The Worst Manga
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 มิ.ย. 2024
- The most interesting manga ever! Goodnight PunPun is a hard manga to read and I hard trouble finishing it. It’s a depressing manga and many people don’t like that. Punpun makes you feel uncomfortable and uneasy. But it’s one of the greatest manga I’ve ever read.
-
-
-
-
-
#goodnightpunpun #manga #anime #night #depression #depressing #goodnightpunpunreview #youtube #channel #thumbnail #4 #views
“Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.” - บันเทิง
Tbh, punpun was a pretty sad manga. But I definitely wasn’t depressed after I finished it. I just thought it was a pretty well put together work of literature. Not some morbidly poignant manga that depresses me to the point where I can’t sleep anymore
Yea same, I think it’s just my inability to feel sadness through fictional media. Something about it not actually being real takes a lot of the impact out, and I’ve never actually cried during a movie/song/show ect. Guess I’m just emotionless
@@astroaustin516 nah in my view, as long as you’re able to feel emotion from things that are real and not fiction (like oyasumi punpun), then it’s perfectly rational not to be upset by such works. It definitely doesn’t take away from this manga though, like I said in my earlier comment, it’s still great fictional media
it did make me feel a certain way but the best thing about this manga is that it's not never ending misery but it's realistic misery. It doesn't feel unnatural and it allows you to empathize with the characters in such a way that you feel as if you were experiencing those situations yourself. I started reading it in a period were i was very depressed but it brought me a lot comfort instead of making me feel shittier.
Same
@@gremlinonion1323 Punpun is a sociopath I never related to him, the other kids were more relateable for me
Punpun will actually fuck you up. You'll be miserable while reading it but don't wanna stop with the hope of there being some sort of closure
I always felt the worst part about pun pun is that the story sticks with you after you read it
So as I’m going through my life the rough moments thinking of the story makes me depressed af
Nope. You would be bored, waiting when the plot will finally stars and anything meaningfull happens.
@@sychuan3729tbh I agree. The entire manga was a snoozedest with a below average ending. I don't see why people like it except "it's dark bruh" as if that automatically makes it good.
@@Moody.Smiruaioutrageous take.
Aiko's suicide broke me. My wife asked me why I kept reading that Manga, and I told her I didn't know why.
Broke me too 😢
I had to go outside and walk around after seeing Aiko hanging. It sucked the air out of my lungs. I had a sinking feeling when Punpun woke up alone but I was holding out hope.
There was no hope:(
@@BasedBuffet Unfortunately 😢
I finished the manga yesterday. What a masterpiece, but I still feel a heavy weight on my chest. Aiko's demise broke me. She deserved to find peace within herself.
It's never that serious 😂
@@santiagorincon92 she deserves the world
poor aiko 😭😭😭😭
Yes it was a very interesting read and everything about was just off. It was just so refreshing but depressing at the same time
I know!
I just feel so left out cuz although I love the story indefinitely I just didn’t cry or get too emotional while reading, I just took in all in, I mean it was terribly sad but I never came out of it depressed or crying and I felt for the characters and everything it just didn’t really effect me emotionally wise
You’re a lucky man
I personally stopped caring about PunPun and in that way stopped feeling sad for him. Maybe for his uncle I felt something, but I lost all sympathy for PunPun when he tried to rape that girl after art exhibition.
you're not alone, i too didn't cry or made a huge impact on me but i did still felt the feeling of dread reading it, and the feeling of not wanting to read it again
Yeah I totally didn’t cry after this.
Yeah there’s a whole lotta stuff but you got your point through
haha LOSER!!!!
1:33 Onodera was always a people pleaser, when he broke his promise to Aiko he probably couldn't live with the burden that a person was relying on him. That's probably why he has obsessive behavior around her. Look at Sachi, they're still together because she relies on Onodera.
I binged the shit outta Punpun. I once put it on hold on chapter 90, because relating to Punpun was scary, but then, I picked it back up and didn't sleep. I was just looking at the ceiling, thinking that could've happened to me too.
Actually I think this manga might be more hurtful for people with a stable mental health than the ones without it. I struggle with depression and other mental problems and I also had pretty similar experiences to Punpun in my life so far. I did feel sad when I first finished the manga but the sadness quickly faded away because those feelings weren't anything out of the ordinary for me.
Both punpun and aiko acted in horrible ways. Aiko wanted someone who could just leave everything behind for her, and that's why she liked punpun, because he had absolutely nothing. Punpun idolized her to the point that their relationship would inevitably come to disappointment, putting her up to an unreachable pedestal. It's honestly my favorite piece of literature ever
Hits so hard when you’ve been in the EXACT situation dawg, just finished it two days ago and idek what’s goin on anymore
I was not able to sleep after reading this.
It Was too depressing
Welcome to the club🤧
Goated thumbnail. Goated video. Goated editing. Tell me how I haven't found your channel before.
I’m underground lol and this is a goated comment
@@BasedBuffet poor thing I will be waiting for your channel to blow out with subscribers with great interest and yea punpun broke me too
@@iluz1eiluzie370 hopefully we get that bread🙂
i did not cry but.. i felt this emptyness inside my soul like im missing something
I love this video because it isn't over 30mins long like every other Punpun video. It's simple but still pretty deep.
Well done.
Thank you:)
Frankly, what you get out of Punpun is how much you've experienced in your life. Broken people can appreciate the negative themes of this manga. If you haven't experienced a lot of negativity and abuse in your life, you won't be able to fully relate past, "oh, that was kind of sad".
Because the manga is meant for broken people.
Only broken people can fully understand what it's like to be Aiko or Punpun.
It hits so much harder when you relate more
As of writing this, I just finished Goodnight Punpun about an hour ago and I am not okay. It’s very hard to get me to tear up, but once I saw that first panel of Aiko’s feet hanging, it felt like an emotional punch to the gut and legit made me cry. Now I can’t think about her without spiraling into depression and tearing up. Aiko didn’t deserve this, she deserved better 😰😢😭
i felt empty after finishing that manga
I'm still sad for Aiko.
Join the club... sadly😔
The Worst and funny enough BEST manga I've read.
But when a story makes you Feel or realise something about yourself then i think it actually deserves all the attention and recognition it can get.
!Don't read it unless you are AT LEAST 16 and have some emotional pillars in your life! Jesus Christ Don't read it it if you are depressed or having suicidal thoughts!
Please preach this because it’s such a great story but you have to be mentally stable to read it. That’s how powerful it is.
Welp I read it while not being mentally stable, and here I am with even a bigger depression 🤣🤣 at what price? Reading this Asano masterpiece
Im 13 and i have read it 😳
As much as you wish someone would heed this warning and listen to it, some people just seek disparity and just want that awful feeling, like me. And just saying "don't read it if you're not certain age" will just lure more people under said age to read it.
Hawks Profile Picture, Amazing Thumbnail, Great Video. You earned a sub and a follow on twitter.
Thank you king!! Been loving your content and thumbnails and glad for your growth on TH-cam
@@BasedBuffet
Spoilers
Reading this manga really didn’t make me feel that emptiness and depression that everyone says they feel. Reading through this manga my emotional attachment for the characters was broken, all the absolute fucked up things that punpun and others around him did really made the characters not feel like someone I should be empathetic towards, which I guess is why I guess I didn’t feel much from this manga.
Some of the things that did actually hit me like a bag of bricks were the letter that punpuns mother wrote for him after she died, Shimizu forgetting who seki was, and the letter aiko left after she killed herself
Totally valid and well rounded opinion, I think what really hits people is the stuff they don’t expect
When I saw Aiko hanging, I didn't feel anything. I figured that's where it would eventually end. The only thing I remember saying was "oh", and I can honestly say I just felt relief. I preferred Sachi.
I think the most horrifying part of the manga was Aiko's mom. She crawled around, pretending to be crippled, only for it to be revealed that she could walk, not by coincidence, but because she tried stabbing her own daughter. She dressed in Aiko's uniform, called her over to beat her, made her feel guilty for wanting to leave, manipulated her, but even after all that was over, after she died, there was a final thing her character did that made my stomach drop.
Punpun received a package addressed to Aiko's mom while they were in the house with the mom's corpse. When they opened the package, they found a vibrator. Aiko was isolated, forced to work a job where she was talked down to, abused, and at the end of the day, her mom was likely using the money Aiko made in self serving ways. It felt like all of the things Aiko was put through only led up to a joke.
Disturbingly well said😔
I've read punpun about 3 times already, and every time i get to volume 7 it always manages to break me each time.
I wanna feel bad for punpun but it’s actions make me just not. The way he was going to murder aiko and then gets on with his life like usual. Why wouldn’t he take her to the hospital ik she said she didn’t want to and they’d be caught, but he basically accepted he was letting her die slow and painful, choosing not to help her emotional or physical. I think it’s telling the first time he gets a real gf (the one he’s been thinking about forever) he acts like he’s father and treats her terrible, getting more violent and resenting her for the murder and for being her protector. He should of taken her to the hospital but then he’d lose his control on her, they wouldn’t be together. He knew she’d die eventually if he ignored her wounds long enough ( there’s the serval time she suddenly sits down bc she’s in so much pain and pun pun doesn’t seem to concerned or at all like he cares) and was getting more angry every day she didn’t, to the point where he was just going to murder her himself. After all of that he just gets to walk away. Yes he s*lf h*rmed himself took his eye and went to prison for a few years, buts that not enough. He gets with the manga girl, they’re not together but she’s acting as his his pseudo-mom and girlfriend now, accepting the responsibility of dealing with him again. Not to mention her kid looks exactly like him. Ik that was suppose to mean new hope and him projecting onto the baby seeing it as himself but it looked like he was dad, that even what I thought when she told him she was pregnant.
Ik aiko was bad too. From the moment she met punpun again she was emotionally trying to manipulate, feeling him out with lies, but so was he lol. She does other bad stuff too ik like the murder but I can hardly feel to bad for me mom but it does show how unhinged and ready she is to snap especially during moment of extreme stress. She goes on to pull a knife in punpun (this is ofc bad but she did think he was taking her into the woods to kill her, seeing who abusive he had been leading up to that I don’t blame her. However it was definitely not okay when she stabbed him ofc she was in the wrong.) She also wants punpuns eyes as a way to show his devotion and to make the wish. So yah she’s not great but she didn’t deserve a death sentence cared out by her abusive and neglectful bf over the course of a emotional distance and violent two weeks.
I wish the writer went with the ending where he gets hit by a train.
Also as soon as punpun said ‘you need to talk to your mom before you leave’ i knewww it was going to be the case of the girl gets tragically killed or sacrificed to give her lover more of an emotional journey. It felt predictable and I just think that trope is lame. You can have a tragic and morally skewed, female character, who is also the main love interest, without them dying. The trope of sad women die for man and man is better bc of it bc he grows emotionally, is terrible I’m sorry.
It’s like punpun got a happy ending, surrounded by friends and back to his old self, sure he has dreams about the gf he murder but he even says he’s letting go after a year, as if he’s saying this won’t effect me anymore. He felt guilty for a year, took his own eye, got a few years in prison, doesn’t seem right considering all he did to aiko
that start had me dying 😂 and i gotta read punpun I’m just not prepared to read it and feel like shit yet
Yeah you gotta be in a good mind to read it
How was it?
@@sedbaka never got around to it 😭
I had no intention to continue punpun, yet this video made me sad. Why did I even watch this
Feel for ya
recently finished and the only moments that really got me upset were the uncle trying to commit suicide on the train tracks and I yelled no when I realized aiko had hung herself. I don't think it's as bad as everyone makes it but it definitely has amazing building. I think the author choosing to continue to allow pun pun to live is a good reflection of life as well. we as humans have to strive and continue to keep going no matter what we go through because the only alternative is to give up and give the Devil what he wants
I really loved this manga, it's so sad but also full of hope about the future, I used to hate Aiko too but at the end she was only a poor girl with a messed up life, i think her death was necessary for Punpun to move on and begin a new life with Sachi (who loves him for real)
I just started to read this manga a week ago and I haven’t really gone that far but I got to a point where even tho up until what I’ve read hasn’t affected me , the more and more I see about this manga the more scared I grow of it but it’s something I can’t stop thinking about, I consider myself pretty happy and have some people In my life that support me but i still question what this manga is like and what will happen if I finish it
You’re (not) gonna like the ending
@@BasedBuffet I have a feeling that is going to be the case
"she decided to leave him"
i mean i would probably not stay with someone who punched my tooth out and strangled me until i almost died especially since he kept trying to leave her countless times beforehand...
aiko did nothing wrong the whole time what literally is that take
What about that one time when she started strangling him after they had sex? I honestly think they’re both just kinda messed up but good people.
@@BasedBuffetwait when did she strangle him?
@@MananaMan second time they did it, it was volume 12. Also Aiko stabbed her mother to death after Punpun left the room
@@BasedBuffet ah yes now i remember, punpun grabs her hands and tries to get aiko to choke him, she stops him, and then states how she doesnt want him to leave her and to stop saying weird things. oh if someone beat me for ten years and then stabbed me in my abdomen i would sure as fuck kill them without thinking about it and would probably have a psychotic episode about it
finished to the manga from chapter one to last in a single day, one hell of emotional ride
I bet it wasn’t fun
Did not think you would keep posting
Proved you wrong
*Spoilers*
I remember i cried in between reading punpun because of how he and aiko loved eachother but were otherwise so terrible for eachother due to expectations. And just seeing the childhood flashbacks made me cry. I think we sometimes forget that Punpun was raped by Midori and that Suuichi basically blamed him for getting raped. He’s been through so much and the people that were supposed to be there for him completely broke him and took advantage of him to make him an empty and depressed individual.
When I finished it, I started bawling my eyes out and was not able to sleep because i couldn’t get the proper closure i was expecting. Yes he was with a family that i guess loved him but in the end it wasn’t what we wanted for him because we wanted something more for him.
i feel like i am one of the very few people who genuinely disliked this manga. sure it's sad but i found it to be boring most times and it was a drag to read. maybe i had high expectations and was disappointed. it was meh for me, i read better depressing and dark material.
Same
After finshing this manga i think i'll go off myself now.
Love this video. Subscribed!
Co incidentally i just finished it 2 days back , I'll never be able to reread it..
Reading pun pun was an experience I both cherish and wish never happened. When I read it I wasn't in a good place, hell I can't say I'm even doing better now, but that manga made me feel even worse. I related to many of the events that happened and it brought back memories I wished never to be brought into my head again. I will never read it again. However the story is amazing, probably one of the best dark stories ever written without a doubt. I would recommend people read it, but I wouldn't recommend reading it when you're in a horrible place already.
Can’t stress this enough
I started it thinking "hmm free depression"
then it traumatized me
am scared remembering a single scene
Those end chapters hit too hard
(SPOILER COMMENT)
I wanted to cry when aiko died. But fr after everything Punpun goes thru and me as the reader, I was just empty. Which is what Punpun must’ve been feeling too based on his actions forward.
It's definitely something. Cause usually when I finish a show or manga, of course I'm going to think to myself about what I thought about it and how it affected me, if at all. But with Punpun, it was more like, only me, not saying I've been through every specific melancholy event in the story. But having the focus of what I thought center in myself and how it made me question certain aspects of my life regarding topics brought up in the manga really is just something that hits way too hard.
Made me sit Back and actually question my self being. I’ve never had that happened before
@@BasedBuffet definitely, it really did strike a chord with me.
I feel the same well tbh, I was asked if I recommended it and it was hard, because it's a great manga, but I just felt horrible after finishing it.
It really is hard to read
@@BasedBuffet it is, it took me some months to even finish it
I was broken way before I read pun pun I read the whole thing in 3 days and didn’t really feel anything
After I read it I didn’t feel anything for a while
I’m just gonna like because you used Everything by Black Skirts with Oyasumi Punpun which fits very well. I respect your opinion and yes I get why you would hate this manga (for me I just have a love hate relationship with Punpun’s character because he does the dumbest shit). Still a great manga and I’m pretty sure you used the background songs from the Oyasumi Punpun playlist.
You’re right I did use the playlist, nice catch! The story was extremely well written in my opinion, it depicted reality in such a way my mental state had a hard time coping with the ending and that’s why a stayed away from the manga once I finished.
@@BasedBuffet Ye the manga just leaves you depressed after finishing it and I don’t think I will be re-reading it anytime soon or in the future either because it still hurts me.
I just finished punpun and I wouldn’t say I’m depressed. Content, but empty. I’m glad it got something of a happy ending. I’ll read it again some day
This manga is hated not because it’s bad but it’s too good
Honestly I loved the ending of Punpun and it felt really really heartwarming seeing him with his family (however shitty it might have been) . And yeah... I was also very sad after that sleep in the countryside. Definitely one of the impactful piece of media I had the pleasure of experiencing.
Definitely a masterpiece
yooo the black skirts LOL anyways u explained everything perfectly
Gotta bop to sad music while writing about trauma
I'm not sure if I was already broken beforehand or I just didn't fully understand Oyasumi Punpun but I didn't break after reading this.
Honestly I think it’s just how it relates to you personally and if it doesn’t resonate with you then it’s fine.
Or you’re already depressed
@@BasedBuffet That's a possibility. A still really enjoyed the manga and I was sort of torn at Punpun's actions. I sort of proposed an argument to myself about his actions and although he wasn't dealt the best hand in life he also wasn't dealt the word hand either. So I can't really say he was justified in indulging in his selfish desires. He's such an interesting character. Also, Pegasus reminded me of Jesus in a lot of ways (before he killed himself and everyone).
Very interesting keep it up!
This man doesn’t miss
Am I the only who didn’t cry at the end. I felt a looming dread but but crying
he got us in the first half not gonna lie
YOU ARE SO UNDERRATED WTF. BRUH UR VID IS AMAZING
Thank you:)
punpun is incredible and yet it makes me want to jump off a bridge at times I need to mentally prepare myself to read it for a single day
edit: and yet I somehow cannot cry about this kind of thing or anything so sad and fictional
everyone should read it, it's a heartwarming story of teen growing up with warm family and supportive girlfriend. it gives people hope in dark times 😉.
Agreed🤥
Same lmao, ironically I bought the whole manga but fuck me I haven’t reread it ever since the first time I read it
Awesome video man, punpun is probably my favorite manga besides part 7
Mine right now are PunPun, SNK, Vinland, JJK, and Chainsaw. And glad you liked the video!!!
@@BasedBuffet OMG BRO YES chainsaw man is amazing as well, and np man the video deserves the praise
If you like Punpun then you should read Aku no Hana is quite similar with Punpun but has a good ending for both main characters
Nice! This is a really hard manga to tackle so good job talking about it!
Yeah it’s nutty
TBH I never was THAT depressed over this manga. Mostly because I stopped caring about PunPun after he tried to rape that girl after that art exhibition and I think that kind of made me not enjoy this manga that much. Also that whole plot thread with the Cult, Shimizu and Seki felt like they belonged in completely different manga and sometimes felt like a waste of time (although Shimizu and Seki are my favorite characters). If I ever put this manga at my favorite top 10 list I would say it's like 10 or 9, but I don't think I will have it even in top 10.
I also feel like the chapters that were about PunPun's uncle's past and stuff didn't really fit in with the rest of the manga
What is the song at 0:23?
The black skirts
Why you got to put a Midnight Gospel clip in an Oyasumi Punpun video? 😭
You know why🤧
I think the idea of goodnight punpun WAS to make you feel worthless and to absolutely make you hold onto hope. That something is there. That maybe it will end up okay, which it doesn’t. Which destroys the reader. I think asanos idea was to not give the reader what they want to insert themselves into punpun or aikos shoes. To hope that everything will end with okay. Which in turn is mentally damaging for both of them and they destroy themselves which makes punpun such an emotional read cause we destroy ourselves for things we love or we destroy ourselves because we have hope. Which makes it such a good read
Incredible awesome Video i really Did Not expect a Video with so high quality from chanel this small.
I subscribed and looking forward for More great content
Keep this Energie 👍
Dang thanks man! Hopefully I won’t let ya down
What dare you to insert the "you cry" scene of midnight gospel!!
Lmao was in the moment
Cringe
great editing on this video !! instant sub and hope ur channel blows up
Thank you☺️
lets go, aiko
Bro how do you have only 800 subs your way too underrated
Thank you it means a lot💜
Please don't write video titles like that. I went to read this after I searched for it and saw the titles on TH-cam where everyone is saying it's the worst and don't read it.. but seriously the story is amazing and very sad but people on TH-cam speaking don't read it is a turn off. Don't do this seriously...please speak honestly...
All great videos warrant at least a little clickbait
I finished goodnight punpun and after reading the whole thing as well. but it didn't help me from getting out of the rabbit hole I dug upon myself. Because this manga puts you in a perspective of the main character and makes you question about life itself. for those who aren't mentally stable, I won't recommend you reading this because it would ruin you more mentally.
It made me question alot of things
The whole thing is good and well done manga but this manga is no good for people who are having bad days and depression. because this manga questions about everything by volumes.
It was depressing but I also recognize that it is masterpiece literature
I'm gonna read it I hope I don't get depression
I only have read the first volume. I couldnt finish it so i just ended up looking for summaries of the entire thing and honestly, i didnt know punpun would make really fucked up decisions. It's all so fucked up.
Aiko and Punpun was so depressing to look at. It's a good story, but it can fuck you up indeed.
Yep
i gotta read this
So I need someone to explain the appeal for me. I felt nothing from this manga. I hated it, and most of it felt pointless. I could not sympathize with any of these characters, so when something “shocking” happened to them, I didn’t care. I felt absolutely nothing when Aiko died. I felt more angry then sad when reading this series. Can someone explain to me what was appealing from goodnight punpun?
I also thought the story went no where at all.
Punpun relies on you being able to relate to it, which may be fine for the earlier chapters but once the manga starts getting into Punpun's adulthood many of the younger readers were lost because they just hadn't experienced what he was going through and couldn't sympathize.
uve earned my subscription my guy
💜
I got hella depressed after reading that manga so depressed infact i wrote a whole story to show that.
What song is 0:23
Here you go th-cam.com/video/tcCvZ3MrCxk/w-d-xo.html
what's your favorite manga?
berserk, vinland, aot, punpun
I don't make many wrong decision in my life. Except..
why i watch ur video.... it make me depress refresh the memory of reading it
Glad to help even if it’s more pain
Good video, keep it up. You have potential.
:)
its been about 1 week since i finished punpun, actually i've been reading punpun since 2020 i had to took long breaks because how heavy its for me but im glad i finished it i am currently trying to not think about the manga ;') haha and i have to admit something ,i throw my phone at too hahaha im sorry if my english is incorret :)
Very sad story glad we shared a similar experience
I finished it a few days ago my favorite manga
Is there a site to read mangas or do you have to buy them. I know nothing about mangas as you can tell
I would just look up the manga on the internet, but mangadex is usually a pretty good site. There will be ads tho
@@BasedBuffet oh ok thanks and I can find chapters in English too there. Just tested it out with Demon Slayer and it wasn’t. But obviously I’m assuming I can specify it
@@ihtishamhussain1785 I would try other sites and see if that works I’m sure you can find one I can’t name any off the top of my head
@@BasedBuffet alright thanks for the help anyway it was a good starting point
10/10
Never reading it again
Will never recommend it to anyone
Straight up horror at times
Hello , I am a fan of Oyasumi Punpun ，i love your video ，i am a blogger of bilibili in china,I want more anime fans to see this video, can i repost this video on bilibili？ I will credit video source and your channal, hope you can agree
Good stuff man!
glad you enjoyed it!
I sometime question my own curiousty and BOI DO I PAY THE PRICE FOR IT!!!
Welcome to the club
Sounds crwispy
Cwispy indeed
My wife left me.
Btw chief keep up the good work man
Thank you:)
@@BasedBuffet Np, ngl this manga is literally "There is nothing permanent except change. "
Punpun had sort of the same affect on me but I feel the opposite I really love stories that make me feel just awful
Welcome to the club🤝
This was a good read indeed
Glad you liked it
damn. couldnt beat rance and itadaki?! mangaka's gotta try harder
Rance kinda hits different
Nice video ❤
bro whats the first song name?
Here ya go th-cam.com/video/tcCvZ3MrCxk/w-d-xo.html
@@BasedBuffet ok you are now my favorite youtuber bro
@@masterpingu8251 means a lot from a small TH-camr thx fam
This manga dosent break people it destroys people
00:25 song?
Here ya go th-cam.com/video/tcCvZ3MrCxk/w-d-xo.html
@@BasedBuffet ty:)