"Winter can't sing live"
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 พ.ค. 2022
- The clips aren't mine they are belong to the rightful owners @aespa
Winter at coachella
Aespa at Coachella Live
Minjeong/Winter High notes
#fyp #coachella #aespa #winter #minjeong #trending #naevis #my #savage #nextlevel. - บันเทิง
![[4K] LE SSERAFIM - “FEARLESS” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mX3CmeEv0KY/mqdefault.jpg)
She eats CD's fo breakfast..
@@lilylkxthey sound exactly like the recording
Yoo I thought Nmixx was the only ones how didnt I know she did too 🤯
@@V3nelopeyou were living under a rock 😂😂
@@Human-eg7yf girlll... pipe down it was sarcasm 🙃😂
@@V3nelope ik at first I was confused but when I wanted to edit I couldn't find the video 😨💀
do people really think sm would debut people who can’t sing? out of all companies, it’s sm-
They are probably new kpop stans who have no idea who runs the game when it comes to vocal. ✨SM✨
vocalsm entertainment
Uh actually sometimes yeah
@@dekyar.6356 example?? I'm 100% sure there ain't no SM idol who can't sing or rap live
@@dekyar.6356 no they’ve never debuted an idol who can’t sing. even their rappers are decent vocalists.
I noticed Winter's Stage presence becomes very good when she sings live instead when lip synching
did anyone noticed this too ?
Yep!
Not just her but the whole group since they can feel the song more
Because she’s not a liar i guess 😂
Yeah, she seems to be in a more bitter mood when they lip sync. She's like "this is a piece of cake, let me sing"😂
Her mother Taeyeon is the same. She looked so miserable and annoyed in the step back Performance where she had to lipsync
SM vocalists are hella on another level but damn it's the same issue even before. SM should trust their artists more coz they would be really eating CDs in live performances
It's business, why would they let their artist sing live in a non profit event, sm says pay for a concert ticket if u want to hear them singing live
@@darklighter9750 tbh I think this is smart. I do think during award shows or special performances they should perform live but I understand what they're doing
@@anisaafsar4528 they sing live in big event, overseas or end year, off air too bcoz they got pay alot, music show or tv promotion not need for that bcoz it will destroy their vocal cord if they always singing live even senior artist in sm doing like this
It's not mistrust... Even if you find it odd SM consider their artist the best at everything that's their motto, so a way of taking care of them don't let them sing live at music shows. Those are not paid and usually treat artists badly.
and shes so effortless too
She is so effortless
Winter and ningning are one of the best vocalists in kpop industry.
🙇🙇
Joke of the century
@@jinnxx2729you ✅ winter and ning² ❌
@@jinnxx2729oh really?show me your vocals
@@jinnxx2729don’t be jealous. Your faves can’t sing???
gotta admit, even though SM isn't always perfect in their treatment of idols, they do prepare every trainee to the best of their ability. They ensure that when they launch something, they know what to bring to the table. They don't just throw them into the market without preparation. I really appreciate this aspect of SM Later on, I can feel that people will see its different between the “old player” and “new playes”
WINTER was for sure an SM monster trainee, they hid her for an explosive debut, she rocked her short hair so much. and that voice, damn it.
If you watch the recording of Dreams come true, Winter records like she is barely opening her mouth. That’s literally how she sings ❤️
Yep. Noticed Ning and Winter barely moving their faces while singing high notes
@@donnadarantinao1355 they were trained like that. singing high notes effortlessly.
thats what you call mastery
Yeah it's new style of singing people in past open wide n sing . Now its singing high note with less effort while look easy .
@@parkchithung2672that's Yoo young jin's technique. You can see it in Changmin or D.O and now Winter.
her stage presence is so strong when shes singing live!! whenever she lipsyncs she looks sad
So stable 🔥
le serafim could never
fr
Fr
Can u please stop bringing them up?
L.S Coachella worst and that's the fact.. you can't change what happened
The hate is so forced i agree there vocals were bad and hybe is money hungry but bringing them everywhere is weird
not only can she sing live amazingly well, she’s the most stable in the group! anyone saying she can’t sing, is speaking out of pure jealousy.
bruh look how strong winter’s stage presence is when shes singing live vs when sm forces her to lipsync 😒😒
Iconic moment
Winter is so good at vocals like Ofc she works at sm😭
She looks so beautiful there coachella
Winter deserves to be main vocalist with Ningning
Look at serafim Coachella... Hell ya aespa next level in live vocal
Karina: Black mamba
Winter: yeah yeeeeeeeeeeeaaah
her voice is so beautiful
She’s the song player herself fr 🔥
Coming here after watching le serrafim’s performance… there’s no excuse
So stable yet slay every single part🔥
She could be main vocal in many groups
Her vocals are out of this world ❤
I really love her hair here 🥹
Uri winter is the best
If she actually sings live but people still don't trust her that means she sings too perfect. Congrats my('s) winter girl💫❄️
she doesn't even look like she's struggling
She's under SM and She's the lead vocal yall legit think she can't think?
She's the main vocalist now 😅alongside ning ning🤞
I blame the company for not letting them sing live often ;-;
Seberapa sering SM lipsync tetap saja mereka gudangnya para vokalis. Tidak ada kekhawatiran dalam suara vokal idol SM, encore mereka menjadi salah satu yang paling dinanti
YESSS WINTER SLAYS SO GOOOOOD, I WISH SME LEARN AND GIVE HER A FCKING MIC ON!!!!
She eats cd ❤
Sm not letting her sing live as much isn't the same as her being unable to sing live bc we know thats so so false
Vocal: SM
Rap: YG
Dance: HYBE
visual: Starship
all rounder: JYP
(MY OPINION)
Visual : SM tho 😅
I cane hear to clean my ears from le sserafim 😂
Winter is the most stable live singing while dancing and that's a fact
Even though some high notes were off key, she tried her best
ik it must have been a lot of strain
karina without bangs >>> but she def looks good with bangs too
I don't think anyone ever questioned her singing.
Her stage presence when she sings live >>>>
QUEENNNNN
Wowwww😳😳😳😳
Winter gueeeh
Next level
Yejiii and winter we're eat CD for breakfast
I hope she intentionally make a mistake to prove them wrong.
They are real girl group from vocal and anything then another girl group their vocal so strong and stable
for the first time I thought that she lipsing because it was too much clear to be real. Winter is queen of vocal
you want to see them sing live, please buy aespa concert tickets- SM.. haha
IM GONNA SLAP PEOPLE WHO ARE SAYING MINJEONG CANT SING
sm stans: ….. next
Wow que bonita voz ❤😮
There is no fcking vocalist under SM that can’t sing live.
OMG 🌸✨️❤️
She slayed
Shes never gonna beat the she eats cd for for breakfast allegations
É tão fofo ver o quanto ela fica feliz e sua presença de palco melhora quando ela realmente canta ao vivo❤🥰
winter god
My bias and sm's bias too I love it hehe
Was the songs edited it sounded soo fast that's literally tiring
Yes, like 1.1 speed, sorry
@@liacherries1856 ah that's why
We know they can all sing we are just upset with the company policy it’s not very successful marketing… plus they were a bit nervous and lacking in stage presence because of the lack of live stage they were allowed to do until that point
Winter muito rainha ❤
Aespa compuesto por: WINTER, KARINA, NINGNING, GISELLE.
Sounds good to me.
If you really want to hear Winter’s singing voice, you should watch the episode where she sang A poem called you. I’ve been giving her her flowers since then
That's my favorite cover of her 😫❤
Winter bir tanedir ❤ best vokalistimmm
Do any of you have the link to winter “savage” high note? 😭
Song name?
Next level / Savage
@@user-ks3kt8do2mthanks💓
Winter ana vokal oldu 🎉🎉❤❤
Black pink also use lypsyncron but today Aespa sing so good live and they didn’t use the lypsyncron like black pink. Black pink sing live godd but they use often lypsyron it’s only my opinion
No they don't
@@priceless-jewel. of course
Karena suaranya terlalu bagus sampe dibilang ga bisa nyanyi mulu wkwkwkwkwk
Ha ha ha 🤣
ÆSPA HOLOGRAMA NÆVIS ROBOT EMO GIRLS
winter singing slow SONG....
What stage is that???
It's Coachella
SM will choose idol that can sing ok .. 🗒️
That's nasal screaming
All that vocal rest since debut finally paid off~
yes but someone just see her lipsynce
Out of all the times they actually sing live why would they speed up the track so much? Not that she sounds bad, but she sounds so rushed
Give me the songs
Next level and savage by aespa
Why are so many voices nasally? She sounds like she's screeching
Yikes 😅
too nasally
Nasal voice")
She has the same skills than Amy Winehouse. Not the same vocal range, but the same skills.
❤ Winter ❤
Her voice is like a maniquiin so very thin.,.minalas Yung kanta ni Yesung Kasi nagduet pa siya .,the songs so bored 🥱.,yeye has no taste.,
Sandra park is the best in singing
Winter is the only one in Aespa who are really in pitch ... ooo pls
She can sing but her voice/tone is absolutely painful to listen to during higher notes.
I think because i sped this up before
@@liacherries1856 mmm, no. Winter just naturally has a nasally tone.
@@unidentifiable.individualFake voice?
@@pruitv10 hers?
Why is winter from JYP? No. She is not a twice who can't sing stop this already.
??
Bruh just say you hate twice and go, this made no sense 😭
@@ILoveLLawlietxD not a hater but only Jihyo and Nayeon can sing live but the rest are unstable😁😁
@@idol7833 Jeongyeon is stable
Suaranya cempreng, aku ga suka
She is not singing live at all.
Savage was not completely live
I’m sorry I don’t even know who she is but that high note was ridiculously off pitch 💀
Then don’t comment don’t comment and just hate on someone you don’t even know
@@skylarsdior1207 I ain't trying to hate. I'm sure she's a good singer considering that's her profession but I'm just pointing out the note she sang was off pitch.
Bro, thats how they made the song. Listen to Next Level by aespa. That line was actually designed to be kinda offpitch.
@@jaecrystal6098 well she was singing and dancing at the same time. And before this song she had to sing live to 3 of 4 other songs. So considering that the fact that she had the stamina to belt that note is still pretty impressive
Which part off pitch?? High note? Are you sure??
Sound like mosquito to me
What the point of this video ? You just show some lip sync performance. What is it supposed to prove 🤣
Then y r u listening just skip she is not lipsync and I can understand if u thought she lipsync because she sounds soo good that u misunderstand this for lipsyncing
lol this is literally at coachella they sang it live
@@90slunne dude, don't be a blind sheep. I know they sand live at Coachella, BUT they didn't sing all the song live, the back track was on. Ningning sang her high notes and we could hear her voice crack a little, result next song SM decided to use the backtrack for winter.
In the real live performance you can hear the idol breath. Which is normal, they are dancing at the same time.
Even though some high notes were off key, she tried her best
ik it must have been a lot of strain