Please click the link to watch our other Weapon Detective videos th-cam.com/users/playlist?list... Please click the link to watch our other Weapon Detective-Sea videos th-cam.com/users/playlist?list...
In the P-15B class:- Electronic Warfare system, Gearbox, SONAR, Torpedoes, Combat Management System, IR suppression system, steel, ASW rockets, consoles, design, etc all completely Indian designed and built. Missiles are Jointly designed with foreign partner and manufactured in India. Main gun, CIWS, ASW rocket launcher all manufactured in India. Only radar and engines are directly imported. . In next generation Indian destroyers, other than the gas turbines and some parts of the IEP, everything else like radar, missiles, CIWS, etc will be completely Indian designed and built. Each of these sub-systems are already under developmental testing stage.
Amazing. India has never aggressively projected power. As far as I'm concerned, it's called the Indian Ocean for a reason and I'd rather have the Indian Navy out there than the Chinese. Pact with Japan, Taiwan, Vietnam, Micronesia & hurry. The world needs India.
Never do that it takes our government and bureaucrats ten years to approve weapon procurements the only reason we seem to be doing somewhat good is because we are big
@@bramha9680 As a Filipino I am aware that given India’s size, it’s weapons procurement is pretty slow. From the aging aircraft to the delays in the MBT project, there maybe some other problems I am not aware of. But hey, everybody has problems.
@@bramha9680 people like you takes our Country down. Until what time we will be truly independent??. This country needs reforms and change. You may be a slave but a substantial part of population of India are not slaves anymore. We want to fly high. Thankyou 🙏
@@philnightjar1971 we have one more problem, our Government officials have Girlfriend/Boyfriend outside India. Hope you understand the rest and the reason behind slow processing of orders.
Such accurate unbiased review on Indian Navy. "in possible Sino-Indian war, India must rely on its own; bcoz western countries would wait for this gigantic nations to wear out first". 🙌
India is a democracy, if your fighting communist china i'd say western countries and other asian countries would more than likely fight alongside india in a full blown war. Evrerybody hates the ccp these days
@@masterofpuppets7295 F the west and F China we'll deal with the Chinese first and then liberate Diego Garcia and hand it over to Mauritius it's all a matter of time 🖕
@@lipikamitra1481 lmao why would we attack the base of a friendly nation, with whom we have signed the Logistics pact we can take help of Diego Garcia base in times it's needed due to the pact.
@@pratiknath3267 thanks :) i think at least 6 of each class should have been built. These are powerful destroyers. Also think india shouldnt have decommisioned older destroyers and instead used them for anti-piracy operations in the indian ocean. They dont need to perform anti shipping roles but just some coastal defense and anti piracy. Maybe help with search and rescue operations, citizen rescues from indians living in the middle east, etc. They'd be quite good for support roles.
@Arup Ratan Mitra right thanks for correcting me. I still think more should be inducted to counter China. That and also more scorpene class submarines.
Great video which included past and present in detail of Indian Navy Destroyers. The Project 18 class of destroyers of Indian Navy will be a game changer as it will be around 12000/13000 tons in displacement with nearly 128/144 VLS and their will be 6 of them.
This really is a superb channel. For those interested and who can find it, _No Easy Answers_ by former chief of the Royal Australian Navy R.Adm. James Goldrick is a good read on the history of the subcontinent navies up to 1996 when it was published.
Actually I read the chinese mostly want to control the south china seas mainly. Indian ocean too, but that'll be tough in the presence of Indian navy and south east asian navies
I came to know lot of information regarding this great Indian class destroyer KOLKATA, thanks a lot sir as it make my day cause i belong to same named place also.
I liked the frankness and sincerity of the narration , because it openly admitted mechanical problems and construction delays , also , the overall clearness of the narrated history of the Indian navy .
@@prasadchaturdesale5795 Cooperation doesn't only mean in shipbuilding, but a broader cooperation in terms of countering China and other areas such as enforcing the rule of law in the Indian Ocean Region. Australia is important because while we can stop Chinese from crossing Malacca, unless Aussies stop them from crossing via Lombok or Sunda straits, we won't be able to limit Chinese forces in IOR.
My only gripe is that they manufacture only 3. I feel like they should produce more than 3 but i understand the money is the problem. However the vishakapatnam class is a very good destroyer
We also ha e very few shipbuilders so they r always full of order and it has its upside too rathar than printing the same stuff for 20 years we order small then after 10 years we order the upgraded version and so on
@@hritikjuyal5484 money isn't the only issue - mazagon docks(main destroyer-frigate builder) use russian method of ship which requires less skilled labour which takes long time to build a ship which intern increases cost Thankfully they are now testing building by blocks which is how Nilgiri class is build and that's why they have larger quantity order
*Dear Detective, below are the list Indigenous Indian weapon systems, can you please do your independent analysis of these platforms* 1. Light combat Fighter 'TEJAS' 2. BRAHMOS supersonic cruise missile 3. AKASH surface to air missile 4. New generation Anti Radiation Missile (RUDRAM) 5. PINAKA rocket MLRS 6. Beyond visual range air-to-air missile ‘Astra’ 7. Indian ASAT missile anti satellite 8. Advanced Towed Artillery Gun System (ATAGS) 9. Weapon Locating Radar (WLR) Swati 10. Dhruv is a utility helicopter 11. Light Combat Helicopter (LCH) is an Indian multi-role attack helicopter 12. Arihant-class submarine nuclear powered 13. NETRA AEW&C system 14. AGNI Ballistic missile systems
Very impressive Naval ship building program and the long operational experience is really very rare in Asia. The aggressive behemoth to the East is a manufacturing and technological power house will we see a global power realignment like it was back in 1000 CE? We live in interesting times.
I wish you had paid a bit more attention to and made a mention of India's ancient seafarers - the Cholas and their contemporaries from present-day Odisha. THEY were India's first naval powers.
One should take the Mach 2 figure for Barak-8 with a grain of salt. It is the officially published figure but it is an improbably low speed for such a missile to max out at, so I suspect some obfuscation is at play. Somewhere in ball park of Mach 3.5-4.5 is more likely.
@@mortified776 Nope, I don't think so, this dual pulse rocket motor was developed by India's Defence R&D organization named DRDO as part of the Indo-Israeli collaboration to develop the Barak 8. Rest of the missile was developed by IAI. The development of this dual pulse rocket motor has been a huge boon for several Indian defence projects like Next Generation Anti Radiation Missile(NGARM), Astra Mk2 BVR A2A missile, Akash-NG SAM system.
@@aniruddhamulay2932 India's missileers have indeed been prodigious. I remember back twenty years ago when DRDO was having a lot of problems with the Trishul point defense system for the IN. They of course ended up buying Barak 1 from the Israelis which I think is where the seeds of the Indo-Israeli joint missile initiative were planted if I am not mistaken. Sometimes failure leads to better things than you planned in the first place! I was glad to read recently that the IN's new point defence system recycles a lot of the Trishul work, so even that wasn't a waste after all!
@@aniruddhamulay2932 On reflection, it was also daft of me to think a country which has sent orbiters to Mars on lifters they developed from scratch would need to use anyone else's rocket motor!
😂indians are funny. how can barak8 defend such junk if we shoot YJ-21 from 1000kms away? barak 8 at best travels at 2 mach, slow as the progress of amca
Something which even Indians looked over the last 5 years is the fact that the Indian Navy's Nuclear Missile Submarine program just went into overdrive. The INS Arihant class is almost complete, and the successor class has already been laid down. As they are not as huge as the Russian or American SSBNs they still provide a level of Hunter Killer capability.
@@boejiden7093 arihant S1 is basically to train sailors and officers as well as to serve as a testbed for weopons while S2 being same as S1 with slight improvements will provide a second strike capability with S3 and S4 being more powerful and 1000 tonnes more heavy will be more heavy and capable enough to strike any country in South Asia and most central Asia... S5 class will be the most powerful and destructive ones equally capable as many ssbn across the world
Arihants 83MW power wont allow it to perform hunter killer capabilities effectively.. its designed to be quiet not to be fast which is one of the key requirements for SSNs
*Sir, can you please analyze more about Indian military, we in India are interested to know more about our Military from 3rd party like you. Thank you Sir!*
@@WeaponDetective *Dear Detective, below are the list Indigenous Indian weapon systems, can you please do your independent analysis of these platforms* 1. Light combat Fighter 'TEJAS' 2. BRAHMOS supersonic cruise missile 3. AKASH surface to air missile 4. New generation Anti Radiation Missile (RUDRAM) 5. PINAKA rocket MLRS 6. Beyond visual range air-to-air missile ‘Astra’ 7. Indian ASAT missile anti satellite 8. Advanced Towed Artillery Gun System (ATAGS) 9. Weapon Locating Radar (WLR) Swati 10. Dhruv is a utility helicopter 11. Light Combat Helicopter (LCH) is an Indian multi-role attack helicopter 12. Arihant-class submarine nuclear powered 13. NETRA AEW&C system 14. AGNI Ballistic missile systems
Thank you for a video on indian naval ships. I would request you to please make a video in ins vikrant aircraft carrier of indian navy and arihant class ssbn submarines. Love your videos.
I would say India should order a full second production run of the Visakhapatnam-class. With the PLAN being so aggressive India needs to have a larger number of high powered warships. And their lastest destroyer class fits the bill perfectly. Along with increasing the number of Frigates they are building as well. Maybe partner up with the other local powers to build more ships in India and other nations to sell and reduce cost of the navy expansion.
India is the world's 3rd largest naval ship builder after US and China. Its just that...China builds way more due to their larger economy and defence budget.
@@rohitb5834 being the 3rd doesn't change that they should partner with the other local powers. All of them need ships so working together to help grow is important.
@@rohitb5834 Actually we are the 4th largest. Japan has us beat for now. And in terms of overall shipbuilding, even South Korea has us beat. But not for long.
@@death_parade eh, Japan has 8 major warships currently under construction . S.Korea has 6. India has 17. And im only talking about the major combat ships.
15.15 Western countries did not help to India when a war will come with China, it is true, so India must build its military rapidly to strengthen its muscles in the Indian Ocean Region.
My memory which may be incorrect is that Trump caused itel and satellite data transfer info to India. How much assistance this was I do not know. Franky it didn't seem that India needed any kinetic or troop help with China as Indias elite mountain troops did better than Chinas and US troops would have had acclimatization problems. Had China decided to go all in with land air sea while Trump was president I'm quite certain the US and Indian and Australian navies awoud have reduced Chias feet substantially. I'm also certain that the US air force would have joined Ibdias air force if necessary a ry. Sadly with Biden it is currently difficult to say what would happen. The recent insult to India by an intrusion unasked by India of an American destroyers not understandable to the average American.
@@josephfreeman3816 that's not the case even with trump, it is a US habit of abandoning allies, examples- afghan government, kurdish forces and we don't see a possibility US going to war with china for taiwan either nor for India to be honest because we were once at the receiving ends of US navy in 1971 when US 7th fleet and UK carrier strike Group under HMS eagle was in indian ocean against India after the bangladeshi genocide done by pakistani military then pakistan bombed india, started another all out war and still got the support of half the freaking world against India and US was tagging india as an aggressor, expansionist in the UNSC also US was pushing resolutions against india. That was an existential crisis for India and at that time russians stepped up their game ,they vetoed everything in favour of India and sent their battle group to the Indian ocean to help India and made a firm line of atomic subs and naval presence that actually stopped both the carrier strike groups and that war left pakistan surrendered with 93,000 troops "largest after world war 2" and Independence of bangladesh. That's how russians made their presence in India and US is still untrusted by most of the Indians. Believe it or not more than half of the Indians will choose russia over US but never china that's for sure and if russia chooses china then it's over for the russians too. But we do think that Australia and japan can go to war in case India goes into it because they need India in the Indian ocean as the dominant power along with that India has the capability of having a vast maritime information of the region in its naval fusion centres just recently a permanent british liaison officer has been appointed in that indian navy's fusion centre of the Indian ocean also maybe even a french officer was appointed some years ago. India will need US satellite info only for the nuclear exchange even that only for the parts of china which are near eastern end of china near the sea because we already have 23 satellites monitoring everything in the indian subcontinent and ocean for us. US is still supplying equipment to pakistan , some of which was found in the hands of terrorists that attacked India even mumbai terror attacks had a US informer involved, he was scouting targets in mumbai for pakistani intelligence and Laskar e taiba terrorists and he is serving a 35 year imprisonment for the lives of 160 people because he is a US citizen and an intelligence informer and cannot be extradited to India, if he would have been extradited to India we would have hanged him within a month. The Western alliance gave pakistan some 35 billion dollars of military and economic aid during the war on terror and where does pakistan used all of that money, to develop tactical nukes against India to be used as the first strike on battlefields. During the soviet afghan war, US sent money and weapons through pakistan into Afghanistan against soviets guess what happened after the war, those terrorists were sitting idle with pakistan getting more money they were turned against India in kashmir and do you wanna know how many soldiers we have lost? 6000 soldiers since 1980s to 2015 something and how many jihadis we have killed, it is well over a 100,000 on our soil. We can't deploy airsupport, artillery against them because the same US will start publishing reports about how india is using merciless force. This is the truth which we hate because it literally costs the lives of our well trained soldiers that are officially not into a war but still in combat every day. We are 8th most affected country by terrorism. We just do a partial trust on your government thanks to their own policies, they are going to sanction us again for S400s for sure even if the sanction will be minor because right now they can't afford to sanction India but still it will be stupidity.
Your videos are the best. Includes economy history defense international relations. If you could do a video on t129 atak, i would greatly appreciate it
These are just upscaled talwar class frigate ( which are admiral grigorovich class frigate of russia) Made in india by trasfer of technology from russia .. Also these are underarmed .. air defence missiles are half of what other nation destroyers carries
India needs over 40 destroyers and over 50 submarines 4 ACs along with numerous frigates, corvettes, missile boats and patrol vessels to ensure we are safe in the sea. By 2050 China plans to induct over 100 destroyers and submarines and India has to deny China the indo pacific if it wishes to survive. Naval budget should directly funded from the national budget and not the defense budget because that's how important the Navy is. The airforce and army can then share the defense budget amongst themselves and will have a greater and more appropriate share. Even the Andaman and Nicobar islands should be heavily fortified and armed. I think the P18 destroyers will be the appropriate size of destroyers for our navy and we should order atleast 10 of them before moving on to the next design.
through the introduction of the private sector into defense industry will enable the Indian Navy to achieve new heights . . . Indian PSU will lease multiple naval task force to the IN . . . the naval task force will comprise of a fleet of three next generation 114,850 ton (126,900 ton loaded) stealth (CATOBAR) super carrier powered by new cutting edge bioFuelCell3^ i-SMARTHYBRId® marine propulsion system . . . IN also needs two Mistral class 38,390 ton (46,290 ton loaded) non-amphibious (CSTOL) multi mission assault ship powered by the same bioFuelCell3^ i-SMARTHYBRId® power pack . . . being non amphibious by it won't feature a dedicated vehicle deck as found in most amphibious assault ships . . . instead it'll have an enlarged full size aircraft hangar with a higher than normal hangar roof height that will accommodate 20 - 26 surface ship borne helicopters like the MH-60U SeaCombat® Hawk maritime multi role helicopter gunship . . .
China has a bulk of Frigates which makes its navy look like huge but it is a combination of both old ships and newer frigates, older ones being more in numbers. Frigates are good and effective in close quarter naval warfare, high sea patrolling, interception but lack defensive power and Firepower against organised Battle Groups (formations)....
It would be better if the IN would order a further batch of 2 more P-15B and design a further class of ASW dedicated frigates based on the P-17A. There the IN should try to build a class of 6 ships at the minimum with 8 being better perhaps in sub classes of 2,3&3.Naturally to make funds available for these important ships all pipe dream projects like LHD,15000 ton CG, CATOBAR carriers should be cancelled, cancelled and deferred respectively. What the IN could design is a 9000 ton CG with its main armament to be 24 x Brahmos 450 and it's VLS launching system designed such that it could also eventually carry the Brahmos 600 when it enters service. But rather like the Mogami class CL designed with barbettes that could carry the 2x8in guns in place f the launched 3x6.1in guns. We could more easily build such a ship and faster too. The need is for ships in service in number.
No. The Navy is doing good right now. Its time to move over to indigenous weapons and sensors for our next class of Destroyers. Project-18 will be larger, better and more powerful than all Project-15/A/B Destroyers. More importantly, the existing foreign sensors and weapons will be replaced by better Indian sensors and weapons:- . Israeli MF-STAR ------> DRDO LRMFR (in testing on INS Anvesh) Indo-Russian BrahMos --------> DRDO HSTDV-based missile (TD tested, missile in design) Indo-Israeli Barak 8 ---------> DRDO AD-1 (about to start testing) ---------------> DRDO AD-2 (in design) Barak 1, Shtil-1 ---------------> DRDO VL-SRSAM (in testing) Ak-630 ----------------> DRDO CIWS (mentioned in TPCR of Indian Navy) . EW, C2 and ASW systems are already Indian. In other words, Project-18 onwards, we can think of churning out large number of Destroyers because they'll have mostly Indian weapons and sensors meaning that they'll be more cost effective and the money will not be lost in foreign exchange.
@@death_parade Churning out large number of DDG & FFG is what I am afraid our yards have shown a remarkable habit of being able to do since the last 60 years. The P-17 is the 1st time we are seeing a marked improvement in build times, though even the P-15B showed great initial promise. The crucial delay happens during the fitting out stage and there your point if indigenous products being available might be able to help. But for all purposes both Brahmos and the Barakarar are our own products (specially the Brahmos) and more important reliable and proven. The DRDO designs show promise and must be developed further, yes but they are still at design & development stage. For them to enter service would take at least a decade further on. We cannot wait that long as the PLAN is increasing the lead over us inexorably. We need ships and aircraft now in the water and those ships which even now are equal to the Chinese. The P-15B & the P-17A are just those ships we need. Let us have them to hold the fort and see off the imminent Sino-Pak threat around our coasts. If we lose the game now it is over for us for the next generation at least. And the P-18 which is still another 12 years away from service will be of no use to us then. So the further P-15B and the new ASW FFG that I want will help us buy the time which will make the P-18 a really useful weapon for India when it joins the IN.
@@peterasp1968 Your gripe has nothing to do with shipyards, although yeah, it would be great if we had better build times, shipyards are slow in adopting modular construction. BUT, the major culprit in our slow shipbuilding process is the fact that we don't have the money. Navy's Capital Expenditure is around $5 Billion annually. By 2030, it will be around $12 Billion and only then will we be able to churn out more ships. . Many DRDO systems are already in operation on IN warships. The ones in testing right now will be ready by 2025. But the Navy won't have enough money to place an order for the Project-18 till 2027-28.
Please click the link to watch our other Weapon Detective videos
th-cam.com/users/playlist?list...
Please click the link to watch our other Weapon Detective-Sea videos
th-cam.com/users/playlist?list...
Ist Vishakhapatnam class destroyer commission in navy this year
Need some indian subscribers, eh!?
In the P-15B class:-
Electronic Warfare system, Gearbox, SONAR, Torpedoes, Combat Management System, IR suppression system, steel, ASW rockets, consoles, design, etc all completely Indian designed and built. Missiles are Jointly designed with foreign partner and manufactured in India. Main gun, CIWS, ASW rocket launcher all manufactured in India. Only radar and engines are directly imported.
.
In next generation Indian destroyers, other than the gas turbines and some parts of the IEP, everything else like radar, missiles, CIWS, etc will be completely Indian designed and built. Each of these sub-systems are already under developmental testing stage.
Congratulations India!!!!🇨🇱
Regards from India to Chile.
🇮🇳love form 🇮🇳
Support from the Philippines 🇵🇭
I can't believe someone pronounced indian names very nicely. Kudos
Those are truly impressive warships. Makes me happy to see the Indian Navy ready to defend it's territory
Amazing. India has never aggressively projected power. As far as I'm concerned, it's called the Indian Ocean for a reason and I'd rather have the Indian Navy out there than the Chinese.
Pact with Japan, Taiwan, Vietnam, Micronesia & hurry. The world needs India.
Delusional
We do want to play claim to any territory that is not ours...when we fight, we fight to protect our land and sea...no dashes in our oceans I am afraid
48 Indians like your comments 😂
I envy your country. I hope we could build our own ship too. Respect from the Philippines
Never do that it takes our government and bureaucrats ten years to approve weapon procurements the only reason we seem to be doing somewhat good is because we are big
@@bramha9680 As a Filipino I am aware that given India’s size, it’s weapons procurement is pretty slow. From the aging aircraft to the delays in the MBT project, there maybe some other problems I am not aware of. But hey, everybody has problems.
@@bramha9680 people like you takes our Country down. Until what time we will be truly independent??.
This country needs reforms and change.
You may be a slave but a substantial part of population of India are not slaves anymore. We want to fly high.
Thankyou 🙏
@@philnightjar1971 we have one more problem, our Government officials have Girlfriend/Boyfriend outside India. Hope you understand the rest and the reason behind slow processing of orders.
@@KrishnaDas-qi6ds I am not an Indian Citizen, I have no right to butt into your problems.
Pronunciation is great. With the tough indian words. Kudos. Man. Keep it up.
"lounched".
@@desydukuk291 haha
sahi ja rhe ho balak
Oh My Eyes,What kind of psychopath developed this weird-looking boat, his brain must be full of shit
Such accurate unbiased review on Indian Navy. "in possible Sino-Indian war, India must rely on its own; bcoz western countries would wait for this gigantic nations to wear out first". 🙌
Yes. This is the reason why PM Modi didn't took China's name. Because India is own its own.
India is a democracy, if your fighting communist china i'd say western countries and other asian countries would more than likely fight alongside india in a full blown war. Evrerybody hates the ccp these days
@@masterofpuppets7295 my friend, politics and war is more complicated than it seems.
@@masterofpuppets7295 F the west and F China we'll deal with the Chinese first and then liberate Diego Garcia and hand it over to Mauritius it's all a matter of time 🖕
@@lipikamitra1481 lmao why would we attack the base of a friendly nation, with whom we have signed the Logistics pact we can take help of Diego Garcia base in times it's needed due to the pact.
Hey man , good job on pronouncing the names correctly.
The ability of India to assemble weapons systems from different countries is quite impressive. 👍
Man, those are powerful destroyers. As a Canadian, our frigates are weak AF.
Problem for India is that we only have a 3 of the kolkata class and 3 planned vishakapatnam class. India should have built a more of each class.
@@boejiden7093 well said Mr President.
@@pratiknath3267 thanks :) i think at least 6 of each class should have been built. These are powerful destroyers. Also think india shouldnt have decommisioned older destroyers and instead used them for anti-piracy operations in the indian ocean. They dont need to perform anti shipping roles but just some coastal defense and anti piracy. Maybe help with search and rescue operations, citizen rescues from indians living in the middle east, etc. They'd be quite good for support roles.
@Arup Ratan Mitra right thanks for correcting me. I still think more should be inducted to counter China. That and also more scorpene class submarines.
@Arup Ratan Mitra i agree. Its truely sad.
A correction MFSTAR is destroyer variant of kolkata class has detection range of 400km and 250km range is for corvette variant of Israeli Navy
We mentioned the 250 km range for the fighter-sized aircraft. You are right. We were ought to mention the range for naval vessels, as well.
@@WeaponDetective range of mf star on Kolkata class is 450 km vs 1 m2 target
Yes range is more than 450 km and can detect stealth target 160 km
It is the modified version of iron Dome radar, its range is no joke
its range is around 500 kms. Was told to me by a Sailor onboard INS Kolkata.
And in reality, when he says "500 kms", it means its "Over 500 kms" ;)
Love the in depth analysis! Much better than other channels. Subbed!
Great video which included past and present in detail of Indian Navy Destroyers. The Project 18 class of destroyers of Indian Navy will be a game changer as it will be around 12000/13000 tons in displacement with nearly 128/144 VLS and their will be 6 of them.
This really is a superb channel. For those interested and who can find it, _No Easy Answers_ by former chief of the Royal Australian Navy R.Adm. James Goldrick is a good read on the history of the subcontinent navies up to 1996 when it was published.
1996 is 25 years ago. A lot has changed since then.
@@sublimefermion2205 Indeed, but many of us are interested in history prior to that.
Thanks
13:25 desire that will remain desire 😊
Actually I read the chinese mostly want to control the south china seas mainly. Indian ocean too, but that'll be tough in the presence of Indian navy and south east asian navies
@@mnd7381 BHRAMOS is waiting
@@90sstreetz23 Brahmos is already there. Brahmos 2 is waiting.
@@mnd7381
Fake news
This is 1st time heard an foreigners pronouncing hindi word so fluently , grt brother
Which amongst these were Hindi words?
I came to know lot of information regarding this great Indian class destroyer KOLKATA, thanks a lot sir as it make my day cause i belong to same named place also.
Back the elephant and not the dragon
Why ? Because the dragon is an imaginary creature
Tiger is national anml
We identify ourselves more with tigers...and Tigers are precious.
@@ShivankurMittal They compare India with elephant because of our size (population count), and mostly calm nature.
Those Oto Melara guns are insane.
Excellent video. Well done India.
India will have 7 such ships till 2025.
3 kolkata class destroyers.
4 visakhapatnam class destroyers.
In 2030 India would have 10 heavy destroyers.
Also 4 more Talwar class frigates
We also have 3 Delhi Class Destroyers
And 3 shivalik class frigate, 7 nilgiri class, 11 talwar and 6 p16 heavy destroyer on order
@@purusottamkundu5591 holy fucking shit thats alot
@@purusottamkundu5591 these ships are mostly replacements for the existing fleet. So, it ain’t gonna beef up the numbers
I liked the frankness and sincerity of the narration , because it openly admitted mechanical problems and construction delays , also , the overall clearness of the narrated history of the Indian navy .
Cooperation with Australia and South Africa will pay great dividends as naval allies and development partners
Well i don't want to offend but i don't think Australia or south africa have anything to teach india
I mean india built it's own nuclear sub
@@prasadchaturdesale5795 Cooperation doesn't only mean in shipbuilding, but a broader cooperation in terms of countering China and other areas such as enforcing the rule of law in the Indian Ocean Region.
Australia is important because while we can stop Chinese from crossing Malacca, unless Aussies stop them from crossing via Lombok or Sunda straits, we won't be able to limit Chinese forces in IOR.
My only gripe is that they manufacture only 3. I feel like they should produce more than 3 but i understand the money is the problem. However the vishakapatnam class is a very good destroyer
Yes, money is a problem. Indian Navy budget is less compared to Army and Airforce. Our focus is more on land border.
We also ha e very few shipbuilders so they r always full of order and it has its upside too rathar than printing the same stuff for 20 years we order small then after 10 years we order the upgraded version and so on
They have made 3 kolkata class and ordered 4 Visakhapatnam class destroyers.
Budget
@@hritikjuyal5484 money isn't the only issue - mazagon docks(main destroyer-frigate builder) use russian method of ship which requires less skilled labour which takes long time to build a ship which intern increases cost
Thankfully they are now testing building by blocks which is how Nilgiri class is build and that's why they have larger quantity order
Pretty damn impressive destroyers!!
#Atmanirbhartā is the only and best option for India!
*Dear Detective, below are the list Indigenous Indian weapon systems, can you please do your independent analysis of these platforms*
1. Light combat Fighter 'TEJAS'
2. BRAHMOS supersonic cruise missile
3. AKASH surface to air missile
4. New generation Anti Radiation Missile (RUDRAM)
5. PINAKA rocket MLRS
6. Beyond visual range air-to-air missile ‘Astra’
7. Indian ASAT missile anti satellite
8. Advanced Towed Artillery Gun System (ATAGS)
9. Weapon Locating Radar (WLR) Swati
10. Dhruv is a utility helicopter
11. Light Combat Helicopter (LCH) is an Indian multi-role attack helicopter
12. Arihant-class submarine nuclear powered
13. NETRA AEW&C system
14. AGNI Ballistic missile systems
Thank you for your answer. Over time, we will do our research and prepare videos about these systems.
@@WeaponDetective waiting for it.
@@WeaponDetective well it's been too long not a indian video since long time
The caption helps me to understand the content, thanks man
Very detailed video. Even being & Indian 🇮🇳👳 i don't know the fects. Thanks for bringing this. 👍👍👍
Very impressive Naval ship building program and the long operational experience is really very rare in Asia. The aggressive behemoth to the East is a manufacturing and technological power house will we see a global power realignment like it was back in 1000 CE? We live in interesting times.
Great video....Thanks WD✌️❤️🇮🇳🙏
That name
@mee mee that's cool though
Which universes r u from??
@@yanbemopatton , I'm from no where ..lol
@@VELS436 haha..
I wish you had paid a bit more attention to and made a mention of India's ancient seafarers - the Cholas and their contemporaries from present-day Odisha. THEY were India's first naval powers.
Also the Marathas under kanhoji Angre who created a sizeable fleet.
brilliant!!!! and full of fascinating info, keep up the great work
Can't wait for India to launch it's cruiser/destroyers of 13,000 ton displacement(on paper program but waiting an official yes from the Gov't P-18)
Wait for Project 18 class destroyer
Can't wait for India to build it's own aircraft carrier.
@@beerthug Already done.
@@death_parade Without a ramp, lol.
@@beerthug We already had one back in the 70s. We will have one again next decade. Its not as if STOBAR carriers are paper dragons.
One should take the Mach 2 figure for Barak-8 with a grain of salt. It is the officially published figure but it is an improbably low speed for such a missile to max out at, so I suspect some obfuscation is at play. Somewhere in ball park of Mach 3.5-4.5 is more likely.
Barak 8 accelerates to Mach 5 in its terminal flight phase when the second of the dual pulse rocket motor kicks in
@@aniruddhamulay2932 Now Mach 5 makes a lot more sense. Is it the same DP motor that Stunner uses?
@@mortified776 Nope, I don't think so, this dual pulse rocket motor was developed by India's Defence R&D organization named DRDO as part of the Indo-Israeli collaboration to develop the Barak 8. Rest of the missile was developed by IAI.
The development of this dual pulse rocket motor has been a huge boon for several Indian defence projects like Next Generation Anti Radiation Missile(NGARM), Astra Mk2 BVR A2A missile, Akash-NG SAM system.
@@aniruddhamulay2932 India's missileers have indeed been prodigious. I remember back twenty years ago when DRDO was having a lot of problems with the Trishul point defense system for the IN. They of course ended up buying Barak 1 from the Israelis which I think is where the seeds of the Indo-Israeli joint missile initiative were planted if I am not mistaken. Sometimes failure leads to better things than you planned in the first place! I was glad to read recently that the IN's new point defence system recycles a lot of the Trishul work, so even that wasn't a waste after all!
@@aniruddhamulay2932 On reflection, it was also daft of me to think a country which has sent orbiters to Mars on lifters they developed from scratch would need to use anyone else's rocket motor!
We are glad your on our side. Brownie Western Australia
Don't forget about the stealth fly carpet interceptor's they have not to be messed with.
What a detailed viedo, Bravo!!
You are awesome . Keep it up 🔥🔥🔥🔥💓
Really good channel and equally good in depth analysis!!
Really beautiful ship
Thank you,
Very Nice Explained
Great video! Weird question, where are you from? I can't quite guess your accent
Our colleague who read the text is a Turco-American.
@@WeaponDetective give him a raise! He nailed the names!
76mm gun to be replaced by the M45 127mm gun
I can see jealousy of Chinese 🇨🇳👲 bots in comment section 🤣🤣, Bcz their Junk navy can't make this type of war ship
😂indians are funny. how can barak8 defend such junk if we shoot YJ-21 from 1000kms away? barak 8 at best travels at 2 mach, slow as the progress of amca
Something which even Indians looked over the last 5 years is the fact that the Indian Navy's Nuclear Missile Submarine program just went into overdrive.
The INS Arihant class is almost complete, and the successor class has already been laid down.
As they are not as huge as the Russian or American SSBNs they still provide a level of Hunter Killer capability.
Hunter killer capability?? Do you know what you are talking about??
@@subram2011 not even close bro. He has no idea what he’s talking about. Like most others
@@boejiden7093 arihant S1 is basically to train sailors and officers as well as to serve as a testbed for weopons while S2 being same as S1 with slight improvements will provide a second strike capability with S3 and S4 being more powerful and 1000 tonnes more heavy will be more heavy and capable enough to strike any country in South Asia and most central Asia... S5 class will be the most powerful and destructive ones equally capable as many ssbn across the world
Arihants 83MW power wont allow it to perform hunter killer capabilities effectively.. its designed to be quiet not to be fast which is one of the key requirements for SSNs
lol arihant is more like a training sub its like tejas of navy used to gain experience airghat is more capable than arihant
*Sir, can you please analyze more about Indian military, we in India are interested to know more about our Military from 3rd party like you. Thank you Sir!*
Thank you for your nice comment. Is there a system you specifically want?
@@WeaponDetective *Dear Detective, below are the list Indigenous Indian weapon systems, can you please do your independent analysis of these platforms*
1. Light combat Fighter 'TEJAS'
2. BRAHMOS supersonic cruise missile
3. AKASH surface to air missile
4. New generation Anti Radiation Missile (RUDRAM)
5. PINAKA rocket MLRS
6. Beyond visual range air-to-air missile ‘Astra’
7. Indian ASAT missile anti satellite
8. Advanced Towed Artillery Gun System (ATAGS)
9. Weapon Locating Radar (WLR) Swati
10. Dhruv is a utility helicopter
11. Light Combat Helicopter (LCH) is an Indian multi-role attack helicopter
12. Arihant-class submarine nuclear powered
13. NETRA AEW&C system
14. AGNI Ballistic missile systems
@@joyjoy442 Greedy!
@@guanjun1178 Hehe 😜
@@WeaponDetective a video on upcoming Nilgiri class frigates
Israel radar, Russian missiles and CWIS, Italian gun and Indian body, very globalized ship.
Lmao, India has already replaced Italian gun and Israeli raders and it doesn't has a single Russian missile cope harder 🤣
@@breath7819😅replace lol. when can india produce own radar and guns?
@@dravenvea2605it's 75% indigenous cry even more ,idiot anything can't be 100% indigenous from begging.
@@dravenvea2605 Now
Thank you for a video on indian naval ships. I would request you to please make a video in ins vikrant aircraft carrier of indian navy and arihant class ssbn submarines. Love your videos.
Thanks for your interest. Lucky for you, our next Weapon Detective-Sea content will be about INS Vikrant.
@@WeaponDetective that's stupendous, love you sir.
I would say India should order a full second production run of the Visakhapatnam-class. With the PLAN being so aggressive India needs to have a larger number of high powered warships. And their lastest destroyer class fits the bill perfectly. Along with increasing the number of Frigates they are building as well. Maybe partner up with the other local powers to build more ships in India and other nations to sell and reduce cost of the navy expansion.
India is the world's 3rd largest naval ship builder after US and China. Its just that...China builds way more due to their larger economy and defence budget.
@@rohitb5834 being the 3rd doesn't change that they should partner with the other local powers. All of them need ships so working together to help grow is important.
@@adventwolfbane partner in what sense?
@@rohitb5834 Actually we are the 4th largest. Japan has us beat for now. And in terms of overall shipbuilding, even South Korea has us beat. But not for long.
@@death_parade eh, Japan has 8 major warships currently under construction . S.Korea has 6.
India has 17.
And im only talking about the major combat ships.
15.15
Western countries did not help to India when a war will come with China, it is true, so India must build its military rapidly to strengthen its muscles in the Indian Ocean Region.
My memory which may be incorrect is that Trump caused itel and satellite data transfer info to India. How much assistance this was I do not know. Franky it didn't seem that India needed any kinetic or troop help with China as Indias elite mountain troops did better than Chinas and US troops would have had acclimatization problems.
Had China decided to go all in with land air sea while Trump was president I'm quite certain the US and Indian and Australian navies awoud have reduced Chias feet substantially. I'm also certain that the US air force would have joined Ibdias air force if necessary a ry.
Sadly with Biden it is currently difficult to say what would happen. The recent insult to India by an intrusion unasked by India of an American destroyers not understandable to the average American.
@@josephfreeman3816 that's not the case even with trump, it is a US habit of abandoning allies, examples- afghan government, kurdish forces and we don't see a possibility US going to war with china for taiwan either nor for India to be honest because we were once at the receiving ends of US navy in 1971 when US 7th fleet and UK carrier strike
Group under HMS eagle was in indian ocean against India after the bangladeshi genocide done by pakistani military then pakistan bombed india, started another all out war and still got the support of half the freaking world against India and US was tagging india as an aggressor, expansionist in the UNSC also US was pushing resolutions against india. That was an existential crisis for India and at that time russians stepped up their game ,they vetoed everything in favour of India and sent their battle group to the Indian ocean to help India and made a firm line of atomic subs and naval presence that actually stopped both the carrier strike groups and that war left pakistan surrendered with 93,000 troops "largest after world war 2" and Independence of bangladesh. That's how russians made their presence in India and US is still untrusted by most of the Indians. Believe it or not more than half of the Indians will choose russia over US but never china that's for sure and if russia chooses china then it's over for the russians too. But we do think that Australia and japan can go to war in case India goes into it because they need India in the Indian ocean as the dominant power along with that India has the capability of having a vast maritime information of the region in its naval fusion centres just recently a permanent british liaison officer has been appointed in that indian navy's fusion centre of the Indian ocean also maybe even a french officer was appointed some years ago. India will need US satellite info only for the nuclear exchange even that only for the parts of china which are near eastern end of china near the sea because we already have 23 satellites monitoring everything in the indian subcontinent and ocean for us. US is still supplying equipment to pakistan , some of which was found in the hands of terrorists that attacked India even mumbai terror attacks had a US informer involved, he was scouting targets in mumbai for pakistani intelligence and Laskar e taiba terrorists and he is serving a 35 year imprisonment for the lives of 160 people because he is a US citizen and an intelligence informer and cannot be extradited to India, if he would have been extradited to India we would have hanged him within a month. The Western alliance gave pakistan some 35 billion dollars of military and economic aid during the war on terror and where does pakistan used all of that money, to develop tactical nukes against India to be used as the first strike on battlefields. During the soviet afghan war, US sent money and weapons through pakistan into Afghanistan against soviets guess what happened after the war, those terrorists were sitting idle with pakistan getting more money they were turned against India in kashmir and do you wanna know how many soldiers we have lost? 6000 soldiers since 1980s to 2015 something and how many jihadis we have killed, it is well over a 100,000 on our soil. We can't deploy airsupport, artillery against them because the same US will start publishing reports about how india is using merciless force. This is the truth which we hate because it literally costs the lives of our well trained soldiers that are officially not into a war but still in combat every day. We are 8th most affected country by terrorism. We just do a partial trust on your government thanks to their own policies, they are going to sanction us again for S400s for sure even if the sanction will be minor because right now they can't afford to sanction India but still it will be stupidity.
Very interesting. The western navies should update with better anti-ship missiles.
Very good analysis
10 THOUSAND SPECIAL VIDEO!
Awesome video and commentary 👌
Your videos are the best. Includes economy history defense international relations. If you could do a video on t129 atak, i would greatly appreciate it
Good lookin ships, for sure
Nice analysis
Great video 👍
Harika bir video . Teşekkürler
Awesome Channel!
1st Visakhapatnam-class destroyer , INS Visakhapatnam inducted into navy
These are just upscaled talwar class frigate ( which are admiral grigorovich class frigate of russia)
Made in india by trasfer of technology from russia ..
Also these are underarmed .. air defence missiles are half of what other nation destroyers carries
India needs over 40 destroyers and over 50 submarines 4 ACs along with numerous frigates, corvettes, missile boats and patrol vessels to ensure we are safe in the sea.
By 2050 China plans to induct over 100 destroyers and submarines and India has to deny China the indo pacific if it wishes to survive. Naval budget should directly funded from the national budget and not the defense budget because that's how important the Navy is. The airforce and army can then share the defense budget amongst themselves and will have a greater and more appropriate share.
Even the Andaman and Nicobar islands should be heavily fortified and armed.
I think the P18 destroyers will be the appropriate size of destroyers for our navy and we should order atleast 10 of them before moving on to the next design.
Great video 😉 Keep it up 🙏
Love from INDIA, Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Just imagine some random person chilling on the ship at 12:50 and seeing Fing torpedo getting launch at him !
Can you make a video on the first Made in India aircraft carrier INS Vikrant
Are these classes of ships stealth?
I am from vizag means visakhapatnam
🙏nice
How did you source the footage?
INS Kolkata, INS Visakhapatnam 🇮🇳🇮🇳 are doing mind blowing work in Arabian Sea, Mediterranean Sea in containing anti piracy activities.
Very nice video
INS Kolkata a quality product from house of Mazgaon Shipyard Docks 🇮🇳🇮🇳
through the introduction of the private sector into defense industry will enable the Indian Navy to achieve new heights . . . Indian PSU will lease multiple naval task force to the IN . . . the naval task force will comprise of a fleet of three next generation 114,850 ton (126,900 ton loaded) stealth (CATOBAR) super carrier powered by new cutting edge bioFuelCell3^ i-SMARTHYBRId® marine propulsion system . . . IN also needs two Mistral class 38,390 ton (46,290 ton loaded) non-amphibious (CSTOL) multi mission assault ship powered by the same bioFuelCell3^ i-SMARTHYBRId® power pack . . . being non amphibious by it won't feature a dedicated vehicle deck as found in most amphibious assault ships . . . instead it'll have an enlarged full size aircraft hangar with a higher than normal hangar roof height that will accommodate 20 - 26 surface ship borne helicopters like the MH-60U SeaCombat® Hawk maritime multi role helicopter gunship . . .
China has a bulk of Frigates which makes its navy look like huge but it is a combination of both old ships and newer frigates, older ones being more in numbers.
Frigates are good and effective in close quarter naval warfare, high sea patrolling, interception but lack defensive power and Firepower against organised Battle Groups (formations)....
"Frigates lack firepower"
Project-17: Are we a joke to you?
They can't leave 5k km beyond
is written "destroyer" but it pronounces "cruiser"
8000 tons isnt a cruiser by any means.
@@jorlm2364 the armament says otherwise
@@Foxtrop13 and it has a battle control system like cruisers
@@Foxtrop13 Umm......its not a cruiser by any metric. Even after they retrofit 32 more VL-SRSAM VLS on it, it won't be a cruiser.
A aesthatically better and powerful ASW version of Type 45
huh?
What??
It has nothing in common with the type45
@@lipikamitra1481 both have tall mast with radar on top.Both look similar
@@Rtgv123 Type 45's radar is under-powered compared to the MF-STAR.
It would be better if the IN would order a further batch of 2 more P-15B and design a further class of ASW dedicated frigates based on the P-17A. There the IN should try to build a class of 6 ships at the minimum with 8 being better perhaps in sub classes of 2,3&3.Naturally to make funds available for these important ships all pipe dream projects like LHD,15000 ton CG, CATOBAR carriers should be cancelled, cancelled and deferred respectively. What the IN could design is a 9000 ton CG with its main armament to be 24 x Brahmos 450 and it's VLS launching system designed such that it could also eventually carry the Brahmos 600 when it enters service. But rather like the Mogami class CL designed with barbettes that could carry the 2x8in guns in place f the launched 3x6.1in guns. We could more easily build such a ship and faster too. The need is for ships in service in number.
No. The Navy is doing good right now. Its time to move over to indigenous weapons and sensors for our next class of Destroyers.
Project-18 will be larger, better and more powerful than all Project-15/A/B Destroyers. More importantly, the existing foreign sensors and weapons will be replaced by better Indian sensors and weapons:-
.
Israeli MF-STAR ------> DRDO LRMFR (in testing on INS Anvesh)
Indo-Russian BrahMos --------> DRDO HSTDV-based missile (TD tested, missile in design)
Indo-Israeli Barak 8 ---------> DRDO AD-1 (about to start testing)
---------------> DRDO AD-2 (in design)
Barak 1, Shtil-1 ---------------> DRDO VL-SRSAM (in testing)
Ak-630 ----------------> DRDO CIWS (mentioned in TPCR of Indian Navy)
.
EW, C2 and ASW systems are already Indian. In other words, Project-18 onwards, we can think of churning out large number of Destroyers because they'll have mostly Indian weapons and sensors meaning that they'll be more cost effective and the money will not be lost in foreign exchange.
@@death_parade Churning out large number of DDG & FFG is what I am afraid our yards have shown a remarkable habit of being able to do since the last 60 years. The P-17 is the 1st time we are seeing a marked improvement in build times, though even the P-15B showed great initial promise. The crucial delay happens during the fitting out stage and there your point if indigenous products being available might be able to help. But for all purposes both Brahmos and the Barakarar are our own products (specially the Brahmos) and more important reliable and proven. The DRDO designs show promise and must be developed further, yes but they are still at design & development stage. For them to enter service would take at least a decade further on. We cannot wait that long as the PLAN is increasing the lead over us inexorably. We need ships and aircraft now in the water and those ships which even now are equal to the Chinese. The P-15B & the P-17A are just those ships we need. Let us have them to hold the fort and see off the imminent Sino-Pak threat around our coasts. If we lose the game now it is over for us for the next generation at least. And the P-18 which is still another 12 years away from service will be of no use to us then. So the further P-15B and the new ASW FFG that I want will help us buy the time which will make the P-18 a really useful weapon for India when it joins the IN.
@@peterasp1968 Your gripe has nothing to do with shipyards, although yeah, it would be great if we had better build times, shipyards are slow in adopting modular construction.
BUT, the major culprit in our slow shipbuilding process is the fact that we don't have the money. Navy's Capital Expenditure is around $5 Billion annually. By 2030, it will be around $12 Billion and only then will we be able to churn out more ships.
.
Many DRDO systems are already in operation on IN warships. The ones in testing right now will be ready by 2025. But the Navy won't have enough money to place an order for the Project-18 till 2027-28.
@@death_parade USD 5 billion is that over a period of time?
@@peterasp1968 Per year.
the more i watch these videos im having a feeling that Admiral Bulldog is behind the voice..😂
Huge area of the ship is unoccupied.onthe foxel area ifcompared with Rajput class ratio of diamesion to amament.
LONG LIVE JAPAN🇯🇵
LONG LIVE INDIA🇮🇳
Excellent tech, maybe India needs to take a side, especially if it wants Western support in the future
No thanks. India is on its own side.
No thanks...I think we are good.
We always try to stand still by our own
Yes, India needs to get closer to West while saving the individuality.
INS Kolkata is capable of firing supersonic cruise missile Bramhos
Very large targets for submarines and drones
Jai Hind❤
👍
👍👍👍👊
Technically the largest surface ships are the aircraft carriers, but ok.
Proud to be an indian
what's the name of rocket launchers in the back of kolkata class destroyers?
rbu-6000
They are at front
@@PSP-lr7ms Im talking about decoy launchers
@@chris-ir3qx Oh😅 name is "Kavach", it's made in india by DRDO
The information is great but y the old 80's background music
that is a very LARGE Destroyer.
Build coastal patrol boats for my country please
India is working on rail guns since 1990s and the next gen destroyers will be with that rail gun .
🇮🇳❤️
Vishakhapatnam class is heavier not lighter
Your videos are interesting but the background music is annoying.