🆕🎦 Get our updates directly on WHATSAPP and catch our videos as soon as they’re released. CLICK HERE ➡ bit.ly/News_Backing_Track_Center ⬅ 🟥🟫🟧🟨🟩🟦🟪🟦🟩🟨🟧🟫🟥🟫🟧🟨🟩🟦🟪🟦🟩
Richtig, die Verantwortlichen für die Liste haben wirklich keine Ahnung von der Musik aus den 70ern und Krautrock. Frumpy auf Platz 19 und Birth Control Platz 15 sind dazu noch Unverschämtheiten. Es fehlen auch Atlantis bzw. Kin Pin Meh etc.
First time heard 1981 in Hamburg CCH when I served for Bundeswehr. Decades later a few times more in west of Germany, one time in Westfalen Stadion BVB. DO YOU HEAR SOLAR MUSIC GREAT SONG ALWAYS DIFFERENT INTERPRATED.
Da fehlen aber viele Rockbands, eher Prog Rock fehlen: Lucifer's Friend, Nektar, Epitaph, Kin-Ping-Meh aus MA, Embryo, Wind aus Nürnberg, Parzival, Bröselmaschine, Dies Irae, Kraan, Hoelderlin, Message, Ihre Kinder, Neuschwanstein, Wallenstein u.viele mehr !
Stimmt, es gibt viele gute Bands in der deutschen Progressive-Szene, ich denke, die Liste musste Platz für mindestens 40 Bands bieten. Danke für deinen Kommentar!
Epitaph, Kraan und Wind, einer der wenigen deutschen Bands mit internationaler Klasse. In dein "und viele mehr" gehört bestimmt auch noch Nine Days Wonder 🙂
@@tomtrana3449 stimmt aber auch Triumvirat und Lucifers Friend, Banquet von denen ist eines der besten ProgRock Alben die ich kenne u. hatte.......Nine days Wonder waren auch aus MA.
Nice list ! Thank you ! Tangerine dream is my favorite, but the most of them I don't know. Here in Brazil, some Kraftwerk and Triunvirat albums made some success. But here in Brazil, the most appreciated German musicians are Beethoven, Bach, Schubert and, of course, Skorpions, Michael Schenker and Uli Jon Roth...Serious !!!
I'm glad you liked the list. Having access to records from more specific musical movements, especially from the 70s, has always been expensive. We end up having to settle for the more popular ones! Thanks for commenting! 🎸
La Düsseldorf, Neu! and Faust should be in the top 5. And Can should be number 1. They were way ahead of the rest - except for perhaps Kraftwerk who achieved real international mega status.
La Düsseldorf, Neu! and Faust have a unique sound and deserve to be among the best. Can is truly revolutionary! A list of 20 shows us the elite of the style, so everyone on it is highly regarded. Thanks for commenting!
I can agree with most of the bands mentioned. But instead of Triumvirat and Eloy, I would have chosen Kraan and Embryo, at least in a top 20. I saw most of the bands you mentioned live. Greatest singer was and still is Inga Rumpf of Frumpy and later Atlantis. Others in your list struggle with the English language quite a bit. In particular Triumvirat. And they wrote silly lyrics like "it was shortly after nine, when they started the new time" (from Spartacus).
Interesting! Triumvirat and Eloy lean more symphonic, while Kraan and Embryo have a jazzier vibe. Just a matter of style, right? Inga Rumpf is fantastic, no doubt! I agree that Triumvirat sometimes went a bit heavy with the lyrics. Thanks for commenting!
Man, those three are truly essential! Each with their unique style. Amon Düül II, especially, is such a trip. Which album of theirs do you like the most?
É complicado, tem de importar se quiser a mídia física de alguns desses gigantes do krautrock, e custa o olho da cara! Mas, se você já tem esses, então tá bem amparado, só banda boa!
Great list my friend and I am happy to see Faust, Kraftwerk and Frumpy. Missing is Nina Hagen Band. Multigenre mix of Krautrock, Punk, Rock and Opera. The Rattles must be also on this list with their song "The Witch". Krautock meets Psychedelica.
These bands are definitely great! GILA has a very atmospheric and engaging sound. Great suggestions that will be considered for a second part. Thanks for the collaboration!
Excellent list of German Kraut/Prog Bands. My personal order would be different e.g. Frumpy in the Top 3 and including Klaus Schulze - in my Top 3 as well.
Cool, everyone has their own personal order, right? Frumpy in the top 3 is an interesting opinion that I personally share, and Klaus Schulze definitely deserves a mention, the guy is huge!
For sure, Kraan is a unique band, and a lot of people really miss them on the list. Which of their albums would you consider the best? Thanks for your comment!
Thanks for liking the video! It seems like the list would be really interesting with the inclusion of bands like Wallenstein and Hoelderlin. What would be your top 5?
Great list delighted to see Triumvirat on there , I ‘ m a German Keyboard prog nut so also love bands like Amos Key , Odin, Minus Two and especially Sixty Nine
That's true! Kraan, Schulze, and Satin Whale are amazing, each with their unique style! German progressive rock has so much diversity and quality. Which band do you listen to the most these days?
Welcome to our channel! It's really cool to see your comment here! Kraan, Embryo and Klaus Schulze are amazing, but unfortunately there wasn't room for everyone. Who would you take off the list to fit them in?
The absolutely most influential band of all times is Kraftwerk ! Many bands are sounding partial a little bit like Kraftwerk, but Kraftwerk sounds like no other.
@@BackingTrackCenter You can hear the influence of Kraftwerk in nearly every kind of music ! I astounded everytime when I recognize that in Depeche Mode and even Rammstein 🤣.
It´s hard to say, which Krautrockbands are the best, but I´m missing some groups like Mythos, Annexus Quam, Birth Control, Virus, Tomorrow´s Gift, The Petards, Gäa, Yatha Sidhra, Out of Focus, Rufus Zuphall, Gila, Dzyan, Achim Reichel & Machines, My Solid Ground, Klaus Schulze….
That’s true, many important bands were left out. Mythos and Annexus Quam are great picks! Do you think there’s a band that shouldn’t be on the list to make room for these?
@@BackingTrackCenter Very difficult... - Make the best 25 Krautrock bands and add Mythos, Annexus Quam, Klaus Schulze, My Solid Ground, Rufus Zuphall, and/or Gila to this list - for my taste La Düsseldorf, Novalis, or Triumvirat are not so imporatant - but all is very subjectiv....I think for the majority your list is OK as it is...
For a woman in UK, I have heard of AND have records by, ALL of those bands except Ash Ra Temple (though I have heard OF them) and Frumpy. And a few others besides.
Having records from all those bands shows a very eclectic taste in music. Frumpy is a classic band; definitely worth checking out! Do you have a favorite album among the ones you’ve listened to?
That style is Wonderfull, I heard faust, can, ash ra tempel, and followed tangerine dream very much, the álbumes éxit and hiperborea are my favoritos im 65 years
I am not connected with this band in any way but I want to turn your attention to: Wintergarden - Blame it to these endless nights The cello solo there made me learn the cello in my fourties ...
I'm an avid music lover and I am German. But I only know 8 out of 20 bands or at least I've heard the name of... I was convinced Kraftwerk make #1 of the list, after all they are worshipped almost as much as the Beatles for their influence on modern music...
Guru Guru, Amon Düül II und Frumpy sind mir immer noch die liebsten von allen deutschen Bands dieser Jahre. 😜 Wolf City (Amon Düül II) ist ein absolut geiles Album, welches ich heute immer noch gerne höre...mindestens ein mal im Monat! ...ach ja, Janus gehört auch noch dazu, vor allem ihr geniales Album "Gravedigger"!!!
Guru Guru, Amon Düül II und Frumpy sind wirklich großartig! „Wolf City“ ist ein Klassiker, der nicht altert, und „Totengräber“ von Janus ist ein unterschätztes Meisterwerk. Ich mag diese Auswahl wirklich!
Lucifer’s Friend and Gift are 2 German bands I discovered that are really good. I believe they were referred to as Krautrock as was ‘70s era Scorpions which is my favorite era for them.
Man, Lucifer's Friend has some pretty heavy albums and Gift isn't far behind either! And I agree, '70s Scorpions had something special, kinda Krautrock-ish.
@@BackingTrackCenter definitely in the top ten some of the songs in the 70s especially Spanish gallion really had a great prog rock feel john Lawton was a phenomenal vocalist rip
Kraan is really an awesome band and deserved more attention! About CAN, I agree they could be in first, but the competition at the top is tough, right? Thanks for commenting!
I think that both Kraftwerk and Tangerine Dream should have higher places!! And that both Peter Baumann and Klaus Schultze (both former Tangerine Dream members) deserve a place in the list. So, why don’t make a list with ”25 great krautrock artists”?
Ich sah Frumpy und mehrfach Birth Control live. Tolle Erlebnisse. Mit Bernd Noske auch oft gesprochen kurz vor den Konzerten. Äußerst sympathischer Mensch und jedesmal sehr nervös, wie er mir sagte. RIP, Nossi, und er trommelt jetzt für die Engel😉
Solche Erfahrungen bleiben ewig, oder? Noske war ein toller Musiker und offenbar auch ein toller Typ. Es war wirklich cool, vor den Shows von diesem Kontakt zu erfahren. Vielen Dank, dass Sie diese Erinnerung geteilt haben! 😊
Frumpy is awesome! They have such a distinctive style, and Inga Rumpf's voice is unforgettable! Be sure to check out "Frumpy 2". It's a classic album that will definitely surprise you.
I know Manuel Gottsching was in AshRa Tempel but his solo albums as Ashra especially Blackouts and New Age of Earth are excellent . Tangerine Dream top the list for me though .
@@BackingTrackCenter Hi , I enjoyed the video , my favourite T.Dream album is Underwater Sunlight closely followed by Force Majeur and Hyperborea . My youth was spent immersed in Phaedra and Rubycon but I like best the late 70`s and 80`s albums .Edgar was a brilliant guitarist and I loved his playing , very underrated .Your favourite ?
“Underwater Sunlight” is truly an amazing album, and I also love their later works. I’d say “Phaedra” is one of my favorites for its unique atmosphere. Thanks for your comment!
@@BackingTrackCenter Can Triumvirat Eloy Jane e Tangerine Dream, este último meu preferido . Os demais não tenho disco é estou descobrindo depois da Internet ajudar nos a termos mais conhecidos i.ento e não depender de pessoas de poder.
Can ist für mich Nr. 1. Aber es gab viele gute deutsche Rockbands. Das mit den Top 20 erregt natürlich Widerspruch, aber danke für die Reminder. Mir fallen schlagartig immer mehr ein. Kraan gehört für mich auch da rein, z.B. Embryo gibts immer noch, inzwischen 2. Generation, die Embryos Reise als Kids mitgemacht haben. Erst vor ca 3 Jahren gesehen.
Can als Nummer 1 ist ohne Zweifel eine gute Wahl! Und ja, die Liste ist nur ein Ausgangspunkt, um sich an diese großartigen Bands zu erinnern und sie zu diskutieren. Es ist unglaublich, dass der Embryo immer noch aktiv ist, oder? Danke fürs Teilen!
Bitte nicht vergessen, dass es bis 1990 zwei deutsche Staaten gab. Auch in der ehemaligen DDR (East Germany) gab es progressive Bands, anders als in der BRD, jenseits vom Mainstream.
Du hast vollkommen recht! Die DDR hatte eine eigene interessante Musikszene mit vielen talentierten Bands. Welche Bands verdienen Ihrer Meinung nach mehr Aufmerksamkeit auf einer Liste über deutschen Rock?
Die Musik meiner Menschwerdung! Einzig Inga Rumpf hab ich nie wirklich gemocht. La Düsseldorf wurde immer als Geheimtip gehandelt. Und später lachte jeder über den zweiten Schlagzeuger von Birth Control, der dann Tutti Frutti moderierte: Hugo Egon Balder. Wattfür schöne Zeiten, abhängen im Plattenladen und überhaupt! Joe Albrecht (Karthago) machte gerne mal vor deutschem Publikum die Anmoderation auf englisch und kam sich total cool dabei vor. Pfiffe garantiert.
@@gerardreiters488 Because it just doesn't belong to this musical style or spirit...it's post punk or batcave/goth rock as others would call it but certainly not krautrock
Good evening my friend so good to see Frumpy and Faust on the list. I missed the Rattles a real good Krautrock band. for progressive german rockband Poverty's No Crime is missing. I made a list of the Best Vocalists Early Years of Progrock a few weeks ago. I hope you liked that one.
Thanks for the comment, my friend! Rattles and Poverty's No Crime are fantastic suggestions, I can see what you mean. And about your list of vocalists, I loved it and I'm sure I'll use many of your suggestions for future videos.
@@BackingTrackCenter I am happy to hear. If you like the idea I can make a list of criminally underrated music all genres with bands like: Walrus, Bevis Frond and Poverty's No Crime.
Ich stimme zu, Kraan hat es verdient, auf der Liste zu stehen! Manchmal ist es eine undankbare Aufgabe, große Namen außen vor zu lassen. Vielen Dank, dass Sie das hervorgehoben haben. Es ist immer gut, darüber zu diskutieren. Danke für deinen Kommentar!
@@BackingTrackCenter ... and on Sunday we were hungry, because we didn't have some food, we forgot to buy it on Saturday, when we were fat and felt so good...
Die Liste ist absolut diskussionswürdig. Listen sind halt begrenzt. Can hinter Eloy dürfte allerdings bei niemanden auf Verständnis treffen, der Aufnahmen von beiden Gruppen kennt.
Ja, Listen erzeugen immer gute Debatten! Ich stimme zu, dass Can einen so einzigartigen Stil hat, dass viele sie über Eloy stellen würden. Aber genau das macht diesen Gedankenaustausch so cool! Vielen Dank für Ihre Meinung!
@@ChristianGoergen es mag sein, daß Can in mancher Hinsicht besser wie Eloy sind. Aber ich finde, daß ist Ansichtssache. LP Ocean von Eloy finde ich z.B. ein echt gutes Prog Rock Album. Viele Grüße
@ Natürlich ist es Ansichtssache. Es wird auch Musikwissenschaftler geben, die Mendelssohn gegenüber Beethoven den Vorzug geben. Aber das Eis ist dünn. Ähnlich verhält es sich bei Can und Eloy. Ich kann auch Dawn häufiger hören als Tago Mago. Aber die Spuren die Can hinterlassen hat sind m.E. tiefer.
@ChristianGoergen deine Argumente sind Klasse & nachvollziehbar. Im Endeffekt ist es wohl die Einstellung des Betrachters, wie er die Sache sieht. Man könnte über Musik & ihre Wirkung auf Personen eh ewig reden. Danke dir
nice list, but better not voting, with all your comments its difficult to add more, some Names i forgot but can remember them live, you had to pay 3 Dmarks fot example in Hamburg : Fabrik :)
What an amazing memory, paying 3 D-marks at the Fabrik in Hamburg to see those bands live must have been out of this world. Thanks for sharing that memory!
Lift und Reform sind sehr gut. Auch nicht zu vergessen sind "Joco Dev Sextett",Uve Schikora, Electra Combo und "Klosterbrüder/Gruppe Magdeburg"....Auch viele frühe Stücke von den Pudhys sind echter Prog Rock
Ja, Kin Ping Meh war stark, aber es ist schwer, bei so vielen großartigen Bands alle unterzubringen. Trotzdem, sie hätten sicher einen Platz in einer erweiterten Liste verdient. Danke für die Erinnerung an diese großartige Band!
I understand what you mean, but the list focused more on the bands than on the producers. Although Conny Plank is super important with formidable works with Cluster and Moebius & Plank, we preferred to list the main bands, even with the difficulty of the limited space of 20 that we proposed. I appreciate your comment!
Absolutely! Kraan has a very dedicated fan base and is admired for its originality. Unfortunately, the list is limited and many important bands ended up being left out. Thanks for mentioning them!
@@Slazlo-Brovnik Wenn es deutsch ist und aus einer bestimmten Epoche, zählt es unter Krautrock, selbst wenn es wie Electronica klingt. Ich finde das auch irritierend, aber irgendwann haben sich Musikhistoriker wohl mal darauf geeinigt.
@@leximatic Das waren keine Musikhistoriker, sondern (vor allem britische) Journalisten, die sich das ausgedacht haben. Und es ist bis heute recht umstritten was "Krautrock" ist und was dazu gehört. Alles was aus Deutschland kommt und in den 60er Jahren entstanden ist einfach "Krautrock" zu nennen ist bestenfalls nur faul. Das kann man schon daran erkennen, dass Genres normalerweise einem Musikstil beschreiben. Bei "Krautrock" ist das aber nicht so, es beschreibt nur "Band aus Deutschland der 60 und 70er Jahre". Bei Kraftwerk kommt dazu, dass deren stil sich sehr gewandelt hat. Die ersten 2 Alben waren Krautrock, alles mit und nach "Autobahn" … also die Majorität Ihrer Veröffentlichungen nicht.
Kraan, Embryo, and Xhol Caravan are essential, I agree! They each have a sound that really shaped the German scene. Which one do you think most deserved a spot?
Nektar should have been in the top ten, imho. Consistent discography. Remember the Future always cited as one of the greatest Prog LP of all time. Depends if German band is german personnel or a band living in Germany
Kraan is an amazing band, no doubt! Even though they didn’t make the list, they definitely deserve recognition for their originality and incredible live performances. Thanks for commenting!
Although Epitaph is a good band, they are not as associated with krautrock and progressive rock as some of the others on this list. But you can't deny their quality! Thanks for commenting!
@@BackingTrackCenter knapp 100 Leute ,schön bierselig, Ich war 18 Jahre alt und mein bis dahin 2 Live Konzert neben der Edgar Broughton Band in einer Schule . Unvergessen auch der umgebaute Leichenwagen der Band . Einfach unvergessen und prägend bis zum heutigen Tag!!!! Lieben Gruß UDO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ja, Kraan ist eine großartige Band, die problemlos auf der Liste stehen könnte! Aber da wir uns auf 20 Bands beschränken, kommt es immer wieder vor, dass etwas ausgelassen wird. Welche Band sollte Ihrer Meinung nach diese Liste streichen, um Platz für Kraan zu schaffen?
@@BackingTrackCenter Es ist sehr schwer. Am besten, die Liste um mindestens 5 erweitern. Dann könnte z.b. auch von vielen gefordert k.schulze mit rein...
Ich verstehe deine Frustration! Es ist schwierig, alle großartigen Bands auf einer Liste zusammenzufassen, und jeder hat seine Favoriten. Welche Bands sollten Ihrer Meinung nach aus der Liste verschwinden und welche reinkommen?
@@BackingTrackCenter Frumpy und Birth Control gehören auf alle Fälle die vorderen Plätze, Unter anderem fehlen Karthago, Atlantis, Wallenstein, Kin Ping Me, Ton Steine Scherben etc. um nur inige zu nennen
@BackingTrackCenter I've known Christian Burchard, Multiinstrumentalist and founder of Embryo, since the early seventies, when we both lived in München. He sadly passed away in january 2018. 🙏✨♥️
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
🆕🎦 Get our updates directly on WHATSAPP and catch our videos as soon as they’re released.
CLICK HERE ➡ bit.ly/News_Backing_Track_Center ⬅
🟥🟫🟧🟨🟩🟦🟪🟦🟩🟨🟧🟫🟥🟫🟧🟨🟩🟦🟪🟦🟩
I'm 65 years old & come from Germany. So I know the Scene exactly! Where are Kraan, Nektar & Karthago? Otherwise well researched
Kraan, Nektar, and Karthago are great names, they could easily be on the list too. Thanks for the compliment!
yes, where is KRAAN and EMBRYO ?
@@BackingTrackCenter Nektar are not a German Band. They lived at the time in Germany, but they were Brits.
Richtig, die Verantwortlichen für die Liste haben wirklich keine Ahnung von der Musik aus den 70ern und Krautrock. Frumpy auf Platz 19 und Birth Control Platz 15 sind dazu noch Unverschämtheiten. Es fehlen auch Atlantis bzw. Kin Pin Meh etc.
@@theheepster trotzdem gehörten sie dazu und waren auf allen Deutschen Musikfestivals dabei
"Solar Music" by Grobschnitt is the most amazing live performance I've ever seen!
I love "Solar Music"! The mix of progressive rock with theatrical performances is jaw-dropping. Thanks for commenting!
First time heard 1981 in Hamburg CCH when I served for Bundeswehr. Decades later a few times more in west of Germany, one time in Westfalen Stadion BVB.
DO YOU HEAR
SOLAR MUSIC
GREAT SONG ALWAYS DIFFERENT INTERPRATED.
Da fehlen aber viele Rockbands, eher Prog Rock fehlen: Lucifer's Friend, Nektar, Epitaph, Kin-Ping-Meh aus MA, Embryo, Wind aus Nürnberg, Parzival, Bröselmaschine, Dies Irae, Kraan, Hoelderlin, Message, Ihre Kinder, Neuschwanstein, Wallenstein u.viele mehr !
Stimmt, es gibt viele gute Bands in der deutschen Progressive-Szene, ich denke, die Liste musste Platz für mindestens 40 Bands bieten. Danke für deinen Kommentar!
@@clannad99germany70 Bröselmaschine? Ich bitte Dich ... 🤮
I miss "SFF" and "Twentysixtysix and Then"!
Epitaph, Kraan und Wind, einer der wenigen deutschen Bands mit internationaler Klasse. In dein "und viele mehr" gehört bestimmt auch noch Nine Days Wonder 🙂
@@tomtrana3449 stimmt aber auch Triumvirat und Lucifers Friend, Banquet von denen ist eines der besten ProgRock Alben die ich kenne u. hatte.......Nine days Wonder waren auch aus MA.
Nice list ! Thank you ! Tangerine dream is my favorite, but the most of them I don't know. Here in Brazil, some Kraftwerk and Triunvirat albums made some success. But here in Brazil, the most appreciated German musicians are Beethoven, Bach, Schubert and, of course, Skorpions, Michael Schenker and Uli Jon Roth...Serious !!!
I'm glad you liked the list. Having access to records from more specific musical movements, especially from the 70s, has always been expensive. We end up having to settle for the more popular ones! Thanks for commenting! 🎸
La Düsseldorf, Neu! and Faust should be in the top 5. And Can should be number 1. They were way ahead of the rest - except for perhaps Kraftwerk who achieved real international mega status.
La Düsseldorf, Neu! and Faust have a unique sound and deserve to be among the best. Can is truly revolutionary! A list of 20 shows us the elite of the style, so everyone on it is highly regarded. Thanks for commenting!
@@europainvicta3907 CAN auf der Nummer 1…., natürlich…. 👍👍👍
I am from Holland and great fan of the German progrock. Eloy is one of the greatest bands in the scene worldwide!
That’s awesome! Eloy is surely one of the greatest prog bands worldwide. What’s your favorite album of theirs? Thanks for the comment!
Zeker! Planets I & II, Silent cries..., Oceans, juweeltjes!
This video is mirroring 95% of my Vinyl-Collection. Very Good!
That’s awesome! Your vinyl collection must be impressive. Glad to hear the video matches your taste so well!
Achim Reichel "Die grüne Reise" von 1971 sollte auch nicht in Vergessenheit geraten.😃
Es stimmt, dieses Album ist spektakulär! Der Stilmix, den Achim Reichel mitbringt, ist einzigartig. Danke für deinen Kommentar!
Oh ja, absolut richtig…. 👍👍👍
I can agree with most of the bands mentioned. But instead of Triumvirat and Eloy, I would have chosen Kraan and Embryo, at least in a top 20. I saw most of the bands you mentioned live. Greatest singer was and still is Inga Rumpf of Frumpy and later Atlantis. Others in your list struggle with the English language quite a bit. In particular Triumvirat. And they wrote silly lyrics like "it was shortly after nine, when they started the new time" (from Spartacus).
Interesting! Triumvirat and Eloy lean more symphonic, while Kraan and Embryo have a jazzier vibe. Just a matter of style, right? Inga Rumpf is fantastic, no doubt! I agree that Triumvirat sometimes went a bit heavy with the lyrics. Thanks for commenting!
Can, Faust and Amon Duul II are first 3 for me.
Man, those three are truly essential! Each with their unique style. Amon Düül II, especially, is such a trip. Which album of theirs do you like the most?
@@BackingTrackCenter Monster Movie from Can, First from Faust, and hard to say for Amon, maybe Tanz....
Can and Faust at equal No. 1 for me.
@@andrewhounsome5969 Yes!
Tanz Der Lemminge
Aqui no Brasil só chegaram: Eloy, Nektar, Triunvirat, Tangerine Dream, Kraftwerk, foram os que comprei aqui. Gosto muito!
É complicado, tem de importar se quiser a mídia física de alguns desses gigantes do krautrock, e custa o olho da cara! Mas, se você já tem esses, então tá bem amparado, só banda boa!
Great list my friend and I am happy to see Faust, Kraftwerk and Frumpy. Missing is Nina Hagen Band. Multigenre mix of Krautrock, Punk, Rock and Opera. The Rattles must be also on this list with their song "The Witch". Krautock meets Psychedelica.
For your second part, IHRE KINDER, MY SOLID GROUND, WIND and GILA are definitely worth mentioning.
These bands are definitely great! GILA has a very atmospheric and engaging sound. Great suggestions that will be considered for a second part. Thanks for the collaboration!
Excellent list of German Kraut/Prog Bands. My personal order would be different e.g. Frumpy in the Top 3 and including Klaus Schulze - in my Top 3 as well.
Cool, everyone has their own personal order, right? Frumpy in the top 3 is an interesting opinion that I personally share, and Klaus Schulze definitely deserves a mention, the guy is huge!
cool compilation - thanx a lot !! (I'm a german guy born in the fifties), but don't miss the unique awesome brilliant ... KRAAN :-))
For sure, Kraan is a unique band, and a lot of people really miss them on the list. Which of their albums would you consider the best? Thanks for your comment!
@@BackingTrackCenter Kraan Live 1975 Wiederhoeren 1977
Nice video. My List would have a totally different order! And some bands like Wallenstein and Hoelderlin would be included.
Thanks for liking the video! It seems like the list would be really interesting with the inclusion of bands like Wallenstein and Hoelderlin. What would be your top 5?
@BackingTrackCenter Maybe it would be Novalis, NEU!, Kraftwerk, Hölderlin and Can.
Gila, Kin Ping Meh, Embryo, Mythos, My Solid Ground, Xhol Caravan, Nine Days Wonder fallen mir noch ein.
Mann, das sind Klassiker! Besonders Gila und Embryo mit diesem experimentelleren Sound. Danke für die Erwähnung!
Oh? Ein Kenner. My Solid Ground hatte ich weiter oben u.a. auch aufgezählt.
Great list delighted to see Triumvirat on there , I ‘ m a German Keyboard prog nut so also love bands like Amos Key , Odin, Minus Two and especially Sixty Nine
Great to hear you like Triumvirat! Those other bands are awesome too, especially Sixty Nine with their incredible arrangements. Thanks for commenting!
Popol Vuh, Tangerine Dream, Ash Ra Tempel, Klaus Schulze,Cosmic Jokers,Can ,Amon Duul II: they are the first ...no ifs or buts !
No doubt, those bands were pioneers and defined krautrock! But don’t you think others like Neu! or Faust also deserve to be among the top?
@@BackingTrackCenter yes, bro !👍👍...and Agitation Free, Guru Guru,Faust...
Oh , and Edgar Froese `s solo albums especially Stuntman .
Yes, Froese's solo albums are great, but since the idea was to list bands, we ended up leaving those out. Thanks for watching the video!
Kraan, Schulze, Satin Whale, EGO,- there were a lot of german progressive rock bands - and i loved them all....
That's true! Kraan, Schulze, and Satin Whale are amazing, each with their unique style! German progressive rock has so much diversity and quality. Which band do you listen to the most these days?
🆕Get our updates directly on WHATSAPP and catch our videos as soon as they’re released.
CLICK HERE: bit.ly/News_Backing_Track_Center
Eloy Floating is in my top 10 albums. A prog masterpiece.
"Floating" is definitely a prog masterpiece, no doubt!
Thanks. I have most of the bands, but mentioned a couple that I don't have. I will have to check them out
That’s awesome! Check out those bands you don’t have, I think you’ll like them. Which ones caught your eye the most?
🎸Wonderful🎸❤🌹
A GREAT DOKU !
GREETINGS FROM THE AMON DÜÜL II-BASSPLAYER )))
(but where is KRAAN, EMBRYO and KLAUS SCHULZE ?
Welcome to our channel! It's really cool to see your comment here! Kraan, Embryo and Klaus Schulze are amazing, but unfortunately there wasn't room for everyone. Who would you take off the list to fit them in?
🆕Get our updates directly on WHATSAPP and catch our videos as soon as they’re released.
CLICK HERE: bit.ly/News_Backing_Track_Center
The absolutely most influential band of all times is Kraftwerk ! Many bands are sounding partial a little bit like Kraftwerk, but Kraftwerk sounds like no other.
I totally agree, Kraftwerk is a unique band that influenced not only krautrock but electronic music as a whole. They really paved the way!
@@BackingTrackCenter
You can hear the influence of Kraftwerk in nearly every kind of music ! I astounded everytime when I recognize that in Depeche Mode and even Rammstein 🤣.
I would have put Inga & Frumpy at # 1 as they were that good as was Atlantis & Inga still plays & she's not lost a thing in her talent.
Inga really has incredible talent! Frumpy made a huge mark, and it's amazing how she still delivers so well. Thanks for commenting!
It´s hard to say, which Krautrockbands are the best, but I´m missing some groups like
Mythos, Annexus Quam, Birth Control, Virus, Tomorrow´s Gift, The Petards, Gäa,
Yatha Sidhra, Out of Focus, Rufus Zuphall, Gila, Dzyan, Achim Reichel & Machines,
My Solid Ground, Klaus Schulze….
That’s true, many important bands were left out. Mythos and Annexus Quam are great picks! Do you think there’s a band that shouldn’t be on the list to make room for these?
@@BackingTrackCenter Very difficult... - Make the best 25 Krautrock bands and add Mythos, Annexus Quam, Klaus Schulze, My Solid Ground, Rufus Zuphall, and/or Gila to this list - for my taste La Düsseldorf, Novalis, or Triumvirat are not so imporatant - but all is very subjectiv....I think for the majority your list is OK as it is...
Mythos e Gila também são grandes nomes. La Düsseldorf e Novalis acabam entrando mais pela influência geral.
For a woman in UK, I have heard of AND have records by, ALL of those bands except Ash Ra Temple (though I have heard OF them) and Frumpy. And a few others besides.
Having records from all those bands shows a very eclectic taste in music. Frumpy is a classic band; definitely worth checking out! Do you have a favorite album among the ones you’ve listened to?
That style is Wonderfull, I heard faust, can, ash ra tempel, and followed tangerine dream very much, the álbumes éxit and hiperborea are my favoritos im 65 years
That’s awesome! You’ve got great taste in krautrock. "Exit" and "Hyperborea" by Tangerine Dream are really special. Thanks for commenting!
I am not connected with this band in any way but I want to turn your attention to:
Wintergarden - Blame it to these endless nights
The cello solo there made me learn the cello in my fourties ...
That's cool! It’s amazing how music can inspire us to learn a new instrument.
I enjoy Ramses, Zomby Woof, Pancake, Serene, cheers from Canada.
Great choices! Ramses and Zomby Woof have a very distinct sound. I haven't heard of Serene yet. Thanks for the tip. Hugs to Canada!
I'm an avid music lover and I am German. But I only know 8 out of 20 bands or at least I've heard the name of... I was convinced Kraftwerk make #1 of the list, after all they are worshipped almost as much as the Beatles for their influence on modern music...
Kraftwerk at #1 would definitely make sense for a lot of people given their groundbreaking influence. Thanks for commenting!
As someone who started listening to Prog in the 80s, I knew only half of the bands!😉
That's super common! The prog scene is huge, and there are always new bands to discover. Which bands from the list did you already know?
Guru Guru, Amon Düül II und Frumpy sind mir immer noch die liebsten von allen deutschen Bands dieser Jahre. 😜
Wolf City (Amon Düül II) ist ein absolut geiles Album, welches ich heute immer noch gerne höre...mindestens ein mal im Monat!
...ach ja, Janus gehört auch noch dazu, vor allem ihr geniales Album "Gravedigger"!!!
Guru Guru, Amon Düül II und Frumpy sind wirklich großartig! „Wolf City“ ist ein Klassiker, der nicht altert, und „Totengräber“ von Janus ist ein unterschätztes Meisterwerk. Ich mag diese Auswahl wirklich!
Lucifer’s Friend and Gift are 2 German bands I discovered that are really good. I believe they were referred to as Krautrock as was ‘70s era Scorpions which is my favorite era for them.
Man, Lucifer's Friend has some pretty heavy albums and Gift isn't far behind either! And I agree, '70s Scorpions had something special, kinda Krautrock-ish.
Doesn't anyone who made this list remember Lucifers friend
Lucifer’s Friend is an amazing band! They definitely deserve more recognition. Maybe in a bigger list. What spot do you think they deserve?
@@BackingTrackCenter definitely in the top ten some of the songs in the 70s especially Spanish gallion really had a great prog rock feel john Lawton was a phenomenal vocalist rip
Ja, Lucifer's Friend fehlt auch noch - siehe "Ride the Sky" (1971)
@@Preussenzug great tune that whole first record is heavy my favorite track is nobodys clown
@@anthonymorton4050 "Banquet" is a masterpiece.
absolutely missing is KRAAN! - and CAN just on second place???
Kraan is really an awesome band and deserved more attention! About CAN, I agree they could be in first, but the competition at the top is tough, right? Thanks for commenting!
@@rattenbeuler CAN is always number One, you're right! 😊
Sollten mal 'nen,,Kraut Rock,, Festival Veranstalten.Leben wahrscheinlich nur noch 10 % der Leute,aber wäre ja mal was...👍😎🎸🥁🎤
Haha, ja, die 10 % würden die Bühne sicher noch zum Beben bringen! Ein echtes Revival-Festival wäre mega. Ich hoffe, jemand greift die Idee auf! 🎸🎸
@@ThomasErismann Joo, die alten Hirsche bringen's noch. Kraan sind nächstes Jahr im Juni auf Tour. Ich bin dabei 👍😝🙋♂️
I think that both Kraftwerk and Tangerine Dream should have higher places!! And that both Peter Baumann and Klaus Schultze (both former Tangerine Dream members) deserve a place in the list. So, why don’t make a list with ”25 great krautrock artists”?
That's a valid opinion! Kraftwerk and Tangerine Dream really revolutionized electronic music and deserve more recognition.
Sperrmüll - No Freak Out 1973 - sollte auch nicht vergessen werden. Fiel mir gestern Abend im Bett noch ein.
Gute Erinnerung! „No Freak Out“ ist ein Krautrock-Juwel. Hast du einen Lieblingstitel auf dem Album?
@@BackingTrackCenter Ja, das Stück "No Freak Out" selbst. Das Album hatte ja keinen Namen.
Nice list, but you forgot KRAAN and PELL MELL
Good call! Kraan and Pell Mell are amazing bands, but they just didn’t fit in this list. Maybe in the next one, right? Thanks for commenting!
Ich sah Frumpy und mehrfach Birth Control live. Tolle Erlebnisse. Mit Bernd Noske auch oft gesprochen kurz vor den Konzerten. Äußerst sympathischer Mensch und jedesmal sehr nervös, wie er mir sagte. RIP, Nossi, und er trommelt jetzt für die Engel😉
Solche Erfahrungen bleiben ewig, oder? Noske war ein toller Musiker und offenbar auch ein toller Typ. Es war wirklich cool, vor den Shows von diesem Kontakt zu erfahren. Vielen Dank, dass Sie diese Erinnerung geteilt haben! 😊
Eloy é fantástico!
Eloy é demais mesmo! Aquela sonoridade única que só eles têm. Valeu o comentário!
There were a few that I had never heard of before.
Nice that you found something new! There’s always something great to discover in prog. Which band caught your attention the most?
@@BackingTrackCenter Frumpy sounded pretty cool.
Frumpy is awesome! They have such a distinctive style, and Inga Rumpf's voice is unforgettable! Be sure to check out "Frumpy 2". It's a classic album that will definitely surprise you.
@@BackingTrackCenter Ah, Inga Rumpf. The voice sounded so familiar to me. I always thought she sang with the band “Atlantis”.
I know Manuel Gottsching was in AshRa Tempel but his solo albums as Ashra especially Blackouts and New Age of Earth are excellent . Tangerine Dream top the list for me though .
Gottsching is really great! "Blackouts" is amazing, but Tangerine Dream is also on another level. What's your favorite album from them?
@@BackingTrackCenter Hi , I enjoyed the video , my favourite T.Dream album is Underwater Sunlight closely followed by Force Majeur and Hyperborea . My youth was spent immersed in Phaedra and Rubycon but I like best the late 70`s and 80`s albums .Edgar was a brilliant guitarist and I loved his playing , very underrated .Your favourite ?
“Underwater Sunlight” is truly an amazing album, and I also love their later works. I’d say “Phaedra” is one of my favorites for its unique atmosphere. Thanks for your comment!
ótima lista,
Valeu! Fico feliz que tenha gostado. Qual sua banda preferida do estilo? Obrigado por comentar!
@@BackingTrackCenter Can Triumvirat Eloy Jane e Tangerine Dream, este último meu preferido .
Os demais não tenho disco é estou descobrindo depois da Internet ajudar nos a termos mais conhecidos i.ento e não depender de pessoas de poder.
Can ist für mich Nr. 1. Aber es gab viele gute deutsche Rockbands. Das mit den Top 20 erregt natürlich Widerspruch, aber danke für die Reminder. Mir fallen schlagartig immer mehr ein. Kraan gehört für mich auch da rein, z.B. Embryo gibts immer noch, inzwischen 2. Generation, die Embryos Reise als Kids mitgemacht haben. Erst vor ca 3 Jahren gesehen.
Can als Nummer 1 ist ohne Zweifel eine gute Wahl! Und ja, die Liste ist nur ein Ausgangspunkt, um sich an diese großartigen Bands zu erinnern und sie zu diskutieren. Es ist unglaublich, dass der Embryo immer noch aktiv ist, oder? Danke fürs Teilen!
Bitte nicht vergessen, dass es bis 1990 zwei deutsche Staaten gab. Auch in der ehemaligen DDR (East Germany) gab es progressive Bands, anders als in der BRD, jenseits vom Mainstream.
Du hast vollkommen recht! Die DDR hatte eine eigene interessante Musikszene mit vielen talentierten Bands. Welche Bands verdienen Ihrer Meinung nach mehr Aufmerksamkeit auf einer Liste über deutschen Rock?
@@roland7218 Nennen Sie die Namen! Oder ich spiele Modern Talking!
@@BackingTrackCenter City
Die Musik meiner Menschwerdung! Einzig Inga Rumpf hab ich nie wirklich gemocht. La Düsseldorf wurde immer als Geheimtip gehandelt. Und später lachte jeder über den zweiten Schlagzeuger von Birth Control, der dann Tutti Frutti moderierte: Hugo Egon Balder. Wattfür schöne Zeiten, abhängen im Plattenladen und überhaupt!
Joe Albrecht (Karthago) machte gerne mal vor deutschem Publikum die Anmoderation auf englisch und kam sich total cool dabei vor. Pfiffe garantiert.
Was für tolle Erinnerungen! Danke für deinen Kommentar.
Pell Mell,Reaction, Sitting Bull, Fashion Pink,Erna Scmidth, 2066, Aera, Missus Beastly, Thristy Moon, Guru Guru,Nosferatu, Murphy Blend, Satin Whale, Emtidi, Parziwal, McChurch Soundroom, Elfenbein, Emergency, Electric Sandwich. etc. CHEERS.
Wow, you mentioned some real gems. Thanks for the comment!
@@BackingTrackCenter Certainly. Long live KRAUTROCK. Cheers.
Dies Iare, Hairy Chapter, Arktis, Gomorrha, German Oak, Hanuman, Jeronimo, Pancake, Asterix, Randy Pie, Tiger B. Smith, Thrice Mice, Ardo Dombec, mAMMUT, Ikarus, Hallelujah,Subject esquire, BRAINSTORM, BLACKWATER PARK, Broeselmashine, Necronomicon, Dschinn, Vinegar, Epsilon, Albatros,Electric Food, Da Capo, Lied Des Teufel, Wind,
Wow, with your suggestions I can make another 2 lists. Thank you very much!
@@BackingTrackCenter Good luck to You. CHEERS.
Eloy Number 1 👍👍👍
Eloy at the top truly matches their sound and influence, right? Do you have a favorite album of theirs?
@BackingTrackCenter Ocean is my favourite album.
Inside
What about Klaus Schulze, Xmal Deutschland, Lokomotive Kreuzberg,..????
Klaus Schulze is legendary, but I left out solo works. Lokomotive Kreuzberg and Xmal Deutschland are great too. Thanks for commenting!
Xmal Deutschland??? Nothing to do with Krautrock
@@hollandaisvolant9943 why???
@@gerardreiters488 Because it just doesn't belong to this musical style or spirit...it's post punk or batcave/goth rock as others would call it but certainly not krautrock
Good evening my friend so good to see Frumpy and Faust on the list. I missed the Rattles a real good Krautrock band. for progressive german rockband Poverty's No Crime is missing. I made a list of the Best Vocalists Early Years of Progrock a few weeks ago. I hope you liked that one.
Thanks for the comment, my friend! Rattles and Poverty's No Crime are fantastic suggestions, I can see what you mean. And about your list of vocalists, I loved it and I'm sure I'll use many of your suggestions for future videos.
@@BackingTrackCenter I am happy to hear. If you like the idea I can make a list of criminally underrated music all genres with bands like: Walrus, Bevis Frond and Poverty's No Crime.
Wow, that would be great. If you could send me a slightly longer list so I can have more freedom in editing, that would be great. I'd be grateful!
@@BackingTrackCenter I will make one list of 20 different bands each one album, one song will be a mixed list all genres
Perfect!
Got to have Nektar in there surely
Nektar is amazing indeed! 'Remember the Future' is a classic. Where would you place them on the list?
@@BackingTrackCenter ..
would certainly be in the top three.A Tab in the Ocean is my personal favourite of theirs
Ich kann nicht glauben, daß kraan nicht unter den 20 besten Krautrock Bands sein soll. Ganz klar für mich die Nummer 1
Ich stimme zu, Kraan hat es verdient, auf der Liste zu stehen! Manchmal ist es eine undankbare Aufgabe, große Namen außen vor zu lassen. Vielen Dank, dass Sie das hervorgehoben haben. Es ist immer gut, darüber zu diskutieren. Danke für deinen Kommentar!
@@BackingTrackCenter ... and on Sunday we were hungry, because we didn't have some food, we forgot to buy it on Saturday, when we were fat and felt so good...
Wintrup, this song is amazing!
Die Liste ist absolut diskussionswürdig. Listen sind halt begrenzt. Can hinter Eloy dürfte allerdings bei niemanden auf Verständnis treffen, der Aufnahmen von beiden Gruppen kennt.
Ja, Listen erzeugen immer gute Debatten! Ich stimme zu, dass Can einen so einzigartigen Stil hat, dass viele sie über Eloy stellen würden. Aber genau das macht diesen Gedankenaustausch so cool! Vielen Dank für Ihre Meinung!
@@ChristianGoergen es mag sein, daß Can in mancher Hinsicht besser wie Eloy sind. Aber ich finde, daß ist Ansichtssache. LP Ocean von Eloy finde ich z.B. ein echt gutes Prog Rock Album. Viele Grüße
@ Natürlich ist es Ansichtssache. Es wird auch Musikwissenschaftler geben, die Mendelssohn gegenüber Beethoven den Vorzug geben. Aber das Eis ist dünn. Ähnlich verhält es sich bei Can und Eloy. Ich kann auch Dawn häufiger hören als Tago Mago. Aber die Spuren die Can hinterlassen hat sind m.E. tiefer.
@ChristianGoergen deine Argumente sind Klasse & nachvollziehbar. Im Endeffekt ist es wohl die Einstellung des Betrachters, wie er die Sache sieht. Man könnte über Musik & ihre Wirkung auf Personen eh ewig reden. Danke dir
@@uweschonfeld1290 Gerne, Musik wird für immer bleiben, auch wenn die Platte nach 20 Minuten umgedreht werden muss.
Satin Whale - 'Desert Places'
Best German prog rock album
I agree, Desert Places is incredible, and many fans also consider it among the best of German prog. What an album! Thanks for the comment! 👍
A very good list, although I would have put Jane higher in the top 5.
Jane is really an amazing band. I agree with you!
nice list, but better not voting, with all your comments its difficult to add more, some Names i forgot but can remember them live, you had to pay 3 Dmarks fot example in Hamburg : Fabrik :)
What an amazing memory, paying 3 D-marks at the Fabrik in Hamburg to see those bands live must have been out of this world. Thanks for sharing that memory!
Grobschnitt und Jane immer wieder gern gehört 🎉🎉🎉
Ich stimme voll und ganz zu, Grobschnitt und Jane haben immer einen garantierten Platz auf Playlists. Was für einen guten Geschmack du hast! 🎉
Hoelderlin... Traumstadt is freakin Amazing
I agree, "Traumstadt" is a sensational album, full of unique atmospheres. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
I would have added Shicke Furs Froling. Those guys were great
I agree, Shicke Furs Froling were great and definitely deserve recognition. Which album of theirs do you like the most? Thanks for the comment!
SFF Live!
@@BackingTrackCenter Führs& Fröhling „Ammerland“ , ganz entspannt aber nicht flach. Leg ich mir direkt auf.
Hmmm, no Cosmic Jokers, Embryo or Achim Reichel & Machines.
That's true, Cosmic Jokers, Embryo, and Achim Reichel & Machines are strong names and could have made it! Where would you place them, in your opinion?
Baba Yaga, Reform, Lift, Pyramid (!!!)...
Baba Yaga and Pyramid are fantastic picks!
Lift und Reform sind sehr gut. Auch nicht zu vergessen sind "Joco Dev Sextett",Uve Schikora, Electra Combo und "Klosterbrüder/Gruppe Magdeburg"....Auch viele frühe Stücke von den Pudhys sind echter Prog Rock
For sure you missed KIN PING MEH from MANNHEIM, with FRIEDER SCHMITT/keyborads&KALLE WEBER/drums for example...
Ja, Kin Ping Meh war stark, aber es ist schwer, bei so vielen großartigen Bands alle unterzubringen. Trotzdem, sie hätten sicher einen Platz in einer erweiterten Liste verdient. Danke für die Erinnerung an diese großartige Band!
I feel a bit bad because the one mußt important Soundmaker was Conny Plank and not even one time he´s name only some of his groups
I understand what you mean, but the list focused more on the bands than on the producers. Although Conny Plank is super important with formidable works with Cluster and Moebius & Plank, we preferred to list the main bands, even with the difficulty of the limited space of 20 that we proposed. I appreciate your comment!
Kraan missing....if you really know the German Rock Scene in the 1970s....like all the others mentioned before...
Absolutely! Kraan has a very dedicated fan base and is admired for its originality. Unfortunately, the list is limited and many important bands ended up being left out. Thanks for mentioning them!
Well basically for me its CAN. The Rest is far behind, but I do not consider Kraftwerk or NEU! "Krautrock".
I agree! CAN is truly unique. Kraftwerk and NEU! have different styles, but they share the krautrock innovation. Thanks for commenting!
@@Slazlo-Brovnik Wenn es deutsch ist und aus einer bestimmten Epoche, zählt es unter Krautrock, selbst wenn es wie Electronica klingt. Ich finde das auch irritierend, aber irgendwann haben sich Musikhistoriker wohl mal darauf geeinigt.
@@leximatic Das waren keine Musikhistoriker, sondern (vor allem britische) Journalisten, die sich das ausgedacht haben. Und es ist bis heute recht umstritten was "Krautrock" ist und was dazu gehört. Alles was aus Deutschland kommt und in den 60er Jahren entstanden ist einfach "Krautrock" zu nennen ist bestenfalls nur faul. Das kann man schon daran erkennen, dass Genres normalerweise einem Musikstil beschreiben. Bei "Krautrock" ist das aber nicht so, es beschreibt nur "Band aus Deutschland der 60 und 70er Jahre".
Bei Kraftwerk kommt dazu, dass deren stil sich sehr gewandelt hat. Die ersten 2 Alben waren Krautrock, alles mit und nach "Autobahn" … also die Majorität Ihrer Veröffentlichungen nicht.
Where are Sweet Smoke and Missus Beasley?
Good point! Both bands have a unique sound and could easily make the list. Thanks for commenting!
@@BackingTrackCenter Mabe forgotten becoase of to many "just a pokes"?
I miss Kraan, Embryo and Xhol/Xhol Caravan!
Kraan, Embryo, and Xhol Caravan are essential, I agree! They each have a sound that really shaped the German scene. Which one do you think most deserved a spot?
@@BackingTrackCenter I would say Kraan.
Personally a great fan of Mythos.
I like Mythos too, a really underrated band in the scene. What's your favorite album of theirs? Thanks for commenting!
What is about RAMSES, or EPITAPH?
Great mention! Ramses and Epitaph left their mark and could easily be on the list. Thanks a lot for your comment! 😃
Your No 4 is my No 1
Great choice! Tangerine Dream have such a unique sound. What’s your favorite album of theirs? Thanks for the comment!
OMGOD! No Cluster? Or SFF?
True, Cluster and SFF are giants! But with so many amazing bands, it's hard to fit everyone. Who do you think should be dropped to make room for them?
Nektar should have been in the top ten, imho. Consistent discography. Remember the Future always cited as one of the greatest Prog LP of all time. Depends if German band is german personnel or a band living in Germany
We avoided Nektar for this reason, leaving it predominantly for native Germans, but it will certainly be part of future lists. Thanks for commenting!
What about KRAAN?
Kraan is an amazing band, no doubt! Even though they didn’t make the list, they definitely deserve recognition for their originality and incredible live performances. Thanks for commenting!
@@BackingTrackCenter youre welcome
Einsturzende Neubauten anyone.
Great reminder! Einstürzende Neubauten, though more on the industrial side, is undeniable as a reference. Glad you brought it up!
🆕Get our updates directly on WHATSAPP and catch our videos as soon as they’re released.
CLICK HERE: bit.ly/News_Backing_Track_Center
Xmal Deutschland. All female band. Well worth a listen.
Vous oubliez Wallenstein😊 et Nektar😊
Je suis d'accord, Wallenstein et Nektar sont fantastiques ! Ils devraient également figurer sur la liste. Merci pour le partage !
Kraan
Kraan is an amazing band! A lot of people mentioned them in the comments. I'll note them down for future videos! 🎶
Straight Shooter
(My time , Your time)
Excellent choice! My Time, Your Time by Straight Shooter is one of those albums every German rock fan should check out. Any favorite tracks? Thanks!
Plastic people " birth control: monster organ. Frumpy. My favorites '
Great picks! "Plastic People" by Birth Control is amazing, and Frumpy is awesome too. Thanks for commenting!
Kann es sein, dass ich die beste deutsche Band aller Zeiten "FRUMPY" übersehen habe.
FRUMPY ist wirklich exzellent, vergessen wir nicht, sie steht auf der Liste. Danke für deinen Kommentar!
But where are Epitaph ?? One of the best German Rock Bands. Since 55 ! Years on Stage. About 16 Albums, and timeless good.
Although Epitaph is a good band, they are not as associated with krautrock and progressive rock as some of the others on this list. But you can't deny their quality! Thanks for commenting!
FRANZ K 1973 in einem Jugenheim gesehen / Duisburg Hambotn /
Zu viel! Franz K damals live zu sehen, muss unglaublich gewesen sein. Wie war die Stimmung im Publikum?
@@BackingTrackCenter knapp 100 Leute ,schön bierselig, Ich war 18 Jahre alt und mein bis dahin 2 Live Konzert neben der Edgar Broughton Band in einer Schule . Unvergessen auch der umgebaute Leichenwagen der Band . Einfach unvergessen und prägend bis zum heutigen Tag!!!! Lieben Gruß UDO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Was für eine unglaubliche Erfahrung. Vielen Dank, dass Sie dies mit uns geteilt haben!
@@BackingTrackCenter gern. bestes Konzert bis dato 1978 Humble Pie !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Triumvirat😎🇨🇱.
Aera is also missing 😊
True, Aera made amazing music and could have been on the list. Thanks for the comment!
I miss Jeronimo.
Schon mal was von Kraan gehört??Wer hat denn die Liste zusammengestellt🙈
Ja, Kraan ist eine großartige Band, die problemlos auf der Liste stehen könnte! Aber da wir uns auf 20 Bands beschränken, kommt es immer wieder vor, dass etwas ausgelassen wird. Welche Band sollte Ihrer Meinung nach diese Liste streichen, um Platz für Kraan zu schaffen?
@@uwelyko579 der große teil hier vermisst Kraan. Ist irgendwie merkwürdig. Die waren ja auch großartig
@@BackingTrackCenter Es ist sehr schwer. Am besten, die Liste um mindestens 5 erweitern. Dann könnte z.b. auch von vielen gefordert k.schulze mit rein...
Du hast recht, die Liste sollte mindestens 30 haben.
@@BackingTrackCenter und beim nächsten mal frumpy weiter vorn 😂😉 weiter so 👍
Wallenstein !
Wallenstein is awesome! Which albums of theirs do you like the most?
Amon duul ll birth control Faust can. Is my top 4
Great choice of bands! Amon Düül II and Can are absolute classics! Which albums of theirs do you like the most?
@@BackingTrackCenter amon dull yeti. Birth control the first album. Can monster movie. Faust so far.
Where is Gäa?
Where would you place them on this list?
Where's Kraan and Passport
Kraan and Passport are amazing! Which album would you recommend? Thanks for the comment!
@BackingTrackCenter Kraan live, and looking thru by passport
@@FlatfootChronicles Passport, Doldinger, die Jazzrockschiene...
Wer diese Liste verbrochen hat kann nicht dabei gewesen sein
Ich verstehe deine Frustration! Es ist schwierig, alle großartigen Bands auf einer Liste zusammenzufassen, und jeder hat seine Favoriten. Welche Bands sollten Ihrer Meinung nach aus der Liste verschwinden und welche reinkommen?
@@BackingTrackCenter Frumpy und Birth Control gehören auf alle Fälle die vorderen Plätze, Unter anderem fehlen Karthago, Atlantis, Wallenstein, Kin Ping Me, Ton Steine Scherben etc. um nur inige zu nennen
Embrio?
Where would you put Embrio?
Birth Control and Guru Guru?
These two fantastic groups are on the list, I think it went unnoticed by you! Thanks for commenting.
Where ist Guru Guru
You can find Guru Guru at 02:12, just after Novalis.
@BackingTrackCenter Danke!Das Motto von Guru Guru war: täglich fit durch zwei Gramm Shit!!!
😂😂
Where is "Embryo", the pioneers of worldmusic ???
I completely agree, Embryo brought something unique and pioneering with world music. They definitely deserved a mention! Thanks for pointing that out!
@BackingTrackCenter I've known
Christian Burchard, Multiinstrumentalist and founder of Embryo, since the early seventies, when we both lived in München. He sadly passed away in january 2018. 🙏✨♥️