At primary school in the UK 1960s, late afternoon, we would close our eyes and rest our heads on our desks to have some quiet time. My teacher at the time, Mr Jones, would play classical music for us to listen to, this was always one, if not my favourite! I'm 65 now and have listened to and enjoyed classical music every day of my life since then! My children and grandchildren are devoted fans too having been brought up on such classical masterpieces.
On rainy days, we would gather in the hall at lunchtime and the Headmaster would play classical music for us. My introduction to such gems as Swan Lake, Peter and the wolf, etc. I still remember those occasions with great fondness.
I'm 65; why on earth didn't they do that in Australia, too? It would have been brilliant. As it was, it took me decades to discover the joys of classical music.
My mother said that this was playing when she gave birth to me, hence the reason why I decided to look it up. Seems pretty awesome to think that this was the first thing I would have heard.
Interesting Fact. Whilst on his way to Scotland Felix Mendelssohn stopped to inspect the Liverpool & Manchester Railway. The first locomotive worked Inter-City Railway in the World was in its final stages of construction. Robert Stephenson escorted the composer around the new railway. He became the first member of the public to travel on the line between the two cities!
Two 19th century geniuses together. I hope they had translators around. German to English.... English to Geordie.... Geordie to English etc... apparently Robert Stephenson's accent was so broad he really did have a translator with him when he traveled outside of the north east.
+Robert Gage Hmm. I was 18 in 1966 here in Lafayette, IN. I think I might have been there for the performance. At that big meeting house (I forget the name) a block north of Main St.? Not at Mars theater?
i was supposed to play this for my final concert of the session for my youth orchestra and it was cancelled because of the covid-19. this was my favorite piece out of everything we played :(
You will always remember that just as I remember that the school puppet show I was to take part in at Christmas 1957 was cancelled because half the class, including myself, contracted the Asian Flu. Of course at that time we all stayed in school until sick.
I headed out from the isle of Iona to Staffa where Fingal's cave is located yesterday. The Atlantic surge was too much to be able to moor at the island so we could only just hold on to the sides of the wooden boat while staring into the crashing darkness between the basalt pillars. Then the captain told us about the crashing of the surf is what inspired Mendelssohn when he came here in 1856(?) to write this piece, and it played over the tannoy while cormorants dived and guillemots swam around us, the sea heaved, the foam sprayed up around the rocks, and the grey seals watched us from their breeding ground around the island's side.
Wow... this man just managed to use the words tannoy, cormorant, and guillemots. in the same sentence... Let's take a moment to recognize his perspicacity whatever that means
I went from Mull to Iona and then on to Staffa, on a fantastic August day when the sky was blue with fluffy white clouds, the sea was a fabulous azure and the sand as white as snow. It is the most beautiful memory matched by this beautiful music.
I agree with all of you that he is underestimated, and so is Dvorak, to some degree. But they both have composed some beautiful pieces, this one among them.
I remember having the little mermaid audio tape when I was a kid each chapter started with this. Always makes me think of plunging to the depths of the ocean!
@@jaakkokeskinen The sea has many faces. The prelude to Act 3 of Tristan and Isolde sounds like a powerful but largely calm sea, such as the Baltic. Listen to Wagner's prelude to The Flying Dutchman to get an impression of a stormy sea, such as that which Wagner and his wife experienced on a crossing to England after they had fled Riga in the eastern Baltic. Or listen to the Sea Interludes in Benjamin Britten's opera Peter Grimes. Mendelssohn is describing sea passages around Hebridean islands in the eastern Atlantic. I grew up close to the North Sea coast in Scotland and have seen the Atlantic in Scotland, Ireland, France, Spain, Portugal, Iceland and Norway. It can be a very, very wild indeed. I've been on ferries in a Force 10 gale. The Baltic just doesn't get gales like that.
Such joy! I could taste the salty sea air. majestic. Moving me to tears before that baton was laid aside. I am actually the proud owner of this powerful piece on a 78 which was recorded in 1928. My maternal grandfather was the previous owner of this 78 which, when played on the old gramophone, he would conduct his invisible orchestra! Ordinarily, his 'conducting' was carried out on a Sunday morning before we all set off to church. I would call into my grand parents house which was on our farm, and I'd find my grandfather wearing his pyjama's and a bow tie. The perfect outfit for all conductors! After he performed this energetic form of art, he'd quickly shower, get properly dressed and before we knew it we were in the church. A brilliant start to a Sunday for any young child!
@@philipwilliams5808It is indeed. I visited it yonks ago, the music coursing through my mind as I oggled the basalt columns - that's the trouble with being a geologist we 'consume' the rocks.
Thats impressive. Im from the west coast, and like many people from an area, we are the worst tourists and don't explore as we should. That cave, from pictures, I would describe as a natural cathedral, so it must be something in reality.
"That's the beauty of music. They can't get that from you... You need it so you don't forget...there are places in this world that aren't made out of stone. That there's something inside... that they can't get to, that they can't touch - that's yours." -- Andy Dufresne, "The Shawshank Redemption"
When I was a child of 7 in England and my brother was 9, we loved this piece of music whenever it was played on the radio. That's the only place we heard it. We'd sit there transfixed. So beautiful.
amazingly beautiful country. pity it has the worst weather on earth... oh and my horrible, toxic mother lives there, so i will make do with memories... why does this overture make me think of Luis Buñuel?
I have been inside this cave. One little known fact...if you are well inside the cave, and look towards the entrance, you can see the entrance framing the Isle of Iona.
I wonder if Mendelssohn was freaking out when he wrote this, thinking "This is really good. It's going to be a classic. 200 years from now, people will download this from the internet and leaving comments on how good it is. This is great!"
James A ""This is really good. It's going to be a classic. 200 years from now, people will download this from the internet and leaving comments on how good it is." , and that darn Mynah Bird:).
Having twice been in the actual Fingal's Cave in the island of Staffa, this has particular significance both for the peerless music and the natural grandeur of the Cave itself. No wonder Mendelssohn was moved to compose this superb piece.
I first heard this on that 1943 film, The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp, when the main character went to the POW camp after WW1 to find his prewar German friend. That music was playing in the background, and I liked it so much, I looked it up 😊
So many appreciative comments here... And I, too, have much to recognise, acknowledge and appreciate. My reception teacher, Miss Irwin, in 1959, was an outstanding teacher and musician. Sadly, long gone, I pay public tribute to a truly lovely lady who helped to shape my life and life-long interest in music. RIP Miss Irwin.
Mr Felix Mendelssohn ... you composed many breath taking Masterpieces. I admire and have always thought of you as among the all time great composers in the same level as Bach, Handel, Schubert, Schumann, Tchaikovsky, Brahms, Mozart and Beethoven.
Likewise! I grew up listening to everything in Classical music, and Mendelssohn has been always among my dearest composers. Playing the piano, I asked my father his book for piano Romance without Words, which I got for one of my birthdays as a teen. Such a joy to be able to play his wonderful compositions.
@@alancumming6407 That's just a turn of phrase for saying that the person who likes the piece thinks that others who don't or don't even know it are philistines for not appreciating it.
@@alicemilne1444 No, unfortunately I had never heard of this until just recently. When I was a kid, they never taught anything in school about Felix Mendelsohn and whenever anyone plays classical music it's always the same old Mozart and Beethoven stuff over and over again.
Was there ever a piece of music that so perfectly captured the ebb and flow...the constant rise and fall of the ocean in all its moods? I think not. A top orchestra and conductor do it justice here.
They were pretty good yes? They really are exactly like natural storms. Beethoven th thunder& th storm moving on. Korsakov's sea storm - u can imagine th swell of waves growing taller & more violent! PJS.
@@petersmith9077 Peter - absolutely right. It requires not only a musical skill but the necessary imagination to write music of this sort. In more modern times Richard Rodgers wrote some fine music in a similar nautical vein for the 1950s TV series "Victory at Sea" (arranged by R.R.Bennett, I seem to recall). The title theme "Song of the High Seas" was a good example.
We are living in extremly strange times and the world is in stress factor but listening to classical music seems to take the worrying pressure away if only for a short while to the people of Japan be careful keep safe take care love as always Dave ENGLAND a land next door to heaven
@@davidbarber4709 Thank-you Take care of yourself Good luck ！ For the second year in a row , we have refrained from the banquet under the cherry blossoms in full bloom in the parks of Tokyo , which is a very pity .
Yes these are stressful times and good wholesome music helps. And watching Baby Sea Otter Joey & Friends also provides hours of relaxation. Hope you are well.
Did not make it to The Hebrides on our recent Scotland tour. Yet made it to Skye, and couldn’t help but whistle this masterpiece upon which our tour guide said, “You whistle that quite nicely.” 🎶
I love this piece. It moves me and inspires me. Mendelssohn was indeed one of the greatest composers of his time and one of the greats of the ages. Thank you for loading this wonderful work of art for the world to enjoy!
My absolutely favorite piece of music. Something majestic and airy about this emotional experience absorbing this performance. I wish Mendelssohn had a larger library of compositions. But ill settle for this small piece of perfection
@@palmermonsen9098 @jeffrey burger His Octet for Strings is one of the greatest pieces of chamber music ever written and he wrote it when he was....wait for it....16.
We had a teacher in 1970. Miss Lamb. She taught us well and exposed us to this early. Her father was the choir master at the Cathedral. I remember those days from the 70s well.
I had the great good fortune to be invited to go to Fingal's Cave, on an island off Mull, when visiting the Hebrides. Mendelssohn's musical imagination captures the place wonderfully, down to the surging tides and eddies by the cave mouth. Listen, and you're there! Promise.
I visited Fingal's Cave on Staffa last week with my family and little dog. Oh my goodness, it was amazing. It was particularly poignant as Staffa tours play this music as they enter the cave before you get off the boat to explore. It is really worth the journey and so moving to listen to this piece of music.
"Now from the gray mist of the ocean the white-sailed ships of Fingal appear. High is the grove of their masts, as they nod, by turns, on the rolling wave. Swaran saw them from the hill. He returned from the sons of Erin. As ebbs the resounding sea, through the hundred isles of Inistore; so loud, so vast, so immense, returned the sons of Lochlin against the king. But bending, weeping, sad, and slow, and dragging his long spear behind, Cuthullin sunk in Cromla's wood, and mourned his fallen friends. He feared the face of Fingal, who was wont to greet him from the fields of renown! ... Fingal, tall in his ship, stretched his bright lance before him. Terrible was the gleam of his steel: It was like the green meteor of death, setting in the heath of Malmor, when the traveller is alone, and the broad moon is darkened in heaven." (Epic of Fingal III from the Poems of Ossian)
Thankyou. This transported me away from all the idiocy and madness and onto beautiful landscapes of legends and myth with mountains and storm lashed coves.
There was a cartoon that featured a snippet of this when I watched as a kid.Never bothered to listen to the entire piece till now. Genius. Artstry. Combined.
I first heard this sometime in the '80s in an old "Don Winslow of the Navy" serial; it was the main theme of the show IIRC. Anyway the music wasn't attributed; it took me some 20 years to finally learn the name and composer, but I never forgot its haunting beauty. Nor have I forgotten since.
The "Don Winslow Of the Navy" serial was the first time I heard this too. The main theme played when the enemy submarine appeared. Took a long time to discover the entire piece. Then I found Otto Klemperer's recording of it. (That record also had Mendelssohn's "Scottish" and "Italian" symphonies).
One of my favorite pieces... Performed this in high school orchestra at state competition with a 10/10 from all judges. Our orchestra was very, very good at the time, I was a violist and performing this in a very well put together group is intense! One of my best memories.
Listening to this very late one Sunday night - (well, easily Monday morning now ...) I am just reminded of what an underrated genius Felix Mendelssohn was. There is something about this piece of music that takes you right to the place the inspired him ... I feel like I am in that cave on that Scottish isle looking out on to the world with different eyes ... perhaps, sharing his eyes of the time? I feel connected. In fact, about twenty five years ago I did just that very thing - I have piece of paino music that I wrote, it's stashed away somewhere, and it was provisionally entitled 'Scottish Isle piece' It doesn't bear much resemblance to this Mendelssohn masterpiece other than the mood and the concept. But over a couple of days in the mid nineties I was completely taken with a theme I had in my head and I fleshed out a piece for piano ...i must dig it out sometime soon.
***** I agree, but that doesn't make it any better. It is art since it is music, denying that would be immature and just simply incorrect. Just because I don't like it doesn't mean I don't perceive it as art, but it still irritates me incredibly for the fact that, like you said, it shows where we are as a society and a culture. And that is a very low, very narrow-minded and superficial place that we have reached.
***** you have your view, not sure its an accurate one--Ive never listened to ONE Cyrus, or what ever her name is--but have listened to 10 different versions of this immortal work alone. Which will be listened to in 500 yrs--the answer is obvious--
After visiting many of the islands it's quite moving to hear this music again capturing the mood and rugged beauty of such an outstanding part of the world We live on a planet with some extraordinary stunning places and the inner and outer Hebrides counts as one of them
I play trumpet in it now with our amateur orchestra. Here I hear that much dynamics is indeed inherent to this piece but it's rarely coming from the instruments that find this the most easy : the brass.
i agree with peace harmony, and get an earful of his third symphony if you have a mo, second movement (starts at about 17 min): th-cam.com/video/FbH95mO_o3A/w-d-xo.html
I am going to hear this tonight at the Sydney Town Hall - Sydney Symphony orchestra and I am so excited ...never heard it live and I think this is one the most evocative pieces of music of all time.
Got to play this on double bass many years ago and as difficult as it was, I still look back with fond memories of playing this piece. That was at least 10 years ago
The opportunity to visit Fingal's cave as I did recently and experience first hand where the young Mendelssohn envisioned this wonderful overture was sublime. It perfectly translates the beauty and tumult of this remarkable place.
We are going to Scotland, hopefully in May. One of our stops will be Iona, the Ferry to Staffa and Finns Cave the inspiration for this masterpiece is there!
A truly great composer and yet many people pass over him without a glance he deserves more recognition. Only true connoisseurs of music recognise this man's genius.
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W1D3 | Summer | เคาะ 8 ทีมแรก ที่ไปรอวันอาทิตย์](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eKFbDC1qe38/mqdefault.jpg)
At primary school in the UK 1960s, late afternoon, we would close our eyes and rest our heads on our desks to have some quiet time. My teacher at the time, Mr Jones, would play classical music for us to listen to, this was always one, if not my favourite! I'm 65 now and have listened to and enjoyed classical music every day of my life since then! My children and grandchildren are devoted fans too having been brought up on such classical masterpieces.
@Lil Wen You had a great teacher!
How amazing. I’m 62 and our Headmistress did the same in 1960’s. Miss Gayford (Primary school in the UK) played this and it has stuck ever since.
Q
On rainy days, we would gather in the hall at lunchtime and the Headmaster would play classical music for us. My introduction to such gems as Swan Lake, Peter and the wolf, etc. I still remember those occasions with great fondness.
I'm 65; why on earth didn't they do that in Australia, too? It would have been brilliant. As it was, it took me decades to discover the joys of classical music.
My mother said that this was playing when she gave birth to me, hence the reason why I decided to look it up. Seems pretty awesome to think that this was the first thing I would have heard.
Wow! That is quite an anecdote to share! Fascinating that this welcomed you into the world!!
Unborn babies can already hear in their mother's womb.
But the strings don't come through very well underwater.
you had to look it up? didn't you remember it?
Nah my memory is pretty crappy haha
Interesting Fact. Whilst on his way to Scotland Felix Mendelssohn stopped to inspect the Liverpool & Manchester Railway. The first locomotive worked Inter-City Railway in the World was in its final stages of construction. Robert Stephenson escorted the composer around the new railway. He became the first member of the public to travel on the line between the two cities!
Two 19th century geniuses together. I hope they had translators around. German to English.... English to Geordie.... Geordie to English etc... apparently Robert Stephenson's accent was so broad he really did have a translator with him when he traveled outside of the north east.
@@andymoore9977 Wow, that's a neat fact! (I've been a model railroader since 1953 and a classical music fan before that.) Stay safe.
I remember playing this at music camp while it was pouring rain outside. One of the best experiences of the summer.
I remember seeing a Mynah bird walk to this song.
As a 16 year old i played this with the Lafayette, Indiana symphony in 1966. I have loved it ever since......beautiful overture.
+Robert Gage Amen for music education in High School!
+Robert Gage Hmm. I was 18 in 1966 here in Lafayette, IN. I think I might have been there for the performance. At that big meeting house (I forget the name) a block north of Main St.? Not at Mars theater?
I just heard it done at the indianapolis symphony orchestra!! It was stunning!
i was supposed to play this for my final concert of the session for my youth orchestra and it was cancelled because of the covid-19. this was my favorite piece out of everything we played :(
You will always remember that just as I remember that the school puppet show I was to take part in at Christmas 1957 was cancelled because half the class, including myself, contracted the Asian Flu.
Of course at that time we all stayed in school until sick.
LOL GET REKT
F
Really sorry to hear that:(
Oof
I headed out from the isle of Iona to Staffa where Fingal's cave is located yesterday. The Atlantic surge was too much to be able to moor at the island so we could only just hold on to the sides of the wooden boat while staring into the crashing darkness between the basalt pillars.
Then the captain told us about the crashing of the surf is what inspired Mendelssohn when he came here in 1856(?) to write this piece, and it played over the tannoy while cormorants dived and guillemots swam around us, the sea heaved, the foam sprayed up around the rocks, and the grey seals watched us from their breeding ground around the island's side.
1829.
Yes! ☺️
Wow... this man just managed to use the words tannoy, cormorant, and guillemots.
in the same sentence...
Let's take a moment to recognize his perspicacity
whatever that means
Lord have mercy. Thank you.
@@tarengo3 i wish people still had the ability to speak like this. I love reading it and it's so much more interesting describing it like that
There are two types of people:
“This is a truly beautiful classical masterpiece”
*“YUMMY FRESH MEAT FOR MY POT”*
I am both 😂
Rusty Warlus of Crash Twinsanity x)
I’m the second one.
C'è qualcuno italiano
NAUGHTY MEAT
Went to the Hebrides in a heavy rainstorm. Mendelssohn definitely caught the feeling of those islands on the edge of the North Atlantic.
Went there back in '95, beautiful weather... It was August. I miss the Atlantic... Greetings from Italy
I went from Mull to Iona and then on to Staffa, on a fantastic August day when the sky was blue with fluffy white clouds, the sea was a fabulous azure and the sand as white as snow. It is the most beautiful memory matched by this beautiful music.
@WastingMyLifeInGlasgow
The only other place in the world would have Mynah Birds.
Perhaps the most underestimated of the great composers. And he was nothing less than great.
Definitely agree. My favorite is his Italian Symphony.
I'm sure you love the Scottish. So uplifting and saying Yes to Life!
One of my 5 favourites.
Sheer GENIUS! The quintessential romantic sublime!
I agree with all of you that he is underestimated, and so is Dvorak, to some degree. But they both have composed some beautiful pieces, this one among them.
There is no tune that so invokes the sea as this one. I must have been a seaman in a past life, because I long for this life...
I remember having the little mermaid audio tape when I was a kid each chapter started with this. Always makes me think of plunging to the depths of the ocean!
listen to the first movement of Shahrazade by Rimsky Korsakov who was a captain in the Czar's navy.
What about beginning of 3rd act of Wagner's Tristan und Isolde? That is, to me, the best sea description ever in music.
FTN
@@jaakkokeskinen The sea has many faces. The prelude to Act 3 of Tristan and Isolde sounds like a powerful but largely calm sea, such as the Baltic.
Listen to Wagner's prelude to The Flying Dutchman to get an impression of a stormy sea, such as that which Wagner and his wife experienced on a crossing to England after they had fled Riga in the eastern Baltic.
Or listen to the Sea Interludes in Benjamin Britten's opera Peter Grimes.
Mendelssohn is describing sea passages around Hebridean islands in the eastern Atlantic.
I grew up close to the North Sea coast in Scotland and have seen the Atlantic in Scotland, Ireland, France, Spain, Portugal, Iceland and Norway. It can be a very, very wild indeed. I've been on ferries in a Force 10 gale. The Baltic just doesn't get gales like that.
Such joy! I could taste the salty sea air. majestic. Moving me to tears before that baton was laid aside.
I am actually the proud owner of this powerful piece on a 78 which was recorded in 1928. My maternal grandfather was the previous owner of this 78 which, when played on the old gramophone, he would conduct his invisible orchestra! Ordinarily, his 'conducting' was carried out on a Sunday morning before we all set off to church. I would call into my grand parents house which was on our farm, and I'd find my grandfather wearing his pyjama's and a bow tie. The perfect outfit for all conductors! After he performed this energetic form of art, he'd quickly shower, get properly dressed and before we knew it we were in the church. A brilliant start to a Sunday for any young child!
That's lovely. I have been to Fingal's Cave it is a magical place, like the house of your Grandfather obviously was for you!
@@philipwilliams5808It is indeed. I visited it yonks ago, the music coursing through my mind as I oggled the basalt columns - that's the trouble with being a geologist we 'consume' the rocks.
@@Volcano-Man Hi Gerard, It must be very gneiss to be a geologist!
That is such a wonderful story.
@@kithughesx Bless you - thanks! Just a wee trip down memory lane and music does tend to draw us there. Enjoy your day.
How can one dislike such a masterpiece?!
Not everyone can truly comprehend a masterpiece. Totally understand your reaction tho!
Go figure?
I think the appreciation of music its pretty subjective . Many people out there would discard classical music all together.
I've been to the actual cave. Unbelievable beauty. Music is the only way to describe it, because it's beyond words.
Thats impressive. Im from the west coast, and like many people from an area, we are the worst tourists and don't explore as we should. That cave, from pictures, I would describe as a natural cathedral, so it must be something in reality.
I wonder if there are any Mynah Birds in that cave?
Both a Tuba Player and a Crash fan at the same time i love it.
Tubas rule!
I a Tubaist also loved the transcription we played in college. Hard Hard Hard but twice the fun. Never got to play it with the Symphony.
I'm a mynah bird lover.
"That's the beauty of music. They can't get that from you... You need it so you don't forget...there are places in this world that aren't made out of stone. That there's something inside... that they can't get to, that they can't touch - that's yours."
-- Andy Dufresne, "The Shawshank Redemption"
YUMMY FRESH MEAT FOR MY POT
You told what I would have if I had had the inspiration to express that in words...
Wonderful!!
beautifully expressed!
Ah, but, Fingal's Cave is completely made of stone!
I also listened to this at primary school in the 1960’s,we used to lie down and close our eyes to listen.Magical,a distant time now 😢
When I was a child of 7 in England and my brother was 9, we loved this piece of music whenever it was played on the radio. That's the only place we heard it. We'd sit there transfixed. So beautiful.
1x speed: what lovely music i'm listening to
1.5x speed: AHHH YUMMY! FRESH MEAT FOR MY POT!!
😂
I precisely came for that game and I didn't expect to find any comment referencing it
confusion
This and the Scottish symphony make me miss Scotland and I've never even been there.
I have the same feelings about Scotland, but I've been there twice and it's breathtakingly amazing!
I feel the same way about "Donald Where's Your Troosers?"
DanceCommandant oh you bloody heathen😂😂
amazingly beautiful country. pity it has the worst weather on earth... oh and my horrible, toxic mother lives there, so i will make do with memories...
why does this overture make me think of Luis Buñuel?
Same, bro, same. I feel some weird kind of patriotism for this country without ever having been there :'D
I have been inside this cave. One little known fact...if you are well inside the cave, and look towards the entrance, you can see the entrance framing the Isle of Iona.
Staffa.
Where is this cave?
@@marciep3535 It's on the island of Staffa, in the Inner Hebrides, Scotland.
@@alexgabriel5650 Thank you
@@marciep3535 You are welcome :)
I wonder if Mendelssohn was freaking out when he wrote this, thinking "This is really good. It's going to be a classic. 200 years from now, people will download this from the internet and leaving comments on how good it is. This is great!"
James A ""This is really good. It's going to be a classic. 200 years from now, people will download this from the internet and leaving comments on how good it is." , and that darn Mynah Bird:).
Wow. He conceived of the internet at the same time as writing this piece. Extraordinary...
Having twice been in the actual Fingal's Cave in the island of Staffa, this has particular significance both for the peerless music and the natural grandeur of the Cave itself. No wonder Mendelssohn was moved to compose this superb piece.
I first heard this on that 1943 film, The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp, when the main character went to the POW camp after WW1 to find his prewar German friend. That music was playing in the background, and I liked it so much, I looked it up 😊
Rusty Walrus theme sounds beautiful😍
Tears in my eyes- this is what music is all about - emotion
Lenny V so very, VERY true! 😎
Lenny V ... and mathematics and instruments and people ...
it's all about the crash twinsanity remakes for the song and fresh meat for my pot
Further proof that the best music is composed by whites.
@@John-qj2xi Ha ha ha ha ha - what a ignorant remark, Mr White Supremacist.
So many appreciative comments here...
And I, too, have much to recognise, acknowledge and appreciate.
My reception teacher, Miss Irwin, in 1959, was an outstanding teacher and musician.
Sadly, long gone, I pay public tribute to a truly lovely lady who helped to shape my life and life-long interest in music.
RIP Miss Irwin.
I had the pleasure of hearing this live in LA and I cried like a baby.
Lovely Shrew::: At least you're honest. Most beautiful women lie habitually.
Why?
Mr Felix Mendelssohn ... you composed many breath taking Masterpieces. I admire and have always thought of you as among the all time great composers in the same level as Bach, Handel, Schubert, Schumann, Tchaikovsky, Brahms, Mozart and Beethoven.
Lennon, McCartney...
i love Mendhellsohn. It's underrated.
@@agenziapagano4928 he’s*
@@agenziapagano4928 Mendelssohn...
Likewise! I grew up listening to everything in Classical music, and Mendelssohn has been always among my dearest composers. Playing the piano, I asked my father his book for piano Romance without Words, which I got for one of my birthdays as a teen. Such a joy to be able to play his wonderful compositions.
There are two people who listen to this song.
Classical music enjoyers
And Crash twinsanity fans.
Or those who appreciate the Mynah Bird
I played crash twinsanity years ago and I DIDN’T EVEN RECOGNIZE THIS MUSIC BUT I SAW THE NAME OF THE SONG
My favourite classical piece. Criminally underrated, and pure genius.
In what way is it criminally underrated?
@@alancumming6407 That's just a turn of phrase for saying that the person who likes the piece thinks that others who don't or don't even know it are philistines for not appreciating it.
@@alicemilne1444 Yes that's it. Well said.
@@alicemilne1444 No, unfortunately I had never heard of this until just recently. When I was a kid, they never taught anything in school about Felix Mendelsohn and whenever anyone plays classical music it's always the same old Mozart and Beethoven stuff over and over again.
@ct6502 That's a pity. There's so much more than those two, isn't there? Still, it means plenty to discover.
Was there ever a piece of music that so perfectly captured the ebb and flow...the constant
rise and fall of the ocean in all its moods? I think not. A top orchestra and conductor
do it justice here.
It's a wonderful work, Mark. Allow me to suggest you listen to "La Mer" (The Sea) by Debussy. With closed eyes.
I can think of at least 2 composers who had storm passages(pardon th pun)in their music. BEETHOVEN the Pastoral Symphony and KORSAKOV'S Scherezade
They were pretty good yes? They really are exactly like natural storms. Beethoven th thunder& th storm moving on. Korsakov's sea storm - u can imagine th swell of waves growing taller & more violent! PJS.
@@neilbriscoewhite4953 Thanks Neil. I know Debussy's La Mer and agree
with your point about its quality in thsi regard.
@@petersmith9077 Peter - absolutely right. It requires not only a musical
skill but the necessary imagination to write music of this sort. In more
modern times Richard Rodgers wrote some fine music in a similar nautical vein for the 1950s TV series "Victory at Sea" (arranged by R.R.Bennett, I seem to recall). The title theme "Song of the High Seas" was a good example.
Just by listening to this masterpiece ,
the worries of this fleeting life will be blown away
From Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
We are living in extremly strange times and the world is in stress factor but listening to classical music seems to take the worrying pressure away if only for a short while to the people of Japan be careful keep safe take care love as always Dave ENGLAND a land next door to heaven
@@davidbarber4709
Thank-you
Take care of yourself
Good luck ！
For the second year in a row , we have refrained from the banquet under the cherry blossoms in full bloom in the parks of Tokyo , which is a very pity .
Yes these are stressful times and good wholesome music helps. And watching Baby Sea Otter Joey & Friends also provides hours of relaxation. Hope you are well.
@@cdog9559
Thank-you so much to your wonderful comments
Which is your country ？
nothing made me feel more whole than playing a piece like this in class. i miss those days.
I am 67 And I just love this maybe because I am scottish
50 years old and just joined a symphony orchestra in my area. Never played this before and I love it.
@@lynnharris2934
Cook
Fantastic tone poem and an amazing way of tuning into the life all around. Mendelssohn was a true artist.
Indeed, much like the sacred Mynah Bird.
Did not make it to The Hebrides on our recent Scotland tour. Yet made it to Skye, and couldn’t help but whistle this masterpiece upon which our tour guide said, “You whistle that quite nicely.” 🎶
The Isle of Skye is part of the Inner Hebrides, so technically you did make it to the Hebrides. 🤓
I love this piece. I always think of a windy, cloudy day at the beach when I hear this, the cold air biting.
I love this piece. It moves me and inspires me. Mendelssohn was indeed one of the greatest composers of his time and one of the greats of the ages. Thank you for loading this wonderful work of art for the world to enjoy!
Just beautiful;
@@jackporter9257
It is the Mynah Bird that is truly beautiful.
My absolutely favorite piece of music. Something majestic and airy about this emotional experience absorbing this performance. I wish Mendelssohn had a larger library of compositions. But ill settle for this small piece of perfection
His violin concerto is amazing though
@@palmermonsen9098 @jeffrey burger His Octet for Strings is one of the greatest pieces of chamber music ever written and he wrote it when he was....wait for it....16.
This small piece of perfection is made better by a small walking Mynah Bird.
6:48 , I m pretty sure Wagner take inspiration of this part for beginning of walkyrie theme
*COME BACK HERE NAUGHTY MEAT*
Totally agree!
You can say that this song will never get... rusty.
Crash Twinsanity
Rusty Walrus ;-)
Clever. :)
“Ah! Yummy fresh meat for my pot!!
Thank goodness I'm not the only one!
The clarinet soli at 7:46 is one of the most beautiful things ever written for the instrument.
Truly magical x
We had a teacher in 1970. Miss Lamb. She taught us well and exposed us to this early. Her father was the choir master at the Cathedral. I remember those days from the 70s well.
"YUMMY, FRESH MEAT FOR ME POT!"
"COME BACK HERE, NAUGHTY MEAT!"
What's this reference
I've never been to the Hebrides and most likely never will, but this music helps imagine those islands. Thank you.
You are seriously missing out, these islands are wonderful, just like the music !
love you mendy!
AHHHH YUMMY... FRESH MEAT FOR MY POT
I had the great good fortune to be invited to go to Fingal's Cave, on an island off Mull, when visiting the Hebrides. Mendelssohn's musical imagination captures the place wonderfully, down to the surging tides and eddies by the cave mouth. Listen, and you're there! Promise.
Staffa one of the Inner Hebrides.
El re"descubridor" de J. S. Bach. Uno de los más grandes compositores del romanticismo
I visited Fingal's Cave on Staffa last week with my family and little dog. Oh my goodness, it was amazing. It was particularly poignant as Staffa tours play this music as they enter the cave before you get off the boat to explore. It is really worth the journey and so moving to listen to this piece of music.
Did a little Mynah Bird walk by?
Nada mas brillante que empezar la mañana con esta hermosa obra de Mendelssohn
Si, tienes razon
"AAHHHH YOOMY, FRESH MEAT FOR MAH POT!!"
-That one Walrus
COME BACK HERE NAUGHTY MEAT!!!!!
"Now from the gray mist of the ocean the white-sailed ships of Fingal appear. High is the grove of their masts, as they nod, by turns, on the rolling wave. Swaran saw them from the hill. He returned from the sons of Erin. As ebbs the resounding sea, through the hundred isles of Inistore; so loud, so vast, so immense, returned the sons of Lochlin against the king. But bending, weeping, sad, and slow, and dragging his long spear behind, Cuthullin sunk in Cromla's wood, and mourned his fallen friends. He feared the face of Fingal, who was wont to greet him from the fields of renown! ... Fingal, tall in his ship, stretched his bright lance before him. Terrible was the gleam of his steel: It was like the green meteor of death, setting in the heath of Malmor, when the traveller is alone, and the broad moon is darkened in heaven." (Epic of Fingal III from the Poems of Ossian)
I have to find that , thank you 😊
This masterpiece of literature is echoed in the masterpiece of a musical work! Thanks for your comment!👌👍
Thankyou. This transported me away from all the idiocy and madness and onto beautiful landscapes of legends and myth with mountains and storm lashed coves.
The most sublime melody ever written
More sublime than the Mynah Bird?
What in Gods name mendelssohn was a genius!!**
C'est MAGNIFIQUE!!!
Oui, c'est vrais! Bon chance!
Oui!!!!
This the kind of music that sets the imagination and emotions, perhaps it will entice the other music lover to classical music..
I can’t help but think of a hungry walrus chasing me when I hear this song lol
Wow- amazing! Such a beautiful, haunting melody to listen to on a cold evening huddling in a warm room.
So true Mark Pope
I totally agree
If you have a warm room..
This was my gateway drug for classical music
There was a cartoon that featured a snippet of this when I watched as a kid.Never bothered to listen to the entire piece till now. Genius. Artstry. Combined.
Inki and the Minah bird
@@manuel2cinco6 ha!
Muy cierto , buscando ese cartoon y por un comentario sobre el autor de esta pieza de arte estoy aquí
forever masterpiece in music history~!!👍👍
I first heard this sometime in the '80s in an old "Don Winslow of the Navy" serial; it was the main theme of the show IIRC. Anyway the music wasn't attributed; it took me some 20 years to finally learn the name and composer, but I never forgot its haunting beauty. Nor have I forgotten since.
The "Don Winslow
Of the Navy" serial was the first time I heard this too. The main theme played when the enemy submarine appeared. Took a long time to discover the entire piece. Then I found Otto Klemperer's recording of it. (That record also had Mendelssohn's "Scottish" and "Italian" symphonies).
Absolutely love Mendelsohn - his music gives serenity to my soul and heart- especially this particularly...
One of my favorite pieces... Performed this in high school orchestra at state competition with a 10/10 from all judges. Our orchestra was very, very good at the time, I was a violist and performing this in a very well put together group is intense! One of my best memories.
That's so awesome
sublime is an understatement in describing this gift by Mendelssohn.
Michael Lee AH Yummy Fresh meat for my Pot!
Enjoying this beautiful music while in Lock down here in the UK.
Love and blessing from Wolverhampton England to you all.
@Kit stay safe and blessed Kit. 👍
Hi from Los Angeles
@@elionaidgranados1005 I've subscribed to your channel
@Kit I've subscribed to your channel
Listening to this very late one Sunday night - (well, easily Monday morning now ...) I am just reminded of what an underrated genius Felix Mendelssohn was. There is something about this piece of music that takes you right to the place the inspired him ... I feel like I am in that cave on that Scottish isle looking out on to the world with different eyes ... perhaps, sharing his eyes of the time? I feel connected.
In fact, about twenty five years ago I did just that very thing - I have piece of paino music that I wrote, it's stashed away somewhere, and it was provisionally entitled 'Scottish Isle piece' It doesn't bear much resemblance to this Mendelssohn masterpiece other than the mood and the concept. But over a couple of days in the mid nineties I was completely taken with a theme I had in my head and I fleshed out a piece for piano ...i must dig it out sometime soon.
This was the piece that introduced me to classical music at the age of 14.
It's such a delight to listen this song in the background...
...even more if in the meantime you get chased by a hungry walrus
AH! YUMMY, FRESH MEAT FOR MY POT!
It is so sad that Miley Cyrus is getting hundreds of millions of views, but truly wonderful works like this are stuck at 130,000.
nobody will ever forget the real beauty of music.
***** I agree, but that doesn't make it any better. It is art since it is music, denying that would be immature and just simply incorrect. Just because I don't like it doesn't mean I don't perceive it as art, but it still irritates me incredibly for the fact that, like you said, it shows where we are as a society and a culture. And that is a very low, very narrow-minded and superficial place that we have reached.
Sad?
It's CRIMINAL!
***** you have your view, not sure its an accurate one--Ive never listened to ONE Cyrus, or what ever her name is--but have listened to 10 different versions of this immortal work alone. Which will be listened to in 500 yrs--the answer is obvious--
3 years later...549,467
One of my favourite pieces of classical music
First time ever hearing classical music I was 7 and absolutely enthralled. Love other forms, but my classics are my home.
My old school friend Bill had this played at his funeral. He spent every summer holidaying in the Scottish isles.
So easy to imagine the waves "crashing" on to the rocks and then swilling away.
That is clever. Thanks stranger from seven months ago
@@Willcon970
Hi stranger from a month ago. All hail the mighty Mynah Bird.
@@doddsino hi stranger from eleven hours ago, I just checked my notifications
I'm studying Classical Music and felt I'd lost all love for the subject, but this piece ALWAYS rekindles it. It's so beautiful.
I'm studying Mynah Birds.
Imagine floating on this music, crossing the Hebrides, can we ever come closer to heaven?
A great masterpiece! I often listen to this beautifull music.. close my eyes and imagine I am at the Hebrides.
"..And we in dreams behold the Hebrides"
After visiting many of the islands it's quite moving to hear this music again capturing the mood and rugged beauty of such an outstanding part of the world
We live on a planet with some extraordinary stunning places and the inner and outer Hebrides counts as one of them
This is perfection.... and we're playing this with our chestra, I'm so happy:3
Me too
I play trumpet in it now with our amateur orchestra. Here I hear that much dynamics is indeed inherent to this piece but it's rarely coming from the instruments that find this the most easy : the brass.
Sends shivers every time!!!
If I had to name my favorite classical composition, it would be this.
+Joe Hargrave May I suggest you check out his Violin Concerto? You won't regret it. :)
Wow! That is really saying a lot...with all the music over the centuries!!
i agree with peace harmony, and get an earful of his third symphony if you have a mo, second movement (starts at about 17 min): th-cam.com/video/FbH95mO_o3A/w-d-xo.html
I am going to hear this tonight at the Sydney Town Hall - Sydney Symphony orchestra and I am so excited ...never heard it live and I think this is one the most evocative pieces of music of all time.
Got to play this on double bass many years ago and as difficult as it was, I still look back with fond memories of playing this piece. That was at least 10 years ago
The opportunity to visit Fingal's cave as I did recently and experience first hand where the young Mendelssohn envisioned this wonderful overture was sublime. It perfectly translates the beauty and tumult of this remarkable place.
Totally agree,a beautiful piece that captures that emotion.
This work is the acme of his genius
I was introduced to this in school, aged 11, and it remains a favourite,
Me to loved it ever since
Beautiful, and beautifully rendered by a master conductor.
this is the piece of music which got me into classical symphonium music........still love this, just about my fave piece.....
I'm the very same, this is the first life of classical music I ever heard. I was 12 and in school and I fell in love with it.
We are going to Scotland, hopefully in May. One of our stops will be Iona, the Ferry to Staffa and Finns Cave the inspiration for this masterpiece is there!
Came straight to the comments to see the other people who have the same soul as me & love this music!
Mendelssohn's symphony that immortalized the Hebrides.
Rui alberto Costa very much
Thank you! So important to keep this genre going strong- mendelssohn and Sebelius are like superheros
A great piece, conducted by a great conductor!
what about the chase man Rusty Walrus
I was listening to this piece while I was at a park, observing the river and the green trees and grass 💚
I'm listening to this and there is a strange bird following me.
Deve ser um alienigena querendo ouvir a musica extraordinaria que você está oivindo.
Hha
The worlds a mystery
its me
photos1.blogger.com/blogger/4525/2278/1600/InkiMinahBird01.jpg
A truly great composer and yet many people pass over him without a glance he deserves more recognition. Only true connoisseurs of music recognise this man's genius.
Sheer GENIUS! The quintessential romantic sublime!
Mendelson, es genial su música te da una paz infinita