Why Modi-Shah have failed to replicate Vajpayee-Advani's success in building mass leaders for BJP
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ต.ค. 2024
- #PoliticallyCorrect #ModiShah
Loyalty, not merit, as promotion criterion, insecurities, wrong judgement? There are questions galore about why Modi-Shah failed to develop mass leaders for BJP in states as Vajpayee-Advani did, ThePrint Political Editor DK Singh explains in this episode of Politically Correct.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read 2019 Politically Correct here: theprint.in/op...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read this week's Politically Correct here: theprint.in/op...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
Vajpayee and Advani had a humane approach. The Modi Shah combination have become ruthless which will lead to bad electoral loss.
Last 10 years proved something else lets see time will tell.
As long as sangh is their bjp will never have leadership vaccum, they will find new leadership they always have, fadnavis, yogi, shivraj mama trio will lead party after these 2
Vajpayee was Nehru 2.0.....Incompetent and indecisive......PM Modi is decisive and a true nationalist.....No wonder India-haters are Modi-haters as well.....Shame on them
Modi-Shah are Indira-Sanjay Gandhi of BJP. The have done to BJP what older duo did to Congress. Basically destroy internal party structure and cadre and make it completely hollow organisation that is dependent on personality cult. The cult can not remain forever and it will crumble the organisation like house of cards.
They are insecure. Also, they are greedy. Huge mistake on BJP part to bank on Modi
PM Modi is competent, decisive and a true nationalist.....No wonder India-haters are Modi-haters as well.....Shame on them
Modi-shah has a big fond of bootlickers (chatukaar) . It sometimes seems they themselves don't want anyone chart out of their shadows. Modi has weakened bjps ideology in the long run a big power vacuum will emerge once he leaves
Which ideology was weekened.
Did you ever support BJP's ideology, that you feel qualified to make a comment? I don't think so.
Fadnavis is very much the face of the BJP in Maha. He hasn't been sidelined at all.
he's being made the face to take the fall for the disaster that's going to happen this election.
Scary for those who care about BJP
What a valid point. Rightly pointed out.
In bihar bjp don't have any face
10 करोड़ सदस्य वाली पार्टी से सोशलमीडिया के पोस्ट पर हजार लाइक और शेयर नहीं आता वही कांग्रेस के ऐक छोटा सा पोस्ट वायरल हो जाता है
Vajpayee and Advani did not have 1/100000000th of the financial/corporate interests and entanglements that these two have. They are running a corporation not a party.
Very nice analysis DKS
Modi should not be compared with Vajpayee. Even if he is a person of RSS, its principles in any context It is not imposed on people. fanatics Never encouraged. Never indulged in corruption. Mainly Vajpayee A selfless patriot. If Vajpayee is the Himalaya, Modi is a small rock at its base.
Modi is a piece of gobar😅😅
Vajpayee was Nehru 2.0.....Incompetent and indecisive......PM Modi is decisive and a true nationalist.....No wonder India-haters are Modi-haters as well.....Shame on them
Itne din kaha the aap😢
Wait. Few months before you told BJP has good HR policy. I sense you just change your views with the market.
they thought abouth themself only thats why
Modi-shah combo gave way for leaders like Yogiji, Hemanth biswa sarma, Devendra Fadnavis, Annamalai, Vishnu Deo of Chhattisgarh, Arunachal CM etc.
But i agree Vajpayee-Advani combo gave so many leaders to nation including Modiji.
@@shortentertainment93Yogi stands on his own
@@shortentertainment93Hemanth is a congress import
@@shortentertainment93Annamalai flopped harder than the movies by SRK after 2015
The absence of not coming any episode of Politically correct could not be better restitution than seeing this superb commentary on Modi-Shan and Atal-Advani era with plethora of leaders and their comparison. DK sir, each and every minute of this episode was worth watching and deserves standing ovation. It looks that in another 10-15 years BJP may come down to 2 seats then a new Jodi would come and party may rise like a phoenix. As of now I am able to understand what you might have pointed out in between the lines. Hats off for this flawless episode. Respect sir
while modi shah and BJP are a separate problem, even congress and other opposition parties have lausy leadership structure...unless we have real inner party democracy in all political parties all are just pvt ltd cos
They Will from 2026 -27 As We All Know Ajit Shah is Not a Pan India Mass Leader in Fast " No Leader "
Excellent analysis!
Yogi , himanta , fadnavis are the next generation of leaders and they have proved themselves in their respective states.
Will the others accept them is the question of the hour. Advani ji succeeded Vajpayee ji. Similarly Amit Shah will succeed Midi. But is that what BJP want? Or does it matter what's good for BJP infront of Amit Shah's ambition?
They have proved themselves to be suckers and the worst hate crimes and fascism
Great video Sir.Thanks🙏
You should have regular episode on print, pleaee guy like this comment to make sure we have more dk singh episode on regular basis.
Sir Vajpayee and Advani are true Politicians who had decency..These 2 present men are like Rowdies...pretty cheap in their public speeches and campaigns and governance...They dont even know they are architects of hate and hate only...both in looks and acts
They didn't failed in gardening leader's but never wanted to do so, always applauded lickers like Mohan Yadav, Khattar,Bhajanlal, Bhupendra Patel etc
Yogi akela bhari padega aane wale time mein. Modi maargdarshan mandal mein jaega
Bang on analysis..
They need to make way..
Thats their style.. they never groomed any one in gujrat.. or they do not allow anyone to groom.
But these modi sha leader ship are assiduously promoting Kangana ranaut as the next best happening in the country. Why anyone should care for second tier leader ship in the party?!
Good one
Make a similar analysis of the Contgress
An incisive analysis of BJP’s HR failures👍. Not good for BJP and ultimately for the nation.
It's good for nation but not for bhakts like you😅😅
Bjp is cadre party sangh will find new leadership they always have, even with all their experiments out of which 99% failed, few exceptions emerged out - yogi ji is obvious pure mass leader more popular than any other cm in country, Fadnavis no matter what ur opinion about him, he will be essential to party with complete backing of sangh also age is on his side among all current Maharashtra leader he is youngest, than u have emerging young talent of op Chaudhary current finance minister of Chattisgarh ex ias, Annmalai in tamil nadu, By vijendra is heir to his father bsy, Bandi Sanjay in telangana, himantha in north east, I don't agree their will be vaccum like other family Base party face
Faddnavis ... sahab... never give up..
Is it EXIT POLLS or EXIT modi-amitshah
Fadnavis is a casualty of BJP-SS split. If they got the Shinde faction to defect, then the faction had to be appeased, by making Shinde as CM.
At the end of the day, India is a caste-ridden country. BJP believes Hindutva can make people forget their caste identity, and prioritize their Hindu identity. But reality is different.
Only urbanization can dissolve caste identity.
And we still hate cities. Congress has played a good game of pitting rural areas against cities, by opposition to farm reform laws, opposing manufacturing, and peddling rural freebies at the cost of urban development.
Land acquisition was already thwarted, by an Amendment in 2013, and with Modi backing out of a correction in 2015, when Rahul shouted suit-boot sarkar.
It's a longer game of slowly opposing every reform by the Congress. And BJP has not countered that.
Congress does not need to do anything, but maintain status quo of the existing problems and pretend to be saviour of one from another, without solving them. The guy who wants to solve it, will always find it difficult.
Open but camouflaged venom in the form of analysis. Brilliant.
Annamalai?
Still believing him? he is no longer interested in it and left to London.
The Tide have turned
I am Concern Of Amir Shah Fatty
Had Modi got 300 seats the analysis would have remained locked up for another day..
Analysis is based on reality not on conjectures 😅😅😅
मोदी शाह को चाटुकारिता का लगाव हो गया है नड्डा और अमित मालवीय की परफॉरमेंस कोई देख क्यों नहीं रहा 10 करोड़ सदस्य वाली पार्टी के पेज पर हजार लाईक और शेयर नहीं आते और कोई कांग्रेस के पेज पर जाके देखता तक नहीं की कैसे उनके पोस्ट वायरल हो रहे हैं
Yogi,Himanta ,Fadnavis are leaderships built by Modi and Shah only....Win or loss can happen after 10 years of antiincumbency...How the political pandits change language after one election.
Hey far left comrade yogi ji , mama ji, hemant sharma ji coming in 2029 🤫 Please run for funding 😅 for your unbiased journalism 🤫 donate to run The print.