Thanks so much for these wonderful videos. I always love your commentaries too. As for the object in the Charity card: Charity holds a flame in her hand. This represents the "fire of charity", which in Catholic theology, the will of charity wishes the salvation of souls and the fire of truth that cleanses us from sin.
I've learned so much from you. I'm only starting out on my TdM journey and I appreciate all your knowledge. I'd pay a few $ a month to be a channel member. I have the patron app but rarely use it. I don't have the capacity for so many apps. I'd pay a few dollars a month for a TH-cam membership to your channel. I wouldn't expect much from it. Maybe a weekly or monthly members only TdM lesson.
Thank you. New references jumped at me as you were sharing. We do not have all the decks to compare. But some of your musings tap onto symbolic compressed nuances worth noting.
THANK YOU !!! A wonderful video ,from start to finish I loved every minute ! I'm determined this year to delve deeply into the Minchiate . As always I learnt so much from your video and really do appreciate you offering your knowledge so freely 💕.👏👏👏
Thank you for saying so. The Spencer's deck holds up pretty well and seems to compare with the Al Cigna deck. Of course we're not talking quality paper stock and it's got titles on the cards, but for $20 it's a great find.
I'd like to see more on how to read the Minchiate and a comparison of the older ones with a more modern one like the Brian Williams version. I first saw the Williams version on your channel and purchased it. Thanks 55:46
Thank you for this idea. I think I might have compared Brian's Minchiate to a few historic examples already. I've also done a video comparison with a very inexpensive Minchiate. I'll check my Minchiate playlist to see. If I didn't, I'll put your idea in my queue and if I did, I'll send you the link. Thank you for watching and sharing your feelings. ~ Marilyn
Wonderful comparisons! I’m so surprised to how similar the Spencer Minchiate was to the Al Cigno! 🤔 You’re right with your thoughts about some of the transitions of some cards from Minchiate to TdM. So many possibilities 😉 As I always say; so many tangents. 😂 Thank you for such a wonderful presentation Richard
I'm glad you enjoyed it Richard. I'm thinking of doing a pip comparison, unless they're all basically the same. Isn't crazy about Al Cigna and the Spencers? It seems likely the Al Cigna was the deck they copied. Thank you for gifting me with this and other beautiful decks and making the last few videos possible. ~ Marilyn
@Richard Boo I've forgotten so much Greek Mythology I wouldn't be very helpful, but I'll still show them of course, when I show the pips. For those like you who know GM, it may be helpful. ~ Marilyn
You were right, Marilyn. It was fascinating. The Spencer deck is pretty cool, except for the titles. That would rule it out for me. I like both Lo Scarabeo decks - of course, the Il Meneghello decks would be my first choice. But I was so happy with the Lo Scarabeo Al Soldato that I might treat myself to one or both of their Minchiate decks. I love how excited you get when discussing your theories. They make perfect sense. As always, time well spent. Thanks, again.
Yeah, the titles on the Spencer's is definitely off-putting, but if a person has limited means and really each wants a Minchiate, it isn't a bad if albeit temporary option. Thank you as always, for watching and commenting! ~ Marilyn
@@MarilynFromTarotClarity I just ordered the Al Cigno. I'm excited. I think it's very interesting that it contains those extra cards for the elements and the zodiac. I know nothing about astrology, only that I'm an aquarius. I was delivered by a midwife in Germany and have no idea what time I was born, so I don't think I can get much from astrology, but it's pretty cool, nonetheless. Thanks for the lesson. I'll watch the other Minchiate video today or tomorrow.
@frances robinson I've read that if someone doesn't know their exact time of birth, the suggestion is to use noon, being mid day. It's not exact, but it seems a reasonable option. I hope you love the Al Cigna when it arrives! ~ Marilyn
As always, learning a tid bit or two watching your videos...which is the most I seem to be able to handle at one time so it's perfect. I will make sure to reference you and your channel if I ever become proficient enough with my speaking haha. I was wondering if you know of any decks where the star card is the person with the tools, like we saw in the moon card in these decks. I am coming to a whole new appreciation ( l loved it anyway but it seems so much more than before with the context of history) of Patrick Valenza's Trionfi Della Luna. In his it is the star card that has the astronomer, and I wonder where he picked that up from...
The old Italian decks, prior to the French TdM, had simple representations of the sun, moon, and star cards, sometimes with astronomical tools like calipers. The Vieville and some decks contemporary to it also did. Thank you for watching and asking. ~ Marilyn
I'm really surprised by the Spencer's Minchiate Tarot Cards and how much I like them. However, the current box that's at Spencer's now is marked $19.95 and says that it's a 78-card deck. I'm guessing the next best price is going to be Lo Scarabeo's Minchiate Al Cigno and that's a 97-card deck.
Oh man, that's a real disappointment. The Spencer Minchiate, ironically, closely resembles the AL Cigna, except in that it titles the cards. I imagine these novelty stores are hit and miss with their tarot products. I think there's a surge every time I showcase one of their decks 🤣. I would keep an eye on their website, you never know what they'll have. I bought my very 1st tarot deck from either Spencer's or Spain's (they are similar stores), and it was the 1JJ Swiss Tarot deck, now a classic! Thank you for watching~ Marilyn
I just went to their website and they have it! The box might say 78 cards (mine does too) but that could have been an error made by someone in packaging it. If you look at the cards in the photos, you'll see it's a Minchiate deck with astrological cards, etc. If you want it, it appears to be available. ~ Marilyn
That's why I'm happy to share my decks in video. Some of them might be hard to find and this way they can at least be seen. Thank you for watching and commenting. ~ Marilyn
Please, do you have comparison between Minchiate Al Cigno and Minchiate Al Leone ? I think I will buy Al Leone, the colors are different. I know Al Cigno is limited version Lo Scarabeo
Hello! I am not sure if I have the Al Leone. If I have it, I will do a comparison for you. I have a feeling I do not have the Al Leone. Thank you for watching and asking. ~ Marilyn
Thanks so much for these wonderful videos. I always love your commentaries too.
As for the object in the Charity card:
Charity holds a flame in her hand. This represents the "fire of charity", which in Catholic theology, the will of charity wishes the salvation of souls and the fire of truth that cleanses us from sin.
Thank you for this explanation! ~ Marilyn
❤❤❤❤❤ I so appreciate your wisdom,graceful,and dignified nature. Thank you 🙏🏻 ❤
Thank you very much. What a lovely compliment. ~ Marilyn
I've learned so much from you. I'm only starting out on my TdM journey and I appreciate all your knowledge. I'd pay a few $ a month to be a channel member. I have the patron app but rarely use it. I don't have the capacity for so many apps. I'd pay a few dollars a month for a TH-cam membership to your channel. I wouldn't expect much from it. Maybe a weekly or monthly members only TdM lesson.
Wow, that's awesome. I appreciate your input. Thank you. ~ Marilyn
This is very encouraging. Thank you very much for your input. I appreciate this. ~ Marilyn
Thank you. New references jumped at me as you were sharing. We do not have all the decks to compare. But some of your musings tap onto symbolic compressed nuances worth noting.
I'm glad the video was of interest to you. Thank you for watching!
THANK YOU !!! A wonderful video ,from start to finish I loved every minute ! I'm determined this year to delve deeply into the Minchiate . As always I learnt so much from your video and really do appreciate you offering your knowledge so freely 💕.👏👏👏
Thank you Ann. I'm glad it was meaningful for you. You must be a fellow tarot geek to hang in there with me. Thank you! ~ Marilyn
Thank you for all your videos and knowledge 💜 .. loving the colors of the Spencers version and of the LoScarabeo as well. 🤩
Thank you for saying so. The Spencer's deck holds up pretty well and seems to compare with the Al Cigna deck. Of course we're not talking quality paper stock and it's got titles on the cards, but for $20 it's a great find.
I'd like to see more on how to read the Minchiate and a comparison of the older ones with a more modern one like the Brian Williams version. I first saw the Williams version on your channel and purchased it. Thanks 55:46
Thank you for this idea. I think I might have compared Brian's Minchiate to a few historic examples already. I've also done a video comparison with a very inexpensive Minchiate. I'll check my Minchiate playlist to see. If I didn't, I'll put your idea in my queue and if I did, I'll send you the link. Thank you for watching and sharing your feelings. ~ Marilyn
Another great video! Thank you.
Thank you for sharing! I really appreciate that. I'm glad you enjoyed the video. ~ Marilyn
Wonderful comparisons! I’m so surprised to how similar the Spencer Minchiate was to the Al Cigno! 🤔
You’re right with your thoughts about some of the transitions of some cards from Minchiate to TdM. So many possibilities 😉
As I always say; so many tangents. 😂
Thank you for such a wonderful presentation
Richard
I'm glad you enjoyed it Richard. I'm thinking of doing a pip comparison, unless they're all basically the same. Isn't crazy about Al Cigna and the Spencers? It seems likely the Al Cigna was the deck they copied. Thank you for gifting me with this and other beautiful decks and making the last few videos possible. ~ Marilyn
@@MarilynFromTarotClarity I think a comparison of the courts and how they all differ as Greek mythology deities on the knights. 😉
@Richard Boo I've forgotten so much Greek Mythology I wouldn't be very helpful, but I'll still show them of course, when I show the pips. For those like you who know GM, it may be helpful. ~ Marilyn
Thanks for sharing pal!!!
I will start with this deck.
❤
You're very welcome! Great choice!
Thank you so so much❤ i very love your video and knowledge you share ❤
Thank you, and I appreciate your presence. Thank you for watching and leaving a comment. ~ Marilyn
You were right, Marilyn. It was fascinating. The Spencer deck is pretty cool, except for the titles. That would rule it out for me. I like both Lo Scarabeo decks - of course, the Il Meneghello decks would be my first choice. But I was so happy with the Lo Scarabeo Al Soldato that I might treat myself to one or both of their Minchiate decks. I love how excited you get when discussing your theories. They make perfect sense. As always, time well spent. Thanks, again.
Yeah, the titles on the Spencer's is definitely off-putting, but if a person has limited means and really each wants a Minchiate, it isn't a bad if albeit temporary option. Thank you as always, for watching and commenting! ~ Marilyn
@@MarilynFromTarotClarity I just ordered the Al Cigno. I'm excited. I think it's very interesting that it contains those extra cards for the elements and the zodiac. I know nothing about astrology, only that I'm an aquarius. I was delivered by a midwife in Germany and have no idea what time I was born, so I don't think I can get much from astrology, but it's pretty cool, nonetheless. Thanks for the lesson. I'll watch the other Minchiate video today or tomorrow.
@frances robinson I've read that if someone doesn't know their exact time of birth, the suggestion is to use noon, being mid day. It's not exact, but it seems a reasonable option. I hope you love the Al Cigna when it arrives! ~ Marilyn
thank you so much for this wonderful video!
You're welcome. Thank you for watching and commenting. Please spread the word, my channel and website could use some traffic! ~ Marilyn
As always, learning a tid bit or two watching your videos...which is the most I seem to be able to handle at one time so it's perfect. I will make sure to reference you and your channel if I ever become proficient enough with my speaking haha. I was wondering if you know of any decks where the star card is the person with the tools, like we saw in the moon card in these decks. I am coming to a whole new appreciation ( l loved it anyway but it seems so much more than before with the context of history) of Patrick Valenza's Trionfi Della Luna. In his it is the star card that has the astronomer, and I wonder where he picked that up from...
The old Italian decks, prior to the French TdM, had simple representations of the sun, moon, and star cards, sometimes with astronomical tools like calipers. The Vieville and some decks contemporary to it also did. Thank you for watching and asking. ~ Marilyn
I'm the happy owner of the Minchiate Etruria by Il Meneghello and I looooove it
Isn't it wonderful!? I'm glad you have it. Thank you for being here, watching and commenting. ~ Marilyn
@@MarilynFromTarotClarity yes, it's a wonderful deck. And I thank YOU for this video (and all the others).
Have a great weekend!
@@78puertas Thank you César, 😊 You also! ~ Marilyn
❤❤❤
I'm really surprised by the Spencer's Minchiate Tarot Cards and how much I like them. However, the current box that's at Spencer's now is marked $19.95 and says that it's a 78-card deck. I'm guessing the next best price is going to be Lo Scarabeo's Minchiate Al Cigno and that's a 97-card deck.
Oh man, that's a real disappointment. The Spencer Minchiate, ironically, closely resembles the AL Cigna, except in that it titles the cards. I imagine these novelty stores are hit and miss with their tarot products. I think there's a surge every time I showcase one of their decks 🤣. I would keep an eye on their website, you never know what they'll have. I bought my very 1st tarot deck from either Spencer's or Spain's (they are similar stores), and it was the 1JJ Swiss Tarot deck, now a classic! Thank you for watching~ Marilyn
I just went to their website and they have it! The box might say 78 cards (mine does too) but that could have been an error made by someone in packaging it. If you look at the cards in the photos, you'll see it's a Minchiate deck with astrological cards, etc. If you want it, it appears to be available. ~ Marilyn
@@MarilynFromTarotClarity That's EXCELLENT to know! I'm so glad that you have these decks to show us. Thank you!
@@robertawalsh2995 You're very welcome :)
Bravo
You have a few Minchiates I would love to have in my collection.
That's why I'm happy to share my decks in video. Some of them might be hard to find and this way they can at least be seen. Thank you for watching and commenting. ~ Marilyn
How does the Al cigno cardstock compare to the minchiate Etruria from lo scarabeo?
They are the same. They are both from the Anima Antiqua series and they both feel and look the same. Thank you for watching and commenting. ~ Marilyn
Please, do you have comparison between Minchiate Al Cigno and Minchiate Al Leone ? I think I will buy Al Leone, the colors are different. I know Al Cigno is limited version Lo Scarabeo
Hello! I am not sure if I have the Al Leone. If I have it, I will do a comparison for you. I have a feeling I do not have the Al Leone. Thank you for watching and asking. ~ Marilyn