Mad props to Samuel H. He literally built all of this and the only time Toycat mentioned that he built it was when he had some criticism on the build, like at least say at the beginning who built it instead of just saying "Minecraft Won't Improve Structures & So I Did" and "it's been so long since we saw improved structures, so I took it upon myself...", sure its stated in the description, but who actually reads the description.
@MangoBerry420 yea..so with a cobblestone generator and vine farm it's infinitely renewable and basically free. i.e. not rare whatsoever. plus vines are extremely easy to find now. used to be only in jungles
I’ve been saying this for a while now. There will have to be a “outdated update”. Just like walking around my 9 year old MC world, you can find really poorly built and antiquated designs from 6 years ago. Things have changed and improved. Especially after the epic deep dark cities, the original structures are so outdated.
I would say the improvements aren't really that good. I'm not a fan of nearly anything after 1.8, but I have reasons for these. My reasoning for why the structures shouldn't be changed starts with how depth and lore should be minor. The noticeable maximum that depth and lore gets is like: cold biome freezes, iron is tougher than wood, warm biome gets dry and dead, pillagers were outcasted- so they hate villagers, gold is brittle like butter, trees burn because fire spreads, and villagers get jobs from tables, but all that is only a minimum to help explain features and stuff / not to make things more complicated than necessary. Remember this is an expanding sandbox game of randomness with little point of direction, but survival mechanics were one of the added options to give it some depth, and it isn't a survival game with options, cheats, lore, and depth added. To give the only good point some recognition, though, for newer versions, perhaps old style structures could be given updated looks like a desert well having a chest, nearby, with a empty bucket inside, or witch huts could use a ladder to get up them.
Sadly it wont happen notch needs come back he probably put in new things and make more things like woth the copper block actually putting in the copper gulm and actually listen to us
1 we cant have everything we want 2 remaking structures to look new, modern and stuff wont add up to the lore the lore god damnit 3 i am too into remaking the structures but not to look like that some people want lore and new and modern structures wont add to that
They just need to hire ibx and his editor to showcase and build the structures for them and they can implement those structures with different loot plus i mean he's been doing this since like seed sunday on xbox360 so the man knows the game.
I would love to see this on an archeologically update. The structures have a lot of lore associated and so will the archeology mechanics when they’re added
nether fortress is just a no imo. it just shifts colors wildly and randomly, doesnt feel coherent. the shape is otherwise ok, except for interchanging between full and fence blocks every other block on the bridges jungle temple looks great, maybe just replace the wooden parts with some cobblestone/stone bricks pyramid also looks great, though it feels a bit plain on the outside. love seeing the husks getting used in there, though i do not think endermites belong in there at all igloo isnt very iglooey shaped, looks weird with dark wood combined with snow. honestly a real improvement over the current one tho witch hut is great, im a bit iffy on the mushrooms but totally sold on the interior dungeon is cool, harder to conquer, i like it. i think theres more potential for decorating it as a dungeon though stronghold 1000% should not have end stone (or other blocks only found in the end) in it at all. otherwise i see no problem with deepslate strongholds they look interesting. i like your new end portal room too end city isnt too different from the existing one, im quite iffy on the hot air balloons. i feel like the main big problem with most of these is the abundance of resources you can get from finding any of them. they probably need to be way more spaced out than they are currently in vanilla minecraft. but yeah, anyway, cant wait for a datapack adding these structures to the game :]
They should definitely add more puzzles to the jungle temple. I always loved the concept of solving various puzzles to get valuable loot, but it's unfortunate they didn't implement it better. Also the dungeon idea is really cool, considering the current dungeon is more of an ugly box than an actual dungeon.
They also need to add more challenge. The game is too easy even on hard. That means when you mess up in a puzzle they shouldn't have one arrow shoot at you, but a real stream of arrows, which is pretty easy too do, redstone wise.
That nether fortress idea is cool. For jungle temples I think they should lean into puzzles more, make it so that you can’t mine certain things and you have to solve Puzzles and fight mobs like in Minecraft story mode Edit: they can really lean into red stone and how improved it is now. It would be a good showcase almost for players after they beat the temple Edit 2: and fossils should be more integrated with the archaeology update. Maybe they are planning something for that.
Jungle Temples could use a beacon style item that creates a constant debuff (That instantly reapplies if you use milk to get rid of it while still in the area) to prevent mining. Or a mob like an Elder Guardian.
@@katlicks that makes more sense yea, it would be less confusing for people because you may not know what you can and can’t mine, although, if there is treasure and such, after you beat the temple, the debuff should be removed.
Desert biome needs more stuff added for sure, I love the desert villages, but besides that exploring the desert is usually pretty boring. I also think the nether needs more stuff done to it like in the video. I think it would be cool if you could live in the nether or end realm more easily.
@@Bloxstrosity6209 nobody plays Minecraft vegan, it’s impractical and it’s a video game with NO GORE! Nobody feels bad killing an animal that isn’t a dog or something in Minecraft
For the dessert pyramid, it would be cool if when u loot the warrior from all his favourite gear a special zombie spawns and starts to attack the player as if the corpse had gotten mad that someone was taking his stuff, idk
I think the main thing here is that the structures need more variation. They should be fun and exciting every time you go into them and not just be the same thing. I think they really did good with this idea with bastions, I haven't learned how to identify different types of bastions and which ones have which loot and stuff, so every time I find one I have no idea what to expect
I think the witch hut was supposed to have a unique roof. It was never meant to have a normal roof, rather it's a rundown shack, with a roof that is covered in water, but the witch doesn't care. If you've ever seen a real flat roof, water pools on it, and makes young buildings look old. I think it fits the vibe.
This is straight proof that we NEED a structures update... like obviously we can still keep the Og ones as rare variants for nostalgia purposes, but that doesn’t mean that structures such as mob spawner “dungeons,” ocean monuments, nether fortresses, strongholds (although the deep dark cities are kind of in a weird way updated strongholds), jungle pyramids and desert pyramids don’t deserve their own fun, unique, beautiful, challenging, exciting and rewarding counterparts... That once you’ve finished raiding, you can take them over as your base or even destroy it!!
well actually have variants that it very similar to the old ones, lets say the desert temple would have afew randomly generated pressure plates than always at the middle for a small desert temple, for the jungle pyramid, i dont feels as if its so nostalgic as the others, also, you can keep the Og ones when you had generated it before an update
I'm fine with them changing every structure except for the desert temple, I have so much nostalgia connected to it that I just never want it to change.
I think that structures like jungle and desert temples as well as the stronghold should be: 1: expanded with new rooms, traps, riddles, maybe even parkour sections 2: be procedurally generated to be a bit random and unique 3: utilize similar mechanic with mining fatigue as ocean monument, until the structure is conquered, to encourage players to interact with it's mechanics instead of just digging their way to loot.
parkour in the game naturally and not only on servers sounds so cool, we need mining fatigue in most structures especially the jungle and desert temples and the loot needs to be better and the puzzels need to be harder so people cant mine in! great idea !
I guess but the endermen are seen using the stronghold portal when transporting the Orb of Dominance and the Endersent can be seen coming into the over world through the portal as well
I love they way these new structures can teach the player certain mechanics, like the jungle temple showing what effect arrows are, or how witch huts can help with explaining potions. And to add on to the fossil idea, it would be cool if sometimes they connected with the new archeology, maybe you see an archeology dig site and know to dig down and find a fossil.
The fact the Toycat said "I didn't have much time to build this" or "I thought", and never mentioning Samuel, he only mentioned him when he criticized his builds.
I love the fossil idea! I remember it was pretty exciting to hear them come to minecraft, but then underwhelming when you saw how rare and useless they'd be. I love the dog idea along with that, since dogs have very little practical purpose, too.
Great new video Toycat! Genius ideas, but I think the older structures should stay (nostalgia) and the newer versions could be a variant. Besides with the Nether Fortress, I don't think anyone would miss the old one. EDIT: I got an idea, maybe the Nether Fortress could have a biome variant for all the biomes in the Nether, but in Nether Wastes it would have the classic look.
nah, nostalgia isn’t an excuse for having straight up bad structures in the game. they updated villages, they should do the same for witch huts and the rest
i think my favorites must have been the end city or the desert well. having the desert well as a rare chance at vegetation and food is really good if you happen to spawn in a big desert, because it makes it possible to settle down without walking hundreds of blocks. the aqueducts also raise some intriguing ideas about the people who lived there the end city being more advanced makes a lot of sense. its meant to be a city, but it doesnt even look like a place where anyone would want to live. a more advanced end city would also make you filled with awe at how far the civilisation that built it had come
Thank you for doing this, these new structures look really nice and I struggle to understand why the developers are so against updating the older structures
@@randomguy9305 his editor/team did, you should read the description a bit closer before commenting on every single comment pointing out the cool builds
@@hulopinja3522 he only credited him in the description and in the video title, in the description and throughout the video itself he talked about the structures as if he made them.
The desert well one actually gives me an idea of an oasis biome, that would act as a sort of mini biome inside the desert. Introduces a new type of wood as well as some other stuff
Temples and Dungeons should be made of material as strong as obsidian and can only be mined by Diamond or netherite. Though dungeons should be directly connected to new underground structures called Catacombs. Which are just made of stone.
Personally I think having really simple structures is part of what makes Minecraft cool and unique. It would make sense for the nether fortress to have some slight variation based on biome, similar to how villages used to be, and end strongholds need to be made of deepslate when they're in that area (speaking of which, why don't we have mossy deepslate??) but I don't think the end stronghold needs to be super fancy. I do think the witch huts should have space for the witch's hat and a barrel of some potion supplies, but nothing too elaborate. edit: oh and I agree fossils should get updated in the archeology update
Everyone needs to send this to mojang. We all 100% want this. I hope 1.20 is a structure update. Honestly, I want an end update too, but id gladly wait longer for that for this first. Mojang doesn't want to do this because of nostalgia though. But it's no longer nostalgic, it's just outdated. Please, mojang, give us this.
The Ravager in the Igloo in closure is probably the coolest structure update you made. It fits with the lore and looks like a really sick build! Nice work
Igloos are normally small huts made of compacted snow. So not necessarily something that should change from the exterior although a different build which is far larger would be interesting
maybe they could have three-five structure votes with a LOT of information for every structure so no one gets that upset and they promise they will try to update the losers to sometime. The next vote will have one (or maybe two) losers in it. maybe the votes could be one per week on minecraft live month to give people time to chose. The structures could be woodland mansions, nether fortresses, end cities, strongholds, igloos, ocean mounuments, jungle and desert temples, and more! great idea, sorry my comment is so long!
@@blazekitsune no... because we’d have to wait 1000 years to get confirmation that the losers would make it into the game... All the structures NEED an overhaul, and a minecon vote shouldn’t get in the way of that..
@@officialprincelouie well I was thinking that they’d do “which structure get updated next” update the winner then update everything else. Or instead of voting for one structure at a time have three voting candidates with three structures in each.
I know what you mean but can you elaborate on not finding his content engaging. I feel the same way but not sure what it is... Cant put my finger on it
@@ukiy01 I think it's about his videos being so unedited and kind of podcast-like. He just kinda records himself doing some type of weird (and ugly but I don't want to be mean) project in his survival world, while he talks very slowly about something like an update, or a random thought, etc Idk, i don't exactly know as well
I find them all amazing! But I really feel like the jungle temple is the best, maybe it’s because I started playing only a few months before it was released, but I really love it and my only thing to say is I didn’t love the warped nether wart on the corners of the fortress but that’s so small I don’t believe it matters at all, otherwise absolutely amazing work! Only love and respect to Samuel H. And IBXToycat Edit: But seriously, Mojang gotta hire Samuel for these builds!
I'd do anything to have an oasis in the desert! I think it would be so pretty, even if there was no other functionality to it, it would make deserts much more interesting to explore.
The dungeons really really need an update. Even the nether fortress and the mineshafts need it, maybe they could add mini bosses too. I hope they update all the structures too but I'm wishing for an End Update first to be honest. I hope they do something similar to what they did with the Nether and make it more fun and interesting, more blocks and mobs, maybe new items too.
An end city overhaul would be fitting in this update although the end city already looks good compared to pre 1.9 structures so i don't think it needs any major overhaul
I agree with all of these, EXCEPT the igloo. I don’t know why, but I love the simple charm of the igloo. It’s small, but it doesn’t need to be anything big. Maybe touch ups on it would be good, but idk
@MangoBerry420 well yeah the witch hut really does need an update but not a major one that looks like it’s made by a professional builder but maybe a little tweak
These designs are incredible! Samuel really should be working for minecraft because they absolutely need to step it up. The update with the deep slate has made mining absolutely soul crushing. You are just surrounded by black for hours at a time and if you are mining for diamonds you don't come up with a bunch of other stuff to make it worth while anymore, you just come up empty handed. Some new life in the old structures would help.
I agree with all of these except for having endstone in the stronghold. Mostly because whoever entered it before you did never returned. For the interest of alliteration, I think the update should be called the Sound Structures or Structurally Sound update. Could also work if they take the horns out of 1.19 and add them back in with the structures. My suggestion anyway.
Mojang must finally update these structures!!! The ideas mentioned in the video would be very useful and suit the game and its mechanics. The witch hut design is probably the best alongside the desert temple as this would improve Minecraft, especially survival mode and help players who are not as experienced at getting much loot early in-game. 👏
Not even going to lie, These ideas you presented were really solid. I was impressed that you even updated structures like the Desert Well (Which IMO is a useless structure and really needs to be changed), but I really liked the Nether Fortress, it felt alive and with life, the current one right now feels so bland. With the Desert Temple, I like the pressure plate Idea, you have to at minimal remove the pressure plates before you even start looting, making it like that is a significant change and makes players have to mine around it. The Ocean Monument IMO is totally fine at this moment (later it might need a change), but the jungle temples need a massive Overhaul, this isn't 2014 anymore, and the igloo is a super interesting structure, adding more villigers really makes them way more useful. The Witch Hut needs a complete Overhaul too, as the only good thing you have to do is make a farm, but with that being said, it is so mundane, and no real life to it, so I was overall very happy with those structures as they are the most mundane of the structures. The Dungeons are also very old (even though people like to farm them), they are too boxy, I have played MC for a while, and I have to say these structures are maybe one of the most useful things for XP (which is why Mojang prob won't update them as they are farmable), but the End Cities are really interesting, I think the end itself is the problem not the cities themselves, but those are my opinions from the video.
I really like this idea, I feel like the wells lose their purpose when there’s rivers every 500 blocks. They’d feel much more valuable if that was the only water in the entire biome
The witch hut could definitely use a facelift, especially since it's in a biome that's the main target of revamping in the upcoming update. I also do agree dungeons can use a facelift, though a labyrinth like that may not work since spawners do take up a lot of power. Put enough in a small area and there will be lag (if you were to recreate a custom world with high dungeon count where it's possible to get dungeon complexes, it will lag).
about the dungeon I think there'd have to be a key at the end of it so you'd have to fight through the dungeon in order to break the blocks also 11:11 that's paleontology, archeology is the study of humans (not exactly but its just not Dinos)
ive really looked into the idea of a structure update since toycat mentioned it and ive started reimagining how revamped structures and new structures would look like, i dont think every structure should be special and be big or have good loot but for example witch's hut having blaze powder would be a great feature as an alternate way to speedrun etc. even if theres a tiny chance it has enough to give for a portal
@@axoltheartist what do u mean by the point I dont think the point of the witch hut was for people to go there it’s a witches hut right? And the igloo your just suppose to randomly come across it on your world not actually try to find it unless you want the villagers in some igloo’s but other than that you wouldn’t really need to find an igloo it’s just for aesthetic purposes and for the lore
EVERYONE READING THIS: IN THE DESC, SAMUEL H. WAS THE ONE WHO EDITED THE VID AND MADE THE BUILDS IN THE VID IDK WHY IT WASNT MENTIONED IN THE BEGINNING OF THE VIDEO BUT IT SHOULDVE BEEN ty have a nice day ^^
It wasn't mentioned because this yter is pretty selfish. You can see it in the title as well, "So I did". Complete lack of credit and really disrespectful
I really like your End City and Ocean Monument redesigns, they make me absolutely happy and I think both are a great reason to use copper in some vanilla structures. It fits so well in the oxidized and fresh states, accordingly. And I totally feel like the End needs more greens and teals to match the Ender Peals and Eyes of Ender, instead of just a two color block palette.
While some of these are a bit over the top imo, i definitely think most structures should be improved in the fundamental aspect of excitement/funness. Minecraft is a game, and it should be sustainably enjoyable to keep playing. The monotony makes it way too boring if you don't bring your own creativity into the game
I thuroughly agree with most of these changes! I'd add to this that many structures should be even more rare and that some of them should have more variations within them, like the jungle and desert temples. They shouldn't all look and play exactly the same.
Hot take: most if not all structures should give the player Mining Fatigue III until they have been conquered. Traps are pretty useless because you can just dig them out, same goes for puzzles.
Wow, great video! Only if this were in Minecraft lol! There is so much to change or improve in Minecraft! Like the structures to be upgraded, for pets to do more like dogs or cats, new trees, new structures, new mobs, and many things from better Minecraft ( they have many changes from real Minecraft, dragons, and so much more!
I think the nether fortress is good because it reminds you of old structures, just like we still have old castles and stuff in real life. If it were to be changed it should spawn in either as the old version or new version. Why not have both for the nostalgia and the newness?
I love the idea But i must admit some of the designs like the igloo are WAY too complicated so maybe if we can find more simplified designs like the witch hut we will have a chance
I'm gonna have to disagree with you on this one. Part of the charm of these small structures is their simplicity. Plus we still need game balance, and forgetting the pickaxe could be a dire thing. Don't get me wrong, I care tons about Minecraft lore, but you have to keep the game balance. That being said, you had some cool ideas, like the bell in the nether fortress, or the entrance to the basement of the igloo.
Simplicity only goes so far, and by now the game has evolved out of its simplicity, to the point many structures feel uncanny and out of place, or just plain dull. Things get a lot better, and the simplicity isn't one of them, but that's my opinion
I like the idea of having witches huts be a good place to find potion ingredients. I even think it could be a neat idea to possibly find a blaze rod there if you're lucky.
your witch hut design odly inspired me, what if a new witch rework made them into a neutral villager mob, but their hobby is just witchcraft. like piglins, they attack you unless you got something of intrest too them, perhaps even trading opportunities. example; say you hold in your offhand an item from the end, end crystal, chorous, dragon egg, the witch becomes 'intrigued' and invites you into her home too trade for late game content not so much as items but information, like end game magic or new structure maps for other dimensions, some crazy concept that would fit a witch
The fossil on the surface of the desert reminded me of the krayt dragon skeletons on Tatooine! I think Mojang should hire this man for structure building he has such good ideas!
Mad props to Samuel H. He literally built all of this and the only time Toycat mentioned that he built it was when he had some criticism on the build, like at least say at the beginning who built it instead of just saying "Minecraft Won't Improve Structures & So I Did" and "it's been so long since we saw improved structures, so I took it upon myself...", sure its stated in the description, but who actually reads the description.
yeah i was just thinking about that
Thanks for confirming that lol, got 2 structures in and went "wait these are too good to be toycats designs"
i hate when youtubers do that its so easy to say IN the video "big thanks to ____" and change the title "so WE did"
@@sofiegoldie4861 ikr
That's why I went looking for who built it, but you shouldn't have to go look for the builder...
i support this comment. It's basic honesty
Man, remember when collecting a few pieces of mossy cobblestone was soo rare and special?! how times change
@MangoBerry420 you can just combine vines and cobblestone which is everywhere lol
@MangoBerry420 yea..so with a cobblestone generator and vine farm it's infinitely renewable and basically free. i.e. not rare whatsoever. plus vines are extremely easy to find now. used to be only in jungles
I still instinctively collect mossy cobble in dungeons 😂😂
@@DarkMetaOFFICIAL vines used to be in swamps always too
Bruh mossy cobblestone is very hard
I’ve been saying this for a while now. There will have to be a “outdated update”. Just like walking around my 9 year old MC world, you can find really poorly built and antiquated designs from 6 years ago. Things have changed and improved. Especially after the epic deep dark cities, the original structures are so outdated.
I would say the improvements aren't really that good. I'm not a fan of nearly anything after 1.8, but I have reasons for these. My reasoning for why the structures shouldn't be changed starts with how depth and lore should be minor. The noticeable maximum that depth and lore gets is like: cold biome freezes, iron is tougher than wood, warm biome gets dry and dead, pillagers were outcasted- so they hate villagers, gold is brittle like butter, trees burn because fire spreads, and villagers get jobs from tables, but all that is only a minimum to help explain features and stuff / not to make things more complicated than necessary. Remember this is an expanding sandbox game of randomness with little point of direction, but survival mechanics were one of the added options to give it some depth, and it isn't a survival game with options, cheats, lore, and depth added. To give the only good point some recognition, though, for newer versions, perhaps old style structures could be given updated looks like a desert well having a chest, nearby, with a empty bucket inside, or witch huts could use a ladder to get up them.
yes
@@thereallyrealplayer it was originally also a survival game, we dont care, mist structures are boring
In this outdated update they could also give the old mobs new animations
That could be called the nostalgia update
Great ideas, i feel like mojang needs a team just to revamp old structures and mobs becuase they seem to never get around to it
Yep
Sadly it wont happen notch needs come back he probably put in new things and make more things like woth the copper block actually putting in the copper gulm and actually listen to us
1 we cant have everything we want
2 remaking structures to look new, modern and stuff wont add up to the lore
the lore god damnit
3 i am too into remaking the structures but not to look like that some people want lore and new and modern structures wont add to that
we need an end update not this a the moment
They still haven't added parity with the witch huts. Bedrock has potions in its witch huts. Java does not.
All of these ideas are just wonderful for the benefit of the game. Mojang needs to remaster the structures in 1.19 or 1.20.
Ikr? Mojang really needs to hire him.
I agree. 1.20 could be a structure update focusing on revamping some structures to be brand new.
Never, I love the jank of mc structures. And it makes your builds look better in comparison
@@walls_of_skulls6061 it's disgusting to look at though
They just need to hire ibx and his editor to showcase and build the structures for them and they can implement those structures with different loot plus i mean he's been doing this since like seed sunday on xbox360 so the man knows the game.
The dungeon design might be my favorite, it’s so clever yet simple and I’d be so exited to find it in game!
I would love to see this on an archeologically update. The structures have a lot of lore associated and so will the archeology mechanics when they’re added
nether fortress is just a no imo. it just shifts colors wildly and randomly, doesnt feel coherent. the shape is otherwise ok, except for interchanging between full and fence blocks every other block on the bridges
jungle temple looks great, maybe just replace the wooden parts with some cobblestone/stone bricks
pyramid also looks great, though it feels a bit plain on the outside. love seeing the husks getting used in there, though i do not think endermites belong in there at all
igloo isnt very iglooey shaped, looks weird with dark wood combined with snow. honestly a real improvement over the current one tho
witch hut is great, im a bit iffy on the mushrooms but totally sold on the interior
dungeon is cool, harder to conquer, i like it. i think theres more potential for decorating it as a dungeon though
stronghold 1000% should not have end stone (or other blocks only found in the end) in it at all. otherwise i see no problem with deepslate strongholds they look interesting. i like your new end portal room too
end city isnt too different from the existing one, im quite iffy on the hot air balloons.
i feel like the main big problem with most of these is the abundance of resources you can get from finding any of them. they probably need to be way more spaced out than they are currently in vanilla minecraft.
but yeah, anyway, cant wait for a datapack adding these structures to the game :]
I agree with this completely!
I think the endermites are supposed to represent scarabs
They should definitely add more puzzles to the jungle temple. I always loved the concept of solving various puzzles to get valuable loot, but it's unfortunate they didn't implement it better. Also the dungeon idea is really cool, considering the current dungeon is more of an ugly box than an actual dungeon.
They also need to add more challenge. The game is too easy even on hard. That means when you mess up in a puzzle they shouldn't have one arrow shoot at you, but a real stream of arrows, which is pretty easy too do, redstone wise.
@@iexist.imnotjoking5700 step on a pressure plate = you get every bad potion effect and the world blows up
@@iexist.imnotjoking5700 yeah, also complex redstone!, to teach the player you can do complex things with redstone!
That nether fortress idea is cool.
For jungle temples I think they should lean into puzzles more, make it so that you can’t mine certain things and you have to solve Puzzles and fight mobs like in Minecraft story mode
Edit: they can really lean into red stone and how improved it is now. It would be a good showcase almost for players after they beat the temple
Edit 2: and fossils should be more integrated with the archaeology update. Maybe they are planning something for that.
Jungle Temples could use a beacon style item that creates a constant debuff (That instantly reapplies if you use milk to get rid of it while still in the area) to prevent mining. Or a mob like an Elder Guardian.
@@katlicks that makes more sense yea, it would be less confusing for people because you may not know what you can and can’t mine, although, if there is treasure and such, after you beat the temple, the debuff should be removed.
heh...fossils and archaeology, reminds of a certain mod
Yes and maybe add a little maze
They need to play a tomb raider game for inspiration.
Desert biome needs more stuff added for sure, I love the desert villages, but besides that exploring the desert is usually pretty boring.
I also think the nether needs more stuff done to it like in the video. I think it would be cool if you could live in the nether or end realm more easily.
You can live in the nether
@@BenjjyBoi I know you can, but you can't grow anything
@@jasonknowing i mean, you can eat meat from hoglins but if you're vegan.. uhmm...
@@Bloxstrosity6209 nobody plays Minecraft vegan, it’s impractical and it’s a video game with NO GORE! Nobody feels bad killing an animal that isn’t a dog or something in Minecraft
@@Bloxstrosity6209 for vegans there's the option of collecting mushrooms and finding golden carrots in bastions but for the most part you are right
For the dessert pyramid, it would be cool if when u loot the warrior from all his favourite gear a special zombie spawns and starts to attack the player as if the corpse had gotten mad that someone was taking his stuff, idk
It would be cool if they added apple pie for dessert
I think the main thing here is that the structures need more variation. They should be fun and exciting every time you go into them and not just be the same thing. I think they really did good with this idea with bastions, I haven't learned how to identify different types of bastions and which ones have which loot and stuff, so every time I find one I have no idea what to expect
I think the witch hut was supposed to have a unique roof. It was never meant to have a normal roof, rather it's a rundown shack, with a roof that is covered in water, but the witch doesn't care. If you've ever seen a real flat roof, water pools on it, and makes young buildings look old. I think it fits the vibe.
This is straight proof that we NEED a structures update... like obviously we can still keep the Og ones as rare variants for nostalgia purposes, but that doesn’t mean that structures such as mob spawner “dungeons,” ocean monuments, nether fortresses, strongholds (although the deep dark cities are kind of in a weird way updated strongholds), jungle pyramids and desert pyramids don’t deserve their own fun, unique, beautiful, challenging, exciting and rewarding counterparts... That once you’ve finished raiding, you can take them over as your base or even destroy it!!
Id argue the old ones should be like the zombie village but with nostalgic value, you arent gaining anything by finding them over the new varients
@@alexanderthegreat3444 You’re spot on, that’s exactly how they should be.
well actually have variants that it very similar to the old ones, lets say the desert temple would have afew randomly generated pressure plates than always at the middle for a small desert temple, for the jungle pyramid, i dont feels as if its so nostalgic as the others, also, you can keep the Og ones when you had generated it before an update
I'm fine with them changing every structure except for the desert temple, I have so much nostalgia connected to it that I just never want it to change.
@@alexanderthegreat3444 Perfect idea
Samuel H needs to turn these into a datapack...
I think that structures like jungle and desert temples as well as the stronghold should be:
1: expanded with new rooms, traps, riddles, maybe even parkour sections
2: be procedurally generated to be a bit random and unique
3: utilize similar mechanic with mining fatigue as ocean monument, until the structure is conquered, to encourage players to interact with it's mechanics instead of just digging their way to loot.
parkour in the game naturally and not only on servers sounds so cool, we need mining fatigue in most structures especially the jungle and desert temples and the loot needs to be better and the puzzels need to be harder so people cant mine in! great idea !
@@fieldsfamily6447 not in desert but 100% jungle
The stronghold idea conflicts with the lore; end blocks shouldn't be used since the builders never left the end
I guess but the endermen are seen using the stronghold portal when transporting the Orb of Dominance and the Endersent can be seen coming into the over world through the portal as well
I love they way these new structures can teach the player certain mechanics, like the jungle temple showing what effect arrows are, or how witch huts can help with explaining potions. And to add on to the fossil idea, it would be cool if sometimes they connected with the new archeology, maybe you see an archeology dig site and know to dig down and find a fossil.
It's weird that they don't have potions in witch huts in Java
The fact the Toycat said "I didn't have much time to build this" or "I thought", and never mentioning Samuel, he only mentioned him when he criticized his builds.
Fax, this yter sucks
0:57 The Nether Fortress isn't supposed to be "alive" it's an ancient relic like the bastion.
More variants would be cool :)
These structures are genuinely good. You should release this as a mod and or addon
I agree.
ye
Hopefully not on the marketplace. This way, you can actually use the addon in your own worlds.
He didn't make them, check the description
@@randomguy9305 someone who works with him did though
I love the fossil idea! I remember it was pretty exciting to hear them come to minecraft, but then underwhelming when you saw how rare and useless they'd be. I love the dog idea along with that, since dogs have very little practical purpose, too.
Great new video Toycat! Genius ideas, but I think the older structures should stay (nostalgia) and the newer versions could be a variant. Besides with the Nether Fortress, I don't think anyone would miss the old one.
EDIT: I got an idea, maybe the Nether Fortress could have a biome variant for all the biomes in the Nether, but in Nether Wastes it would have the classic look.
nah, nostalgia isn’t an excuse for having straight up bad structures in the game. they updated villages, they should do the same for witch huts and the rest
@@papramayro46 It would still be cool to have the old structures in there somewhere, deleting them completely would be like removing history.
@@SirLiamTheGreat they did it for the villages.
@@papramayro46 I know, I'm still just saying
I wouldn’t miss any old structures, they’re all ugly and we need structures made to be actually somewhat good-looking
Copper is a genius idea for the ocean monument, because prismarine is also aging, even if the item doesn't say that.
My favorite redesigns in the video were definitely the Igloo and the Witch Hut.
i think my favorites must have been the end city or the desert well.
having the desert well as a rare chance at vegetation and food is really good if you happen to spawn in a big desert, because it makes it possible to settle down without walking hundreds of blocks.
the aqueducts also raise some intriguing ideas about the people who lived there
the end city being more advanced makes a lot of sense.
its meant to be a city, but it doesnt even look like a place where anyone would want to live.
a more advanced end city would also make you filled with awe at how far the civilisation that built it had come
The igloo was my least favorite as it completely misses the point
Thank you for doing this, these new structures look really nice and I struggle to understand why the developers are so against updating the older structures
He didn't make the structures, check the description
@@randomguy9305 his editor/team did, you should read the description a bit closer before commenting on every single comment pointing out the cool builds
@@hulopinja3522 he's not his editor, though, is he? it's still relevant to point out he didn't build these
@@hulopinja3522 he only credited him in the description and in the video title, in the description and throughout the video itself he talked about the structures as if he made them.
They aren't against it, they updated villages remember? They are just focusing on other things rn.
I just love how the ocean monument represents a guardian lazering a squid since that is what they do
i really hope for a 1.20 structure update, it's amazing how far minecraft has come but adding structures just doesn't cut it
The desert well one actually gives me an idea of an oasis biome, that would act as a sort of mini biome inside the desert. Introduces a new type of wood as well as some other stuff
Thank god someone has finally made a video on this topic. This has been bugging me since Mojang updated villages.
I love all of these ideas, but that new Witch Hut is really fantastic. I kinda want to use it as a base.
He complained about there not being a bed in there and then didn't put a bed in there himself LOL
Witch Huts need work. They aren't even the same across versions. Bedrock Witch huts give you a potion. Java ones do not.
Question for ibxtoycat
Have you seen the nerf Minecraft toys and what do you think of them
Temples and Dungeons should be made of material as strong as obsidian and can only be mined by Diamond or netherite. Though dungeons should be directly connected to new underground structures called Catacombs. Which are just made of stone.
Make this ocelot a dev already
All these designs seem like amazing survival projects if you're ever bored
Personally I think having really simple structures is part of what makes Minecraft cool and unique. It would make sense for the nether fortress to have some slight variation based on biome, similar to how villages used to be, and end strongholds need to be made of deepslate when they're in that area (speaking of which, why don't we have mossy deepslate??) but I don't think the end stronghold needs to be super fancy. I do think the witch huts should have space for the witch's hat and a barrel of some potion supplies, but nothing too elaborate.
edit: oh and I agree fossils should get updated in the archeology update
1. Hire this guy too
2. Bro has to take a breath
Everyone needs to send this to mojang. We all 100% want this. I hope 1.20 is a structure update. Honestly, I want an end update too, but id gladly wait longer for that for this first.
Mojang doesn't want to do this because of nostalgia though. But it's no longer nostalgic, it's just outdated. Please, mojang, give us this.
The Ravager in the Igloo in closure is probably the coolest structure update you made. It fits with the lore and looks like a really sick build! Nice work
Samuel made it not him, and he didn't even credit him that much
@@ChompyMaster well then Samuel made a cool structure
@@1luke_ oh true
I really enjoyed the concept of the updated structures. Making old structures more interesting is something I hope happens to Minecraft.
Igloos are normally small huts made of compacted snow. So not necessarily something that should change from the exterior although a different build which is far larger would be interesting
They should do a structure vote in the next Minecon event. I thinking between ocean monuments, woodland mansions, nether fortresses, and end cities
Oh that’s a really good idea!!
maybe they could have three-five structure votes with a LOT of information for every structure so no one gets that upset and they promise they will try to update the losers to sometime. The next vote will have one (or maybe two) losers in it. maybe the votes could be one per week on minecraft live month to give people time to chose. The structures could be woodland mansions, nether fortresses, end cities, strongholds, igloos, ocean mounuments, jungle and desert temples, and more! great idea, sorry my comment is so long!
Agree, until you realize that all of them just have changes
@@blazekitsune no... because we’d have to wait 1000 years to get confirmation that the losers would make it into the game... All the structures NEED an overhaul, and a minecon vote shouldn’t get in the way of that..
@@officialprincelouie well I was thinking that they’d do “which structure get updated next” update the winner then update everything else.
Or instead of voting for one structure at a time have three voting candidates with three structures in each.
omg these look so good. They really need to add these, it would make adventure and just the game better.
I don't usually find your content engaging but this structure remakes are very cool! keep up the good work
I know what you mean but can you elaborate on not finding his content engaging. I feel the same way but not sure what it is... Cant put my finger on it
@@ukiy01 I think it's about his videos being so unedited and kind of
podcast-like. He just kinda records himself doing some type of weird (and ugly but I don't want to be mean) project in his survival world, while he talks very slowly about something like an update, or a random thought, etc
Idk, i don't exactly know as well
@@marcelinepink i get it.. its very unfiltered
I find them all amazing! But I really feel like the jungle temple is the best, maybe it’s because I started playing only a few months before it was released, but I really love it and my only thing to say is I didn’t love the warped nether wart on the corners of the fortress but that’s so small I don’t believe it matters at all, otherwise absolutely amazing work! Only love and respect to Samuel H. And IBXToycat
Edit: But seriously, Mojang gotta hire Samuel for these builds!
I'd do anything to have an oasis in the desert! I think it would be so pretty, even if there was no other functionality to it, it would make deserts much more interesting to explore.
I love these ideas, it makes the traveling worth it and the looting is great as well.
The dungeons really really need an update.
Even the nether fortress and the mineshafts need it, maybe they could add mini bosses too.
I hope they update all the structures too but I'm wishing for an End Update first to be honest. I hope they do something similar to what they did with the Nether and make it more fun and interesting, more blocks and mobs, maybe new items too.
An end city overhaul would be fitting in this update although the end city already looks good compared to pre 1.9 structures so i don't think it needs any major overhaul
Are we just gonna ignore the brown panda at 3:47
I agree with all of these, EXCEPT the igloo. I don’t know why, but I love the simple charm of the igloo. It’s small, but it doesn’t need to be anything big. Maybe touch ups on it would be good, but idk
@MangoBerry420 well all of them to me was quite over the top I think the structures are fine, simple but that doesn’t mean they’re bad
@MangoBerry420 well yeah the witch hut really does need an update but not a major one that looks like it’s made by a professional builder but maybe a little tweak
@MangoBerry420 yeah
These designs are incredible! Samuel really should be working for minecraft because they absolutely need to step it up. The update with the deep slate has made mining absolutely soul crushing. You are just surrounded by black for hours at a time and if you are mining for diamonds you don't come up with a bunch of other stuff to make it worth while anymore, you just come up empty handed. Some new life in the old structures would help.
Great video! Keep up the great work! :)
OK ok now that snow house is AMAZING!
I agree with all of these except for having endstone in the stronghold. Mostly because whoever entered it before you did never returned. For the interest of alliteration, I think the update should be called the Sound Structures or Structurally Sound update. Could also work if they take the horns out of 1.19 and add them back in with the structures. My suggestion anyway.
Mojang must finally update these structures!!! The ideas mentioned in the video would be very useful and suit the game and its mechanics. The witch hut design is probably the best alongside the desert temple as this would improve Minecraft, especially survival mode and help players who are not as experienced at getting much loot early in-game. 👏
Not even going to lie, These ideas you presented were really solid. I was impressed that you even updated structures like the Desert Well (Which IMO is a useless structure and really needs to be changed), but I really liked the Nether Fortress, it felt alive and with life, the current one right now feels so bland. With the Desert Temple, I like the pressure plate Idea, you have to at minimal remove the pressure plates before you even start looting, making it like that is a significant change and makes players have to mine around it. The Ocean Monument IMO is totally fine at this moment (later it might need a change), but the jungle temples need a massive Overhaul, this isn't 2014 anymore, and the igloo is a super interesting structure, adding more villigers really makes them way more useful. The Witch Hut needs a complete Overhaul too, as the only good thing you have to do is make a farm, but with that being said, it is so mundane, and no real life to it, so I was overall very happy with those structures as they are the most mundane of the structures. The Dungeons are also very old (even though people like to farm them), they are too boxy, I have played MC for a while, and I have to say these structures are maybe one of the most useful things for XP (which is why Mojang prob won't update them as they are farmable), but the End Cities are really interesting, I think the end itself is the problem not the cities themselves, but those are my opinions from the video.
Best editor in toycat history
the dungeons, fossils and desert well ideas are amazing!
Love love love all of these!! Now I'm sad the structures don't look this good.
related to the desert well problem, I'd really like to see deserts have some enormous, vast variants, with no water sources - but the occasional well.
What if they were the same as before but you can travel below the water and theres some cooler bigger space
I really like this idea, I feel like the wells lose their purpose when there’s rivers every 500 blocks. They’d feel much more valuable if that was the only water in the entire biome
@@_kaleido yeah, to me it kind of defeats the whole point of a desert
The witch hut would also become a fortress replacement for speed runners for blaze powder
I've been thinking that they need to update mob A.I. and structures together, it would seem to batch really well together.
The witch hut could definitely use a facelift, especially since it's in a biome that's the main target of revamping in the upcoming update. I also do agree dungeons can use a facelift, though a labyrinth like that may not work since spawners do take up a lot of power. Put enough in a small area and there will be lag (if you were to recreate a custom world with high dungeon count where it's possible to get dungeon complexes, it will lag).
Woah there. This is too creative for Mojang. You might scare them off.
“The new jungle temple will have memorie traps that will really test the player🤡”
Me just breaking the blocks-🗿
about the dungeon I think there'd have to be a key at the end of it so you'd have to fight through the dungeon in order to break the blocks also 11:11 that's paleontology, archeology is the study of humans (not exactly but its just not Dinos)
yeah, you would need to search all chests to find a key to open the locked hest in the middle
ive really looked into the idea of a structure update since toycat mentioned it and ive started reimagining how revamped structures and new structures would look like, i dont think every structure should be special and be big or have good loot but for example witch's hut having blaze powder would be a great feature as an alternate way to speedrun etc. even if theres a tiny chance it has enough to give for a portal
I think the ocean monuement already does look good the only thing lacking are chest with loots in it
Strongold was made for just surviving, no aesthetic?
Dangerous place? The place was made for safety from the wither
yeah and why would it have endstone if the builders got trapped in the end
Perhaps it was artificialy created
Honestly I think the igloo is perfect
So many of these use bad block combinations that don’t make sense or are far too detailed and stand out too much…
I think some structures should stay simple to show that some builds don't need to be big
true
But there is the argument that the point would be lost, because no one wants to actually go there.
@@axoltheartist what do u mean by the point I dont think the point of the witch hut was for people to go there it’s a witches hut right? And the igloo your just suppose to randomly come across it on your world not actually try to find it unless you want the villagers in some igloo’s but other than that you wouldn’t really need to find an igloo it’s just for aesthetic purposes and for the lore
@@kwz9930 but that’s all opinion, and I hope you understand. Have a great day/night!
@@axoltheartist yeah I guess
EVERYONE READING THIS: IN THE DESC, SAMUEL H. WAS THE ONE WHO EDITED THE VID AND MADE THE BUILDS IN THE VID
IDK WHY IT WASNT MENTIONED IN THE BEGINNING OF THE VIDEO BUT
IT SHOULDVE BEEN
ty have a nice day ^^
theres a pinned comment about this
It wasn't mentioned because this yter is pretty selfish. You can see it in the title as well, "So I did". Complete lack of credit and really disrespectful
@@ChompyMaster true :< rlly hoping that changes
@@ChompyMaster theres literly a pinnded comment :/
nvm they removed the pinned comment
Love the content! Keep up the great work!
I really like your End City and Ocean Monument redesigns, they make me absolutely happy and I think both are a great reason to use copper in some vanilla structures. It fits so well in the oxidized and fresh states, accordingly. And I totally feel like the End needs more greens and teals to match the Ender Peals and Eyes of Ender, instead of just a two color block palette.
While some of these are a bit over the top imo, i definitely think most structures should be improved in the fundamental aspect of excitement/funness. Minecraft is a game, and it should be sustainably enjoyable to keep playing. The monotony makes it way too boring if you don't bring your own creativity into the game
You should make either a world download or datapack of these amazing creations. Imagine the fun let's plays reviewing the awesome stuff!
I thuroughly agree with most of these changes! I'd add to this that many structures should be even more rare and that some of them should have more variations within them, like the jungle and desert temples. They shouldn't all look and play exactly the same.
YES!! Forever ago they did an update on the village (which could use another tbh)- I’m stunned at how they refuse to do this
Hot take: most if not all structures should give the player Mining Fatigue III until they have been conquered. Traps are pretty useless because you can just dig them out, same goes for puzzles.
Ooh that is actually very true. But also great idea on how to counteract this problem.
Wow, great video! Only if this were in Minecraft lol! There is so much to change or improve in Minecraft! Like the structures to be upgraded, for pets to do more like dogs or cats, new trees, new structures, new mobs, and many things from better Minecraft ( they have many changes from real Minecraft, dragons, and so much more!
I think the nether fortress is good because it reminds you of old structures, just like we still have old castles and stuff in real life. If it were to be changed it should spawn in either as the old version or new version. Why not have both for the nostalgia and the newness?
maybe make the old one rarer, like 1 in 5
I love this new genre that ur doing.
I'd love Ibxtoycat to work for minecraft 😍
He didnt build these
They should make you get a bad omen when opening the desert pyramid chests
I love the idea
But i must admit some of the designs like the igloo are WAY too complicated so maybe if we can find more simplified designs like the witch hut we will have a chance
Structure update should def be the next major one
I'm gonna have to disagree with you on this one. Part of the charm of these small structures is their simplicity. Plus we still need game balance, and forgetting the pickaxe could be a dire thing. Don't get me wrong, I care tons about Minecraft lore, but you have to keep the game balance. That being said, you had some cool ideas, like the bell in the nether fortress, or the entrance to the basement of the igloo.
Simplicity only goes so far, and by now the game has evolved out of its simplicity, to the point many structures feel uncanny and out of place, or just plain dull. Things get a lot better, and the simplicity isn't one of them, but that's my opinion
I like the idea of having witches huts be a good place to find potion ingredients. I even think it could be a neat idea to possibly find a blaze rod there if you're lucky.
your witch hut design odly inspired me, what if a new witch rework made them into a neutral villager mob, but their hobby is just witchcraft.
like piglins, they attack you unless you got something of intrest too them, perhaps even trading opportunities.
example; say you hold in your offhand an item from the end, end crystal, chorous, dragon egg, the witch becomes 'intrigued' and invites you into her home too trade for late game content
not so much as items but information, like end game magic or new structure maps for other dimensions, some crazy concept that would fit a witch
I SAW A FRICKIN BROWN PANDA IN JUNGLE TEMPLE 2:36
These structure updates are awesome but I feel that they would have to adjust the spawn rate of them
Great job. I love the archeology idea it's perfect you go to the desert for sand so why not have a sweet place to unearth. Keep up the good work.
Whats great about these is that they're _mostly_ vanilla style
This is awesome, One suggestion: Make all the designs you used look more abandoned like the current ones
Maybe so things dont get to OP, you could make the new structures less common.
I think some of the structures should stay simple like the igloo, like not everything in Minecraft needs to look like an architect made it
Omg he mentioned Zelda!!!
The fossil on the surface of the desert reminded me of the krayt dragon skeletons on Tatooine! I think Mojang should hire this man for structure building he has such good ideas!