Because this machine does not have any tension system. It is some very low quality braiding. You can buy a real braiding machine in China for 300 usd which is 100 times more complex mechanics. This is worth nothing in my opinion.
@@danielcrall9507 Like most of his machines, it demonstrates the principle without necessarily being useful at all. I agree a real maypole-style braider is not expensive in Asia and can do real work. Or for serious production, a Wardwell style.
I would have asked the same question. It would be interresting to see what realy comes out. I expect a fairly loose braid. This could have been optimized with some tensioned rope feeder.
Why don´t you show the complete machine in one shot? 12:15 One thing is strange: The machine makes a braid at the bottom. After the film cut you can see a twisted cord being wound up. No braid!
5:39 There's a lot going on in this schematic but I don't understand the purpose of most of this. You're using A4988 motor drivers (presumably for the nema 17 steppers) but also include two L293D's for DC Motors, from what's shown here it looks like only some of the circuit is actually used (the stuff for the stepper motors), had you not used stepper motors in the first place you probably wouldn't have needed any micro-controller circuitry.
Very cool design but why use an Arduino and steppers? Couldn't you just have easily used 2 brushless DC motors and maybe some felt pads to tension the string? Also you have a 3d printer so would it not have been easier to make the aligning top plate from plastic instead of wood? I see you may have had some very slight under extrusion and maybe small tolerance issues on your 3d printer so I can see how that could be an issue but I would assume it's more precise than a jigsaw and a piece of paper.
Great Build! Some tolerance issues, but I feel with CNC Cut Aluminium for the non 3D Printed Parts, as well as low friction plastic for the contact points and you have yourself a very capable machine. Do you have a program that measures the length produced etc? Also how does spool changing work? Is this scalable to larger designs or more threads? Also can wire be used? All in all great work.
What Arduino is doing here, rotating gears only ... Anyone from Bangalore, India , want to do such experiments and video, ping me, i will provide our R&D lab to build your product from idea, equipped with cnc , 3d print , pcb prototype, lathe etc ..
Nice build but I don't like a flat drill in a drilled hole. It will catch and ruin the drill, I'd has ruined one. Drill with the flat drill to the desired depth, thereafter drill through with the jobber drill. The jobber drill will center in the centerhole the flat drill made. You had an hole in the aluminium rod prior to start drilling. Not unexpected, it had a little runout. When you drill anew, the runout will persist. If you plane the hole away completely, ( and use a center drill first ) you avoid the runout.
It's quite amazing how many deaf mutes are on TH-cam. Btw, fingers so close to a spinning blade will eventually make future projects a little more difficult.
Thanks for the idea, I will build it without all the motors. Maybe 3D printing the top also works. Do you have a template for the top? Could you upload it to thingiverse?
Going by your final image of the three ply twist, your braiding machine was a failure. Do you think we can't tell the difference between three ply which is just twisted together and braiding?
Once the thread has been braided can you place the 3 ply thread back on the machine and braid again or would you need larger bobbins? I love this design by the way and look forward to your video's arriving.
Since I know nothing about electrical engineering, I can still use this design but just use a crank to move the first gear! As long as I don’t have to braid the string with my hands 😅
Such a strange mix of 3D printed parts, wooden parts, and machined metal parts. I don't think the machine works very well, there's no tension on the cords and it's not shown working all in one, uncropped shot. Finally, as other's have pointed out the final product seems to be twisted and not braided.
Exactly what i was saying regarsing tension. I know a lot about braiding machines and i did not watch even the final rope part. Now when i look at it its really a twisted 3 strand rope and not a braided rope. This video is made just for having profit from the viewers.. Clearly. This is not a working product.
@@danielcrall9507 if you look at the track pattern it is braided, albeit loosely. The braid works only appear to twist in one direction because it's only 3 strands.
Why not 3D print everything? There's a LOT of unnecessary things in there. You can get a couple stepper motor driver / oscillators for next to nothing unless you just wanted to layout a board and go through all that.
I thought about that too. I think the controller is used so that you can adjust the twist rate. Also the speed of the upper motor needs to allow down as the roll grows.
@@worstcaseontario6395 The machine is not fake though, so very confusing why they show just a twisted rope instead, my guess is that since there is nothing to deal with tension (and varying tension as the top spool picks up more and more rope) the braiding is very sloppy and poor. With a bit of extra effort this can be made to work but really needs some clever programming on the Arduino (more clever than just having 2 steppers turn at set speeds) and some way to monitor tension (simple weight loop with height measurement for instance).
Dude do you work some where as an engineer..you can't be a random person having a passion for things to make..have you done your from college and worked professionally some where, i,m sure of it..! please reply.Thanks ~namaste~
There was nothing added to this project by using an arduino and stepper motors than cost. I would like to see the machine you used to make the finished rope, it was NOT the machine you built.
Why was the rope shown at the end just twisted and not braided?
It seems to be a good question.
Because this machine does not have any tension system. It is some very low quality braiding. You can buy a real braiding machine in China for 300 usd which is 100 times more complex mechanics. This is worth nothing in my opinion.
@@danielcrall9507 Like most of his machines, it demonstrates the principle without necessarily being useful at all. I agree a real maypole-style braider is not expensive in Asia and can do real work. Or for serious production, a Wardwell style.
I would have asked the same question. It would be interresting to see what realy comes out. I expect a fairly loose braid. This could have been optimized with some tensioned rope feeder.
Because we live in a simulation and the simulation didn't think anyone would notice
Why don´t you show the complete machine in one shot? 12:15 One thing is strange: The machine makes a braid at the bottom. After the film cut you can see a twisted cord being wound up. No braid!
Приятно смотреть когда у человека руки из правильного места растут😁👍👍👍
5:39 There's a lot going on in this schematic but I don't understand the purpose of most of this. You're using A4988 motor drivers (presumably for the nema 17 steppers) but also include two L293D's for DC Motors, from what's shown here it looks like only some of the circuit is actually used (the stuff for the stepper motors), had you not used stepper motors in the first place you probably wouldn't have needed any micro-controller circuitry.
Very cool design but why use an Arduino and steppers? Couldn't you just have easily used 2 brushless DC motors and maybe some felt pads to tension the string? Also you have a 3d printer so would it not have been easier to make the aligning top plate from plastic instead of wood? I see you may have had some very slight under extrusion and maybe small tolerance issues on your 3d printer so I can see how that could be an issue but I would assume it's more precise than a jigsaw and a piece of paper.
Great Build! Some tolerance issues, but I feel with CNC Cut Aluminium for the non 3D Printed Parts, as well as low friction plastic for the
contact points and you have yourself a very capable machine. Do you have a program that measures the length produced etc? Also how does spool changing work? Is this scalable to larger designs or more threads? Also can wire be used? All in all great work.
What Arduino is doing here, rotating gears only ...
Anyone from Bangalore, India , want to do such experiments and video, ping me, i will provide our R&D lab to build your product from idea, equipped with cnc , 3d print , pcb prototype, lathe etc ..
Good stuff. I would also like to see a loom to make fabric if possible
Que precio en moneda colombiana tiene esa máquina de trenzar?
Nice build but I don't like a flat drill in a drilled hole. It will catch and ruin the drill, I'd has ruined one. Drill with the flat drill to the desired depth, thereafter drill through with the jobber drill. The jobber drill will center in the centerhole the flat drill made. You had an hole in the aluminium rod prior to start drilling. Not unexpected, it had a little runout. When you drill anew, the runout will persist. If you plane the hole away completely, ( and use a center drill first ) you avoid the runout.
Can this be scaled up by 3-4 spools. Perfect start for a Litz Wire Machine
Thanks for sharing!
Mr innovative.......mr amazing 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👍😀
You could use a empty filament spool as a spool.
cool vid. Cheers
Creo que puedo hacerlo sin Arduino y sin motores paso a paso. Solo con motores simples DC y con tensores. Buen trabajo con el 3D.
It's quite amazing how many deaf mutes are on TH-cam. Btw, fingers so close to a spinning blade will eventually make future projects a little more difficult.
He will simply make "shorter" videos with his remaining fingers. ☺
@@BeachsideHank Giving someone the finger won't quite have the same sentiment.
@@jasongreene303 He'll only be 98.7% of the man he used to be if he doesn't pay attention whilst sawing. ☺
Will it work for an hour without catastrophic self-damaging?
It does not look at all. The finished rope at the end of the video is not even braided it is just twisted.
Is there a way to make one to make a 4 strand braid ?
Thingiverse+ instructables = innovative
Anyone wonder why we weren't shown the point of contact of the yarn or the tensioner at work?
Thanks for the idea, I will build it without all the motors. Maybe 3D printing the top also works. Do you have a template for the top? Could you upload it to thingiverse?
Going by your final image of the three ply twist, your braiding machine was a failure. Do you think we can't tell the difference between three ply which is just twisted together and braiding?
Once the thread has been braided can you place the 3 ply thread back on the machine and braid again or would you need larger bobbins?
I love this design by the way and look forward to your video's arriving.
The video is fake the rope at the end is just twisted it is not even braided.
how would you extend this machine to braid 8 wires?
We want to make this product bet there little different we have to join pices can you will give idea please
Wow...
3 spindle...😍😍😍
Which tablesaw you use?😎
Since I know nothing about electrical engineering, I can still use this design but just use a crank to move the first gear! As long as I don’t have to braid the string with my hands 😅
what is the size of the ball bearing?
really nice tool, there is nothing left to say but 👍👍👍
Great machine. Useless for most of us but still great
It is fake if you look the rope at the end is not even braided it is just twisted.
This ain't DIY, this is the original thing
Very nice wedding machine
The project is very well defined. But you dont need a atmega for this i guess
Very nice project.I am interested to get more such video from your channel❤
Hi mr. Inovative, master mind, please make video on a3 size cnc and laser.making at minimum cost. Thanks
Excellent project 👍
Now time for nicely braided wire on future projects. (not meant as a negative comment just a possible upgrade project.)
is a machine with extra steps... since you dont need steppers for the mechanisms...
Hi. Do you have the files for the electronic connections ? I see the 3d parts, but not for connections
anyone knows how to program this with a adruino NANO 33 board?
What is the size of gear
Super bro.i need pcb how much cast?
Muchas gracias hermano segi subiendo contenidos un abrazo gigante
Cast the gears with recycled molten aluminum 😉
Arduino is completly unecessary here...
Actually, if it could be expanded by 3-4 spools, it would be a great 3D printed Lenz Wire Machine! Can it be scaled up easily? Thanks for sharing!
Si può averlo pagando? Grazie
ahora haz uno de 8 engranajes
May I get the complete machine?
I want to buy this machine... please help
But same thing would be achieved using simple geared dc motor.
No requirement of stepper motors, their drivers and their diver (arduino) !
It is for publicity. JLC pcb
It's for unstucking the thing when the gears go caput
If you control the current to the dc motor for spooling up the braid, you control the tension, not the speed.
Your'e my favorit channel! Nice projects!
Hola estoy interesada en comprar esa maquina
Bro nice video. Keep it up❤️
At i crazy, or is the “final product” not braided? It’s just twisted.
The braiding mechanism and bobbin on top are never pictured together.
Very nice job 😘😘😘
Estoy en Colombia cuánto cuesta una
Quiero una, me la puedes vender?
Excellent project bro
I like step by step guide .
Thanks
Such a strange mix of 3D printed parts, wooden parts, and machined metal parts. I don't think the machine works very well, there's no tension on the cords and it's not shown working all in one, uncropped shot. Finally, as other's have pointed out the final product seems to be twisted and not braided.
Exactly what i was saying regarsing tension. I know a lot about braiding machines and i did not watch even the final rope part. Now when i look at it its really a twisted 3 strand rope and not a braided rope. This video is made just for having profit from the viewers.. Clearly. This is not a working product.
@@danielcrall9507 if you look at the track pattern it is braided, albeit loosely. The braid works only appear to twist in one direction because it's only 3 strands.
Good project. The details were clear.
Price and how can i buy it?
It`s cool! i`m understand how it`s work!
Great job man.
I like the mechanism👌
I want to Buy readymade machine can you sell
No hace trenza hace cuerda😢
Can I have cad files for it
Bhai aap ka number mil Santa ha muje colour sorting 🛠🛠 bnai hai meni puts bnai deya hai per mere pas JLCPCB nhi hai 😟😟😟😟😟
Membuat alat gulung dinamo tamiya bisa ?
Bro nice video thanks useful video
very good idea. i like it
Fantastic.....
3D Files ?
But the rope show is twisted not braided
Why not 3D print everything? There's a LOT of unnecessary things in there. You can get a couple stepper motor driver / oscillators for next to nothing unless you just wanted to layout a board and go through all that.
Pretty cool
Podrían traducir al español por favor?
Love video 💟💟💟💟💖💖💖👌🔔
So nice bro
No demo: you show the spools moving around (neat, yes) but no real braiding.
The background music is: Bon délire by Jerome Saramet soundcloud.com/jeromesaramet/bon-delire
sir meek a pest filinge mesine
Very Top execelent
Good job .
I know sir what is your education?
Mst bro..
Parabens!
You need a CNC dude!
Địa chỉ mua linh kiện ?
Why do yo need an atmega here!!! A simple motor with some gears would be enough..
I thought about that too. I think the controller is used so that you can adjust the twist rate. Also the speed of the upper motor needs to allow down as the roll grows.
Washing machine mowtor
Please share the files
The macine is fake. Look at the rope at the end it is just twisted not even braided.
@@worstcaseontario6395 The machine is not fake though, so very confusing why they show just a twisted rope instead, my guess is that since there is nothing to deal with tension (and varying tension as the top spool picks up more and more rope) the braiding is very sloppy and poor. With a bit of extra effort this can be made to work but really needs some clever programming on the Arduino (more clever than just having 2 steppers turn at set speeds) and some way to monitor tension (simple weight loop with height measurement for instance).
Thanks for playing this crappy music instead of explaining anything
AMAZING
Good
Cuánto cuesta una
❤❤❤
👍👍👍
Dude do you work some where as an engineer..you can't be a random person having a passion for things to make..have you done your from college and worked professionally some where, i,m sure of it..! please reply.Thanks
~namaste~
Nice
There was nothing added to this project by using an arduino and stepper motors than cost. I would like to see the machine you used to make the finished rope, it was NOT the machine you built.