I’m a bears fan from Chicago but a bigger Fields fan. I’m originally from Jersey. If Fields signs with Giants I will be a happy dude! I grew up rooting for Giants during the Simms and Parcells era. Your critique and analysis of Fields was dead on. This kid is a sleeping giant no pun intended! lol
As for QB I’d definitely get fields, I was hoping they get fields last year. I would trade Thibs for a 2nd rounder. 1st pick Carter, 2nd rounder best available & additional 2nd get Milroe. Top FA pickup would be Higgins. That’s 5 players that could turn this team around.
I think this is a great spot with Dabol. At the same time, He does come with a risk. I am a big Fields fan that has followed him . Here is what you can expect: Floor is DJ play off edition 2.0. Ceiling: Unknown. With a legit #1 ( see dj moore) he has the best qb-wr rating in 2023. he is accuate in situtions where Wideouts dont get separation. He is a great locker room presence. He is getting better at not turning the ball over and at not taking sacks. He has a good deep ball but when he misses it usually high and bad. He lacks touch and aneeds to typically see the WR get open but has been gettin g better at anticipation. He is a better scrambler than runner. He can read the defense well but it is sporadic. he has not had quality wr or o-line play and his coaches were defensive minded guys with horrible OC's Arthur smith is ok.
DJ Moore's numbers where WAY DOWN playing without Fields this past season. Fields should be the Giants number QB target this offseason and that includes what they do in the draft. Rather the Giants Sign Fields, go BPA with the #3 pick(Carter, Hunter), then draft a developmental QB in one of the later rounds of the 2025 draft.
I think Jameis Winston is the best option. Fields has the same problem Jones had with the Giants. He fails to push the ball downfield. That is why he got benched with the Steelers. They were not happy with the lack of production from the passing game. I don't want Sam Darnold. Through 83 games Darnold 61.2 % Completion Percentage 16,383 Yards 98 TDS 68 INTs QBR 83.9 Jameis WInston throught 83 games Completion Percentage: 60.6% Passing Yards: 28,701 Touchdowns: 174 Interceptions: 114 Passer Rating: 87.1 I used each guys first 83 games because Darnold has only played 83 games. Both have a career completion percentage of 61.2%. Winston's biggest negative is he is too aggressive looking to force the ball downfield. Leads to interceptions it would be easier for Daboll to get Winston to pull back some. Then it would be to get Fields to take chances. I prefer the guslinger mentallity at QB. In Cleveland this year Winston had a worse O line than the Giants have he also had the worst WR room in the NFL especially in terms of drops. He still had 2100 yards and 13 TDs in just 5 games. He put up 334 yards and 3 TDs against the Ravens. As well as 497 yards and 4 TDs against the Broncos. Topped 300 yards passing 3 times and had 2 or more TDs 4 times. Given the prices for Darnold is estimated around 40 million. Give me Winston who has signed a 1 year 4 million dollar contract each of the last 2 seasons. Better play and 1/10th the price.
I like Anthony and respect his opinions. But my view on our supposed next “bridge “ quarterback is he will either be;a) a journeyman back-up, b) old and washed up, or c). A combination of a) and b). That’s what these guys are. Guy like Darnohl are the unicorns. But, seeing as that is my opinion anyway, we may as well give Fields to Anthony…if only to make him happy.
Then Anthony’s point went over your head. He’s not saying fields is likely to be the savior but he is a young player that has a possibility to emerge if his talent is used properly. You already know what you have with every other bridge QB option. There is no upside or best case scenario with the other options. With Fields you know he has a high ceiling still and an adequate floor. It’s win-win. You get an average starter at worst and an emerging franchise star at best.
I would be OK with it but before the Steelers went to Russ, he looked like he did with the bears, holding the ball too long quick to tuck and run it, staring down receivers, not my first choice but I would be OK with it
Wrong! What We need is PASSER ,High Completion Percentage,He doesn't Fit What We want to Accomplish,Draft your Future QB,,Sign a Veteran Bridge,,A Lot of Free Agent Options out there and affordable too.
This makes so much sense dude..Giants should hire you somehow, shape or form lol... They're in dire need of fresh minds like yours. This type of move would put the Giants in a decent position to at least win some more games
He isn’t a Bridge QB man. Unless the Giants truly believe that he is a franchise QB he is not a guy you bring in to wait on a drafted guy. You bring in Russell Wilson on someone like that.
What about Malik Willis. He looked good this season in the opportunities he was given. And Daboll gives me no confidence he’s good at developing a QB! Josh Allen masked Daboll. Dude is top 10 QBs talent wise EVER 6’5 249 with cannon of an arm and can run like Ben Rothlesburger on ROIDS! And wants to be great!
Also your Assuming He's gonna come in Learn another new offense and Absorb enough to NOT make mistakes that cause turnovers,,Center Exchanges aren't automatic you know it takes reps,,lots of reps,,Your Reaching Bruh.
But also keep in mind that Eberflus didn’t do Caleb Williams any favors either. He had two 1st round QBs with high upside and athleticism, and he screwed up both Caleb and Justin. I still think Justin has a high ceiling and Caleb will benefit from being with a more offensively creative coach.
Justin Fields is just a faster Daniel Jones until you can prove otherwise. If you tired of a 1 read QB holding the ball then how you want Fields, we had 6 yrs of it, make it make sense. He not the QB to groom my rookie Qb cos that's what a "bridge" Qb basically is. I'll give him some credit, his deep ball better than Jones.
I'm all about Fields as a bridge, but he has some of the same issues as Jones. He doesn't process well and he doesn't work the middle of the field. He'll never be more than an average QB.
I’m a bears fan from Chicago but a bigger Fields fan. I’m originally from Jersey. If Fields signs with Giants I will be a happy dude! I grew up rooting for Giants during the Simms and Parcells era. Your critique and analysis of Fields was dead on. This kid is a sleeping giant no pun intended! lol
JF has statistically gotten better every season, despite shit coaches and rosters. If this was a white QB he wouldn’t get so much hate
"This kid is a sleeping giant no pun intended! lol That's why Schoen won't sign him!. He's clueless about QB's.
He’s a QB1 , not a bridge QB
Asterisk on both.
Fields has been my guy since he was in high school!!! Give Justin a chance!!!
QB 1 for sure
💯 agree. Fields is the best QB FA you can sign. Do it.
Fields, Nabers, Hunter, and Tracey would be elite
Facts
Agree Fields is the #1 target. 3-4 year deal with options..
Fields is best option because we could hit a miracle and he becomes the next Darnold
If darnold did anything like fields did in his first 3 seasons he woulda been on jets still fields just need a good OC and a few weapons
Definitely a good option when you consider we probably won't get Cam or Sanders. Draft Hunter, sign Fields and let's see how far Daboll can take them.
Great idea!
Fields is staying in Pittsburgh. It's pretty clear at this point.
Agree he has enough experience maybe new team that actually has his back could do him good
Fields to Malik, Travis, Wandale, Tracey, and Theo. 🤟🏼
Why on earth would Justin Fields want to come to this dumpster fire of an organization? We have ZERO to offer him.
you offer a malik nabers and travis hunter to throw to
Send the Patriots a draft pick for Joe Milton.
Daboll came in with a spark and energy he was more on who practiced best and went with those guys wasn't done any of that in the last 2 seasons
We need to draft for the trenches
I always like fields never really got a chance
What game exactly is Fields playing in 🤣, love watching you guys! Let’s go Giants 3:53
I agree!
Please let us get fields man it will make the draft a lot less complicated if he's on the roster
As for QB I’d definitely get fields, I was hoping they get fields last year. I would trade Thibs for a 2nd rounder. 1st pick Carter, 2nd rounder best available & additional 2nd get Milroe. Top FA pickup would be Higgins. That’s 5 players that could turn this team around.
Hell yeah do it.....
Let’s do it hope Shane feels the same way . Sign fields draft Hunter and dart,or alamba or Texas qb second round
Texas QB is not good
Justin fields is qb1 bridge
I think this is a great spot with Dabol. At the same time, He does come with a risk. I am a big Fields fan that has followed him . Here is what you can expect: Floor is DJ play off edition 2.0. Ceiling: Unknown. With a legit #1 ( see dj moore) he has the best qb-wr rating in 2023. he is accuate in situtions where Wideouts dont get separation. He is a great locker room presence. He is getting better at not turning the ball over and at not taking sacks. He has a good deep ball but when he misses it usually high and bad. He lacks touch and aneeds to typically see the WR get open but has been gettin g better at anticipation. He is a better scrambler than runner. He can read the defense well but it is sporadic. he has not had quality wr or o-line play and his coaches were defensive minded guys with horrible OC's Arthur smith is ok.
Yes please!
clear w take
DJ Moore's numbers where WAY DOWN playing without Fields this past season. Fields should be the Giants number QB target this offseason and that includes what they do in the draft. Rather the Giants Sign Fields, go BPA with the #3 pick(Carter, Hunter), then draft a developmental QB in one of the later rounds of the 2025 draft.
Why not? I'll Definitely Do It!
I think Jameis Winston is the best option. Fields has the same problem Jones had with the Giants. He fails to push the ball downfield. That is why he got benched with the Steelers. They were not happy with the lack of production from the passing game.
I don't want Sam Darnold. Through 83 games Darnold 61.2 % Completion Percentage 16,383 Yards 98 TDS 68 INTs QBR 83.9
Jameis WInston throught 83 games Completion Percentage: 60.6% Passing Yards: 28,701 Touchdowns: 174 Interceptions: 114 Passer Rating: 87.1
I used each guys first 83 games because Darnold has only played 83 games. Both have a career completion percentage of 61.2%. Winston's biggest negative is he is too aggressive looking to force the ball downfield. Leads to interceptions it would be easier for Daboll to get Winston to pull back some. Then it would be to get Fields to take chances. I prefer the guslinger mentallity at QB. In Cleveland this year Winston had a worse O line than the Giants have he also had the worst WR room in the NFL especially in terms of drops. He still had 2100 yards and 13 TDs in just 5 games. He put up 334 yards and 3 TDs against the Ravens. As well as 497 yards and 4 TDs against the Broncos. Topped 300 yards passing 3 times and had 2 or more TDs 4 times.
Given the prices for Darnold is estimated around 40 million. Give me Winston who has signed a 1 year 4 million dollar contract each of the last 2 seasons. Better play and 1/10th the price.
I like Anthony and respect his opinions. But my view on our supposed next “bridge “ quarterback is he will either be;a) a journeyman back-up, b) old and washed up, or c). A combination of a) and b). That’s what these guys are. Guy like Darnohl are the unicorns. But, seeing as that is my opinion anyway, we may as well give Fields to Anthony…if only to make him happy.
Then Anthony’s point went over your head. He’s not saying fields is likely to be the savior but he is a young player that has a possibility to emerge if his talent is used properly. You already know what you have with every other bridge QB option. There is no upside or best case scenario with the other options. With Fields you know he has a high ceiling still and an adequate floor. It’s win-win. You get an average starter at worst and an emerging franchise star at best.
@@azikkiiyou apparently don’t appreciate my sense of humor😊
Agreed but do the NYG try to sign him?
I would be OK with it but before the Steelers went to Russ, he looked like he did with the bears, holding the ball too long quick to tuck and run it, staring down receivers, not my first choice but I would be OK with it
Wrong! What We need is PASSER ,High Completion Percentage,He doesn't Fit What We want to Accomplish,Draft your Future QB,,Sign a Veteran Bridge,,A Lot of Free Agent Options out there and affordable too.
I agree fa day 1 Schoen better land him. If bring Jimmy g in also as vet back up
This makes so much sense dude..Giants should hire you somehow, shape or form lol... They're in dire need of fresh minds like yours. This type of move would put the Giants in a decent position to at least win some more games
Would love him
Justin Fields round 1 Travis hunter round 2 Kyle Mc Cord
We need justin fields but joe Schoen will mess everything up 🏈
Anything is better than the trash 🗑 the Giants have right now
He isn’t a Bridge QB man. Unless the Giants truly believe that he is a franchise QB he is not a guy you bring in to wait on a drafted guy. You bring in Russell Wilson on someone like that.
What about Malik Willis. He looked good this season in the opportunities he was given. And Daboll gives me no confidence he’s good at developing a QB! Josh Allen masked Daboll. Dude is top 10 QBs talent wise EVER 6’5 249 with cannon of an arm and can run like Ben Rothlesburger on ROIDS! And wants to be great!
Hoping Justin goes to Cleveland.
Funny thing is the GAINTS had a chance to draft him and as always they shitted the bed he shouldn’t step foot in this organization
Sign fields. Trade down and get a later one, some seconds and thirds. Need a bunch of good players at low salary.
Also your Assuming He's gonna come in Learn another new offense and Absorb enough to NOT make mistakes that cause turnovers,,Center Exchanges aren't automatic you know it takes reps,,lots of reps,,Your Reaching Bruh.
Remember when Fields helped the Bears go to the Super Bowl? Yeah, me neither!
But also keep in mind that Eberflus didn’t do Caleb Williams any favors either. He had two 1st round QBs with high upside and athleticism, and he screwed up both Caleb and Justin. I still think Justin has a high ceiling and Caleb will benefit from being with a more offensively creative coach.
We are keeping him find ur own qb
Don't understand why the gaints just go through draft
I don't want Justin field. By the end of the season, we are going to be pushing him out the door.
Justin Fields is just a faster Daniel Jones until you can prove otherwise. If you tired of a 1 read QB holding the ball then how you want Fields, we had 6 yrs of it, make it make sense. He not the QB to groom my rookie Qb cos that's what a "bridge" Qb basically is. I'll give him some credit, his deep ball better than Jones.
2 yrs 30 mil
I'm all about Fields as a bridge, but he has some of the same issues as Jones. He doesn't process well and he doesn't work the middle of the field. He'll never be more than an average QB.
He has improved midden field vision and throwing look at his highlights
Yeah, no thanks 😂 fields sucks
Obviously Field's wasnt as good as a old russell.....that says it all
😅😅😅 wtf would JF go to the giants for 8 games terrible... if you sig. Fields you DONT take a QB early
I’m looking at Carr if he’s released
Carr is done