I’ve never seen Doug get choked up like that. Bless his heart. I hope those women know strangers all across the country shed tears over this and I hope they realize how many were rooting for them to fix their relationship.
I love Judge Milian and her compassion for family. She dreads laying down the law sometimes because it could tear a family apart being in court. I love how she coaches families into forgiveness because family is so important .
I disagree. The judge kept questioning this woman on the details of her daughter's death. Almost like a cross examine. She didn't have any tact in my opinion.
I think the plaintiff blames the defendant for her son's suicide and thinks she probably abandoned him. She started to lash out, the defendant was still grieving and trying to keep her daughter's memory alive and still feeling alone from her husband not processing their daughter's death the same way she was, and probably came defensive. It's a sad thing all the way around. They are both hurting. I hope they reconcile. How sad.
I didn't get the impresson the defendant blames her ex-daughter-in-law for her son's suicide. The issue seemed to be about what they expressed in court: the burial plots and the MIL not switching schools to follow the plaintiff. I believe if the MIL had transferred schools, they would have maintained their relationship. The son couldn't handle his daughter's death and that's nobody's fault.
The murder of the defendant's daughter remains unsolved so I entirely understand why she continues to try and get the media involved. The plaintiff was wrong on that part accusing her former daughter-in-law of using the cameras. They both have hurt each other but on that issue I understand the defendant.
Plus the defendant took his own life such a sad place for the both of them..family members 🙏🏾🙏🏾🤍🕊️🕊️🕊️💜🩵🙏🏾💪🏾😭please work things out with loved ones..love ya bye🥰🥰
She IS using her d€ad daughter for attention! Look how she came to court!! If someone was REALLY wanting their daughter's murder to be solved. You would work with the police and maybe call in regularly to see if anything knew has happened!! And if you have the money you would hire a reputable privet eye or detective! Not get money from donors and appeal to the media regularly and wear shirts like that anytime you are in front of the camera! I am sorry she lost her daughter but sometimes there are no leads in a case! But to use her daughter's d€ath for attention! SIX YEARS LATER she is STILL trying to get attention for it!
This is very similar to what happened to my family. My brother died from a terminal illness at 5 y/o. My parents grieved, but not in support of each other. They ended up divorcing, and my mother committed suicide a year later. My dad and I had it real rough. We never recovered from the losses, we didn't have the best relationship, we really didn't discuss what happened and we both handled things in a destructive way. My dad passed away a few months ago at 63. His death could have been preventable, but he soothed himself with unhealthy foods. When there is a loss of a child, EVERYONE need to be in grief therapy as soon as possible. It's the kind of tragedy that can't be handled without professional psychological help. You can't just pray it away. The tragedies destroyed a good portion of our lives.
Yes dear. Prayer without the work is nil. I pray you can recognize the comfort and instructions that come from your praying. Blessings to you and yours.
I’m tired of people always trying to tell people how to grieve!! I loved tf out my sister and I can’t bring myself to visit her grave after 6 years!!! Just love on each other life is very short!!
Same, when my grandmother passed away it was the hardest for me. I loved her so much and in my own dumb way by me not saying goodbye to her in some sense it’s like she never has left me. I never allowed her to leave my mind so that’s why I never said goodbye to her at her grave. I’ve never visited her nor was I there for the service. I won’t come down to say goodbye to her. She was too special to me and I can’t idealize myself saying goodbye to her. It’s now more than 10yrs and I still remember her morning pancakes
Some people need a physical place to feel close to their loved ones. Some people can feel that connection with thoughts and feelings. I hope everyone learns to understand and appreciate humanities many different facets. I’m sorry for your loss.
This is probably the most heart wrenching court case I have ever watched! I’ve never cried for a case until now! God Bless Judge M. & pray for both families ❤❤
The grandmother isn't gonna do it, she keeps bringing up "the whole family" thing as an excuse, it doesn't have to include the whole family, it can just be you and her, but you're using that as an excuse cause you don't wanna actually change
Definitely not. Even when the judge was talking, she was raising her hand to speak. People need to listen to LISTEN and UNDERSTAND, not listen to reply. You might not agree, but you still need to listen, especially in a case like this with family.
Cause ya'll only see it 1 way. The grandmother is then only one on her own side her son is gone. Meanwhile, the defendant has her whole family against her. Even in her description of the situation at the school.. she never puts the defendant down, she says it was the defendants sister. I got a feeling that family was nasty nasty to her after she stayed at the other school. And yes the defendant played a role in it. Those feelings dont just go away in a snap. The plaintiff didn't do anything to the defendant. She plaintiff feels wronged
@@TheZogie Bruh, all of this drama over some $1,700 grave plots?! She feels wronged?😂😂😂😂 Her son is dead. Her granddaughter is DEAD. It's just money. She's feel wronged? I bet the girl who caught a stray felt wronged, too. I bet the mother who's daughter caught a stray bullet, then had her (ex) husband kill himself feels wronged, too. Meanwhile, let's just wallow in the dysfunction and argue about a couple thousand dollars. Make it make sense.
@@g355150 what? Is this the new husband doing the most? As I was explaining i have a feeling the defendants family absolutely treated the plaintiff horribly. And the defendant allowed it because she felt the plaintiff should have worked for her company. Thats the wrong im speaking of.
Wow. This has my throat in knots. I really hope they can fix it. When Doug can't get petry and you hear the tremble in his voice you know its real. Justice for Tiphanie D. Hollis🙏🏽🕊️🕊️
@michelehemlokhexwhite4310 the spelling does matter as some people may consider that disrespectful and it's literally on the screen for over 90% of the episode
@@Misty8097 ovs in no way shaped or formed me misspelling name her was disrespectful. Bc the way I said her name and my post was not in a disrespectful manner. Her name was shown 98%, they focused on this beautiful young woman's face for at least 5 seconds, yes I misspelled it, but that does not mean my heart was not in the right place Misty!! 🥴🙄 You WANT to go back and forth w ppl so u can have the last thought. Enough now.
I was teary-eyed watching this. If the grandmother says she’s tried and the ex daughter-in-law’s family constantly chimes in, then that is a hard road to travel. I pray that the current husband can help with the recovery of both sides. It’ll be really tough work but possible positive results. 🙏🏾 Thank you Judge Milan for setting the wheels in motion. This was rough to see the pain!
This one was a real heartbreaker. I lost my sister two days after Christmas 2013 and the pain that it can put a family through is unimaginable. I hope that both of these ladies find peace and healing 💛
Awful. I can’t imagine burying a child and a grandchild. Truly heartbreaking. My condolences to both of these beautiful women and my they find peace and strength in each other.
Judge Milian, you did such an awesome job on this case. I have watched hundreds of your cases and this is the first time I have been brought to tears, not just by the case but by your compassion and wisdom and your true desire to mend the broken hearted.
This episode really accented Harvey's lack of compassion. Was quite jarring to come back from break in a very intense situation and have Harvey's loud uncaring tone propose an irrelevant question and not let anyone answer it. The judge was incredible.. as usual!
I've NEVER cried watching People's Court, BUT this got me crying so hard, I had to pause it several times. Such a sad case. Sending them all positive vibes ❤❤❤
This is so very sad. My heart breaks for this whole family. I’m sorry for their conflict that brings them here. Prayers for them. It’s just too much loss, too much tragedy. Sending them love & wishes for all they need. Rest in Peace Tiphne and her daddy Tim.
There is a lot of pain in that room right now. The overwhelming pain of losing a child is too much for people to handle. Both women have lost their children and no one knows how to process it in a positive way. They also have no answers and no one to be angry at so it is easier to be angry at each other. I hope that there is healing since the filming of this episode
Once the gram said that to the mom about the grave, it would be hard for me to forgive her. Nobody can compare the amount of love she has for their own child.
That was it for me too. I don’t think I would be able to get beyond that. (Although nobody REALLY knows what they would do if actually faced with such immense, heartbreaking tragedy….)❤
Cried the whole time... starting at 20 seconds in! Ohhhh my heart! But then again I'm dealing with a similar situation... How much pain can a person take?????!!????!!???!!!???
I'm usually not a fan of when litigants are family or exes but as a girl-dad myself I've never felt more locked in to a case. My heart goes out to everyone involved even those not on TV.
The judge was really bothered by these two. I believe she does want the two to get it together. I think this is the first time I have ever heard Doug so sincere and caring. His voice was kind of trembling. This is a sad case though. I think the mother in law is MOST resistance to reconcile because of the new marriage and money owed. The daughter in law still has too much grief to deal. No resolution to the murder and the possible guilt about the ex's suicide. I am glad she has support in her new husband. Both women need support and healing.
I think you meant to say that the mother-in-law had the MOST resistance to reconciling , not the LEAST. If I am wrong please forgive me for saying anything. I truly hope they can get back to being friends/family again. I am still worried that the mother-in-law isn’t willing to just let all the hurt and anger be in the past. And Judge Milian handled this perfectly. My sincerest condolences to the families for the loss of both Tim and Tiphine.
@@synnove1046 You are correct!! I certainly will change that. You are also correct in saying that the mother in law is not willing to let go of the past. You have to admit, both women have suffered a lot of losses in such a short amount of time. They each lost a child. I think no parent ever gets over that.
This was a rather sobering case. No silly antics or he said she said… just cases of grief causing people to withdraw. I hope they have healing and come together as a family. God bless them.
Update on Tiphne's case... they still haven't found the shooter, sadly, but, the week of March 20th is officially "Tiphne Hollis Week" in Jacksonville, FL. I hope these two ladies worked this out.
I think one part of this case is that both women came to the court in pain but still remained calm. We've all seen TV court cases where the people involved get ugly and while they both said hurtful things it is clearly stemming from their own deep hurts. It's not uncommon for a marriage to break after the loss of a child. I do hope they can find some level of peace and comfort in a reconciliation. May they both be comforted in their loss and may the memories of their children be for a blessing.
You can tell that the judge truly felt sympathy for both the plaintiff and the defendant. And doug truly showed his warm side in this case. I didn't know he had it in him . I'm so used to seeing him being sarcastic.
This is not the first time I have seen Doug get out of character and try to bring people together after an emotional case. He spoke for many folks when he invited them to patch things up after the case. Much prayer is needed for them to see how they are affecting those looking on from the outside. They must both take personal hurt out of the equation to resolve this.
Tiphne's death made her a fighter; the only thing about that she thinks that everyone should fight like her and grieve like her. She needs to attend grief therapy. It works. When my father died, the hospital where he passed away was at. Made me go to grief therapy. It's part of their hospital's policy. I wish all hospitals had this policy. When I returned home to California, they gave me a list of places to go. I continued it. I loved it. Now, I first tell people that they should try grief therapy.
You can tell both are still grieving. Time stops for everyone affected by death. They’re both so angry and taking it out on people they love. I hope they mend their family.
Only episode of people’s court that had me crying. I pray they get justice but I also pray they can truly forgive each other. As a mother who lost a child I can tell you that pain is so bad I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.
I don't think anyone could easily watch this. I'm pretty sure this was even a tough one for JM because she even was tearing up in the beginning. I wish the best for this family
As harsh as JM can be in certain cases, it is her genuine care, shared grief and general empathy (that she is not afraid of showing to the world) that make her stand out amongst the many TV Judges! …Together with Judge Mathis, who also shares his feelings, when he’s touched by the emotional circumstances in certain cases!
I shed a tear on this one... I pray that health healing and restoration constantly flow thru them and that strength and forgiveness resonate through out their relationship... It's just sad... It really is.. Praying they gain peace that surpasses all understanding ❤️❤️
WOW! This one ☝🏻 had me Weeping! Between Judge Marilyn & Doug helping them to see the bigger picture was So Phenomenal!!! I Love ❤️ The People’s Court!! It is Sorely Missed 🥺
11:21 those letters that the plaintiff wrote to the defendant was so vicious and nasty. That was completely uncalled for. I feel bad for the both of them. This was just soooo sad.
JM was on the verge of tears on this one. This was so sad to watch. There's been too much heartbreak in this family for them to pull away from each other on top of it all
I don't ever again want to hear people say JM is racist and has no compassion for black people. She was incredibly empathetic in this case. All the best to this family❤
@evonza4858 I love me some Judge Mathis, but sometimes he let's their rants go on too long and the case becomes a circus. Milian knows when to dead it and she regains control of the courtroom a lot better. He and Milian cannot be beat when it comes to their empathy, because their beginnings are so humble.
They’re from Jacksonville, FL. I remember when she was killed. Her murder is still unsolved until this day. Lord keep this family covered. RIP Tiphne 🕊️🕊️🙏
Lost my oldest son 10 months ago from suicide and its the toughest pain a parent will deal with in life losing a child I pray this family make amends and treat each other kind this was so sad
I believe grandma she’s a very well spoken quiet lady and I’m sure her former daughter in law spoke to her nasty I do pray healing for both. Although the letter was shared of what the mother in law said which wisdom I’m sure encouraged her to bring. None of us had a clue why she responded with what she said. The defendant had the judge thinking she bad mouthed her pretty bad and as the plaintiff said it wasn’t just the defendant it was her family too
Whew. This was soo sad. I’m crying like a lil baby. Even JM was about to cry. Please please forgive each other and love each other. Y’all don’t have to be super close anymore but check up on each other and be there for one another when needed.
They're both in so much pain and I understand it. I had to bury my son as a baby. I'm hoping that they can both come together and forgive one another. It doesn't matter what the rest of the family does but the two of them need to fix it before it's too late
Ooo man this hurts my heart! I won’t tell a lie. I have been crying majority of this episode… this hurts! I pray for the family! As a mother I don’t even want to imagine my angels being taking away from me in that way😩😂😭
Men and women tend to grieve differently, and sometimes, that can rip a marriage apart. The same thing nearly happened with my uncle and aunt when they lost their only daughter, my cousin, to a car accident. But thank God that they were able to work through it somehow, and now they’ve been married for 50 years.
This was tough to watch. Please give both of them strength to heal.
Yes it was..my condolences to the family 💔
Amen! AMEN 🙏🏾
Jesus IS…a Healer! JUST CALL ON HIM FOR “HIS” Strength to carry you both THROUGH🙏🏾🕊️🕯️🙏🏾
Completely heartbreaking 😢
Very
This is very rough 😔
I’ve never seen Doug get choked up like that. Bless his heart. I hope those women know strangers all across the country shed tears over this and I hope they realize how many were rooting for them to fix their relationship.
Right ❤
Well said... very sad😢... not just across the country but all over the world. ❤🇦🇺❤
I was going to say he was really nice this time around and really wanted them to make nice
@@gringo6797 you are right ❤️. I stand corrected 😀
This is the comment right here
I love Judge Milian and her compassion for family. She dreads laying down the law sometimes because it could tear a family apart being in court. I love how she coaches families into forgiveness because family is so important .
Agreed. Whenever she hears about how long people have known each other or if it is family. She always makes heart matter more than money.
This case had me bawling, I can’t imagine what this family is forced to live with daily. I pray they find who did this and they are held accountable.
I disagree. The judge kept questioning this woman on the details of her daughter's death. Almost like a cross examine. She didn't have any tact in my opinion.
Yes she is my favorite because of this compassionate, yet tough and fair
I think the plaintiff blames the defendant for her son's suicide and thinks she probably abandoned him. She started to lash out, the defendant was still grieving and trying to keep her daughter's memory alive and still feeling alone from her husband not processing their daughter's death the same way she was, and probably came defensive. It's a sad thing all the way around. They are both hurting. I hope they reconcile. How sad.
I agree with this 100%
Thats sick if she blames her ..
I agree
I didn't get the impresson the defendant blames her ex-daughter-in-law for her son's suicide. The issue seemed to be about what they expressed in court: the burial plots and the MIL not switching schools to follow the plaintiff. I believe if the MIL had transferred schools, they would have maintained their relationship. The son couldn't handle his daughter's death and that's nobody's fault.
I Agree
The murder of the defendant's daughter remains unsolved so I entirely understand why she continues to try and get the media involved. The plaintiff was wrong on that part accusing her former daughter-in-law of using the cameras. They both have hurt each other but on that issue I understand the defendant.
Plus the defendant took his own life such a sad place for the both of them..family members 🙏🏾🙏🏾🤍🕊️🕊️🕊️💜🩵🙏🏾💪🏾😭please work things out with loved ones..love ya bye🥰🥰
She IS using her d€ad daughter for attention! Look how she came to court!! If someone was REALLY wanting their daughter's murder to be solved. You would work with the police and maybe call in regularly to see if anything knew has happened!! And if you have the money you would hire a reputable privet eye or detective! Not get money from donors and appeal to the media regularly and wear shirts like that anytime you are in front of the camera!
I am sorry she lost her daughter but sometimes there are no leads in a case! But to use her daughter's d€ath for attention! SIX YEARS LATER she is STILL trying to get attention for it!
Agreed she is trying to keep her dtrs death in the spot light
Agreed!
Absolutely
OMG! Brought me to tears when she spoke about marching every 20th of the month for 6 years.... that hurt runs deep 😢
Yessss
So sad. I hope Tiphne’s killer is brought to justice and I hope this family heals and consider grief counseling.
Doug never NOT talks crap after the case…until this one! You can tell this really disturbed him and the judge
Right! I’ve even seen him sass the people that win the cases but he was different here
Amen
My heart goes out to the plaintiff and the defendant. The Judge feels both of their pain you can see the pain in her eyes. Very sad case.
This is very similar to what happened to my family. My brother died from a terminal illness at 5 y/o. My parents grieved, but not in support of each other. They ended up divorcing, and my mother committed suicide a year later. My dad and I had it real rough. We never recovered from the losses, we didn't have the best relationship, we really didn't discuss what happened and we both handled things in a destructive way. My dad passed away a few months ago at 63. His death could have been preventable, but he soothed himself with unhealthy foods. When there is a loss of a child, EVERYONE need to be in grief therapy as soon as possible. It's the kind of tragedy that can't be handled without professional psychological help. You can't just pray it away. The tragedies destroyed a good portion of our lives.
I am so sorry that your family has experienced so much pain💔
Yes dear. Prayer without the work is nil. I pray you can recognize the comfort and instructions that come from your praying. Blessings to you and yours.
Reading this comment made my heart heavy.
I am sorry for your losses.
Sorry for your losses and you're 💯 RIGHT regarding grief counseling. 🙏🏼🕊️
This one broke my heart. I really hope they both heal and fix it like the Judge said.
I was crying while watching this
@@Nevaeh1 Me too!!! I was just so sad for this family
I’m tired of people always trying to tell people how to grieve!! I loved tf out my sister and I can’t bring myself to visit her grave after 6 years!!! Just love on each other life is very short!!
Same, when my grandmother passed away it was the hardest for me. I loved her so much and in my own dumb way by me not saying goodbye to her in some sense it’s like she never has left me. I never allowed her to leave my mind so that’s why I never said goodbye to her at her grave. I’ve never visited her nor was I there for the service. I won’t come down to say goodbye to her. She was too special to me and I can’t idealize myself saying goodbye to her. It’s now more than 10yrs and I still remember her morning pancakes
Sending you love ❤️
God bless you with strength and perseverance, so sorry for your loss.
Some people need a physical place to feel close to their loved ones. Some people can feel that connection with thoughts and feelings. I hope everyone learns to understand and appreciate humanities many different facets. I’m sorry for your loss.
Sending you love and comfort... I'm so sorry for your grief 😢
This mother is a strong mother she has done an amazing job letting her daughter's legacy live on.
I really felt this episode 💔 My condolences to this family.
This is probably the most heart wrenching court case I have ever watched! I’ve never cried for a case until now! God Bless Judge M. & pray for both families ❤❤
Totally agree. Watching it now😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
I’m over her balling like a baby, I pray to god that Tiphne gets Justice
#JusticeForTiphne
Huh!?!??? Why would you be over her crying? How dare you tell someone how to grieve?
@@deandriaevans2154I think it says I'm over here balling like a baby. I'm almost certain this is a typo by the looks of the whole comment
The grandmother isn't gonna do it, she keeps bringing up "the whole family" thing as an excuse, it doesn't have to include the whole family, it can just be you and her, but you're using that as an excuse cause you don't wanna actually change
Definitely not. Even when the judge was talking, she was raising her hand to speak.
People need to listen to LISTEN and UNDERSTAND, not listen to reply. You might not agree, but you still need to listen, especially in a case like this with family.
I agree. Grandma isn’t willing to forgive yet and probably won’t be. It’s very sad.
Cause ya'll only see it 1 way. The grandmother is then only one on her own side her son is gone. Meanwhile, the defendant has her whole family against her. Even in her description of the situation at the school.. she never puts the defendant down, she says it was the defendants sister. I got a feeling that family was nasty nasty to her after she stayed at the other school. And yes the defendant played a role in it. Those feelings dont just go away in a snap. The plaintiff didn't do anything to the defendant. She plaintiff feels wronged
@@TheZogie Bruh, all of this drama over some $1,700 grave plots?! She feels wronged?😂😂😂😂
Her son is dead. Her granddaughter is DEAD. It's just money. She's feel wronged? I bet the girl who caught a stray felt wronged, too. I bet the mother who's daughter caught a stray bullet, then had her (ex) husband kill himself feels wronged, too. Meanwhile, let's just wallow in the dysfunction and argue about a couple thousand dollars. Make it make sense.
@@g355150 what? Is this the new husband doing the most? As I was explaining i have a feeling the defendants family absolutely treated the plaintiff horribly. And the defendant allowed it because she felt the plaintiff should have worked for her company. Thats the wrong im speaking of.
Doug is normally so messy but he couldn’t even take it. He had to have them seek forgiveness and make them hug. ❤
Wow. This has my throat in knots. I really hope they can fix it. When Doug can't get petry and you hear the tremble in his voice you know its real. Justice for Tiphanie D. Hollis🙏🏽🕊️🕊️
That's not her name
her name is huge on her shirt and u still spelled it wrong😭
Doesn't matter the spelling, particularly. The sentiment is more important ❤
But yes, it's Tiphne Darshay Hollis
@michelehemlokhexwhite4310 the spelling does matter as some people may consider that disrespectful and it's literally on the screen for over 90% of the episode
@@Misty8097 ovs in no way shaped or formed me misspelling name her was disrespectful. Bc the way I said her name and my post was not in a disrespectful manner. Her name was shown 98%, they focused on this beautiful young woman's face for at least 5 seconds, yes I misspelled it, but that does not mean my heart was not in the right place Misty!! 🥴🙄 You WANT to go back and forth w ppl so u can have the last thought. Enough now.
God bless these two beautiful women, and may their loved ones rest in peace. ❤️♥️
I was teary-eyed watching this. If the grandmother says she’s tried and the ex daughter-in-law’s family constantly chimes in, then that is a hard road to travel. I pray that the current husband can help with the recovery of both sides. It’ll be really tough work but possible positive results. 🙏🏾 Thank you Judge Milan for setting the wheels in motion. This was rough to see the pain!
I always love the advice the Judge gives when family is having disputes. One of the things I love about watching her!
JM was SPOT TARGET ON🎯
Old woman still refuses to put her hand down even at the end.
my brother committed suicide. Hardest thing I ever had to deal with. It's been 5 years and I still cry for him
This one was a real heartbreaker. I lost my sister two days after Christmas 2013 and the pain that it can put a family through is unimaginable. I hope that both of these ladies find peace and healing 💛
💔😪
Awful. I can’t imagine burying a child and a grandchild. Truly heartbreaking. My condolences to both of these beautiful women and my they find peace and strength in each other.
Judge Milian, you did such an awesome job on this case. I have watched hundreds of your cases and this is the first time I have been brought to tears, not just by the case but by your compassion and wisdom and your true desire to mend the broken hearted.
This episode really accented Harvey's lack of compassion. Was quite jarring to come back from break in a very intense situation and have Harvey's loud uncaring tone propose an irrelevant question and not let anyone answer it. The judge was incredible.. as usual!
Always Harvey section was unnecessary I skip his part all the time
That's his role on the show though...
@@keturahbethel6966His role is to adk irrelevant questions?
This is absolutely heart breaking to watch. These two women are feeling and have felt the same pain. God bless them and help them heal 🙏🙏❤️
Watching it now😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢. OMG in tears…….
I've NEVER cried watching People's Court, BUT this got me crying so hard, I had to pause it several times. Such a sad case. Sending them all positive vibes ❤❤❤
This is so very sad. My heart breaks for this whole family. I’m sorry for their conflict that brings them here. Prayers for them. It’s just too much loss, too much tragedy. Sending them love & wishes for all they need. Rest in Peace Tiphne and her daddy Tim.
There is a lot of pain in that room right now. The overwhelming pain of losing a child is too much for people to handle. Both women have lost their children and no one knows how to process it in a positive way. They also have no answers and no one to be angry at so it is easier to be angry at each other. I hope that there is healing since the filming of this episode
Judge Milian really cares about families and friendships. I can tell those 2 things are dear to her heart.
.
Once the gram said that to the mom about the grave, it would be hard for me to forgive her. Nobody can compare the amount of love she has for their own child.
That was it for me too.
I don’t think I would be able to get beyond that.
(Although nobody REALLY knows what they would do if actually faced with such immense, heartbreaking tragedy….)❤
The grandmother, I'm sure, was speaking out of pain & didn't really mean what she had said.
@@dessean1She didn't apologize sooo
@@dessean1 no excuse. It dishonored the granddaughter by kicking her mom when she is grieving.
@@dessean1yea she meant it
Cried the whole time... starting at 20 seconds in! Ohhhh my heart! But then again I'm dealing with a similar situation... How much pain can a person take?????!!????!!???!!!???
I'm usually not a fan of when litigants are family or exes but as a girl-dad myself I've never felt more locked in to a case. My heart goes out to everyone involved even those not on TV.
The judge was really bothered by these two. I believe she does want the two to get it together. I think this is the first time I have ever heard Doug so sincere and caring. His voice was kind of trembling. This is a sad case though. I think the mother in law is MOST resistance to reconcile because of the new marriage and money owed. The daughter in law still has too much grief to deal. No resolution to the murder and the possible guilt about the ex's suicide. I am glad she has support in her new husband. Both women need support and healing.
I think you meant to say that the mother-in-law had the MOST resistance to reconciling , not the LEAST. If I am wrong please forgive me for saying anything. I truly hope they can get back to being friends/family again. I am still worried that the mother-in-law isn’t willing to just let all the hurt and anger be in the past. And Judge Milian handled this perfectly. My sincerest condolences to the families for the loss of both Tim and Tiphine.
@@synnove1046 You are correct!! I certainly will change that. You are also correct in saying that the mother in law is not willing to let go of the past. You have to admit, both women have suffered a lot of losses in such a short amount of time. They each lost a child. I think no parent ever gets over that.
This was a rather sobering case. No silly antics or he said she said… just cases of grief causing people to withdraw. I hope they have healing and come together as a family. God bless them.
Update on Tiphne's case... they still haven't found the shooter, sadly, but, the week of March 20th is officially "Tiphne Hollis Week" in Jacksonville, FL. I hope these two ladies worked this out.
I remember when this happened in Jacksonville ,FL so sad.Im glad to know March 20th Tiphne Hollis week
The plaintiff was not pleased... you can tell by her body language... the pain runs deep on both sides of the families.
Yea bc some older ppl are set in their ways
They need a family counselor, not a court show😢
I think one part of this case is that both women came to the court in pain but still remained calm. We've all seen TV court cases where the people involved get ugly and while they both said hurtful things it is clearly stemming from their own deep hurts. It's not uncommon for a marriage to break after the loss of a child. I do hope they can find some level of peace and comfort in a reconciliation.
May they both be comforted in their loss and may the memories of their children be for a blessing.
I so appreciate the Judge’s efforts to bring healing and reconciliation.
You can tell that the judge truly felt sympathy for both the plaintiff and the defendant. And doug truly showed his warm side in this case. I didn't know he had it in him . I'm so used to seeing him being sarcastic.
This is not the first time I have seen Doug get out of character and try to bring people together after an emotional case. He spoke for many folks when he invited them to patch things up after the case. Much prayer is needed for them to see how they are affecting those looking on from the outside. They must both take personal hurt out of the equation to resolve this.
Tiphne's death made her a fighter; the only thing about that she thinks that everyone should fight like her and grieve like her. She needs to attend grief therapy. It works. When my father died, the hospital where he passed away was at. Made me go to grief therapy. It's part of their hospital's policy. I wish all hospitals had this policy. When I returned home to California, they gave me a list of places to go. I continued it. I loved it. Now, I first tell people that they should try grief therapy.
I admire Judge Milian 's integrity and humility
You can tell both are still grieving. Time stops for everyone affected by death. They’re both so angry and taking it out on people they love. I hope they mend their family.
1ST case I EVER seen JM.... NOT.... raise her voice in anger to nobody....🥺🥺🥺😥😥😥😥😥... bless this family
I neverrr saw JM soft side im soo used to her hollering & screaming it was warm seeing her express empathy❤❤
Only episode of people’s court that had me crying. I pray they get justice but I also pray they can truly forgive each other. As a mother who lost a child I can tell you that pain is so bad I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy.
I don't think anyone could easily watch this. I'm pretty sure this was even a tough one for JM because she even was tearing up in the beginning. I wish the best for this family
I cried for this family. I really hope they can work things out. May Tiphne and her father rest in peace.
As harsh as JM can be in certain cases, it is her genuine care, shared grief and general empathy (that she is not afraid of showing to the world) that make her stand out amongst the many TV Judges!
…Together with Judge Mathis, who also shares his feelings, when he’s touched by the emotional circumstances in certain cases!
I cried like a baby watching this. God bless both of these women. ❤
JM did a great job on this case. So much compassion and good advice
The mother is gorgeous. To go through that and still look good. Its good she wanted to do things in her daughter’s honor.
I shed a tear on this one... I pray that health healing and restoration constantly flow thru them and that strength and forgiveness resonate through out their relationship... It's just sad... It really is.. Praying they gain peace that surpasses all understanding ❤️❤️
Much love and respect for the defendant for keeping her late daughter’s legacy alive 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
WOW! This one ☝🏻 had me Weeping! Between Judge Marilyn & Doug helping them to see the bigger picture was So Phenomenal!!! I Love ❤️ The People’s Court!! It is Sorely Missed 🥺
Watching until the end to comment. The first couple of minutes have left me speechless!
Poor women! Pulls at my heart strings, I am so sorry for their loss!! 😢
Judge Milan was fighting her tears this entire time & it’s making me cry 😢
11:21 those letters that the plaintiff wrote to the defendant was so vicious and nasty. That was completely uncalled for. I feel bad for the both of them. This was just soooo sad.
Doug thank you 😢😢😢 I’m crying I’m praying for their healing
Even Doug Llewellyn was emotionally moved. Never saw him like this.
Unfortunately death can bring out the worst in people. Healing for all ❤
yep!!
JM was on the verge of tears on this one. This was so sad to watch. There's been too much heartbreak in this family for them to pull away from each other on top of it all
Wow, i have never watched a case on this show to have touched my heart as much as this case did. This was very emotional💔
The church hug at 19:24 said it all 😂😂 They not rockin with eachother no more. Period.
This was heart tugging and I love the love the court room provided them to help start their healing ❤❤❤❤
So sorry she lost her baby and grandma lost her grand baby. And Even in divorce I know her ex husbands death still hurt her tremendously.
The grandmother lose his son and the grand children
I don't ever again want to hear people say JM is racist and has no compassion for black people. She was incredibly empathetic in this case.
All the best to this family❤
Even a broken clock is right at least once a day.
I always listen when judges give their personal advice and their life stories, that comes from the heart.
And THIS is why Judge Milian is the best judge. Her empathy, her wits, her smarts, her attention, etc are just unmatched.
True, I'm so glad she's getting her own new show soon!💯
One of the best because Judge is one too 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾🥰❤️🖤💚
@@evonza4858 Which judge?
@@JloveLamar Judge Mathis is #1👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾🥰❤️🖤💚
@evonza4858 I love me some Judge Mathis, but sometimes he let's their rants go on too long and the case becomes a circus. Milian knows when to dead it and she regains control of the courtroom a lot better. He and Milian cannot be beat when it comes to their empathy, because their beginnings are so humble.
They’re from Jacksonville, FL. I remember when she was killed. Her murder is still unsolved until this day. Lord keep this family covered. RIP Tiphne 🕊️🕊️🙏
My heart was hurting this entire video. Clearly this was a close family, im so sorry this happened to them.
I’ve never seen Doug so saddened, wow
The Judge Handled This Case Really Well! I pray this brings peace and justice to the family!
I'm going to miss Judge Milian! I love her! I pray the ladies make amends 🙏🏽
Heartbreaking Rest In Peace beautiful daughter. May your family and friends find healing and peace blessings be
That was a non-hug at the end. Doesn’t look promising for their relationship.
The first time I've had to watch PC with tissues😥. So sad! I love to see Judge show her softer side when ruling.
I love the judge's compassion in this case! Even Doug was nice to them in the hallway, lol
I pray they do work it out.
My prayers goes out to both families that God will heal them both!
Incredibly sad. Such a hard case to watch.
I couldn’t concentrate on cooking listening to this. Just breaks my heart all the way around. Please I pray they mend things 🙏🏾.
So the daughter's mom wants everything done her way or it’s the highway.
Lost my oldest son 10 months ago from suicide and its the toughest pain a parent will deal with in life losing a child I pray this family make amends and treat each other kind this was so sad
The grandma looks exactly like my grandmother's sister, even the hair it is so eery
She is cute as a button
@@Kre410 Ye she is, My great aunt was just like her. Very loving and chill.
This case brought tears to my eyes. I’m praying that they find it in their hearts to fix this for Tipheni and Timothy.🙏🏾🙏🏾
I believe grandma she’s a very well spoken quiet lady and I’m sure her former daughter in law spoke to her nasty I do pray healing for both. Although the letter was shared of what the mother in law said which wisdom I’m sure encouraged her to bring. None of us had a clue why she responded with what she said. The defendant had the judge thinking she bad mouthed her pretty bad and as the plaintiff said it wasn’t just the defendant it was her family too
Whew. This was soo sad. I’m crying like a lil baby. Even JM was about to cry. Please please forgive each other and love each other. Y’all don’t have to be super close anymore but check up on each other and be there for one another when needed.
They're both in so much pain and I understand it. I had to bury my son as a baby. I'm hoping that they can both come together and forgive one another. It doesn't matter what the rest of the family does but the two of them need to fix it before it's too late
This is one of the saddest cases Ive seen. I dont even want to "pick a side." Its all just terrible.
Almost cried like a baby. Judge is so kind hearted
Ooo man this hurts my heart! I won’t tell a lie. I have been crying majority of this episode… this hurts! I pray for the family! As a mother I don’t even want to imagine my angels being taking away from me in that way😩😂😭
This one was too sad to watch. My heart breaks for all the family.
&&& funerals really bring out the worst inn people . . . .😮😮😮😮
Men and women tend to grieve differently, and sometimes, that can rip a marriage apart. The same thing nearly happened with my uncle and aunt when they lost their only daughter, my cousin, to a car accident. But thank God that they were able to work through it somehow, and now they’ve been married for 50 years.
Instead of grieving they in court? So sad ... SMH 🤦♂️