It's amazing how he brings the hospital, school, office, mental asylum and jail (birth to death) - into the same structural understanding and basis of oppression and violence.
@@NoahsUniverse i believe it has something to do with a lot of videos touching on social justice issues who use a phrase with some variation of "We live in a society where..." Also I think the Joker character from Batman is often mocked for spouting shallow social commentary, which even Heath Ledger's Joker was implicated for. I don't know for sure, though, I kinda pulled this one out my ass.
@@feature.of.jarjar24 you're right but it's mostly the former I think. It serves as a sharp criticism of the resentment of the mediocre. It's a criticism of the ego of democracy, and further more, the capitalists bastardization of social criticism.
Indeed, I don't understand how any little layman can believe or feel they have control at all. Moreover, even if you've conquered humanity, you're still shackled by the limitations of physics.
I don't think it's necessary or helpful to reduce power to a single definition. Boudrillard might note that 'freedom of movement' is also euphemism for correctly working bowels in laxative advertisements. We're regularly reminded that we have freedoms to buy this and that, move here or there.
I made the mistake of laying down to go to bed then bam, a man getting his arms pulled off by a team of horses. It made my eyes shoot open real quick and my heart race.
The Gulag Archipelago | Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn summarized it best.. go read. the most interesting point was that prison FOLLOWED the practice of exile .... and is far more destructive.
You sound like a native speaker of American English, but you seem to have a lot of trouble with pronunciation of multisyllabic words. May I recommend that before you read a section, you look up longer words in the dictionary to get the pronunciation right? It's a massively hard job you're trying to do and it's a shame you're not creating masterpieces of oral presentation. (The most common error: Although the accent falls on the first and third syllables of the noun "distribution", in the adjectives "distributive" and "distributive" the accent falls on the second syllable. I think in places you're saying "juridical" but the pronunciation is so garbled, it's hard to know.)
Yeah I'm definitely aware that I'm imperfect and inconsistent in a lot of these types of things. I suppose its the words that seem obvious and easy are the ones that really get you over the ones that are more difficult and you need to look up ha! Thanks for the specific examples though, I will be sure to keep those in mind in particular.
I really like the way your reading though. For me your pronunciation seems clear and whatever you pronounce differently doesn't disturb the flow of the reading at all! The only thing I noticed that you mispronoumced is french words, which hurts my soul, but is not something anyone could ask of someone who doesn't know french. Pls continue making great audiobooks, thank you so much for the effort! =)
Most intense book opening in history.
7:54 pg 6
11:13 pg 7
13:55 pg 8
20:43 pg 10
30:07 pg 13
38:35 pg 16
50:52 pg 20
56:32 pg 22
1:05:47 pg 24
1:13:05 pg 27
1:32:19 pg 35
1:35:30 pg 36
1:47:32 pg 40
2:08:40 pg 47
2:27:16 pg 53
2:39:59 pg 58
2:56:15 pg 63
3:26:42 pg 77
3:41:00 pg 82
4:12:26 pg 92
4:18:10 pg 94
4:39:55 pg 101
4:59:42 pg 108
5:16:26 pg 114
5:34:27 pg 120
5:52:37 pg 126
6:26:41 pg 141
6:50:14 pg 149
9:19:04 pg 200
9:47:30 pg 209
10:20:14 pg 220
gd bless u
It's amazing how he brings the hospital, school, office, mental asylum and jail (birth to death) - into the same structural understanding and basis of oppression and violence.
.tfŕrz44z3tccytť, b b l
He doesn't say they are necessarily oppressive, just that they have similar structure.
@@Heyu7her3I think it’s implied (especially regarding the Panopticon) but it might be time for a rereading.
i'm prepping to teach my grad class and this is so much better than the other available versions I found - thanks so much for this.
This makes me very happy to hear, very glad my work can be of important use! Best of luck to you.
you are a pretty based teacher
We truly do live in a society...
I still have yet to understand why people say this
That's what I keep sayin but the people don't listen
@@NoahsUniverse lack of originality, mostly.
@@NoahsUniverse i believe it has something to do with a lot of videos touching on social justice issues who use a phrase with some variation of "We live in a society where..." Also I think the Joker character from Batman is often mocked for spouting shallow social commentary, which even Heath Ledger's Joker was implicated for. I don't know for sure, though, I kinda pulled this one out my ass.
@@feature.of.jarjar24 you're right but it's mostly the former I think. It serves as a sharp criticism of the resentment of the mediocre. It's a criticism of the ego of democracy, and further more, the capitalists bastardization of social criticism.
This channel is such a gift! Please keep up the excellent work!
Thank you so much! This recording was so helpful for finishing my reading on time. Bravo.
Thank you, thank you, thank you! I haven't found a good one in Brazilian Portuguese, so, thank you very much for this!!!
What a book 💙
Thank you for the extraordinary effort
Thank you so much for this. Foucault is one of my favorite philosophers.
Woo, same here, there's no one like him!! I'm trying to get into grad school and working on a paper comparing his ideas on power with Adorno's.
@@joseph-zoramcbride4029Who’s Adorno?
The genealogy of discipline, the phenomenology of cruelty, the unfolding of mass pathology. The birth of fascism.
This book is savage; I love it.
Thank you so much for your time and effort on your channel. You are a very good reader.
Do you have any plans to read Madness and Civilization?
It was a grave mistake to begin this book while eating...
incredible effort!
Thanks for doing these
3:13:32 Part 2
After this, I think the best definition of power is “the physical proof of an individual or entity’s freedom”.
Does anyone have a different one?
What do you mean by 'proof'?
@@theoryaudiobooks9635 It's an undeniable, unmistakable, self-evident conclusion beyond a reasonable doubt.
@@roguespecies3203 Crystal clear! Insightful questions raised! 🙌
Indeed, I don't understand how any little layman can believe or feel they have control at all. Moreover, even if you've conquered humanity, you're still shackled by the limitations of physics.
I don't think it's necessary or helpful to reduce power to a single definition. Boudrillard might note that 'freedom of movement' is also euphemism for correctly working bowels in laxative advertisements. We're regularly reminded that we have freedoms to buy this and that, move here or there.
6:07:34 Part 3: Discipline, 1. Docile Bodies
literally the part i was looking for, thank you lol
Thank you so much ❤️
16:57 17:15 17:59 9:36:36
this is great, thank you so much
Thank you homie 🙌🏼🙌🏼
The amount of ads are the real torture
This is really good
We want new uploads... Where are youuuu.. Your contents were so amazing
Thank you, this was very helpful 👍
I made the mistake of laying down to go to bed then bam, a man getting his arms pulled off by a team of horses. It made my eyes shoot open real quick and my heart race.
Thank you!
Awesome. thank you very much.
Well read. Keep it up.
Thanks for this
thank you man
very good reading !
Eating while listening to this is enough to put me off my food for a whole day ! Don’t eat and listen to this 😒😂
Better to wash the dishes while listening to it
can someone tell me where the section discipline starts
Big Brother Forever. ⚘
no subtitles
Thank You!!!!!!!!!
did there have to be ads every 5 minutes tho like...
5:03:50
Does anyone know which translation this is?
English
This is Alan Sheridan's 1977 translation
55:39 page 22 first word
8:30:17
23:20
You put the emPHAsis on the wrong sylLABles when pronouncing apocryphal, repentant, and a few other repeated words. Great work, though.
The Gulag Archipelago | Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn summarized it best.. go read. the most interesting point was that prison FOLLOWED the practice of exile .... and is far more destructive.
9:24:00
4:07:01
4:24:17
4:36:56
5:06:39
5:11:24
5:44:03
@54:00
*THE MECHANISM*
01:03
Loving the book, but the reader sounds like the "#15: burger king foot lettuce" guy
57:16
What is this accent? It’s perplexing.
Did you just pronounce the word “cure” as “keer”? What even was that word!?!
38:40
❤️🙏
You sound like a native speaker of American English, but you seem to have a lot of trouble with pronunciation of multisyllabic words. May I recommend that before you read a section, you look up longer words in the dictionary to get the pronunciation right? It's a massively hard job you're trying to do and it's a shame you're not creating masterpieces of oral presentation. (The most common error: Although the accent falls on the first and third syllables of the noun "distribution", in the adjectives "distributive" and "distributive" the accent falls on the second syllable. I think in places you're saying "juridical" but the pronunciation is so garbled, it's hard to know.)
Yeah I'm definitely aware that I'm imperfect and inconsistent in a lot of these types of things. I suppose its the words that seem obvious and easy are the ones that really get you over the ones that are more difficult and you need to look up ha! Thanks for the specific examples though, I will be sure to keep those in mind in particular.
@@theoryaudiobooks9635 PS "Gesture" isn't pronounced the same as "jester."
I really like the way your reading though. For me your pronunciation seems clear and whatever you pronounce differently doesn't disturb the flow of the reading at all! The only thing I noticed that you mispronoumced is french words, which hurts my soul, but is not something anyone could ask of someone who doesn't know french. Pls continue making great audiobooks, thank you so much for the effort! =)
@@roguespecies3203 hear hear!
I thought you did great! Very clear audio and voice! My only gripe is you sound a bit too... dramatic... Otherwise great.
47 54
59:55
thank you sm homes 🫶🏼
Thank you!
9:04:20
6:21:03
1:39:25
9:37:31
35:24
25:12
4:46:24
5:33:20
9:47:30
10:43:43