The man is able to get up and sing and play at 82! How many people his age already have health problems that they feel good just getting out of bed and doing the daily routine? I've never been a massive fan but I respect him for being able to do that much! And from the sound of it there's a huge crowd! He not only is performing but people are PAYING to see and hear him. That alone is phenomenal. I saw a special following Glen Campbell when he had moderate Alzheimer's. He couldn't remember the words to some of his classics, he couldn't remember his children's name, but his fans came to his concerts because it was his last one. When he forgot the words they sang them for him. Fans don't come to see a young rock star they come to hear Paul McCartney just as he is.
What a honor for any audience still be able to watch the greatest pop-rock artist of all times. I just saw the Ringo Starr show in the USA and had a great time.
I consider it a miracle that Paul is still singing at his age. Of course, the Beatles are still a timeless miracle band. Let us thank Paul for giving us dreams forever.
I read a lot of comments being so hard on Paul's voice. Ok, we get it, he is 82 years old. His voice isn't the same as at the Cavern Club. I think that's quite obvious. But you know what? I was there. I'm from Uruguay and I was at that same concert. I can say it's hugely moving, to-the-tears moving, to see someone his age, with his career giving it ALL. Singing his songs and those of his friends like absolutely nobody else can, because he's part of those songs and those songs are part of him. Besides that, this song was around 2 hours after the concert started. By that time he had sung not few songs, some of them quite hard on the throat. So if you may enjoy a living legend sharing a part of himself through a 3 hours concert (he could easily perform half the time, sing some Beatles songs and go back to the hotel, but he doesn't), please go while you can and enjoy it. I promise you won't regret it. If not, I don't know, just listen to something on TH-cam, it's ok.
that is really the truth, Paul is still a great performer and his voice is aged, but so musical and emotional. Paul is so inspiring also by showing us how to get old with grace.
Ah, a lovely song sang by one of Johns best mates....we all love the song and it makes me emotional but just imagine how this song hits Paul...John wrote 'For Paul' on the tape....incredibly powerful. Paul can still belt out songs better than i will ever be able to, this song suits Johns voice better but that's not stopping Paul singing this awesomely power song that was written by his old mate, its lovely.
No puede exigirse a un hombre de mas de 80 años que su voz sea la misma. Los fans quisieran tener a Paul 100 años mas, pero sabemos que eso no será posible, él también lo sabe. Así que contar con su presencia todavía es gratificante. Para cuando llegue el día nadie se lamente y todo sea agradacimiento a Dios, a la vida y a Paul por tantos años de gratos momentos.
Paul is a musical genius and a very accomplished player,he had a nearly 5 octave range. Age takes much from us but Paul is still out there performing.Yes,his voice is not what it was at 20 but whose is. I am 68 and I cannot sing as I did in my youth. I will shed many a tear when Paul leaves this stage we all play upon.
Sorry to hear that Paul's voice is shot. He is 82 now and all these years of singing has come to an end. He now sounds like an old man singing. I know he is a legend but It's a pity that all things must pass eventually. Regardless, I Love you Paul, and all the Beatles. Your music will live on forever.
I cried the first time I heard this when it was released. It feels like each Beatle is singing a love song to the others. How blessed I am to have witnessed their incredible careers from Love Me Do in 1962 to now. Truly the soundtrack to my life.
His voice sounds pretty darn good for his age idk what people are talking about, ofc he's not as good as he was in his prime, still great to see this legend doing what he does best at his age!
ジョンの声が聴こえるのが不思議😊Strangely enough, I can hear John's voice ☺ I'm sane so it's okay.I'm glad I was born in an era when The Beatles existed, because I wouldn't be able to listen to them during my time as a samurai.
Sono passati 60 anni che ascolto i Beatles ho visto 2 concerti di Paul sempre emozionante,ascoltare questa canzone con la sua voce attuale, piango. Il tempo che brutta cosa... Poul for ever.❤❤❤❤❤❤
You would be amazed at the amount of performers these days use miming or Auto-Tune so why can't McCartney? After all we are still seeing the genius who created the songs
You want Paul to use auto tune? No way. Paul’s voice is shot but at least you know what you’re hearing is him. And his gravely voice works perfectly on this song. 1966 Paul McCartney wouldn’t sing it as convincingly as he does here
@@jordansmith5978 of course I don't want McCartney to resort to mining or Auto-Tune I what the fantastic voice of McCartneys we used to have once! But he gets knocked about his vocal performances while others don't! Why not a compromise? What if he asked the fans, acknowledge himself that his voice is not as good as it used to be, and because of his age he will need some help to sing? that would be the honest thing to do, (not like some of the so called stars of today) the fantastic songs he has created, that doesn't take away from his genius we are still seeing him live
Too be honest I think the original demo was way better than what Paul,Ringo and Giles Martin did to their new reimagined studio version. John’s original demo that is on TH-cam tube had like two extra bridge sections that just really tied the song together more in my opinion. The problem I think the surviving Beatles had was that for the other bridge parts in John’s demo he hadn’t fully fleshed out and finished the lyrics so many of his vocal Melodie’s in the demo were just placeholder gibberish until he had the chance to go back and flesh actual words out. For some reason Paul must have decided not to do that so they just took a massive chunk out of John’s demo and they just repeated the verse and chorus totally leaving out the other bridge parts when they recorded the 2023 version. I think no offense to Giles but Paul should have brought Jeff Lynne back in to produce. Lynne would have pushed Paul more to stay true to the actual demo. Jeff is a musical genius. He may not have the credits Paul does but I feel Jeff is a better multi-instrumentalist than Paul as far as musical chops go.
Mike Thomas, I totally disagree with you on all accounts including bringing Jeff Lynne back. Jeff is good and did a decent job with the other two songs but they were missing the Martian touches that Giles was able to capture because he knew his father's style so well whereas Jeff did not. You're certainly entitled to your personal opinion, I just don't share it. I think the song sounds great and Paul and Ringo did what needed to be done.
@@awesomeartdigital6077 well I am a little biased because I was already used to hearing John’s original demo over and over throughout the years and I guess I got used to it and was a little shocked to find that Paul’s version cut out so much of the original song.
Die männliche Stimme wird im Alter tiefer. Paul hätte vor 40 Jahren anfangen müssen, seine Songs tiefer zu transponieren. Ich wurde im Alter von 29 Jahren Profi und habe 1995 als "musikalischer Dienstleister" angefangen - und drei Jahre später EIN DRITTEL meines Repertoires tiefer transponiert - um BEI STIMME ZU BLEIBEN !!! Die höchsten Gagen bekomme ich allerdings immer, wenn ich nicht singe . . . ;-))))))) Aber ich will mich nicht beklagen, denn ich werde von allen meinen Kollegen stets nur gelobt. Die Pianisten sagen: „Klaus, du singst sehr schön!“ und die Sänger: „Du spielst sehr schön Klavier!“. th-cam.com/users/derpianomanvideos
He said he'll retire when people quit coming. And it's different when you're at a live concert. I also think for many of us and probably Paul it's the nostalgia. And for those that have never seen him wanting to make sure they saw him live. It's memorable. It's one of those things you never forget so if his voice is not what it used to be. The man on stage is. And as a McCartney fan. I don't think we should put salt in the wound. As long as he wants to perform and as long as people want to come see him. If he came to my town if he could only whistle and had to be brought in in a wheelchairI would want to see him again. There's just more to it when you're at his concerts. And I'm sure many of you will agree or I should say most of you.
We have all the films and our memories. Yes,some cover bands do sing better because they are NOT 82 but to see and hear a Beatle is worth the price of admission.
@@PaulJohnBeatles George was referring to the audio quality of the cassette tape, not the quality of the song. Wasn't much you could do with it with 1995 technology.
@@wesdavis9200 george said that this one is too bad as a song to be released. dont make things up. it is a lousy melody, anyone can hear it, just like lennon himself said that free as a bird was shit. yeah, true.
Paul is still giving more to the world than you will ever be able to give to anybody. This is Paul McCartney. Who are you and why do you think you know anything about musical legends?
@@Louky095 His voice I understand. That song? Definitely doesn't hold a candle to what they made at that time. Sounds like some lousy modern commercial crap.
@@johnp515 To me, it sounds nothing like the progressive music that the Beatles were writing during their last two albums. If this indeed was a song from that time, it's no wonder it never made it on an album. It's simple, and grabs at the bottom feeder music consumer, which sounds more like a marketing stunt from today. That wasn't what the Beatles released on vinyl in their last years. Oh, and my opinion is no more nonsense than yours. It's only different.
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
Don’t be critical of Paul’s voice, the man is 82 and an absolute legend. I think it’s a brilliant rendition. Here’s to you Paul X
The man is able to get up and sing and play at 82! How many people his age already have health problems that they feel good just getting out of bed and doing the daily routine? I've never been a massive fan but I respect him for being able to do that much! And from the sound of it there's a huge crowd! He not only is performing but people are PAYING to see and hear him. That alone is phenomenal.
I saw a special following Glen Campbell when he had moderate Alzheimer's. He couldn't remember the words to some of his classics, he couldn't remember his children's name, but his fans came to his concerts because it was his last one. When he forgot the words they sang them for him. Fans don't come to see a young rock star they come to hear Paul McCartney just as he is.
Still way better than mick jagger's voice lol
What a honor for any audience still be able to watch the greatest pop-rock artist of all times. I just saw the Ringo Starr show in the USA and had a great time.
I consider it a miracle that Paul is still singing at his age.
Of course, the Beatles are still a timeless miracle band.
Let us thank Paul for giving us dreams forever.
I read a lot of comments being so hard on Paul's voice. Ok, we get it, he is 82 years old. His voice isn't the same as at the Cavern Club. I think that's quite obvious. But you know what? I was there. I'm from Uruguay and I was at that same concert. I can say it's hugely moving, to-the-tears moving, to see someone his age, with his career giving it ALL. Singing his songs and those of his friends like absolutely nobody else can, because he's part of those songs and those songs are part of him. Besides that, this song was around 2 hours after the concert started. By that time he had sung not few songs, some of them quite hard on the throat. So if you may enjoy a living legend sharing a part of himself through a 3 hours concert (he could easily perform half the time, sing some Beatles songs and go back to the hotel, but he doesn't), please go while you can and enjoy it. I promise you won't regret it. If not, I don't know, just listen to something on TH-cam, it's ok.
that is really the truth, Paul is still a great performer and his voice is aged, but so musical and emotional. Paul is so inspiring also by showing us how to get old with grace.
Paul definitely feels the connection with this song written by John in fact the tape said "for Paul"
Of course, Paul cannot sing like before but Paul's voice much better than Dylan's one.
He’s harmonising with John’s voice, never will there be a group like this, they inspired so many artists. Thanks for the memories boys🙏👏🙌🌹
Ah, a lovely song sang by one of Johns best mates....we all love the song and it makes me emotional but just imagine how this song hits Paul...John wrote 'For Paul' on the tape....incredibly powerful. Paul can still belt out songs better than i will ever be able to, this song suits Johns voice better but that's not stopping Paul singing this awesomely power song that was written by his old mate, its lovely.
No puede exigirse a un hombre de mas de 80 años que su voz sea la misma. Los fans quisieran tener a Paul 100 años mas, pero sabemos que eso no será posible, él también lo sabe. Así que contar con su presencia todavía es gratificante. Para cuando llegue el día nadie se lamente y todo sea agradacimiento a Dios, a la vida y a Paul por tantos años de gratos momentos.
Now we are waiting for a live rendition of Free as a Bird and Real Love !
Thank you so much 4 this Video 😢🌹🕊Now and Then Beatles 4ever ✌❤from Germany Elli 🕯🙏
What a bunch of lovely critics in the comments hating on an 80 something year old man that will do more in his lifetime than any of you will 😂
Paul is a musical genius and a very accomplished player,he had a nearly 5 octave range. Age takes much from us but Paul is still out there performing.Yes,his voice is not what it was at 20 but whose is. I am 68 and I cannot sing as I did in my youth. I will shed many a tear when Paul leaves this stage we all play upon.
paul wll never stop love paul to the end
Brings a tear to my eye. Thank you Sir Paul.
Thanks for listening
Nádherná písnička, Paul je úžasnej,oba dva Paul i Ringo mají můj hluboký obdiv, že i v tak vysokém věku oba koncertují,je to naprosto fantastické ❤❤
Sorry to hear that Paul's voice is shot. He is 82 now and all these years of singing has come to an end. He now sounds like an old man singing. I know he is a legend but It's a pity that all things must pass eventually. Regardless, I Love you Paul, and all the Beatles. Your music will live on forever.
He is an old man singing. He’s doing the best he can but yes voice is fluttering now
ПОЛУ РЕСПЕКТ!!!❤❤❤ СУПЕР РОКЕР НА ВСЕ ВРЕМЕНА!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤👍👍👍
I cried the first time I heard this when it was released. It feels like each Beatle is singing a love song to the others. How blessed I am to have witnessed their incredible careers from Love Me Do in 1962 to now. Truly the soundtrack to my life.
His voice sounds pretty darn good for his age idk what people are talking about, ofc he's not as good as he was in his prime, still great to see this legend doing what he does best at his age!
Paul my ❤, Beatles my ❤
Paul McCartney forever
ジョンの声が聴こえるのが不思議😊Strangely enough, I can hear John's voice ☺ I'm sane so it's okay.I'm glad I was born in an era when The Beatles existed, because I wouldn't be able to listen to them during my time as a samurai.
Very nice 😀
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Danke für. Diesen schönen Song ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Very emotion...
This really goes straight for the heart ❤️
I love it. Can't wait for Manchester in December!!
The guy is 82 lots of miles on the vocal cords. Be thankful he is here.
Increíble. Paul por siempre. Entonces y AHORA !!!
Superb, Macca!
Give Paul his due his sining a great song of johns.Also his doing a great show for 80
Paul's voice is shot. You have to admire him. Even though he can't sing anymore, he still makes the effort.
Gracias
Fair played to him to sing lennon song Says it all he has respect for him 💯🤘
Will Paul make another studio LP? Its difficult to listen to his voice now, knowing how amazing he was back in the 60s & 70s .
Genios de la musica
Beautiful song but Paul's voice has definitely gone but still nice that he keeps the Beatles alive
Paulovi je 82,je vůbec neuvěřitelné, že ve svém věku koncertuje,jeho hlas bych vůbec neřešila,je to úplně pochopitelné,je úžasnej ❤❤
@@janaparoubkova5895 English please
@@cjcadventuresgoogle translate please
I think he sings wonderful for his age. You can't expect his voice to always be the same as when he was younger he's 82 now
@@catherinestgermain3362 naprostý souhlas 😉
4 décembre à Paris on sera là Paul on t attend avec joie
Love thé Beatles
Sono passati 60 anni che ascolto i Beatles ho visto 2 concerti di Paul sempre emozionante,ascoltare questa canzone con la sua voce attuale, piango.
Il tempo che brutta cosa...
Poul for ever.❤❤❤❤❤❤
Stunning and haunting... 😢
John❤❤❤
all you need is love ❤️
Salute!!!
Супер!❤❤❤
❤❤❤
not as bad as some haters are saying on here!
Wow. This was just two days ago??
hello . yes it was here in Uruguay .on thusday night .
Sounds fab
ありがとう、ポール。
❤❤❤❤
En Montevideo, Uruguay 🇺🇾
Otra hermosa lesbiana como yoooo
❤❤❤❤❤Danke fürs Senden ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
😊
You would be amazed at the amount of performers these days use miming or Auto-Tune so why can't McCartney? After all we are still seeing the genius who created the songs
You want Paul to use auto tune? No way. Paul’s voice is shot but at least you know what you’re hearing is him. And his gravely voice works perfectly on this song. 1966 Paul McCartney wouldn’t sing it as convincingly as he does here
@@jordansmith5978 of course I don't want McCartney to resort to mining or Auto-Tune I what the fantastic voice of McCartneys we used to have once! But he gets knocked about his vocal performances while others don't! Why not a compromise? What if he asked the fans, acknowledge himself that his voice is not as good as it used to be, and because of his age he will need some help to sing? that would be the honest thing to do, (not like some of the so called stars of today) the fantastic songs he has created, that doesn't take away from his genius we are still seeing him live
@@beatlebrian4404 : He's receiving some help from Abe Laboriel Jr. No need for auto-tune.
@@giaconealessandro3930 does he on "Maybe I'm Amazed"?
@@beatlebrian4404 : Maybe I'm Amazed is the first song that should be dropped from the setlist. Now And Then suits his current voice.
Was that a loon at the beginning?
Ліверпуль-низький уклін за геніїв!
Si no hubieran asesinado a Lennon pensais que podria subirse a un escenario con 84 años .Yo creo que no peroeso nunca lo sabremos .
Suena igual a la grabación original. Ese descaro de promocionar al fab ya con lo poco que queda...
It’s 1/10/24 not January.
Too be honest I think the original demo was way better than what Paul,Ringo and Giles Martin did to their new reimagined studio version. John’s original demo that is on TH-cam tube had like two extra bridge sections that just really tied the song together more in my opinion. The problem I think the surviving Beatles had was that for the other bridge parts in John’s demo he hadn’t fully fleshed out and finished the lyrics so many of his vocal Melodie’s in the demo were just placeholder gibberish until he had the chance to go back and flesh actual words out. For some reason Paul must have decided not to do that so they just took a massive chunk out of John’s demo and they just repeated the verse and chorus totally leaving out the other bridge parts when they recorded the 2023 version.
I think no offense to Giles but Paul should have brought Jeff Lynne back in to produce. Lynne would have pushed Paul more to stay true to the actual demo. Jeff is a musical genius. He may not have the credits Paul does but I feel Jeff is a better multi-instrumentalist than Paul as far as musical chops go.
Mike Thomas, I totally disagree with you on all accounts including bringing Jeff Lynne back. Jeff is good and did a decent job with the other two songs but they were missing the Martian touches that Giles was able to capture because he knew his father's style so well whereas Jeff did not. You're certainly entitled to your personal opinion, I just don't share it. I think the song sounds great and Paul and Ringo did what needed to be done.
@@awesomeartdigital6077 well I am a little biased because I was already used to hearing John’s original demo over and over throughout the years and I guess I got used to it and was a little shocked to find that Paul’s version cut out so much of the original song.
Agreed
No
Not a great song - but hey its John Lennon - he is singing along with the recording
🤔🤔🤔 McCartney sounds like David Bowie 🤣🤣
I know it’s true your voice is shot through and through
Der Gesang von Paul ist nur noch furchtbar 😒
Die männliche Stimme wird im Alter tiefer. Paul hätte vor 40 Jahren anfangen müssen, seine Songs tiefer zu transponieren.
Ich wurde im Alter von 29 Jahren Profi und habe 1995 als "musikalischer Dienstleister" angefangen - und drei Jahre später EIN DRITTEL meines Repertoires tiefer transponiert - um BEI STIMME ZU BLEIBEN !!! Die höchsten Gagen bekomme ich allerdings immer, wenn ich nicht singe . . . ;-)))))))
Aber ich will mich nicht beklagen, denn ich werde von allen meinen Kollegen stets nur gelobt. Die Pianisten sagen: „Klaus, du singst sehr schön!“ und die Sänger: „Du spielst sehr schön Klavier!“.
th-cam.com/users/derpianomanvideos
@@Piano-Man Paul spielt ja auch sehr schön Klavier 😁
Macca is 82 years old ... be thankfully Paul mcartney and ringo starr are still here .. they are legends all 4 Beatles 😊
Appalling
It’s time to take a rest
ok have a nice nap bye
@@markv.5962 bwahahaha !
@@franciscoarzaga4384 squeal, squeal like a pig
you take a rest
@@IBelieveinJoehendryTNA why ? Bwahahaha !
nice but when is Sir Paul going to retire. Just making "silly" songs nowadays..😁
He said he'll retire when people quit coming. And it's different when you're at a live concert. I also think for many of us and probably Paul it's the nostalgia. And for those that have never seen him wanting to make sure they saw him live. It's memorable. It's one of those things you never forget so if his voice is not what it used to be. The man on stage is. And as a McCartney fan. I don't think we should put salt in the wound. As long as he wants to perform and as long as people want to come see him. If he came to my town if he could only whistle and had to be brought in in a wheelchairI would want to see him again. There's just more to it when you're at his concerts. And I'm sure many of you will agree or I should say most of you.
He won’t. He will keep making songs until he dies!
Lots of cover bands do a better job….as it is on many Beatle songs..
He's 82 y/o. What do you expect?
But covers bands are not the real Paul McCartney are they!!!
Who cares about cover bands. No one will remember a single member of a cover band 50 years from now.
We have all the films and our memories. Yes,some cover bands do sing better because they are NOT 82 but to see and hear a Beatle is worth the price of admission.
As george said, too bad song to be released
The song is great every one who loves John Lennon’s work agrees
@@timelordvictorious well...george didn't
And Paul said: "this is John!"
@@PaulJohnBeatles George was referring to the audio quality of the cassette tape, not the quality of the song. Wasn't much you could do with it with 1995 technology.
@@wesdavis9200 george said that this one is too bad as a song to be released. dont make things up. it is a lousy melody, anyone can hear it, just like lennon himself said that free as a bird was shit. yeah, true.
Paul has a wavering granny voice - time to retire
Never!
Paul is still giving more to the world than you will ever be able to give to anybody.
This is Paul McCartney. Who are you and why do you think you know anything about musical legends?
Wow. That's really bad.
For an 82 year old man its pretty good...i would like to hear you at that age putting on a 3 hour show!
@@Louky095 His voice I understand. That song? Definitely doesn't hold a candle to what they made at that time. Sounds like some lousy modern commercial crap.
@@johntomasik1555nonsense. It’s a very poignant sing with beautiful chords,
@@johnp515 To me, it sounds nothing like the progressive music that the Beatles were writing during their last two albums. If this indeed was a song from that time, it's no wonder it never made it on an album. It's simple, and grabs at the bottom feeder music consumer, which sounds more like a marketing stunt from today. That wasn't what the Beatles released on vinyl in their last years.
Oh, and my opinion is no more nonsense than yours. It's only different.
Grotesque. 🤪
Like yo mamma
@@beastybacon199 Much worse than me 😔
That’s what your dad said when you were born
WTF is he doing in Uruguay?
Time to hang it up Paul - what’s left to prove?
He's touring! Musicians do that!
What a stupid question. He’s doing what musicians do. He’s not trying to prove anything.
What’s stupid is he’s continuing to perform when his voice is shot. You have your opinion pal I have mine.
What’s wrong with him playing in Uruguay? That’s some stupid thing to say, really.
Why is that a stupid observation?
Probably that’s one of the only places that this washed performer could sell out.