Edits are certainly something. I think they are good for the most part but in my opinion just a bit much. If I’m being honest when I watch a Mk8dx vid I like the gameplay aspect more than the actual editing.
Completely understandable! The goal is to make minimalistic edits to emphasize the gameplay while not just being the raw gameplay, and we're gonna work towards that!
some gentle feedback on the editing: - the subtitles at the start of the video feel a bit arbitrary. I think they mostly make sense for "hype moments" like 25:03 - 25:20 - I like when the transitions match up with the track. Like the ice transition at 16:30 looks great to me while the fire at 6:22 feels off - the sound effects should match up with what's happening, at 2:20 you're mostly optimistic but a sad sound effect plays
I like that you put effort into the editing. For my personal taste its a bit to much going around. In my opnion MK is a game which is really colourful, Stressful and fast. With this Type of editing everything is bit overloaded. During the the races it doesnt need big colour subtitels or memes. The Facecam Zoom for example is quite Nice and doesnt distract
Thank you so much for the feedback! I completely understand where you're coming from. Our goal is to add in subtle, minimalistic edits that don't take away from the gameplay and we're going to work towards making a flawless system. Your feedback will be forwarded to the team!
It's kind of difficult to explain how I feel about this new editing. It is a more engaging style that a lot of other youtubers in general use even outside of Mario Kart with like popping subtitles and sound effects and always things going on. But I feel like its a little to chaotic for me and feels a little bit more meant for people younger than me with the attention spam of acorns. But in general it makes the video more alive so if that's what your going for it does that. You put a lot of personality in the beginning of the video to make new people stay and open the video with your high energy which I appreciate.
Completely understandable! The goal is for the edits to be as seamless and minimalistic as possible while still adding to the video rather than taking away from it. So we'll work towards making that happen every time!
Overall, I think the edits are good, but sometimes a bit distracting. The face cam edits at the end of races and the transitions after are amazing. The sound effects are mostly good, but sometimes they don’t fit with the commentary (ex. 6:47). The face cam zooming and some of the subtitles in the middle of the race feels distracting to me. I’m personally here to watch Mario Kart, and I’m watching JPG for the best commentary. I hope this helps and the comment wasn’t too long lol
Completely understandable! The goal is to make the edits as seamless and minimalistic as possible in these videos, and we're gonna get there one vid at a time!
From editor to another I respect the edits, but it sometimes feels unnecessary because of how many sound effects are already in Mario Kart. What I think would be cool would be intense strings, hiss, drumroll etc. during very risky and dangerous parts to amplify the tension.
This doesnt have much to do with the editing but i totally agree that your midset has changed and i love the vibe now it just feels a lot happier also like the new editing
I think if you incorporate references in your commentary, be it to past events or stuff outside the game, and add colorful language it opens up postproduction opportunities for the editor to play with beyond just the gameplay or your tone of voice. I think that's important, to set up the easy plays with commentary so the editor can come in with the slam dunk.
Hey JP I really love how passionate you are about TH-cam and it really shows in this vid. I love that you are trying something new with your content and it seems amazing! Hope 2025 is a great year for you mentally and physically and your an inspiration for many especially with your positive vibes, keep reaching for unforeseen possibilities and never give up even when things get tough. You are a great person and hope you relalize that, don’t let haters get in the way of what makes you YOU Keep on giviner bud❤
Great edit! Loved to watch it! Minor feedback for me would be to scale even more into your thumbnail for reactions when you show scoreboard & even see you full frame in the beginning and ending doing your jpg signature moves to have like iconic intro + outro
Your videos are always so entertaining, thanks for putting in the work to make your channel awesome. Keep up the good work! Also, that shock dodge on Donut Plains was soooooo sick!
It's cool to see the new editing style! Like others have said, the edits look good but it is a bit much and the sound effects should match the current tone. For example, the sad music being overlayed with your more energetic tone didn't make much sense, especially when the placement wasn't too bad given the situation. The sound effects also seemed to be a bit too loud, like the splat sound effect whenever you got hit was just a bit too loud and didn't have a release tail, so it's pretty easy to hear when the sound effect cuts off. Overall, I am curious to see how the edits shape the future of this channel!
I don't know if you will see this JB but I think that you should do the editing style that you like to do or eventually find the one the works for you. And also this is the first time you and your editor are doing this so you still need to find the little things to make it better, so I hope that this helps and have a get new year and I also love your videos. And just keep on Giviner Bud. 💙
Edits are a lot of fun, adds depth to the content which is always nice. Trust your instincts with the edits you are going to get a ton of diff opinions so do what feels right and listen to what feels right. In my own humble opinion, I think the intro could go without the editing and leave it only to enhance gameplay moments that are worthy of enhancing !
Awesome races dude! This is the first members only video I've watched in a long time XD Love you dude, you're so freaking amazing ❤ (Also the editor is CRAZY good, major props to them!)
Hey jpg kinda late on the feedback but besides all of the other suggestions I felt that a lot of edits were a bit too random. Like random phrases or monologues were subbed with no apparent reason. Also I would expect like some kind of edit when the shock happens or if you dodge it but there was no consistency. In general it felt somewhat random but still I appreciate the effort of trying to improve the viewer experience 😁
I like the new editing style! The only complaint are the subtitles. They are pretty distracting from the race. Maybe remove them or make them black and white. Otherwise, I love it. YESSIR!
As a constant viewer I don’t mind adding in fun edits/sound effects and such. However the subtitling did seem kind of chaotic and just not needed imo. I think the sound effects are fun and zoom ins and shakes when things are happening. Or even like some slo mo moments for when there’s close calls. Besides the random subtitles I think it’s fun and something new which never hurts!
Big fan of the new editing style, although I think the subtitles and some of the sound effects are unnecessary, it sometimes feels like one of those dank meme videos from 2012
Let’s get some animations when JPG does his classic “BANGER TRACK” e.g., an explosion right before the vid transitions to JPG saying banger track. Idk, but shout out to the editor! Can’t wait to see how this all evolves.
Keep this kind of editing going! Do you think there could be a unique type of edit for your signature tracks? Like on DK Mountain, maybe have a special edit to give the winter feel. Just a thought! Keep it up!
The music when you win/lose i feel is annoying, but the facecam shaking and the captions and overall editing is great. Keep it up, more videos like this! Also, when your facecam grows, it should return less abruptly and be more soft and slow
25:03 I remember watching this from Liam’s perspective, it was so funny because he was tilted from losing “Ah yes the TRUE winners have revealed themselves!!!” Awesome video 🙂
Notes for editor (a lot of this is personal preference) - Remove bobbing effects on subtitles/focused JPG cam. Besides accessibility, it removes the weird snapping when returning to normal - make JPG's border match the MK8DX UI better - whenever focusing on JPG, make the zoom faster - big fan of matching font faces. depending on what element/whos talking (if you ever do squad again), you can find really good font mimics for free. The licensed fonts you'll need to find mimics for are Rodin (game), Shin Go NT (Switch UI). Shortcat uses Gilroy Extra Bold, RTAT uses Hartwell Black. Given MrBeast's reputation, maybe go as far as changing your font from Komika Axis to an all caps Mario mimic used in your logo (reduce tracking to match) - change font back to white and use a gradient outline instead - have more sfx variety (do not use more, the current amount is fine)
I love the edits JPG. Im a little late so you probably wont see this, but i love your vibes recently, its amazing. Keep on giviner bud, YESSIR!! Im also canadian fr
I'm late to the party, but I still want to share a little bit of my thoughts about the editing even though I'm far from being a professional in that domain. I read a few comments and I have to agree with them about some parts feeling like a bit too much. As somebody who watches your content a lot, and other Mario Kart content creators for that matter, I could tell that some of the editing distracted me from the original gameplay. Now, I can see that there is a balance with subtitles and the facecam close-ups and they're definitely relevant depending on the things you say, though I don't think they're mandatory if you say something along the lines of having a specific item that may or may not be the cause of a hyping-up moment. However, I do find the sound effects somewhat redundant at times, specifically the "punch" one when you get hit by an item as well as the "winning" and "losing" sound effects after crossing the finish line, which may not be adapted to every single instance. The former especially feels off in instances where you're talking and don't mention it at all, whereas the latter would be more relevant where your position at the end isn't determined yet if that makes sense. For example, you could put the "winning" sound effect for a comeback moment at the very end or a track that you ran all the way through, then the "losing" one when you expect a late comeback but either don't achieve as big as you initially thought or simply nothing at all. I don't think they're necessary to put at the end of every race, mostly those where your position is pretty much determined and, for the "losing" sound effect, where you make an optimistic comment about being satisfied with a low spot because it could've been worse and whatnot. No hate towards you or your editors at all though! All of this remains my point of view, but I do hope it'll help adapting your editing style for your audience. This is just the beginning of the new era, and I'll definitely be looking forward to what comes next!
Love all the videos and congrats on playing in tier S again! In my opinion the editing is a bit too much for my liking, I felt like it was hard to focus on the actual gameplay at times. Keep up the great work though! Keep on giving her bud!
There needs to be a better ratio for the edits, i think the bigger flashier ones should be in the transitions and downtime before the race starts and less or no text diring the race, takes your eyes away from the action, the editing is superb, but just a bit too much in some areas when you would want us to watch
edits definitely aren’t bad! i agree with a lot of the people who say that it’s a *bit* much, especially considering you already have pretty energetic commentary & this is a pretty overstimulating game. i will admit i don’t know a lot about editing, so yall might not even have control over this, but a lot of the sound effects do remind me of like…a 2012 vine compilation, & not necessarily in a good way, if that makes sense? like i said though, i don’t know shit about editing & that might just be the options you have for emphasis sounds. a lot of the edits complimented this video & your specific personality well, i just think they need to come down like two notches LOL
Editing little too much, and also too much energy from you in this vid.. you can tell you didn’t know what to say at some point, you’re a great TH-camr, maybe just keep it more chill imo
Yeah I gotta admit, I'm not a fan of these edits, sorry :( edits should be made to enhance a funny or interesting moment in the video, but all of the edits made here feel like they're being made for the sake of editing more. The random zoom-ins on the facecam and captions are unnecessary and don't add to the viewing experience at all. instead editing should enhance what's happening (e.g: you get hit at a really inconvenient time and react in a funny way, so the facecam zooms in; you make an interesting decision in the game and don't mention it in the commentary, so add a caption saying why you did what you did; etc). I'm sure there's an audience for videos edited like this (probably children if I'm being honest), but I think most people prefer editing styles like Shortcat's or NMeade's which are lowkey and subtle, but enhance funny or interesting moments in the video.
i think edits like this would work if the video was cut a lot more but that doesn’t work for mario kart, the zoom in and captions can work but i think a little sparser for more consequential plays/mistakes/funny moments.
Damn poor Liam getting smoked... trailed him right off of respawn on DK Jungle xD Edits are good but a bit too much imo. All this but a little bit less seems great!
I would agree. I think editing is the “meta” if you will for more engagement and better performing videos, but highkey some moments like the dollar store sad trombone every bad race or the punch sound every hit made me fumeeee. Someone said it made them feel like a toddler and I thought that was an odd comment until I watched the video and I agreed with them
i really like the video editing but the sound effects where too much for me😅 i guess thats highly subjective tho and most people seem to enjoy it🙃 also the little error pointing to the 11th when u said ur 11th made me laugh out loud😂
Unload everything you're comfortable unloading and don't be afraid to unpack deep rooted trauma. If you can learn to manage, cope with, or abolish everything negative in your life, it will take you so far. You got this!
Edits are certainly something. I think they are good for the most part but in my opinion just a bit much. If I’m being honest when I watch a Mk8dx vid I like the gameplay aspect more than the actual editing.
Completely understandable! The goal is to make minimalistic edits to emphasize the gameplay while not just being the raw gameplay, and we're gonna work towards that!
I think having the biggest edits saved for the most hype/Heartbreaking/close call moments would be great.
Great idea!
💯
Banger Idea!
some gentle feedback on the editing:
- the subtitles at the start of the video feel a bit arbitrary. I think they mostly make sense for "hype moments" like 25:03 - 25:20
- I like when the transitions match up with the track. Like the ice transition at 16:30 looks great to me while the fire at 6:22 feels off
- the sound effects should match up with what's happening, at 2:20 you're mostly optimistic but a sad sound effect plays
Thank you so much! I will relay this feedback to my team!
but his intro is really energetic/hype, so maybe that's what they were going for. I see what u mean though
Yeah, fire for bc and gv, snow for dks, ice for riw, vines for rp, et cetera
I like that you put effort into the editing. For my personal taste its a bit to much going around. In my opnion MK is a game which is really colourful, Stressful and fast. With this Type of editing everything is bit overloaded. During the the races it doesnt need big colour subtitels or memes. The Facecam Zoom for example is quite Nice and doesnt distract
Thank you so much for the feedback! I completely understand where you're coming from. Our goal is to add in subtle, minimalistic edits that don't take away from the gameplay and we're going to work towards making a flawless system. Your feedback will be forwarded to the team!
It's kind of difficult to explain how I feel about this new editing. It is a more engaging style that a lot of other youtubers in general use even outside of Mario Kart with like popping subtitles and sound effects and always things going on. But I feel like its a little to chaotic for me and feels a little bit more meant for people younger than me with the attention spam of acorns. But in general it makes the video more alive so if that's what your going for it does that. You put a lot of personality in the beginning of the video to make new people stay and open the video with your high energy which I appreciate.
Completely understandable! The goal is for the edits to be as seamless and minimalistic as possible while still adding to the video rather than taking away from it. So we'll work towards making that happen every time!
Overall, I think the edits are good, but sometimes a bit distracting. The face cam edits at the end of races and the transitions after are amazing. The sound effects are mostly good, but sometimes they don’t fit with the commentary (ex. 6:47). The face cam zooming and some of the subtitles in the middle of the race feels distracting to me. I’m personally here to watch Mario Kart, and I’m watching JPG for the best commentary. I hope this helps and the comment wasn’t too long lol
Completely understandable! The goal is to make the edits as seamless and minimalistic as possible in these videos, and we're gonna get there one vid at a time!
I agree 100%. Love the effort and am interested to see where you go from here, JP!
From editor to another I respect the edits, but it sometimes feels unnecessary because of how many sound effects are already in Mario Kart.
What I think would be cool would be intense strings, hiss, drumroll etc. during very risky and dangerous parts to amplify the tension.
This doesnt have much to do with the editing but i totally agree that your midset has changed and i love the vibe now it just feels a lot happier also like the new editing
YESSIR!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH!
It needs more fart sound effects
this editing is really good! i like how he moves the camera! the captions are good, too. no complaints, keep it up!
I'm so glad to hear that!!!
@@JPGivineryeah I agree with chao
@@JPGivinerI agree mostly with Chao, but I kinda feel like the subtitles are a bit unnecessary
The editing is making me feel like a toddler... 😖😫
Sorry HAHA
The editing feels like a montage 😂 I really like the editing. the camera enlargements really add to the action keep up the good work 👍
Thank you so much!!!
Loved this new style, love the new vibes and enjoyed the stream tonight. Keep on giviner!! JPG the goat!!
good vibes. great video. also super happy that you can focus more on other things now that you have editor(s) on board
I think if you incorporate references in your commentary, be it to past events or stuff outside the game, and add colorful language it opens up postproduction opportunities for the editor to play with beyond just the gameplay or your tone of voice. I think that's important, to set up the easy plays with commentary so the editor can come in with the slam dunk.
This editing is so refreshing. Got no complaints about it!
Next level of editing too !! Keep on giviner bud :D
Hey JP I really love how passionate you are about TH-cam and it really shows in this vid. I love that you are trying something new with your content and it seems amazing! Hope 2025 is a great year for you mentally and physically and your an inspiration for many especially with your positive vibes, keep reaching for unforeseen possibilities and never give up even when things get tough. You are a great person and hope you relalize that, don’t let haters get in the way of what makes you YOU
Keep on giviner bud❤
i love the editing. especially the sound effects and the subtitles are a nice touch
Great edit! Loved to watch it! Minor feedback for me would be to scale even more into your thumbnail for reactions when you show scoreboard & even see you full frame in the beginning and ending doing your jpg signature moves to have like iconic intro + outro
Love those ideas! Thank you so much!
oh yeah the toddlers will be retained with this one
Great video JPG! Keep up the positivity and keep on givener bud!
Thank you so much!
Your videos are always so entertaining, thanks for putting in the work to make your channel awesome. Keep up the good work!
Also, that shock dodge on Donut Plains was soooooo sick!
It's cool to see the new editing style! Like others have said, the edits look good but it is a bit much and the sound effects should match the current tone. For example, the sad music being overlayed with your more energetic tone didn't make much sense, especially when the placement wasn't too bad given the situation. The sound effects also seemed to be a bit too loud, like the splat sound effect whenever you got hit was just a bit too loud and didn't have a release tail, so it's pretty easy to hear when the sound effect cuts off. Overall, I am curious to see how the edits shape the future of this channel!
This is truly a Competitive Mario Kart 8 Deluxe 220 moment
This is truly a TRWario moment
Truly
🗣
@@JPGiviner the goat replied 🗣🗣🗣🗣
No it’s not
I don't know if you will see this JB but I think that you should do the editing style that you like to do or eventually find the one the works for you. And also this is the first time you and your editor are doing this so you still need to find the little things to make it better, so I hope that this helps and have a get new year and I also love your videos. And just keep on Giviner Bud. 💙
W editing. I'm really looking forward to what your editor is gonna cook next time!
This is new and great
Keep it up mate
Every time a Golden Mushroom fails you or helps you win, make a short about the Golden Mushroom. Only from real games.
Edits are a lot of fun, adds depth to the content which is always nice. Trust your instincts with the edits you are going to get a ton of diff opinions so do what feels right and listen to what feels right. In my own humble opinion, I think the intro could go without the editing and leave it only to enhance gameplay moments that are worthy of enhancing !
SO REAL! Thank you so much dude!
Awesome races dude! This is the first members only video I've watched in a long time XD Love you dude, you're so freaking amazing ❤ (Also the editor is CRAZY good, major props to them!)
Thank you so much dude, I really appreciate it!
@@JPGiviner you bet! I'll make sure to keep on giviner bud!
This is free for all moments in competitive Mario Kart Deluxe episode 8 (these edits are absolutely awesome)
I'm so happy to hear you love them!
Really like the editing man makes the videos more enjoyable fricking love it good job man!
Never beating the dp3 is ur best track allegations btw W editing my guy
LMFAO thank you bro!!!
I love the vibes with you man ❤ keep it uk doing great
Oh These Edits Are BANGER!!!! Im Loving It
im honestly loving this new editing style makes it much more interactive i feel and i like how it all flows W mans!!
Thank you so much!!!
Jpg do not worry about the recording you are amazing and record many great videos in my opinion you are the best mk TH-camr in the world
❤❤❤❤
Hey jpg kinda late on the feedback but besides all of the other suggestions I felt that a lot of edits were a bit too random. Like random phrases or monologues were subbed with no apparent reason. Also I would expect like some kind of edit when the shock happens or if you dodge it but there was no consistency. In general it felt somewhat random but still I appreciate the effort of trying to improve the viewer experience 😁
Loving the edits! The subtitles really underscore the really funny stuff you say, and the edits in the intro are fire 🔥
Thank you so much!!!
I like the new editing style! The only complaint are the subtitles. They are pretty distracting from the race. Maybe remove them or make them black and white. Otherwise, I love it. YESSIR!
Thank you so much! We'll keep that in mind!
Love the editing! Great vídeo! YES SIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR
As a constant viewer I don’t mind adding in fun edits/sound effects and such. However the subtitling did seem kind of chaotic and just not needed imo. I think the sound effects are fun and zoom ins and shakes when things are happening. Or even like some slo mo moments for when there’s close calls. Besides the random subtitles I think it’s fun and something new which never hurts!
these are definitely some good edits, that first was clutch!
Love seeing the Subtitles at the beginning and you John trying to turn into Super Saiyan is just amazing we need moew
Big fan of the new editing style, although I think the subtitles and some of the sound effects are unnecessary, it sometimes feels like one of those dank meme videos from 2012
Thank you for your support and feedback! We're gonna make it perfect with time!
Let’s get some animations when JPG does his classic “BANGER TRACK”
e.g., an explosion right before the vid transitions to JPG saying banger track. Idk, but shout out to the editor! Can’t wait to see how this all evolves.
I like the editing good job
Keep this kind of editing going! Do you think there could be a unique type of edit for your signature tracks? Like on DK Mountain, maybe have a special edit to give the winter feel. Just a thought! Keep it up!
The music when you win/lose i feel is annoying, but the facecam shaking and the captions and overall editing is great. Keep it up, more videos like this! Also, when your facecam grows, it should return less abruptly and be more soft and slow
Thank you for your support and feedback!
Did you edit this? This editing is incredible
He has an editor and they’re trying new things out, it’s not him editing
25:03
I remember watching this from Liam’s perspective, it was so funny because he was tilted from losing
“Ah yes the TRUE winners have revealed themselves!!!”
Awesome video 🙂
Edits made no sense and were garbage, will have to see how long this editor is kept on board...
mindless criticism lol i loved this video
I love leaving constructive instructive feedback lol, but I loved the video even more
Like the editing style a lot. Keep it up. Make sure to save all those presets 😆
Thank you so much!!!
Your editing is so cool bro
Edit: L1am spotted
Notes for editor (a lot of this is personal preference)
- Remove bobbing effects on subtitles/focused JPG cam. Besides accessibility, it removes the weird snapping when returning to normal
- make JPG's border match the MK8DX UI better
- whenever focusing on JPG, make the zoom faster
- big fan of matching font faces. depending on what element/whos talking (if you ever do squad again), you can find really good font mimics for free. The licensed fonts you'll need to find mimics for are Rodin (game), Shin Go NT (Switch UI). Shortcat uses Gilroy Extra Bold, RTAT uses Hartwell Black. Given MrBeast's reputation, maybe go as far as changing your font from Komika Axis to an all caps Mario mimic used in your logo (reduce tracking to match)
- change font back to white and use a gradient outline instead
- have more sfx variety (do not use more, the current amount is fine)
I really dont like the comic sans style fonts
I love the edits JPG. Im a little late so you probably wont see this, but i love your vibes recently, its amazing. Keep on giviner bud, YESSIR!! Im also canadian fr
I see everything 😤 thank you so much for your support!!!
I'm late to the party, but I still want to share a little bit of my thoughts about the editing even though I'm far from being a professional in that domain. I read a few comments and I have to agree with them about some parts feeling like a bit too much. As somebody who watches your content a lot, and other Mario Kart content creators for that matter, I could tell that some of the editing distracted me from the original gameplay. Now, I can see that there is a balance with subtitles and the facecam close-ups and they're definitely relevant depending on the things you say, though I don't think they're mandatory if you say something along the lines of having a specific item that may or may not be the cause of a hyping-up moment. However, I do find the sound effects somewhat redundant at times, specifically the "punch" one when you get hit by an item as well as the "winning" and "losing" sound effects after crossing the finish line, which may not be adapted to every single instance. The former especially feels off in instances where you're talking and don't mention it at all, whereas the latter would be more relevant where your position at the end isn't determined yet if that makes sense. For example, you could put the "winning" sound effect for a comeback moment at the very end or a track that you ran all the way through, then the "losing" one when you expect a late comeback but either don't achieve as big as you initially thought or simply nothing at all. I don't think they're necessary to put at the end of every race, mostly those where your position is pretty much determined and, for the "losing" sound effect, where you make an optimistic comment about being satisfied with a low spot because it could've been worse and whatnot. No hate towards you or your editors at all though! All of this remains my point of view, but I do hope it'll help adapting your editing style for your audience. This is just the beginning of the new era, and I'll definitely be looking forward to what comes next!
this editing is actually golden, new era looks hype! 2025 yessirrr!
So glad to hear that!
7:49 only thing editor is missing is the vine boom for the shock dodge
VERY TRUE
Love all the videos and congrats on playing in tier S again! In my opinion the editing is a bit too much for my liking, I felt like it was hard to focus on the actual gameplay at times.
Keep up the great work though! Keep on giving her bud!
I AM HERE BEFORE TRWARIO LETS FREAKIN GOOOOOOOOOO
anyway banger editing!! editors are absolutely awesome right now
Thank you so much!
this editing is peak
So glad to hear!!!
JPG, all you need to do is say “I understand it now” it will work trust
No more Price is Right trombone
Bruh, those edits are TOP TIER.
John seems really motivated this episode huh?
I like the new editing style, but sometimes it's a bit over edited.
Serenity now, insanity later.
the real ones get to comment early b4 its goes public
real
love the editing
Thank you!
There needs to be a better ratio for the edits, i think the bigger flashier ones should be in the transitions and downtime before the race starts and less or no text diring the race, takes your eyes away from the action, the editing is superb, but just a bit too much in some areas when you would want us to watch
edits definitely aren’t bad! i agree with a lot of the people who say that it’s a *bit* much, especially considering you already have pretty energetic commentary & this is a pretty overstimulating game. i will admit i don’t know a lot about editing, so yall might not even have control over this, but a lot of the sound effects do remind me of like…a 2012 vine compilation, & not necessarily in a good way, if that makes sense? like i said though, i don’t know shit about editing & that might just be the options you have for emphasis sounds. a lot of the edits complimented this video & your specific personality well, i just think they need to come down like two notches LOL
Feels good to be a JPG viewer :)
YESSIR!
Personally the edits are a bit much but keep giviner man
We'll work towards them not being as overbearing!
Wait when did he become a pro editor
HAHAHA I'm not that insane! I hired a team :)
edits are peak YESSIR
Bro I’m not even 10 seconds in and I’m loving the edits oh my god-
HAHAHA I'm so glad!!!
Love the editing. I just think the subtitles need to be toned down a bit. They feel kinda random sometimes
Completely understandable! Thank you so much for your support and feedback!
way to make monday 10x better
WWW
Personally, I think the sound effects are great. However, your face kinda blocked the screen a bit when screen size increased.
Editing little too much, and also too much energy from you in this vid.. you can tell you didn’t know what to say at some point, you’re a great TH-camr, maybe just keep it more chill imo
Yeah I gotta admit, I'm not a fan of these edits, sorry :( edits should be made to enhance a funny or interesting moment in the video, but all of the edits made here feel like they're being made for the sake of editing more. The random zoom-ins on the facecam and captions are unnecessary and don't add to the viewing experience at all. instead editing should enhance what's happening (e.g: you get hit at a really inconvenient time and react in a funny way, so the facecam zooms in; you make an interesting decision in the game and don't mention it in the commentary, so add a caption saying why you did what you did; etc).
I'm sure there's an audience for videos edited like this (probably children if I'm being honest), but I think most people prefer editing styles like Shortcat's or NMeade's which are lowkey and subtle, but enhance funny or interesting moments in the video.
i think edits like this would work if the video was cut a lot more but that doesn’t work for mario kart, the zoom in and captions can work but i think a little sparser for more consequential plays/mistakes/funny moments.
21:46 nice rhyme
I wonder how you will perform, if you use off-meta in a S tier competitive game.
Golly gee I wonder if he got an editor🤔
Damn poor Liam getting smoked... trailed him right off of respawn on DK Jungle xD
Edits are good but a bit too much imo. All this but a little bit less seems great!
Enjoying the edits, personally not a fan of the added sound effect for the shell hits. Enjoying the change tho!
I LOVE YOUR CONTENT NOW!!!!!!!!!
THANK YOU!!!
OMG THESE EDITSSS
Edits are fine lol, people gotta get used to them is all in my opinion
so real
Do a new year's eve race online
I hate the sound effects every time you get hit man
I would agree. I think editing is the “meta” if you will for more engagement and better performing videos, but highkey some moments like the dollar store sad trombone every bad race or the punch sound every hit made me fumeeee. Someone said it made them feel like a toddler and I thought that was an odd comment until I watched the video and I agreed with them
Day 34 of asking for the scheduled 200cc video to return
i really like the video editing but the sound effects where too much for me😅 i guess thats highly subjective tho and most people seem to enjoy it🙃
also the little error pointing to the 11th when u said ur 11th made me laugh out loud😂
Thank you for your feedback! We're gonna work towards including the best, most seamless edits possible, one video at a time!
Edits add basically nothing. Just paying for word print and sound effects
I feel like the editing is a bit too much rn
Also, JPG. Im thinking of going to therapy. Got any advice for me?
Unload everything you're comfortable unloading and don't be afraid to unpack deep rooted trauma. If you can learn to manage, cope with, or abolish everything negative in your life, it will take you so far. You got this!
Please leave out the captions, they are very distracting