Raspberry Pi 5 Vs Raspberry Pi 4 Model B | Comparison & Benchmarking
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 พ.ค. 2024
- The Raspberry Pi 5 is here and one of the biggest questions is, how does it stack up against the previous Pi 4? Well, we already have one to take a look at so let’s run some benchmarks and compare the two.
Watch our full Raspberry Pi 5 review here: • Raspberry Pi 5 | Revie...
🔗 The full guide : _core-electronics.com.au/guide...
🔧🔨🧰 Hardware featured in this guide:
core-electronics.com.au/raspb...
core-electronics.com.au/raspb...
core-electronics.com.au/raspb...
core-electronics.com.au/raspb...
core-electronics.com.au/raspb...
💡❓ If you have any questions about this content or want to share a project you're working on head over to our maker forum: coreelec.io/forum
0:00 Intro
0:15 Hardware Overview
2:44 Benchmark Overview
3:24 CPU Benchmarks
5:30 GPU Benchmarks
6:25 Memory Benchmarks
7:12 MicroSD Benchmarks
7:49 Power and Boot Testing
8:34 Experience Comparisons
🌏🦘 Core Electronics is located in the heart of Newcastle, Australia. We're powered by makers, for makers. Drop by if you are looking for:
• Raspberry Pi core-electronics.com.au/raspb...
• Arduino core-electronics.com.au/ardui...
• Sparkfun core-electronics.com.au/brand...
• Adafruit core-electronics.com.au/brand...
• Pololu core-electronics.com.au/brand...
• DFRobot core-electronics.com.au/brand...
The following trademarks are owned by Core Electronics Pty Ltd:
"Core Electronics" and the Core Electronics logo
"Makerverse" and the Makerverse logo
"PiicoDev" and the PiicoDev logo
"GlowBit" and the GlowBit logo
Is very considerate of you to hand talk for our Italian viewers
Rapper hand movements on point
If the Pis survived this video, you can add "whiplash trauma resistance" to the spec sheet.
Hahahahahaha
The pi5 is more powerful than the laptop i used in school
When testing power consumption, it would be interesting to compare how much total energy is required to do a single task. For sure the Pi5 will use more power, but if it completes a task in half the time of the 4, it may still use less energy. Think Wh or mAh for units.
You can only measure , average power because it will fluctuate a lot and can not be measured easaly, but the Pi 5 will use somewhat more power because the power supply is also 27 watts.
@@ronaldhofman1726I think the op is taking about energy consumption. For that you'll capture all of those fluctuations and integrate over the time of the application. You'll then have a number that captures all of that
Yes, I was disappointed that they DIDN'T color the GPIO pins! You didn't mention the audio connector. I AM glad they added separate pins for the Fan, rather then using up 2 of the GPIO pins, which means blocking HAT boards to be plugged in! 👍
Was wondering if you got got one of the first white box Pi5's. Most on the complaints seem to be the missing audio jack.
what are you thinking about replacing nvidia shield with pi 5? Will it make it or wait for pi 6? My father use nvidia to iptv mainly but after 4 years it's been a little bit lagging and struggling
I'm a little worried that the devices on his hands will feel dizzy. 😵💫
A little bit of motion sickness, but they are good now!
@@Core-Electronicscringe
that's what im saying lol
@@qozia1370 relax
Please stop moving your arms like that
Agree. Great and interesting vid, but the presenter's 'animation' is rather distracting :(
Ha-ha, I kept expecting the cards to fly through the air, the next moment!
No go for broke!
Totally dude, stop waving your arms. Adderall?
I thought I was the only one who noticed his arms were all over the place lol
Great video and information. Thank you!
Well done - very thorough video.
Imagine homie at the dinner table trying to have polite conversation while having spaghetti.
Ill give this one an 8/10 for the Italian joke, a lot more creativity in this...
@@Core-Electronics honestly, i didn't even think of it as an italian joke. I just had a mental image of him flapping sauced noodles on a fork while complaining about something nobody asked about.
I wanted to know what the score was on Antutu Benchmarks
Sad that the io control doesn’t allow for the same things as the rp2040 with the pins..
OK 1) First time here - LOVE this guys enthusiasm - it's infectious... 2) Whilst I am excited for the Pi5 - I have a Pi3 and..... well, I haven't even plugged it in for years. I love them - great little units, but I think they are "Project" units rather than day-to-day. I get that the Pi5 Can and will perform well, but compared to a decent MiniPC, decent Refurb, or even a decent cheap basic home build.... not sure it would make much sense for most users? Don't get me wrong - I'll be buying one, more out of curiousity than anything!!! But for most home users... A Ryzen G based system with 16GB ram would be a "better" choice. Not slating the Pi at ALL - it's built for enthusiasts and project focus, not to replace Windows. But now at this power level, it's moving into mainstream market, and the question is can it hold its own against a similar priced (including case, KB, Mouse, etc) mini PC? I'm... doubtful. I like it and I want one, but... we're definately blurring the lines and edges here...
I have used a Pi 4b daily as a desktop and development environment for the past couple of years. I have a Ryzen 7 mammoth system sitting next to me that I turn on maybe two or three times a week for running a flight simulator. The reason for this, is I really love the silence of the Pi 4 as well as of course the power consumption, 2-4W average draw compared to 50-180W draw for the ryzen system. To use it as a daily driver, I have made it very snappy by cutting back on visual goodies, it's a very simplistic visual setup which I am aware would not appeal to many users. The Pi 5 I am really looking forward to, for me it will be a direct upgrade.
The pi can't hold a candle to a proper PC performance wise. For people who aren't specifically makers who don't care much for the superior I/O, it still has the space advantage, a better power/performance ratio, portability, and lifespan. In all the browsing I did in prep for a pi 5 battle station, I found that a good minimum viable total system cost is around 155 USD. That's for the pi itself, a mouse and keyboard, a cheap 32GB micro SD card, a small monitor, a cord with a mini HDMI lead, and a small heatsink. Most people have at least one of these things, like a spare micro SD card or old mouse, and you can also plug it into a TV. Plus, you can always get a previous generation pi if you don't need the performance capacity of the pi 5. On average, the cost will be less than that of even the cheapest new laptops, and only slightly beaten by the refurbished machines market, and those usually don't last as long.
A mini PC for that same kind of money will probably be among the many that run the AMD A9 9400 APU. Raw performance wise, it's actually not that much better than the BCM 2711 from the pi 4. The pi 5 with its new BCM 2712 is pretty much on par from what I can tell from all the prerelease videos. It may even be stronger. RAM wise, 4GB is plenty for a casual desktop experience and office work on any Linux OS, though I will always recommend getting the most you can afford unless you have a specific use in mind.
Mini PCs scale better with budget size, as that money goes into the choice of hardware. But for the pi, the bulk of the hardware is predetermined, so beyond the board itself, extra money goes into peripherals or luxurious addons like a nice case or LED strips.
Were it not for the lack of a true plug-and-play experience with the pi compared to any cheap rig that runs windows, it could easily be among the best value for money on the lower budget end
Nice video - thank you! Nice graphcis, too (though, remember, 9% of the population can't distinguish green and red). In terms of performance, the Pi 5 is clearly a big step up. But for those who want a SBC for portable computing - one of the reasons SBCs came to exist - using batteries, the optimal 5A supply required works against it. For portable applications, the Pi 4B is the best energy use/performance balance, IMHO.
Yes Standard Pi's running Wildlife or Surveillance software will run quite well on PI 3's or 4's, while they are not trying to Browse Web as Well, confined to a single piece of Software Pi's can last a while on Battery Supplies, Its what I look for, but I also use "Friendly Electricals" a Firm on Ali that has the Lowest Powered SBC's, not as well supported as R-Pi, as per these Plug in USB PC's to Run Retro Games in a Stick you plug into a HDMI Screen to use, a Quad Core, even more low-powered than a Pi .. All I am Saying this "SALES PUSH" from R-Pi is a bit late, they flooded TH-cam & Social Media with Reviews, like always they hide we bits we care about, while trying to "make-up" for lack of Supply with a Slightly better Model of 4b, when it needed to be something more..
Are you guys going to let us pre-order them?
Amazing review! I can't wait to play with my just ordered Raspberry Pi 5. Mr. Core Electronics I love your speech, enthusiasm, data and ability to dumb it down for us. My one suggestion would be to have less arm movement in your video but I also get it, I get super nervous in front of camera's and also excited about things when explaining them to others. Once again... INCREDIBLE video! I'm now subscribing.
Was less nerves, more too much redbull just before a shoot 😂. Enjoy your Pi 5!
Core Electronics is one of my favorite channels.
1st thing I will make with this is 3d camera with two cameras
i want a pi 5 vs orange pi 5 comparison
Amazing video. All metrics and relevant information was pre3sented in an organized manner. Thanks. Keep on making videos. A quick suggestion thou! don't move your hqnds sooooooooo much
I really want to run two cameras and my Coral dual edge TPU on the PCIE to do some robot navigation experiments.
what pi 5 did you use? the 8gb model or something smaller?
We used an 8GB model for these tests.
My guy is so animated hes practically a cartoon with the movements and the hair wiggles.
but do i need it? its new so almost a yes.. but just bought the 4 which almos the same price as a 5. another month for 5 though and i wanted to learn linux and a few projects
Nice comparison!
I want one.
Still rocking my IndieDroidNova 16GB RAM, which is equivalent to the Pi 4.
can u compare between the jeston nano and rasberry pi 5
I want to make a gesture-controlled game with the help of Raspberry Pi 4 with OpenCV and a camera and projector but without a laptop or PC. how can I do this? can we download all the code into Raspberry Pi and run it as a standalone module linked with a webcam and a projector. The projector displays a game on the wall and the camera captures the gesture of the guy to check that he hits the ball to the wall and then procedure the next procedure that what to show on the wall.
You can use the raspberry pi in a desktop computer environment to work in and develop all the code without another computer. Projector through the hdmi and camera through either the MiPi connector on the board, or a usb webcam would work as well. Sounds like a really great project, best of luck!
damn i just bought the pi 4 :( is it worth it to go ahead and get the pi 5 now or would i be fine cruising on the pi 4 for a bit? (have a feeling im gonna need to shell out the shmeckles for the pi 5)
What will you do with it?
I want to detect objects with Yolov8 using Raspberry pi 5. How many FPS can I get from Raspberry pi 5?
I think that the Pi are not longer a relevant option for a low end desktop. Price have gone up and still neeed to count in all the accessories. There is plenty of low cost small factor PC that cost about same and have better connectivity for the desktop user.
Only way I still deploy a Pi at this time is things like Pi-hole with Unbound to take care of my DNS services.
Used to run Homebridge too but now that most of the things are Matter enabled and cross platform compatible that gets less and less relevant for my use too.
If you connect his upper extremities to a generator and use that to supply the pi 5, it would literally be “arm-powered” 😅
how do you get one ???
I receiver my PI 5 few days ago, needed to set is QHD and not 3840x2160, after that it was indeed 60 herz and is fst , have 8gb and active cooler on it looked at Explaining computers first and the active cooler is best for the Pi 5 , removed the top cover and made the hole bigger in the transparant peqce of it , wich contained the fan that i don't use.
Does it run ESXi 8?
Could you make a video for Raspberry Pi 5 vs Orange Pi 5 ?
The ram bandwidth was like that on the Pi5 because it was measuring the cache not ram.
You jiggle more than Michael J Fox
AMAZING
So keen to get hands on 1 .. might do it early next year.
Whats with all the hand waving? its distracting
Too much coffee ! 😀
Must be from Italian family
2:54 Apart from lozone 4k RAND read, thats slightly slower 😊 good video though
As a rule of thumb, if something is 3 times (or more) faster I feel that i will notice and appreciate the difference and thus the upgrade could be worth it
Just purchased a PI from you guys and happened to stumble upon your youtube channel.
Makes me so happy to see an AUS company doing great videos like this. Thanks guys!
Awesome! Thank you!
vs orange pi?
SOUNDS GREAT... BUT I CAN"T GET ONE!
The big difference I notice is the code to use GPIO is totally different. This is a big deal for noobs, because there is a lot more support for older generations at the moment. PI 5 there still isn't a lot of projects yet to buy online. So if you want to learn PI and the GPIO, I'd still go with PI 4B. If you don't care about GPIO and coding then go for the 5.
So many content creators on TH-cam must've started out as magicians. Either that or there are classes that TH-cam must give that statistically show that a whole lot of hand movement equals more views.
I present a third option, too much Red Bull before an early morning shoot. 😓
10:22 yes next time you test RPI5 and RPI6 even you allready test RPI5. mayby you test RPI zero 3 then RPI zero 3W then RPI zero 3.2w. or mayby this this its WB wifi and bluetooth
Yep, more like a Pi4.5, Things that needed to be fixed on 4, Sadly as I have multiple Raspberry Pi's here (1x3a,2xzero,2x3b,4x4b), & supported Raspberry Org, these performance figures are low, using a Orange Pi 5, plus you get a NPU for robotics ..
its wierd they removed hardware accelerated video on the PI5, instead putting burden on the CPU.
I think "it's a Upgrade", which they can MANUFACTURE on same assembly line equipment, Faster CPU, No GPU change, but improved I/O so CPU doing the work is not so noticed, kept prices down for THEM, while the New Parts in Design give the Pi a Small Speed Increase .. Sadly R-Pi 5 has nothing I Need, which as a Long time Raspberry Pi User, Bothers me .. @@AndrewTSq ,
And we can buy it in the year 2525, if man still survives...
No audio jack 🤢🤢
To be fair, the audio jack output on the Pi 4 is pretty terrible. A few $ will get you a USB audiocard which is a vast improvement on the audiojack. Or even better of course an audio DAC HAT.
@@wingandaprayer883 Ok, thanks for the info & tip
so which is better ? ...
wünsche mir einen x1 core und die 3 fache Grakigleistung sollte nur 5 Euro mehr kosten in der Herstellung
7 oder 10 nm Fertigung
less redbull next time
Small problem though. I can buy Pi 4B 8GB easily, but Pi 5 8GB is unavailable.
The accent says Australian but the hands say Italian 🤌🤌
We're a multicultural nation 🍝
top video!!!!!! WOW
Wow! Jaryd Giesen!
Double the power consumption so what’s the point . It would have been a upgrade if it was faster and the same power consumption
It is not double the power consumption.. it's like a 50-70% increase. In efficiency terms it's actually an improvement from the 4.
would have
@@azoriusmage thanks
@@wingandaprayer883 50% is double is it not , there is already a faster alternatives to pi 3 before the 4 came out and only reason it didn’t catch on was software issues
@@YiZed-wo4cu A 100% increase would be double. Most so called 'faster alternatives' are at a much higher price point, have little information, community and support and are in a bigger package size. Pi's are not trying to be the absolutely fastest thing out there, they are conforming to a design philosophy. If it doesn't suit your use case then that is of course fine. There are many different use cases.
Word.
I suppose the guy is a living cooler for the pi's
You're pretty animated with your hands for a review.
0:29 dont say that! RPI6 coming
Why 2x4k on a piece of shot like this?
Nice information. Thanks but pls try to talk a little slower. You were talking so fast like Raspberry Pi 8 😄
Its's all about dat videocore
other boards coming out are at 16gb for top-tier some as high as 32 and 64gb ..yet lets leave it at 8gb. Whats the bet that CoreElectronics ganks everyone again where "awwww...out of stock but you can buy a stupidly overpriced bundle with extra bits you don't want that'll discourage you from getting bits for your project from us because you can't afford the bits you need and can enjoy the bits we're forcing on you". ..again. No longer my first choice for bulk purchases.
Why would you need 32gb?
@@reheyesd8666 Because I do a lot with my existing ARM boards. Often it starts swaping to hard drive (swapping to SD card will kill the card in under an hour.. then chuck it away). I've regularly seen apps like browsers eat north of 5-6 gb after some light browsing. Also it'd be great for people home-lab'ing k8's etc and running more than trivial servers. I dearly wish there was boards with 0gb ram shipped and they have one or more SO-DIMM slots. So .. here's your board, go find your own ram. There's a fairly large segment of people I run into on IRC and other places running these things for more than hobbyist systems at home. Some boards such as the Khardas gear is 32gb and 64gb soon. Can't wait.. but dearly wish the RPi gear with the very standard and popular hardware all being the same, will have better software support.
I ended up getting a Dell Wyse 5070 @ $45 its way better than pi5
This guy must be Italian
This guy is an Italian.
😂😂😂😂 they added the power button😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Goodbye headphone jack 😢
till 7 or 8, i won't sell my mac mini m1 for this!!! ;)
Timestamps would be highly appreciated
Good information, but you gesticulate like an angry Italian at lunch time.
great info but honestly almost unwatchable with the hand shit going on.
Smd components like resistors flew away after giving the boards to him
Who needs desolder braid ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
@@Core-Electronics nice, neither a hot air station nor a soldering iron
"PIN THIS COMMENT NOW'
STOP whaling around those arms around Jesus
bro are you ok? your hand motions are so extra
Too many RedBulls too early in the morning...
It's cheaper here to get the pi 5 than the pi 4
Nice review, but block the video and just listen. The dude has wayyyyyyy to much coffee.
Man's buggin'
I made a NAS with a Pi4B and a 18TB USB HDD. But I couldn't get any system monitor graphs or graphs from Mission Center. I have ordered a celeron based nuc, so I can get back to mainstream, and ditch the toy Raspberries and their immature/unstable linux distros. I've had enough of Arm junk. The new nuc has 4 3.0 usb ports, a 2.5 GB LAN, and an NVME SSD. I'll be able to run makeMKV directly on it, avoiding the time to copy movies over ethernet.
Please stop flapping your wings. You might take off and hit the ceiling!
Is he a drummer or just pretending
The flailing arms made me click away...
What to animate fellow. I wish he would setttle down a bit as it is distracting with all the flailing about. Pretty good coverage though.
Your arm gestures are too dramatic and faKe
Very detailed review with a lot of benchmarks and useful data. But you are throwing your arms a little too much. Work on that and you would be even more presentive. Otherwise thanks. Take care.
Why are you flailing so much? Relax
Stop waving your arms, please.