Rei stans honestly deserve the most respect, they are literally the chillest in the fandom. You don’t see them complain unlike certain stans. Till this day, solo toxic stans will hate on wonyoung when she’s not even close to being second or first. Have these stans not learn anything throughout the past years? After she wrote shine with me. It was about the hate that they were facing, yet people still continue to hate on wonyoung for no absolute reason.
rei has many solid lines in other songs and she usually gets to sing the killing part when she has less lines just like in I AM, we're already feel content with it ^^
Well as a gaeul stan I won't say gaeul to get more lines but good 2 3 different lines not just repetitive lines ...or just a rap part like in after like ...nothing else i don't want her to top but after looking how she got treated in supernova love ..I can't imagine anything worse ...or the worst could happen is her leaving this group...like no lines...... ?! No screentime...no centre part in choreo..at least other members have got their moments..Gaeul is the only one who got ignored ..even dives are not worried about her as they were for liz...
While I also 100% hope Gaeul is featured more and gets more lines, I do actually think that since Switch, Starship is making more of an effort to focus on her. She got to be the lead in the Accendio music video, and in Accendio and Heya’s dances she is featured in the center more (in my opinion). While she doesn’t get a lot of lines in Supernova, I do think she’s featured in the music video much more than Liz or Rei. Try not to worry, I don’t think she’s being forgotten💕
Liz: Queen of first places Yujin: Queen of second places Wonyoung: Queen of third places Iso: Queen of fourth places Rainy: Queen of fifth places Autumn: Queen of sixth places. Very similar to Red Velvet, MISAMO and Everglow.
@@bahihorse her & wony kept switching for the 3rd place lot of times- if the next album treats leeseo like IVE MINE/SWITCH then prob the gap will increase & they won't switch anymore but if Wony gets Love dive/After like treatment again she'll be 3rd again coz the gap isn't big So it depends ig 😭
Wony mostly gets a lot of lines in the title tracks, love dive , after like , kitsch and baddie, that's the reason people complain. I mean of course, others should get a chance to shine in title tracks too, and now starship is actually giving the others to shine
@@IsrxtRxmisa i mean she is center, and the one who attracts nonfan the most so it's normal for her to get the highlight part. But recently other members get to shine to. That's a good thing
Liz and Ningning stans are happy they threat the queens as Main Vocals ❤ We are so happy hoping Jihyo will get her justice so the world will totally healed 🎉
If iam honest wonyoung get only ton lines in title songs expect heya and iam She get less in less lines in bsides also i dont get the kpop stans critized her when even she get least lines in her self written bsides for ive.The producers chosed always members fit better and making more noise They need know wonyoung is the least promoted since 2023 by starship
i think it's still fair even when wonyoung have less lines since she gets a lot of screen times and dance at the center as well so she will still shine when they're performing. she usually gets to open / end some songs. try to see it from every aspects :)
GAEUL DESERVES BETTER!!! Many will say “she's the worst vocalist in the group that's why she has few lines” it's true, ok I understand you, but that doesn't mean she should always be in the last places, they don't let her shine.
Giselle & Gaeul being the rappers of their group but not having any rap lines lmaooo . Lord I pray everyday that for solo activities that Gaeul and Giselle can have somebody else manage them so they can get dedicated rap verses.
Average Line Distribution per song #1 Liz: 30.2 | 20.8% #2 Yujin: 29.4 | 20.3% #3 - #4 Wonyoung & Leeseo: 23.9 | 16.5% #5 Rei: 20.6 | 14.2% #6 Gaeul: 17 | 11.7% Variation: 23.4% Color of Zone: Green
Rei is literally the third best vocalist and main rapper, hope she gets more lines Gaeul is the second most talented member, hope she gets more lines too Rap line 💓
Liz stans need stop blamed the other members because asleast she get most lines and solo schedules than wonyoung and leeseo. As wonyoung stan i never complaint even we know ive will not this popular Without yujin and wonyoung esp in sales and virality.
The amount of time I've seen you in ive content trying to pity wonyoung by painting some1 else as the bad guy is absolutely unhealthy , you're too mentally attached to a celebrity , get help , Liz stans haven't been complaining since baddie era , stop making stories up from you b hole , gaeul stans complains because gaeul hardly gets raps nowadays and neither liz or gaeul stans blamed wonyoung or leeseo(except a few token stans) their blame was always towards starship , wonyoung is quite popular and have more haters in general , anyone can come up to you pretending like a liz stan and hate on wonnie that doesn't mean liz stans are to blame , people always find ways to hate on wonnie and sometimes they use other members as an excuse(you're also part of that problem just in opposite sides). "As wonyoung stan i never complaint" , hold up right there , you have at least one hundred comment in every ive video complaining about how wonnie is mistreated and reply to almost everyone with an opposing opinion , BFFR right now .
Maybe don’t listen to stans. They tend to be biased. Center isn’t “supposed” to have more lines, center traditionally has more center positioning in group formation during choreography, photoshoots etc. hence why the position is called CENTER.
third or fourth is really pushing it her voice doesn't suit the songs as well as the other members and if you listen closely she struggles most with sounding good singing live and english lyric
The way Liz stans up until now still complaining about having low line is sending me. They see any members have more line than them in a song and they riot.
@@fawkiouuuggi don't mean by wony favouritism because its too far from the concept…im talking about how startship started to give more rap lines to leeseo instead to gaeul that its the lead rapper,rei got some justice but gaeul really was robbed!! wony can also be bad or good but i dont forget she’s te reason why starship still gain money!! and you can see that leeseo is not enough powerful as gaeul to rap that much
@@superbluerock8327what i meant is that leeseo took the rap parts so thats why its more than wony rei and gaeul because she rapped and almost have not given a lot of vocal time! She is not that good and at least give some proper time screen to wony,vocal and rap to rei and gaeul because how its going it reminds me of after like era
@@thatoneperson731 liz and wonnie has completely different voice if you confuse between their voice you need some help , the adlibs were liz , yujin and wony at the last .
Now that Liz is in first place, fans are turning a blind eye to the group's poor distribution of lines. It has been so unfair to see how fans have absolute favoritism for such an artist, it's disgusting. Gaeul hardly sings, she's always the one with the least lines, the one with the least amount of prominence, as a fan of the group and observing that the fandom ignores the situation, it makes me angry, because when Liz didn't have her position as Main vocalist in the distribution lines, everyone cried, said she deserved more and Gaeul? Doesn't deserve more? Doesn't deserve better and fairer lines? Or the problem Is it just because the main vocalist isn't on top? Hypocritical Dives
@phenobarbidolI She doesn't sing because her parts are going to other people in the group, since her position is rapper, it doesn't make sense for wony to take the rap, for leeseo to take the rap, it doesn't make sense. But the fandom is hypocritical and only "fought" because the main vocalist was in 2nd place in the distribution lines, when she literally got a single song with 9s of participation. Keep defending Liz's position and ignoring the fact that Gaeul is extremely erased from the group with each comeback, you guys are disgusting
@@eupedromarcello and why are you writing a whole paragraph here about liz? i havent said a single word about her, in this i agree with you, it was comical when everyone was crying cause she got little lines in just one song when she sung the most in the whole album; with gaeul, well, these arent her lines if she wasnt given them so i dont know how is anyone "taking" anything from her, where it wasnt hers in the first place, for me she has adequate amount of lines for what she brings, but again, i do agree that they shouldnt cut out her verse from the mv version of this song and leaving her out on this
@phenobarbidolI The problem isn't even not appearing in the mv, but not having enough lines within the song, and no, the amount of lines she has in a song is not fair, compared to rei and leeseo. You can understand that the company has neglected Gaeul since her debut, with each song she has fewer lines, while other members have practically doubled since their debut. The group's fandom remains in a disconnected Kpop event of only caring about the main positions, such as center, leader and main vocalist, it is frustrating to see how Gaeul is forgotten.
![aespa ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from BLACK MAMBA to WHIPLASH]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/17Q5PecvJ84/mqdefault.jpg)
![aespa ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from BLACK MAMBA to WHIPLASH]](/img/tr.png)
![(CORRECTED) BABYMONSTER ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from SHEESH to DRIP]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mShZHU_BRoY/mqdefault.jpg)
![아이브 원영이VSA초연이 막판에 우는 초연이...[아이브 다이브♡]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mkkscL_pgLE/mqdefault.jpg)
Liz being the main vocalist and the best vocalist being 1st.
Yujin being the second best vocalist being 2nd.
I'm happy with this.
Rei stans honestly deserve the most respect, they are literally the chillest in the fandom. You don’t see them complain unlike certain stans. Till this day, solo toxic stans will hate on wonyoung when she’s not even close to being second or first. Have these stans not learn anything throughout the past years? After she wrote shine with me. It was about the hate that they were facing, yet people still continue to hate on wonyoung for no absolute reason.
rei has many solid lines in other songs and she usually gets to sing the killing part when she has less lines just like in I AM, we're already feel content with it ^^
Rei is my bias 🫶
Rei can have the least lines and she still will shine in her 10-15 seconds
She's just iconic 🛐
Yes I’m a rei stan and this is true lol we’re so chill 😎
Wonyoung carrying this group even hybe know ..
Well as a gaeul stan I won't say gaeul to get more lines but good 2 3 different lines not just repetitive lines ...or just a rap part like in after like ...nothing else i don't want her to top but after looking how she got treated in supernova love ..I can't imagine anything worse ...or the worst could happen is her leaving this group...like no lines......
?! No screentime...no centre part in choreo..at least other members have got their moments..Gaeul is the only one who got ignored ..even dives are not worried about her as they were for liz...
While I also 100% hope Gaeul is featured more and gets more lines, I do actually think that since Switch, Starship is making more of an effort to focus on her. She got to be the lead in the Accendio music video, and in Accendio and Heya’s dances she is featured in the center more (in my opinion). While she doesn’t get a lot of lines in Supernova, I do think she’s featured in the music video much more than Liz or Rei. Try not to worry, I don’t think she’s being forgotten💕
Liz: Queen of first places
Yujin: Queen of second places
Wonyoung: Queen of third places
Iso: Queen of fourth places
Rainy: Queen of fifth places
Autumn: Queen of sixth places.
Very similar to Red Velvet, MISAMO and Everglow.
Iso Rainy and Autumn 😍
Iso rainy and autumn
Stan iso rainy and autumn
How about calling Liz 'Backup' because Jiwon means backup in Korean? And Yujin 'Eugene' and Wonyoung 'Lostold' or 'Wonton'?
the ironic part is toxic dives will collectively shame wonyoung the second she has lines
#LIZ #리즈
#WONYOUNG #원영
#LEESEO #이서
#REI #레이
#YUJIN #유진
#GAEUL #가을
First 🎉 also can you do kep1er all songs to tipi tap
Their line distribution is actually fair- Best & 2nd best vocalist at 1st & 2nd
The rest are pretty similar in vocals & all of IVE can sing
@@Cryforme-leeseo being 3rd isn't fair
@@bahihorselmfao mad asf
@@bahihorse her & wony kept switching for the 3rd place lot of times- if the next album treats leeseo like IVE MINE/SWITCH then prob the gap will increase & they won't switch anymore but if Wony gets Love dive/After like treatment again she'll be 3rd again coz the gap isn't big
So it depends ig 😭
Changing image for every Era no more 😔 So sad... but i understand because it is not that easy to edit 😊
This line district is kind fair-
LIZ-Main Vocalist.
YUJIN-Lead Vocalist.
LEESEO-Sub Vocalist,Sub Rapper.
WONYOUNG-Sub Vocalist
REI-Main Rapper,Sub Vocalist.
GAEUL-Lead Rapper,Sub Vocalist.
Sub vocalist and rapper gets more than a lead rapper and sub vocal
@yoonasclawThey got more lines because IVE is a vocal based group and leeseo and wonyoung have better vocal than gaeul.
i find it funny how everyone always complained that wony got more lines than everyone else when shes literally not been in the top 2 at any point
Yes i think because she's the center, she should have more line in titles
@@quynhnhi0505No she’s not main or lead vocals. She should have least lines.
@@quynhnhi0505 Being center doesn't mean getting more lines, Liz and yujin have more skilled vocal than her soo..
Wony mostly gets a lot of lines in the title tracks, love dive , after like , kitsch and baddie, that's the reason people complain. I mean of course, others should get a chance to shine in title tracks too, and now starship is actually giving the others to shine
@@IsrxtRxmisa i mean she is center, and the one who attracts nonfan the most so it's normal for her to get the highlight part. But recently other members get to shine to. That's a good thing
Liz and Ningning stans are happy they threat the queens as Main Vocals ❤ We are so happy hoping Jihyo will get her justice so the world will totally healed 🎉
30 minutes ago ❤😊
Poor Gaeul got rekt the whole time
❤❤❤
Lips
Heroine
Summer festa
Payback
Off the record
Classic
I want
OTT
Accendio
Misamo Please
Yujin last in supernova love
If iam honest wonyoung get only ton lines in title songs expect heya and iam
She get less in less lines in bsides also i dont get the kpop stans critized her when even she get least lines in her self written bsides for ive.The producers chosed always members fit better and making more noise
They need know wonyoung is the least promoted since 2023 by starship
i think it's still fair even when wonyoung have less lines since she gets a lot of screen times and dance at the center as well so she will still shine when they're performing. she usually gets to open / end some songs. try to see it from every aspects :)
GAEUL DESERVES BETTER!!!
Many will say “she's the worst vocalist in the group that's why she has few lines” it's true, ok I understand you, but that doesn't mean she should always be in the last places, they don't let her shine.
Wony is Lead Vocal and Leeseo is sub vocal
Wonyoung is sub
Lead vocal !? LoL
Gaeul and Liz❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Giselle & Gaeul being the rappers of their group but not having any rap lines lmaooo . Lord I pray everyday that for solo activities that Gaeul and Giselle can have somebody else manage them so they can get dedicated rap verses.
In three years they already have more songs than BP 😐
Toxic ive stans always attack wonyoung for anything
POOR GAEUL im so tired omg its literally unbearable how she gets 0 opportunities to showcase her skills
She IS the weakest singer, so I kind of understand why she has the least lines. she could have more when it comes to more rap ish songs…. But yeah
@@rdpa4019 she barely got Rap parts lately. She's not the weakest vocalist in their group.
@@lisaicanmeow5157 that’s exactly what I am saying. She doesn’t get many rap lines. And she is definitely , by far, the weakest singer in ive
@@rdpa4019 bruh leeseo and wonyoung are weaker vocalists
@@gingerlovesgaeul ????? Whatever, gurl
Average Line Distribution per song
#1 Liz: 30.2 | 20.8%
#2 Yujin: 29.4 | 20.3%
#3 - #4 Wonyoung & Leeseo: 23.9 | 16.5%
#5 Rei: 20.6 | 14.2%
#6 Gaeul: 17 | 11.7%
Variation: 23.4%
Color of Zone: Green
Song count
38 (all members)
Wonyoung deserve better, in izone she always get most line distribution
in Supernova Love, the ranking is :
1st - Rei
2nd - Liz
3rd - Wonyoung
4th - Leeseo
5th - Gaeul
6th - Yujin
where did u get it?
@AnhPhan-kr6lj on Nomallen_k's channel
I don't think Liz is first..
nope corrected ver
1 wonyoung
2 liz
3/4 yujin / leeseo I forgot but they were close to being tied anyway
5 rei
6 gaeul
Rei in first with 4 lines@@turqoisesea4
MISAMO PLEASEEE
어이상실~~
Naoi Rei 😢 she should get more lines
No hate but IVE could remove Leeso and Gauel and stick with Liz, Yujin, Rei and Wonyoung and be just fine.
WDYM no hate? ot6 or none
Now that could happen but they could not bc they have lesseo for vocals and she eats and so does geaul
Leave
They are a group of 6
I mean you're not wrong but groups needs filler members as well .
and still they're always barking about wonyoung
Rei is literally the third best vocalist and main rapper, hope she gets more lines
Gaeul is the second most talented member, hope she gets more lines too
Rap line 💓
Gaeul is great dancer and okay rapper but not stable vocalist in live.
We need Gaeul having rap lines and Rei having more vocal lines
Second most talented? Her best talent is not even that grand in comparison to the next best dancer pls. She’s a dozen.
in All Night, every member has lines...
But that doesn’t count since they all sing together… plus those are just adlibs
Leeseo favoritism why does she get more than wonyoung and rei
Wth are u on
She has less than 2 seconds more than Wonyoung, pls 😭
It’s not that deep the difference between wony and Leeseo is 1.7 seconds
And Gaeul..
@@MrNosyNeasybut Rei ? Rei Is a better vocalist by far
but i thought it was wonyoung and friends??? and that liz was mistreated and always got no lines??? what happened
Next txt pls
Please next video Misamo
So cute how gaeul got no lines in SUPERNOVA LOVE😊
she got a solo line and a chorus part with Rei lmao
You only heard it on TH-cam, but Spotify has the full version
Girl she got like 18 seconds and its a fair track. I get it i ❤ her too! Bit she is more rap based then vocal. But I know she can sing for sure
@@camapdeptrai127nope no chorus...just a line of 6s that was not even in mv ...generally people watch mv how would they get...?
Liz stans need stop blamed the other members because asleast she get most lines and solo schedules than wonyoung and leeseo.
As wonyoung stan i never complaint even we know ive will not this popular Without yujin and wonyoung esp in sales and virality.
It’s not just liz stans, it’s also gaeul stans too!
The amount of time I've seen you in ive content trying to pity wonyoung by painting some1 else as the bad guy is absolutely unhealthy , you're too mentally attached to a celebrity , get help , Liz stans haven't been complaining since baddie era , stop making stories up from you b hole , gaeul stans complains because gaeul hardly gets raps nowadays and neither liz or gaeul stans blamed wonyoung or leeseo(except a few token stans) their blame was always towards starship , wonyoung is quite popular and have more haters in general , anyone can come up to you pretending like a liz stan and hate on wonnie that doesn't mean liz stans are to blame , people always find ways to hate on wonnie and sometimes they use other members as an excuse(you're also part of that problem just in opposite sides).
"As wonyoung stan i never complaint" , hold up right there , you have at least one hundred comment in every ive video complaining about how wonnie is mistreated and reply to almost everyone with an opposing opinion , BFFR right now .
Liz stans are sweet. Wonyoung antis just pretend to be Liz stans
crush line distribution was wrong
According to nayeon and wonhee stans center is supposed to have more lines yet wonyoung has less lines than the weakest vocalist of the group 💀
wonhee?
since when?
Maybe don’t listen to stans. They tend to be biased. Center isn’t “supposed” to have more lines, center traditionally has more center positioning in group formation during choreography, photoshoots etc. hence why the position is called CENTER.
@@bimbean I meant wonyoung
@@Lewis-hl9qwexactly
Supernova love Rei in first place Isn't it?
Liz and Ningning two young women got first place. 🥇🥇
The main vocalist who has been second places for a long time has now successfully taken over number 1 places!
all night still wrong 😑
Nope it’s correct bc that’s their actual lines. The rest are just when they all sing together not counting as actual lines
@ ik but liz has no adlibs in that song (the ones that she "sings" are wonyoung)
Need gaeul to get a bit more n then perfect, may the next comeback be gaeul era
Gaeul is the lead rapper, the main dancer, and she's the third or fourth with the best vocal, why does she always sing so little?
third or fourth is really pushing it her voice doesn't suit the songs as well as the other members and if you listen closely she struggles most with sounding good singing live and english lyric
Gaeul really struggles with vocally challenging lines like in I am, you can hear her voice strain alot.
Vocally I am sure that she is last. She struggles the most even in the easiest lines
fifth or sixth lmao be fr dont listen to kpop vocal "analysts" and their "objective" vocal tier system
Gaeul getting the shit end of the stick again…
The way Liz stans up until now still complaining about having low line is sending me. They see any members have more line than them in a song and they riot.
and people complain about liz lines in kitsch
Leeseo above Wonyoung? Yeah never she's the worst vocal and she's third starship is really waiting for it's downfall
By 2 seconds. You act like it’s by 10 minutes or something.
Wonyoung is only a slightly better vocalist then Leeseo in terms of support. And they basically have the same amount.
by 2 seconds be serious now
@@fawkiouuuggi don't mean by wony favouritism because its too far from the concept…im talking about how startship started to give more rap lines to leeseo instead to gaeul that its the lead rapper,rei got some justice but gaeul really was robbed!! wony can also be bad or good but i dont forget she’s te reason why starship still gain money!! and you can see that leeseo is not enough powerful as gaeul to rap that much
@@superbluerock8327what i meant is that leeseo took the rap parts so thats why its more than wony rei and gaeul because she rapped and almost have not given a lot of vocal time! She is not that good and at least give some proper time screen to wony,vocal and rap to rei and gaeul because how its going it reminds me of after like era
all night is wrong wonyoung and yuijn are the only members who had lines
All night was ot6
No Liz has some adlibs too
@@Teecvpliz’s adlib was wony
@@thatoneperson731 liz and wonnie has completely different voice if you confuse between their voice you need some help , the adlibs were liz , yujin and wony at the last .
Now that Liz is in first place, fans are turning a blind eye to the group's poor distribution of lines. It has been so unfair to see how fans have absolute favoritism for such an artist, it's disgusting.
Gaeul hardly sings, she's always the one with the least lines, the one with the least amount of prominence, as a fan of the group and observing that the fandom ignores the situation, it makes me angry, because when Liz didn't have her position as Main vocalist in the distribution lines, everyone cried, said she deserved more and Gaeul? Doesn't deserve more? Doesn't deserve better and fairer lines? Or the problem Is it just because the main vocalist isn't on top? Hypocritical Dives
maybe she hardly sings cause she cant really sing...
@phenobarbidolI She doesn't sing because her parts are going to other people in the group, since her position is rapper, it doesn't make sense for wony to take the rap, for leeseo to take the rap, it doesn't make sense. But the fandom is hypocritical and only "fought" because the main vocalist was in 2nd place in the distribution lines, when she literally got a single song with 9s of participation.
Keep defending Liz's position and ignoring the fact that Gaeul is extremely erased from the group with each comeback, you guys are disgusting
@@eupedromarcello and why are you writing a whole paragraph here about liz? i havent said a single word about her, in this i agree with you, it was comical when everyone was crying cause she got little lines in just one song when she sung the most in the whole album; with gaeul, well, these arent her lines if she wasnt given them so i dont know how is anyone "taking" anything from her, where it wasnt hers in the first place, for me she has adequate amount of lines for what she brings, but again, i do agree that they shouldnt cut out her verse from the mv version of this song and leaving her out on this
@phenobarbidolI The problem isn't even not appearing in the mv, but not having enough lines within the song, and no, the amount of lines she has in a song is not fair, compared to rei and leeseo.
You can understand that the company has neglected Gaeul since her debut, with each song she has fewer lines, while other members have practically doubled since their debut. The group's fandom remains in a disconnected Kpop event of only caring about the main positions, such as center, leader and main vocalist, it is frustrating to see how Gaeul is forgotten.
Wonyoung is first in supernova love not liz
Count the adlibis
@@BESTENHIVEoh thanks
@@BESTENHIVEsorry 😅
Why Yujin always get first place in LD? Liz is main vocal of IVE
Are u blind? Liz literally has more 1st places than her overall💀?
@@no4528 FR like liz has a lot of songs where she is first
I hate Liz because look at her, she’s always first like Nayeon and Taehyun
its not her fault same as nayeon and taehyun?
IT WAS HER FAULT!!!
@@Lena-i6b3d footy know what a main vocalist is ofc she is going to get more lines…
She is the best vocalist by a far distance and she deserves first
Wow , someone show the over obsessed wonyoung stan in this comment section that other members also get hate .
❤❤❤