Ukraine's military chief: Significant Russian advantages in forces and resources | DW News
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 เม.ย. 2024
- Ukraine's top general says his forces have suffered several setbacks on the battlefield in the war against Russia. In posts made on social media on Sunday, the commander-in-chief of the armed forces, Oleksandr Syrsky, said: "The situation on the front has worsened…The enemy has concentrated its main efforts on several areas, creating a significant advantage in forces and resources. The enemy is actively attacking along the entire front line, and making tactical gains in some areas…"
For more on this, we talk to military analyst Franke Ledwidge, who just returned from Ukraine.
#Ukraine #Russia #Donetsk
Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
![เกิดใหม่ทั้งทีก็เป็นสไลม์ไปซะแล้ว ซีซั่น 3 - ตอนที่ 56 [ซับไทย]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cT05Arhf_q8/mqdefault.jpg)
You guys told us Russian weapons wouldn’t last them a year. What happened?
You believed the MSM?. That’s very naive of you.
russians adepted a war time economy is what happened and republican in congress did not provided help in time so that new reality is now in place
promised support was held back by US republicans for nearly 3/4 of a year so eventually that shows when munitions run dry and it will take still some more time for the by now apporpriated support to reach the frontlines.
Meanwhile russia adpated a war time economy and if the west does not account for that and therefor also keeps up support or rather increases that support, the war may get lost for Ukrain. Otherwise purely from production capabilities, the west is a deeper well, but to draw from it would also mean consequences for the populations in the west which of cause for a pampered populace may seem inconvenient.
edit: grammar
@@kinngrimmyou ready to volunteer to fight in Ukraine?
@@kinngrimmThe weapons you claim were held back is a lie. The money promised is for production of new weapons, not drawing from existing stocks which are depleted across the West. Don’t parrot the Democrats.
Significant gains as Ukraine Gains backwards while Russia retreats fowards
Haha !!!
WAIT - the same guy said russia "ran out of ammo" in August of 2022 was the SAME GUY that said "China is doomed to fail".
they did run out of ammo in certain areas, but something called supply lines exist and eventually they get more.
You forgot he needed ping pong Xi and Unn for new ammo and equipment already?
Russia had low missiles ammo, then it thinks about war economy and eat their own country for war crimes. Well their infrastructure is bad, why dam breaks in Russia
He has 0 credibility and doesn't know how real war works😂😂😂This is why Ukraine is losing, they are listening to people like this.
Remember Prigozin swearing about ammo ?
Before Russia capturing a western tank it's a game changer
After Russia capturing it, it's an old model tank
For anyone who follows at least partially the situation in Ukraine the analysis of this "expert" is an insult of our intelligence.
I want these western analysts' job - they can carry on being wrong again and again and againa and again and again ... over literally decades, and still call themselves experts and be paid.
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine trying to weaken Russia as they think, but in fact Russia is only becoming stronger.
Western leaders think that removing Coca-Cola and McDonald's from the country will cause famine, a riot and the collapse of the state, but for some reason nothing happened
That is there job, the are advertisers not analyst.
It's like forecasting the weather!
They are paid for what they say.😜
that's the kind of "expert" they need, and got.
The Ukrainian general says the situation at the front is critical, but Mr Frank(an arm chair general) says it's not true.
It's very interesting in deed
Remember. "All warfare is based on deception" and "'Appear weak when you are strong, and strong when you are weak" .
@@eddualmeida5790 I don't think that applies when their Men are dying 2 months straight. Deception has its limits
@@josephh4795 2 years straight
He is a an arm chiar spon general
- Is this a reality check?
- No. We knew it all along.
Wow. Shovels are now retreating forward.
You poor bot
Sigh. The shovels were Prighozin's gift to his convicts, sent forward under enemy fire to dig trenches for the mercenaries that came after them.
I'm surprised nobody told you about that.
Wow at such a low pace against empty positions
@@majorminor3367 You Biden loverboy
It’s those dang washing machines of mass destruction.
Imagine what would Russians do if they had clean, not rusted shovels, and real microchips, not those pulled out from washing machines.
That's exactly what is starting to happen
imagine they were capable of providing these things themselves ... only to realize they aren't
Yah the old stuff are gone....
excellent point
@@kinngrimm Who cares who is providing .....
The same guy who said that during Ukraine greatest summer offensive Crimea would be captured and he can’t wait for beach holidays there🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂
😂😂😂
😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
These western analysts are paid for spreading copium analysis😂
That’s because the western MSM only puts on “experts” who tell them what they want to hear. If they put on Professor John Miershimer they would get a very different not to mention realists assessment of what’s actually happening in Ukraine.
Russian analysts were saying Ukraine would be taken in 3 days. And here we are, 2 years later..
"mobilize on the same scale as Russia"... and from what magic hat exactly would you expect them they pull those conscripts Mr expert?
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine trying to weaken Russia as they think, but in fact Russia is only becoming stronger
The funnies part is that Russia has had just one mobilization wave, whereas Zelensky has been conscripting soldiers non-stop for the last two years.
And would those conscripts want to fight?
From all the people who have not been conscripted?
@@user-un3ru6dt3wone never ending mobilization wave lol
And to think Blinken kindly asked China to not supply them with shovels...
Sigh. The shovels were Prighozin's gift to his convicts, sent forward under enemy fire to dig trenches for the mercenaries that came after them. So you are laughing at Russia cannon fodder tactics.
flying shovels....
TSMC 🇹🇼 Slava
China gets 40% of their income from the US. China did not vote for you in the UN. China refused to buy your coal beginning now.
@@16252 the shovels joke comes from the UK media repeating incesantly that the russians only fight with shovels. OK so this is what russians with shovels do.
“The Ukrainians need to mobilize on a similar scale to that of the Russians” wow, you don’t say! 🤯
Zelensky said Ukraine mobilized 800k troops, and also Zelensky said only 35k causalities to date. 🤔
Somehow Ukraine ran out of troops. 🤔🤷♂️
@@WSOJ3 wow i bet you feel so smart for realising he lied, yup, he did the exact thing that Russia has done thousands of times
ehm ... open the borders for those who wish to flee the war?
@@emil3458well at this point, Russia has been more honest than Beggensky throughout the war. They claimed a ridiculous number of casualties as well as downplayed the significant losses to Russia like Avdiivka.
The Russians are taking this fight deadly seriously. Regardless of whether you agree with their motives or not they are in this to win. These West by contrast has been all over the place.
There's a difference between Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya and Russia... it's beginning to be more and more clear
in Afghanistan, Americans shot women and children with machine guns, but here the situation is completely different
Afghanistan caused Russia to collapse last time when they were armed with western weapons. This is a lot more intense.
The difference is the Americans weren’t trying to annex parts of other countries for themselves.
@@jeremyj5932they were trying to. Indirectly by proxy.
@@Pqihtyieojn12 said who ? Putin ?
The real news is: 47th mechanized brigade left its frontline positions because they werent rotated out for a year, Russians noticed the gaps on the frontline, and made a 6 km advance, capturing Ocheretine in a few hours, blocking any traffic towards the south. That made the 115th mechanized brigade's position untenable since they were surrounded, so they had to evacuate Berdichi. Ukraine has to retreat 10 kilometers towards the next potential natural barrier. North of that position in Krasnokhorivka two columns of tanks and troop carriers made a 4 km rush towards the town, and deployed assault squads on the southern outskirts, which almost instantly captured those positions. By seeing the success Russians sent a constant cycling of troop carriers and sent four tanks which rushed in the streets of the city and spotted the potential Ukrainian troop concentrations. Where they found some the troops were directed there, so they took 3/4 of the town by the end of the day.
to whom are you trying to explain??? they don't care. they never try to find ukraine on map
Just giving depth to what actually is behind Sirsky's report. They only mentioned Chasiv Yar, where Su25's made flyovers over Ukrainian positions last week, which pretty much freaked them out.@@eliotness4029
Interesting, thanks.
Thanks. I tried following other channels such as Duran and History Legend but this detail about the withdrawal of the 47th was somehow missed.
for that, Blinkin is trying to blame China for Ukr's failure ?
the russians have learned a great deal from this war and damn it would be very difficult for any military to defeat them now.
sure, and they just have to spend every cent of their economy to keep it up. wont have to defeat them on the battlefield. But if we do decide to, the west has twenty times the GDP of Russia. that means if we spend 2 percent of our GDP to produce weapons, russia has to spend 40 percent of GDP just to keep up. you see how thats not a sustainable situation for Russia right?
@@peterpeterpeter6315is the GDP fighting in the battlefield?! If it does, then all those countries also are suffering a lot setbacks too! Ukraine has got billions of dollars on expensive equipment which shows to be ineffective on the battlefield! Ultimately, even Ukranians troops have been unsatisfied with those user-unfriendly, costly and commercial western military equipments, intended for both military operations and also profits private weapon manufacturers. How about that? 😂😂😂😂
Now tell that without crying@@peterpeterpeter6315
@@BarSoapGuy and you ignore that the largest arsenal of smart weapons is in russia? do you think that their glide bombs and hypersonic missiles hit the target just because chance?
@@peterpeterpeter6315 Wars are expensive. Look at how much we have to give to Ukraine and Israel to keep it up.
Why should any Ukrainian give his life for a totally corrupt system and for Blackrock? I wouldn't.
Well said
They don’t “georgyi”
@@maryanchabursky9148 They do...🤣🤣🤣
or give it for a guy in the White House that wears Depends and can't match his socks in the morning
Yeah being recolonized by the russian Empire is "better"
Anyone remember Mariupol, Bakhmut, Avdiivka?
Meat grinder
Mr expert said that Russia had small advances...
Slava TSMC 🇹🇼
remain in my heart
Yes, we Russians remember. And we also remember that Kharkiv and Odessa are Russian cities.
Reality Check is the right term no matter the Western denial.
Damn! Must be those powerful washing machines and advanced shovels!
not bad for a country that ran out of ammo 1.5 years ago....
Running to North Korea for ammo is sad for a wannabe superpower…
You are right
Maybe they ran out of ammo but they haven't run out of shovels.
@@foolish-808 Ah so like the uS getting small arms munitions from Mexico🤣🤡
All the more reason for Chinese and North Korean sanctions.
The hardwares in Russia are not
like Home Depot in the US, their
Shovels are lethal and dangerous 😊
So are their windows, apparently.
One side of the shovel blade is indeed sharpened and the Spetsnaz are trained to use it in unarmed combat. It is balanced so that it can also be used as a throwing knife.
Saying Ukraine can beat Russia is like saying Biden can walk upstairs without falling over..
😂😂
But wait...Elensy said not long ago Ukraine had lost 31k soldiers. Russia lost 31k the first month....
Best comment.
So Zelensky is a liar?
@@agungprasetyo2665 No way!
russia has lost more than 60k men, but many of these men perhaps as much as 25% are not russian, which should be a war crime.
Russia does lose way more troops but they don't care.
This so called analyst or expert forgot to mention what happened to the previously supplied air defense systems.
they run out of ammo
Frank is frankly preaching to save his job!
Oh come on, if they fail it, then the whole war will be forgotten.
Is not He the same Military Analyst who said Russia Has no Missiles left in 2022 ? 😎
Well done Frank !!! You are a Genius..give Frank a Medal and one Billion Euro !!! and tell the other Men that Frank is a Genius !!! Impressive Frank !!! 😄
Never in thousands years would I have thought that washing machine chips and shovels would be this effective in the battlefield 😂😂🤣🤣
That's cool
So basically the front has collapsed. That’s what he is saying.
Lmao. The frontline has collapsed. Boy expectations for rusbots are low
No. Unfortunately, the Russians are still there. But it is just a matter of time.....
By looking at live maps, I think there’s a spearhead that made it through, but I wouldn’t say that the frontline has collapsed.
It collapsed months ago. Russia has been in control of Ukraine entire east coast since prior to December
"It's not critical". This fool should lose his job over nonstop double talk.
Sure, Ivan
Absolutely. He knows nothing what's talking about!
Frank: Ukraine is winning and winning bigly.
Bot
@majorminor3367,
Do you mean frank is a bot?
No, he is NOT an analyst, he is an Anglo-Saxon propogandalist.
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine trying to weaken Russia as they think, but in fact Russia is only becoming stronger
@@majorminor3367 And you ? A copium miner for 🇺🇦 😂
On April 23, 2024 a new rule was put out on Ukrainian embassy website. Ukraine has stopped issuing new passports to some military-aged men living abroad as part of a bid to pressure them to return home to fight. The move is temporary and comes the day after the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry suspended consular services for men from 18 to 60 years old. Long queues formed at passport offices in European countries after Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba announced the measures. The limits come shortly after Ukraine adopted a new, stricter mobilization policy to shore up forces amid gains by Russia on the battlefield.
Every time he says Russia is learning he has to say Ukraine is learning too so if all are learning then how do you describe what's happening 😮
Everybody can learn.but putting into practice the lessons you learned while fighting a war and battles ,it's a different thing.the other guy won't allow you to play your game.
Never bring a gun to shovel fight😆🤣😂
After this war ended, most wanted items are Russian Shovels😊😊
Yes the turtle tanks really shocked the world.
And Chinese washing machines with those removable chips.
Sigh. The shovels were Prighozin's gift to his convicts, sent forward under enemy fire to dig trenches for the mercenaries that came after them. So you are laughing at Russia cannon fodder tactics.
yes, absolutely right. russian air defences, drohnes, FAB's tanks (compared to Abrams) will be big seller, guess kinshal, iskander are for now not for sale, at least not officially
Apparently they are only effective against an army that has “run out of men” lol
At 00:47 second he says “reality check” is not the right term and then at 1:54 he says “as you said reality is beginning to set in”
Good catch!
double talk as always
Double-think and new- language just as George Orwell 1984.
Never take $61 billion to a shovel fight.
Um, what?
We all know Ukraine will pocket most of it, and achieve next to no military gains.
😂😂😂😂
Russia has the right to defend itself from the Evil west and its support for genocides.
That was a sad time, corpses everywhere with either a shovel or other objects like a large stick at svatove, seems not even pro russians care about the army and are completely apathetic
Real men who deeply care about the lives of ordinary Ukrainians would have demanded for the war to stop and brought Ukraine and Russia to star real negotiations. Unfortunately, there are people who have vested interest in the continuation of the war. Ukraine sadly lacks visionaries and the country is being destroyed slowly.
Those shovels are amazing, aren't they? They keep digging and digging till they'll get to the water bed 😂😂😂
Ukraine is winning, says the British media and experts.😂😂😂
Ukraine is losing. Says the state controlled Russian media😂😂
@@majorminor3367west media controlled more than Russian media
The reality is that Russia is slowly winning. But it’s been a much harder fight than they expected.
@@majorminor3367 If Ukraine was winning, it wouldn't make any new rules to pressure their own men that are living abroad to fight. it looks like they are loosing after all. On April 23, 2024 a new rule was put out on Ukrainian embassy website. Ukraine has stopped issuing new passports to some military-aged men living abroad as part of a bid to pressure them to return home to fight. The move is temporary and comes the day after the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry suspended consular services for men from 18 to 60 years old. Long queues formed at passport offices in European countries after Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba announced the measures. The limits come shortly after Ukraine adopted a new, stricter mobilization policy to shore up forces amid gains by Russia on the battlefield.
If they can have adiivka, they can have anything.
Mobilizing is one, but giving them the necessary training and integrating them is very important.
end this war
military expert desperately trying to spin how Rus with shovels and museum tanks are winning
It is too bad US cannot send Ukrainians common sense.
That is not profitable.
U.S. can not do that, because they can not send Ukrainians, what they do not have.....
Ukraine has stopped issuing new passports to some military-aged men living abroad as part of a bid to pressure them to return home to fight. The move is temporary and comes the day after the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry suspended consular services for men from 18 to 60 years old. Long queues formed at passport offices in European countries after Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba announced the measures. The limits come shortly after Ukraine adopted a new, stricter mobilization policy to shore up forces amid gains by Russia on the battlefield.
Они может и могли бы дать здравый смысл, но его нет у самого сша
@@lunog🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣❤️♥️💯
I find it funny that the Top General of Ukraine is an ethnic Russian who attended Russian military school. 😂
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine trying to weaken Russia as they think, but in fact Russia is only becoming stronger
in USSR time it was one country. later ukrainians receive money from CIA to be barking dogs againt Russia
It's not funny but sad reality.
You know the situation is far worse when they cant lie anymore and tell the truth
Thanks to the west that plays with Ukraine life. We help you as long as it takes then ohh we don't help. What a shame.
We can’t, nato defensive
You act like this would have been the first time. What a surprise. How about the destruction of Iraq, Afghanistan, Korea, Vietnam, Hungary (1956), Syria, Serbia and so on, most of the African countries, Sudan, Congo, Libya... The West was always playing games with weeker and smaller countries, promising them a lot then letting them down.
The Ukrainians would have had the necessary arms in Novemember if the Republicans hadn't played politics with the aid package. It's hard to defend a position with no artillary. Ukraine also should have mobilized months ago.
@fr2ncm9
Ukraine should’ve thought about that back in 1991 when it gained its independence……….. it is a “democracy”……….. ohhhhhh that’s right it isn’t, never was and never will be………… but it’s probably easier to blame a democracy for a lack of artillery shells………… good luck, commander………… 🤨
@fr2ncm9
If republicans…….. wha wha wha….
Go blame some other democracy……… 😉
There exists no conceivable scenario in which Russia relinquishes control of Crimea and the Donbas region. The provision of NATO-led weaponry by the US will not bolster Ukraine's position; rather, it will inevitably lead to further casualties on the battlefield during the interim. It is imperative to pursue a negotiated settlement without delay. Failure to do so risks the West's unwavering support for Ukraine, at the cost of lives on the battlefield.
Russia has more casualties and running out of ammo.. most of their weapons are old soviet style and their military gains and missile attacks are all symbolic😂😂
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine trying to weaken Russia as they think, but in fact Russia is only becoming stronger.
Western leaders think that removing Coca-Cola and McDonald's from the country will cause famine, a riot and the collapse of the state, but for some reason nothing happened
Very interesting, if Ukraine have had enough men to fight. Maybe they wouldn't make new rules for all the Ukrainian men that are living abroad. On April 23, 2024 a new rule was put out on Ukrainian embassy website. Ukraine has stopped issuing new passports to some military-aged men living abroad as part of a bid to pressure them to return home to fight. The move is temporary and comes the day after the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry suspended consular services for men from 18 to 60 years old. Long queues formed at passport offices in European countries after Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba announced the measures. The limits come shortly after Ukraine adopted a new, stricter mobilization policy to shore up forces amid gains by Russia on the battlefield.
Russia running out of ammo was the case a year ago, so the media Actually doesnt lied, but russia was able to ramp up its production.
If the entire public is being fed with wrong information about the state of the Ukraine war, then you the media can be bold enough to take responsibility. Starting With your guest Frank who is almost always so fragile with the facts
But okraine only lost 31000?!
Kremlin trolls, India started paying for oil with bananas. If I were you, I'd start looking for another job.
@jankowalyk7301 You are repeating yourself put more effort than just copy pasting, funny thing you call others trolls
@@srve1149 Why need to put effor to descredit russian bot, russian troll?
@@srve1149 You do note deserve better. Panial?
@@wanderer2246I wonder how can you discredit the facts on the ground? Oh ye you can call them kremlin bots lol 😂 have some more copium, nafo troll, it's supplied abundantly these days 😅
Just tell the truth one day the truth will come out
The truth is that Mr Putin is not interested in liberating anyone in Ukraine, and he doesn't care how many people die. He just wants to be admired by millions of serfs as the next Tsar of all the Russias.
COMEDIAN + PRESIDENT = THE GREATEST CONMAN OF ALL TIMES.
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine trying to weaken Russia as they think, but in fact Russia is only becoming stronger
You should not say that because if he did ran from Ukraine you all call him the biggest coward president in history don't you..the man try fight for his country am not a Ukrainian am a Jamaican so yes big up the man who never back down to a giant he is not a hero just a man fighting for his freedom an the people of Ukraine....he is a warrior whether he win or lose...
Slava 🇹🇼
dictator please they supposed to hold election but Zellensky won't allow it
@@bonnie7898 good for them they can increase their bank balance 20 bill cash on the way 🤣
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine for theire own interests 😢😢😢😢
USA and EU sacrifice Ukraine trying to weaken Russia as they think, but in fact Russia is only becoming stronger
Nah
They would still be fighting, only with Soviet equipment. Do you think the people of Ukraine want to be under the oppression and genocide of the Kremlin, as they have been for centuries. There are people still alive in Ukraine who can vividly recall the Holodomor.
They made their choice when they kicked Yanukovich back to his puppet masters and chose Europe.
@@mrbad3036Ukraine today is the largest open air prison in the world. No man 18-60 is allowed to leave the country for the third year already and they are routinely forcibly dragged from streets to be sent to the frontlines with just 2 weeks of training. All opposition parties are banned, elections are cancelled and all TV channels show the only allowed news program called "Telemarathon". Thousands of people locked in jails as alleged "Russia sympathizers". Russia in comparison is a beacon of freedom and democracy.
@@mrbad3036 what are you even talking about "under the oppression and genocide" you don't know the meaning of those words. Go look at the map. Find the conflict and look at the involved parties with your own two eyes. You'll be shocked."They made their choice when they kicked Yanukovich back to his puppet masters and chose Europe." - that was CIA. Everything you wrote is a lie from CIA. You are very naive.
The implementation of a war of attrition against Russia has proven to be an ineffective strategy. Throughout history, numerous nations have attempted this approach, only to experience catastrophic failures.
Afghanistan chuckles at your posts
@@asynchronicity Aye, perhaps the leadership back then didn't want to bleed out their good soldiers unlike Putin. Two different cultures and people as well though - definitely not a good idea to try and occupy Afghanistan.
The US was successful in supporting a parallel Afghan society run by Afghans for 21 years, but as we unfortunately saw when the Roman Legions were unceremoniously called back in a disastrous move by Biden, the Taliban took over swiftly, conquering the corrupt Afghan army and propped up western led Afghan government in a matter of days.
Goat , sheep shepherds defeated the mighty NATO😅
@@asynchronicitythat was just a mess dear lord… maybe he means a war of attrition with no mountains to run and hide in.
@@bache72 Yeah, Trump of course kicked the Afghanistan can down the road for all the obvious reasons.
Europe is stuck in this position because of a foreign policy led by the US arms industry, which NEEDED to continue making an enemy out of post-Soviet Russia. None of this would have happened if Ukraine had simply stayed neutral and refused to play that game.
💯 now Ukraine is the Syria of Europe
The same arms industry that has yet to spin up enough to provide what's needed? Yes. Yes, they spent years conspiring to create this war and have now missed out on 2 years of arms buying because....plans.
helping ukraine has large bipartisan support in both US and EU, not just the US. If we don't stop the russians in ukraine, they will keep taking
@@paulert23keep taking? Will they go to Berlin in order to provide well-being for numerous newcomers from M.E. and Africa??😅
@@paulert23 'Helping' Ukrainians destroy themselves has little support outside of the US / NATO political class. The fantasy of Russian expansion has no basis in reality. Russia is interested in finally ending its 2014-vintage war with Ukraine's CIA-installed government. Russia is also very interested in ensuring Ukrainian neutrality. But it has absolutely no interest - nor the material capability - to get involved in a wider war.
These are not setbacks its a systematic collapse
.... and defeat 😊
@@jankowalyk7301 Hey buddy, there are no trolls here, only people who wants to know and spread the truth.
Don’t think so
@@kamilhorvat8290 Tovarisch Iwanow. Truth is only on RT and Sputnik.
@@user-xq8xx7gq8lyou wish.. after 2 years!?
Herr Frank Leywidge the military analyst - who said Ukraine was not in crises, seemed jittery, nervous, talked too fast - usual signs of a person not telling the truth
In Russian's shovels we trust.
Thank God for independent journalists, other sources like scott ritter and many others than listening to these clowns
Last year, you said Ukraine's reformed 14th Waffen Grenadier Division of the SS 1st Galician was on the outskirts of Moscow! What happened?
It would be worth thinking about Russia's superiority in forces and resources in advance, before stipulating membership in NATO in its Constitution.
Indeed. Their so called democratic regime sold the whole generation
But Latvia bots laugh when we say russia are winning even though the chief of their army admitted it
The Baltic states always bark loudly, but when the troops arrive, they dance well and pour drinks
@@igormatrosov5984 And they are always first in line when Mutti Ursula gives handouts from Brussels. How stunning and brave they are.
@@Memovox Ignorance is bliss. Imagine if they realized they are a puny US sponsored speedbump against Russia, shall Russia decide to move into Europe proper ( luckily for them, it won't )
baltic tigers
Hello again bot
Those advantages don't mean squat, when you are clueless on how to conduct a modern war with 1950's and 1960's equipment.
Thank you senior Defence analyst.
Fred, why should anyone belief a word you have to say?
Russian shovels and washing machines are beating abrams and leopards? Damn...
You can't hold a modern battle front if the other side has airpower and you don't.
The person giving witness is self pleasing
Russia has been building up their forces, so this was expected, but when they attack from the north Ukraine will be in more trouble! Russia still has plenty of tanks & troops & other equipment in abundance, lossing a thousand tanks is nothing to Russia, they have not been using their best kit as yet!
damn those washing-machine chips
What happened to that American Made "Parrot Missile System " ??
Extinct..but being reintroduced😂
busy catching flies and mosquitos I heard, failed at that too
That guy knows the real truth but he has some difficulties saying it to the public 😊😇
The best thing to do for Ukraine is to call Russia and start negotiations ! Those hopes of winning are unrealistic, Ukraine should preserve both men and territories that are left !
Indeed. Ukraine was never going to defeat its much bigger neighbour in a stand up fight. That reality is now being realised.
@@fspg3207 sad times to be a ukr bot
@@fspg3207 All conflicts end in negotiation
The best time to negotiate is before the first shot is fired.
The next best time to negotiate is now.
The absolute worst time to negotiate is when you can no longer fight back.
The reason you call him a troll is because subconsciously you have already accepted defeat.
spitting truth like a mad philosopher @@MetaView7
What do you think they are, intelligent?
im shocked all the reporting has had ukraine winning any day now
Says the absolute random nobody
Ukrainians are advancing backwards while Russians are retreating forward 😂
@@noahbrooks8939How dare you call DW News a "random nobody".
@@DrojanaleTorvic to be fair, russia advanced backwards about 175,000 square kilometers while russia has advanced about 15000 square kilometers in these two years
@@Talinthis yeah Talinthis, and this mistake will not be made again
I recalled that the defense minister of Ukraine was replaced. The motives were just that his staff did not believe of the Ukranian victory. However, I imagine this scenario. He wanted to retreat its forces near the capital to concentrate their defenses and to coordinate better the units, to which Zelinsky did not agree. Instead of studying the assessment, he replaced the minister of defense.
Wait, I thought the Russian soldiers still uses shovels and are being pushed back into Moscow🤔
Losing ground means winning.
Yes, winning the losing ground game……. And pretty well also…….
Yes because now Russia has more land that they have to control. While Ukraine can consolidate their defense line.
just russian
shovels
Russia has lost ground throughout the war too. The West needs to redouble their efforts in supporting Ukraine. Russia is willing to sacrifice many more Russian lives.
They're just luring them in... yeah, that's it
🙏🏻🇺🇦 ❤️from 🇺🇸 UNITED TOGETHER 🌎☮️
you really want eternal war underneath all your platitudes
Fred, always the optimist and feeding us tripe. Where is his ukrainian flag 😂
Russia must start exporting those deadly shovels, its so deadly
Yep, they seem to have a handle on those shovels
Good on DW for leaving the comments section open. Respect.
I thought Russians are fighting with shovels?😂
Before the aid they were losing because of the lack of supply. Now after 60 billion dollar aid they still losing because it's not enough. 😅
What part of this could not have been foreseen two years ago?
This is the same comedian military analyst that said over 2 years ago that Russia will collapse in a month .
And next month, we are going to hear the experts: "Why are child soldiers good for democracy in ukraine". This is literall clown show.
Freedom comes at a price.
And what bonus freedom will the average Ukrainian have that they would not have had in a neutral Ukraine?
@@Hereford1642 Protection against Russia whenever they decide to attack again and violate whatever new peace deal they agree to.
A peace agreemeant was reached in 2014, obviously Russia didn’t respect it. What’s to stop them from invading again?
Only NATO membership can ensure Ukraine’s future as a democratic and independent state.
What if that person does not want to go die for it's state establisment?
Can we have Ben Hodges on with one of his alternate reality mood boosters please? Ukraine will take back Crimea next month!
Joker from sky news, never said single thing right
Indeed. If you want a good dose of delusional BS there is no one better than Ben Hodges.
If they have any men left to fight. Looks like they are loosing. News just spread out. On April 23, 2024 a new rule was put out on Ukrainian embassy website. Ukraine has stopped issuing new passports to some military-aged men living abroad as part of a bid to pressure them to return home to fight. The move is temporary and comes the day after the Ukrainian Foreign Ministry suspended consular services for men from 18 to 60 years old. Long queues formed at passport offices in European countries after Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba announced the measures. The limits come shortly after Ukraine adopted a new, stricter mobilization policy to shore up forces amid gains by Russia on the battlefield.
@@braxxian My number one for delusional BS is Times Radio. But I will check Ben Hodges too.
So to quote classics:
9th March, the Cannibal has quitted his den
10th, the Corsican Ogre has landed at Cape Juan
11th, the Tiger has arrived at Gap
12th, the Monster slept at Grenoble
13th, the Tyrant has passed through Lyons
14th, the Usurper is directing his steps towards Dijon, but the brave and loyal Burgundians have risen en masse and surrounded him on all sides
18th, Bonaparte is only sixty leagues from the capital; he has been fortunate enough to escape the hands of his pursuers
19th, Bonaparte is advancing with rapid steps, but he will never enter Paris
20th, Napoleon will, tomorrow, be under our ramparts
21st, the Emperor is at Fontainebleau
22nd, His Imperial and Royal Majesty, yesterday evening, arrived at the Tuileries, amidst the joyful acclamations of his devoted and faithful subjects.
They should be asking themselves what is the reason behind the disaperance of UA anti-aircraft capabilities.
Ammunition for them was largely expended after Russia launched an extensive drone and missile attack using stockpiled domestic and foreign drones and missiles.
It's true that they have run low on missiles but the major problem is the defeat of most of their patriot batteries. They have been struck both in kieve and the Eastern parts of the country.
U.S. M1A Abrams tanks worse than useless against Russian drones.
But what tanks are better against UAV?
Now they all agree that the Russians learn so they are not as dumb and careless as they all made us believe after all
can you imagine the morale if everytime i look acoss the battlefield i see my previous position for two years
But you told the World that Russia had no Army 😂😂😂😂😂and that Ukraine had all the advantage
Stop been delusional
The Russian army is very incompetent and inefficient. They advance through sheer numbers and persistence, especially in light of the critical lack of ammunition on the Ukrainian side due to MAGA Republicans holding up aid for months.
As history shows.
The tides can change.
Russia has always had an advantage in manpower etc, it's just starting to bear fruit now.
Opposite 😊
I can hear your accent. Tell your boss at the bot farm to get you English lessons.
so now they are telling what you want right? why are you still mad... they are telling your agenda
This explains why ukraine is aggressively drafting men into their army. The tales of Ukrainian victory have been hollow ones.
I Thought Russian was running out of missilen in 2022
I thought russian wount last using shovel😂