Well, all scat singing is piano scales. All singing is piano scales. I would love to see if Beyonce was actually scat singing in 2009 or whenever, in the video you are about to upload.
What He was doing is actually warming his voice up. Anybody who thinks just because he wasn't singing he cant scat just because he gave My girl B the stage y'all must not know who Stokley Carmichael is from Mint Condition. lmaooo
And he was rhythmically improvising. There were no chords when he was improvising . So he was in no particular key....the band started playing chords when she got up there...establishing a progression, even tho it was just a two chord vamp. I give her credit for taking the risk. Love her...and so there. LOL...I'd like to see his whole show too...he's a bad ass.
@@Beytheevocalist. lol and you’re literally an idiot, trying to argue with someone about their opinion. This wasn’t scatting 😂 and it never will be. Like I said, she redeemed herself from this mess 😂😂😂
i love Beyonce's prowess but this was the first time I can say she was outta her element here, she did RnB riffs in a Jazz groove, she was supposed to cat. For most jazz heads this can go down as a barely passing or fail depends how critical you wanna be. She did the I'm checkin my riff on the chords face-i do that from time the time when I dont land where I should have in the chord change. Still go Bey
franktib actually Beyoncé can sing multiple riffs in any key she wants. She has done R&B riffs, classical/operatic riffs, she has also done jazz/scatting at her Las Vegas concert back in 2009 when singing "Deja Vú live.
I was looking for your comment Lol. I was worried something was wrong with my ears cause people were saying she slayed. I love me some Beyoncé (just like everyone else) and she sounded pretty, we know she can sing but I'm sorry that was one stage that she didn't belong on. Not even close to scatting i.m.h.o.
Love, love, love Bey, and she is awesome in her lane, but this right here... I'll admit that ladies like Lalah Hathaway, Rachelle Ferrell, and Lesedi have spoiled me rotten. I wanted to cheer her on here, but... way out of her element.
yup. She still went for it tho...gotta love it...it's just a two chord vamp w/ a couple of passing chords...not difficult...very typical thing to do...but I dont think she caught on tht it was just a two chord vamp till later... Also we don't know what that stage sounded like...she might not have been able to hear them...that place was hella noisy ...I give ppl a lot of credit for getting up out of their comfort zone for whatever reason and just being willing to be exposed, screw up, figure it out, and have a little fun come what may. It's what we do. LOL... It's gotta be a lottttt harder when your Beyonce. Soon as she gets up there the cameras start rolling....It gores from casual toe OH OH quick! LOL....Cou'rage ! KUDOS! She's my girl! LOVE YOU BEY!
@BMediaHQ The instrumentals, do they have a name for it? like was it an actual song they were free styling to, or was everybody including the musicians just straight having an improvise jam session?
...She definitely cannot scat, that's for sure! Beyonce doesn't know what she's doing. Jazz is something you do not fool around with at all. It takes complete dedication and one have to take this true American art form seriously. I truly do not believe that Beyoncé Knowles knows the difference between a flatted fifth and a tonic chord. Something like "Caravan," written by the late valve-trombonist Juan Tizol and the late Duke Ellington, at a breakneck tempo. Beyoncé has a beautiful voice. However, she is not vocally equipped to sing traditional pop standards, jazz and blues classics. Yes, Beyoncé did portray the legendary Etta James in the film, "Cadillac Records." However, musically, she is not anywhere near the latter. I wouldn't be surprised if Miss Knowles did listen to Ella Fitzgerald, Sarah Vaughan, Dinah Washington, Billie Holiday, Diahann Carroll, Carmen McRae, Dakota Staton, Della Reese, Anita O'Day, June Christy, Chris Connor, Betty Carter, Gloria Lynne, Ruth Brown, Dianne Reeves, Annie Ross, etc. as well as Aretha Franklin, Gladys Knight, Dionne Warwick, Patti LaBelle, Chaka Khan, Phyllis Hyman, Anita Baker, Whitney Houston, etc. I can say this, because I've been listening to Jazz since I was was a child. I'm sixty-six years old.
Hey she didn't sign a waver or disclaimer..LOL.....she just got up because her friend asked her to...she didn't say she was a scat singer or anything close...never has said anything about singing jazz professionally. But she's a huge star...you know he asked and she got egged on to get up....she did what she could and knew she was out of her element...they were just vampin on a couple of chords...they weren't playing Giant Steps, or Donna Lee for cryin out loud.... LOLOLOL. LOL PS I've heard Chaka destroy standards so bad you wonder if she lost her damn mind. And I've also heard her be brilliant. Conversely, ever hear Ella sing pop? Those were some AKWARD years. Be nice. It's not her Genre. So what? She was gracious and got up and gave the crowd what they wanted. She didn't get up there to rewrite BEBOP. REEEEEEE lax. It was a night club. All the best, C
I agree Bruce..I am not taking away from her singing ability, though she is not my favorite or among them..but this is definitely NOT scatting!!! Scatting is by definition "nonsense words" all one has to do is listen to Ella to know.
Daro Corbett ...You are absolutely and positively correct, Daro! Beyoncé Knowles is not anywhere near the FIRST LADY OF SONG. And, she needs a lot more lessons beyond imagination.
She CAN skat like she did during her Vegas tour in 2010. This was 2004 which was those early times she focused in RnB and was know for that. She barely tackled other genres, but today she's learned to seep into different music which is why some people say 'we miss the old Beyonce' because she's not limited anymore to RnB like she used to.
@@JCole-fg3rr ...Scatting is the closest to a musical instrument in jazz, and that's something Beyonce is not. I've been listening this true American art form before you, Beyonce and the rest weren't even born. She wouldn't know the difference between a flatter fifth or a tonic chord. Ask her to scat and improvise in a breakneck tempo (e.g.: "Cherokee").
Bruce Scott First off, I don’t give a fuck. Secondly, Beyoncé, AGAIN, was not asked to scat, she was asked to just sing and freestyle it. You don’t know wtf Beyoncé knows. If Prince, the musical genius, was thoroughly impressed with Beyoncé’s musical knowledge, then your irrelevant ass opinion means nothing.
Who's here in 2021😩❤😭I was just So younggg
Cant stop watching this. Love her wow
This is talent.
she just snapped into it
just natural born talent
HAHA at first she was like no please I don't wanna do this...she was acting like Beyoncé...and then....BAM she was SASHA FIERCE :D
Beyonce aint have to go off like that!
You need to see Beyoncé scating notes, in 2009, I'll try to put it on youtube, it's like all piano scales !
I would love to see it. Beyonce hasn't scat sung at all in her music.
Well, all scat singing is piano scales. All singing is piano scales. I would love to see if Beyonce was actually scat singing in 2009 or whenever, in the video you are about to upload.
@@drosemjordanlove7827 Go : th-cam.com/video/uZRKUOf__94/w-d-xo.html
@@drosemjordanlove7827 th-cam.com/video/uZRKUOf__94/w-d-xo.html !!
Hei where is the vídeo?
What He was doing is actually warming his voice up. Anybody who thinks just because he wasn't singing he cant scat just because he gave My girl B the stage y'all must not know who Stokley Carmichael is from Mint Condition. lmaooo
And he was rhythmically improvising. There were no chords when he was improvising . So he was in no particular key....the band started playing chords when she got up there...establishing a progression, even tho it was just a two chord vamp. I give her credit for taking the risk. Love her...and so there. LOL...I'd like to see his whole show too...he's a bad ass.
Only the real ones know 🙌
blazing february I came here lookin for his name lol I knew it was someone from MC
Stockley Williams, not Stokely Carmichael, who died in '98
Thank you, I just stumbled upon scatting but I’m researching different noises and I was wondering what was going on 😂.
I loved the "I can't believe I'm doing this" haha.
sooo perfect
at a loss for words\
wow
She was like: naw I don't wanna embarras ya..I'm serious. stop..don't push me. Ight. eff it her we go!!
You got me cracking up!
😂😂😂
She will kill dat shit now
S?O to Beyonce!! I can see when the music took over, she made that face! Yess B girl do what you do :)
2:50 on !!!!🔥 🔥🔥🔥
Queen B.
2:20!SO CUTE 😍😍😍
The guy was like ooo she bootylicious jay must have not been there
Queen!!! 👑😍✨✨✨🍷
She Was Like "Please I Don't Wanna Slay You Or Sing Circles Around You Or Bring You To Absolute Shame Or Destroy You" But Then She Ended Up Doing It
TayTay BeyNippy she didnt destroy him, she killed it though
@Edmund Thomas no
@Edmund Thomas no
@Edmund Thomas no
Scatting is more about knowing the scales and chords of the genre more than it's about if you're an amazing singer..
Cool, but Beyoncé is a star listed by vocalist vocals experts, (the only one of popular music of the 21st century)
Damn, it was still good… it was improv, gotta be so technical…bet if it were anyone else this comment wouldn’t even had been made🤦🏽♀️
@@latonyarhodes4246 Go : th-cam.com/video/uZRKUOf__94/w-d-xo.html
And yet she ate that up. Next.
@fernandodiniz6029 ...False!
And that's how it's done baby
yess feel it boo!
Amo demais ❤
"Woo woo woo woo woo Beyonceee." Is reminded of who she is tells herself I am Beyonce steps back and says im not going out like this!
gracias por compartir!!!!!
b still went for it remember she is a rnb pop star not jazz ok
Go : th-cam.com/video/uZRKUOf__94/w-d-xo.html
WOW! :)
She redeemed herself when she scat at her Super Bowl show on Crazy In Love.
Beyonce didn't do scat singing at her Super Bowl show.
What was there to redeemed she did amazing here lmao. She literally was chilling
@@Beytheevocalist. and that’s just your opinion, which I don’t agree with lmao.
@@dregoinplaces and your wrong she literally was chilling lmao, and got up there and freestyles plus everyone there was gagged and loved it
@@Beytheevocalist. lol and you’re literally an idiot, trying to argue with someone about their opinion. This wasn’t scatting 😂 and it never will be. Like I said, she redeemed herself from this mess 😂😂😂
wow
She learned scat singing and he learned to
Wow... :) :)
She needed that extra energy from the band.
i love Beyonce's prowess but this was the first time I can say she was outta her element here, she did RnB riffs in a Jazz groove, she was supposed to cat. For most jazz heads this can go down as a barely passing or fail depends how critical you wanna be. She did the I'm checkin my riff on the chords face-i do that from time the time when I dont land where I should have in the chord change. Still go Bey
Michael Crenshaw she only knows r&b riffs. its like a blues guitar player trying to play jazz
franktib actually Beyoncé can sing multiple riffs in any key she wants. She has done R&B riffs, classical/operatic riffs, she has also done jazz/scatting at her Las Vegas concert back in 2009 when singing "Deja Vú live.
I was looking for your comment Lol.
I was worried something was wrong with my ears cause people were saying she slayed. I love me some Beyoncé (just like everyone else) and she sounded pretty, we know she can sing but I'm sorry that was one stage that she didn't belong on. Not even close to scatting i.m.h.o.
Love, love, love Bey, and she is awesome in her lane, but this right here... I'll admit that ladies like Lalah Hathaway, Rachelle Ferrell, and Lesedi have spoiled me rotten. I wanted to cheer her on here, but... way out of her element.
yup. She still went for it tho...gotta love it...it's just a two chord vamp w/ a couple of passing chords...not difficult...very typical thing to do...but I dont think she caught on tht it was just a two chord vamp till later...
Also we don't know what that stage sounded like...she might not have been able to hear them...that place was hella noisy ...I give ppl a lot of credit for getting up out of their comfort zone for whatever reason and just being willing to be exposed, screw up, figure it out, and have a little fun come what may. It's what we do. LOL... It's gotta be a lottttt harder when your Beyonce. Soon as she gets up there the cameras start rolling....It gores from casual toe OH OH quick! LOL....Cou'rage ! KUDOS! She's my girl! LOVE YOU BEY!
dadudaduuuhoooohooohooowdudududududu!
When and where was this?
is there anything that Beyonce can't do??
Nguyen Minh Phuong Yes, she can’t scatt :))
Magda Mulla she actually can and HAS scatted before.
Cook
@@Ep-ef2ej she can paint and she can speak different languages among other things. stop acting like you know her personally, weirdo.
@magdamulla2196 ...Thank you!
I like this better then her commercial stuff
What’s the title of the song the band plays?
What is the actual song they are playing?
they made it up.
@BMediaHQ The instrumentals, do they have a name for it? like was it an actual song they were free styling to, or was everybody including the musicians just straight having an improvise jam session?
XJman no, they were free-styling the whole thing. Matching Beyonce's riffs & progression.
Thats dope, and really impressive. I'd love to have a studio recorded track of this though
It's Erykah Badu's next lifetime
Beyoncé is a beast but that was not scatting at all
Beyone didn’t come to scat, she came to SANG!!!
she ran me up and down, through in some jazz notes, that’s enough tbh. it ain’t scatting but she killed it
Go : th-cam.com/video/uZRKUOf__94/w-d-xo.html
@aaron newman ...You don't know anything about jazz, PERIOD!!!
I think it was Sasha Fierce ;)
yeah that's stokely
...She definitely cannot scat, that's for sure! Beyonce doesn't know what she's doing. Jazz is something you do not fool around with at all. It takes complete dedication and one have to take this true American art form seriously. I truly do not believe that Beyoncé Knowles knows the difference between a flatted fifth and a tonic chord. Something like "Caravan," written by the late valve-trombonist Juan Tizol and the late Duke Ellington, at a breakneck tempo. Beyoncé has a beautiful voice. However, she is not vocally equipped to sing traditional pop standards, jazz and blues classics. Yes, Beyoncé did portray the legendary Etta James in the film, "Cadillac Records." However, musically, she is not anywhere near the latter. I wouldn't be surprised if Miss Knowles did listen to Ella Fitzgerald, Sarah Vaughan, Dinah Washington, Billie Holiday, Diahann Carroll, Carmen McRae, Dakota Staton, Della Reese, Anita O'Day, June Christy, Chris Connor, Betty Carter, Gloria Lynne, Ruth Brown, Dianne Reeves, Annie Ross, etc. as well as Aretha Franklin, Gladys Knight, Dionne Warwick, Patti LaBelle, Chaka Khan, Phyllis Hyman, Anita Baker, Whitney Houston, etc. I can say this, because I've been listening to Jazz since I was was a child. I'm sixty-six years old.
Hey she didn't sign a waver or disclaimer..LOL.....she just got up because her friend asked her to...she didn't say she was a scat singer or anything close...never has said anything about singing jazz professionally. But she's a huge star...you know he asked and she got egged on to get up....she did what she could and knew she was out of her element...they were just vampin on a couple of chords...they weren't playing Giant Steps, or Donna Lee for cryin out loud.... LOLOLOL. LOL PS I've heard Chaka destroy standards so bad you wonder if she lost her damn mind. And I've also heard her be brilliant.
Conversely, ever hear Ella sing pop? Those were some AKWARD years.
Be nice. It's not her Genre. So what? She was gracious and got up and gave the crowd what they wanted. She didn't get up there to rewrite BEBOP. REEEEEEE lax. It was a night club. All the best, C
leave my girl alone she went for it tho b is a rnb singer she still gets a a for trying
I agree Bruce..I am not taking away from her singing ability, though she is not my favorite or among them..but this is definitely NOT scatting!!! Scatting is by definition "nonsense words" all one has to do is listen to Ella to know.
Who said that she was scatting? Btw, she does know how to scat sing.
she actually can scat now i don't know about back then but now yes she can there is videos of her scatting on youtube
fucking terrible..would have failed anybody's audition...sorry
Go : th-cam.com/video/uZRKUOf__94/w-d-xo.html
I love her Vibratto but she sounds horrible I am so extremely happy she grew up
She ain't no Ella Fitzgerald, that's for sure. Bey needs a few lessons in skat. SMH
Daro Corbett ...You are absolutely and positively correct, Daro! Beyoncé Knowles is not anywhere near the FIRST LADY OF SONG. And, she needs a lot more lessons beyond imagination.
She CAN skat like she did during her Vegas tour in 2010. This was 2004 which was those early times she focused in RnB and was know for that. She barely tackled other genres, but today she's learned to seep into different music which is why some people say 'we miss the old Beyonce' because she's not limited anymore to RnB like she used to.
Bruce Scott no y’all both wrong, Beyoncé was not instructed to scat, she was told to just sing and do whatever.
@@JCole-fg3rr ...Scatting is the closest to a musical instrument in jazz, and that's something Beyonce is not. I've been listening this true American art form before you, Beyonce and the rest weren't even born. She wouldn't know the difference between a flatter fifth or a tonic chord. Ask her to scat and improvise in a breakneck tempo (e.g.: "Cherokee").
Bruce Scott First off, I don’t give a fuck. Secondly, Beyoncé, AGAIN, was not asked to scat, she was asked to just sing and freestyle it. You don’t know wtf Beyoncé knows. If Prince, the musical genius, was thoroughly impressed with Beyoncé’s musical knowledge, then your irrelevant ass opinion means nothing.