Crusades lasted ~200 years. There were people who believed frighting powerful western Barbarians was wrong and there should be a compromise. There was no shortage of critiques of Salah din Ayyub himself when he launched campaign to liberate Jerusalem and Palestine from occupation. So, why support those whose only job is to criticize others !
By the way salahuddine was a sunni under the command of shia fatimids before climbing ascending to his status, he fought for the shia before fighting fo the sunnah..... imagine that today, imagine all those neosalafis happy for hms leaders dying because theyre asharis or because they united with shia against israel.... what a joke
@@abdelhakyac7285 What is your point ? Salafis continues to support Genocide as asked by their western backed masters. Theology for them is just an eyewash to justify their action to the layman.
@@None-wi2co I don't know if this is a fair comparison... The wars you speak of are ones where the two sides were more balanced and attacks on the enemy had the possibility of defeating them. Some succeeded while others failed. In the case of Hamas, there was no intent to take over Tel Aviv on Oct 7 from what we know, nor was there an agreement with other armies to join the fight that we know of. It was a group with improvised weapons going against the powerhouse in the region, that has both nukes and a strong control of worldwide media, as well as having the backing of the world's superpower. If we are to compare this to the Crusades, this would be more like an army of 5 going against an army of 1000. Of course Allah SWT can give them victory if He so wills, but where is the due diligence in 5 attacking 1000?
@@iHaveBankai Understood, but Palestinians DO have the right to self defend themselves. Before Oct 7, ~250 Palestinians were killed in 2023. They had to act. All the neighboring states had abandoned them by signing peace treaties. By not doing anything, tragedy would have been much worse meaning occupation was guaranteed to continue for centuries. Now most of the world are united in demanding rights of Palestinians should be preserved.
Its normal having mixed feelings, some want freedom with its so unbearable price.... and others think that they can live under the occupier better than risking everything..... its always the sad situation in any revolution under new leadership.....its same everhwhere.....
@@Xorgot yeah yeah yeah..... continue to believe that..... the actual people talking in gaza are saying quite the opposite right now..... plus you seem you dont understand for them at it was still hell before oct 7 th
@@abdelhakyac7285i follow social media accounts from Gaza that say the same thing -- they are definitely in the majority now. Pspcr is a Palestinian organization mind you
Salaam Dr Shady may Allah Almighty preserve u ameen. I agree with u sir that a person cannot empathise with someone unless they have been through what our brothers and sisters in Palestine are going through may Allah Almighty bring them victory. 🇵🇸❤️🇵🇰🇬🇧🤲
2:08 It is not that those Imam's are worried about Palestinians, they are more worried about themselves and their image in the west, their benefits, their perks, their lifestyles and their jobs. Even if they do not get blamed by the west, they will now have to kiss their feet to ensure they are not like those Palestinians or be booted out of their lucrative positions.
Dr. Shadee, respectfully, what you're saying about Palestinians not being opposed to hamas' actions is untrue. Polls reflect their declining popularity. Currently, according to pcpsr only 39% of Gaza supports 10/7. It has been declining this past year and I would expect it to go down lower.
Hudhayfah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “It is not befitting for a believer to humiliate himself.” They said, “How does he humiliate himself?” The Prophet said, “He confronts a trial he cannot endure.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2254 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Salaam shaikh, JAK for the video but I continue to struggle to understand this from an Islamic perspective. Assuming there was no plan by Hamas to target non-combatants on Oct 7, the outcome of the attack was certain to be a massive and disproportionate retaliation by Israel as per their demonstrated pattern, and that they're basically waiting for any excuse to "mow the lawn" -- so this was a known. There are even signs to suggest that Israel planted this idea and allowed it to happen in order to wipe out Gaza and possibly more -- as we see day to day. On the other hand, the massive growth of pro-Palestinian sentiments, awareness, campus protests, people converting to Islam, etc. around the world are all alhamdulillah great, but could not have been anticipated in advance, much less any potential fall of the Israeli state as a result of the attack. My question is: as leaders of the community, is it not the duty to protect the flock from harm, or at least lessen the harm to the maximum extent possible? For sure everything is in Allah's hands, but there is also a duty of due diligence, where the estimated gains of any (halal) action need to outweigh the estimated losses. In this case I don't feel that that was done, and that any positive results we see today are an unexpected consequence. I've also heard a couple of Hamas spokespeople after Oct 7 say how basically "no pain, no gain" and that what was happening was the pain required to achieve the greater objective of a free Palestine. From a personal perspective I can understand that, but when it's your people, your mothers, children, etc. that are being put in danger to achieve the objective, to me this says that "ends justify the means", which I do not believe is in line with Islam, where we do our best in what is halal, and leave the results to Allah SWT. Lastly, my understanding from people on the ground in Gaza is that not all Gazan's supported this attack, or even Hamas, but don't ask me for exact percentages. My struggle to understand this is genuine, and not someone who thinks I know better than anyone else. Things just don't add up for me from a strategic or Islamic perspective.
I stop you there from the beginning.... firstly, every adult mle or female over 18 years old in israel unlike the rest of the world are active combattatants or reservists, the only civilians are kids and the ultra orthodox.... so its not that easy to blame someone for civilians where civilians are only kids in the kibbutz, and they made sure not to harm kids and no kid was directly harmed by hms ..... secondly that evil wicked sick argument of not fighting back because the enemy is too powerful..... thats hypocrites argument..... never once the companions werent outnumbered against the roman and persian empire..... you fight for justice, not for the result..... if you are truthful then when 2 guys enter your home and threaten you family you will simply give them your wife, your money and everything because its what? A better outcome for coward you? Will you do it? I hope not
@@SlanovichWallahi I really hope the Shaikh will address this, as I'm truly not able to understand this and I can see many others being in the same boat
I can't speak for Palestinians in Gaza but what I can say is that polls in support for October 7th and hamas have been dropping. Hamas committed horrific atrocities against Israeli civilians, many of whom wanted peace with Palestinians. The level of destruction and wrath Israel has inflicted is unprecedented, and pure malevolent. Centuries of history have been erased for good. At the same time, peaceful resistance such as the great march of return, or negotiations did not yield anything for Palestinians. Armed resistance forces attention from the world, it ideally is supposed to create leverage by making it clear to the occupier that the status quo is unsustainable. When the world abandoned Palestine, what else should they do?
@@ayeshak6822 Were the Sahaba weak in faith when they withstood the oppression by the people of Mecca? SubhanAllah, that it is weak in faith, as if depicted as sinful, to care for the brothers. You accusing the Madakhila of being Zionist while you conform to the exact ideology by promoting and supporting traps by the Zionists to "justify" their invasion and obliteration of both Gaza and Palestine.
I love Dr. Shadee and have learned a lot from him, but I have to respectfully disagree in this case. If a lion comes into your house and traps you in one room with your entire family, half of whom are young children, and you're armed with nothing but a pencil, you would be reckless for provoking the lion knowing it's going to fight back viciously and eat your children first. The imperative is to survive the immediate situation first. Then, make a plan and strike when the right conditions exist for a potential victory, don't just fight for the sake of fighting with no regard for the obvious repercussions. And it's not an evidence to say that Israel has done worse to civilians, so what Hamas has done to their civilians is okay. The IDF are not our teachers and we don't take our ethics of war from them. Harming civilians is not part of our religion and any Muslim has the right and the duty to remind the believers of that. To say that other Muslims should not speak on how Gazans should resist is akin to when liberals say that men are not allowed to speak or advise on women's issues. And finally Hamas was elected into power nearly 20 years ago when half of Gazans were not even born yet, and there have been no elections since then. It doesn't make sense to say they have some kind of democratic mandate to decide for Gaza on how to resist the occupation.
I agree with most of what you say. A lot of what you said was spot on MashaAllah. I think the only thing I would dispute is that the Palestinian cause was nearly dead. Most middle eastern countries were interested in moving past it and wanted to normalize relations with Israel. Palestinians were an obstacle to their geopolitical strategy and their cause was about to get erased for good. Saying that they should fight at a better time was just not possible. The great march of return as well as decades of peaceful resistance did not yield anything for the Palestinians. They were only met with brutality and ignored by the international community. I don't know what other strategy they could've followed with at that point.
![แฉกลโกงงานวัด 2024 [ โกงมั้ยครับ ep.106 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/taC5dpP3HXA/mqdefault.jpg)
When injustice becomes law resistance becomes duty
This not being promoted on the algorithm shows its true colours
i got it from algorithm
@Azothoth827 not really. The algorithm is creating isolated bubbles. And prevents that this information reaches new people.
The only way for the oppressed to express their humanity is through resistance
Crusades lasted ~200 years. There were people who believed frighting powerful western Barbarians was wrong and there should be a compromise. There was no shortage of critiques of Salah din Ayyub himself when he launched campaign to liberate Jerusalem and Palestine from occupation. So, why support those whose only job is to criticize others !
By the way salahuddine was a sunni under the command of shia fatimids before climbing ascending to his status, he fought for the shia before fighting fo the sunnah..... imagine that today, imagine all those neosalafis happy for hms leaders dying because theyre asharis or because they united with shia against israel.... what a joke
@@abdelhakyac7285 What is your point ? Salafis continues to support Genocide as asked by their western backed masters. Theology for them is just an eyewash to justify their action to the layman.
@@abdelhakyac7285so refreshing to see intelligent comments on YT,
@@None-wi2co I don't know if this is a fair comparison... The wars you speak of are ones where the two sides were more balanced and attacks on the enemy had the possibility of defeating them. Some succeeded while others failed. In the case of Hamas, there was no intent to take over Tel Aviv on Oct 7 from what we know, nor was there an agreement with other armies to join the fight that we know of. It was a group with improvised weapons going against the powerhouse in the region, that has both nukes and a strong control of worldwide media, as well as having the backing of the world's superpower. If we are to compare this to the Crusades, this would be more like an army of 5 going against an army of 1000. Of course Allah SWT can give them victory if He so wills, but where is the due diligence in 5 attacking 1000?
@@iHaveBankai Understood, but Palestinians DO have the right to self defend themselves. Before Oct 7, ~250 Palestinians were killed in 2023. They had to act. All the neighboring states had abandoned them by signing peace treaties. By not doing anything, tragedy would have been much worse meaning occupation was guaranteed to continue for centuries. Now most of the world are united in demanding rights of Palestinians should be preserved.
Dr Shady I’m from PS and from what I see there’s mixed feelings and people are lost but the majority support it.
Its normal having mixed feelings, some want freedom with its so unbearable price.... and others think that they can live under the occupier better than risking everything..... its always the sad situation in any revolution under new leadership.....its same everhwhere.....
❤
Majority of those in Gaza do not support it now according to polls
@@Xorgot yeah yeah yeah..... continue to believe that..... the actual people talking in gaza are saying quite the opposite right now..... plus you seem you dont understand for them at it was still hell before oct 7 th
@@abdelhakyac7285i follow social media accounts from Gaza that say the same thing -- they are definitely in the majority now. Pspcr is a Palestinian organization mind you
You have spoken truth.
Beautiful explaination with that picture.
Really neat how the Sheikh threw in 'Greater Palestine'. May the Ummah be revived to build it. Allaahumma ameen
Allah protect you 🤲🏻
ما شاء الله عليك حفظك الله ورعاك
Salaam Dr Shady may Allah Almighty preserve u ameen.
I agree with u sir that a person cannot empathise with someone unless they have been through what our brothers and sisters in Palestine are going through may Allah Almighty bring them victory.
🇵🇸❤️🇵🇰🇬🇧🤲
I can't believe we're having a whole video on why that's the right thing to do
@@nafizulsanko I thought the same too
Allahumma aslih ahwala al muslimeena fi filisteen
If not mistaken this has been going since the 1920s not just in 1948
People who victim blame are either abusers or victims themselves. No one else in their right mind does this.
🌹
It started first in 1897 with an atheïst
and continue with the British mandate and the so called Israël untill now
2:08 It is not that those Imam's are worried about Palestinians, they are more worried about themselves and their image in the west, their benefits, their perks, their lifestyles and their jobs. Even if they do not get blamed by the west, they will now have to kiss their feet to ensure they are not like those Palestinians or be booted out of their lucrative positions.
Dr. Shadee, respectfully, what you're saying about Palestinians not being opposed to hamas' actions is untrue. Polls reflect their declining popularity. Currently, according to pcpsr only 39% of Gaza supports 10/7. It has been declining this past year and I would expect it to go down lower.
Hudhayfah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “It is not befitting for a believer to humiliate himself.” They said, “How does he humiliate himself?” The Prophet said, “He confronts a trial he cannot endure.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2254
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Salaam shaikh, JAK for the video but I continue to struggle to understand this from an Islamic perspective. Assuming there was no plan by Hamas to target non-combatants on Oct 7, the outcome of the attack was certain to be a massive and disproportionate retaliation by Israel as per their demonstrated pattern, and that they're basically waiting for any excuse to "mow the lawn" -- so this was a known. There are even signs to suggest that Israel planted this idea and allowed it to happen in order to wipe out Gaza and possibly more -- as we see day to day. On the other hand, the massive growth of pro-Palestinian sentiments, awareness, campus protests, people converting to Islam, etc. around the world are all alhamdulillah great, but could not have been anticipated in advance, much less any potential fall of the Israeli state as a result of the attack. My question is: as leaders of the community, is it not the duty to protect the flock from harm, or at least lessen the harm to the maximum extent possible? For sure everything is in Allah's hands, but there is also a duty of due diligence, where the estimated gains of any (halal) action need to outweigh the estimated losses. In this case I don't feel that that was done, and that any positive results we see today are an unexpected consequence.
I've also heard a couple of Hamas spokespeople after Oct 7 say how basically "no pain, no gain" and that what was happening was the pain required to achieve the greater objective of a free Palestine. From a personal perspective I can understand that, but when it's your people, your mothers, children, etc. that are being put in danger to achieve the objective, to me this says that "ends justify the means", which I do not believe is in line with Islam, where we do our best in what is halal, and leave the results to Allah SWT.
Lastly, my understanding from people on the ground in Gaza is that not all Gazan's supported this attack, or even Hamas, but don't ask me for exact percentages.
My struggle to understand this is genuine, and not someone who thinks I know better than anyone else. Things just don't add up for me from a strategic or Islamic perspective.
I stop you there from the beginning.... firstly, every adult mle or female over 18 years old in israel unlike the rest of the world are active combattatants or reservists, the only civilians are kids and the ultra orthodox.... so its not that easy to blame someone for civilians where civilians are only kids in the kibbutz, and they made sure not to harm kids and no kid was directly harmed by hms ..... secondly that evil wicked sick argument of not fighting back because the enemy is too powerful..... thats hypocrites argument..... never once the companions werent outnumbered against the roman and persian empire..... you fight for justice, not for the result..... if you are truthful then when 2 guys enter your home and threaten you family you will simply give them your wife, your money and everything because its what? A better outcome for coward you? Will you do it? I hope not
Very well said, brother/sister
@@SlanovichWallahi I really hope the Shaikh will address this, as I'm truly not able to understand this and I can see many others being in the same boat
@@iHaveBankai Agreed. Please see my top level comment where I expressed similar thoughts.
I can't speak for Palestinians in Gaza but what I can say is that polls in support for October 7th and hamas have been dropping. Hamas committed horrific atrocities against Israeli civilians, many of whom wanted peace with Palestinians.
The level of destruction and wrath Israel has inflicted is unprecedented, and pure malevolent. Centuries of history have been erased for good.
At the same time, peaceful resistance such as the great march of return, or negotiations did not yield anything for Palestinians. Armed resistance forces attention from the world, it ideally is supposed to create leverage by making it clear to the occupier that the status quo is unsustainable.
When the world abandoned Palestine, what else should they do?
Sadly Arabs will not liberate falastina they talk down on the leaders like Hero sinwar🤲 ❤❤
This was not recommended, strangely 🤔
Was recommend to me by the algorithm...
@@wakannnai1 same
Hopefully "they" dont come after you 💀
Some very rare bur famous Palestinians do that, like Motaz (when he writes in Arabic on twitter)
but they definitely don't represent most people, only the elite Arab/ Muslim liberals.
...but they don't represent most people, just some elite Arab/ Muslim liberals.
I have a few videos of people in Gaza saying this.. how do I show the shaykh?
Outliers. People of weak faith.
@@ayeshak6822 Were the Sahaba weak in faith when they withstood the oppression by the people of Mecca?
SubhanAllah, that it is weak in faith, as if depicted as sinful, to care for the brothers. You accusing the Madakhila of being Zionist while you conform to the exact ideology by promoting and supporting traps by the Zionists to "justify" their invasion and obliteration of both Gaza and Palestine.
Can i know which imam said that and from which country? I'm pretty sure a lot of european juice interested to know.
Probably a Saudi madhkali.
@@ayeshak6822 Probably a sheikh of Ahlul Sunnah wa Jammaha
Prove from the seerah
I love Dr. Shadee and have learned a lot from him, but I have to respectfully disagree in this case.
If a lion comes into your house and traps you in one room with your entire family, half of whom are young children, and you're armed with nothing but a pencil, you would be reckless for provoking the lion knowing it's going to fight back viciously and eat your children first. The imperative is to survive the immediate situation first. Then, make a plan and strike when the right conditions exist for a potential victory, don't just fight for the sake of fighting with no regard for the obvious repercussions.
And it's not an evidence to say that Israel has done worse to civilians, so what Hamas has done to their civilians is okay. The IDF are not our teachers and we don't take our ethics of war from them.
Harming civilians is not part of our religion and any Muslim has the right and the duty to remind the believers of that. To say that other Muslims should not speak on how Gazans should resist is akin to when liberals say that men are not allowed to speak or advise on women's issues.
And finally Hamas was elected into power nearly 20 years ago when half of Gazans were not even born yet, and there have been no elections since then. It doesn't make sense to say they have some kind of democratic mandate to decide for Gaza on how to resist the occupation.
I'm sure Palestinians don't care what you think, and even a 5-year-old Palestinian child has more courage in their body than you.
I agree with most of what you say. A lot of what you said was spot on MashaAllah.
I think the only thing I would dispute is that the Palestinian cause was nearly dead. Most middle eastern countries were interested in moving past it and wanted to normalize relations with Israel. Palestinians were an obstacle to their geopolitical strategy and their cause was about to get erased for good. Saying that they should fight at a better time was just not possible. The great march of return as well as decades of peaceful resistance did not yield anything for the Palestinians. They were only met with brutality and ignored by the international community. I don't know what other strategy they could've followed with at that point.
Israeli civilians?
@@chainu3404 Yes
Please talk about USAID and how the U.S state department is subjugating Somalia WIlliam Burns CIA chief was in Mogadishu last week