@@slipperygypsy1366 well where I work, people have a station that might as well be their own home workshop, well depending on the importance of the employee anyway, and people come and take our shit off of our benches, that's why we do this thing called engraving our tools, handy when someone decides your chalk line would be more useful to them
Finally! Great review guys! Time stamps below 1:56 recoil test 4:00 wear of tape coating 7:10 magnetic testing 9:41 debris testing 11:05 stand out 11:48 hook movement 14:09 ergonomics 16:30 readability 18:11 drop tests 19:48 pricing 20:14 best overall
Used Lufkins since the beginning, on & off for 40yrs. Use one now but regular Stanley Powerlock has been my go-to for a long time. Comfort in hand, works good for a long time & available everywhere at a decent price, are the reasons. You reviews are the best. No stupid BS drama, no ridiculous claims, just intelligent & straight forward info.
I bought the Fat Max at Lowe's on Black Friday. 2 for $20. Stupid me took the belt clip off to shove into a tape pouch and lost the screw. I asked Stanley if they could send a replacement. They could not, but sent a whole new tape instead. That is ridiculously kind customer service.
This Video is absolutely the most useful tape measure comparison and review. It is comprehensive, highly informative and most importantly... Over 33 years of jobsite conversation debating the merits of tape measures with every newbie, it goes beyond opinion and provides testers results. One note though, I was taught to never extend a tape more than 2/3rd or 3/4th the length as a general rule. My preference for 20 years was Lufkin 30' but the Fatmax 25' found everywhere, has been on my hip for the last 10.
I've been doing construction for 14 years now. I'm a fatmax fan through and through. For my home shop I tend to lean toward my Lufkin cause it's a good price and doesn't need to be as tough cause it's not out in the elements. Thanks for the review
Such a thorough testing process. Every gripe and issue I've ever had with a tape measure was thought of in this testing process. I'm decades into my career and have tried dozens of brands. Thank you for this great video! Keep up the amazing work.
I'm dyslexic and I didn't realize it for years. My go too TAPE was the Stanley Fatmax after doing a trim job and realizing I had alot of waste because of inversion of numbers, I started looking toward solutions and I found Fastcap. Your toolreveiws are so valuable to me that they have swayed purchase decision solely on your reveiw and your product and field knowledge. Based on that I think you might want to give Fastcap a buzz and have them send some tools out they're a tool solution company. Try the tapes and have them send you a fat boy pencil ( b careful everyone will steal it on the site) give them a try we might have another convert . Thanks again for all the great reveiws .
I work in a metal fabrication shop and I use the Stanley Leverlock most often but the coating wears fast. I only use the Stanley Fatmax for the bigger jobs (mainly cause it is bulky and the magnet picks up too much metal dust) but it's hands down the most durable beast of a tape measure I've ever used. All of our machinist use Lufkin tape measures for their accuracy, but they're no where near as rough on their tapes as we are.
Easily one of the most informational tool comparisons i have ever seen. Super helpful video. Glad the FatMax won cause I've been buying the PowerLock for years and love Stanley tapes
When my grandfather passed, the first thing I grabbed from his garage was a Stanley tape measure circa early 70s. He beat the crap out of it - cement contractor. I still use it today, and when I'm not using it, it sits on my mantle above my fireplace in remembrance. He was the best and so are Stanley's!
In my 35 years I’ve used Stanley and Dewalt, now I use Lufkin 16’ ( I’m a cabinet / trim guy), exclusively because they have the best longevity and the blackface both sides, is easiest to read by far, also best palm feel. Great vid Rob as always
I may buy a lufkin after viewing this. I am a Dewalt guy through and through I use that extended reach all the time and they are so damn comfortable to use
@@ConcordCarpenter Wow, thanks for the reply. I have watched many of your excellent videos. Thoroughly enjoy 'em. I clicked the bell, so now I will keep up with all new videos. Thanks... have a Great Thanksgiving
Stanley would be smart to use that description! Their customers would get it and likely appreciate that kinda thing. A good sense of humor is excellent marketing!
Have used the Fat Max for years and finally switched to the Milwaukee. For the simple reason that I like the belt clip better. All tapes wear out it’s just part of it. The thing that I hate is when the clip spins or scratches me because of wear. Only had the Milwaukee for a couple months but I’ve grown to love it even more then the Fat Max and I would have never thought that could be possible!
The main problem I have with tape measures is when they get wet from working in the rain. The recoil deteriorates and the markings rub away causing rust. I get through at least 5 tape measures a year. A water resistant tape measure would be a god send here in England.
I have that problem too, I applied silicone spray to my tape as it’s a lube that won’t attract dirt. Then I discovered both Stanley and Komelon have made stainless steel tapes. Really good in the wet, however when they bend it’s difficult to get that kink out.
I totally agree with you there. I had the same experience when working out in the yard, until my tape got caught in between some timbers and it was bent out of shape so easily, less than 7 days. Furthermore, while working out in the rain, it corroded more quickly than the cost of buying it.
This is reassuring. I've been using Stanley for years almost exclusively. I use Stanley for a reason that you didn't even address. I use Stanley because on most job sites Stanley is the most common tape used by almost every professional, and Stanely's tolerances are pretty consistent. That means that if I make a measurement, and then someone comes along behind me with a Stanley Tape, they will get the same measurement. That is usually not true if some (or I) come behind someone using a different brand of tape measure. It doesn't matter if I'm working alone from start to finish, but oftentimes (when working off of prints) more than one person is taking measurements. Stanley has practically no variance from tape to tape. I just thought that I'd give you something to consider. I really like your channel. Thank You for the good content.
Well done. Great tests, and great presentation. I've had the Dewalt tape for several months now, and it's held up really well to my abuse. My next tape will probably be that mag tip Fatmax though! Thanks for the great review!
FISCO BIG-T tapes are awesome. I am a cabinet and furniture maker and the Fisco Big-T tapes are all I use. They used to be called Johnson "Big Johnson" tapes, but Fisco Big-T is what to look for now. Yes, I posted twice on this. I go out of my way to let people know about these tapes. No, I have no stock in them, I just like them. Before the Big-T tapes, I used a 16' Lufkin with the Stanley magnetic attachment quick-draw mechanism.
Like you I have always bought the Stanley. I never even thought to buy another until watching this review. Although it didn’t place in the top 2 the Milwaukee has my attention with the features and the scale rule in the back. Thank you for your videos and great content. Stay safe out there
I've been running the Fatmax for 10+ years n the best part is a localy owned hardware store where I'm from exchanges the tapes for free, so when our tape starts running rough or has a slight bend to it we just snap the end off, exchange it n buy a new scratch pad. Love the vids, keep up the great work!!
I definatly agree with this video. I use a Fat Max at work in a heavy steel production shop. We calibrate every 3 months. I have never had to replace a tape because of the hook going out of whack. I only have to replace my tape when when it gets all nasty and full of crap like metal dust, coolant and oil. Or sometimes I do something stupid like measure near a torch flame and melt the markings off lol. People keep your eyes peeled at Home Depot they have a 2 pack of 25' Fat Max tapes for the price of a single. Seems to be around Christmas every year.
I’ve been scaffolding for 10 years and had two Stanley Fatmax tapes, my first one lasted about 8 years and I am currently on my second one. I find the tape very good for my job and after watching this video I will buy another one when needed.
Lufkin classic all the way. Accurate measurement every time the end never gets bent on drops. Super durable and only 5$. 15 years I’ve been using them. Switched from Stanley and I’ll never go back
My Stanley lever lock has started to fail by not recouping all the way unless I extend almost all of the tape and reel it back in. I was looking at my options and happened across this video in my feed. Looks like I'm getting another Stanley. Great job on the presentation and data collection.
“Essential craftsman”. said his choice is a Stanley; years in the trades and experience, I trust his advice -all his advise has been accurate so far. I have several Stanley’s I’ve had for years.. I’m not a professional, but I do use them a lot.
The Cobalt tape measures from Lowes are made by Komelon. Lowes offers a lifetime replacement warranty, for any reason. I've replaced one in the past 3 years, without issue. While the tapes are more readable, they are more fragile than the Fatmax. Most of my tapes are the Stanley Fatmax, but I keep one or two of the Cobalt tapes around if I'm doing fine work. Plus they have nice magnetic tips. The Stanley magnets are hokey. The magnetic tip is really nice when working with metal framing and taking measurements on commercial projects where metal is widely used. My favorite general purpose tapes were the Stanley Fatmax with the chrome case and wide hook. Those were phenomenal for framing work and measuring on site. They would hook and hold well with that large hook, and the famous Fatmax standout was great for those purposes. Especially on a ladder trying to get a measurement. The thinner tapes just fall a few times, leaving you aggravated. I have one 16' chrome case left in my truck that I'm taking care of like it's priceless, but I use it weekly. All in all, I currently have 4 tapes either in my box or on the truck at any given time. 16' Fatmax chrome cased 25' Fatmax 25' Cobalt 30' Fatmax They are all used for different reasons. Like any tool in the toolbox, they each have their purpose.
I liked Milwaukee’s old magnetic tape. It had 2 magnets one for the end like they still have now. And on that face down so it could stick to a pipe or metal that way.
Just found your site and have so far watched a few comparison tests between different manufacturers. So far I'm very impressed, have subscribed and will definitely be coming back. Thanks.
I have the STANLEY "Write-On" 25' tape measure. What I like about it is that all the scales are numbered except the 16th scales. This tape measure are for those who can't remember the fraction scales in standard unit of measure. Which is why metric scale is much easier.
I've had two 30' Stanley power lock tapes since 1997 when I started my business and they've really held up. They're also not very rigid at all anymore and when I saw a 25' Milwaukee on clearance for 12 bucks, it was mine. However, I really do need a Fatmax. Most days I work alone and the Fatmax is really helpful when you measure solo.
These reviews are awesome!!! Never thought you’d be able to compare a tape measure to that level but it was actually pretty interesting. I called the fat max winning from the start, but’s it’s nice to have your biases confirmed :)
You don't need a tape measure for that. On alot of greenlee benders the multiplier is on the head of the bender. One side has degrees other side has the multiplier
Also it's nice to have the lifetime warranty, if I am ever dumb and break my klein tools I take it to home depot and do a 1 for 1 swap and am out in 5 minutes. I think they should have taken that to consideration.
Courtney Sutherlin Greenlee, Ideal, and Klein benders all have the multiplier on one side and the angle on the other, but the Klein tape measure also has the shrink charts which fall off the handles of all the benders. For electrical work where most of your measurements are under 10’, the fatmax is just too big, heavy and bulky, however I do recognize that it is more durable.
i bought a Milwaukee tape like the one in this video and it almost immediately stopped retracting itself and getting jammed up. I also hated the belt clip, and the end clip got loose real fast. I know its only my experience but i would not buy one again. I replaced it with a Fat Max and that tape is awesome, its held up well the last couple years. Its super tough, stands out far (i remodeled my house alone so i needed that) and it has yet to get jammed, even though it gets full of drywall and saw dust.
My Stanley FatMax (33-725 25) fricken broke the first week of having it. I literally span out like 15’ or so, and its really good to know that pulling it out so far can damage the tape, but it got jammed in a strange way, and literally wouldn’t wind up. Mind you now, it was a 25’. Now i’ve been using those new Craftsman tape measures. (CMHT37625S) So far, 8 months in, and its been the best tape measure i’ve ever had.
Always liked the Fatmax. My preference was always the 30', as quite often I was measuring just over 25'. The last tape I bought was a Kobalt 30' - not particularly durable. Decent standout, the magnet was okay, but quality of materials was sub-par. Great video, confirms what every tradesman knows- Fatmax is number 1!
I can’t say one’s better than the other, but my Stanley fatmax was dropped from 20-25 ft and still works perfectly. I work in construction so it handles harsh conditions daily
It's a great comparison definitely. Though I am using a komelon tape at the moment at work and it's held up to work in the metal industry very well so far.
My favorite tape measure is the free one from Harbor Freight that they offer with a coupon. It is a half inch wide tape by 25 feet. Never had a problem with it and I must have a dozen around the house. I pick one up every time I am there.
I've been back and forth on tapes, but for the past year I've been using Lufkin Shockforce almost entirely. The main reason is the gritted hook, which absolutely grips PVC and plastic pipe so easily (I'm a plumber, and I cant tell you how many times I've hooked an end of a pipe to measure a cut only to have the hook fall off with other tapes). It hooks once and doesn't fall off until you want it to. I love the feel of it, the double sided blade, the horizontal lettering on one side but vertical on the other, and the absolute rigidity that it has, because it is definitely the stoutest tape I've ever had (second would be the Milwaukee stud). This is my second Lufkin this year, but not because the first broke. I actually lost it. I want to try the shockforce black widow for its black blade with neon green markings, because working in new crawlspaces can get dark.
I have be running the same milwaukie for about 5 years now. Before that I had a lufkin for about 3 years. Before that it was always Stanley power or level lock.
Yup, been using Fat Max’s for years so it’s good to know I chose well but I learned about some other features that I will go looking for next time. Very impressed with two sided numbers, high visibility scales and less damaging belt clips. Great info….keep reviewing and comparing tools that don’t break the bank.
Great channel and you do a great informative presentation with reviews, well done, it's great for us tradesmen who utilize tools all day everyday, cheers fellas, well done.
I have a Lufkin 16' tape measure. Have had this thing for years. Also, have a tape i picked up at wal mart, Hyper Tough 25'. Works for what i need it for. Worked on a rough-in crew a couple of years( '97-98'). Had a stanley 25' but lost it, or someone thought they needed it more than i did.
As a stainless steel pipe fitter I’ve gone through dozens of tape measures. Stanley fatmax was the best and lasted the longest. Would accurately stretch to 10 feet without bowing which made fitting fast and easy. Fatmax hands down reigns supreme.
i replaced my fatmaxes wtih milwaukee... nothing wrong with fatmax, milwaukee is just lighter and more compact package with similar performance... i also like tajima but theyre lighter duty... komelon broke the first day under light use, the tape is like paper...
I used to work for a steel company and we would go through a tape like every other month. They would get oily, dirty, cut, dropped. The one that was the best was a Stanley. It had a green body. I still have it. This was a great video
I liked the video. I am an old guy now, but years ago, when I was working my way through college (so I didn’t have any debt, lol) I had a job cutting out window parts, running a miter saw. We went through tapes (and drills). Interestingly enough, our two best tapes were Lufkin and Stanley (in that order). I used Lufkin for years after that. Now I own Stanley, but only because that was what happened to be available when I needed to buy a new one. Just in case you might be interested, we eventually came to use only Makita drills. They left all others in the dust. That was more than 45 years ago though. Most tools (name brand tools) seem better made now than then.
Awesome test. I have moved to a LUFKIN Black Widow. The hi-viz blade is REALLY easy on the eyes. I have not had any issue with it, but I have not used it setting forms, or real framing yet. More to come after I knock the new off it.
Ever tried a Lukin Multiread tape? The centre measurements include the tape body for when measuring between walls etc. I've used many different brands, and the Multiread is the best on the market in my opinion
I've been getting into different tapes for different needs and environments, which generally leaves me with my favorite being babied. Which I'll never complain about.
I looked at all of those tape measures at Home Depot. All of them were missing an important feature the other had. I went with Mulwark and am quite happy.
Back in the 80's the sanitary piping job I had everybody had a Stanley 30"er, I got to like the Stanley Leverlock even though it only came in 25'. In the 90's I got a job in a union Millwright shop and the first thing I noticed was everybody had a Craftsman tape measure. There were made in America back then and when they broke you just took them back to Sears and they gave you a brand new one. ;-) As many tape measures as that 40 man shop kept taking back was probably the downfall of Sears. ;-)
I I'm an a electrical Apprentice and I use a FatMax. I'm constantly on a scissor lift and occasionally had dropped my tape measure. It seemed to have always stood up to the drop and work perfectly afterwards. As apprentice who can't always afford to keep buying new tools I definitely recommend for new apprentices to look into buying a Stanley FatMax.
I’ve been using a Milwaukee 25’ magnetic for well over a year now. It’s my second one bc the first one’s blade snapped after about a year of service. It’s a great tape and it measures faster bc it’s red ;)
Back in my framing days, the FatMax was the only one, but now in the shop I carry my 16’ Komelon daily and for the money cant be beat. Nice vid guys, nice work.
Stanley fat max is the best overall and has been for probably a decade now. I can't remember how long ago I bought my first one. It simply has the longest reach for wood framing applications, most durable on the jobsite and has quick recoil. I almost switched to Dewalt last year and would have because I liked using their tapes, but I broke two in a single month which never happens with the fatmax.
To me the most important is how it fits in the tool pouch. Always used Stanley not the fatmax. It's too wide but now I use Milwaukee has a nice feel. Always make sure the apprentice had the same tape cause they can vary a 1/16
I absolutely agree with you, that the fit in the pouch of the tool belt is prime. It has to go in fast and easy, retrieve fast and easy. good readability, get rid of the 32nd scale, My choice over the years is the Lufkin 16' tape. Rarely did I need a 25' tape unless for layout, and most of the time the 16' did fine for that. The 25s jamb up too easy and you spend time playing with the thing. On critical inside to inside measures I use a zigzag with a metal slide out extension. Started in trade school with them and have always used em for accuracy.
I measure frameless shower glass for a living. Lots of inside measurement where rolling the tape is not accurate enough. The width of the tape body is critical for easy math on inside measures where you add the body to the extended tape to get the exact measure. The Stanley FatMax 16' Autolock is exactly 3 inches wide, which allows for quick math. You would be surprised how many tapes have random width bodies or don't sit flat against the surface you butt it against to measure between two surfaces. Please include this test in your next comparison.
RT S lufkin have a tape that has a center scale on the blade that includes the tapes case. You simply read the center scale at the case when you butt the case to say “a wall” and measure out. I use it for fix out and things like rafters etc etc very very handy......... very easy to confuse apprentices with it hahaha
@@tristanpatterson3843 I own two Bosch GLR 225s. This laser tape doesn't have the accuracy and repeatability that a quality tape does. I rarely get the same reading twice from the same position. For this reason I don't trust it for fine finish work. They are great for rough measures though. Maybe there are better units out there for exacting work.
No more Fatmax for me... I learned a long time ago, have several sized tapes. No need to carry a heavy 30' tape for most finish work. I also learned that I've never cut an 8' sheet good that was longer than (wait for it) 8', so I keep a 12' Stanley in my pocket. On top of that, most of the work I did didn't need me to extend my tape out longer than 16". I keep a 30' for exterior work and framing. But gone are the days of the one tape to rule them all. I gave up on Fatmaxes. There was a time that they all failed at the 4' mark for some reason, plus it was like lifting a dumbbell after a while and one drop and they'd go to crap. I did however love their operation; Smooth as silk, like if it had ball bearings in it. Oh man, and when those things reeled back in, watch out or you'd get whiplashed! LOL Tajimas...the best (at least when they were being made in Japan). Love them. Light, easy to read, durable, took a beatin' and well priced. In fact, Tajima makes a few outside-of-the-box thinking tools.
Couldn't agree more. I was on the fatmax train for a long while, then lufkin. I won't go back since i've found tajima. Light, easy to read, Belt clip lasts, it always retracts and it can take a beating.
I just noticed the other day and that my Stanley FatMax had survived over an entire year on an industrial jobsite, to have the blade start to tear the very next day. In my trade experience the FatMax has always been the preferred choice of my peers. But my dad always always always use the lufkin's. Amazing through review
Yep I loved how well done his review was, but I cringed each time he mispronounced the name of the Korean tape measure. I have the Komelon myself, and it's an awesome tape measure, although probably not up to the vaunted Fat Max.
@@Gunners_Mate_Guns dont be fooled the premium model at walmart $15 for a 35 foot tape and extends almost as far as fat max. $15 at lowes will only get you a 25ft crapsman
@@whoodiestyle To be fair, my Komelon is a different model. I'm sure it's not the best tape measure, but it's very nice. Rugged and has a nice retract.
Wow what a great thorough test protocol you used, thanks! I have the FatMax and I agree it’s beefy. It took me a while to get used its button operation but it’s ok. I appreciate it now after seeing your recoil tests.
I'll have to check out the fat max. The Kom Pro W6725 has been my favorite for years but it gave up the ghost tonight, spring broke. Spent close to an hour looking for a replacement or parts to repair it with no luck, however, I stumbled upon this video. I haven't cared for the ergonomics of the fat max when borrowed but I'm sure I can adapt. Thanks for sharing this well made video! It is obvious that you did quite a bit of testing and research.
I usually use the blue komelon tape for when I'm fabricating granite and a fatmax when I do tile. Both are good. The blue komelon is stainless and doesn't rust while I use water fabricating, the fatmax will only last me a month while the komelon lasts me a year. The fatmax is an awesome tape.
This is great. What an exhaustive set of testing you guys did. Thanks for taking the time to do all this, I bet it was kinda fun too though. Where I live, my tape has to have metric and SAE, which is super annoying when you need to line up a measurement on the near side, for example, in inches - but that side happens to have the metric scale on it. What a pain in the ass.
Yeah I've used them exclusively for about 9 or 10 yrs now. They perform predictably right up until the tape breaks. I go at least a season on one tape. I got a new DeWalt for Xmas.. but it sucks lol I wanted to like it cause I'm a DeWalt guy but I just don't like it compared to the fat max
Yeah they used to last me for a long time up until they switched to that metal piece under the blade seems like they did that on purpose as the plastic piece that was there worked fine and now I notice l lose the coating on the bottom of the blade quick planned obsolescence me thinks
Paul Hopkins well I I guess I've been using a fat max for so long it doesn't bother me I was waiting on the truck at home depot to get one so about 14 years so I would say I've made 2 or 3
im an electrician that does high rise slab. so i need a 30m tape for layout and it gets the shit kicked out of it, i prefer my milwaulkee tape for that, and for inside finishing stuff i use my klein tape. dewalts always mess up on me, and i just dont buy stanely because everyone else has one and thats how they get stolen by accident. HOWEVER regarding the lufkin, when i was in my teens i worked an equestrian horse jumping facility and we built the courses in sandy dirt, and to measure the jump height nothing beat lufkin in those conditions
I love the Stanley 25 foot tape measure, but my favorite of that is the Stanley Lever Lock. So easy to control the rewind. I don't buy anything else. I worked in a cabinet shop as a millman, and my Parts kept coming up too long, with guys coming back to trim the pieces. My boss came out, and had us pull 4 tapes side by side, and within 4 feet, the Lufkin was off 1/4". It was brand new.Threw it away and never bought another one. But where the Lever Lock really shines, is in the field framing. Used a 25 and 30 foot Lever Lock for over 30 years. When framing, every movement counts. I don't want to be balancing 3 stories up on a 2" x 4" wall, trying to work buttons. Just squeeze the lever.
As an apprentice metal stud Framer I used fat max but have since graduated up to the Milwaukee Magnetic 25’ tape measure and simply love it. When it breaks I just take it back to Home Depot and replace it, no questions asked. Maybe I will retry a fat max next time.
No way was it too in depth. People who use a tape to the extreme everyday need and want all of this information. The job comes to a screeching halt when a measure breaks.
I know it might not have been much of a difference, but for the magnetic strength test you should have weighed the tape measures as well. It was also having to support that weight as well hanging from the ceiling.
i like the thoroughness of these videos but for this one i would say the best tape measure is the one with the best warranty because no matter what any tape you get is going to break and its our number one tool in any industry. I am a union Sheet Metal worker and i have bought 1 tape measure and have never had to buy a new one, i bought a Kobalt due to it having a lifetime warranty meaning i dont have to wait for a replacement from stanley, i can walk into a lowes grab one off the shelf show my original and im out the door with my new one, if the magnet comes loose or loses the magnet, if it snaps or is cracking whatever the issue they replace it no questions asked and for that it is my only pick without question.
finally a video about something I can afford lol.
They’ll do track saws next week don’t worry
25 feet or less any longer and it's out of my budget ;)
Lol
😬😬
Joe Boxter hey at least you have a tape.
I use a long string . I have to tie knots every foot. It’s really a bitch.
I always used lufkin tapes because every body else semmed to have stanley so my tape didn't get legs and walk off the job as easy.
Walk off the job lol don't you have a tool belt and if your not taking tools home youd have to have a lock box
@@slipperygypsy1366 well where I work, people have a station that might as well be their own home workshop, well depending on the importance of the employee anyway, and people come and take our shit off of our benches, that's why we do this thing called engraving our tools, handy when someone decides your chalk line would be more useful to them
lmao! Great idea.
Jack Braddell Bernie Sanders?
LOL me too! I thought it was only me! They work great, almost nobody else has them and they're not that expensive.
Finally! Great review guys! Time stamps below
1:56 recoil test
4:00 wear of tape coating
7:10 magnetic testing
9:41 debris testing
11:05 stand out
11:48 hook movement
14:09 ergonomics
16:30 readability
18:11 drop tests
19:48 pricing
20:14 best overall
Federer2001 you da real MVP.
Thank you sir
Federer2001 ZZ
Not all heroes wear capes!
Federer2001 w
Used Lufkins since the beginning, on & off for 40yrs. Use one now but regular Stanley Powerlock has been my go-to for a long time. Comfort in hand, works good for a long time & available everywhere at a decent price, are the reasons. You reviews are the best. No stupid BS drama, no ridiculous claims, just intelligent & straight forward info.
I bought the Fat Max at Lowe's on Black Friday. 2 for $20. Stupid me took the belt clip off to shove into a tape pouch and lost the screw. I asked Stanley if they could send a replacement. They could not, but sent a whole new tape instead. That is ridiculously kind customer service.
lier
@@ssbt2018 spell properly before you call names lol
Ssafi Bishara, nice work hat douchebag...
Lufkin has a new one out with a 14 foot standout
@therockkkkher its callwd the lufkin shock force. Its on youtube. I havent seen it for sale anywhere
This Video is absolutely the most useful tape measure comparison and review. It is comprehensive, highly informative and most importantly... Over 33 years of jobsite conversation debating the merits of tape measures with every newbie, it goes beyond opinion and provides testers results. One note though, I was taught to never extend a tape more than 2/3rd or 3/4th the length as a general rule. My preference for 20 years was Lufkin 30' but the Fatmax 25' found everywhere, has been on my hip for the last 10.
I've been doing construction for 14 years now. I'm a fatmax fan through and through. For my home shop I tend to lean toward my Lufkin cause it's a good price and doesn't need to be as tough cause it's not out in the elements. Thanks for the review
Such a thorough testing process. Every gripe and issue I've ever had with a tape measure was thought of in this testing process. I'm decades into my career and have tried dozens of brands. Thank you for this great video! Keep up the amazing work.
I'm dyslexic and I didn't realize it for years. My go too TAPE was the Stanley Fatmax after doing a trim job and realizing I had alot of waste because of inversion of numbers, I started looking toward solutions and I found Fastcap. Your toolreveiws are so valuable to me that they have swayed purchase decision solely on your reveiw and your product and field knowledge. Based on that I think you might want to give Fastcap a buzz and have them send some tools out they're a tool solution company. Try the tapes and have them send you a fat boy pencil ( b careful everyone will steal it on the site) give them a try we might have another convert . Thanks again for all the great reveiws .
Diesel B813 I’m also dyslexic and I also prefer the FastCap.
I work in a metal fabrication shop and I use the Stanley Leverlock most often but the coating wears fast. I only use the Stanley Fatmax for the bigger jobs (mainly cause it is bulky and the magnet picks up too much metal dust) but it's hands down the most durable beast of a tape measure I've ever used. All of our machinist use Lufkin tape measures for their accuracy, but they're no where near as rough on their tapes as we are.
Easily one of the most informational tool comparisons i have ever seen. Super helpful video. Glad the FatMax won cause I've been buying the PowerLock for years and love Stanley tapes
When my grandfather passed, the first thing I grabbed from his garage was a Stanley tape measure circa early 70s. He beat the crap out of it - cement contractor. I still use it today, and when I'm not using it, it sits on my mantle above my fireplace in remembrance. He was the best and so are Stanley's!
In my 35 years I’ve used Stanley and Dewalt, now I use Lufkin 16’ ( I’m a cabinet / trim guy), exclusively because they have the best longevity and the blackface both sides, is easiest to read by far, also best palm feel. Great vid Rob as always
I may buy a lufkin after viewing this. I am a Dewalt guy through and through I use that extended reach all the time and they are so damn comfortable to use
Crescent lufkin night eyes g2 25’ for for the win
Most intensive testing of tape measures on the TH-cam Universe ... you guys are special ! I mean that as a true compliment. So much fun to watch.
rhino ranchThank you brother, have you seen our other head to head tests? We have one coming out this Sunday as well
@@ConcordCarpenter Wow, thanks for the reply. I have watched many of your excellent videos. Thoroughly enjoy 'em. I clicked the bell, so now I will keep up with all new videos. Thanks... have a Great Thanksgiving
@@Clambelly Thanks
Stanley would be smart to use that description! Their customers would get it and likely appreciate that kinda thing. A good sense of humor is excellent marketing!
Have used the Fat Max for years and finally switched to the Milwaukee. For the simple reason that I like the belt clip better. All tapes wear out it’s just part of it. The thing that I hate is when the clip spins or scratches me because of wear. Only had the Milwaukee for a couple months but I’ve grown to love it even more then the Fat Max and I would have never thought that could be possible!
The main problem I have with tape measures is when they get wet from working in the rain. The recoil deteriorates and the markings rub away causing rust. I get through at least 5 tape measures a year. A water resistant tape measure would be a god send here in England.
I have that problem too, I applied silicone spray to my tape as it’s a lube that won’t attract dirt. Then I discovered both Stanley and Komelon have made stainless steel tapes. Really good in the wet, however when they bend it’s difficult to get that kink out.
Fatmax is the best
I totally agree with you there. I had the same experience when working out in the yard, until my tape got caught in between some timbers and it was bent out of shape so easily, less than 7 days. Furthermore, while working out in the rain, it corroded more quickly than the cost of buying it.
I use a Powerlock. At least with those I can just replace the blades for cheap rather than having to replace the whole thing.
Butters 1786 I used to have the same problem, move to Australia and a tape will last nearly 2 years
This is reassuring. I've been using Stanley for years almost exclusively. I use Stanley for a reason that you didn't even address. I use Stanley because on most job sites Stanley is the most common tape used by almost every professional, and Stanely's tolerances are pretty consistent. That means that if I make a measurement, and then someone comes along behind me with a Stanley Tape, they will get the same measurement. That is usually not true if some (or I) come behind someone using a different brand of tape measure. It doesn't matter if I'm working alone from start to finish, but oftentimes (when working off of prints) more than one person is taking measurements. Stanley has practically no variance from tape to tape. I just thought that I'd give you something to consider. I really like your channel. Thank You for the good content.
Well done. Great tests, and great presentation. I've had the Dewalt tape for several months now, and it's held up really well to my abuse. My next tape will probably be that mag tip Fatmax though! Thanks for the great review!
FISCO BIG-T tapes are awesome. I am a cabinet and furniture maker and the Fisco Big-T tapes are all I use. They used to be called Johnson "Big Johnson" tapes, but Fisco Big-T is what to look for now. Yes, I posted twice on this. I go out of my way to let people know about these tapes. No, I have no stock in them, I just like them. Before the Big-T tapes, I used a 16' Lufkin with the Stanley magnetic attachment quick-draw mechanism.
Like you I have always bought the Stanley. I never even thought to buy another until watching this review. Although it didn’t place in the top 2 the Milwaukee has my attention with the features and the scale rule in the back. Thank you for your videos and great content. Stay safe out there
I've been running the Fatmax for 10+ years n the best part is a localy owned hardware store where I'm from exchanges the tapes for free, so when our tape starts running rough or has a slight bend to it we just snap the end off, exchange it n buy a new scratch pad. Love the vids, keep up the great work!!
I definatly agree with this video. I use a Fat Max at work in a heavy steel production shop. We calibrate every 3 months. I have never had to replace a tape because of the hook going out of whack. I only have to replace my tape when when it gets all nasty and full of crap like metal dust, coolant and oil. Or sometimes I do something stupid like measure near a torch flame and melt the markings off lol. People keep your eyes peeled at Home Depot they have a 2 pack of 25' Fat Max tapes for the price of a single. Seems to be around Christmas every year.
Geoff Moore ONLY TOME I BUY !!!!!!!!!😂👍🏼🎶🎶🇨🇱🖖🖖
I have used them all and they all will do the job. I have a Kutir now and it works fine.
This side-by-side test was exhaustive and extremely accurate, thanks for a great job guys!
I’ve been scaffolding for 10 years and had two Stanley Fatmax tapes, my first one lasted about 8 years and I am currently on my second one. I find the tape very good for my job and after watching this video I will buy another one when needed.
Lufkin classic all the way. Accurate measurement every time the end never gets bent on drops. Super durable and only 5$. 15 years I’ve been using them. Switched from Stanley and I’ll never go back
My Stanley lever lock has started to fail by not recouping all the way unless I extend almost all of the tape and reel it back in. I was looking at my options and happened across this video in my feed. Looks like I'm getting another Stanley. Great job on the presentation and data collection.
the chrome Stanley is a favorite of mine. No fancy bells and whistles. Just clear marking tough tape. Great video by the way.
“Essential craftsman”. said his choice is a Stanley; years in the trades and experience, I trust his advice -all his advise has been accurate so far.
I have several Stanley’s I’ve had for years.. I’m not a professional, but I do use them a lot.
Fat max is the best boyyyyy all I’ve ever bought hands down my favorite! Glad to know I pick them well!
Love the channel. No hype. Just solid, organized thoughts. Bought a Fat Max. Thanks!!!
Yeah! Stanley tape measure devices are pretty good. I have been using the power lock model for years. Excellent review Bob, keep it on!
The Cobalt tape measures from Lowes are made by Komelon. Lowes offers a lifetime replacement warranty, for any reason. I've replaced one in the past 3 years, without issue. While the tapes are more readable, they are more fragile than the Fatmax.
Most of my tapes are the Stanley Fatmax, but I keep one or two of the Cobalt tapes around if I'm doing fine work. Plus they have nice magnetic tips. The Stanley magnets are hokey. The magnetic tip is really nice when working with metal framing and taking measurements on commercial projects where metal is widely used.
My favorite general purpose tapes were the Stanley Fatmax with the chrome case and wide hook. Those were phenomenal for framing work and measuring on site. They would hook and hold well with that large hook, and the famous Fatmax standout was great for those purposes. Especially on a ladder trying to get a measurement. The thinner tapes just fall a few times, leaving you aggravated. I have one 16' chrome case left in my truck that I'm taking care of like it's priceless, but I use it weekly.
All in all, I currently have 4 tapes either in my box or on the truck at any given time.
16' Fatmax chrome cased
25' Fatmax
25' Cobalt
30' Fatmax
They are all used for different reasons. Like any tool in the toolbox, they each have their purpose.
I liked Milwaukee’s old magnetic tape. It had 2 magnets one for the end like they still have now. And on that face down so it could stick to a pipe or metal that way.
yes still have a few of these, visibly better than the replacement.
Yesss!!!!! Those where the best
FishFind3000 I liked side hook as well. New gen 2 sits on pipe better though
Ya that's the one I had i didn't rebuy a Milwaukee tape when I needed one because they were different and I went back to the basic Stanley 25'
Just found your site and have so far watched a few comparison tests between different manufacturers. So far I'm very impressed, have subscribed and will definitely be coming back. Thanks.
I have the STANLEY "Write-On" 25' tape measure. What I like about it is that all the scales are numbered except the 16th scales. This tape measure are for those who can't remember the fraction scales in standard unit of measure. Which is why metric scale is much easier.
The USA just couldn't adopt metric. Literally everyone else uses metric and it is hella easy.
I've had two 30' Stanley power lock tapes since 1997 when I started my business and they've really held up. They're also not very rigid at all anymore and when I saw a 25' Milwaukee on clearance for 12 bucks, it was mine. However, I really do need a Fatmax. Most days I work alone and the Fatmax is really helpful when you measure solo.
These reviews are awesome!!! Never thought you’d be able to compare a tape measure to that level but it was actually pretty interesting. I called the fat max winning from the start, but’s it’s nice to have your biases confirmed :)
I’m currently trying the DeWalt tape but I’ve been using a Stanley for 20 years! Can’t beat them!
I love my Klein tape for electrical work when I’m bending pipe. If I ever forget how much to multiply for the degrees, it gives a chart on the back
Dylan Elder yes the conduit bending chart is awesome for you guys
You don't need a tape measure for that. On alot of greenlee benders the multiplier is on the head of the bender. One side has degrees other side has the multiplier
Or just memorize it! It's only like 3 numbers, and one of them is 2!
Also it's nice to have the lifetime warranty, if I am ever dumb and break my klein tools I take it to home depot and do a 1 for 1 swap and am out in 5 minutes. I think they should have taken that to consideration.
Courtney Sutherlin Greenlee, Ideal, and Klein benders all have the multiplier on one side and the angle on the other, but the Klein tape measure also has the shrink charts which fall off the handles of all the benders. For electrical work where most of your measurements are under 10’, the fatmax is just too big, heavy and bulky, however I do recognize that it is more durable.
I've always rocked the beefier 8m dewalt tape working as an industrial carpenter. Great testing but I'll stick to what served me well over many years
i bought a Milwaukee tape like the one in this video and it almost immediately stopped retracting itself and getting jammed up. I also hated the belt clip, and the end clip got loose real fast. I know its only my experience but i would not buy one again. I replaced it with a Fat Max and that tape is awesome, its held up well the last couple years. Its super tough, stands out far (i remodeled my house alone so i needed that) and it has yet to get jammed, even though it gets full of drywall and saw dust.
My Stanley FatMax (33-725 25) fricken broke the first week of having it. I literally span out like 15’ or so, and its really good to know that pulling it out so far can damage the tape, but it got jammed in a strange way, and literally wouldn’t wind up. Mind you now, it was a 25’. Now i’ve been using those new Craftsman tape measures. (CMHT37625S) So far, 8 months in, and its been the best tape measure i’ve ever had.
I'm surprised you didn't use the regular Fatmax. I tried the magnetic one and had major issues. Fatmax (regular) is all we use on our jobsite.
Im sure its still an amazing tape - just minus the magnet
Noconz0727 MC I agree! Had the regular fat max for years, thought I would give the magnetic one a try. Nothing but issues. Right back to the regular!
Been using fat Max for years, rough and finish work. I love the easy to read tape.
I've had the magnet stay stuck on a piece of iron and pop out. There you go its a regular Fatmax lol
Everyone knows the fat max is the best tape on the market.
DAY-um!
I'd never have wondered about differences between tape measures, and as I've come to expect you showed me things I'd never have considered.
Always liked the Fatmax. My preference was always the 30', as quite often I was measuring just over 25'. The last tape I bought was a Kobalt 30' - not particularly durable. Decent standout, the magnet was okay, but quality of materials was sub-par.
Great video, confirms what every tradesman knows- Fatmax is number 1!
I can’t say one’s better than the other, but my Stanley fatmax was dropped from 20-25 ft and still works perfectly. I work in construction so it handles harsh conditions daily
It's a great comparison definitely. Though I am using a komelon tape at the moment at work and it's held up to work in the metal industry very well so far.
My favorite tape measure is the free one from Harbor Freight that they offer with a coupon. It is a half inch wide tape by 25 feet. Never had a problem with it and I must have a dozen around the house. I pick one up every time I am there.
I loved watching you destroy all the tape measures that I hate.
I've been using the Fat Max since it was first introduced, still my favorite.
I've been back and forth on tapes, but for the past year I've been using Lufkin Shockforce almost entirely. The main reason is the gritted hook, which absolutely grips PVC and plastic pipe so easily (I'm a plumber, and I cant tell you how many times I've hooked an end of a pipe to measure a cut only to have the hook fall off with other tapes). It hooks once and doesn't fall off until you want it to. I love the feel of it, the double sided blade, the horizontal lettering on one side but vertical on the other, and the absolute rigidity that it has, because it is definitely the stoutest tape I've ever had (second would be the Milwaukee stud). This is my second Lufkin this year, but not because the first broke. I actually lost it. I want to try the shockforce black widow for its black blade with neon green markings, because working in new crawlspaces can get dark.
I have be running the same milwaukie for about 5 years now. Before that I had a lufkin for about 3 years. Before that it was always Stanley power or level lock.
Yup, been using Fat Max’s for years so it’s good to know I chose well but I learned about some other features that I will go looking for next time. Very impressed with two sided numbers, high visibility scales and less damaging belt clips. Great info….keep reviewing and comparing tools that don’t break the bank.
Great channel and you do a great informative presentation with reviews, well done, it's great for us tradesmen who utilize tools all day everyday, cheers fellas, well done.
I have a Lufkin 16' tape measure. Have had this thing for years. Also, have a tape i picked up at wal mart, Hyper Tough 25'. Works for what i need it for. Worked on a rough-in crew a couple of years( '97-98'). Had a stanley 25' but lost it, or someone thought they needed it more than i did.
You guys are freakin awesome!! I was leaning toward the FatMax, but only based on a few key features. You made it no-brainer for me. THANKS!
First video I’ve seen, I already love this channel. Can’t wait to see what else you guys have worked with and tested.
Welcome aboard!
As a stainless steel pipe fitter I’ve gone through dozens of tape measures. Stanley fatmax was the best and lasted the longest. Would accurately stretch to 10 feet without bowing which made fitting fast and easy. Fatmax hands down reigns supreme.
i replaced my fatmaxes wtih milwaukee... nothing wrong with fatmax, milwaukee is just lighter and more compact package with similar performance...
i also like tajima but theyre lighter duty... komelon broke the first day under light use, the tape is like paper...
I used to work for a steel company and we would go through a tape like every other month. They would get oily, dirty, cut, dropped. The one that was the best was a Stanley. It had a green body. I still have it. This was a great video
I love how thorough these tests are!
Same here
I liked the video. I am an old guy now, but years ago, when I was working my way through college (so I didn’t have any debt, lol) I had a job cutting out window parts, running a miter saw. We went through tapes (and drills). Interestingly enough, our two best tapes were Lufkin and Stanley (in that order). I used Lufkin for years after that. Now I own Stanley, but only because that was what happened to be available when I needed to buy a new one. Just in case you might be interested, we eventually came to use only Makita drills. They left all others in the dust. That was more than 45 years ago though. Most tools (name brand tools) seem better made now than then.
Awesome test. I have moved to a LUFKIN Black Widow. The hi-viz blade is REALLY easy on the eyes. I have not had any issue with it, but I have not used it setting forms, or real framing yet. More to come after I knock the new off it.
Ever tried a Lukin Multiread tape? The centre measurements include the tape body for when measuring between walls etc. I've used many different brands, and the Multiread is the best on the market in my opinion
This is my kind of video... Never been a fan of the Stanley but will definitely give it another look. I do use the numbers on the bottom a lot though.
I've been using dewalt tapes for a couple years now and no complaints. Great videos, you guys should test knee pads in one of your next videos.
I've been getting into different tapes for different needs and environments, which generally leaves me with my favorite being babied. Which I'll never complain about.
I used fatmax for years but recently tried and am using the Milwaukee. I find it more comfortable to work with
I looked at all of those tape measures at Home Depot. All of them were missing an important feature the other had. I went with Mulwark and am quite happy.
Back in the 80's the sanitary piping job I had everybody had a Stanley 30"er, I got to like the Stanley Leverlock even though it only came in 25'. In the 90's I got a job in a union Millwright shop and the first thing I noticed was everybody had a Craftsman tape measure. There were made in America back then and when they broke you just took them back to Sears and they gave you a brand new one. ;-) As many tape measures as that 40 man shop kept taking back was probably the downfall of Sears. ;-)
nope it was amazon......again
lil help from wallly mart
OscarWhiskeyFoxtrot what’s a “union millwright shop”? I’m in Australia never heard of one
i am a sucker for the old school powerlock, simple no frills tape measure
Nathan P me too
Every time I need a new tape I look at all my options and end up with another trusty FatMax.
I I'm an a electrical Apprentice and I use a FatMax. I'm constantly on a scissor lift and occasionally had dropped my tape measure. It seemed to have always stood up to the drop and work perfectly afterwards. As apprentice who can't always afford to keep buying new tools I definitely recommend for new apprentices to look into buying a Stanley FatMax.
I’ve been using a Milwaukee 25’ magnetic for well over a year now. It’s my second one bc the first one’s blade snapped after about a year of service. It’s a great tape and it measures faster bc it’s red ;)
Back in my framing days, the FatMax was the only one, but now in the shop I carry my 16’ Komelon daily and for the money cant be beat. Nice vid guys, nice work.
Stanley fat max all the way. Been using them for 16 years now.
Stanley fat max is the best overall and has been for probably a decade now. I can't remember how long ago I bought my first one. It simply has the longest reach for wood framing applications, most durable on the jobsite and has quick recoil.
I almost switched to Dewalt last year and would have because I liked using their tapes, but I broke two in a single month which never happens with the fatmax.
To me the most important is how it fits in the tool pouch. Always used Stanley not the fatmax. It's too wide but now I use Milwaukee has a nice feel. Always make sure the apprentice had the same tape cause they can vary a 1/16
Hey as long as you're the one that buys him the same tape as yours
I absolutely agree with you, that the fit in the pouch of the tool belt is prime. It has to go in fast and easy, retrieve fast and easy. good readability, get rid of the 32nd scale, My choice over the years is the Lufkin 16' tape. Rarely did I need a 25' tape unless for layout, and most of the time the 16' did fine for that. The 25s jamb up too easy and you spend time playing with the thing. On critical inside to inside measures I use a zigzag with a metal slide out extension. Started in trade school with them and have always used em for accuracy.
I use mostly Milwaukee tools but my tape measure is a Stanley. They've been making them forever and I've never had a problem with them.
I measure frameless shower glass for a living. Lots of inside measurement where rolling the tape is not accurate enough. The width of the tape body is critical for easy math on inside measures where you add the body to the extended tape to get the exact measure. The Stanley FatMax 16' Autolock is exactly 3 inches wide, which allows for quick math. You would be surprised how many tapes have random width bodies or don't sit flat against the surface you butt it against to measure between two surfaces. Please include this test in your next comparison.
RT S, Very good point. will have to try it, Thanks.
Get a laser.
This is the reason why I always carry the 16' FatMax
RT S lufkin have a tape that has a center scale on the blade that includes the tapes case. You simply read the center scale at the case when you butt the case to say “a wall” and measure out. I use it for fix out and things like rafters etc etc very very handy......... very easy to confuse apprentices with it hahaha
@@tristanpatterson3843 I own two Bosch GLR 225s. This laser tape doesn't have the accuracy and repeatability that a quality tape does. I rarely get the same reading twice from the same position. For this reason I don't trust it for fine finish work. They are great for rough measures though. Maybe there are better units out there for exacting work.
I use a fat max because whenever it wears out I can take it to Lowe's or Menards and get a replacement completely free and its a great tape.
No more Fatmax for me...
I learned a long time ago, have several sized tapes. No need to carry a heavy 30' tape for most finish work. I also learned that I've never cut an 8' sheet good that was longer than (wait for it) 8', so I keep a 12' Stanley in my pocket. On top of that, most of the work I did didn't need me to extend my tape out longer than 16". I keep a 30' for exterior work and framing. But gone are the days of the one tape to rule them all.
I gave up on Fatmaxes. There was a time that they all failed at the 4' mark for some reason, plus it was like lifting a dumbbell after a while and one drop and they'd go to crap. I did however love their operation; Smooth as silk, like if it had ball bearings in it. Oh man, and when those things reeled back in, watch out or you'd get whiplashed! LOL
Tajimas...the best (at least when they were being made in Japan). Love them. Light, easy to read, durable, took a beatin' and well priced. In fact, Tajima makes a few outside-of-the-box thinking tools.
Couldn't agree more. I was on the fatmax train for a long while, then lufkin. I won't go back since i've found tajima. Light, easy to read, Belt clip lasts, it always retracts and it can take a beating.
Yankee Sure your name isn’t “Uncle James” ??
He ALSO would not p/u a pencil !!!!! Said it took too long !!😂 Kept 4-5 in his pocket !
😂👍🏼🖖🖖🎶🎶🇨🇱
I just noticed the other day and that my Stanley FatMax had survived over an entire year on an industrial jobsite, to have the blade start to tear the very next day. In my trade experience the FatMax has always been the preferred choice of my peers. But my dad always always always use the lufkin's. Amazing through review
It's not chameleon, it's Komelon. Short for Korea Motorized Electron. Nothing to do with lizards.
Ha ha, yeah. I was wondering where he was getting that from too.
My go to tape measure..lightweight and good visibility
Yep
I loved how well done his review was, but I cringed each time he mispronounced the name of the Korean tape measure.
I have the Komelon myself, and it's an awesome tape measure, although probably not up to the vaunted Fat Max.
@@Gunners_Mate_Guns dont be fooled the premium model at walmart $15 for a 35 foot tape and extends almost as far as fat max. $15 at lowes will only get you a 25ft crapsman
@@whoodiestyle To be fair, my Komelon is a different model.
I'm sure it's not the best tape measure, but it's very nice.
Rugged and has a nice retract.
Wow what a great thorough test protocol you used, thanks! I have the FatMax and I agree it’s beefy. It took me a while to get used its button operation but it’s ok. I appreciate it now after seeing your recoil tests.
Milwaukee all the way, I love it! I carry a 16ft pretty much everyday 👍🏼
Why 16ft. They are useless
@@BarukHabaBShemYahuah I do glass and the 16' is where it's at for me. I use a 25' when I'm framing or doing carpentry.
I'll have to check out the fat max. The Kom Pro W6725 has been my favorite for years but it gave up the ghost tonight, spring broke. Spent close to an hour looking for a replacement or parts to repair it with no luck, however, I stumbled upon this video. I haven't cared for the ergonomics of the fat max when borrowed but I'm sure I can adapt.
Thanks for sharing this well made video! It is obvious that you did quite a bit of testing and research.
Fat max is the way man I’ve been beating them up for years
I usually use the blue komelon tape for when I'm fabricating granite and a fatmax when I do tile. Both are good. The blue komelon is stainless and doesn't rust while I use water fabricating, the fatmax will only last me a month while the komelon lasts me a year. The fatmax is an awesome tape.
I like my klein, double sided markings, bold lines every 1/8 inch, smooth lock and rugged
You must have the 30 footer ??
Not that rugged apparently.. thing blew up in the drop test- dead last of all of the ones tested.. they do make a nice tape tho..
This is great.
What an exhaustive set of testing you guys did. Thanks for taking the time to do all this, I bet it was kinda fun too though. Where I live, my tape has to have metric and SAE, which is super annoying when you need to line up a measurement on the near side, for example, in inches - but that side happens to have the metric scale on it. What a pain in the ass.
Not surprised the fat max won, definitely the best tape out there.
Yeah I've used them exclusively for about 9 or 10 yrs now. They perform predictably right up until the tape breaks. I go at least a season on one tape. I got a new DeWalt for Xmas.. but it sucks lol I wanted to like it cause I'm a DeWalt guy but I just don't like it compared to the fat max
Yeah they used to last me for a long time up until they switched to that metal piece under the blade seems like they did that on purpose as the plastic piece that was there worked fine and now I notice l lose the coating on the bottom of the blade quick planned obsolescence me thinks
Ya I would say the majority of carpenters use the fax max... And for a reason
Paul Hopkins never had a problem I just roll the tape a little to my side
Paul Hopkins well I I guess I've been using a fat max for so long it doesn't bother me I was waiting on the truck at home depot to get one so about 14 years so I would say I've made 2 or 3
im an electrician that does high rise slab. so i need a 30m tape for layout and it gets the shit kicked out of it, i prefer my milwaulkee tape for that, and for inside finishing stuff i use my klein tape. dewalts always mess up on me, and i just dont buy stanely because everyone else has one and thats how they get stolen by accident.
HOWEVER regarding the lufkin, when i was in my teens i worked an equestrian horse jumping facility and we built the courses in sandy dirt, and to measure the jump height nothing beat lufkin in those conditions
doing kitchen installs for 15 years only use 25' regular fatmax best tape for the money
I do walk in and sliding robes etc. Get a Lufkin Multiread and you'll never go back
You cap
I love the Stanley 25 foot tape measure, but my favorite of that is the Stanley Lever Lock. So easy to control the rewind. I don't buy anything else. I worked in a cabinet shop as a millman, and my Parts kept coming up too long, with guys coming back to trim the pieces. My boss came out, and had us pull 4 tapes side by side, and within 4 feet, the Lufkin was off 1/4". It was brand new.Threw it away and never bought another one. But where the Lever Lock really shines, is in the field framing. Used a 25 and 30 foot Lever Lock for over 30 years. When framing, every movement counts. I don't want to be balancing 3 stories up on a 2" x 4" wall, trying to work buttons. Just squeeze the lever.
I love lufkin tape measures only thing i use
Yay lufkin are great
As an apprentice metal stud Framer I used fat max but have since graduated up to the Milwaukee Magnetic 25’ tape measure and simply love it. When it breaks I just take it back to Home Depot and replace it, no questions asked. Maybe I will retry a fat max next time.
This was almost too in depth
No way was it too in depth. People who use a tape to the extreme everyday need and want all of this information. The job comes to a screeching halt when a measure breaks.
You can never be too in depth lmao
Hahahahaha!
yeah it was a bit much. if you use one hardcore everyday you know what you want. and if ya’ don’t have an extra tape or two then “get the fuck out”
Thanks
I know it might not have been much of a difference, but for the magnetic strength test you should have weighed the tape measures as well. It was also having to support that weight as well hanging from the ceiling.
The shorter Komeleon is my new favorite!
i like the thoroughness of these videos but for this one i would say the best tape measure is the one with the best warranty because no matter what any tape you get is going to break and its our number one tool in any industry. I am a union Sheet Metal worker and i have bought 1 tape measure and have never had to buy a new one, i bought a Kobalt due to it having a lifetime warranty meaning i dont have to wait for a replacement from stanley, i can walk into a lowes grab one off the shelf show my original and im out the door with my new one, if the magnet comes loose or loses the magnet, if it snaps or is cracking whatever the issue they replace it no questions asked and for that it is my only pick without question.