I want to state here one very true fact. May be Hard to hear but very true! The burden of Hindu-muslim and other religions migrant mostly bearing By North-east only.. other state GOV or people literally want to implement CAA or any migrant citizenship act but don't want to give them shelter, Only North-eastrn knows how demographic changed by these migrant, now it constantly becoming huge threat for indigenous people of North-east. I recommend you to study Tripura history and how there demographic got change after 1965 migrations.. u will understand it clearly!👍
Why they are deporting to other state instead of their native place of chattogram . Chattogram is their ancestral homeland. First of all why chattogram was given to bangladesh first .It was buddhist ,hindu ,tribal majority land.
@@AtulChakma I haven't read about such negotiation anywhere .But anyhow chakma and other native tribes of chattogram hill tracts should be relocated in their native ancestral land of chattogram .Everyone has right to live in their native land and follow their indigenous culture and language . As far as negotiation is concerned if it was happened it carry no meaning as it was decided by bunch of some british educated brown english people like gandhi ,nehru ,jinnah .They are big fool and idiot .Had they ever been to chattogram how they could decide fates of native tribes from delhi ? Negotiatons and drawing line was totally null and void.
@@sourabhkumar-ie2hm yes brother there was negotiation, and our core leaders weren't able not meet PM P. J Nehru, they waited and waited, ignored due to minority, but finally in 1964-1969, For any religious prosecution info in CHT to mostly Buddhist and Hindus please refer to prominent news agency, and do check out the population minority of CHT now
Ek 'sanki' (not literally, but kaise bhi bina soche samjhe)British lawmaker ne ye Partition karte samay Lines khiche jo aaj Borders bane hai. Aajakal rarely aisi jagah hai jaha British ne kuch kand na kiya ho.
What was indian government doing when India won 1971 war ??? Why didn't India settle this issue with Bangladesh that time ????.......... should have taken winning advantages ............this war could settle a lot of issues but indian government didn't take any initiative ........
@@AtulChakma that's is what I am saying ......Indira Gandhi should have helped chakma tribes .......India should have pressured Bangladesh to make Chittagong hill area as autonomous region or annexed to India that time or anything the people of hill area wants........but sorry you guys had to suffer a lot ..........hope your problems get solved and you guys can live a peaceful life with dignity , respect and certainty.....🙏🙏🙏
Am from arunachal Pradesh And folks it's not really about religion Remember arunachal people never had violence in the name of religion ever. But what we feel is that we are so less in population of only 15 lakhs and in that the largest tribe has only 1 lakh population which means by default chakma and hazong will be the 2nd largest group Remember we were Indians from the beginning and gave them so much support as refugees now u can't force us to give our land to them Either it may Muslims Christian or hindu
What is our main concern is that their population of 60000 would affect very much to our political system as they are the 2nd largest group in arunachal For example in 10-15 years they may be the largest group in arunachal now nyishi tribe being the largest tribe of only 1 lakhs and if this happens our CM ,MP etc will be from chakma and hazong people and we will be like a minority(in terms of tribe population coz arunachal is multi tribe state) in our own land and that's what really worries us
@@wanderingsoul504 Your concern is genuine but overrated.During Partition Punjab also absorbed much of the migrants from Pakistan.Some Parties try to create such scene .But with timely intervention of centre issues resolved in very fine manner. In case of Arunachal Pardesh,Parliament can extend 6th schedule protection to Arunachal Pardesh and for economic assistance ,Union govt should provide additional grants for a period of 20-30 years
@@jewelchakma2196 i support you in this matter...living in a place for 57 years..it is not possibel to relocate..and also arunachal donot have a large population that they are overpopulated...don't ever move anywhere...stay there and no one can remove you
Any Chakmas and Hajongs here???? Just answer some questions 1.Why didn’t you fight for your people and your homeland when you people were being chase out of your own country?? 2. You talk about human rights, fundamental rights?? What did you do when your people were being persecuted and killed in your country Bangladesh?? 3.Your people were given temporary shelters in Arunachal Pradesh didn’t you know you were just a refugees?? 4. Is it fair to people of Arunachal??? BECAUSE We never agreed to grant you APST STATUS 5. When you can’t even fight and demand for your basic fundamental and human rights from your own native country which is BANGLADESH Why expect it India?? 7. Some chakmas commenting about civil war and going to United nation Why not do it to live with dignity In your own country Bangladesh......... People of Arunachal are not against you being Indian,be our Indian brothers but we can’t share an inch of our land with you... we have been good to you,we have given you refuge when no one was ready to help you when your own people of BANGLADESH WERE killing and persecuting you... you should be thankful to the people of Arunachal Pradesh
Why some people in Arunachal Pradesh wants these people to be sent to Assam ??? We are already overpopulated and our land area is less than Arunachal Pradesh. Moreover we have no role in settlement of these people in Arunachal Pradesh, they were bought by central government under a definite plan. If they come to our state, where will we go? We don't have any constitutional protection unlike Arunachal Pradesh, its a free place, so it will become more vulnerable to us than it is for u in Arunachal Pradesh. Kindly solve ur issues yourselves and avoid looking for our limited resources
There is a huge Migration crisis in Northeast.. Which Central Government and Rest of India don't understand...so it's depend on every state how they handle the issues...if amit shah want to give citizenship to every outsiders than asked them to come to western states because we have limited resources in northeast
@@HimanshuShekhar7 there is reason to that.... We aren't prosperous as u guys, our resources r limited & instead of using it in our people, we will give it to the refugees? seriously?? They hv started encroaching lands & being from underdevelopd areas wat do u want those tribals to do, Who r solely dependent on their land for foods, should they jst let them keep on encroaching their lands & die??
Whole Assam is full of Bangladeshi people. They cross border and come to Assam. Govt should stop playing votebank game and get these people of of India. It's a serious problem. Make a video on this topic too sir.
@talk seek uh hello firstly, Delhi is our national capital. Secondly, the states you mentioned are Indian states which makes them Indian citizens. Finally, chakma hajong are not indian citizens. Peace out.
Uffffff. If you guys were indigenous people from Tripura then you guys could have understood what I am trying to convey. Like: what happened when in a state outsider has more population/influence than local.
I strongly support Arunachal residents demand. They showes loyalty during 1962 Chinese war and tortured chinese army. So they showed loyaloty towars India. They should not be disturbed for traitor people.
@@AtulChakma why ur king gone to Pakistan and why he enjoyed minister post till death 2012. Tridev Roy and Rana hamir of amarkot sindh is traitor to devide land and faithful to jinha during partition of India . King of amarkot. Google it.
@@hanumandehru3107 brother amarkot in Sindh and the Chittagong is in Bangladesh if you have knowledge but you don't have the knowledge with the right way amarkot is a princely state while Chittagong is not a princely state it is a part of Bengal British province and that time Chittagong Hill area came under the Chittagong district and that was Muslim majority
This is called empty vessel sounds much. Do u know how many chakma soldiers died in the indo Chinese war. More than 1500. PM asked help from the chakma king. Because of chakmas only present day u called arunchal Pradesh exist. If chakmas dint fight with the Chinese then it would have already captured by China.
This is what happens.... Chronology smjh rhe Phele wo aap se bachaane ki guhaar lgeyenge Uske baad apni population badhayenge Fir equal rights demand karenge Fir bolenge Hindustan hamara hi to h ....lol 😂 Bangladesh is free now .... Why not go their ?
@@lauvachakma3215 what. You want me to stay out of it. What the hell have you done to hindustan Rather than doing insurgencies, protests and blaming own country'. . Are most of you mad. Look. Indian always thinks of development and growth but you people are mad. One side you wish everything for free, ans on other hand, you claim to be the king. . Listen dear. Beggars can't be choosers. .
These tribal peoples are absolutely backward It's 21st century and they are still stuck in 12th century mindset... Fighting on tribe,village issues like pig, Buffaloes,Donkeys do it in Forest Like dogs urinate and capture that place, then ask others to not come here
@@sadhanjaychakma6077 sure we not gonna share with this chakma people from Bangladesh, what a shameless people is arunachal is their mother land go back ur mother land Bangladesh
For everyone saying that this is the fault of missionaries or any other religious group, read this: In north east, ethnicity matter WAY MORE than religion. That is why Hindu Ahoms protested against CAA as it could lead to settlement of Hindu Bengalis in the Brahmaputra valley, the heartland of Ahoms. And that is why Hindu Bengalis from Tripura protested against the settlement of Bru refugees in Tripura who are ALSO HINDU. Please EDUCATE YOUR IGNORANT MIND about the politics of the north east before commenting. North east is NOT northern India, where religion matter a lot.
@@JeetuKumarYadav-ow8jq 🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻. Sure man, whatever you believe you is true. I, a native of Arunachal, knows ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about the politics of my own state.
This is a critical situation when a country accept refugees. You know it's a emotional attachment to give shelter to the refugee thinking they have also human rights as they are badly abused in their own land. But when it comes to sharing resources it's difficult to accept they are now our citizen Some one has rightly said *Talwaar ka Dhaar Dono Taraf Hota hai.*
@@hanumandehru3107 as u are mentioning about Mizoram please remember that as Mizoram shares boundary with Bangladesh it is fortunate that same people lives on both sides of a country as can u relate sikh people living both in Pakistan and in india. And so you can't label all chakmas as refugees
@@hanumandehru3107 bhai do some research and comment please. Chakmas already have st/sc status in west bengal, assam, meghalaya, tripura and mizoram. And talking about the chakmas of mizoram, we already have autonomous district council. We are fighting for our rights as a fellow human beings not any other else.
After Indo China War 1962 , Chakmas were brought by Central Government to protect Border area from Chinese encroachers . Its been more than 57 year we have been living in Arunachal Pradesh . Now relocation is not possible , Chakmas did't came to India. They were brought by Indian Government and settled in NEFA .During Partition of India Chakmas demand to be part of India but due to lack of Indian politicians ,CHT Chakmas became part of Bangladesh .
Who said chakmas were brought to India?? It was due growing population of Muslim in Bangaldesh and when they are started killing Chakmas living in that area , so basically the chakmas has no place to except to run from their own land. Also it was not the decision of NEFA it was Assam government who distrbuted chakmas in both Megahalaya and Arunachal pradesh. Insteading of arguing you people should thank Arunachal pradesh people for taking your burden for more then 50 year. But since Bangladesh is secular country chakmas should go bacl there.
@@AtulChakma bro i have a seen all the related video about chakmas. Even in this video it said that due immense percicutation of chakmas in Bangladesh they had to leave the country.
@@aspirant5108 Actually there is faction of reality in @Atul Chakma claim. Chakma people handled reckless Muslim invasion in their region with militant activity.And because of their struggle their region is under special protection in Bangladesh. A good population of Chakma stil lives in Bangladesh
@@aspirant5108 In 1969 Pakistan government constructed a Hydro Power Dam without consent of Chakmas . In consequence Chakmas lost their land due to dam and flood . After that India government decided to invite them to settle in NEFA after 1962 indoChina war
If Delhi didn't ignored us during 1947,while our people were shouting out to be integral Part of India there would have been another beautiful state in india today that is CHT(Jumma Land)it would have been so important for india and a very strategic location of Economic development and Defense too. What a mistake, While other parts of Northeast India some tribes stood against India,and on the other hand Chakma's and Hajong were loyal and they were ignored, What a blunder History done by the politician on that time.
Hello Guruji Happy Teachers day. For your kind information: To be precise, there are more issues that is going on apart from socio economic and that is illegal encroachment of land, Burning of houses and agricultural fields of Indigenous tribal indians like Mishmi's in the Lohit district kathan area in the district border of Changlang and Lohit. They are so desperate now that they are trying to take support of banned outfits to suppress local people (as informed/stated by locals) who live with less population in the border. Last time they tried to make issues of religion when they started underway construction of stupa in disputed land while abandoning their existing stupa in their occupied area to capture larger areas. Personally I support to give citizenship of our country to them but they have to go from our State because their acts and intention is not good in the eyes of local indian tribal people ( who resided in India since time immemorial) Jai Hind Jai Bharat
These chaknahajongs must b thrown out of the country! Why don't u guys ask support from AAPSU and with the help of them throw them out together!? Seriously people from eastern Arunachal are sooo cowards yeah!
Church's role in this whole drama should be investigated first. They are getting too powerful these days. I am damn sure they have something to do with this entire episode.
Where the hell did Chruch came in? When Government was announcing that they will being NRC so that "illegal" Bangladeshi immigrants would be deported. But now when they are Deporting, you people are Crying 😭 They will not get persecuted in Bangladesh (cuz bangla is secular state) but Rohingyas will get, actually they will get slaughtered if they go back to Burma.
@@mihirsen7845 not true. Thats the case only when the issue is among them. But here hindus and Buddhists are involved. So I am 100% sure they have something to do in this issue. How can we forget some terror outfit in Tripura threatening Hindus to convert to Christianity? Church is very powerful there, so much that u can't even imagine.
Bitul vlogs , ur leader were traitor ur king devided our land and flavoured pak and then 1971 u favoured Pakistan and became traitor of bengladesh. U didn't oppose ur leader.
@KJM and as a result you can see ,Tripura which once land of indigenous people hve becomes minority in their own state. Also in Bengal you know who is in more population?? It is the People who living in their from before or is the Bangladeshi which have immigrated there?? Figure out then you will know.
Indian government should have bilateral talks with bangladesh govt to relocate them in their native land,chittagong hill tract.Dear chakma n hajong brothers and sisters,your forefathers ancient spirits are calling you back.apna jagah toh apna jagah hota hai,live with dignity there,die with dignity there.
Chakma people are the worst victims even after decades. Arunachal government must be ashamed of denying their citizenship rights. Supreme court should impose fine for denying their birth rights or its order. Jai Hind💝💝💝
@@chimchimadmirer7619 you are afraid of the Chakma because Chakma are more educated then you all.your narrow though think if Chakma will get citizenship within arunachal Pradesh they well get all the facilities that's the main reason you people are opposing but we have with supreme court don't worry we are getting very soon just wait n watch
@happy who are you to deliver the judgement? Are u making the mockery of our honourable Apex court? Do you think that our honourable supreme court is a comedy show platform? Don't you respect it and its verdict? If you consider yourself as true indian by mind and soul then try to learn how to respect our supreme court.
We the Chakmas and Hajongs are Law abiding citizens of India. And we are By Birth Citizens of India born in Arunachal Pradesh. Nobody is above the Law of the Land. We all the Chakmas and Hajongs abide by the Constitution of India. I appeal to all the people to support the Law abiding Chakmas and Hajongs Citizens of India. 90% of the Chakmas are Citizens By Birth under section (3) (1) (a) of the Citizenship Act of 1955 and others subsequent Provisions of the Act. We are Constitutionally Allowed to enjoy Our Rights By virtue of being Birth Citizens.
Bro ur forefathers were given shelters by Indian as refugees Do u realise how many countries don't even accept refugees into their country.see for example our neighborhood only like Bangladesh and mayanmar. It's not like India wants to sent u back to Bangladesh it's just we are relocating u elsewhere within India where Ur population of 60000 won't matter much but it does in state like arunachal where whole state population is only 15 lakhs so by default u will be the second largest group in arunachal first being the nyishi people of only 1 lakhs. Here u can very much affect our political system..who knows within 10-15 years Ur population might double and u elect Ur people as our CM,MP etc and that fucking worries us and nothing much personal bro
Common man what are speaking atleast speak in sense, by your own ideology Indian don't have the right to be a citizens of USA. Upgrade your knowledge Kiren Riju mister of law is from Arunachal Pradesh where the population is very less if we follow your concept all the ministry portfolio should be given to Uthar Pradesh and Bihar because they have lot's number of population. If someone has the quality to become a MLA or MP or other he can be. Choose quality not nepotism. And for your kind information more than Nishi tribe chakma tribe serve the nation as an ARMY OR other arm forces.
@China 32 gold India 1 gold let them take arms they will supressed by law and if you start a revolution blood shed has to be from both side and for your kind info if you are talking about arms I guess you don't belong to a nation where Gandhiji showed his ideology and vision.
And according to recent CAA act . It is not applicable to AP . So, you all say you are Indian so follow the law of land and go wherever you want .we just don't want you all
Bangladesh is now a free different country.Unlike 1965 there is elected government and Chittagong hill tracts is still there. Why don't you people go back to your native place??? Why you want to remain as refugees in other countries???
Do some research... You put only chakma point of view who came from Bangladesh and didn't mention or put a point for the indigenous people of the state. Bias AF. If tommorw Afghan refugees and tibetian claims the same... Sabko sar pe bethaoge kya. Bias
@Jeetu kumar Arunachal is different from other NE states,yaha church ka kuch political role nahi hota hai,hota toh 2019 mein BJP ka sarkaar nahi banta.Chakma n hajong se itna hi pyar hai toh apne state mein invite karo aur apna mitti ho toh kindly donate kardo,possible?
Brother u shouldn't say anything without knowing the ground reality... we Arunachalee Don't want any outsider to snatch our land. They are forming militias and capturing small areas with goons, where main indigenous people people are being displaced.. And my family is one of those forcefully displaced victim.. there are many other reasons... So... brother if u don't know the farrago of this issue and our concern.. u better shut ur mouth .. because u don't know the pain and feelings... of we indigenous people. We don't want any outsider whether they are from so called HINDU,CHRISTIANS, MUSLIMS, BUDDHIST,SIKH.. EYC ETC.. WE JUST DON'T WANT OUTSIDERS.
Don't think chakma and hajong aren't like by Arunachalee because they Buddhist and hindu this case is different and ur saying churches lol more then church we have mandirs( don't believe then come and see) in every link road so in Arunachal these churches , mandirs, or masjid don't have problem like your mainland stop spreading your hypocrisy no one is dare to hear it. And Arunachal govt giving u a option if u r that much humanism toward these refugees then please take them away instead of campaign against churches..
Kuch Sawal hamare mann me shanka paida karti hai... Ispe gaur kare.... 1. Every upright man feels for his land and people, respects and remembers it with utmost regard and fights to win it back. The Jews are the best examples. Our own Kashmiri pandits are other bright examples. But what kind of race is the Chakmas who we never hear talking about their motherland in Bangladesh in the chittagong hill tract. 2. Usually, people who are granted refuge remain grateful to the benefactor. The best examples are the Tibetans who had come even before the chakmas and have still not forgotten their motherland and are struggling to win it back. We never hear them forcing and intimidating the government to grant them citizenship or land rights. Just contrast the Tibetans with these chakmas. They are using propaganda at national and international level with help of outside organization to defame the country and use pressure tactics to bow down the government itself using the system of the country itself. 3. In Arunachal, the consent of the then illiterate and backward locals were never sought and the consequence of forceful assimilation was never pondered upon while settling them. The result now, their decadal population growth rate is more than twice the locals and they are being extremely belligerent and hateful towards the locals with illegal and anti social activities against the locals. Dhyaan rahe, what you are bringing home. Kahi aisa na ho ki woh apne Bharat varsh ke deshbhakt baccho ko hi nigal jaye. Inki lakshano par gaur kare orr samjhe inko apnaana kis had tak sahi hai. Kya aap ek badmash mehmaan ke liye apne ghar ke baccho ki hitt ko daao me rakhoge.....?
Yes you are right but the arunachal cheap mine people are disrespecting the supreme court order they are scare of us brother if they give citizenship to the Chakma they will get all the job facilities because Chakma are educated as a compare to other..Chakma are intellectual
Most of the Chakma are going to take admission like Assam ,megalaya , mizoram , and other states but within arunachal.we get discrimination for our education
Arunachal Pradesh is wholly a tribal State, which is protected under BEFR - 1873...... There are two Laws prevalent in the State....i.e Constitutional Law and Customary Law !!! How can REFUGEE expect to become aboriginal people of the Tribal land ??? ....... Refugees are not permanent residents of a place, State or a Nation !!! They are residing on someone else's land(s) for a specific period, or till the disputes of their actual lands are sorted out......BANGLADESH IS A FREE NATION NOW !!! They should thank the tribal people of the State (especially the tribes on whose lands they are living) for giving them shelter during their worst days, and should return to their ancestral lands !!! Besides, Supreme Court can persuade the State Governments for granting Citizenship to REFUGEES.....But can the court give direction to provide ST/PRC status to REFUGEES ??? Ofcourse not !!! Besides, being a protected State, even the people from other States of the nation are bound to procure ILP during their visit in the State (AP); what makes the Refugees to think that they should be provided with superior-dignity than the rest of Indians !??? Should be ashamed of their demand(s) !!! Even the United Nation (UN) has framed a DECLARATION (UNDRIP - United Nation Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People) to safeguard the traditional rights of tribal populace around the World !!! Refugees are not our (Tribal fraternity) responsibility ...... Government may give them citizenship according to their convenience, but not in the pristine Tribal State of Arunachal Pradesh......and hence, their deportation is much justified !!!
It's sad to see that these people of community is only bitching about our people and land. Trying to make villian out of everyone who has given them refuge(Mizoram/Tripura/assam).
Chakmas are by birth, descent etc citizenship of India according to constitution but due to discrimination of other tribes of Arunachal Pradesh till now rights less, no equal rights etc
Even Chakmas has outonomus council in mizoram and they are living in most of the part of northeast and all over India....but for arunachalee we got only arunachal Pradesh as our native place..therefore as a indigenous native of arunachal we are only protecting ourself from getting outnumbered....later leading to loss of culture and identity...thank you...jai hind..🇮🇳
Chakma and hazong were long refugees and it's good that they are getting citizenship but it doesn't mean they will get land right in Arunachal Pradesh. They aren't ST of Arunachal Pradesh, and they won't be getting ST status too. To be honest it's been a long fight for them. And this will be another long fight for them,if they want to settle in AP. so better leave and start afresh , were they could call the land their own. neither their forefather could enjoy the land right nor them but it's now upto them,what they want to give to their children.see, after the judgement of supreme court also citizenship process has not been processed. citizenship is very imp to be eligible for getting job.this fight will go on and children of these refugees will never see the dawn. so better to take wise step, to prevent children from this pit of darkness. otherwise, coming generation will also live the same life, like them.
Chakma and hojong population has grown very rapidly within very short time. There is resources shortage and local population is totally against them. So refugees can not demand what they want from the original inhabitants of land . People who feel injustice, please kindly settle these people in your state. We will be very grateful to you.
These tribal peoples are absolutely backward It's 21st century and they are still stuck in 12th century mindset... Fighting on tribe,village issues like pig, Buffaloes,Donkeys do it in Forest Like dogs urinate and capture that place, then ask others to not come here
@@gautamdada2979 you arunachal people are totally narrow mine greedy people become of you arunachal still undeveloped Always spread hatred towards Chakma ..
The union gov. should implement a new law to bombard refugess asking citizenship rather than shelter.... And it should be named "WISE ACT ". END of the debate... Thankyou🙏
I didn't understand what's the problem with some North eastern states. Don't they travel and live in other major cities like delhi, bengluru etc. They buy home ,land and work their, if people from every state think like that people form other states or of different ethnicity change our demography then we must relocate them. This is not how country works. India is a multi ethnic and culture country. We must not allow this kind of action/decision. In country every person must have rights to live where ever they want until there is some problem like environmental issue. These people has been living in Arunachal Pradesh for ver long time. I think govt. Should reject this plan.
@@aspirant5108 90% of them are now INDIAN by law of land & By our heritage. This is a politcal problem of regionalism where one faction feel threatens in addition of more voters.
Dude, India is a representative democracy. That is why Assam, a state smaller in land area than Arunachal has WAY more MPs in the Parliament than Arunachal. Chakmas are huge in numbers (compared to other tribes). And already man tribes aren't getting adequate representation in the State Assembly and the Parliament due the sheer number of ethnicities. If Chakma's are made domicile of Arunachal, they will dominate the state politics just due to their numbers.
Well said bro!👌 There's a shloka said by lord Rama in Ramayana after being asked and proposed by Laxmana to settle and stay permanently in the Golden Lanka, after that a beautifully replied by lord Rama "जननी जन्मभूमिश्च स्वर्गादपि गरीयसी ॥" Means, mother and motherland are greater than paradise. We decline and oppose non-violently as well as amicably such unacceptable plan, every citizen won't be ready to be relocated from his homeland, especially who has been staying for many decades. Let us oppose by showing our " Unity in Diversity" being with our brothers and sisters of Chakma and Hajong. Jai Hind🇮🇳
Thank you brother for making this video. Let others get lesson how chakmas has been getting discriminated every day and night deprived from basic human rights because of some uneducated and selfish people in the state.
Exactly bro! Chakmas have been discriminated in various fronts,be it education, fundamental rights, basic amenities and health care facilities..we are living this life with no future.Thank u Anirudh sir for your video clip.i rigorously follow you and your channel and your channel helped me alot to make myself a sincere citizen of this beautiful country.🙏
They are our people and we must feel pain for them, they are in their own country, the land of their ancestors, Government of India shall make appropriate arrangements to give the safe and stable life. My personal belief is that our Northeastern family has tremendous capabilities, if provided with adequate opportunities they can add wings to the flight of this nation on the trajectory of progress and prosperity
Bhai woh log refugee tah..GOI citizenship bhi diya parr ab ST status, PRC demand karr raha hai.Jahan jagah diya wohi ka indigenous ko damki dene laga hai o Bangladeshi miya ki tarah itna human produce karr raha hai..Aap google mein unlogo ka population increase percentage dekho...Sab patah chal jayega. Miya jo ya Chakma o Hajong..Religion alag hai parr kandh karna Barabar.
The entire episode of today's chakmas and hajong crisis in AP is due to political blunder made in 1946-47 by unjust award of cht to the then East pakistan violating boundary commission. Again, the issue had been lingering for over 57 years of living in AP now due to the dark side of democracy where "majority wins and minority is suppress". Tell me, on what ground an union law minister can uproot an entire community from their native land without their consent? Isn't this ethnic cleansing? Chakmas n hajongs are lawful citizen of india as recognised by the constitution of india where it clearly stated that under article 5 sec 3 of acquisition of indian citizenship: 1."A person born in india on or after 26july 1950 but before 1st july 1987, is citizen of india by birth, irrespective of nationality of his parents." 2. A person born in india on or after 1st july 1987 but before 3rd december 2004, is considered citizen of india by birth if either of his parents is a citizen of india at the time of his birth....n so on Now, has any one of you witnessed so far in independent india that any law or union minister did uproot an entire community(citizen by birth) because of their ethnicity violating the rule of law?? And If any such minister is ensuring his public in his independence speech of doing such for the very first time in free india then one can see the level of exploitation grossly made by the public n the incumbent govt itself. The so called indegenious people do not want to accept chakmas n hajongs on the flimsy ground that AP is protected by BEFR-1873 which restrict the non arunachalee to enter AP without inner line permit(ILP) and also restrict buying of land(ownership) to non arunachalee. These two things are protected under BEFR-1873 which is centuries old regulation now imposed by british. As per as i know, BEFR-1873 was imposed to other places as well in northeast (including jummaland CHT) like sivsagar, nawgong(nagaon), kamrup, AP, etc mainly for few reasons as follows 1. To safeguard the unique traditions of the hill people by not allowing the people from advanced societies from mainland india to mix with them. 2. to safeguard the tribal land which would otherwise have acquired by advanced societies by duping the tribals 3. To protect the timbers and other forest products * If the BEFR-1873 is scrapped for district of assam then it is clear that it is scrapable if require My interpretation now: 1. BEFR-1873 was enacted to safeguard the tribals and not only ap. chakmas were also tribals protected under BEFR-1873 2. So if govt had decided to settle the chakmas in AP relaxing BEFR-1873 (bcoz chakmas were also protected under befr) and rehabilitated there since over 57 years now where many chakmas had been born and died, is it at all possible to uproot them? Thats why i call it political gimmick and entertained for vested interest. Sometimes i wonder thinking that when people are striving to become ias, ips, mla, minister, etc we are still striving tooth n nail to get the basic right leading to a whopping gap in between ours n other societies. Please do not support relocation n appeal the central govt to solve our issue once and for all " because we wish to live n wish to flourish after consistent suffering for over 57 years
So according to you a person from Bihar up Kerala also allow to buy land in Arunachal Pradesh? Chakma and hajong came as a refugees Arunachal government gave shelter now they are Indian citizens so if they want to stay in Arunachal Pradesh then they must have inner line permit like other non Arunachali since chakma and hajong is not from Arunachali,, according to articles 371 you are not allowed to have land in Arunachal Pradesh like others non Arunachali,,simple as that
Government of India must honour the Judgment of Supreme court of India and INDRA-MUJIB PACT of 1972. But keeping the interest of Arunachal Tribe from demographic dilutions. The GOI must address either of this two points:- 1. Chakma and Hajong along with other Refugees like Tibetan should be given separate UNION administration status. OR 2. Should collect proper data and grant them for Citizenship aonly those who are found came before 1971 but other than these register for Citizenship, CHIN HILL Regulations 1896 and BENGALI EASTERN FRONTIER REGULATIONS 1873 should be strictly observe. Of course relocate and resettlement is out of QUESTIONS, to solve one problem can't create another like it happens with the BRU REFUGEE from Mizoram.
Arunachal won't be breeding ground for refugees. they say they r born in A.P so they should get citizenship,so then i guess the non tribal born there should also be given citizenship,an American borning there should be given citizenship? I knew it just like the chakmas in tripura has demanded chakmaland,in A.P they r using this kind of tactic.i guess all the Myanmar refugees residing in Eastern side also given citizenship? bullshit.
Major point to think is that now after many years and liberation of Bangladesh, and things settled cooled why dont the Bangladesh govt Hesitant to take back its citizens.
Mr aggarwal, ur video is one sided. You haven't shown any sentiments of arunachal Pradesh. Without knowing any actual ground reality, you can't just make any video. Sitting in ur home, reading articles/news, please stop throwing knowledge on such sensitive issue. Our state is a tribal state, chakma and hajongs can have home anywhere, they have international diaspora. We arunachalee have only arunachal as our only home where we live with our culture, we are discriminated across india, just by our looks. Our state is protected by BEFR act 1873. Chakma and hajongs population have exploded rapidly, in no time they can cover our tribal indigenous population. We don't want to be other tripura, sikkim, or (some parts of) assam where there original indigenous population becomes minority. Where were you when Arunachalee's where protesting since ages. They were brought without our knowledge, we didn't have any representative from our land. We will protect our home at all cost, even if it means blood, because this is our only home. Hindu and Buddhist have home all over India, but Arunachalee have only arunachal where we can live peacefully.
One thing you missed to say that they were temporarily allowed to stay in arunachal pradesh by former prime minister and thats why the citizenship was not granted during that time also. Please don't provide half truth to your viewers it is a very sensitive topic for both side of the people of that state.
@@dolamoja4908 don't worry we will relocate you anyhow by the rule of law or by force and this disgusting vomited brain will enjoy if it is done by forced.
@@jellysonamnlg9023 through your sentence your ancestors aggressiveness can be seen.... Lol and you talk about peace.... 😂😂😂 Let's see how you relocate us!
And by through your sentences it seems your ancestors were coward and shameless who abandoned their land and arrived as guest in our home and now claiming like you are the owner no wonder why I will personally enjoy if there will be .....
@@jellysonamnlg9023 let's see who are cowards... You are behaving as if your ancestors have popped up like a mushroom from the land of Arunachal Pradesh... Lol all human were nomads.... Study bro😂😂😂
CAA to bohat pehle se laagu ho chuka h... Inko citizenship kyuñ nhi mili abhi tk? Ye 1960s se reh rhe h itne m to inko mil jaani chahiye thi bina CAA k hi... Kyuñki inhone 14 saal se zyada ka wqt yha spend kr liya h
@@Arman12371 what I mean is to be implemented properly, I think it started in Dec 2019/ Jan 2020🤔, but yes it should be questioned why there are still people not on the list.
Absolutely sir CAA also should required in Arunachal theirs mindset is now out of damn....Arunachal tribe ko bahut gaman ho gaya....inner line permit ko bhi hatna chaye...then they will learn some new lesson!
Act of deporting the refugees from Bangladesh to Intensely sensitive protected tribal land if eastern himalaya then NEFA now Arunachal was in itself an utter attrocitious and blunderous act. Instead of protection from outer interference, they injected war refugees into the sensitive land. Govt must take responsibility, now as situations have cooled, deport them back to their homeland or give them refuge in the New Delhi Nayional Capital central Govt Territory.
Let u not accept. That is what we asking from the Centre now, leave chakma inhabitants area so that centre can grant us into union Territory moreover u people have been eating us from the past half century only. U don't study well because u have all the tiger share resources hence education was not required for u all.
Lagbhag 1 crore Nepali bhutiya Tibetan log Bharat mein rehte Hain to 60000 chakma hajong Bharat mein kyon nahin rah sakte Bangladesh Chittagong to Bharat ka hi hissa tha yah jimmedari Bharat ki hai 🙏🙏🙏
Bcz nepali, bhutiya are not demanding for ST in arunachal pradesh..... Reh sakte ho ap... But kisi ka ghr m betke .... Malik ka ghr ko hi lene se kaha hoga.... Nepali lok mehen ki tara rehte h... Naki apki tara dusre k ghr ko mangte h
Chakma in Arunachal Pradesh are Like Miya In Assam having same characteristics. Firstly, They belong to Bangladesh. Secondly, Don't have control over population growth, Thirdly illegal land encroachment of Indigenous people and lastly threat to entire state
This issue has been created by the central govt.. Allowing immigration, settlement of refugee, providing citizenship.. Now they want separate union territory.. Who and how gonna central and state fulfill their demand
60000 of them is just according to the papers, their population is more than 2L by now for sure. 1 mom +1 Dad = maximum kids possible is their family policy. Apart from socio-economic reasons, the rising criminal activities and insurgencies by this group is a matter or grave concern for us.. Whatever card they are playing and excelling in it but in reality the local population are the real victims
If we swift 60k tribes from Arunachal then the low population this East Himalayan region which have roughly 6-8 mil population cause of dehabitization The Chinese claim on Arunachal as South Tibet will be in future more more more agressive and maybe china attack there...we are indians we have to united and patriotic to nation 🇮🇳❤️ neither foreign powers which are always ready to Divide ➗ India as 1947
After 1962 IndiChina war Chakma were settled in Arunachal and they were given arm traning and gun licence to fight against Chiniese . Indian Government know that Chakmas always have been loyal for India .
@@suppotchakma868 Bhai, I just wanted to say that the chakma community from Arunachal Pradesh so where do we take them to live...And Arunachal Pradesh is not such Uttar Pradesh...to swift chakmas from here the population will decline... although the birthrate in Arunachal is not so good... Fighting together we are clearing path of our enemies... China 🇨🇳 china is the greatest Grand threat for Arunachal...they building 🚅 roots near our border, building 🏢🏫 colonies just before our border...Come unite and say with one tune...Jay Hind Jay Bharat Mata You know How china became superior? Unity and Integrity. Unless we become extreme nationalist we can't fight with China . It is clear, To make India superpower we have to unite have to Integrate To protect Arunachal, for those frontier indians we have to make sure their condition is good, if not so we must prepare the infrastructure there... Good well designed indian armours to resist dushmans Whenever I see my country replace china The glorious motto then shine with more intensity than sun and our triranga waves in that morning
Thank u sir for urs kind information about chakmas and hajong but sir Chakmas and hajong will not accepted to this Rascial proposal in any mean so however in Arunachal most of tribe didn't have humanity they only created communal,Rascium and descriminating even in mindland Indian people's ...so in lastly love from chakmas and hajong community,one more subscriber to urs channel!
Hahaha... What a joke!!! We Arunachalee rescued you guys from persecution by giving temporary settlement & now you call us inhumane. Shame on you guys! Bhalai ka zamana hee na raha.
Jab chattagong hills se gand marwa k bhaag aya tha tb tum logo ko roti kapra makan dya or ab hm log racist h or hm mai humanity nhi h. Tm chakma hajong ka na yahi problem h jis thali pe khata h usse mai thukta h Tum logo ko relocate nhi balki gadda khod k zinda jala dena chahiye
@Gom agong look who is talking? Jis taali pe Kaya whi pe cheda! Go back to chitagong hills! If u really think we are racial, inhumane.. Why don't u just leave our state and return back to ur own homeland lol!
Sir bas religious persecution k wajah se nahi.. Ye log 1960s tak apne bangladesh k settlement me India ka flag hoist krte the.. Aur pakistaniyo ne inke area ka dam kholdiya tha jiske wajah se inke gao flooded hogye the..
The whole mission and idea of the Indian government first prime Minister Jawahar lal Nehru Ji and verrier elwin a tribal anthropologist, was to let this NEFA (arunachal) region be protected from any interference and let them grow according to their own indegenious ways and own pace of intelligence as it was a tribal place, only medical, efucation, some few administrative supplies where to be provided and protected from any external interference from the country via, british Beft policies and special land rights. This act of deporting Chakma back then was itself a very offensive act it was a very unjust decision to deport the refugees into a sensitive protected tribal land. The central govt mistake was made then, and now the act of asking for citizenship is totally blasphemy. This act of India n govt. will be an act of immense attrocity against the tribal people of Arunachal and it will cause bitterness and cite untowards feeling againdt the govt in the sensitive area bordering china. To avert such situation the govt can justfully take decision of those temporary refugees hold talks with the Bangladesh Govt as the situation is better their now and deport them back to their homeland or they can deport them to the National Capital Region which will be justified, but encroachment of indegenious tribal territories is utterly unjustified and the govt must take step to protect the tribal land.
great 👍 outsider is always outsider...then only a stable state or nation build, settle them on mizoram border of assam where Bangladeshi are now settled illegally by assam.
@@ishikinokami1575 huu so they have to send to nepal..if they merge them then good...if not then send them back to their nation from where they come...hindu or Muslims is not issue is they are outsider mean outsider...
Chakma-Hajongs have been sheltered in Arunachal Pradesh for more than 50 years. Since Arunachal Pradesh is a protected land by constitution of India by various laws and regulations like BEFR 1873 so settling them in our land is illegal. They are foreigners, they are diluting of local population and creating danger to the lives and property of indigenous people. I appeal the Government of India to please send them back to Bangladesh otherwise there is a making of another Assam/Tripura like situation.
I want to state here one very true fact.
May be Hard to hear but very true!
The burden of Hindu-muslim and other religions migrant mostly bearing By North-east only.. other state GOV or people literally want to implement CAA or any migrant citizenship act but don't want to give them shelter,
Only North-eastrn knows how demographic changed by these migrant, now it constantly becoming huge threat for indigenous people of North-east.
I recommend you to study Tripura history and how there demographic got change after 1965 migrations.. u will understand it clearly!👍
So true😢
ST quota should be remove from North east. Let see how you behave in India.
@@subinoysbc you should be ashamed of saying this..,. Who are you to say this....
@@subinoysbc jaaa na bangali
Ur right, thanks for the words👍
Why they are deporting to other state instead of their native place of chattogram . Chattogram is their ancestral homeland. First of all why chattogram was given to bangladesh first .It was buddhist ,hindu ,tribal majority land.
During Partition CHT was trade off by politicians with secret negotiation in exchange of some Firozpur of Punjab .
@@AtulChakma I haven't read about such negotiation anywhere .But anyhow chakma and other native tribes of chattogram hill tracts should be relocated in their native ancestral land of chattogram .Everyone has right to live in their native land and follow their indigenous culture and language .
As far as negotiation is concerned if it was happened it carry no meaning as it was decided by bunch of some british educated brown english people like gandhi ,nehru ,jinnah .They are big fool and idiot .Had they ever been to chattogram how they could decide fates of native tribes from delhi ? Negotiatons and drawing line was totally null and void.
@@sourabhkumar-ie2hm yes brother there was negotiation, and our core leaders weren't able not meet PM P. J Nehru, they waited and waited, ignored due to minority, but finally in 1964-1969,
For any religious prosecution info in CHT to mostly Buddhist and Hindus please refer to prominent news agency, and do check out the population minority of CHT now
@@sourabhkumar-ie2hm Exactly... They should raise voice for their native land instead of fighting with innocent Arunachalee
Ek 'sanki' (not literally, but kaise bhi bina soche samjhe)British lawmaker ne ye Partition karte samay Lines khiche jo aaj Borders bane hai.
Aajakal rarely aisi jagah hai jaha British ne kuch kand na kiya ho.
What was indian government doing when India won 1971 war ??? Why didn't India settle this issue with Bangladesh that time ????.......... should have taken winning advantages ............this war could settle a lot of issues but indian government didn't take any initiative ........
Same dought
Happiness of defeating pakistan again was more in mind those days
Sir, Sneha Kumar Chakma attempted till his last breath but didn't get support or attention from Indra Gandhi ji and others politicians
Kongress vis similar to Britishers and leave some for next time disputes.
@@AtulChakma that's is what I am saying ......Indira Gandhi should have helped chakma tribes .......India should have pressured Bangladesh to make Chittagong hill area as autonomous region or annexed to India that time or anything the people of hill area wants........but sorry you guys had to suffer a lot ..........hope your problems get solved and you guys can live a peaceful life with dignity , respect and certainty.....🙏🙏🙏
Am from arunachal Pradesh
And folks it's not really about religion
Remember arunachal people never had violence in the name of religion ever.
But what we feel is that we are so less in population of only 15 lakhs and in that the largest tribe has only 1 lakh population which means by default chakma and hazong will be the 2nd largest group
Remember we were Indians from the beginning and gave them so much support as refugees now u can't force us to give our land to them
Either it may Muslims Christian or hindu
I support you yar... 💪
What is our main concern is that their population of 60000 would affect very much to our political system as they are the 2nd largest group in arunachal
For example in 10-15 years they may be the largest group in arunachal now nyishi tribe being the largest tribe of only 1 lakhs and if this happens our CM ,MP etc will be from chakma and hazong people and we will be like a minority(in terms of tribe population coz arunachal is multi tribe state) in our own land and that's what really worries us
@@meaayushdogra thanks mate
@@wanderingsoul504 Your concern is genuine but overrated.During Partition Punjab also absorbed much of the migrants from Pakistan.Some Parties try to create such scene .But with timely intervention of centre issues resolved in very fine manner.
In case of Arunachal Pardesh,Parliament can extend 6th schedule protection to Arunachal Pardesh and for economic assistance ,Union govt should provide additional grants for a period of 20-30 years
@@jewelchakma2196 i support you in this matter...living in a place for 57 years..it is not possibel to relocate..and also arunachal donot have a large population that they are overpopulated...don't ever move anywhere...stay there and no one can remove you
Any Chakmas and Hajongs here????
Just answer some questions
1.Why didn’t you fight for your people and your homeland when you people were being chase out of your own country??
2. You talk about human rights, fundamental rights?? What did you do when your people were being persecuted and killed in your country Bangladesh??
3.Your people were given temporary shelters in Arunachal Pradesh didn’t you know you were just a refugees??
4. Is it fair to people of Arunachal??? BECAUSE We never agreed to grant you APST STATUS
5. When you can’t even fight and demand for your basic fundamental and human rights from your own native country which is BANGLADESH Why expect it India??
7. Some chakmas commenting about civil war and going to United nation Why not do it to live with dignity In your own country Bangladesh.........
People of Arunachal are not against you being Indian,be our Indian brothers but we can’t share an inch of our land with you... we have been good to you,we have given you refuge when no one was ready to help you when your own people of BANGLADESH WERE killing and persecuting you... you should be thankful to the people of Arunachal Pradesh
True. Tibetans r better than them, they know their refugee status and have not yet demanded unnecessary things.
Chakmas have land grabbing nature that's why de r not moving out from Arunachal..
Chakma are non Arunachalee 😅
If chakmas are getting equal rights with the indigenous people of Arunachal and even the Tibetans and Nepalis of Arunachal should get equal rights. 😂
ARUNACHAL is never going to accept Chakma and Hajong as Arunachali...they may get the Indian citizenship but not in Arunachal.
Why some people in Arunachal Pradesh wants these people to be sent to Assam ??? We are already overpopulated and our land area is less than Arunachal Pradesh. Moreover we have no role in settlement of these people in Arunachal Pradesh, they were bought by central government under a definite plan. If they come to our state, where will we go? We don't have any constitutional protection unlike Arunachal Pradesh, its a free place, so it will become more vulnerable to us than it is for u in Arunachal Pradesh. Kindly solve ur issues yourselves and avoid looking for our limited resources
Some vacant areas shall be filled with Bangla Muslims soon as per constant influx in Assam. Chakmas shall be better than them...
There is a huge Migration crisis in Northeast.. Which Central Government and Rest of India don't understand...so it's depend on every state how they handle the issues...if amit shah want to give citizenship to every outsiders than asked them to come to western states because we have limited resources in northeast
Hold my beer : Panjab , West Bengal.
Agree brother
Assam has always given space but these tribal states in NE, they get insecure by a sneez of a non tribal.
Totally agreee....
@@HimanshuShekhar7 there is reason to that.... We aren't prosperous as u guys, our resources r limited & instead of using it in our people, we will give it to the refugees? seriously?? They hv started encroaching lands & being from underdevelopd areas wat do u want those tribals to do, Who r solely dependent on their land for foods, should they jst let them keep on encroaching their lands & die??
We are support chakma hajong❤❤❤❤❤chakma peoples
Whole Assam is full of Bangladeshi people. They cross border and come to Assam. Govt should stop playing votebank game and get these people of of India. It's a serious problem.
Make a video on this topic too sir.
10 lac + indian working on in Bangladesh .
@@error7329 learn to differentiate between legal and illegal.
@@Mr.kalita01 Other states will never understand the refugee issue faced by us NE people,They will just think oh! hindu aur buddhist hai,rehne doh.
@@krutoiuchiha8942 fukk of maharastra ka naam suna hai pooora ind milega yaha
@talk seek uh hello firstly, Delhi is our national capital. Secondly, the states you mentioned are Indian states which makes them Indian citizens. Finally, chakma hajong are not indian citizens. Peace out.
I feel sad for them seriously I do but when I see the Tripura situation, I changed my mind.
What the fuck are you talking about Tripura???
@@Voice_of_My_wife yes, the FUCK!! FOOK!! FAAK!!
What happen in Tripura, say?
Tripura situation is perfect. And FYI I am from Tripura.
Uffffff. If you guys were indigenous people from Tripura then you guys could have understood what I am trying to convey.
Like: what happened when in a state outsider has more population/influence than local.
I strongly support Arunachal residents demand. They showes loyalty during 1962 Chinese war and tortured chinese army. So they showed loyaloty towars India. They should not be disturbed for traitor people.
Commenting without having proper knowledge , Chakmas became traitor for Pakistan because they supported India . Chakma always been loyal for India .
@@AtulChakma why ur king gone to Pakistan and why he enjoyed minister post till death 2012. Tridev Roy and Rana hamir of amarkot sindh is traitor to devide land and faithful to jinha during partition of India . King of amarkot. Google it.
@@AtulChakma you are right. WE are with you.
@@hanumandehru3107 brother amarkot in Sindh and the Chittagong is in Bangladesh if you have knowledge but you don't have the knowledge with the right way amarkot is a princely state while Chittagong is not a princely state it is a part of Bengal British province and that time Chittagong Hill area came under the Chittagong district and that was Muslim majority
This is called empty vessel sounds much. Do u know how many chakma soldiers died in the indo Chinese war. More than 1500. PM asked help from the chakma king. Because of chakmas only present day u called arunchal Pradesh exist. If chakmas dint fight with the Chinese then it would have already captured by China.
Why don't softy GOI take Chittagong back, it was already disputed during partition of Bengal.
This is what happens.... Chronology smjh rhe
Phele wo aap se bachaane ki guhaar lgeyenge
Uske baad apni population badhayenge
Fir equal rights demand karenge
Fir bolenge Hindustan hamara hi to h ....lol 😂
Bangladesh is free now .... Why not go their ?
Exactly 👍
Sahi hai bhai.
Indigenous tribals indians ARUNACHALEE people will never accept them (Bangladeshis refugees).
Le afghan Now:- Please accept us as refugees.
After 5 years :- We need our human rights + homes + voting rights + equal resources.
.
It's about to be 60yrs... Not 5 or 10yrs... So stay out of it ,if you do not know the reality
@@lauvachakma3215 bro honestly leave our land with regard and say thanks to all arunachal pradesh and all indigenous tribes people.
@@lauvachakma3215 what. You want me to stay out of it.
What the hell have you done to hindustan Rather than doing insurgencies, protests and blaming own country'.
.
Are most of you mad.
Look. Indian always thinks of development and growth but you people are mad.
One side you wish everything for free, ans on other hand, you claim to be the king.
.
Listen dear.
Beggars can't be choosers.
.
@@SuniL.KrishnA Well said
Bilkul sahi kaha apne
We will not going to be tolerate outsider who dillute our culture. Whatever step should needed we will take.
Take the step and move on
These tribal peoples are absolutely backward
It's 21st century and they are still stuck in 12th century mindset...
Fighting on tribe,village issues like pig, Buffaloes,Donkeys do it in Forest
Like dogs urinate and capture that place, then ask others to not come here
@@sadhanjaychakma6077 sure we not gonna share with this chakma people from Bangladesh, what a shameless people is arunachal is their mother land go back ur mother land Bangladesh
Just proves what a weak culture you have
For everyone saying that this is the fault of missionaries or any other religious group, read this:
In north east, ethnicity matter WAY MORE than religion. That is why Hindu Ahoms protested against CAA as it could lead to settlement of Hindu Bengalis in the Brahmaputra valley, the heartland of Ahoms. And that is why Hindu Bengalis from Tripura protested against the settlement of Bru refugees in Tripura who are ALSO HINDU. Please EDUCATE YOUR IGNORANT MIND about the politics of the north east before commenting. North east is NOT northern India, where religion matter a lot.
Very true brother
Actually we never get to know ground situation of these states so its very unknown for us to get such facts
Why north east is becoming christian so rapidly? Church is responsible for this problem
@@JeetuKumarYadav-ow8jq 🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻.
Sure man, whatever you believe you is true. I, a native of Arunachal, knows ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about the politics of my own state.
@@createyourself8825 well I am glad I could shed a little bit of light 👍🏻
@@riichobamin7612 right bro light is dim but it is not out
This is a critical situation when a country accept refugees.
You know it's a emotional attachment to give shelter to the refugee thinking they have also human rights as they are badly abused in their own land.
But when it comes to sharing resources it's difficult to accept they are now our citizen
Some one has rightly said *Talwaar ka Dhaar Dono Taraf Hota hai.*
Refugee can't demand and have choice. And no reservation like sc/st. They also demanding st in Mizoram in neet mbbs seat.
I am haryanavi but don't favour unjustified things.
@@hanumandehru3107 as u are mentioning about Mizoram please remember that as Mizoram shares boundary with Bangladesh it is fortunate that same people lives on both sides of a country as can u relate sikh people living both in Pakistan and in india. And so you can't label all chakmas as refugees
@@hanumandehru3107 bhai do some research and comment please. Chakmas already have st/sc status in west bengal, assam, meghalaya, tripura and mizoram. And talking about the chakmas of mizoram, we already have autonomous district council. We are fighting for our rights as a fellow human beings not any other else.
@@rakeshchakma2261 Then go fight there brother ,but not in Arunachal Pradesh .let us live peacefully .
Church n Christian missionaries.. have a great role behind this
This is Northeast Not UP, Bihar,MP. In Northeast people fight for culture & identity rather than religion.
@@tva449 ya in Mizoram how missionaries are fooling indigenous mizo people. And now they are active in Punjab. Crypto Christian
@@tva449 and you are a Christian
@@mayur96nagori how kindly explain.
@@ramsengar1761 hahaha haha 😂 ek number
After Indo China War 1962 , Chakmas were brought by Central Government to protect Border area from Chinese encroachers . Its been more than 57 year we have been living in Arunachal Pradesh . Now relocation is not possible ,
Chakmas did't came to India. They were brought by Indian Government and settled in NEFA .During Partition of India Chakmas demand to be part of India but due to lack of Indian politicians ,CHT Chakmas became part of Bangladesh .
Who said chakmas were brought to India??
It was due growing population of Muslim in Bangaldesh and when they are started killing Chakmas living in that area , so basically the chakmas has no place to except to run from their own land.
Also it was not the decision of NEFA it was Assam government who distrbuted chakmas in both Megahalaya and Arunachal pradesh.
Insteading of arguing you people should thank Arunachal pradesh people for taking your burden for more then 50 year.
But since Bangladesh is secular country chakmas should go bacl there.
@@aspirant5108 Sir please read History ,
Reference book " Chakma Refugee" By Aditya Prakash .
@@AtulChakma bro i have a seen all the related video about chakmas.
Even in this video it said that due immense percicutation of chakmas in Bangladesh they had to leave the country.
@@aspirant5108 Actually there is faction of reality in @Atul Chakma claim.
Chakma people handled reckless Muslim invasion in their region with militant activity.And because of their struggle their region is under special protection in Bangladesh.
A good population of Chakma stil lives in Bangladesh
@@aspirant5108 In 1969 Pakistan government constructed a Hydro Power Dam without consent of Chakmas . In consequence Chakmas lost their land due to dam and flood . After that India government decided to invite them to settle in NEFA after 1962 indoChina war
If Delhi didn't ignored us during 1947,while our people were shouting out to be integral Part of India there would have been another beautiful state in india today that is CHT(Jumma Land)it would have been so important for india and a very strategic location of Economic development and Defense too. What a mistake, While other parts of Northeast India some tribes stood against India,and on the other hand Chakma's and Hajong were loyal and they were ignored, What a blunder History done by the politician on that time.
bro where chakma hajongs came at 1964 not in 1947 so your whole statement is a lie
@@blockykid3792 yu are itself a lie, bcz you don't want to accept the fact
@@binoylarma5630 ur fact wrong 👎🏻
India independence in 1947 and u think Delhi resolved ur problem 😂
@@blockykid3792 bro whole thing started at partition in 1947 when we lifted indian flag in Chittagong hill tracts for 3 days
Thank you sir for highlighting our issue in your channel.
Nice Explanation. U r one of my fav teacher.....
Thanks a lots Sir for the video... You made it Cristal clear... Hat off you... Plz make more videos related to our cause..
All chakmas and hazong are our brothers and sisters.
But arunachalii peoples don't think
You are right we are brother and sister but some narrow mine people they don't understand
But they are Sucking out
Our resources, which only belongs to real arunachalle
@@suppotchakma868 my friend rise yur voice in Social media we support u.
No they are Bangladeshi
And most of Bengali hindus from bangladesh settled in tripura
100% correct
Yes come and visit tripura u Will see lots of Bangladeshi roming like local people
Hello Guruji Happy Teachers day.
For your kind information:
To be precise, there are more issues that is going on apart from socio economic and that is illegal encroachment of land, Burning of houses and agricultural fields of Indigenous tribal indians like Mishmi's in the Lohit district kathan area in the district border of Changlang and Lohit. They are so desperate now that they are trying to take support of banned outfits to suppress local people (as informed/stated by locals) who live with less population in the border.
Last time they tried to make issues of religion when they started underway construction of stupa in disputed land while abandoning their existing stupa in their occupied area to capture larger areas.
Personally I support to give citizenship of our country to them but they have to go from our State because their acts and intention is not good in the eyes of local indian tribal people ( who resided in India since time immemorial)
Jai Hind Jai Bharat
These chaknahajongs must b thrown out of the country!
Why don't u guys ask support from AAPSU and with the help of them throw them out together!?
Seriously people from eastern Arunachal are sooo cowards yeah!
Church's role in this whole drama should be investigated first. They are getting too powerful these days. I am damn sure they have something to do with this entire episode.
Most of the people in North East value their ethnic and tribal identity more than anything else.
Where the hell did Chruch came in?
When Government was announcing that they will being NRC so that "illegal" Bangladeshi immigrants would be deported.
But now when they are Deporting, you people are Crying 😭
They will not get persecuted in Bangladesh (cuz bangla is secular state) but Rohingyas will get, actually they will get slaughtered if they go back to Burma.
@@mihirsen7845 FACT!
@@mihirsen7845 not true. Thats the case only when the issue is among them. But here hindus and Buddhists are involved. So I am 100% sure they have something to do in this issue. How can we forget some terror outfit in Tripura threatening Hindus to convert to Christianity? Church is very powerful there, so much that u can't even imagine.
@@crazyshorts4278 ugh CAA protects Buddhists which the chakmas are
We the chakma are discriminated because of our religion as Buddhism
Bitul vlogs , ur leader were traitor ur king devided our land and flavoured pak and then 1971 u favoured Pakistan and became traitor of bengladesh. U didn't oppose ur leader.
@@hanumandehru3107 he saved our tribes from genocide while supporting Pakistan
Bitul vlogs , don't play victim card. Go in history. U r citizens of pakistan.and loyal to Pakistan.
@KJM well they were pakistani brother.
@KJM and as a result you can see ,Tripura which once land of indigenous people hve becomes minority in their own state.
Also in Bengal you know who is in more population?? It is the People who living in their from before or is the Bangladeshi which have immigrated there?? Figure out then you will know.
Indian government should have bilateral talks with bangladesh govt to relocate them in their native land,chittagong hill tract.Dear chakma n hajong brothers and sisters,your forefathers ancient spirits are calling you back.apna jagah toh apna jagah hota hai,live with dignity there,die with dignity there.
@Alfred Rose Their PM is ready to take them in. But they're not ready to go.
@Alfred Rose they fought but you think they can win with a proper bangladeshi army 😠😠😠😠😠
Thank you Anirudh Sir for discussing this serious issues🙏🙏🙏
Thank you for the correct information
Chakma people are the worst victims even after decades. Arunachal government must be ashamed of denying their citizenship rights. Supreme court should impose fine for denying their birth rights or its order. Jai Hind💝💝💝
Government is for the people.. And we Arunachalee(mandated Arunachal govt.)don't want situation like Lebanon. So better be a mute spectator.
@@chimchimadmirer7619 what's wrong with chakma ? Are they killing you?
@@chimchimadmirer7619 you are afraid of the Chakma because Chakma are more educated then you all.your narrow though think if Chakma will get citizenship within arunachal Pradesh they well get all the facilities that's the main reason you people are opposing but we have with supreme court don't worry we are getting very soon just wait n watch
@@singhrajput6949 brother just ignore all they are disgusting fellow
@happy who are you to deliver the judgement? Are u making the mockery of our honourable Apex court? Do you think that our honourable supreme court is a comedy show platform? Don't you respect it and its verdict? If you consider yourself as true indian by mind and soul then try to learn how to respect our supreme court.
Thank you sir Juju..
Love you
I think Ladhak is best place for them similer to Arunachal Temperature
But If they not want to Go from Arunachal then thats also OK
Ladhak main pani ka problem hai. To solve this every citizen should give one land for rehabilitation of refugees.
Dear sir they live in Arunachal more the 57 to 60 years it's not possible to relocated!
@@gomagong371 everything is possible. Since your community were refugees initially and now got citizenship too and now relocation is possible too.
@@priyabratapatra4253 Arunachal me b resources ka problem hai.
...It's only solution is to create a UT under Central Govt within the Chakma/Hajong locating area, without disturbing so called local people..
Thank you for correct information.
May be it will be helpful for those who don't have much knowledge about Chakma and Hajong.
Now a days chakma and Hajong population is not sixty thousands. Their population is around 2 Lakhs. They changed the demographic of the State .
Very well explained about chakma and hajong sir 😊👌👌👌👍👍👍
We the Chakmas and Hajongs are Law abiding citizens of India. And we are By Birth Citizens of India born in Arunachal Pradesh. Nobody is above the Law of the Land. We all the Chakmas and Hajongs abide by the Constitution of India.
I appeal to all the people to support the Law abiding Chakmas and Hajongs Citizens of India.
90% of the Chakmas are Citizens By Birth under section (3) (1) (a) of the Citizenship Act of 1955 and others subsequent Provisions of the Act.
We are Constitutionally Allowed to enjoy Our Rights By virtue of being Birth Citizens.
Fully support you. Don't worry, nobody will deport you.
Bro ur forefathers were given shelters by Indian as refugees
Do u realise how many countries don't even accept refugees into their country.see for example our neighborhood only like Bangladesh and mayanmar.
It's not like India wants to sent u back to Bangladesh it's just we are relocating u elsewhere within India where Ur population of 60000 won't matter much but it does in state like arunachal where whole state population is only 15 lakhs so by default u will be the second largest group in arunachal first being the nyishi people of only 1 lakhs.
Here u can very much affect our political system..who knows within 10-15 years Ur population might double and u elect Ur people as our CM,MP etc and that fucking worries us and nothing much personal bro
@@wanderingsoul504 well said brother
Common man what are speaking atleast speak in sense, by your own ideology Indian don't have the right to be a citizens of USA. Upgrade your knowledge Kiren Riju mister of law is from Arunachal Pradesh where the population is very less if we follow your concept all the ministry portfolio should be given to Uthar Pradesh and Bihar because they have lot's number of population. If someone has the quality to become a MLA or MP or other he can be. Choose quality not nepotism. And for your kind information more than Nishi tribe chakma tribe serve the nation as an ARMY OR other arm forces.
@China 32 gold India 1 gold let them take arms they will supressed by law and if you start a revolution blood shed has to be from both side and for your kind info if you are talking about arms I guess you don't belong to a nation where Gandhiji showed his ideology and vision.
They wrote a letter to RSS.
RSS should help them with supplies. They are Indians
U guys are biggest liability to central government. Centre has to fund u for ur survival hence u should be thankful to rss.
They are not indians...they are just non muslims.
@@rupenkumarchakma2096 go back go back, chakma hajong go back
@@rupenkumarchakma2096 ignore these , love and well wishes from haryana
And according to recent CAA act . It is not applicable to AP . So, you all say you are Indian so follow the law of land and go wherever you want .we just don't want you all
Thank you sir. for the explain about of Chakma..
Bangladesh is now a free different country.Unlike 1965 there is elected government and Chittagong hill tracts is still there. Why don't you people go back to your native place??? Why you want to remain as refugees in other countries???
Do some research... You put only chakma point of view who came from Bangladesh and didn't mention or put a point for the indigenous people of the state. Bias AF. If tommorw Afghan refugees and tibetian claims the same... Sabko sar pe bethaoge kya. Bias
Chup kela ..
@Shinchan tabto hum v British nagrik huwe na jab unke ander 200 sal rahe.
@@agenpertin7439 it too different during British rule in india and chakmas issue lol!
@Shinchan only 50+ lol .
@Shinchan and what if they lived for 50 years or more ? Agar esa raha to hat koi 50 years se jyada raha bolke native log ka zameen chinne lagega kiya?
Absolutely Right Sir👍
Please everyone support our Chakma and Hajong brothers.
Arunachali people are good but Church is the evil. Church is responsible for this problem
Please change your mentallity..
Your type of people divide india into" tum musalman hum hindu tum christian hum jain"
@Jeetu kumar Arunachal is different from other NE states,yaha church ka kuch political role nahi hota hai,hota toh 2019 mein BJP ka sarkaar nahi banta.Chakma n hajong se itna hi pyar hai toh apne state mein invite karo aur apna mitti ho toh kindly donate kardo,possible?
Brother u shouldn't say anything without knowing the ground reality... we Arunachalee Don't want any outsider to snatch our land. They are forming militias and capturing small areas with goons, where main indigenous people people are being displaced.. And my family is one of those forcefully displaced victim.. there are many other reasons...
So... brother if u don't know the farrago of this issue and our concern.. u better shut ur mouth .. because u don't know the pain and feelings... of we indigenous people. We don't want any outsider whether they are from so called HINDU,CHRISTIANS, MUSLIMS, BUDDHIST,SIKH.. EYC ETC..
WE JUST DON'T WANT OUTSIDERS.
BJP also started a missionary cell in Mizroram sadly. The Hindus and Buddhists who face persecution should be welcomed to India
Don't think chakma and hajong aren't like by Arunachalee because they Buddhist and hindu this case is different and ur saying churches lol more then church we have mandirs( don't believe then come and see) in every link road so in Arunachal these churches , mandirs, or masjid don't have problem like your mainland stop spreading your hypocrisy no one is dare to hear it. And Arunachal govt giving u a option if u r that much humanism toward these refugees then please take them away instead of campaign against churches..
Kuch Sawal hamare mann me shanka paida karti hai... Ispe gaur kare.... 1. Every upright man feels for his land and people, respects and remembers it with utmost regard and fights to win it back. The Jews are the best examples. Our own Kashmiri pandits are other bright examples. But what kind of race is the Chakmas who we never hear talking about their motherland in Bangladesh in the chittagong hill tract. 2. Usually, people who are granted refuge remain grateful to the benefactor. The best examples are the Tibetans who had come even before the chakmas and have still not forgotten their motherland and are struggling to win it back. We never hear them forcing and intimidating the government to grant them citizenship or land rights. Just contrast the Tibetans with these chakmas. They are using propaganda at national and international level with help of outside organization to defame the country and use pressure tactics to bow down the government itself using the system of the country itself. 3. In Arunachal, the consent of the then illiterate and backward locals were never sought and the consequence of forceful assimilation was never pondered upon while settling them. The result now, their decadal population growth rate is more than twice the locals and they are being extremely belligerent and hateful towards the locals with illegal and anti social activities against the locals. Dhyaan rahe, what you are bringing home. Kahi aisa na ho ki woh apne Bharat varsh ke deshbhakt baccho ko hi nigal jaye. Inki lakshano par gaur kare orr samjhe inko apnaana kis had tak sahi hai. Kya aap ek badmash mehmaan ke liye apne ghar ke baccho ki hitt ko daao me rakhoge.....?
Supreme court order should be followed....
Yes you are right but the arunachal cheap mine people are disrespecting the supreme court order they are scare of us brother if they give citizenship to the Chakma they will get all the job facilities because Chakma are educated as a compare to other..Chakma are intellectual
In the name of education we get discrimination
Most of the Chakma are going to take admission like Assam ,megalaya , mizoram , and other states but within arunachal.we get discrimination for our education
Arunachal Pradesh is wholly a tribal State, which is protected under BEFR - 1873...... There are two Laws prevalent in the State....i.e Constitutional Law and Customary Law !!!
How can REFUGEE expect to become aboriginal people of the Tribal land ??? ....... Refugees are not permanent residents of a place, State or a Nation !!! They are residing on someone else's land(s) for a specific period, or till the disputes of their actual lands are sorted out......BANGLADESH IS A FREE NATION NOW !!! They should thank the tribal people of the State (especially the tribes on whose lands they are living) for giving them shelter during their worst days, and should return to their ancestral lands !!!
Besides, Supreme Court can persuade the State Governments for granting Citizenship to REFUGEES.....But can the court give direction to provide ST/PRC status to REFUGEES ??? Ofcourse not !!!
Besides, being a protected State, even the people from other States of the nation are bound to procure ILP during their visit in the State (AP); what makes the Refugees to think that they should be provided with superior-dignity than the rest of Indians !???
Should be ashamed of their demand(s) !!!
Even the United Nation (UN) has framed a DECLARATION (UNDRIP - United Nation Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People) to safeguard the traditional rights of tribal populace around the World !!!
Refugees are not our (Tribal fraternity) responsibility ...... Government may give them citizenship according to their convenience, but not in the pristine Tribal State of Arunachal Pradesh......and hence, their deportation is much justified !!!
It's sad to see that these people of community is only bitching about our people and land. Trying to make villian out of everyone who has given them refuge(Mizoram/Tripura/assam).
@@thejaneeyre so they will be enjoying ST status from all states like Mizoram, Tripura, Assam and Arunachal? 😂 Waaoo nice planning.
Church is becoming more powerful in NORTH EAST
How???
Chakmas are by birth, descent etc citizenship of India according to constitution but due to discrimination of other tribes of Arunachal Pradesh till now rights less, no equal rights etc
Even Chakmas has outonomus council in mizoram and they are living in most of the part of northeast and all over India....but for arunachalee we got only arunachal Pradesh as our native place..therefore as a indigenous native of arunachal we are only protecting ourself from getting outnumbered....later leading to loss of culture and identity...thank you...jai hind..🇮🇳
Chakma and hazong were long refugees and it's good that they are getting citizenship but it doesn't mean they will get land right in Arunachal Pradesh. They aren't ST of Arunachal Pradesh, and they won't be getting ST status too. To be honest it's been a long fight for them. And this will be another long fight for them,if they want to settle in AP. so better leave and start afresh , were they could call the land their own. neither their forefather could enjoy the land right nor them but it's now upto them,what they want to give to their children.see, after the judgement of supreme court also citizenship process has not been processed. citizenship is very imp to be eligible for getting job.this fight will go on and children of these refugees will never see the dawn. so better to take wise step, to prevent children from this pit of darkness. otherwise, coming generation will also live the same life, like them.
Chakma and hojong population has grown very rapidly within very short time. There is resources shortage and local population is totally against them. So refugees can not demand what they want from the original inhabitants of land . People who feel injustice, please kindly settle these people in your state. We will be very grateful to you.
Thank you sir for the information.
I hope for a peaceful settlement between the concerned parties.
These tribal peoples are absolutely backward
It's 21st century and they are still stuck in 12th century mindset...
Fighting on tribe,village issues like pig, Buffaloes,Donkeys do it in Forest
Like dogs urinate and capture that place, then ask others to not come here
A big thank you bro.. Truth must prevail. 🙏🙏🙏 Jai Hind..
Sir, thank you very for explaining our cause... God bless you
Day by day coming Bangladeshi bengali hindu in Tripura
A guest should never cross their limit.
Arunachal pradesh is protected by constitution of india....so, chakmas have to relocate from our state.
Good News
We are very grateful to you sir for covering our issue... lots of love from Changma
Thank you sir
entire India belongs to you brothers and sisters. We are all one. Love from Maharashtra
We r Indian.
chakma you are not our brother or sister
@@CRU5ADER373 why don't you let them shelter at your home
Thank you so much for making videos for Chakma we are facing lots of problem sir within arunachal Pradesh
Because you are not arunachali
@@gautamdada2979 you arunachal people are totally narrow mine greedy people become of you arunachal still undeveloped Always spread hatred towards Chakma ..
@@suppotchakma868 and you people are very ungrateful. You are here as guests. Don’t try to become the owner of the land.
@@suppotchakma868 so you better to leave arunachal pradesh please🙏🙏
@@rajatoku3157 just for your imagination have you heard supreme Court judgment you people are unrespectful
क्रिस्चियन मिशनरीज डेमोग्राफी चेंज कर रहें तो कोई दिक्कत नहीं है इन लोगों को लेकिन चकमा और हजोंग से इतनी दिक्कत है?
Champak of Arunachal was forefather homeland of Chakma, according to ancient history of Chakma
Where did this voice and courage goes when they were Kick out from their own country Bangladesh???
thank you sir.
thnx bro , nicely explained..
Sks
The union gov. should implement a new law to bombard refugess asking citizenship rather than shelter.... And it should be named "WISE ACT ".
END of the debate... Thankyou🙏
Thank u sir making this video .
I didn't understand what's the problem with some North eastern states. Don't they travel and live in other major cities like delhi, bengluru etc. They buy home ,land and work their, if people from every state think like that people form other states or of different ethnicity change our demography then we must relocate them. This is not how country works. India is a multi ethnic and culture country. We must not allow this kind of action/decision. In country every person must have rights to live where ever they want until there is some problem like environmental issue. These people has been living in Arunachal Pradesh for ver long time. I think govt. Should reject this plan.
Chakmas are not Indian they are refugee.
@@aspirant5108 90% of them are now INDIAN by law of land & By our heritage.
This is a politcal problem of regionalism where one faction feel threatens in addition of more voters.
Dude, India is a representative democracy. That is why Assam, a state smaller in land area than Arunachal has WAY more MPs in the Parliament than Arunachal.
Chakmas are huge in numbers (compared to other tribes). And already man tribes aren't getting adequate representation in the State Assembly and the Parliament due the sheer number of ethnicities. If Chakma's are made domicile of Arunachal, they will dominate the state politics just due to their numbers.
@aspirant 510 and what about you are you Indian?
Well said bro!👌 There's a shloka said by lord Rama in Ramayana after being asked and proposed by Laxmana to settle and stay permanently in the Golden Lanka, after that a beautifully replied by lord Rama "जननी जन्मभूमिश्च स्वर्गादपि गरीयसी ॥" Means, mother and motherland are greater than paradise.
We decline and oppose non-violently as well as amicably such unacceptable plan, every citizen won't be ready to be relocated from his homeland, especially who has been staying for many decades. Let us oppose by showing our " Unity in Diversity" being with our brothers and sisters of Chakma and Hajong. Jai Hind🇮🇳
Go back Chakma and Hajong from Arunachal Pradesh
U also go back to China India is not urs homeland
Thank you brother for making this video. Let others get lesson how chakmas has been getting discriminated every day and night deprived from basic human rights because of some uneducated and selfish people in the state.
Exactly bro! Chakmas have been discriminated in various fronts,be it education, fundamental rights, basic amenities and health care facilities..we are living this life with no future.Thank u Anirudh sir for your video clip.i rigorously follow you and your channel and your channel helped me alot to make myself a sincere citizen of this beautiful country.🙏
They are our people and we must feel pain for them, they are in their own country, the land of their ancestors, Government of India shall make appropriate arrangements to give the safe and stable life. My personal belief is that our Northeastern family has tremendous capabilities, if provided with adequate opportunities they can add wings to the flight of this nation on the trajectory of progress and prosperity
Take them(chakma-hajong) to your State because Arunachal Pradesh is not a property for illegal migrants.
Pls shift them to your state...we dont want them here
Had I been CM of the state, or PM of this country, I definitely would've done so.
@@nishpakshagupta8331 in a democratic country public voice matter most...pls go ahead, many medium are their and shift them to your location
Bhai woh log refugee tah..GOI citizenship bhi diya parr ab ST status, PRC demand karr raha hai.Jahan jagah diya wohi ka indigenous ko damki dene laga hai o Bangladeshi miya ki tarah itna human produce karr raha hai..Aap google mein unlogo ka population increase percentage dekho...Sab patah chal jayega.
Miya jo ya Chakma o Hajong..Religion alag hai parr kandh karna Barabar.
We want relocation of chakma,hajong
The entire episode of today's chakmas and hajong crisis in AP is due to political blunder made in 1946-47 by unjust award of cht to the then East pakistan violating boundary commission. Again, the issue had been lingering for over 57 years of living in AP now due to the dark side of democracy where "majority wins and minority is suppress".
Tell me, on what ground an union law minister can uproot an entire community from their native land without their consent? Isn't this ethnic cleansing? Chakmas n hajongs are lawful citizen of india as recognised by the constitution of india where it clearly stated that under article 5 sec 3 of acquisition of indian citizenship:
1."A person born in india on or after 26july 1950 but before 1st july 1987, is citizen of india by birth, irrespective of nationality of his parents."
2. A person born in india on or after 1st july 1987 but before 3rd december 2004, is considered citizen of india by birth if either of his parents is a citizen of india at the time of his birth....n so on
Now, has any one of you witnessed so far in independent india that any law or union minister did uproot an entire community(citizen by birth) because of their ethnicity violating the rule of law?? And If any such minister is ensuring his public in his independence speech of doing such for the very first time in free india then one can see the level of exploitation grossly made by the public n the incumbent govt itself.
The so called indegenious people do not want to accept chakmas n hajongs on the flimsy ground that AP is protected by BEFR-1873 which restrict the non arunachalee to enter AP without inner line permit(ILP) and also restrict buying of land(ownership) to non arunachalee. These two things are protected under BEFR-1873 which is centuries old regulation now imposed by british. As per as i know, BEFR-1873 was imposed to other places as well in northeast (including jummaland CHT) like sivsagar, nawgong(nagaon), kamrup, AP, etc mainly for few reasons as follows
1. To safeguard the unique traditions of the hill people by not allowing the people from advanced societies from mainland india to mix with them.
2. to safeguard the tribal land which would otherwise have acquired by advanced societies by duping the tribals
3. To protect the timbers and other forest products
* If the BEFR-1873 is scrapped for district of assam then it is clear that it is scrapable if require
My interpretation now:
1. BEFR-1873 was enacted to safeguard the tribals and not only ap. chakmas were also tribals protected under BEFR-1873
2. So if govt had decided to settle the chakmas in AP relaxing BEFR-1873 (bcoz chakmas were also protected under befr) and rehabilitated there since over 57 years now where many chakmas had been born and died, is it at all possible to uproot them?
Thats why i call it political gimmick and entertained for vested interest.
Sometimes i wonder thinking that when people are striving to become ias, ips, mla, minister, etc we are still striving tooth n nail to get the basic right leading to a whopping gap in between ours n other societies. Please do not support relocation n appeal the central govt to solve our issue once and for all " because we wish to live n wish to flourish after consistent suffering for over 57 years
Bangladesh is now a free country. Why you want to remain as refugees in other countries, when you have your own motherland???
So according to you a person from Bihar up Kerala also allow to buy land in Arunachal Pradesh? Chakma and hajong came as a refugees Arunachal government gave shelter now they are Indian citizens so if they want to stay in Arunachal Pradesh then they must have inner line permit like other non Arunachali since chakma and hajong is not from Arunachali,, according to articles 371 you are not allowed to have land in Arunachal Pradesh like others non Arunachali,,simple as that
Ask your Bangladesh Govt...to your right..... Refugee Bhai Log 🙏🇮🇳
Government of India must honour the Judgment of Supreme court of India and INDRA-MUJIB PACT of 1972.
But keeping the interest of Arunachal Tribe from demographic dilutions. The GOI must address either of this two points:- 1. Chakma and Hajong along with other Refugees like Tibetan should be given separate UNION administration status. OR
2. Should collect proper data and grant them for Citizenship aonly those who are found came before 1971 but other than these register for Citizenship, CHIN HILL Regulations 1896 and BENGALI EASTERN FRONTIER REGULATIONS 1873 should be strictly observe.
Of course relocate and resettlement is out of QUESTIONS, to solve one problem can't create another like it happens with the BRU REFUGEE from Mizoram.
Arunachal won't be breeding ground for refugees. they say they r born in A.P so they should get citizenship,so then i guess the non tribal born there should also be given citizenship,an American borning there should be given citizenship?
I knew it just like the chakmas in tripura has demanded chakmaland,in A.P they r using this kind of tactic.i guess all the Myanmar refugees residing in Eastern side also given citizenship? bullshit.
Even Tibetans and Nepalis in Arunachal should be given the same rights. 😂
@Green Scenery yeah 😂😂 everyone one borning there should get citizenship na 😂😂🙏🙏
Major point to think is that now after many years and liberation of Bangladesh, and things settled cooled why dont the Bangladesh govt Hesitant to take back its citizens.
Mr aggarwal, ur video is one sided. You haven't shown any sentiments of arunachal Pradesh. Without knowing any actual ground reality, you can't just make any video. Sitting in ur home, reading articles/news, please stop throwing knowledge on such sensitive issue. Our state is a tribal state, chakma and hajongs can have home anywhere, they have international diaspora. We arunachalee have only arunachal as our only home where we live with our culture, we are discriminated across india, just by our looks. Our state is protected by BEFR act 1873. Chakma and hajongs population have exploded rapidly, in no time they can cover our tribal indigenous population. We don't want to be other tripura, sikkim, or (some parts of) assam where there original indigenous population becomes minority. Where were you when Arunachalee's where protesting since ages. They were brought without our knowledge, we didn't have any representative from our land. We will protect our home at all cost, even if it means blood, because this is our only home. Hindu and Buddhist have home all over India, but Arunachalee have only arunachal where we can live peacefully.
One thing you missed to say that they were temporarily allowed to stay in arunachal pradesh by former prime minister and thats why the citizenship was not granted during that time also. Please don't provide half truth to your viewers it is a very sensitive topic for both side of the people of that state.
I think you should do your homework instead of vomiting the nonsense half truths that has been put inside your head while you were been brainwashed
@@dolamoja4908 don't worry we will relocate you anyhow by the rule of law or by force and this disgusting vomited brain will enjoy if it is done by forced.
@@jellysonamnlg9023 through your sentence your ancestors aggressiveness can be seen.... Lol and you talk about peace.... 😂😂😂
Let's see how you relocate us!
And by through your sentences it seems your ancestors were coward and shameless who abandoned their land and arrived as guest in our home and now claiming like you are the owner no wonder why I will personally enjoy if there will be .....
@@jellysonamnlg9023 let's see who are cowards... You are behaving as if your ancestors have popped up like a mushroom from the land of Arunachal Pradesh... Lol all human were nomads.... Study bro😂😂😂
That's why we require CAA
CAA to bohat pehle se laagu ho chuka h... Inko citizenship kyuñ nhi mili abhi tk? Ye 1960s se reh rhe h itne m to inko mil jaani chahiye thi bina CAA k hi... Kyuñki inhone 14 saal se zyada ka wqt yha spend kr liya h
@@Arman12371 what I mean is to be implemented properly, I think it started in Dec 2019/ Jan 2020🤔, but yes it should be questioned why there are still people not on the list.
Yes but they can't get citizenship if they stay in arunachal bcoz CAA is exempt in arunachal
Absolutely sir CAA also should required in Arunachal theirs mindset is now out of damn....Arunachal tribe ko bahut gaman ho gaya....inner line permit ko bhi hatna chaye...then they will learn some new lesson!
Act of deporting the refugees from Bangladesh to Intensely sensitive protected tribal land if eastern himalaya then NEFA now Arunachal was in itself an utter attrocitious and blunderous act. Instead of protection from outer interference, they injected war refugees into the sensitive land. Govt must take responsibility, now as situations have cooled, deport them back to their homeland or give them refuge in the New Delhi Nayional Capital central Govt Territory.
We ARUNACHALEES will never accept Bangladeshi Refugees, Chakmas and Hajongs,...jai Arunachal, Jai Hind
You accept or not we are not going anywhere our birth place is arunachal here do of die but never came
Stop the missionaries first lol
Let u not accept. That is what we asking from the Centre now, leave chakma inhabitants area so that centre can grant us into union Territory moreover u people have been eating us from the past half century only. U don't study well because u have all the tiger share resources hence education was not required for u all.
@@somelchangma6509 Full support to Chakma Hindus and Buddhists
Lagbhag 1 crore Nepali bhutiya Tibetan log Bharat mein rehte Hain to 60000 chakma hajong Bharat mein kyon nahin rah sakte Bangladesh Chittagong to Bharat ka hi hissa tha yah jimmedari Bharat ki hai 🙏🙏🙏
Bcz nepali, bhutiya are not demanding for ST in arunachal pradesh..... Reh sakte ho ap... But kisi ka ghr m betke .... Malik ka ghr ko hi lene se kaha hoga.... Nepali lok mehen ki tara rehte h... Naki apki tara dusre k ghr ko mangte h
Chakma in Arunachal Pradesh are Like Miya In Assam having same characteristics. Firstly, They belong to Bangladesh. Secondly, Don't have control over population growth, Thirdly illegal land encroachment of Indigenous people and lastly threat to entire state
Wow what a narrow minded you r event didn't know between the gave of Maya and ST 😂😂😂lol
@@gomagong371 chal put
This issue has been created by the central govt.. Allowing immigration, settlement of refugee, providing citizenship.. Now they want separate union territory.. Who and how gonna central and state fulfill their demand
Its just 60000 man relocate them to Ladakh or some to Jammu.
60000 of them is just according to the papers, their population is more than 2L by now for sure. 1 mom +1 Dad = maximum kids possible is their family policy. Apart from socio-economic reasons, the rising criminal activities and insurgencies by this group is a matter or grave concern for us.. Whatever card they are playing and excelling in it but in reality the local population are the real victims
Ok your right
If we swift 60k tribes from Arunachal then the low population this East Himalayan region which have roughly 6-8 mil population cause of dehabitization The Chinese claim on Arunachal as South Tibet will be in future more more more agressive and maybe china attack there...we are indians we have to united and patriotic to nation 🇮🇳❤️ neither foreign powers which are always ready to Divide ➗ India as 1947
After 1962 IndiChina war Chakma were settled in Arunachal and they were given arm traning and gun licence to fight against Chiniese . Indian Government know that Chakmas always have been loyal for India .
@@AtulChakmaHello Atul where are u from? Arunachal, Mizoram or Assam?!🙋
@happy you are the only one who spreading hatred fact is fact accept it ..
@@suppotchakma868 What do u mean?
@@suppotchakma868 Bhai, I just wanted to say that the chakma community from Arunachal Pradesh so where do we take them to live...And Arunachal Pradesh is not such Uttar Pradesh...to swift chakmas from here the population will decline... although the birthrate in Arunachal is not so good... Fighting together we are clearing path of our enemies... China 🇨🇳 china is the greatest Grand threat for Arunachal...they building 🚅 roots near our border, building 🏢🏫 colonies just before our border...Come unite and say with one tune...Jay Hind Jay Bharat Mata
You know How china became superior? Unity and Integrity. Unless we become extreme nationalist we can't fight with China .
It is clear, To make India superpower we have to unite have to Integrate
To protect Arunachal, for those frontier indians we have to make sure their condition is good, if not so we must prepare the infrastructure there... Good well designed indian armours to resist dushmans
Whenever I see my country replace china The glorious motto then shine with more intensity than sun and our triranga waves in that morning
Thanks you so much sir
Thank u sir for urs kind information about chakmas and hajong but sir Chakmas and hajong will not accepted to this Rascial proposal in any mean so however in Arunachal most of tribe didn't have humanity they only created communal,Rascium and descriminating even in mindland Indian people's ...so in lastly love from chakmas and hajong community,one more subscriber to urs channel!
Hahaha...
What a joke!!!
We Arunachalee rescued you guys from persecution by giving temporary settlement & now you call us inhumane. Shame on you guys! Bhalai ka zamana hee na raha.
Nice explanation I appreciate him👍
Jab chattagong hills se gand marwa k bhaag aya tha tb tum logo ko roti kapra makan dya or ab hm log racist h or hm mai humanity nhi h. Tm chakma hajong ka na yahi problem h jis thali pe khata h usse mai thukta h
Tum logo ko relocate nhi balki gadda khod k zinda jala dena chahiye
You are right tribes in arunachal are inhuman so please kindly leave arunachal and settle in some humanly environment. PLEASE LEAVE!!!
@Gom agong look who is talking?
Jis taali pe Kaya whi pe cheda!
Go back to chitagong hills!
If u really think we are racial, inhumane..
Why don't u just leave our state and return back to ur own homeland lol!
Thank 🙏🙏
Sir bas religious persecution k wajah se nahi.. Ye log 1960s tak apne bangladesh k settlement me India ka flag hoist krte the.. Aur pakistaniyo ne inke area ka dam kholdiya tha jiske wajah se inke gao flooded hogye the..
The whole mission and idea of the Indian government first prime Minister Jawahar lal Nehru Ji and verrier elwin a tribal anthropologist, was to let this NEFA (arunachal) region be protected from any interference and let them grow according to their own indegenious ways and own pace of intelligence as it was a tribal place, only medical, efucation, some few administrative supplies where to be provided and protected from any external interference from the country via, british Beft policies and special land rights. This act of deporting Chakma back then was itself a very offensive act it was a very unjust decision to deport the refugees into a sensitive protected tribal land. The central govt mistake was made then, and now the act of asking for citizenship is totally blasphemy. This act of India n govt. will be an act of immense attrocity against the tribal people of Arunachal and it will cause bitterness and cite untowards feeling againdt the govt in the sensitive area bordering china. To avert such situation the govt can justfully take decision of those temporary refugees hold talks with the Bangladesh Govt as the situation is better their now and deport them back to their homeland or they can deport them to the National Capital Region which will be justified, but encroachment of indegenious tribal territories is utterly unjustified and the govt must take step to protect the tribal land.
great 👍 outsider is always outsider...then only a stable state or nation build, settle them on mizoram border of assam where Bangladeshi are now settled illegally by assam.
They are Hindus and Buddhists. They should be allowed in India
@@ishikinokami1575 huu so they have to send to nepal..if they merge them then good...if not then send them back to their nation from where they come...hindu or Muslims is not issue is they are outsider mean outsider...
Can these refugees be shifted to bigger central or western states.
Those states are still sparsely populated compared to north east.
Chakma-Hajongs have been sheltered in Arunachal Pradesh for more than 50 years. Since Arunachal Pradesh is a protected land by constitution of India by various laws and regulations like BEFR 1873 so settling them in our land is illegal. They are foreigners, they are diluting of local population and creating danger to the lives and property of indigenous people. I appeal the Government of India to please send them back to Bangladesh otherwise there is a making of another Assam/Tripura like situation.
We r not general,obc,or other Backward class we r ST status in Indian constitution dude!
We are here to stay and will take our Birth land Bharat on Top of the world🇮🇳.Infact we are on our way😊.
Sir. Is there a possible option. To gave status of union territory to Chakma hanong Area..
Right point
They should be shifted to Chittagong back to their homeland.They are refuges
Chinese refugee
@@gomagong371 u r refuge in our land ...you should demand all right from your Bangladesh Govt
@@gomagong371 Pakistani Bangladeshi