gone!"
Amazeng! The same gun in corregidor island in philippines, the vanishing gun. Amazeng animation!
I have made it perfectly, about this cannon, and it is metal, it is on my homepage, and try to sell it
shell fuse's ignition was triggered by inertia?
Yes. In the smooth bore shell guns, this Boxer (Colonel Edward Mounier Boxer, RA) type time fuze was initiated simply by the blow-by of gunpowder combustion gases. This was obviously not feasible or reliable in a rifled gun with gas seals, so inertia initiation was used.
I’ve seen one of those disappearing guns when I was younger.
As always, it's great. I was already getting worried.
Glad you like my work, click the Subscriber button at video end and help me get to 100k subscribers
Thank you. I have been your subscriber for a long time.
Many thanks
Many thanks
Masterpiece job👌
Great video! Would you consider doing a video on the PaK 36 gun?
Thanks.