Absolutely fine tho since they both have similar vocal tone and vocal ranges. Wonyoung is the centre while leeseo is the 3rd best dancer and rapper Makes sense
Gaeul slays as usual and always, if Starship doesn’t want to give her lines, then she deserves more dance breaks ngl. They are literally messing with her talent.
Average Line Distribution per song Liz: 29.4 | 20.5% Yujin: 29 | 20.3% Leeseo: 23.7 | 16.6% Wonyoung: 23.6 | 16.5% Rei: 20.4 | 14.3% Gaeul: 17 | 11.9% Variation: 20.1% Color of Zone: Green
I see lot of people saying "y'all liz stans always complain" but these days i don't see people talking the same about Gaeul token stans who hate Leeseo soo much- Ig a lot of people stopped complaining bout Liz lines now but they're using Gaeul to hate Leeseo even more now
Right, and it's pretty stupid because technically, Leeseo is a better vocalist than Gaeul, and in their recent raps, honestly, Leeseo's tone fits better than Gaeul's, especially in accendio
@@C0SM1CLABELSfr gaeul's stans always spread fake facts about how leeseo is the "worst vocalist" in IVE, like MY BROTHER IN CHRIST tf are u talking about, your fav is the real worst one here 😭 gaeul cant even hold a tune to save herself in encores 💀
@@hamstatouillelol if she's worst vocalist then why suddenly they started giving her more vocal lines?? You always blame liz and gaeul stans bcz ur fav never got 5s or 8s or leftovers or repetitive lines in a song..ngl leeseo is a good singer n stable in live but still she has worst technique...just listen to the exact last part of "crush" n try to differtiate between wonyoung and leeseo ..
@@YUNJENNIFERFirst of all she is E+ since she improved drastically in less than a month.Second of all Yujin is the centre,best dancer,best performer,2nd best vocalist
@@YUNJENNIFERu r dvmb that doesn't mean anything at the end Wonyoung is certainly not the best vocalist in the group but she has a great tone and she fits most of her lines, same applies to Yujin, it's nlt their fault liz voice is not as versatile as them, yes she is the best vocalist in IVE, but something Jiwon lacks is emotion in her deliver, that's something Yujin and Wonyoung has Like support is not the only thing that matters when you are doing a line distribution LMFAO, y'all don't know sh1t about how music works
@@GarikArakelyan-ne3pv GAEUL is the best dancer, but I will deal with you according to your stup¡d¡ty. What does dancing have to do with line distribution?
It really isn’t. Stylistic and technique wise speaking she is the weakest vocalist, but I do gotta say that she is non-officially the lead rapper and Lesseo has been taking some of her rap lines ‘away’ from her in the resent comeback, which is kind of sad, since Gaeul already had the least amount of lines. I do gotta admit tho, that Lesseo’s voice suits some rap lines better than Gaeul’s, like the one in Accendio. Both of them have good vocal colors for rap lines tho but I do hope to hear Gaeul rap more in the future🥰
Liz - Main Vocalist. Yujin - Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Leader. Wonyoung - Sub Vocalist, Center, Visual. Leeseo - Sub Vocalist. Rei - Main Rapper, Sub Vocalist. Gaeul - Lead Rapper, Lead Dancer, Sub Vocalist.
@@zachyzxchzach The person who wrote these are mostly wrong, I checked their profile, leeseo is vocalist and sub rapper , and rei is also vocalist, wony is vocalist and dancer, visual is her side role, yujin is main dancer only, there is no lead vocalist yet I think, and gaeul is lead rapper, instead of seeing ppls roles , I think u should try to see the profile from chrome, which actually has right info, even my roles can be wrong so please check the correct roles
@@HaewonVoiceCrack nope , vocalist is a role , but sub vocalist is a half role, that means they will do vocals sometimes not all the time, So you mean does vocals sometimes and wonyoung does vocals sometimes? Don't reply back to me without knowing what your actually gonna say
Go listen to accendio and may lily and you'll see that leeseo is a better vocalist than Rei and gaeul yes they rap better than her but when it comes to vocal leeseo is much better
how is liz only have one 5th place when she's fifth in both love dive and after like(few other songs as well , maybe) . Also there are other videos where yujin is still first and wonyoung is 3rd while leeseo is 4th , so IDK if those videos were wrong or of this one is .
They have no offical positions This is what they recived credit: (based on eleven jp ver id photocard) Gaeul: rapper Yujin: Leader, Vocalist Rei: Vocalist, Rapper Wonyoung: Vocalist Liz: Vocalist Leeseo: Vocalist
? yall act like she gets 5 seconds every comeback. its embarrassing how she only got 6 seconds once and people act like thats the her average amount of lines.
@@Chuu27692They do have official positions. They are listed on their Melon Music profiles and Rei herself confirmed her position of Main Rapper on Lee MinJu service. Liz is Main Vocalist.
They're all very equal but Wony and Leeseo are def the best after the main and lead, Leeseo used to be lower but she improved a lot and Won't has always been good. Idk why y'all always complain when it's literally so fair
@@chewingonchewy7877 theyre not, both are squeaky and nasally when doing higher notes while rei and gaeul’s notes are overall more supported and stable. the fact that wonyoung and leeseo got more vocal lines to demonstrate their abilities doesn’t mean nothing when rei nor gaeul get them to do so as well 😭
@@Chuu27692what do u mean it's just fine she's a better vocalist then lesso and won young go look it up don't make u r own rankings according to u r biases lesso is a terrible vocalist she strains the he'll out of her voice
Liz primera como debe ser😻🩵, creo que es una distribución justa, Liz de primera ya que es la vocalista principal y Yujin de segunda por su gran voz, Leeseo de tercera ya que es rapera y vocalista, Wonyoung cuarta, y rei y gaeul de últimas, solo sería bueno si rei y gaeul tuvieran más líneas pero es muy justo, además es muy alegre ver a Liz de primera ella se lo merece🥳😻🩵
@@zachyzxchzach in all night only wonyoung and yujin do the adlibs since "liz" highnote is actually wonyoung andin wow considering wony is 2nd in this video they probably counted the wowowow in the post chorus as wony when its the bg vocal
Are you okay bro?? Hating on an innocent girl is not looking good for you my guy. Also weird to say someone is better than the other when they're literally friends. Kinda gross tbh @@mariqilieva6650
You guys dont fight over the vocal rankings this is from a thechnical viewpoint 1 liz(can support) 2 yunjin (can support) 3 rei (can support inconsistently) 4 gaeul (can almost support and rarely did) 5 wonyoung (never supported but good execution) 6 lesso (strains her voice not even close to support) You can have u r own opinions this according to vocal teirs u r believe in vocal teirs is upto u
Wrong The vocal ranking is 1. Liz 2. Yujin 3. Wonyoung 4. Rei 5. Leeseo 6. Gaeul It is consistent and even co relates to their their skills shown in live. Gaeul is a weak singer. Rei, Leeseo and Wonyoung on the other hand are average. Support is not the only factor and I can prove you that
For All Night you have to count all the lines, even if they're singing together, because if you count only adlibs, Gaeul, Leeseo & Rei seem to have no lines
liz gaining her first place even after the terrible lines she received between the love dive and the either way era!! still pissed they gave the MAIN vocalist just 5 seconds in a song, gosh. FIRST PLACE DESERVED
@@miam_k oh that's not... ive don't have fixed positions but we all assume she and Liz are main vocalists cause she's the one who got all of the highnotes instead of Liz
@@pedrovittor6794 Liz is a way better vocalist than Yujin Liz is the main vocalist and Yujin is the lead obviously they're not official positions but it's generally accepted lead vocalist doesn't mean she doesn't sing high notes and should have less lines lead vocalists who have more lines and high notes than main vocalists in kpop are very common
All the comebacks in which Yujin was first were a great success, the first era with Liz first in the distributions was weak and without much prominence, take a good look at how this will be.
Well in that case baddie era wasn't a great success either where yujin was 1st ..n most dives say that baddie was worst era..so please don't use this type of stupid reason lol
@@atmybest4980 But I think you didn't understand my reasoning, however there's no point in explaining it. Baddie wasn't a good song, Either Way even less so, Off the Record has the same cool touch as After Like and still wasn't a big hit. I'm not here to defend Yujin at #1 in distribution lines but we know that all comebacks, including Baddie, were a real success, you may not like it, but you never said you didn't listen to it or that it wasn't well reproduced outside Korea. The truth is just like what you don't accept, Liz's vocals are great, but they don't stand out at all and don't enhance any of IVE's songs.
@@eupedromarcello So it's just ur opinion ig bcz for some it stands out...n heya era was actually good too but they weren't able to promote properly it has nothing to do with who sings..Yujin is good vocalist n 2nd doesn't mean she stands out the most n remember yujin was never 1st in any of the title tracks except off the record .Their best song should be "I am" where liz was 1st .lol even they pre released kitsch bcz liz had 5 s n it was a best marketing strategy ..yujin also has tons of lines..and as a vocalist liz>>>>>yujin..
Liz has the most lines but her stans always complained the most out of all the other akgaes lmao. Literally everywhere is just "Liz being treated so unfair" even during Kitsch era, Liz line distribution is already high.
You act like she’s the one choosing the lines🤦♀️ don’t be stupid . Producers only care about the quality of the song and who can do it better. Nobody is greedy for having more parts.
@@MYænter being the centre doesn't give you priority. Centre is only there to represent the groups concept while distributors are in charge of giving the lines.
I find it funny that Liz's fans say that Yujin can handle F+ and E+ notes, when clearly Yujin does very well when it comes to live vocals, the living proof was Heya's lives during the tour.Furthermore, I haven't seen liz realize any vocal potential with high notes other than the choruses of I AM, which are sung at a high pitch, I believe that vocal tier, I believe that Yujin still has a certain vocal prominence precisely because she can sing live and have great techniques, which in this case demonstrates that the vocal tier is something only used by fans to justify such positions of their favorites, since all members of any group can sing and perform good vocals live.
@@eupedromarcellovocal tiers only say vocal techniques wise, other than that it is really vague. It excludes musical genre, the way that the vocalist expresses their voice and musical interpretation. The criteria of vocal tiers are exclusive to european classical music, that’s why their not accurate and the vocal tier enthusiasts should keep that in mind tbh
Bsfr Leeseo is a better vocalist than Gaeul and on par with Rei, and in terms of the rap lines she's been getting, her tone fits those lines better than Gaeul's especially in accendio it's not favoritism it's called distributing the lines to where it'll sound better on the song Gaeul is a good rapper but her tone doesn't fit the rap lines like Leeseo's does
@tzuyu1989 hun Leeseo improved, Gaeul was never much of a stable vocalist to begin with, and Rei was a decent vocalist and now Leeseo is a little bit worse than Rei but still better than Gaeul
@tzuyu1989 Leeseo isn't stealing her lines she just suits the rap lines more than Gaeul does. Leeseo's voice is better suited for Ive's raps at the moment
![NewJeans ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from ATTENTION to SUPERNATURAL]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cqodAaNQXC0/mqdefault.jpg)
![IZ*ONE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from La Vie En Rose to Panorama]](/img/n.gif)
Wonyoung and Leeseo fighting for 3rd place as always....
They switch like every era lmao 😂
I think they weren't fighting but the ones who fight are watchers😅
Absolutely fine tho since they both have similar vocal tone and vocal ranges. Wonyoung is the centre while leeseo is the 3rd best dancer and rapper Makes sense
@@anisaafsar4528yeah but now starship doesn’t use gaeul as rapper anymore, they now give raps to leeseo
@@anisaafsar4528she isn’t a rapper, but anyway
：*Number of 6th places*
Gaeul：Everybody move, MY TIME TO SHINE🫦💅✨️
Gaeul slays as usual and always, if Starship doesn’t want to give her lines, then she deserves more dance breaks ngl. They are literally messing with her talent.
🫦🫦🫦🫦🫦🫦
@@AlineDominoOFFICIALFrrr I want her to lead dance breaks so much 😭
@@jocelyn_wcy Ikr, like she’s an icon
LIZ 🔥 YUJIN
WONYOUNG 🔥 LEESEO
REI, GAEUL : 😋🍿🥤
Literally so fair and Liz has her #no.1 spot taken🎉❤ queen
Average Line Distribution per song
Liz: 29.4 | 20.5%
Yujin: 29 | 20.3%
Leeseo: 23.7 | 16.6%
Wonyoung: 23.6 | 16.5%
Rei: 20.4 | 14.3%
Gaeul: 17 | 11.9%
Variation: 20.1%
Color of Zone: Green
Without kitsch liz get 29.6
@@mr.farkhan563why would u remove kitsch
@@mr.farkhan563 Why? It doesn’t work that way.
Omg 😲 JiWon Is 1st now Omg this is fair with some lines to Rei 🥺😭
Thanks for your work♡
I read it thanks for lines 😂
🫶🏼
@@JIHYO.Y.Y. omg loll
@k-stat omg stats reply to u jiwon 😲
@@JIHYO.Y.Y. Bestieee lmao its just a survival sjow character😂😂
I see lot of people saying "y'all liz stans always complain" but these days i don't see people talking the same about Gaeul token stans who hate Leeseo soo much-
Ig a lot of people stopped complaining bout Liz lines now but they're using Gaeul to hate Leeseo even more now
Right, and it's pretty stupid because technically, Leeseo is a better vocalist than Gaeul, and in their recent raps, honestly, Leeseo's tone fits better than Gaeul's, especially in accendio
@@C0SM1CLABELSfr gaeul's stans always spread fake facts about how leeseo is the "worst vocalist" in IVE, like MY BROTHER IN CHRIST tf are u talking about, your fav is the real worst one here 😭 gaeul cant even hold a tune to save herself in encores 💀
@@hamstatouillelol if she's worst vocalist then why suddenly they started giving her more vocal lines?? You always blame liz and gaeul stans bcz ur fav never got 5s or 8s or leftovers or repetitive lines in a song..ngl leeseo is a good singer n stable in live but still she has worst technique...just listen to the exact last part of "crush" n try to differtiate between wonyoung and leeseo ..
@@hamstatouille youre complaining about leeseo hate but youre hating on gaeul? hypocrite
Yujin in first: “Unfair, the distributions are so unfair, how angry”
Liz in first: “Very fair, how wonderful”
Dives are too hypocritical
Because LIZ is the main vocalist, her support range is D+, while YUJIN is lead vocalist, and her support range is F+
@@YUNJENNIFERFirst of all she is E+ since she improved drastically in less than a month.Second of all Yujin is the centre,best dancer,best performer,2nd best vocalist
@@YUNJENNIFERu r dvmb that doesn't mean anything at the end
Wonyoung is certainly not the best vocalist in the group but she has a great tone and she fits most of her lines, same applies to Yujin, it's nlt their fault liz voice is not as versatile as them, yes she is the best vocalist in IVE, but something Jiwon lacks is emotion in her deliver, that's something Yujin and Wonyoung has
Like support is not the only thing that matters when you are doing a line distribution LMFAO, y'all don't know sh1t about how music works
@@GarikArakelyan-ne3pv
GAEUL is the best dancer, but I will deal with you according to your stup¡d¡ty. What does dancing have to do with line distribution?
@@CoversB
Have you finished or not yet?
That's so unfair for Gaeul😭
It's fair tho?? Bro try stanning everglow 💀💀
It really isn’t. Stylistic and technique wise speaking she is the weakest vocalist, but I do gotta say that she is non-officially the lead rapper and Lesseo has been taking some of her rap lines ‘away’ from her in the resent comeback, which is kind of sad, since Gaeul already had the least amount of lines. I do gotta admit tho, that Lesseo’s voice suits some rap lines better than Gaeul’s, like the one in Accendio. Both of them have good vocal colors for rap lines tho but I do hope to hear Gaeul rap more in the future🥰
@@michellinkapawlowski1795
Ive vocal ranking
1.Liz
2.Yujin
3.Rei
4.GAEUL
5.Wonyoung
6.Leeseo
@@Twasklarim
Liz
Yujin
Rei
Wonyoung
Leeseo
Gaeul
@@Chuu27692no wonyoung and lesseo are the weakest vocalists be fr
I'm so happy for Liz 🎉
Liz - Main Vocalist.
Yujin - Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Leader.
Wonyoung - Sub Vocalist, Center, Visual.
Leeseo - Sub Vocalist.
Rei - Main Rapper, Sub Vocalist.
Gaeul - Lead Rapper, Lead Dancer, Sub Vocalist.
Wony is vocalist and leeseo is sub rapper dude, the roles will change continuously these years , until they start another 7 years contract
Gaeul is no longer treated like rapper anymore😭
@@zachyzxchzach The person who wrote these are mostly wrong, I checked their profile, leeseo is vocalist and sub rapper , and rei is also vocalist, wony is vocalist and dancer, visual is her side role, yujin is main dancer only, there is no lead vocalist yet I think, and gaeul is lead rapper, instead of seeing ppls roles , I think u should try to see the profile from chrome, which actually has right info, even my roles can be wrong so please check the correct roles
@@IsrxtRxmisasub-vocalist and vocalist are the same.
@@HaewonVoiceCrack nope , vocalist is a role , but sub vocalist is a half role, that means they will do vocals sometimes not all the time, So you mean does vocals sometimes and wonyoung does vocals sometimes? Don't reply back to me without knowing what your actually gonna say
Slayyyyyy ATEEEEE PERIOD ❤😊
Is there a possibility you will bring back the center vs edge distribution especially for Itzy???
I want it for all groups 😢
queen liz ate❤
Liz has been getting so many 1st places recently omg 😭
Liz really SWITCHED with Yujin & took her 1st place in IVE SWITCH era after 2½ years
gaeul😢
Leeseo is being so pushed when Gaeul and Rei are better rappers and vocalists than her...
no they're not LMFAO😭 rei is a better rapper but none of them are better vocalists💀💀💀
Gaeul isnt a better vocalist than Leeseo
@@swtvicRei is
@@swtvicand Gaeul is a better rapper
Go listen to accendio and may lily and you'll see that leeseo is a better vocalist than Rei and gaeul yes they rap better than her but when it comes to vocal leeseo is much better
how is liz only have one 5th place when she's fifth in both love dive and after like(few other songs as well , maybe) . Also there are other videos where yujin is still first and wonyoung is 3rd while leeseo is 4th , so IDK if those videos were wrong or of this one is .
Liz is 4th in love dive
2 hours ago 🤩😍
17 mins ago! Btw it is a great video❤❤
🫶🏼
@@k-stat❤❤
I love Gaeul
*Number of 1st places*
Yujin:FINALLY IT'S MY CHAMPION
LOL😂
Liz:I am first
Yujin:what
Please do wayv
I’m so happy that Liz is now becoming a main vocal position
They have no offical positions
This is what they recived credit: (based on eleven jp ver id photocard)
Gaeul: rapper
Yujin: Leader, Vocalist
Rei: Vocalist, Rapper
Wonyoung: Vocalist
Liz: Vocalist
Leeseo: Vocalist
? yall act like she gets 5 seconds every comeback. its embarrassing how she only got 6 seconds once and people act like thats the her average amount of lines.
@@Chuu27692They do have official positions. They are listed on their Melon Music profiles and Rei herself confirmed her position of Main Rapper on Lee MinJu service. Liz is Main Vocalist.
Starship should see this and give gaeul more lines like 100+ seconds less than the the second last is just crazy
가을이 파트좀 줘...
Can you for unis
2 hours!!
gaeul and rei being the best vocalists after liz and yujin, and the best rappers in the group and yet they’re last by far 😭
Gaeul is no way a good vocalist she is the last
@@minjunim0Don't lie to yourself
@@minjunim0 have u even heard her
They're all very equal but Wony and Leeseo are def the best after the main and lead, Leeseo used to be lower but she improved a lot and Won't has always been good. Idk why y'all always complain when it's literally so fair
@@chewingonchewy7877 theyre not, both are squeaky and nasally when doing higher notes while rei and gaeul’s notes are overall more supported and stable. the fact that wonyoung and leeseo got more vocal lines to demonstrate their abilities doesn’t mean nothing when rei nor gaeul get them to do so as well 😭
in all night liz there are no lines
She has a high note
@@Chuu27692thats wonyoung
Lia has no lines
Yes only yujin and wony have adlibs
She has a little high note bit
Wonyoung and Gaeul deserve more lines😭😭😭
No they don't, they're just Fine, the one who deserves more is Rei
@@Chuu27692 wdym “just fine”, it’s so unfair for Gaeul. Wony also is starting to not get lines.
@@Chuu27692 rei has plenty of lines for her position. Rei is my bias.
@@Chuu27692what do u mean it's just fine she's a better vocalist then lesso and won young go look it up don't make u r own rankings according to u r biases lesso is a terrible vocalist she strains the he'll out of her voice
@@Justbechill1548 all of IVE can sing
leeseo vs rei ❌
wonyoung vs leeseo ✅
wonyoung vs liz ❌
liz vs yujin ✅
You should do Xg
next ive all line distribution from eleven to crush
Liz primera como debe ser😻🩵, creo que es una distribución justa, Liz de primera ya que es la vocalista principal y Yujin de segunda por su gran voz, Leeseo de tercera ya que es rapera y vocalista, Wonyoung cuarta, y rei y gaeul de últimas, solo sería bueno si rei y gaeul tuvieran más líneas pero es muy justo, además es muy alegre ver a Liz de primera ella se lo merece🥳😻🩵
wow & all night are wrong
no
@@zachyzxchzach in all night only wonyoung and yujin do the adlibs since "liz" highnote is actually wonyoung andin wow considering wony is 2nd in this video they probably counted the wowowow in the post chorus as wony when its the bg vocal
Liz and Gaeul ❤🤍🩶🖤🤎💜🩵💙💚🧡💛🩷❤️🩹❤️🔥❣️💟💕💞💓💗💖💝💘💌
U forgot all night wony is first in it so 4 1st places for wony
나는 리즈보다 유지니가 좋이니 됨
엥 원영 유진 리즈 이서 레이 가을인줄 알았는데
Well.. this is terrible as always. Idk why leeseo is pushed so much
And Wonyoung too, Gaeul is better than Wony and Lesseo in EVERY single category (not including visual)
Are you okay bro?? Hating on an innocent girl is not looking good for you my guy. Also weird to say someone is better than the other when they're literally friends. Kinda gross tbh @@mariqilieva6650
Man wdym?? The main and lead are 1st, everyone has been 1st and last, it's so fair and dude is still complaining and now hating on a minor
@chewingonchewy7877 I'm not hating on anyone. I'm just saying facts dude 👍
@@mariqilieva6650no you're not. "Gaeul is better than her in every way" is just... That's not... No. Also it's just plain false
You guys dont fight over the vocal rankings this is from a thechnical viewpoint
1 liz(can support)
2 yunjin (can support)
3 rei (can support inconsistently)
4 gaeul (can almost support and rarely did)
5 wonyoung (never supported but good execution)
6 lesso (strains her voice not even close to support)
You can have u r own opinions this according to vocal teirs u r believe in vocal teirs is upto u
Wrong
The vocal ranking is
1. Liz
2. Yujin
3. Wonyoung
4. Rei
5. Leeseo
6. Gaeul
It is consistent and even co relates to their their skills shown in live. Gaeul is a weak singer. Rei, Leeseo and Wonyoung on the other hand are average.
Support is not the only factor and I can prove you that
For All Night you have to count all the lines, even if they're singing together, because if you count only adlibs, Gaeul, Leeseo & Rei seem to have no lines
girl cry more💀
@@Lovewinter19 did I ask for your opinion ? I don't think so
@@julesfoury9240 lol stay mad
@@Lovewinter19 you're funny
@@julesfoury9240 and ur sad bye
liz gaining her first place even after the terrible lines she received between the love dive and the either way era!!
still pissed they gave the MAIN vocalist just 5 seconds in a song, gosh. FIRST PLACE DESERVED
Yujin is also the main vocalist and deserves these lines much more
@@pedrovittor6794Yujin is the lead vocalist
@@miam_k oh that's not... ive don't have fixed positions but we all assume she and Liz are main vocalists cause she's the one who got all of the highnotes instead of Liz
@@pedrovittor6794 Liz is a way better vocalist than Yujin
Liz is the main vocalist and Yujin is the lead
obviously they're not official positions but it's generally accepted
lead vocalist doesn't mean she doesn't sing high notes and should have less lines
lead vocalists who have more lines and high notes than main vocalists in kpop are very common
@@miam_k if you think
Sonyoung and Faeul deserve more lines
No, they're fine
wow r those new members
All the comebacks in which Yujin was first were a great success, the first era with Liz first in the distributions was weak and without much prominence, take a good look at how this will be.
Well in that case baddie era wasn't a great success either where yujin was 1st ..n most dives say that baddie was worst era..so please don't use this type of stupid reason lol
@@atmybest4980 But I think you didn't understand my reasoning, however there's no point in explaining it. Baddie wasn't a good song, Either Way even less so, Off the Record has the same cool touch as After Like and still wasn't a big hit.
I'm not here to defend Yujin at #1 in distribution lines but we know that all comebacks, including Baddie, were a real success, you may not like it, but you never said you didn't listen to it or that it wasn't well reproduced outside Korea.
The truth is just like what you don't accept, Liz's vocals are great, but they don't stand out at all and don't enhance any of IVE's songs.
@@eupedromarcello So it's just ur opinion ig bcz for some it stands out...n heya era was actually good too but they weren't able to promote properly it has nothing to do with who sings..Yujin is good vocalist n 2nd doesn't mean she stands out the most n remember yujin was never 1st in any of the title tracks except off the record .Their best song should be "I am" where liz was 1st .lol even they pre released kitsch bcz liz had 5 s n it was a best marketing strategy ..yujin also has tons of lines..and as a vocalist liz>>>>>yujin..
Liz has the most lines but her stans always complained the most out of all the other akgaes lmao. Literally everywhere is just "Liz being treated so unfair" even during Kitsch era, Liz line distribution is already high.
Atleast wonyoung isn't greedy in line distribution if she did she will get hate
You act like she’s the one choosing the lines🤦♀️ don’t be stupid . Producers only care about the quality of the song and who can do it better.
Nobody is greedy for having more parts.
@Noble482 Since she's the center of the group, she will possibility be the most prioritized, and she will get hated
@@MYænter being the centre doesn't give you priority. Centre is only there to represent the groups concept while distributors are in charge of giving the lines.
We want Yujin back on the first place(((
I find it funny that Liz's fans say that Yujin can handle F+ and E+ notes, when clearly Yujin does very well when it comes to live vocals, the living proof was Heya's lives during the tour.Furthermore, I haven't seen liz realize any vocal potential with high notes other than the choruses of I AM, which are sung at a high pitch, I believe that vocal tier, I believe that Yujin still has a certain vocal prominence precisely because she can sing live and have great techniques, which in this case demonstrates that the vocal tier is something only used by fans to justify such positions of their favorites, since all members of any group can sing and perform good vocals live.
High notes don't define whos better
@@Chuu27692 Vocal tier too
@@eupedromarcellovocal tiers only say vocal techniques wise, other than that it is really vague. It excludes musical genre, the way that the vocalist expresses their voice and musical interpretation. The criteria of vocal tiers are exclusive to european classical music, that’s why their not accurate and the vocal tier enthusiasts should keep that in mind tbh
Give more lines to Yujin and Wonyoung
R u doing drugs?
Hoping that Wonyoung favoritism will be back again. She still can't catch up to the two.
No
Wony never faced any favouritism she's literally only 1st in 3 songs which are title tracks to gain attention bcs she's the most popular
@@mariqilieva6650 yep because the new favored one has an annoying rap tone. But that girl is still a nice singer.
@@chewingonchewy7877 yep that was the era that I missed 🥹
@@coziamsaltysweeeeetyou're talking about favored as if you know what that feels like, we know your parents don't favor you enough☹️
I Hope Yujin First Again In Their Next Comeback 😍🙏🏻
No
No
No
No, Yujin is a great ace, but Liz is the best vocalist
Yes, I hope too
leeseo favoritism
Bsfr Leeseo is a better vocalist than Gaeul and on par with Rei, and in terms of the rap lines she's been getting, her tone fits those lines better than Gaeul's especially in accendio it's not favoritism it's called distributing the lines to where it'll sound better on the song Gaeul is a good rapper but her tone doesn't fit the rap lines like Leeseo's does
@@C0SM1CLABELS 💀 leeseo is not better than gaeul neither on par with rei if anything it's the opposite
@@C0SM1CLABELS gaeul used to get rap lines before leeseo started stealing all her lines with her baby voice
@tzuyu1989 hun Leeseo improved, Gaeul was never much of a stable vocalist to begin with, and Rei was a decent vocalist and now Leeseo is a little bit worse than Rei but still better than Gaeul
@tzuyu1989 Leeseo isn't stealing her lines she just suits the rap lines more than Gaeul does. Leeseo's voice is better suited for Ive's raps at the moment
Yujin will be 1st next comeback 🙏🙏🙏
No
No
No
we hope!
Yes 🙌🏼
Liz got her revenge
I'm just joking not hating or comparing between the members
????
Yall are weird
Yall acting as if this is a competition💀
She was never below second bfr💀 she's my bias but she has never gotten lack of lines except in kitsch.
@@shajisudhakaran9269 and even in kitsch she sang the chorus which is the 15+ seconds each💀