ICJ Ruling on Israel | Reactions as World Court judges order Israel to stop raiding Rafah
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- The International Court of Justice has ordered Israel to halt its offensive in Rafah, Gaza. In its latest application to the Hague-based Court, South Africa petitioned the World Court to order additional provisional measures including a withdrawal of Israeli military from Rafah. ICJ President Judge Nawaf Salam made the ruling. SABC Correspondent Alex Cadier joins us live from The Hague as we get more reaction following that order by the International Court of Justice.
For more news, visit sabcnews.com and #SABCNews on all Social Media platforms.
Why is this court not pressing Hamas to handover the hostages
Heard that many of hostages' Bodies found!! So??
hostages shouldnt have been living on stolen land in the first place
Israel has 1000s of hostages. Including 5 years old children and pregnant women. Hush child.
They did order their immediate release.
Don't waste our time go listen or read the full order. You already assume that the court ddnt without reading the whole order
Lets find solution and peace.
It’s not the big question whether Israel will implement the court order, the big question is someone has to make them implement or else…
Why does anyone think Hamas would stop its ambitions of destroying Israel?
Do they not understand the Islamic “Taqiyya appears in Sura 3:28:"?
“Let not the believers take the unbelievers for friends; and whoever does this, shall have nothing to do with Allâh in any matter; unless you do this to protect yourselves from the unbelievers. Thus Allâh cautions you to have reverence only for him. To Allâh is destiny.”
in other words
Regarding 3:28, Ibn Kathir writes, “… believers who in some areas or times fear for their safety from the disbelievers… are allowed to show friendship to the disbelievers outwardly, but never inwardly.” Ibn Kafthir quotes Muhammad‘s companion, Abu Ad-Darda’, who said “we smile in the face of some people although our hearts curse them"
@@AdamDorfman82talk facts. Try your shallow opinions in court one day to see what happens
@@zuhairzainal- 👍
Why anyone is not speaking about the hostages ?
Why nobody is talking about the hostages ?
I have gotten thrown out of restaurants 248 times in my lifetime. Clearly restaurants have a hate agenda 🤷🏼♀️.
indeed!..👍
While we still have some common sense or not...the world needs to stop this immediately.
If the world stops this immediately,,what happens to Hammas? Is the world also going to stop Russia‘s war against the Ukraine?
salute South Africa
For its reverse apartheid policy against the white farmers!
Obvious if the hostages are not priotise expect nothing to happen
Fantastic timing with the court order-only missed the 1948 Nakba by a bit!
Any UN member state not in support of the ICJ needs to leave the UN. The world will celebrate your departure.
Proud that the Somali Judge Abdulqawi Ahmed Yusuf vote for.
Somalis always stand for justice and doing the right thing.
Sadly the Ugandan judge vote against and bought shame on Africa.
Free Palestine. 🍉 End the Genocide.
"Somalis always stand for justice and doing the right thing." Don't make me fckuing laugh. You idiots are responsible for all the ship hijackings, the deaths of 500,00 of your own people with your civil war...And you dare to post your hypocritical BS,
Well done South Africa ! Your courage as a small country can only be commended!! ❤ SA free Palestine 🇵🇸
What about Free the hostages ?
@@annabellewollis4432 the hostages were silly for putting themselves in harms way and living on stolen land.
@@annabellewollis4432
Thank you, we do this for humanity and not for Imperialistic agendas
@@annabellewollis4432Netanyahu doesn’t want to rescue them, that’s why the families of those hostages are demanding Netanyahu to resign.
Yes we are fighting for peace peace peace peace peace 🎉🎉🎉
What order did the court make concerning the Israeli hostages?
From the the indiscriminate bombing do you think they are still alive 😢?
I doubt it
This court has no say
NO CEASE FIRE THEY AFTO GO IN RAFAH TO GET SINAR
Sherwin SABC your rejoicing create a propoganda it will be short lived joy.
Ban the bomb Peace ✌️
Now the world is showing some of its strength and force...... keep it up sir
Israel needs to stop protecting its civilians from salvage attack of it's Arab opposition? I don't think so! The U.N has now joined the ranks of Israel's barbaric attackers!
What about the hostages ?
Where was the world , Before & After & Beound ?
SABC NEWS 🎉🎉🎉
On top on all this is elections time in the USA and European Union and Uk...very complicated situation for peaand humanity...horrible times for the world.
Wow. Are you YT channel or a phone video?
Judgement after judgement but no enforcement. Nothing achieved here
US, UK and other countries will abide even if Israel does not.
A lot is achieved bra.. ISRAEL can't carry on alone without the help of US, UK and other allies.
@@delorisjuma think you underestimate jewish resolve.
How about the hostages
The 2 million hostages in Palestine?
Israel needs to release the Palestinian hostages from their prison.
@@thembakhumalo-li7bl If you're going to be factious at least be factual.
Netenyahu don't care about those hostages
@@thembakhumalo-li7blthose in Israeli prison are terrorists not civilians !!!!!!!! How hard is to understand that
Why is South Africa, UN or ICJ and others supporting Hamas? Why didn't they take any actions to Punish Hamas
tsjek
Such a naiive comment, the above bodies, are fighting for innocent civilians over 35k people killed, plus the blocking of humanitaren AID. Nothing about the war.
In addition the ICC prosecutor seeks to get arrest warrant for both the opposition leaders (Hamas and Israel)
War machine Netanyahu must be punished before justice!!!
I. C . J. Has no enforcing . power so now it has to go to the u.n securityy councill
Lets see the USA , UK and other countries not abide by the ICJ. Israel will ignore but the rest will rethink providing arms now.
But it will tarnish Israel 🇮🇱 reputation international
sadly the UN is just a waste of oxygen as well
@@andilemtshe9063 you betcha! we took nazis to the nague for crimes against humanity and will also take the zio-nazis to the court for their crimes against humanity. The apple doesnt fall from the tree
This is not true. Listen the guy in the US.
Thank you South Africa! ❤
ISRAEL WHO THINKS IT CONTROLS THE NARRATIVE IN THE WORLD HAS BEEN DISCPLINED AND TAKEN ON BY A SMALL INSIGNIFICANT COUNTRY. BIG UP SOUTH AFRICA, IRELAND AND OTHER COUNTRIES WHO TOOK ON THIS FIGHT.
What about the hostages ?
Which hostages the Palestine or iareal do you mean both because you are fair ?@@annabellewollis4432
Rubbish
FREE THE HOSTAGES! LET GODS PEOPLE GO
@@annabellewollis4432 they shouldnt have been living on stolen land in the first place.
ICJ judge Nawaf Salam ruled against Israel.Unquestionably,he is unbiased.😂
15 vs. 2 verdict.
What can we hear from a moslem 😂.
Pravda for SA. Nice.
Thanks for sharing
Ist possible to negotiate with the monsters?
Well done, South Africa. Right has prevailed.
But civilians have been moved. What about hostages? 700 tunnels
liar jew
@@josephmansour3151 why do you hate em ? have they done something to you ?
@@josephmansour3151why do you support a terrorist organization
Satanyau doesn't even care about them hostages
@@andilemtshe9063 Right, Satanyahu already bombed hostages with Gaza civilians
He was too busy doing Genocide
Time to study, evaluate and revise U. N charter, ICJ and ICC. They look into themselves as "HIGH and MIGHTY" and all nations sovereignty and supreme court's is in their grasp. If not why not Create another body to oversee how U. N behaves ?
My greatest fear as a proud S African is that the people of SA wont be allowed to hear FREE and FAIR, UNFILTRED, UNBIASED NEWS. Is the SABC still such a news outlet? I'm starting to have my doubts.
❤
Israel Leaders must understand that we love both countries. What we hate is the war.
The # of likes your comment has tells us everything we need to know... The world is full of hatred towards a nation... My only hope is that in the end Yeshua will come to rescue 🇮🇱 from his enemies… and the world will be judge
The # of likes your comment has tells us everything we need to know... The world is full of hatred towards a nation... My only hope is that in the end Yeshua will come to rescue 🇮🇱 from his enemies… and the world will be judge
War has casualties... educate yourself... 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
@@deborahfilippi798 it is those casualties we want to avoid going forward. I know very well that has casualties. Like hostages one by one are sadly passing away. Innocent people are also starving. Wake up, blessed are peacemakers.
@@Llllltgyh Yes but Israel still needs to defend herself... and remember that Hamas put their own people in harms way. They built the tunnels under schools and hospitals... Egypt is preventing aid as is the other Muslim countries... Yes, blessed are the peacemakers but Israel is fighting for her survival.. From the river to the sea means their must be no land for Israel. I'm sorry I stand by 🇮🇱
What Israel is doing in Gaza and Rafah is nothing short of criminality. Even if the Court has "no enforcement" provision, it is clear to the entire world, particularly to the enablers of genocide (USA, UK) , that these rulings are extremely serious. The countries that represent the rules-based order (USA,UK) are not above the law and cannot wriggle out of major international court rulings. Israel, as an occupying power, has no automatic right to "defend itself" - as the aggressor on Palestinian land. If Israel's Rafah operation was valid, either to eliminate Hamas or rescue the hostages, then the Court would not have ruled for its immediate cessation.
One rarely sees such a tightly knit dissertation as this in YT comments - and just as rarely one that is so full of gaping holes.
@@Princeps3scorpionusthough not as common and widespread on YT as comments which make assertions without the need for any substantiation whatsoever.
@@wafaabdullah2172 Especially those asserting such concepts as "genocide" and "occupation", right?
@@Princeps3scorpionus Such concepts are also precise legal definitions. The international Courts have described Israel's current and historic position as an 'occupation'. Israel's current military actions are now widely accepted as a genocide especially after the ICJ accepted the argument offered by South Africa. You may like to reject these legal definitions but they are accepted by the highest international court and most of mankind.
@@wafaabdullah2172 "described", "widely accepted", and "argument" are not precise legal terms/definitions. They may have some bearing on a given legal argument, premise of an argument, or support of an argument. The law is malleable and ductile - as are terms and definitions. There are judgments - and there are appeals from judgments. There are concepts such as mitigation and totality of the circumstances. It is usually wiser to consider the merits of BOTH sides of a legal question before rushing to judgment.
🇵🇸❤️🇿🇦✊
ICC wants flat Israel😂
Kangaroo court!!!
I wonder when they will issue a similar order against South Africa’s friend - Russia.
One only needs to look at where the judges are from and it is nothing other than a kangaroo court based on politics and not law or reason.
your victim mentality is showing for us all to see. cringe
Did the angelic friends of South Africa called Hamas release all hostages in accordance with the previous provisional measures by ICJ? What did South Africa do to follow the judgement. Is it fair to pressure Israel to conform to the new provisional measure while the previous has not been complied with by the other party?
Has not said anything about the order on Hamas who can carry on killing IDF soldiers?
Simple
they should get out and go home
simple
You mean defending themselves? IDF is on their land slaughtering their people
Lol...love it@@Transformers-oe5jj
What are those IDF doing in Palestine?? They shouldn't be there first place
I think ICC has no solution to this, they are just escalating things
@@tamhiker1 you must be out of your mind, seems you do not know the flow of the crime so just shut up
True, they are kangaroo court approached by a kangaroo anc
Israel is not ready and will not do it as per order
ICJ go and give orders to your wife and children not to Israel (ICJ 🐛🪱)
cope harder
What about the hostages?
Brilliant!
Biased reporting as usual, pathetic
It is always biased if it does not serve your narrative, isn't?
@@jamludentertainment so are you agreeing or disagreeing its biased and what makes you think I have a narrative thats one sided. I'm sure when I last looked at an A4 page there's was 1+1=2 sides to a page!