Too many dudes in the room. You can't nail that many accents and they just sound recycled Qui-Gon and Anakin plus a crowd. My suggestion is do RoP as Elrond trying to pass it off as what really happened, and only have a hobbit and a human there to hear it because it's relevant to them.
No one's looking forward to Rings of Power. Your reactions to Rings of Power on the other hand, THAT we can't wait for. You know, between the LOTR crew, the GoT crew and the Star Wars crew plus you and the missus, your rent must be insane. Sure, Ned, Sam and Dooku probably live in the cupboard and of course, Qui-Gon's a ghost but you might as well just buy a proper house for what you must be paying for that flat.
moria orc: oh no, some stone fell down. but nothing to worry about. happens all the time in this ancient place. unknown shouting voice: fool of a took! moria orc: well... maybe better have a look
I'd just like to point out that I got to Charlie's videos because of a friend... who thought it was actually Ian McKellen in costume doing a commentary.
Dont inflate charlie's ego to much. Everyone including himself already knows he's a brilliant genius. We don't want him turning into a conceded, self righteous, narcissist on us.😉😂
Gandalf really demonstrated his mastery of magic when he used illusion magic to momentarily turn his and Boromir's faces into Charlie's face at the start. Impressive.
I'll never forget how hard I laughed when I finally made the connection that Gandalf literally told Pippin to kill himself, like he was some 4chan memelord.
@@alanpennie8013 its almost like gandalf was watching them in Bree and when the fellowship formed he acted like he was halfway done with him before they even started.
If anyone cares, a likely influence for the Moria sequence is William Hope Hodgson (1877-1918) who published some fantasy novels before WW1 (in which he was killed). Watchers, squid-monsters, the "apocalyptic log" i.e. Book of Mazarbul are all in Hodgson. Some point to Lovecraft, but in fact Lovecraft admired Hodgson and used the "apocalyptic log" device in the story 'Dagon'.
Aragorn - "It was a combination of all our blows." Elron - "And why did it take so long, I've seen Galadriel slide under a troll dual wielding and take it out with a simple double cut..."
Haven't been this addicted to anything like this since the 80s. Gandalf and crew bring me the light and joy of the Eldar. The best channel on TH-cam this side of the Southlands... I mean "Mordor". Love you Charlie! Thanks for making my favorite universes even more enjoyable!
You think you know what's mordor like? You think it's funny to compare your country to Mordor? You know that modern-day REAL mordor with real armies of real orks is russia. Not your safe and secure country that doesn't invade and attack anyone. You don't know what it's like to live next to mordor and to fight it, so maybe don't make unnecessary comparisons.
@@MrHurst-lb1rn You must be not very bright or empathetic. I'm UKRAINIAN and unlike you I KNOW what it's like to be at war with mordor and to live next to it.
@@MrHurst-lb1rn I'm ''yelling'' at you not because of war but because of you whining about living in ''mordor'' while you live sheltered safe existence in a secure country far from mordor and war. You use words meaning of which you can't even begin to comprehend, edgelord. You say you voted for ''no wars'' or reaaaaally? Do you live in a fairy-tale? What does it even mean ''vote for no wars'', did you vote to not give ukr. help we need in the fight with mordor either? Are you one of those that ''loves peace'' and does not want to even hear about war even though EVERYONE loves peace, most of all those who are robbed of it. You country did not invade us, so again what does your ''vote'' have to do with any of this? Again, you must be VERY educated and compassionate... Not.
Hey, Legolas. Sorry. Apart from the earlier team-effort it was actually Pippin's sword strike to the base of the troll's skull that caused it to raise is head and reveal it's vulnerable neck that you, quite skillfully perforated, promptly puncturing its larynx and probably it's spine. Hence the wobble tongue. Come on, Gandalf. Pippin rodeoing a troll to it's doom is quite impressive.🤣
Ackshyually it was Ori who did all the writing. He joined Balin's expedition to Moria because Dain wouldn't fund the development of a Dwarvish cursive script
"How does Pippin get a point?" "When he does something good, I guess." Can't wait til Pippin saves his ass in part three ("guard of the citadel indeed!"), even though at that point there's nothing that can touch Gandalf (in the book at least)
Hell yes, hours of staring at my TH-cam channel has finally paid off. Awesome stuff Charlie.. You are one of the forces for good in a world of darkness. Question: have you ever heard from your subjects about your work. Id love to know what they think.
OMG i never thought about that, "how many times the moria goblins immediately switch to a war footing and stampede into a room to find its their cousin fred" " sorry i tripped and knocked over the dead dwarf"
Ha ha. At 18:49, I thought that too about Frodo taking the spear to his chest. A bullet proof vest will stop a bullet, but the trauma can still be fatal. Years ago a cop was shot with 45-70 rifle. The vest technically stopped the bullet, but the bullet still pushed the vest into the poor guy’s chest and killed him.
That's not even the most unrealistic thing in this scene in terms of how durable people are. "Boromir" questions Frodo surviving that troll jamming that spear against the Mithril shirt without blunt force trauma but not how he didn't splatter against that wall when that same troll chucked him across the room like a toy, and just walked it off like he was just shoved against a wall by a regular sized person.
That Squid you speak of was Hymbor, a high born oceanic citizen of Derilia that once stood up to the King for demolishing his quarters to build the Royal Armory. Hymbor was then exiled after his family was executed before him for crimes against the crown.He roamed the seas to find an army willing to help him overthrow the present King Durenhal, son of King Herendal the one who wronged Hymbor. But alas, since the fall of Sauron, all races were unwilling to participate in another war, especially one under water. One day he met Pedonis, an elf living in the forest of Gwirren to serve out his life as penance for staging a coup against the leader of his clan, who shared his malice towards the royalty and told him about a great monster deep in the Mines of Moria made of fire and light. Hymbor made his way in search of that light only to end up encountering the Fellowship who cut off his limbs. He managed to regenerate his limbs and swim back to Moria only to find that the Balrog had been defeated. 😢😢
At first i thought Boromir was your worst impression. Then i watched a few times and its still not your Gandalf but the attention to detail with his body language and facial expressions is freaking awesome. 🎉
I love how legalos and gimli have a bromance going on and talk like a couple. Plus legolas being vain af just makes it worth watching these clips. You gotta do the hobbit trilogy...the bromance between azog the defiler and thorin oakenshield would be legendary lol
Must say by the looks of it those goblin cleaners are slacking on the task at hand. Or maybe sick of being interrupted by the whole gang plus troll every time they make a noise.
Imagine living in that place with thousands of other Orcs and Trolls, having to fear the shadow lurking in the deep while pillaging every scrap of wealth this place holds, you can count on low food rations. Probably getting startled by a small noise is like the bells from cantina. Its like:,,Food! First one gets it.'' But on the other hand, they were just as greedy if not more then the dwarfs for not just leaving the mines behind. Also i have to say, poor janitor who has to clean the place up when the dwarfs returned. Makes me think of Mr Filch from this Harry Potter universe.
I love how Boromir pointed out the watcher in the water bit. Even in the book the shit seemed like it came out of nowhere. Like it was a last minute decision without context.
Movie doesn't explain it, but the book does in a subtle manner. Gandalf notes how strange it is that the river is as low as it is higher on the trail, they find that the river was dammed up and Gandalf begins to get very suspicious and tells the group not to mess with the water at all, then Boromir throws a stone in impatience and just as the doors are opened the Watcher in the Water emerges. To my understanding the Watcher was basically set as a trap by the Goblins to catch any Dwarves fleeing that direction to escape the mines.
@@HighPriestFuneral sound plausible until you realise the watcher is just too much a wild card to be played by a bunch of stupid goblins. Even the smartest of them couldn’t come up with a plan that ingenious. Plus that theory also falls apart by the fact that it was stated the goblins didn’t know of the watcher either. It was just a happy accident it cut of the escape of the morian dwarves.
Whats hilarious to me is the 'drums drums in the deep.. ' bit. I mostly remember how awesome the song by CLANDESTINE an aussie hip hop group that sampled it. I cant remember the name, but if you find it, its awesome.
I am loving Gimli and Legolas as a couple. Glad they finally came out about it. Im assuming they just kind of organically stopped hiding it and no one ever said anything or made a big deal because they all knew already. Although seriously, their friendship arc is one of my favorite parts of the book. One of the light elements that makes it enjoyable while being deep. And it's wholesome. Makes me think of the stories about wounded soldiers on opposite sides who run into each other after crawling off the battlefield, and who end up binding each other's wounds and sharing their food and drink and waiting to be saved. Gives one some hope for human nature, on the individual scale.
Fun fact, in the books one of the possible members of the Fellowship was Glorfindel, a guy who killed a Balrog during the Fall of Gondolin. He was passed over in favour of the Hobbits.
LOTR is back! Who's looking forward to Rings of Power?
Gandalf's death now on Patreon: www.patreon.com/CharlieHopkinson
Too many dudes in the room. You can't nail that many accents and they just sound recycled Qui-Gon and Anakin plus a crowd.
My suggestion is do RoP as Elrond trying to pass it off as what really happened, and only have a hobbit and a human there to hear it because it's relevant to them.
why Gimly is not deepfaked? ;)
@@sboinkthelegday3892 probably just struck to how we’ve been doing it
Nice it's back!!
Not really excited for RoP s2, but definitely wanna see your spin on it.
No one's looking forward to Rings of Power. Your reactions to Rings of Power on the other hand, THAT we can't wait for.
You know, between the LOTR crew, the GoT crew and the Star Wars crew plus you and the missus, your rent must be insane. Sure, Ned, Sam and Dooku probably live in the cupboard and of course, Qui-Gon's a ghost but you might as well just buy a proper house for what you must be paying for that flat.
moria orc: oh no, some stone fell down. but nothing to worry about. happens all the time in this ancient place.
unknown shouting voice: fool of a took!
moria orc: well... maybe better have a look
it was literally a cacophny of falling chains.
@@taddad2641 in the movie
I love the whole shtick of Boromir constantly mocking Gandalf for his awesome magical power over light.
It's great to see Sean Bean, fully intact, with nary an arrow in sight.
And, he's alive!!😱
I'd just like to point out that I got to Charlie's videos because of a friend... who thought it was actually Ian McKellen in costume doing a commentary.
Dont inflate charlie's ego to much. Everyone including himself already knows he's a brilliant genius. We don't want him turning into a conceded, self righteous, narcissist on us.😉😂
@@Christrulesall2too late
@@CharlieHopkinson Then you have fallen..into shadow...😔😆
Same here, except I was the friend.
@@DruHarden Then you both have fallen under the great deception of the Dark Lord Charlie.😈😈
Gandalf really demonstrated his mastery of magic when he used illusion magic to momentarily turn his and Boromir's faces into Charlie's face at the start. Impressive.
@KarazolaX so funny 😂 and so true 😉
“Oh that’s just Cthulhu. He wandered in during the song of Creation and never left.” -Gandalf 🤣
Yup
Charlie, you've brought a great amount of joy into my life with these. Thanks, man.
Gandalf and Saruman bragging about their powerful magics, with Light and Open/Close being 0-level cantrips in most D&D editions, gets me every time.
I'll never forget how hard I laughed when I finally made the connection that Gandalf literally told Pippin to kill himself, like he was some 4chan memelord.
We have to assume that Gandalf didn't actually mean it.
It was just a momentary flash of irritation.
The two became quite pally in Minas Tirith.
@@alanpennie8013 its almost like gandalf was watching them in Bree and when the fellowship formed he acted like he was halfway done with him before they even started.
"Pippin is an arsehole". Thank you, someone finally said it. Second fucking breakfast.
Dude he was raised with that culture. He didn't come up with it.
@@sboinkthelegday3892 lol
He's also the youngest, barely out of childhood by Hobbit standards.
was it pippin and some random thing falling down in an ancient mine or was it gandalfs shouting afterwards that alamed the orcs?
Love how people are taking this seriously.
It was actually Ori who wrote the last bit in the journal. Balin was already dead...
"Frodo went to private school I see..." haha, was a good one.
If boromir continues to be the reasonable one, i might have to agree with him that he deserves the ring
his relentless logic does start to wear you down to his side
"He breaths so loudly we could have shot him in the dark."
Gimli: HEAVY BREATHING
🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
If anyone cares, a likely influence for the Moria sequence is William Hope Hodgson (1877-1918) who published some fantasy novels before WW1 (in which he was killed). Watchers, squid-monsters, the "apocalyptic log" i.e. Book of Mazarbul are all in Hodgson.
Some point to Lovecraft, but in fact Lovecraft admired Hodgson and used the "apocalyptic log" device in the story 'Dagon'.
Aragorn - "It was a combination of all our blows." Elron - "And why did it take so long, I've seen Galadriel slide under a troll dual wielding and take it out with a simple double cut..."
Haven't been this addicted to anything like this since the 80s. Gandalf and crew bring me the light and joy of the Eldar. The best channel on TH-cam this side of the Southlands... I mean "Mordor". Love you Charlie! Thanks for making my favorite universes even more enjoyable!
You think you know what's mordor like? You think it's funny to compare your country to Mordor? You know that modern-day REAL mordor with real armies of real orks is russia. Not your safe and secure country that doesn't invade and attack anyone. You don't know what it's like to live next to mordor and to fight it, so maybe don't make unnecessary comparisons.
@@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 you must be fun at parties. I voted for no wars, yell at someone else
@@MrHurst-lb1rn You must be not very bright or empathetic. I'm UKRAINIAN and unlike you I KNOW what it's like to be at war with mordor and to live next to it.
@@MrHurst-lb1rn I'm ''yelling'' at you not because of war but because of you whining about living in ''mordor'' while you live sheltered safe existence in a secure country far from mordor and war. You use words meaning of which you can't even begin to comprehend, edgelord. You say you voted for ''no wars'' or reaaaaally? Do you live in a fairy-tale? What does it even mean ''vote for no wars'', did you vote to not give ukr. help we need in the fight with mordor either? Are you one of those that ''loves peace'' and does not want to even hear about war even though EVERYONE loves peace, most of all those who are robbed of it. You country did not invade us, so again what does your ''vote'' have to do with any of this? Again, you must be VERY educated and compassionate... Not.
Hey, Legolas.
Sorry. Apart from the earlier team-effort it was actually Pippin's sword strike to the base of the troll's skull that caused it to raise is head and reveal it's vulnerable neck that you, quite skillfully perforated, promptly puncturing its larynx and probably it's spine. Hence the wobble tongue.
Come on, Gandalf. Pippin rodeoing a troll to it's doom is quite impressive.🤣
Definitely.
WHO ALL AGREES WITH ME. CHARLIE IS THE BEST IN THE BUSINESS???
He is my captain and king!
Boromir is just perfect I love it so much
I just rewatched fellowship and i just keep hearing your reactions. 😂
Gimli calling Legolas “babe” lol😂
😂😂😂😂😂❤ it's real love! Suck it Tauriel!!!!
Since you have Orlando Bloom down, when Depp? We need POTC watch party.
Please
Oh my gosh, please please
The wooden hand behind Gandalf straight up flipping the bird 😂
Omg all voices are perfectly executed. Love it. Well done, lads 👍🏻❤
Mr. Turning-The-Lights-On 😂
Ackshyually it was Ori who did all the writing. He joined Balin's expedition to Moria because Dain wouldn't fund the development of a Dwarvish cursive script
Pippin: exist
Gandalf: you should jump.
Gimli is such a romantic.
16.55 min mark. Legolas saying yes yes yes with that face 😂
For what it's worth, Boromir, i thought your "Ego-las" quip was funny.
"I got that from a fridge magnet"
I'm dead now. 😂😂😂
Oh really? How is afterlife treating you?🙄🤦♀
@@yevgeniyaleshchenko849 unfortunately I got the room next to the noisy ice machine
It's amazing how if i didn't know, I'd know that was Ian McKellen, Sean Bean, and Hugo Weaving chillin 😂😂😂
And the SamTato!
@@nhmooytis7058 🤣
Quality! Cheers for the time you've put in.
I’ve not laughed so hard for so long… “hands off that shiny shirt you thieving rat” 😂thanks this was great!
I love how much this expands the characters as personalities
“Pippin is an asshole and I’m not going to apologize for anything I said to him.”
Omg 😆 😂
"arsehole"...
There’s also the possibility that it was Gandalf’s shouting that caused the goblins to come charging in
"How does Pippin get a point?"
"When he does something good, I guess."
Can't wait til Pippin saves his ass in part three ("guard of the citadel indeed!"), even though at that point there's nothing that can touch Gandalf (in the book at least)
I look forward to watching this whole series for the 25th anniversary
This Lotr series is so good! cheers, charlie!!!
Nice to see the LOTR boys back for 2nd breakfast. :)
11:26 is something I never knew I wanted to hear Gandalf say.
Hell yes, hours of staring at my TH-cam channel has finally paid off. Awesome stuff Charlie.. You are one of the forces for good in a world of darkness.
Question: have you ever heard from your subjects about your work. Id love to know what they think.
YEAH 👍
OMG i never thought about that, "how many times the moria goblins immediately switch to a war footing and stampede into a room to find its their cousin fred" " sorry i tripped and knocked over the dead dwarf"
Still the best thing on the internet 😂😂😂
Agreed😂😂
Your videos are so well done, I just love when you post the next one❤
You videos make me laugh almost everytime, keep up the great work
"I hate Thursdays" 🤣
“I hate Thursdays” had me dyinggggg 😭😭😭😭
Tha remote on the staff 😂
From this footage, we can clearly see that they could never drop an ice troll in less than ten seconds like the real hero of this setting.
An ice troll, i always assumed it was just a regular troll.
There's a Troll in the mine!! A Troll in the mine! Just thought you otta know.
Oh Eru! That's absolutely amazing)))) Gimly and Legolas are my favorites, they are hilarious))) thank you
Ha ha. At 18:49, I thought that too about Frodo taking the spear to his chest. A bullet proof vest will stop a bullet, but the trauma can still be fatal. Years ago a cop was shot with 45-70 rifle. The vest technically stopped the bullet, but the bullet still pushed the vest into the poor guy’s chest and killed him.
That's not even the most unrealistic thing in this scene in terms of how durable people are.
"Boromir" questions Frodo surviving that troll jamming that spear against the Mithril shirt without blunt force trauma but not how he didn't splatter against that wall when that same troll chucked him across the room like a toy, and just walked it off like he was just shoved against a wall by a regular sized person.
This is one of your funniest, you just keep getting better at this!
Is there any way Gandalf and co could react to the Rankin Bass animated films? Got a feeling they’d have some thoughts.
Once again top stuff charlie& & chums😊
We need to get this channel to a million subs, there is not other channel that makes me laugh like this one.
Agree 1000%!
That Squid you speak of was Hymbor, a high born oceanic citizen of Derilia that once stood up to the King for demolishing his quarters to build the Royal Armory. Hymbor was then exiled after his family was executed before him for crimes against the crown.He roamed the seas to find an army willing to help him overthrow the present King Durenhal, son of King Herendal the one who wronged Hymbor. But alas, since the fall of Sauron, all races were unwilling to participate in another war, especially one under water.
One day he met Pedonis, an elf living in the forest of Gwirren to serve out his life as penance for staging a coup against the leader of his clan, who shared his malice towards the royalty and told him about a great monster deep in the Mines of Moria made of fire and light.
Hymbor made his way in search of that light only to end up encountering the Fellowship who cut off his limbs. He managed to regenerate his limbs and swim back to Moria only to find that the Balrog had been defeated. 😢😢
That’s 100x better fanfic than Rings of Power
Straight up. Because the “Watcher in the water” literally has no backstory in universe or otherwise.
That's a lot of effort for a bad joke
@@johngarrett5189 What joke? Its the Tragedy of Hymbor The Noble Mollusc. Not everything is a joke
@@hirudinaria omfg
At first i thought Boromir was your worst impression. Then i watched a few times and its still not your Gandalf but the attention to detail with his body language and facial expressions is freaking awesome. 🎉
Boromir, Pun of Gondor is what's keeping me alive from this crazy humid Northeast asian summers of 2024
"Pippin is an asshole" should be a fridge magnet.
"arse"...
"I just think it looked a bit like he came in his pants." Elrond for the win, narrowly defeating Boromir's blunt trauma comment.
Ah! Precisely on time, I see.
The squid monster?…… if there is a puddle in a MERP scenario there will be a Kraken in it.
Boromir Stark is back!
Yes!
YES 👏
One of the best so far! Love the dynamic between Egolass and Gimli 😂
Their friendship has flourished into a beautiful "relationship."
I‘ve been waiting for this one ❤
Brilliant.
Egolas is great
Underrated. Top tier!
Finally, the best thing on youtube 🧙♂️💍
I love how legalos and gimli have a bromance going on and talk like a couple. Plus legolas being vain af just makes it worth watching these clips. You gotta do the hobbit trilogy...the bromance between azog the defiler and thorin oakenshield would be legendary lol
So well done. So many LOL kills. Bravo.
Gandalf "you try and remember every scene of your life when you've smoked as much Old Toby as I have!"
I see ork blood and I want to paint it black 🖤 killed me!
These kill me 😂 never stop please
Hi Charlie, back to basics, solid story. Thanks
Must say by the looks of it those goblin cleaners are slacking on the task at hand. Or maybe sick of being interrupted by the whole gang plus troll every time they make a noise.
I saw the velociraptor in the bottom corner of my screen and thought it was cracked…
This is the best thing ever!
That Elf chick is like the Garfield of Middle earth, I hate Thursday's 😂
That’s a man.
As in the character is a man
Boromir and his natural whimsy.
Boromir.. BEAUTIFUL WORDS..
GANDALF.. I got that from a fridge magnet
Imagine living in that place with thousands of other Orcs and Trolls, having to fear the shadow lurking in the deep while pillaging every scrap of wealth this place holds, you can count on low food rations. Probably getting startled by a small noise is like the bells from cantina. Its like:,,Food! First one gets it.'' But on the other hand, they were just as greedy if not more then the dwarfs for not just leaving the mines behind.
Also i have to say, poor janitor who has to clean the place up when the dwarfs returned. Makes me think of Mr Filch from this Harry Potter universe.
Yes the legendary squid monster 😂
I thought someone released the kraken.🦑
@@nhmooytis7058 release the KRAKEN!!!!
I love how Boromir pointed out the watcher in the water bit. Even in the book the shit seemed like it came out of nowhere. Like it was a last minute decision without context.
Movie doesn't explain it, but the book does in a subtle manner. Gandalf notes how strange it is that the river is as low as it is higher on the trail, they find that the river was dammed up and Gandalf begins to get very suspicious and tells the group not to mess with the water at all, then Boromir throws a stone in impatience and just as the doors are opened the Watcher in the Water emerges.
To my understanding the Watcher was basically set as a trap by the Goblins to catch any Dwarves fleeing that direction to escape the mines.
@@HighPriestFuneral sound plausible until you realise the watcher is just too much a wild card to be played by a bunch of stupid goblins. Even the smartest of them couldn’t come up with a plan that ingenious. Plus that theory also falls apart by the fact that it was stated the goblins didn’t know of the watcher either. It was just a happy accident it cut of the escape of the morian dwarves.
love watching these videos its like wondering what the characters do offscreen LOL
Pippin is a asshole. Had me rolling 😂. Quality control!! Yes! Good job 👍
Great script! the jokes are really well written! i laughed so hard at the millennial self-centered Legolas!!! soo funny hahahah
Thank God! Slogging through Acolyte nearly borke my spirit.
Whats hilarious to me is the 'drums drums in the deep.. ' bit. I mostly remember how awesome the song by CLANDESTINE an aussie hip hop group that sampled it. I cant remember the name, but if you find it, its awesome.
No haha this is the best line, “Pippin is an A$$hole haha killing me.
Can you at some point do Matrix? You'd already have Smith.
Finally a new fellowship of the ring vid 😁
4:41 It's true that Pity Bilbo was Bilbo's full name, and Gandalf calls Frodo Pity here in honour as a way to appease him.
I am loving Gimli and Legolas as a couple. Glad they finally came out about it. Im assuming they just kind of organically stopped hiding it and no one ever said anything or made a big deal because they all knew already.
Although seriously, their friendship arc is one of my favorite parts of the book. One of the light elements that makes it enjoyable while being deep. And it's wholesome. Makes me think of the stories about wounded soldiers on opposite sides who run into each other after crawling off the battlefield, and who end up binding each other's wounds and sharing their food and drink and waiting to be saved. Gives one some hope for human nature, on the individual scale.
Another hit👏👏👏
Fun fact, in the books one of the possible members of the Fellowship was Glorfindel, a guy who killed a Balrog during the Fall of Gondolin. He was passed over in favour of the Hobbits.