It's amazing that through all the ugliness and horror of war these two endure that a trace of innocent love is found struggling to live within their hearts. Love is one of the hidden tragedies of war we never expect to see. Heartbreaking.
Most soldiers are sad, lovelorn, homesick, tired, cold, hungry (sometimes) scared all the time, death and suffering all around, bullets and mortar. War is evil men's game.
Ta píseň vystihuje podstatu tohoto krásného filmu. To mlčení mezi nimi řeklo víc než by řekla spousta slov. Moc krásný film a tento klip je prostě úžasný!
Наталья Хаваева Да . Как вы правильно написали... фильм трогательный и долго , долго не отпускает … Признаться давно не смотрела такие фильмы 👍❤️💝❤️💝❤️
Этот фильм достоин Оскара и всех наград! Как же нам сейчас не хватает таких фильмов. Боевики достали. И про любовь если и снимают так обязательно там грязь. Кто то кому то изменяет. Любил потом разлюбил. Или она влюбилась в начальника. Не умеешь любить то не губи жизнь другому... А в этом фильме как всё красиво и трогательно! Проклятая война! Зачем люди воюют и убивают друг друга когда и так жизнь каждого из нас короткая.... 😢
Куда делись талантливые наши режиссёры? Снимают одну муть голубую сейчас... Фильм " Пёс" уже достал. Всё бы ещё ничего если бы не было Звоздилова. Это недалёкого ума персонаж. Но служит в полиции. Потому что племянник генерала. Зачем позорить так полицию Украины? Не понимаю....😮😮😮😮😮😮
Актер который сыграл офицера наверное сейчас пользуется таким же успехом как наш замечательный Вячеслав Тихонов сыгравший Штирлеца! Обоим очень очень идёт военная форма... Побольше бы таких фильмов. Но без смертей и крови. Как в этих фильмах.
The book was written in 1941. The author didn't know the east Russia front was so terrible. It just said that Werner asked to go to battlefields, didn't say that he would go to the east front. The movie changed it and made that it's almost impossible that Werner could survive.
Good point. I never read the book. It must have been a Director or Producer that was jealous of true loves, and just had to put an end like that. Disgusting. It was also IMPOSSIBLE that the girl, after all she had heard from him, like the plea as to what should he do, and all the interest & attraction she had for this good man, that she would not say her feelings immediately then, if not before then? Nah, I think she would have hunted him down when she saw the murder plotted. Any decent person would have done that UNLESS she was afraid the French underground would have gone after her. I don't know. It seems there was a way she could have saved their lives.
@@bookwormdoe1522 Hi, she can't express her feelings because he was the enemy , the capitain had said once :" I really respect the people who love their country " , and in the scene next to the fire in the room ,he said : " you are very lucky because you have a house next to the sea , I like the sea , and I'm lucky because i've met an Oldman and a silent lady , then he said ,,, what I love about sea it's his silence , he meant that he love the girl because she's silent , he used a metaphore here , I don't know if you can understand what i'm trying to explain , my English is really bad . i love that movie the final maked me cry everytime ..... such a rare love
@@bookwormdoe1522 Lol I don't think the producer or director purposely put a tragic ending to destroy their romance. In fact, this movie has a theme that is beyond romance -- Anti-War and Peace. If it wasn't because of war, this duo would have continued their romance with no boundaries or obstacles. The ending is portrayed like this to remind all of us that ---- war should never happen.
@@parasharshikha7 Really? I never heart about this ending ! I'm glad they could meet again and ne happy together (I'm French, so I feel concerned) 🇫🇷❤🇩🇪
my parents lost their peaceful lives because of him and his kind, the German Nazis and I am sorry to say beings like him still exist and still torture and kill people only now they are doing it under the name and guise of 'democracy'...how about we let humanity dictate our actions for once , human rights... animal rights, the preservation of our environment , our planet... and forget everything else which is not really that important to begin with anyway...
La guerra permitio que los protagonistas se conocieran, se amaran y se separaran. .En la realidad la guerra unio a muchas francesas con el invasor alemán cuyo final fue la muerte para muchas, por deslealtad en mano de sus propios compatriotas. Ella es muy valiente, patriota y madura. El como todo oficial alemán era fiel al juramento a Hitler y a su politica. Fue concientemente educado y respetuoso con quienes forzosamente lo hospedaron. Recordar que para el año 1941 Hotler ya exterminaba a miles de judios en Europa a manos de sus oficiales ya que se veian como seres humanos superiores sobre los demás. Admiro el ejemplo de caracter y voluntad de lWener y la joven. También se valora la capacidad de amar, enamorarse respetando sus identidades. No forzar a la protagonista a ninguna situación embarazosa embellece y enaltece el amor del capitan alemán. La musica expreso y comunico con delicadeza y fuerza la atraccion que ambos sentian y libero sus sentimientos. El hecho que el partiera les dio la libertad para hacer lo que ambos querian defender sus ideales sin lastimarse. Ambos lo sabian _ se amaban, se amaron_ pero estaban en guerra.
@mariatoledo5222 I don't think Werner agrees with his government after he saw through their propaganda. Even though he decides to carry out his obligations, the murder of his two friends and the fact Jeanne can not love him under the war condition, he suffers from survivor's guilt and lost his will to live, he chose to die a soldier's death on the Russian Front.
Ele se apaixonou por ela, sendo sempre um gentil., Apesar de um homem do exército alemão, ele sofria com aquela guerra. E era um homem solitário e triste. Ela 5ambem se apaixonou por ele. Pena que não ficaram juntos.
In the mid60s still a child I saw this book lying around and the title of silence de la mar has always had an effect on me a haunting mysterious impression.Today I realise silence means Eternity silence means Adieu.....the Suisse silence ....
The song fits perfectly...if you allow me some corrections ? She's the niece of the elderly. Adieu = farewell. Je m'en vais = I'm leaving. He does not say tonight at that moment. The novel starts in November 1941, it's not about the fall of France, it's about forbidden love in an occupied country.
This kind of relationship probably did happen during that period, no doubt, a handsome officer, a good man, reluctant about war, just doing his duty, and a beautiful French girl, yes, I think there is no doubt about it. However, the idea they wouldn't have spoken for SO LONG is ridiculous. Young, sexual tension wouldn't have allowed that. No way! Although they would have been careful not to be seen in public, they no doubt would have tried to unite at the end of the war.
Καμία φορά λέμε γιατί η ζωή είναι τόσο μικρή, αν είναι να ζεις κάτω από μια αγάπη που δεν είναι όπως θες, ζητάς την προετοιμασία σου, από τον Θεό, να σε πάρει αβασανιστα κοντά του.
@balidancer Two souls recognize each other leads to merging in the vibration of love-----very high frequency, people in love are high initially, that's because their soul meshing give them access to the love frequency---heaven or higher dimension. Falling in love ----ever hear of that? Love between a man and a woman is a very narrow understanding of LOVE the energy/vibration/frequency. Somehow when we are incarnated in the physical body(3D) we have a very hard time to gain access to this high vibration zone. There are other ways to access it, meditation, sports, fasting, dancing (whirling dervishes), singing, listening to music...But Falling in Love is something most people have a chance to experience. Meditation is much harder for average 3D humans. lol. But we are about to have the Great Awakening, which is the collective ascension of humanity, basically when we transcends 3D, we become enhanced with telepathy, clairvoyance, health, mental acuity, etc. We can manifest instantly. Watch the "Soul Tribe" short film by Charles Eisenstein.
la escena final me fascina porque cuando Ella se despide y le dice adiós ...El solo la mira y No se despide porque No quiere en su corazón 💔 pensar en no volver a verla ...Ósea El se abre como manifestación de que quizá algún día se volverán a ver. El director de la película 🎥 Genio total y también El Guionista...La actuación de los tres Fabulosa!!!!! una película inolvidable para mi junto con El Paciente Inglés !
Me apaixonei por esse filme já vó inúmeras vezes Só acho que tinha que ter um beijo abraços carinhos dane se se eram de lados opostos Se amavam isso é que importaba
Не хватило интеллектуальной глубины героя, хотя автор новеллы и наделил героя способностью глубоко анализировать! Да, красив невероятно Вернер! Да, может смотреть "во все глаза", но выражение глаз "не растет ", "не глубинеет". Ушла философская сторона Веркора, остались Hugo Boss, придумавший форму и недопереживший ситуацию актер, сыгравший Вернера. Фильм не был бы таким эффектным ,если бы не актриса, сыгравшая главную героиню. В глубину переживаний ее глаз - верю, а вот мужские-голубые....не дотянули до катарсиса. Неслучайно именно ее игру отметили на кинофестивале. Как в этом фильме усилили трагедию? Да очень просто. Герой едет на Восточный (русский) фронт! Там он обязательно погибнет или от - 40°, или от большевиков! Поехал бы в ином направлении - у истории было бы продолжение...
Your comment is just water under the bridge. Jean Bruller is not a great writer, this film is much better than the short story. Besides, the Resistance had many dark, dubious sides, the historiography is controversial with many court trials between French people after the war. As regards Werner, he is the main attraction of the movie, it would have not been a success without him. She has the longest role, while he has the most important one. She has the dialogues, he has the monologues. Not only his eyes are gorgeous but also his subtle, bright smile. The mimic muscles are connected with some nervous centers on the brain, so that you can see his nobility on his face. Hugo Boss created the most elegant military uniforms ever; like it or not, that's the truth.
@@marinellabakken7491 Well said. Werner has a very tough role in the movie, but he in a way has a heavier load to bare. He bore it like a real soldier and a gentleman. He had a well spring of gentle respect and good will to talk his way into the heart of Jeanne, the good looks definitely help. Though Jeanne's determination not to talk to him in in a private space like Christmas eve when no one is around, is a bit perplexing, considering she was so lovelorn.
@@marinellabakken7491 I would love to hear more about the post war trials between French people. Is the Vichy government still hated in France? Do people understand that after the Germans occupied France, the 24 million French people in the occupied area needs some kind of government to administer to their daily needs, to enforce order, law, ensure safety? Anyone taking up the Prime Minister's role must know he was sacrificing himself for a thankless job because it would ruin his reputation...so they selected Philippe Petain. Sure enough for taking up that job, his reputation was forever sealed, it was so politicized. I wonder if today, the French understand that he made a sacrifice.
LAURA BRETAN - ”NESSUN DORMA” PERFORMANCES in 2019,, and Laura Bretan - Breathe .Laura Bretan - Adagio .She need attention and help to promote her. It is Angels voice. PLEASE help her promote
Linduss sss, may I politely suggest 'Letter from an unknown Woman', by Max Ophuls, or perhaps 'Lady with a small Dog', by Iosif Heifitz. Both dealing in love and loss and what might have been. Oh yes, and 'Fair stood the Wind for France', by H. E. Bates. Made into a TV film in the 80's, I think.
I think by this time seeing him standing there I would have thrown the fish over board and thrown myself at him, hog tied him, placed him on my bike and headed home and converted him to our side, and keep in mind I am not an assertive person 😉 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
That was such a horrible ending. Why couldn't the movie writer have written a hopeful ending. There was NO REASON he should leave for the devastating Russian front, when he knew she saved his life. Yet, she couldn't say "stay, please stay", instead says "adieu". It left all of us wanting more. An embrace, a kiss, a goodbye to the driver---
He has to leave because it seems that he got an order from headquarters that the troops there need to tighten policy there or the SS army is gonna do something there and he is not able to stop them. Remember his friends talked to him about something? They need to implement some plans there, being in love with France, he is not able to do bad things as told in France so he requested move to Russian front. And he is not able to save the girl's neighbours as Jeanne wants. So leaving is the best solution. If Jeanne survives the war, it would be a good memory for her. And also if the Captain dies, for sure he dies with this good memory.
Я смотрела несколько фильмов с его участием и в них он тоже хорошо играет. Он очень эффектный как актёр и обворожительный во всех фильмах. Поэтому, я не думаю, что он актёр одной роли. Просто в данном фильме он моложе и форма ему к лицу.
@@user-py5tv1zg5f Эта роль сильно отличается от его амплуа. Он играет энергичных или комичных героев с подвижной мимикой. Здесь он сдержан, играет больше глазами. Справился на 100%: вон сколько любви выразила женская аудитория :)
The love we could only fantasize about, perfect husband material. So respectful and showing her unconditional giving without anything in return.
It's amazing that through all the ugliness and horror of war these two endure that a trace of innocent love is found struggling to live within their hearts.
Love is one of the hidden tragedies of war we never expect to see.
Heartbreaking.
If only we would feel more than be influenced by misunderstanding and misinformation
Он найдет её после войны, иначе быть не может.Такая любовь не может умереть.
Автор сказал: Больше мы его не видели. Это в одноимённой повести сказано. Повествование ведётся от лица дедушки. Не надо ничего додумывать.
он погибнет
Beau film et superbe interpretation de Thomas Jouannet ...emouvante hîstoire.
Absolutely heartbreaking. Incredible acting.
Un chef d'oeuvre.
THIS IS IT!!!! This is the song for this couple! I am so 💔, 2 soulmates, a war 💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
Люблю этот фильм. Вальтер красавец.
Вернер
Ugh I love this movie but it is so heartbreaking..
Wow great acting for the both lead actor.. nice movie. You'll get carried away. Especially when the captain stared with the miss.❤
Фильм потрясающий. А ведь одно слово могло все изменить… сказаное вовремя…
He is so handsome...
Beautiful and sad...
Silence of the sea...
Most soldiers are sad, lovelorn, homesick, tired, cold, hungry (sometimes) scared all the time, death and suffering all around, bullets and mortar. War is evil men's game.
Ta píseň vystihuje podstatu tohoto krásného filmu. To mlčení mezi nimi řeklo víc než by řekla spousta slov. Moc krásný film a tento klip je prostě úžasný!
Um dos melhores filme de amor durante a guerra que já vi. Filme belíssimo do começo ao fim. E que CAPITAO!!!!
@@papounette307 eu vi esse filme, mas gosto mais de O Silêncio do Mar.OK?
он играет нервными окончаниями, эта полуулыбка ускользающая когда она плачет и говорит прощайте
Фильм, саундтрек ---Рвёт ДУШУ на части не возможно, без боли в Душе смотреть и слушать...ЛЮБОВЬ БЕЗ СЛОВ 🌹🍁🌹
Наталья Хаваева Да . Как вы правильно написали... фильм трогательный и долго , долго не отпускает … Признаться давно не смотрела такие фильмы 👍❤️💝❤️💝❤️
Этот фильм достоин Оскара и всех наград! Как же нам сейчас не хватает таких фильмов. Боевики достали. И про любовь если и снимают так обязательно там грязь. Кто то кому то изменяет. Любил потом разлюбил. Или она влюбилась в начальника. Не умеешь любить то не губи жизнь другому... А в этом фильме как всё красиво и трогательно! Проклятая война! Зачем люди воюют и убивают друг друга когда и так жизнь каждого из нас короткая.... 😢
Хотелось ещё посмотреть какой нибудь фильм этого талантливого режиссера. И этих актеров тоже ещё и ещё на них любоваться....❤
Куда делись талантливые наши режиссёры? Снимают одну муть голубую сейчас... Фильм " Пёс" уже достал. Всё бы ещё ничего если бы не было Звоздилова. Это недалёкого ума персонаж. Но служит в полиции. Потому что племянник генерала. Зачем позорить так полицию Украины? Не понимаю....😮😮😮😮😮😮
Актер который сыграл офицера наверное сейчас пользуется таким же успехом как наш замечательный Вячеслав Тихонов сыгравший Штирлеца! Обоим очень очень идёт военная форма... Побольше бы таких фильмов. Но без смертей и крови. Как в этих фильмах.
i`m just about to have watched this film and now my heart is broken
The book was written in 1941. The author didn't know the east Russia front was so terrible. It just said that Werner asked to go to battlefields, didn't say that he would go to the east front. The movie changed it and made that it's almost impossible that Werner could survive.
Good point. I never read the book. It must have been a Director or Producer that was jealous of true loves, and just had to put an end like that. Disgusting. It was also IMPOSSIBLE that the girl, after all she had heard from him, like the plea as to what should he do, and all the interest & attraction she had for this good man, that she would not say her feelings immediately then, if not before then? Nah, I think she would have hunted him down when she saw the murder plotted. Any decent person would have done that UNLESS she was afraid the French underground would have gone after her. I don't know. It seems there was a way she could have saved their lives.
@@bookwormdoe1522
Hi, she can't express her feelings because he was the enemy , the capitain had said once :" I really respect the people who love their country " , and in the scene next to the fire in the room ,he said : " you are very lucky because you have a house next to the sea , I like the sea , and I'm lucky because i've met an Oldman and a silent lady , then he said ,,, what I love about sea it's his silence , he meant that he love the girl because she's silent , he used a metaphore here , I don't know if you can understand what i'm trying to explain , my English is really bad . i love that movie the final maked me cry everytime ..... such a rare love
In the book the captain said I'm going to Hell , so there is no big chance that he could return .... sad
Hi, does anyone has a copy of the bilingual version of its book? Kindly send me the copy through email. I have been looling for the book. 😢
@@bookwormdoe1522 Lol I don't think the producer or director purposely put a tragic ending to destroy their romance. In fact, this movie has a theme that is beyond romance -- Anti-War and Peace. If it wasn't because of war, this duo would have continued their romance with no boundaries or obstacles. The ending is portrayed like this to remind all of us that ---- war should never happen.
I love song and this film....thank's
So beautiful,thank you.
For those who are upset at the tragic ending--look around. War is hell on earth.
I love this movie. Beautiful and Sad, I hope they meet after they war. is over.
Подскажите название фильма
I Agree!!
I love this film too, but I think unfortunately he died on Russian front 😭😭💔
@@parasharshikha7 Really? I never heart about this ending ! I'm glad they could meet again and ne happy together (I'm French, so I feel concerned) 🇫🇷❤🇩🇪
@@Elena-uh8pt "Молчание моря" 2004 г
So beautiful and wonderful. 😍 🇬🇧
"Love is a touch and yet not a touch."
Какая пара красивая, как жаль, что встретились в такое время! Песня восхитительная, 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️💌
I love this story ❤
Артист прелесть а глаза боже
So handsam and gentle man ❤
Как приятно,вот какая настоящая любовь.Сердце плачет моё. Но почему так.
I lost my peacefull life bcz of this capitan💘💔
same here ....
Renata collins me too!
Same. 😢
Who here wants to go back in 1940s and meet this Capetian.
That’s right.. I’m not the only crazy one
my parents lost their peaceful lives because of him and his kind, the German Nazis and I am sorry to say beings like him still exist and still torture and kill people only now they are doing it under the name and guise of 'democracy'...how about we let humanity dictate our actions for once , human rights... animal rights, the preservation of our environment , our planet... and forget everything else which is not really that important to begin with anyway...
"Come on sweetheart
let's adore one another
before there is no more
of you and me"
Rumi
La guerra permitio que los protagonistas se conocieran, se amaran y se separaran.
.En la realidad la guerra unio a muchas francesas con el invasor alemán cuyo final fue la muerte para muchas, por deslealtad en mano de sus propios compatriotas.
Ella es muy valiente, patriota y madura. El como todo oficial alemán era fiel al juramento a Hitler y a su politica.
Fue concientemente educado y respetuoso con quienes forzosamente lo hospedaron. Recordar que para el año 1941 Hotler ya exterminaba a miles de judios en Europa a manos de sus oficiales ya que se veian como seres humanos superiores sobre los demás.
Admiro el ejemplo de caracter y voluntad de lWener y la joven.
También se valora la capacidad de amar, enamorarse respetando sus identidades.
No forzar a la protagonista a ninguna situación embarazosa embellece y enaltece el amor del capitan alemán.
La musica expreso y comunico con delicadeza y fuerza la atraccion que ambos sentian y libero sus sentimientos.
El hecho que el partiera les dio la libertad para hacer lo que ambos querian defender sus ideales sin lastimarse. Ambos lo sabian _ se amaban, se amaron_ pero estaban en guerra.
Excelente comentário 👏👏👏
@@saulesarti6872 gracias!!!
@mariatoledo5222 I don't think Werner agrees with his government after he saw through their propaganda. Even though he decides to carry out his obligations, the murder of his two friends and the fact Jeanne can not love him under the war condition, he suffers from survivor's guilt and lost his will to live, he chose to die a soldier's death on the Russian Front.
Ele se apaixonou por ela, sendo sempre um gentil., Apesar de um homem do exército alemão, ele sofria com aquela guerra. E era um homem solitário e triste. Ela 5ambem se apaixonou por ele. Pena que não ficaram juntos.
Beautiful....
I love it so much, it's so sweet
Ç’est très magnifique ❤️
Beautiful. Congratulations!
Quando ele se despede dela dentro da casa ele olha fixamente para ela, tentando dizer, que pena que não poderemos ficar juntos 😭😭😭
i love this movie.
What is the name of this movie?or the actors?i would like to see it.
@@helensangster3570 the silence of the sea
Thank You Rene , Beautiful video
In the mid60s still a child I saw this book lying around and the title of silence de la mar has always had an effect on me a haunting mysterious impression.Today I realise silence means Eternity silence means Adieu.....the Suisse silence ....
may i ask why you call it suisse silence?
@@mc-ob7vp Maybe because Thomas Jouannet is a swiss actor ?
Tati Bill yeah but why would it be about the actor and not the book/movie?
❤
A good book along this line is Dear Enemy by Jack Cavanaugh. Loved it, happy ending.
вам любимые актеры жанна и томаш 10 раз звезда.!!!!
Film bellissimo e commovente. La canzone che hai scelto è perfetta, complimenti!
The song fits perfectly...if you allow me some corrections ? She's the niece of the elderly. Adieu = farewell. Je m'en vais = I'm leaving. He does not say tonight at that moment. The novel starts in November 1941, it's not about the fall of France, it's about forbidden love in an occupied country.
Exactly, they're grand father and grand daughter in the movie, but they're uncle and niece in the book.
... but in this film, the 2004 version ,she is the granddaughter, not the neice...
Is it a true story ? What happened to both of them, still alive and reunite?
This kind of relationship probably did happen during that period, no doubt, a handsome officer, a good man, reluctant about war, just doing his duty, and a beautiful French girl, yes, I think there is no doubt about it. However, the idea they wouldn't have spoken for SO LONG is ridiculous. Young, sexual tension wouldn't have allowed that. No way! Although they would have been careful not to be seen in public, they no doubt would have tried to unite at the end of the war.
@@bookwormdoe1522 The problem is that she was afraid of disapproval, persecution. It's not a matter of her loyalty, she was apolitic.
Amazing 👌😍 thanks for sharing ..
Καμία φορά λέμε γιατί η ζωή είναι τόσο μικρή, αν είναι να ζεις κάτω από μια αγάπη που δεν είναι όπως θες, ζητάς την προετοιμασία σου, από τον Θεό, να σε πάρει αβασανιστα κοντά του.
I love it 😍
Tristesse dans un flux d amour .....
J'aime
Eles dois tem que termina juntos ,tem que ter a continuação desse filme,pra eles ficarem junto
молчание-золото!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Amo esse filme 💕💕💕💕
Maravilhoso esse filme💚💚
love is so cruel sometimes......
@balidancer Two souls recognize each other leads to merging in the vibration of love-----very high frequency, people in love are high initially, that's because their soul meshing give them access to the love frequency---heaven or higher dimension. Falling in love ----ever hear of that? Love between a man and a woman is a very narrow understanding of LOVE the energy/vibration/frequency. Somehow when we are incarnated in the physical body(3D) we have a very hard time to gain access to this high vibration zone. There are other ways to access it, meditation, sports, fasting, dancing (whirling dervishes), singing, listening to music...But Falling in Love is something most people have a chance to experience. Meditation is much harder for average 3D humans. lol. But we are about to have the Great Awakening, which is the collective ascension of humanity, basically when we transcends 3D, we become enhanced with telepathy, clairvoyance, health, mental acuity, etc. We can manifest instantly. Watch the "Soul Tribe" short film by Charles Eisenstein.
Uwielbiam słuchać brawooo
Se me hace muy romantica
la escena final me fascina porque cuando Ella se despide y le dice adiós ...El solo la mira y No se despide porque No quiere en su corazón 💔 pensar en no volver a verla ...Ósea El se abre como manifestación de que quizá algún día se volverán a ver. El director de la película 🎥 Genio total y también El Guionista...La actuación de los tres Fabulosa!!!!! una película inolvidable para mi junto con El Paciente Inglés !
obviamente penoso porque El va al frente Ruso donde dice que están todos muriendo de frío! ... pero para la imaginación...
Hola que entendieron de las flores al final? me quedé con la duda.
@@yerarrieta2254 They are to show that she has joined the french resistance.
Não consigo superar esse final
Também não muito triste
Imádom én is ezt a filmet
Me apaixonei por esse filme já vó inúmeras vezes
Só acho que tinha que ter um beijo abraços carinhos dane se se eram de lados opostos
Se amavam isso é que importaba
Mi piace lo guardo tutti giorni bellooooo!
Eu também
Que terribles son las gerras,no podían amarse y casarse por el simple hecho de ser enemigos gracias a la malvada guerra 😥
Как я люблю этот фильм!!! Очень жаль, что такой конец. Может будет продолжение?
Le silence de la mer...gostaria de assistir 🇧🇷😊
the longing 2:45..."ahhh, kill me please!"
turn out he kills her, pride lesson.
Esse filme e lindo e triste
Esse filme deveria ter continuação.
Quién nos entiende a las mujeres...lo tubo tann cerca...lo ignoró...y ahora se va...ya no lo verá más..🥺
I love 😘😘
فدوه 😍😍😍😍😍
Já mais iguinorar todo tempo 😂😂😂😂😂
👍👍👍👍👍
❤🍁❤
💕💕💕💕💕❤️
Cómo ver esta película en español
Superrrrr film !!!!!!!!!......Ih liebe dich Werner !!!!!!!........
Ich auch.......
Ja, Werner ist schon sehr nett
Я тоже
Не хватило интеллектуальной глубины героя, хотя автор новеллы и наделил героя способностью глубоко анализировать!
Да, красив невероятно Вернер! Да, может смотреть "во все глаза", но выражение глаз "не растет ", "не глубинеет". Ушла философская сторона Веркора, остались Hugo Boss, придумавший форму и недопереживший ситуацию актер, сыгравший Вернера.
Фильм не был бы таким эффектным ,если бы не актриса, сыгравшая главную героиню. В глубину переживаний ее глаз - верю, а вот мужские-голубые....не дотянули до катарсиса. Неслучайно именно ее игру отметили на кинофестивале.
Как в этом фильме усилили трагедию? Да очень просто. Герой едет на Восточный (русский) фронт! Там он обязательно погибнет или от - 40°, или от большевиков! Поехал бы в ином направлении - у истории было бы продолжение...
Your comment is just water under the bridge.
Jean Bruller is not a great writer, this film is much better than the short story. Besides, the Resistance had many dark, dubious sides, the historiography is controversial with many court trials between French people after the war.
As regards Werner, he is the main attraction of the movie, it would have not been a success without him. She has the longest role, while he has the most important one. She has the dialogues, he has the monologues. Not only his eyes are gorgeous but also his subtle, bright smile. The mimic muscles are connected with some nervous centers on the brain, so that you can see his nobility on his face.
Hugo Boss created the most elegant military uniforms ever; like it or not, that's the truth.
@@marinellabakken7491 Well said. Werner has a very tough role in the movie, but he in a way has a heavier load to bare. He bore it like a real soldier and a gentleman. He had a well spring of gentle respect and good will to talk his way into the heart of Jeanne, the good looks definitely help. Though Jeanne's determination not to talk to him in in a private space like Christmas eve when no one is around, is a bit perplexing, considering she was so lovelorn.
@@marinellabakken7491 I would love to hear more about the post war trials between French people. Is the Vichy government still hated in France? Do people understand that after the Germans occupied France, the 24 million French people in the occupied area needs some kind of government to administer to their daily needs, to enforce order, law, ensure safety? Anyone taking up the Prime Minister's role must know he was sacrificing himself for a thankless job because it would ruin his reputation...so they selected Philippe Petain. Sure enough for taking up that job, his reputation was forever sealed, it was so politicized. I wonder if today, the French understand that he made a sacrifice.
😘😘😘😘😘👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Mi ennek a filmnek a címe magyarul? Magyarországon látható volt?
❤☘❤☘
⚘
Eu queria ver o filme completo em português.eu queria saber se eles terminam juntos que homem lindo
Dá para assistir completo pelo youtube. E não, eles não terminam juntos. A estupidez da guerra.
👍
Eu queria ver o filme címpeto em português.eu queria saber se eles terminame juntose,que homem lindo
Μόύάρέσέί πάρά πόλί άύ τό τώ έργώ ύπέρώχό σένάρίό μέ ύπέλέκτόύς άνβρώπόύς , σέ έβγνώμώνό γίά πόλί κάλί σκένόθέσόίά , Έδήξές πράγμάτά άξσέίάς πόύ έχόύνέ χάθύ σέ σίμέρίνή έπόχή μάς.
🙏
😢😢😢🌷🌷🌷👄👄👄
This movie frustrates me
Тома Жуанне актёр!
Αυτή είναι η ζωή, λυπάμαι.
Can u please recomend me some movies similiar to this one PLEASES
Linduss sss You can watch Suite Francaise. It’s very similar to this movie. I still love this one the most though!
La suite Francaise is as good as this film... even better in my opion
LAURA BRETAN - ”NESSUN DORMA” PERFORMANCES in 2019,, and Laura Bretan - Breathe .Laura Bretan - Adagio .She need attention and help to promote her. It is Angels voice. PLEASE help her promote
Linduss sss, may I politely suggest 'Letter from an unknown Woman', by Max Ophuls, or perhaps 'Lady with a small Dog', by Iosif Heifitz. Both dealing in love and loss and what might have been. Oh yes, and 'Fair stood the Wind for France', by H. E. Bates. Made into a TV film in the 80's, I think.
"Captain Corelli's Mandolin", 2001, with Penélope Cruz & Nicolas Cage.
"Hanover Street" 1979, with Harrison Ford & Christopher Plummer.
The name of the movie is possible 🌹
I agree
The silence of the sea
E bom mais Se tem amor vale tudo não deram um abraço e e beijos 🥺😞
Por que esse final é triste
Muito triste mesmo, de doer o coração 😢😢😢
I think by this time seeing him standing there I would have thrown the fish over board and thrown myself at him, hog tied him, placed him on my bike and headed home and converted him to our side, and keep in mind I am not an assertive person 😉 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂 -hug him tight
@mariazamarripa8274 Very enticing plan. I am attempted to do that too. lol
2:14
The old man is her uncle, not her grandfather
+In the film is the grandfather. Is the uncle in the book.
TRISTE con muchas emociones y al final nada.
Al contrario , atraves de solo gestos, miradas, expresiones y breves palabras los dos vivieron una gran pasion y un gran amor.....
@@araucana1976 concordo 👏👏👏
@@araucana1976 🌊 ❤🙏
That was such a horrible ending. Why couldn't the movie writer have written a hopeful ending. There was NO REASON he should leave for the devastating Russian front, when he knew she saved his life. Yet, she couldn't say "stay, please stay", instead says "adieu". It left all of us wanting more. An embrace, a kiss, a goodbye to the driver---
The Author was a soldier in that war , he wrote the Novel quickly because he was in a hurry to finish it .
All the beautiful loves are Struggling love with pity...that sucks but can make people feel deeply inside.
He has to leave because it seems that he got an order from headquarters that the troops there need to tighten policy there or the SS army is gonna do something there and he is not able to stop them. Remember his friends talked to him about something? They need to implement some plans there, being in love with France, he is not able to do bad things as told in France so he requested move to Russian front. And he is not able to save the girl's neighbours as Jeanne wants. So leaving is the best solution. If Jeanne survives the war, it would be a good memory for her. And also if the Captain dies, for sure he dies with this good memory.
@@felicityw5163 I can sympathize with you. Thank you
@@felicityw5163 well said. I was a bit confused about his leaving too.
Актер одной роли.Больше он не смог сыграть так проникновенно ни в одном фильме.
А Вы всё его фильмы просмотрели?
У меня другое мнение.
Я смотрела несколько фильмов с его участием и в них он тоже хорошо играет. Он очень эффектный как актёр и обворожительный во всех фильмах. Поэтому, я не думаю, что он актёр одной роли. Просто в данном фильме он моложе и форма ему к лицу.
@@user-py5tv1zg5f Эта роль сильно отличается от его амплуа. Он играет энергичных или комичных героев с подвижной мимикой. Здесь он сдержан, играет больше глазами. Справился на 100%: вон сколько любви выразила женская аудитория :)
A-t-on fait observer combien Mlle Delarme ressemble a la jeune Daphne du Maurier?
So do they fall in love or something?
Yes, without words and physical contacts