Will Tesla's Optimus robot become a reality? | FT Tech
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ก.ย. 2022
- Do humanoid robots have a future? As Elon Musk demonstrates a humanoid robot, we explore Engineered Arts - a humanoid robot factory with the creator of a highly realistic looking robot. Experts analyse Musk's proposals so far, looking at how these robots could become a reality.
#humanoid #humanoidrobot #robotics #robot #technology #tech
Produced and directed by Tom Hannen. Additional filming by Richard Topping, Nicola Stansfield, and Horacio Jones
See if you get the FT for free as a student (ft.com/schoolsarefree) or start a £1 trial: subs.ft.com/spa3_trial?segmen....
► To learn more, visit our website - channels.ft.com/en/tech/
► Watch more videos from this series here - • FT Tech
► Check out our Community tab for more stories on the economy.
► Listen to our podcasts: www.ft.com/podcasts
► Follow us on Instagram: / financialtimes'
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 63 | คู่เอก "ยอดภูผา vs โซเนอร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RGVmBsegKEI/mqdefault.jpg)
Yeah, this is going to age well. Saving it for later.
Someone else who thought Ai day was a product launch.... :D
@@D_Rogers He did promise a product in August this year for sale! Just like he did promise all those other things that never happened! But even those lies where not as bad his lies of solar tiles that didnt exist! He took a year to get to 1980! LOL FAIL!
@@danquaylesitsspeltpotatoe8307 Yea, people who make weird and wacky products that often fail are the worst..
They should make colourful iphone covers instead, like sensible people...
I’m not completely disregarding the possibilities, however when I was a child in the 70’s we were given a myriad of futuristic goals. Flying cars were we wouldn’t need roads. Never happened
Here's a thought:
Flying cars in a fictional world - Everything in neatly order, no accidents, nothing ever goes wrong, everything is perfect.
Flying cars in the real world - September 9/11.
@@onsokumaru4663 yea yea yea yea but that's like saying : Here is how stupid people predict consequences and this is how smart people predict consequences.
Any person with more than a family braincell knows that Flying cars would be disastrous idea for humanity not only because all you did is offset ground road problems into air but also the energy requirements to lift a person and car itself into air and then keep it there, not to mention that flying car would have to be light and therefor more fragile than a regular car.....and about 100 more problems that ASSUME that such a project is feasible without sacrificing safety.
@@onsokumaru4663 haha
Such a great insight and from someone in the UK this was brill. Hope to see more of your work! Thanks
Well.. everyone doubted Tesla's ability to reach profitability and now it's getting the laggards of the much larger auto industry to innovate to catch up on the EV front. I think it's lazy reporting on FT's part to get a robotics company supplying trade fair and amusement parks to chime in advanced robotics. Yes, Elon tends to oversell his timelines but dude's execution is mostly on point. Plus he has a hugely cash flow positive business and the world's best engineers at his disposal.
I seriously don't reckon having a small Cornwall based company giving insight on what is fast becoming the biggest most innovative company in the world (hint: Tesla). So much pessimism tsk tsk. You can't do it doesn't mean others cannot.....
Well said:)
It's a decent first attempt but its not even close to living up to the hype. We were seeing more advanced robots a decade ago. Still got a long way to go
@@Feefa99 very true. Onus is now on Tesla to prove otherwise. I also was expecting slightly more out of AI day. However, as a neutral (although one slightly rooting for innovation), my main gripe was FT not even interviewing someone from ex-Darpa or even Boston Dynamics. Instead they got a tourist attraction supplier from Cornwall.
they always doubt but so far...they all cried
> so much pessimism
Good reason for it - Musk has long track record of promising miracles but delivering nothing
Optimus speech commands from a safe distance (2 to 8 meters): No. Just vaporware until then.
In the eyes of skeptics, anything is impossible
I can see them sending a intire fleet of these to mars to begin underground construction of a settlement, together with his spaceships i think that is his long term plan
Now you are starting to think in Bigger Vision Terms! Unlike those trapped in 140 Character Thought lines! (Stock Analysists, News Anchors, etc!)
Very intriguing
6:57 - I think Sarah Connor here is just talking from her experience with T-1000
"The factory doesn't need humanoid robots!!"
* proceeds to show a factory with human workers *
2:50
You seem to miss the point. Previously humans did most of the tedious tasks but instead of literally build a automatic human we instead just built entire automated factories that are way better than any humanoid robot could ever be, they are purpose built. The humans are mostly there for tasks with large varieties or for supervision, you would still want those even if you had a humanoid robot.
@@PhilfreezeCH You seem to have missed my point. The world is built for humans. There will always be non-specific tasks that only a humanoid can perform. That's why we still have humans in factories. For those general tasks. If we simply had humanoid robots they could replace those last humans working in the factory. Your point makes absolutely no sense.
Cook clean and mow the lawn, at a price of a car, and I'm sold.
Assuming it doesn't talk to remote servers and all processing is done locally.
Software has to be open source to trust.
This robot ain't ever gonna happen, just like the cybertruck, semi, robotaxis, hyperloop, etc 🙄 Notice Boston Dynamics and Hondas robots have jetpacks or hunchbacks but Optimus is slimline??? Where on earth will the giant Dojo supercomputer go 😭
Maybe you should marry one, your perfect wife.
Tesla price been "dipping" since the robot reveal... shorts been printing
@@onsokumaru4663 and why not.just need remote control and edit button. And delete.
The correct approach is to have them Look like robots, without faces.
Because we need them for labor.. Nothing else.. If we want a thinking robot or a classroom aid, we should instead focus on something similar to SIRI, CORTANA or BIGSBY .. simply a voice, maybe even something you would see on a screen..
The idea is to not waste time and resource on something unnessesary. Or give a Robot designed to be amongst children the risk of malfunctioning and using its mechanical physical strength to harm kids.
But also limiting OpenAI thinking machines to a limited actions that it can perform in the real world. For example being unable to communicate with or command Physical robots. So its not able to become skynet :)
Elon really seem to envision a Terrminator. " A robot you can run away from, a robot hopefully you can ovetpower"
Excellent video.
Very interesting and great timing.
I hope it does. Ignoring the plot of the movie iRobot, for example having a robot that can pick up prescriptions for me would be great.
It will go the same way as iRobot they will be linkt to the world wide web.. So hackers can take them over.. IA will be smarther then us.. Now you say you are crazy read this agian in 2050 and you say your where right sir.
2:50 In final assembly at Tesla there are a lot of workers working at the line
you need to consider, as the one lady said, someone that can watch over the elderly all day while everyone is out. it doesn't need to carry them around, just watch over them maybe get them a drink or their dinner pills which would be already counted out in some plastic container in advance. and of course to call if they get sick or pass out, links for emergency nearby should be added to their software in case it's needed, so basically an automated person to talk to when you aren't there.
Yeah that will be $150,000 for the unit and $2000 pcm to make sure it runs trhough their subscription service (Sure it's inflated). I do agree and have been looking at creating a kind of robotic assistant. But one that's more vocal so it can keep people entertained. It would hold up a conversation, listen to others and even give reminders and store important "memories". A lot of work though
@@Gh05t_Dev Bonus points if it can operate a deck of cards and a cribbage board.
Do people realise that any machine is prone to malfunctioning, breaking down or not working as it should. That robot watching over your elderly will always need someone to watch it. I also like futuristic sci-fi movies but unfortunately we live in reality and reality has limitations.
@@onsokumaru4663 A modern machine would detect if it is not working as it should, and send for help.
Even a human assistant that you hired to watch your elderly loved ones could have a stroke or heart attack, or (and this has happened) be attacked and killed by feral pigs.
Even if you watch your own loved ones, who is watching you, in case you break down?
@@kevinbailey8827 So what's the point of having a robot that isn't reliable, really? Isn't that adding more costs. And how often do people who work with the elderly get strokes? Please come down to reality mate.
We are going to see robots in the produce aisles shopping and delivering groceries by 2033
older people need a robot to help them
If these became a reality it could help millions of people in so many ways it's a great idea to have a helping hand when needed at home and yes on the work force so humans dont get hurt and can do jobs or things that dont put them in an high risk setting it would also be beneficial for any age that has issues in basic life they are interesting and hope the cost is kept low and yes having a choice of face or no face and voice sound would also be nice just saying
Xiaomi unveiled their humanoid robot a fews weeks ago and it was just embarrassment.
Musk will be lucky to do as well as Xiaomi Cyberone. LOL
Optimus will be as real as its namesake... notice how Boston Dynamics and Honda's robots had jetpacks/hunchbacks full of electronics... how could Optimus ever be so slim? Where's the Dojo chip 😭
@@macavalli2619 Dojo chip is part of the Tesla supercomputer. It’s not intended to be put in commercial products. There’s no dojo chip in the cars there’s just a specialized gpu that runs the neural net which is trained on the dojo supercomputer at Tesla’s data centre.
@@macavalli2619 And a huge battery that is needed for the power hungry CPU and GPU along with all those servos and sensors
It's a start, though. At least they are working on a humanoid robot. There's not many companies doing it. The more the better.
3:52 🤯🤯🤯🤯
Very cool, I'd love to have a robot at home helping with my Grandma. They could talk & go for walks every day together 😃 An awesome SciFi comic series (only read up to collection #2 so far) is called 'Descender' & there's a sequel series called 'Ascender' The artworks truly unique & the story's fantastic
You guys underestimate neural nets capability to take over any task requiring a brain. Given some set of limbs (albeit not perfect), it can do almost anything you can.
He pushed back the AI event to potentially show a prototype
Like the "prototype" Cybertruck.... this ain't ever gonna happen. Notice how Boston Dynamics and Honda Asimov's has hunchback full of electronics??? Where's Tesla gonna put that Dojo chip 😭
@@macavalli2619 tbf the Tesla Optimus isn't meant for acrobatics.
@Jonathan Loeppky yeah exactly that could fit easily. Tesla has AI specialty in the bag, and manufacturing so scaling wouldn't be an issue. The only thing we need to really see improved in these early days is how they get on with 1 walking as they haven't done this before (although this problem has been solved by other companies so easily possible) and 2 the dexterity of the movement in terms of manipulating the world around it.
With this in mind I see the Tesla bot happening very easily at least at a basic level. Maybe pick up item X and place it over at place Y. That alone would have a ton of use and the platform can be improved to be more capable over the next 10, 20, 30+ years just like our smart phones develop over time.
Specific use cases to start, more generalised in the future.
@@macavalli2619 It did happen lmao.
@@conchaiii4167 they changed the body because the concept was unrealistic. Notice how thick the legs are now & how its not straight at permanently bent at the knees, don't even mention the feet
Finally someone is paying attention to one of the greatest possible invention 👍
And they’ll demo a visualisation system powered by a computer which can leverage data via neural nets like nothing before. Give it 2 years and you will be terrified by the progress.
Technology is like evolution nobody should stop evolution
next year , just like what they said about auto pilot car
The next big thing #tesla
What big thing? Musk's butt? LOL
Tesla owns one of the fastest neural network trainer and all the ground work is done so they will have a chance
"Fastest neural network trainer" which still fails at even training Tesla cars to run in small stretch tunnel in Las Vegas. LOL
This robot ain't ever gonna happen. Note how Boston Dynamics and Honda's robots have jetpacks/hunchbacks but Optimus is slimline??? Where on earth will the Dojo supercomputer go 😭
@@macavalli2619 And the battery needed for it to last hours not mins
@@springer-qb4dv When you compare what FSD has learned since 2015 till 2022 compared to how long the biological eye took to develop it's still good, it's still learning.
A chance at their robots crashing into stationery ambulances. Right.
I watch AI Day 2.0 From a thought on AI Day 1.0 Good progress. I truly want to see next year version. Would think some factory deployment .. in 2 years more factory deployment and some external deployment.... This is a thing - It has arrived and in 20 years this will be wide spread.
well we are about to find out
Congratulations and more power
All the Tesla haters be ready for "Who's laughing now" moment.
Who needs Dr. Frankenstein? We have Elon Musk!
"everyone thought that it was a joke" sometimes first impressions are right
Yeah, but my model 3 robotaxi makes me 50k a year since 2019…. Just as promised….
And sometimes they're wrong
160'000 people are now using FSD beta. They do get stuff done.
@@johntheux9238 You mean that baloney "Fool self driving" Teslas? LOL
@@springer-qb4dv That's the point. Any fool can drive it and soon you won't need a driving license.
This is made by the same man that said AI is far more dangerous than nuclear bombs?
Controlling the inevitable might give you the highest probability of preventing the disaster..
The theory of elon is the remedy against poison is antivenom. Always try to think outside the box and set Contols or basic standards than to destroy the technology. Elon is setting standards for AI technology.
This robot won't see the light of day. Notice Boston Dynamics and Hondas robots have jetpacks or hunchbacks but Optimus is slimline??? Where on earth will the Dojo supercomputer go 😭
@@macavalli2619 Dojo chip is part of the Tesla supercomputer. It’s not intended to be put in commercial products. There’s no dojo chip in the cars there’s just a specialized gpu that runs the neural net which is trained on the dojo supercomputer at Tesla’s data centre.
Read Superintelligence: Paths Dangers and Strategies to understand how and why AI is the most dangerous technology that we will ever invent.
What a brilliant video, made available for free. Good job FT. With the presentation completed, this was pretty much spot on.
you must be a bot... or an NPC or both
Yes! It will be one of the most
Am I the only one who read Sarah O'Connor's name in the Terminator voice?
it's the same bg music used in dji mavic 3
If he suceeds this will be great as the cost will hopefully pass down to consumers because products will be cheaper because labor is cheaper.
This is why GBR will be so behind technology compared to China Japan US. Instead of aspiring to compete with the best technologists, the video illustrates why it won’t work or how long it will take. Don’t kill the will!!! Be a go getter GBR!
Kids love robots.
No mention of the software here, Tesla FSD can perceive objects on the road and react, the robot is an adjacent market. AI = neural nets plus lots of training data.
yes but compact those into a humanoid is very difficult
@@jetli740 The FSD computer and cameras in a Tesla are quite small, the FSD computer fits behind the glove box.
@@jetli740 The difficult thing will be to record data to train the AI. Unlike cars there is no one behind the wheels for a robot.
This robot ain't ever gonna happen, just like the cybertruck, semi, robotaxis, hyperloop, etc 🙄 Notice Boston Dynamics and Hondas robots have jetpacks or hunchbacks but Optimus is slimline??? Where on earth will the giant Dojo supercomputer go 😭
@@johntheux9238 record data can be done the same way as how they train car through simulation and build actual prop. the main
problem all robot have is how it interact with it environment and then hand atm it very clumsy, it need to improve a lot
battery is another problem for musk robot
a slim robot like that dont have much room for battery.
most likely they will have to have a back pack for battery
excellent work
This price was quite Educational
Moments before you do it !
Thank you so much for sharing very much appreciated…
Tesla Bots come to improve what we call Life in some point remember inside all new kind of Idea there’s always those will be fight against of it for example here the creation of personal computers Steve Jobs knew about every people and company in some way will be owner of a personal Computer in home sure the idea was deeply denied so observe now a day must of us carrying on the pockets…
Elon Musk must share the efforts as well with Boston Dynamics and yes the Progress will be must Efficiently Acceptable…
Wonder if Boston dynamics will get bought by a larger company like Google, Microsoft, Apple, or Amazon who could provide a lot more compute power so that they could do an AI/Machine Learning approach to controlling robots.
Its 100 privately owned by Hyundai motors
Boston Dynamics was owned by Google / alphabet but they sold it to SoftBank. Which i think was a mistake that alphabet sold it.
needs to design it to deal with kids hanging off it , dogs jumping up it etc etc .
This robot has a 3.7 kWh battery pack, problem is that would be larger than its torso so where will everything else be stored??? Nvm Asimo & Atlas have hunchbacks to house electronics... oh and it can only be used for 1 HOUR before needing a 6 HOUR charge... can you spell USELESS?
In the home should not be the target market. Think businesses even small businesses where this easily could replace receptionists, go-fers, and I'm thinking security services, especially overnight security. That alone, night watchman, would be huge and actually BETTER than the two humans each position now requires. This robot won't fall asleep on the job, won't drink on the job, won't do drugs on the job - that alone is huge. It has better hearing, sight (infrared?), and doesn't need a potty break or want to go on vacation.
The bots are great for mars for construction
what should be the ecological cost to democratise i-robots ?
Cgi part says a lot
Finally some lucid thinking about this...
Automation has made the few richer and the masses with less opportunities.
Elon Rocks! Underestimate him at your peril !
He's a Jesuit Order puppet like those in the political theatrical pantomime arena
All scientists (unknown) working in Tesla/spacex rocks.
Elon the rockhead? The guy has never invented anything. LOL
Elon, the Genius who gave us the Cybertruck, robotaxi, hyperloop, semi PROTOTYPES. This robot won't see the light of day. Notice Boston Dynamics and Hondas robots have jetpacks or hunchbacks but Optimus is slimline??? Where on earth will the Dojo supercomputer go 😭
I have nearly 17,000 of TSLA Stock currently, every penny I get spare buys more of the stuff. Naysayers please set a timer and revisit your comments 5 years hence. Have a stiff drink beside you and a large slice of humble pie.
Thank you for showing the Terminator in a red light-- not at all clickbaity or hyperbolic definitely going to happen with the Tesla bot definitely, no doubt;)
I’ll buy it ONLY if it won’t blow up like my model 3.
Did you know that when one Tesla Bot learns something, it uploads the learned information to the A.I. mind cloud AKA SkyNet so that all Tesla Bots can access the new, learned information? That’s how Tesla’s A.I. works. For example, if you’re fighting back against a Tesla Bot attacking you and you’re lucky enough to destroy it, it would have uploaded information about who you are to SkyNet by the time that it’s destroyed and dozens of other Tesla Bots, which are all being operated by the same A.I. mind via SkyNet, will find you and destroy you.
I think everyone actually knows the answer to the question in the title. If Musk put as much effort into their innovations as they do into CGI…
XO.
00:10 It's December 2023 and they just did that.
10:34 when the robot revolution happens she’s gonna go first.
Eventually no one will have to work AI will do all the work and generate great wealth that will be distributed amongst the humans? Maybe?
Lmao no
This is the childish naive thoughts this big companies want you to believe my pal
@@biomuseum6645 I don't even think big corporations think that way either. It's honestly more of a super fictional dystopia created by a crazy imagination.
@@daquack1460 kind of, and a cultural phenomenon also
I did say maybe, it can either go 2 ways ones good the other bad, we have to wait and see?
Dreamers push humanity forward. Skeptics like the Financial Times hold us back.
I think it’s a typical British way of envying and remembered their old golden days,
@@GoodLordandGod exactly. Europe just want’s to regulate everything and tax it. It kills growth and start ups.
Wrong. Plentiful energy and resources push humanity forward... over the cliff once it runs out.
Dreamers buy bridges like the cybertruck, semi, hyperloop, robotaxis, etc that's been promised for yeeeeaaarrrrssss but yeah daddy Elon (which means Emerald in Afrikaans 🇿🇦) will *deliver a working "prototype" in under 2 years. Notice Boston Dynamics and Hondas robots have jetpacks or hunchbacks but Optimus is slimline??? Where on earth will the Dojo supercomputer go 😭
i'll be happy with a BB-8 type robot
🤣😂😅🤖
We are working ourselves out of a job as a species.
If Goodyear don't learn EV technology, it's not going to be a good time when Robots take over your mechanics
A future without human labour !😊
Tiling days are numbered 🖐
Yeah i would prefer tesla screen face, it'll be entertaining and funny with his emoji face
Well this guy was mostly wrong.
At the tech event where the prototype was showcased...there was ZERO CGI.
There was also almost nothing that was impressive. They had to hold the goddam thing up. It was pathetic
Good luck with that lol , I wouldn't have one in my house. Thanks will Smith.
You have all electronic devices what would be different with the extra one more.
@@kairuannewambui8456 a wash machine is not as creepy as Tesla bot
ha interesting showing this only 9 days before tesla presentation haha maybe they already know😂
Honda tried with Asimo! The limitation was software
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
And now it really comes.
Whatever that means lmao.
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
bc Elon and Tesla has the most military contracts than any other company in the last 2 years
why show unrelated crash scenes while talking about self driving, stop manipulating ft
Like everything Elon does, most people just won't get it at first, the very first thing they want to do is compare it to existing products in the market, and then jump to conclusions.
What Boston and atlas developed, is a robot, tesla bod is something different because of Ai incorporated into the bod.
i just want some robussy
#JobsAreForRobots
Is this before Ai day at Tesla? They’re coming - and soon.
These "experts" have never built an economical, mass produced item..ever...!
Go Tesla!
Go Muskbot!
No.
>> Tesla has one of the best automated car production lines in the world
With production quality being outright terrible, lol.
That's right, Tesla cars are expensive luxury cars with production quality worse than cheap Kia.
Source: Tesla owner, he still likes it overall, thanks to autopilot and electronics, but assembly quality is awful.
I don’t even have an Alexa in my home cuz I don’t like the idea of cameras, recording, etc just always being on (he typed with his iPhone… I know)
Hahaa there was NO CGI with unit one!! such a a bad forecast
👽
Tesla is using unit one on their industrial plants; not in complex situations yet but nonetheless this unit will be mass produced - it’s NOT “decades” away…
iRobot 2004
iRobot the film will be a resemblance
COOL 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
The comments from this guy just go to show why he’s missed the boat. He simply does not get what Tesla are doing. Must be hard as a Humanoid Robot maker, seeing that you are screwed…